Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Silicon-Polymer Hybrid Materials For Drug Delivery: Eview
Silicon-Polymer Hybrid Materials For Drug Delivery: Eview
Silicon and its oxides are widely used in biomaterials research, tissue engineering and drug delivery. These materials
are highly biocompatible, easily surface functionalized, degrade into nontoxic silicic acid and can be processed into
various forms such as micro- and nano-particles, monoliths, membranes and micromachined structures. The large
surface area of porous forms of silicon and silica (up to 1200 m2/g) permits high drug loadings. The degradation
kinetics of silicon- and silica-based materials can be tailored by coating or grafting with polymers. Incorporation of
polymers also improves control over drug-release kinetics. The use of stimuli-responsive polymers has enabled
environmental stimuli-triggered drug release. Simultaneously, silicon microfabrication techniques have facilitated
the development of sophisticated implantable drug-delivery microdevices. This paper reviews the synthesis, novel
properties and biomedical applications of silicon–polymer hybrid materials with particular emphasis on drug delivery.
The biocompatible and bioresorptive properties of mesoporous silica and porous silicon make these materials
attractive candidates for use in biomedical applications. The combination of polymers with silicon-based materials
has generated a large range of novel hybrid materials tailored to applications in localized and systemic drug delivery.
10.4155/FMC.09.90 © 2009 Future Science Ltd Future Med. Chem. (2009) 1(6), 1051–1074 ISSN 1756-8919 1051
Review | McInnes & Voelcker
electrolyte [32] . The chemistry and mechanism of
Maximum desired (toxic) drug level this electrochemical process has been reviewed
elsewhere [14,33] . pSi has four particularly
attractive qualities for in vivo drug delivery:
n High surface area (up to 800 m 2 /g) [34] ;
Drug level
Calcination
and template
Surfactant Deposition removal
Template
nanoparticle
bonds. Other types of oxidations may be per- as CsOH and KOH. The design of these silicon-
formed to stabilize pSi, including chemical [62– based devices can be as simple as an array of wells
65] , anodic [66,67] and photo-induced [68,69] oxida- or needles [75] or as complicated as the production
tions. Nitridization of pSi has also been described of intricate flaps that control the release of drugs
[70,71] . The presence of Si-OH groups on oxidized from polymer-coated reservoirs [76] . During the
pSi surfaces allows for the functionalization with design stage of any MEMS device for drug deliv-
alkoxy- or chloro-silanes. Ambient conditions ery, there are four major components that should
and only moderately elevated temperatures are be considered for inclusion: microreservoirs,
sufficient for common silanization reactions. micropumps, valves and sensors [15] .
Silanizations can be used to introduce a wide The three major forms of silicon discussed
range of functional groups, including amines, above are all easily functionalized with vari-
isocyanates, methacrylate and polyethylene gly- ous polymer chemistries (e.g., surface-initiated
col (PEG) functionalities. The functionalization and surface-tethered polymerization), grafting
of pSi has been previously reviewed [60,72] . techniques and noncovalent depositions (e.g.,
An additional benefit of pSi-based drug deliv- spin- and dip-coating). In this manner, sili-
ery is that the optical properties of the mate- con–polymer hybrid materials with enhanced
rial allow the noninvasive measurement of the properties for drug delivery can be formed. This
drug-release rate. A self-reporting drug-delivery review will focus on the use of these three silicon
system based on pSi particles has been recently forms in three major approaches to drug delivery
reported in living animal eyes [73] . with silicon–polymer hybrid materials, including
Flat (single crystal) silicon lacks the high sur- micro- and nano-particles, monoliths (e.g., films
face area of pSi, but is a popular model system and membranes) and micromachined devices.
