Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
EXERCISE TECHNIQUE
Exercise technique
lecture
Exercise technique
This 3 hour exercise technique extravaganza lecture is from the meet-up of a previous year’s
PT Course. To help you work through it in an organized fashion and to refer back to it, here’s
an overview of at which times which topics occur.
The Q&A session at the end is not restricted to this week’s topic and not strictly part of this
year’s curriculum, so you can consider this a bonus section.
1
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
CHIN-UPS (33-36)
SQUATS (37-49)
2
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
Q&A (50-64)
3
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
1. Good proprioception, specifically the ability to feel which muscles are currently active
to what degree.
2. The ability to intentionally override your motor cortex’s muscle recruitment pattern
and actively select which muscles are active during a given exercise.
The first point has been covered in the lecture about exercise technique. Even if you have an
above average mind-muscle connection, your perception of which muscles are active is only
poorly related to actual muscle activity levels. You mostly feel fatigue, like the burn and muscle
stretching, not direct muscle activity. So evidence-based exercise selection should primarily be
done according to the principles of exercise selection you learned in this course, not based on
what you feel during an exercise.
Point two is where most bros place the emphasis. If you can change your muscle recruitment
pattern, you can increase muscle activity, right? Unfortunately, it’s not that simple.
For one, your brain’s motor cortex functions like a Bayesian system that has been finetuned
over millions of years of evolution. Most movements, like walking, are so complex in terms of
muscle recruitment pattern that our conscious thought couldn’t remotely govern this task as
well as you can do automatically. Even the brightest mathematicians can still barely create
robots that walk with a hint of elegance. In this respect, trying to take over complex
movements with your conscious thought is a bit like trying to hack a computer by poking into
its motherboard with a kitchen knife.
4
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
When you’re lifting a near-maximal weight during a compound exercise, trying to interfere with
your motor cortex to isolate a certain muscle group often means that you won’t be able to lift
the weight at all. Your motor cortex already optimized your muscle recruitment pattern so that
all muscles can provide maximal force. Any deviation from this plan will result in suboptimal
force production. Try deadlifting your 1RM by focusing on your quads. Or your hamstrings. Or
your glutes. Most people can’t lift the weight without an extrinsic focus, i.e. just thinking of
lifting the weight or standing up and letting the nervous system do its job.
We also see this in strength training research. McAllister et al. (2014) performed a great study
on the mind-muscle connection. They looked at how bench press muscle activity in the triceps
and chest changed when the subjects used regular technique compared to when they tried to
isolate their chest or triceps. The researchers tested this at various intensities. The results are
illustrated below.
1. Your ability to influence your muscle recruitment pattern during the bench press is
limited, even when you’re trying to completely isolate a muscle group. For the chest, the
highest difference was 7% of maximal muscle activity; 11% for the triceps (percent
difference of 1RM maximal RMS EMG).
5
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
2. Your ability to influence your muscle recruitment decreases as the intensity of your
work increases. At the 80% intensity there were in fact no differences in either muscle’s
activity regardless of muscle focus.
And these were not novices: they were strength trained men with an average of 8 years of
strength training experience and an average bench press 1RM of 227 pounds (103 kg). So it’s
unlikely that your mind-muscle connection is a whole lot better.
Moreover, the subjects only performed 3 repetitions at each intensity and they used a very
controlled tempo. So in a practical setting where you’re actually lifting heavy weights close to
muscle failure, it is even more unlikely that you can significantly influence your muscle
recruitment pattern. Unfortunately, this renders the majority of the research on the mind-
muscle connection irrelevant in practice due to its use of artificially light weights and low
proximities to muscular failure.
Even in the event that you can influence which muscles you use, it generally comes at a
significant cost in terms of how much weight you can move. As Greig & Marchant (2014)
explained: “The finding that an internal focus of attention was associated with increased
muscular activity … supports the proposal that such a focus results in greater neuromuscular
‘noise’ when compared to an external focus of attention”.
A similar study in Division III American football players had similar results in that the mind-
muscle connection weakened at higher intensities. At 50% these guys were able to selectively
recruit the triceps or chest, but at 80% they could no longer increase triceps muscle activity.
Only this time at 80% focusing on the chest actually increased muscle activity of the chest ánd
the anterior deltoids. This largely defeats the purpose of using the mind-muscle connection,
since the whole point is to isolate the chest and make sure your shoulders don’t do all the
work.
6
Bayesianbodybuilding.com
We see a similar effect in some blood flow restriction research, where occluding the triceps
increases chest muscle activity. This is likely because you weaken yourself and thus the overall
exercise becomes more difficult. When you’re trying to isolate the chest or occluding the
triceps, 80% may effectively be a 90% intensity because you’re weaker. This is likely not optimal
for long term strength or muscle development. You’d be better off just lifting a heavier weight
so that you also get extra muscle activity in the triceps and you gain more strength.
When you’re injured, however, the mind-muscle connection can be a valuable tool. You can
reach relatively high muscle activation levels with relatively low loads, so the stress on your
connective tissue for a given level of muscle activity is lower than with performance oriented
strength training. Here are some tips to make full use of the mind-muscle connection for
injured body parts. They rely on providing the brain with more information via active feedback.
Touch the muscle group you’re trying to emphasize, if possible. This provides tactile and
kinesthetic feedback. If you palpate your client, there is only kinesthetic feedback, but
you can add verbal feedback.
Perform the exercise in front of the mirror. This provides visual feedback.
Conclusion
You’re generally best off letting your motor cortex do its job when you’re in the gym. Focus on
performance and you’ll automatically optimize muscle activity levels; performance will be higher
to boot. Trying to isolate muscles should generally be reserved during (p)rehabilitation of
injuries to make use of the relatively high muscle activity you can achieve with relatively light
weights.