You are on page 1of 26

Republic of the Philippines

MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES


Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15987
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

ARIES SALAPA y DELORIA ET AL., VIOLATION OF SEC.2, PAR.D OF


Accused. PD 659 AS AMENDED BY PD 686
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Larry M. Quinton ---------------- For the Accused

MOTION FOR RESOLUTION OF URGENT MOTION TO RELEASE THE 500


BAGS OF SUGAR
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: Motion was submitted for resolution.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15960-15966
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

ROSA MARIA QUINAGORAN y VIOLATION OF BP BLG. 22


MALABANAN,
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: During arraignment, accused pleaded not guilty to the crime

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: March 27, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15986
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

JAMESY REYES y ICAL, GRAVE ORAL DEFAMATION


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Nicolas B. Senoren ---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: On arraignment, accused pleaded not guilty to the crime


charged. On pre-trial counsels entered into stipulations. Moreover, pre-trial was
terminated and case was set for trial.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 10, and 17, 2018 for prosecution


and April 24, May 8, 15, 2018 for defense.

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 16017
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

REYNALDO ACOSTA y NOBLE, GRAVE THREATS


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Hospicio I. Laygo, Jr. ---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: On arraignment, accused pleaded not guilty to the crime


charged. On pre-trial counsels entered into stipulations. Moreover, pre-trial was
terminated and case was set for trial.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 10, 2018 for prosecution, April 17,


24, May 8, 15, 2018 for defense.

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 16032
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

RENATO ABAS y BASCO, GRAVE ORAL DEFAMATION


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Rey Daniel Acedillo ---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: On arraignment, accused pleaded not guilty to the crime


charged. On pre-trial counsels entered into stipulations. Moreover, pre-trial was
terminated and case was set for trial.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: June 5, 19 and 26, 2018 for the prosecution


and July 3, 10, 17, 24 and 31, 2018 for the defense.

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 16049
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

REXCEL RIVERA y LOZANO, SLANDER


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: On arraignment, accused pleaded not guilty to the crime


charged. On pre-trial counsels entered into stipulations. Moreover, pre-trial was
terminated and case was set for trial.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 10 and 17, 2018 for prosecution


and
May 8, 15 and 22 for defense.

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 11551
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

MARIVIC BALITA y ROXAS, VIOLATION OF BP BLG. 22


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
---------------- For the Accused

PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: Due to reason/s stated in open court, preliminary conference was


reset to a later date.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: February 27, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15920
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

WILMA DINGLASAN y DATINGUINOO SLIGHT PHYSICAL INJURIES


ET AL.,
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: Due to reason/s stated in open court, case was DISMISSED.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15930
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

GRACE ISABELLE REBOSI y ESTAFA


LEBUMFACIL ET AL.,
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

PRE-TRIAL
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: For reason/s stated in open court, pre-trial was reset to a later
date.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15791-15792
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

LORELIE CUDISAL y VILLANUEVA, VIOLATION OF BP BLG. 22


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Theodore Allan ---------------- For the Accused
Montealegre

PRE-TRIAL
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: When this case was called, accused and her counsel was not
attendant in court despite due notice. For this reason, and upon motion of the
government prosecutor, a bench warrant was issued against the accused and
bondsman was ordered to explain why the bond posted by the accused for her
provisional liberty not be forfeited in favor of the government.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: Presentation of evidence for prosecution


was set on March 27, April 3 and 10.

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15734
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

JENIFER BETE y SIBLOS, PERJURY


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Joel J. Jabal ---------------- For the Accused

INITIAL PRESENTATION OF DEFENSE EVIDENCE


WITNESSES: Jenifer Bete y Siblos, 38 year old, married, unemployed,
resident of Matina, Davao City
MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: Judicial Affidavit of accused
(Exh.1)
Police Blotter (Exh.2); Barangay Blotter (Exh.3); Certification (Exh.4)

REMARKS: After the conclusion of testimony of accused on direct,


prosecutor
moved that his cross-examination be scheduled on a later date.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15735
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

MARY GRACE GARAZA-ALUPIT, PERJURY


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

INITIAL PRESENTATION OF DEFENSE EVIDENCE


WITNESSES: Mary Grace Garaza-Alupit, 24 year old, single, unemployed,
resident of Guinobatan, Calapan City
MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: Judicial Affidavit of accused
(Exh.1)

REMARKS: After the conclusion of testimony of accused, defense counsel


moved for continuance.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 115646-15650
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

CARLO TOLENTINO y MENDOZA, VIOLATION OF BP BLG. 22


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE


WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS: When this case was called, due to settlement on civil aspect of
cases 15647 and 15648, the same were dismissed. By agreement of parties,
criminal cases nos. 15646, 15649 and 15650 were reset to a later date.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 3, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15904
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

ARNEL DACILLO y SEVILLA, UNJUST VEXATION


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

INITIAL PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE


WITNESSES: Leonisa Reyes y Dalina, 46 years old, married, casual
employee of City Government of Calapan, resident of Sto. Nino, Calapan City
MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: Sinumpaang Salaysay (Exh.B),
Signature of affiant (Exh. B-1)

REMARKS: After the conclusion of testimony of witness, prosecutor moved


for continuance.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 17, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Cases No. 15905
Plaintiff,

-versus- -for-

ARNEL DACILLO y SEVILLA, SLIGHT PHYSICAL INJURIES


Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X

MINUTES
of the SESSION held on January 30, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.

PRESENT:
HON. AMIEL RAYMOND O. PARGAS -------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano -------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi -------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo -------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira -------- Process Server

APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. ---------------- For the Accused
Dimayuga

INITIAL PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE


WITNESSES: Maria Rizalina Onda y Mendoza, 37 years old, unemployed
and
resident of Sto. Nino, Calapan City
MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: Sinumpaang Salaysay (Exh A-A-
2),
Katibayan upang Makadulog sa Hukuman (Exh.B); Receipt (Exh.D); Medical
Certificate (Exh.C); Picture of Eyeglasses (Exh.E); Picture of house and watch
(Exh.F)
REMARKS: After the conclusion of testimony of witness, prosecutor moved
for continuance.

CONTINUATION OF HEARING: April 17, 2018

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO


Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV

You might also like