for developers of drug-delivery platforms. Flat When designing materials for drug delivery,
Si can be surface-functionalized by silanization issues such as structural parameters, release and
and hydrosilylation in much the same way as pSi. biodegradation kinetics and mechanisms, load-
However, when performing silanization reac- ing capacity and material toxicity must be taken
tions, the silicon wafers must first be cleaned and into account. It is important to note that the
activated with piranha solution, which is known hybrid materials discussed in this paper are novel
to generate Si-OH groups [74] . On the other hand, and require further testing to fully characterize
complete removal of the native oxide layer with their properties. We have endeavored to discuss Microelectromechanical
HF (to create Si–H surfaces) is required before all relevant data where available. systems
A 100 B 80
Cumulative drug release (wt%)
80
60
60
40
40
20
20
10wt% xerogel loading
50 µm 20wt% xerogel loading 50 µm
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Time (days) Time (days)
Figure 5. (A) Gentamicin release from SiO2–poly(dl-lactide-co-glycolide)-encapsulated single- and (B) double-layered silica xerogel
microspheres. Insets show representative scanning electron microscopy images of encapsulated microspheres.
Adapted with permission from [20] .
Cationic Anionic
polymer polymer Multiple
- - deposition - - deposition - - depositions - -
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
Table 1. Polymers with potential application to silicon- and silica-based drug-delivery composites.
Polymer Useful properties Ref.
Poly(7-allyloxycoumarin) Photodimerization (with drugs or interchain) [138]
Poly(vinylbenzylthymine) Photodimerization (with drugs or interchain) [139]
Poly(ethyleneimine)-co-poloxamer diacrylate High transfection efficiency, good DNA binding, low cytotoxicity [140,141]
or
poly(ethyleneimine)-co-glycerol
dimethacrylate
Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-co-(4- Temperature and pH sensitive, fluorescent [142]
vinylpyridine)-co-(N-
pyrenemethylacrylamide)
High-molecular-weight polyethylene glycols Easily modified, reductively cleavable S-S bonds, hydrolytically degradable, [143]
modified with cysteine bonding to drugs, proteins and DNA
Poly(glycerol-adipate) Nontoxic, biological monomer, low cytotoxicity, high drug loading [144]
Poly(pyridyldisulfide ethylmethacrylate) Multifunctional (able to bind DNA, proteins and sulfur-containing compounds), [145]
variable physicochemical properties
Crosslinked acid liable poly(acrylamide) pH-stimulated release, protection from nuclease degradation [146]
example, in coatings for biomedical devices such stack size to allow higher loading can lead to
as intravascular stents, the coating could locally the retardation of drug diffusion from the film.
release gene-based therapeutics for cardiovascu- Other issues include the inability to release drugs
lar disease [131] . In these works, the time for com- under physiological conditions and the need to
plete drug release was between 30 and 100 h, modify some substrates before deposition [127] .
however these release times could be tuned by However, the LBL deposition of polymers onto
introducing variations in the layer thickness and surfaces such as silicon has many advantages,
number of bilayers used. Zhang et al. have also including the high number of polymers available
released antisense DNA oligonucleotide strands as well as the composition and stack-size of the
from phosphorylcholine-containing polymer polyelectrolyte films. The ability to coat compli-
films on flat silicon wafers [133] . Oligonucleotide cated structures and to store and release a wide
loading increased with increasing film thick- range of compounds, including nanoparticles,
ness and also when the charge density of the still makes these systems exciting candidates for
cationic side chains increased. The film sus- use in drug-delivery applications.
tained the release of oligonucleotides for 8 days.
