1.

0 No Irregularities check is observed on the report as well on analysis file as per clause 7 especially
-Regular and irregular configuration
- Soft story
- Mass Irregularity
- irregular mode of oscillation in two principal plan direction -first three mode should contribute
more than 65% mass participation

2.0 eccentricity is taken 0% for both direction… Calculate eccentricity and apply on dynamic case using
clause 7.8.1
3.0 Provide (Wall load+plaster)/floor finish load calculation on the report
4.0 No Partition wall load observed on future possible change-minimum 1 or calculated which ever is
critical…calculated partion load applied only in few place.
5.0 No staircase void is observed. true representation of staircase load in modelling is missing

6.0

cantilever portion modeling and application of load is not observed

7.0
beam flush with column is not allowable

8.0

Detailing of slab should be revised … instead putting

formula put the value or length
9.0 Submit cantelver portion slab design… also no dlection criteria on slab is not checked.?…
⚫ Partion wall load??
⚫ 100mm thickness???
10.0 Slab section is not observed??? Provide slab section minimum 1 -1 for X and Y direction
11.0 In case of foundation design
⚫ no shear wall load is observed.+
⚫ how is it possible to desing separated raft and providing single raft foundation
⚫ length of raft is >45 m provide expansion gap and design accordingly…
⚫ Deflection criteria check on foundation not foundation
⚫ flushing on both side on mat is observed on drawing but not on Calculation.

12.0 please give reference of the codal clause for

torsional modification
13.0 Whole building is designed for uncracked section… plz design the building as per clause 6.4.3.1
for cracked section
14.0 11-25mm rebar on 30” thickness give less than 3” space so increase the column size or increase
the size of rebar and increase the spacing…. since at junction of column and beam it is almost
impossible to work…
15.0 Plz provide the stirrups calculation and column/beam rebar calculation sheet on report.. and
their planning on the report too
16.0 plz provide the one Typical-longitudinal column section with
providing key-value on proper scale….

-
Please provide Calculated data for section in detailing.
17.

Up to what length stirrups provided… + extra bar length???? Provide proper data.. not formula

18. No Soil Pressure on Retaining wall is observed… pl provide proper soil pressure on wall and…
effect of this should be reflected on raft foundation design
19. design building as per clause 7.2.7 for dual system.
20.

For shop floor???? Plz check the is 875 code

Mass source 0.25 for all live load? … check the code and revise design
21. Time period calculated is 36 m height use for 30m excluding basement floor.
22. Design the retaining wall manually to verify the thickness and reinforcement.

ALL THESE COMMENTS ARE PROVIDED BASED ON SURFACIAL OBSERVATION ONLY BECAUSE OF
TIME LIMITATIONS.

PLEASE TAKE THIS COMMENTS AS REPRESENTATIVE COMMENTS FOR ALL OTHER BLOCKS.
BECAUSE OF TIME LIMITATION STILL WE ARE GOING THROUGH THE DESIGN.

YOUR COORDINATION FOR OTHER THINGS WHICH ARE NOT INCLUDED HERE, (BUT YOU THINK IT
AS IMPORTANT) ARE ALWAYS WELCOME. OUR COMMON MOTIVE IS TO MAKE BUILDING SAFER
AND STRONGER. THANK YOU FOR YOUR UNDERSTANDING.