Active deformation, fault segmentation, scarp morphology, seismic hazard assessment

and geohazards along Muzaffarabad Fault, Hazara-Kashmir Syntaxis, Northwest

Himalaya, Pakistan

Mirza Shahid Baig*1, Robert S.  Yeats 2, MonaLisa 3, Shahab Pervez 1, Basit Masood 4,
Mohammad Amer Sohail 4, Ishtiaq Ahmed Khan Jadoon 5, Allah Bakhsh Kausar 6

1Institute of Geology, University of Azad Jammu & Kashmir Muzaffarabad, Azad Kashmir,
Pakistan
2Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon, USA.
3Department of Earth Sciences, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad, Pakistan
4NESPK House, 1-C Block Model Town, Lahore, Pakistan
5Department of Environmental Sciences, COMSATS Abbottabad, Pakistan
6Geological Survey of Pakistan, Islamabad, Pakistan
* Email: drshahidbaig@yahoo.com or drshahidbaig@gmail.com

The NW-trending Hazara-Kashmir syntaxis (HKS) lies in the hinterland of the Himalayan
collision zone. The NW-trending Indus-Kohistan Seismic Zone (IKSZ) is associated with an
active blind wedge of thick-skin reverse faults which extends obliquely across the HKS [1, 2].
The IKSZ got reactivated during the October 08, 2005 Kashmir earthquake. It has been
suggested that the IKSZ traces SE to the Riasi Thrust in India and the Soan thrust in the Kangra
reentrant [3, 4]. The Main Boundary Thrust (MBT), Panjal Thrust and active Himalayan Frontal
Thrust (Muzaffarabad Fault) are truncated by the active left-lateral reverse Jhelum Fault along
the western limb of the HKS. The MBT has been displaced 38 km along the active left-lateral
reverse ramp of the Jhelum fault from the northern apex of the HKS to Kohala (Berot Nalla) in
the south [5]. The Jhelum Fault in higher structural levels shows evidence for back-steepening
and dips 40-800 ESE in the southern segment and NE in the northern segment, respectively.
The Jhelum Fault extends south from Kohala to Azad Pattan. In this segment of the fault, the
Murree Formation lies in the hanging wall and Kamlial, Chingi and Nagri Formations in the
footwall. The Nagri Formation in the footwall of the fault extends north of Kohala up to
Zamanabad.

The splays of the fault south of Azad Pattan within Siwaliks extend to Nara, Salgran, Shah
Khaki, Thamnoa and Taraki Gujar Khan. These thin-skin faults occur in the cover sequence of
the Indian plate. The active Muzaffarabad Fault, also called the Himalayan Frontal Thrust-HFT
[4, 5, 6, 7, 8] or Balakot-Bagh Fault [9], extends from Allai-Kohistan to Poonch in Jammu and
Kashmir. The fault was segmented as result of left or right stepping during October 08, 2005
Muzaffarabad earthquake.

The fault segments trend NW-SE and dip 35-550 NE. The rupture zone from Allai-Kohistan to
Hangari is not continuous, however, the tectonic deformation expressed as linear landslides is
present north of Siran valley. In this area, the fault acts as a blind reverse fault of the IKSZ. The
fault segment from Balakot to Mara Tanolian Muzaffarabad is along the overturned limb of the
Balakot-Muzaffarabad anticline, and juxtaposes the Cambrian carbonates of the Muzaffarabad
Formation and the Miocene lower Murree Formation. The fault in this segment behaves as a
thrust except in the Shawai Nalla Muzaffarabad, where, due to back-steepening, it is a SW-
dipping pseudo-normal fault. The lower Murree Formation along the Tanda to Sudangali fault
segment was thrust over the upper Murree and Kamlial Formations. However, in the southeast
from Sudangali to Chrikot and Poonch, the fault emplaces the Murree Formation on the Chinji
and Nagri Formations.

The HFT has been reactivated during the October 08, 2005 earthquake along a pre-existing
active structural boundary. It shows right-stepping near Bandi Muzaffarabad, Sali-da-Katha and
Lasdana areas in which it has left-lateral slip instead of its dominantly right-lateral slip. The right-
lateral Muzaffarabad Thrust near Balakot splays into southern and northern segments that show
2.5 to 4 m vertical and 2 to 2.5 m right-lateral slips. The southern segment cuts the western
margin of the HKS in the northwest and reactivates the MBT about 4 km in the Hangarai area.
The MBT (previously called the Murree Fault) here was reactivated in the opposite sense: 
northern-eastern side up whereas the MBT had that side down. The HKS was seismically not
active, since the surface rupture during October 08, 2005 earthquake and zone of seismicity cut
across the syntaxis. The Balakot city and Balakot tectonic ridge lie in the active hanging-wall
anticline of the southern segment of Muzaffarabad Thrust. The active Balakot hanging wall
anticline has been locally imbricated between the southern and the northern segments of the
Muzaffarabad Thrust. The active Bandi anticline formed due to active folding of the hanging wall
of the Muzaffarabad Fault. Holocene terraces are tilted, uplifted and folded in the Bandi anticline
as well as in the Balakot hanging wall anticline.