Released oligonucleotides were able to enter Polymer
grafting on flat silicon
vascular smooth muscle cells. LBL assemblies The grafting of polymers to surfaces can be
have been tuned to do more than just release performed via ‘grafting-to’ or ‘grafting-from’
functional DNA. These multilayered structures polymerization techniques. The ‘grafting-to’
are able to infer protein resistance to surfaces, or, method uses prepolymerized macromolecules
if coated with a top layer such as PLL-g–PEG/ (commonly biomolecules) with functional
PEG–biotin, they are able to selectively bind end-groups to react with complementary func-
streptavidin-bound proteins [134] . Polyelectrolyte tional groups residing on the surface; whereas
LBL-deposited films on silicon have also been the ‘grafting-from’ approach uses surface-
used to deliver therapeutic polysaccharides [7] bound monomer (surface-tethered polym- Surface-tethered
and gentamicin [135] . erization) or initiator groups (surface-initi- polymerization
Although LBL films on silicon are themselves ated polymerization) as anchor points for the A polymerization technique that
allows the tethering of growing
unlikely to find applications in in vivo drug deliv- polymerization process.
polymer chains to surface-
ery, they are widely studied as model coatings, This type of surface ‘grafting-from’ approach bound monomer groups
with the aim to transfer the optimized coatings has been used by Cole et al. to covalently link
to more relevant substrates such as intravascular PNIPAAm to flat silicon [107] . These surfaces
Ti stents [131] . There are some issues involved were anchored via the use of a methacrylate-
with the use of LBL systems for drug release, terminated silane, followed by the free radi-
the most notable being the inability of the films cal polymerization of N-isopropylacrylamide
to load large quantities of drugs. Poor loading (NIPAAm), tethering the resulting polymer
is usually caused by the ionic nature of the mul- chains to the surface. The resulting coatings
tilayered stack; however, simply increasing the were protein-binding above the LCST and
Table 2. Polymers that have been covalently attached to silicon, silica and pSi (since 2007).
Polymerization Polymer Surface Switchable? Ref.
technique (stimulus)
ATRP Poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) Silica and silicon No [147,148]
resisted protein adsorption below the LCST. coatings of PNIPAAm and PAAc to reversibly
PNIPAAm surfaces have also been used by bind fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-labeled
Tsukagoshi et al. to load and release aspirin [8] . BSA [136] . In this case, the polymer network was
At temperatures above the LCST, the release crosslinked with N,N´-methylenebisacrylamide
of aspirin was much slower due to the polymer and the maximum switching of the hydrogel,
chains in the collapsed state entrapping the aspi- in terms of wettability, occurred at a monomer
rin molecules. Kurkuri et al. prepared copolymer ratio of 36:1 PNIPAAm:PAAc. LeMieux et al.
H
Br ONa Br O N Br N
( )n
Br O O O O
O O O O O
O O O O
ONa EDC, NHS NH2
Figure 9. Grafting of biomolecules to the activated carboxyl groups of surface-initiated poly(acrylic acid) chains.
ATRP: Atom transfer radical polymerization.
Adapted with permission from [193] .
A B
Photoresist
PMMA
Silicon
First mask and
reactive ion etch
Second photoresist
150 µm
C
Second mask and
reactive ion etch
Photoresist and
device removal
PMMA drug-
150 µm
delivery devices
Figure 13. (A) Fabrication process for poly(methylmethacrylate) drug-delivery devices. (B) 150 ×
150 × 3 µm poly(methylmethacrylate) devices with four reservoirs. (C) 150 × 150 × 5 µm PMMA
devices with single reservoirs.
PMMA: Poly(methylmethacrylate).
Adapted from [241] .
Microneedles have also been fabricated with examples act as actuators to control the release
porous tips (Figure 11) that could potentially be of drugs from the device. Tsai et al. have used
used to store increased amounts of drugs and a polypyrrole film to induce a conformational
to safeguard against any biocompatibility issues change on a gold membrane upon the applica-
caused by broken tips [231–233] . New fabrication tion of a voltage. This gold membrane is laid
processes have been used to generate arrays fea- across a micromachined silicon aperture inside
turing both short (400-µm) and long-shanked a PDMS drug reservoir. This system is actuated
(900-µm) microneedles that can simultaneously based on the volume change in the polypyrrole
deliver drugs (short needles) and withdraw blood layer as cations move in and out of the polymer
samples (long needles) [237,238] . layer. When the bias is applied, the gold flap
Microneedles have proven difficult to coat opens and releases the drug to the surrounding
uniformly [239] . As an alternative, drug-loaded area [76] .
polymer gels have been used after application of
the microneedle array. To this end, the hydrogel Micromachined
polymeric
formulation containing therapeutic DNA was drug‑delivery devices
placed into the microscale channels created in As early as 2000, microfabrication processes
the skin after the insertion and removal of the were being applied to biodegradable polymers in
microneedles to the epidermis (Figure 12) . The order to create implantable biomedical micro-
DNA can now diffuse from this reservoir into devices. Armani et al. used micromachined
the surrounding epidermis [240] . silicon moulds to create 3D microstructures in
PCL, as well as demonstrating that both dry-
Polymer-enhanced MEMS and liquid-filled microcavities could be covered
The use of polymers in MEMS is not limited with thin gold films, which could potentially
to biocompatible coatings. On the contrary, be removed via anodic dissolution in biological
the polymers in some of the most interesting tissue [218] .
Executive summary
Single crystalline silicon is a popular platform for the initial design and testing of new silicon–polymer hybrid materials. However, the
inability of the silicon to degrade in vivo renders these devices unsuitable for in vivo applications.
Mesoporous and porous silica are attractive candidates for biomedical applications as they are highly tunable for pore size and
morphology, and they are also easily modifiable with a wide variety of chemical moieties.
The optical properties of porous silicon (pSi) or its polymer replicas are sensitive to the release of molecules from the porous matrices.
polymeric coatings.
Microelectromechanical system devices can control the release of drugs via electrically stimulated flaps or the dissolution of
capping layers.
The application of microelectromechanical system technology to drug-delivery devices including features such as reservoirs,
sensors, pumps and valves is producing smart devices with improved control over drug delivery and the possibility of sensor-release
feedback loops.
The development of polymeric devices based on micromachining principles could lead to implantable biodegradable devices that will not
127 Wang L, Wang X, Xu M, Chen D, 138 Mal N, Fujiwara M, Tanaka Y. 150 Wang T-L, Ou C-C, Yang C-H. Synthesis and
Sun J. Layer-by-layer assembled microgel Photocontrolled reversible release of guest properties of organic/inorganic hybrid
films with high loading capacity: reversible molecules from coumarin-modified nanoparticles prepared using atom transfer
loading and release of dyes and mesoporous silica. Nature 421, 350–353 radical polymerization. J. Appl. Polym. Sci.
nanoparticles. Langmuir 24(5), 1902–1909 (2003). 109(5), 3421–3430 (2008).
(2008). 139 Saito K, Ingalls L, Lee J, Warner J. Core- 151 Uekusa T, Nagano S, Seki T. Unique
128 Lu Z, Li C, Zhou Q, Bao Q-L, Cui X. bound polymeric micellar system based on molecular orientation in a smectic liquid
Covalently linked DNA/protein multilayered photocrosslinking of thymine. Chem. crystalline polymer film attained by
film for controlled DNA release. J. Colloid Commun. 24, 2503–2505 (2007). surface-initiated graft polymerization.
Interface Sci. 314(1), 80–88 (2007). 140 Kim T, Cook S, Arote R et al. A degradable Langmuir 23(8), 4642–4645 (2007).
n Crosslinked LBL multilayered films of hyperbranched poly(ester amine) based on 152 Uekusa T, Nagano S, Seki T. Highly ordered
poloxamer diacrylate and polyethylenimine in-plane photoalignment attained by the brush
ssDNA and BSA on silicon wafers were
as a gene carrier. Macromol. Biosci. 7(5), architecture of liquid crystalline azobenzene
used for the controlled release of DNA. The
611–619 (2007). polymer. Macromol. 42(1), 312–318 (2009).
dissolution could be activated and
controlled by proteinase K. 141 Arote R, Hwang S-K, Yoo M-K et al. 153 Gorman CB, Petrie RJ, Genzer J. Effect of
Biodegradable poly(ester amine) based on substrate geometry on polymer molecular
129 Vazquez E, Dewitt D, Hammond P, Lynn D.
glycerol dimethacrylate and weight and polydispersity during surface-
Construction of hydrolytically-degradable
polyethylenimine as a gene carrier. J. Gene initiated polymerization. Macromol. 41(13),
thin films via layer-by-layer deposition of
Med. 10(11), 1223–1235 (2008). 4856–4865 (2008).
degradable polyelectrolytes. J. Am. Chem.