The 0.5-0.75 km brittle shear zone, active linear old and new landslides, southwest tilted (30-
450) trees, active alluvial fans, and cut, tilted (8-250), uplifted and folded terraces are present
along the Muzaffarabad Fault. Active reverse and normal ruptures are present in the rupture
zone ranging from 1 to 3 km in width. The active reverse ruptures are parallel to the trace of the
fault. However, the normal ruptures are parallel to the crests of active hanging wall anticlines or
the topographic front of the Muzaffarabad Fault and are the bending-moment faults. The reverse
and normal ruptures trend NW-SE and dip 60-800 NE or SW. In the areas where reverse
ruptures dip NE and SW, these faults form outcrop scale triangle zones. The local left stepping
of right-lateral ruptures shows outcrop scale pressure ridges in Sudangali-Bagh area.

The reverse ruptures are the result of active NE-SW Himalayan compression. The normal
ruptures represent the NE-SW late extension in the area. The fault scarp morphology includes
vertical, folded and compression arch scarps. The folded scarps are associated with the Balakot
and Bandi active hanging wall anticlines. The fault scarp morphology at places has been
modified as a result of gravity collapse of the hanging wall due to strong ground shaking during
the earthquake.

The horizontal shortening across the scarp measured through strain markers varies from 3 to
3.5 m. The vertical scarp height and lateral offset along the fault vary from 1.5 m to 15 m and
0.75 m to 3 m, respectively. The average vertical uplift along the Muzaffarabad Fault is 3 m [5],
but it reached to a maximum of 7.5 m during the Muzaffarabad earthquake. The scarp height up
to 15 m is the cumulative result of possibly multiple earthquakes in the Holocene. Historical and
palaeoseimological earthquake data have not existed in Muzaffarabad area before the October
08, 2005 Kashmir earthquake for the previously known active Muzaffarabad Fault. The area is
characterized by moderate to high seismicity [10]. Seismic Hazard Assessment (SHA) was
carried out before the occurrence of the Kashmir earthquake using seismological data till 2004
[11]. This earlier work has been revised, incorporating all the available earthquake data till
January 2007 within 50 km of Muzaffarabad. The critical tectonic features in the area have been
reinvestigated to carry out SHA using deterministic approach. The fault length of 120 km from
Balakot to Poonch has been considered on the basis of geological and structural data for the
Muzaffarabad Fault. They assigned a maximum magnitude of 8.0 for a future earthquake at
Balakot-Bagh Fault, with the peak ground acceleration (PGA) value of 0.5g as calculated with
the help of the attenuation equation. MonaLisa et al [12] initially trenched and dated the
Muzaffarabad Fault near Bandi (Nisar Camp) between 2000 to 2005 years and interpreted the
two recent faulting events. The maximum earthquake recurrence interval for 8 magnitude
earthquake along the Muzaffarabad fault based on paleoseismological data is about 1000
years. The geohazards in the area include landslides, active hanging wall anticlines, steep
slopes, slope failure, active faults, back-steepen fault segments, active rupture zones, loose
gouge and breccia, liquefaction, cliffs and banks of rivers. The linear active landslides along the
Muzaffarabad Fault are the result of ground shaking and NE-SW late extension in the area.

Ground shaking, seismic amplification, liquefaction, slope failure, basement failure, structural
collapse, structural design, old buildings, asymmetric structures and building material are the
causes for the damage of civil structures and loss of more than 80,000 human lives. A detailed
study of uplift rates, slip rates, strain buildup, scarp morphology, hazard zonation, Quaternary
geochronology, recurrence intervals, seismicity and seismic hazard assessment is needed to
avoid major human loss during a probable future earthquake along the Holocene Muzaffarabad
Fault.

REFERENCES

1. Seeber, L. and Armbruster. J., 1979. In: Farah, A. and DeJong, K. A. (eds.),
Geodynamics of Pakistan. Geol. Surv. Pak.,    
2. Quetta, 131-142.
3. Seeber, L., Quittmeyer, R. C. and Armbruster, J. G., 1981. Geol. Bull. Univ. Peshawar,
13, 151-168.
4. Armbruster, J. G., Seeber, L. and Jacob, K. K., 1978. J. Geophys. Res., 83, 269-282.
5. Baig, M. S. and Lawrence, R. D., 1987. Kashmir J. Geol., 5, 1-22.
6. Baig, M. S., 2006. Abs., Int. Conf. on Earthquake in Pakistan; Its implications and hazard
mitigation, Jan 18-19, 2006, Islamabad, 21-22.
7. Nakata, T. and Kumahara, Y., 2006. Abs., Int. Conf. on Earthquake in Pakistan; Its
implications and hazard mitigation, Jan 18-19, 2006, Islamabad, 19-22.
8. Nakata, T., Tsutsumi, H., Khan, S. H. and Lawrence, R. D., 1991. Special Publication.
No. 21, Research Center for Regional Geography, Hiroshima University.
9.              NESPAK (National Engineering Services Pakistan) report, 2006. Seismic hazard
microzonation map of Muzaffarabad city.
10. Yeats, R. S., Parsons, T., Hussain, A. and Yagi, Y., 2006. Abs., Int. Conf. on Earthquake
in Pakistan; Its implications and hazard mitigation, Jan 18-19, 2006, Islamabad, 16-18.
11. MonaLisa, Kausar., A. B., Khwaja, A. A. and Jan, M. Q., 2006. Episodes, 20, 5-7.
12. MonaLisa, Khwaja, A. A. and Jan, M. Q., 2007. J. Earthquake Engg., 11, 257-301.

Kando et al., 2007. Abs, GSP post-earthquake 2005 Research Symposium, March 24, 2007,
Islamabad