Soc. 124(47), 13992–13993 (2002). 142 Ozen K, Elmas B, Ozsar O, Senel S, Tuncel 154 Cringus-Fundeanu I, Luijten J, van der Mei
A. Thermoresponsive-fluorescent HC, Busscher HJ, Schouten AJ. Synthesis and
130 Zhang J, Chua L, Lynn D. Multilayered thin
isopropylacrylamide–vinylpyridine– characterization of surface-grafted
films that sustain the release of functional
pyrenemethylacrylamide terpolymer and its polyacrylamide brushes and their inhibition of
DNA under physiological conditions.
complexation behaviour with DNA. React. microbial adhesion. Langmuir 23(9),
Langmuir 20(19), 8015–8021 (2004).
Funct. Polym. 68(2), 623–633 (2008). 5120–5126 (2007).
131 Jewell C, Zhang J, Fredin N et al. Release of
143 Braunova A, Pechar M, Laga R, Ulbrich K. 155 Feng W, Zhu S, Ishihara K, Brash JL. Protein
plasmid DNA from intravascular stents
Hydrolytically and reductively degradable resistant surfaces: comparison of acrylate graft
coated with ultrathin multilayered
high-molecular-weight poly(ethylene glycol) polymers bearing oligo-ethylene oxide and
polyelectrolyte films. Biomacromolecules 7(9),
s. Macromol. Chem. Phys. 208(24), phosphorylcholine side chains. Biointerphases
2483–2491 (2006).
2642–2653 (2007). 1(1), 50–60 (2006).
132 Zhang J, Lynn D. Multilayered films
144 Kallinteri P, Higgins S, Hutcheon G, 156 Stadler V, Beyer M, Konig K et al.
fabricated from combinations of degradable
St Pourcain C, Garnett M. Novel Multifunctional CMOS microchip coatings
polyamines: tunable erosion and release of
functionalized biodegradable polymers for for protein and peptide arrays. J. Proteome Res.
anionic polyelectrolytes. Macromolecules
nanoparticle drug delivery systems. 6(8), 3197–3202 (2007).
39(26), 8928–8935 (2006).
Biomacromol. 6(4), 1885–1894 (2005). 157 Gao X, Feng W, Zhu S, Sheardown H, Brash
133 Zhang Z, Cao X, Zhao X et al. Controlled
145 Wong L, Boyer C, Jia Z et al. Synthesis of JL. A facile method of forming nanoscale
delivery of antisense oligodeoxynucleotide
versatile thiol-reactive polymer scaffolds via patterns on poly(ethylene glycol)-based
from cationically modified
R AFT polymerization. Biomacromol. 9(7), surfaces by self-assembly of randomly grafted
phosphorylcholine polymer films.
1934–1944 (2008). block copolymer brushes. Langmuir 24(15),
Biomacromolecules 7(3), 784–791 (2006).
8303–8308 (2008).
164 Reichelt S, Jakisch L, Simon F et al. Two 176 Ishida N, Biggs S. Salt-induced structural 187 Furbert P, Lu C, Winograd N, DeLouise L.
routes for immobilization of a hyperbranched behavior for poly(N-isopropylacryamide) Label-free optical detection of peptide
OH-terminated polyester on a silicon surface. grafted onto solid surface observed directly by synthesis on a porous silicon scaffold/sensor.
Macromol. Symposia 254(1), 240–247 (2007). AFM and QCM-D. Macromol. 40(25), Langmuir 24(6), 2908–2915 (2008).
9045–9052 (2007). 188 Mosse W, Koppens M, Gengenbach T et al.
165 Feng L, Gu G, Chen M, Wu L. Synthesis and
surface properties of poly(methyl 177 Lewis GT, Cohen Y. Controlled nitroxide- Peptides rafted from solids for the control of
methacrylate)/poly(ethylene glycol) binary mediated styrene surface graft polymerization interfacial properties. Langmuir 25(3),
brushes. Macromol. Mat. Eng. 292(6), with atmospheric plasma surface activation. 1488–1494 (2009).
754–761 (2007). Langmuir 24(22), 13102–13112 (2008). 189 Feng C, Zhang Z, Forch R et al. Reactive
166 Ostaci R-V, Damiron D, Capponi S et al. 178 Brinks M, Hirtz M, Chi L, Fuchs H, Studer thin polymer films as platforms for the
Polymer brushes grafted to passivated silicon A. Site-selective surface-initiated immobilization of biomolecules.
substrates using click chemistry. Langmuir polymerization by Langmuir-Blodgett Biomacromolecules 6(6), 3243–3251 (2005).
24(6), 2732–2739 (2008). lithography. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 46(27), 190 Yao Y, Ma Y-Z, Qin M et al. NHS-ester
5231–5233 (2007). functionalized poly(PEGMA) brushes on
167 Dyer MA, Ainslie KM, Pishko MV. Protein
adhesion on silicon-supported hyperbranched 179 Samanta S, Locklin J. Formation of silicon surface for covalent protein
poly(ethylene glycol) and poly(allylamine) photochromic spiropyran polymer brushes via immobilization. Colloids Surf. B 66(2),
thin films. Langmuir 23(13), 7018–7023 surface-initiated, ring-opening metathesis 233–239 (2008).
(2007). polymerization: reversible photocontrol of 191 Park S, Lee K-B, Choi I, Langer R, Jon S.
wetting behavior and solvent dependent Dual functional, polymeric self-assembled
168 Howarter J, Youngblood J. Self-cleaning and
morphology changes. Langmuir 24(17), monolayers as a facile platform for
anti-fog surfaces via stimuli-responsive
9558–9565 (2008). construction of patterns of biomolecules.
polymer brushes. Adv. Mater. 19(22),
3838–3843 (2007). 180 Charlot A, Gabriel S, Detrembleur C, Jerome Langmuir 23(22), 10902–10905 (2007).
R, Jerome C. Combination of electrografting 192 Azioune A, Ben Slimane A, Ait Hamou L
169 Segal E, Perelman LA, Moore T, Kesselman
and layer-by-layer deposition: an efficient way et al. Synthesis and characterization of active
E, Sailor M. Grafting stimuli-responsive
to tailor polymer coatings of (semi)- ester-functionalized polypyrrole-silica
polymer brushes to freshly etched porous
conductors. Chem. Commun. 4656–4658 nanoparticles: application to the covalent
silicon. Phys. Status Solidi C 6(7), 1717–1720
(2007). attachment of proteins. Langmuir 20(8),
(2009).
181 Ghorbal A, Grisotto F, Laude M, Charlier J, 3350–3356 (2004).
170 Synytska A, Stamm M, Diez S, Ionov L.
Palacin S. The in situ characterization and 193 Dong R, Krishnan S, Baird B, Lindau M,
Simple and fast method for the fabrication of
structuring of electrografted polyphenylene Ober C. Patterned biofunctional poly(acrylic
switchable bicomponent micropatterned
films on silicon surfaces. An AFM and XPS acid) brushes on silicon surfaces.
polymer surfaces. Langmuir 23(9),
study. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 328(2), Biomacromol. 8(10), 3082–3092 (2007).
5205–5209 (2007).
308–313 (2008).