Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BEMOLANGA FIELD
UPPER TRIASSIC ISALO FORMATION RESERVOIR
BEMOLANGA FIELD
Upper Triassic Isalo Formation:
Fluvio-Deltaic Sandstones
Executive Summary that the local inhabitants used the bitumen to seal
their boats. Exploration interest in the oil seeps in
The Bemolanga Field in the Morondava Basin of the vicinity of two giant exhumed oil fields at
western Madagascar (Figs. 1 and 2) is one of the Bemolanga and Tsimiroro began in the early part of
largest tar sand deposits in the world with estimated the 20th Century with the drilling of 23 shallow wells
in-place bitumen reserves of 2-20 BBO, of which <1 before 1939. During 1945-65, the location and
BBO may be recoverable by opencast mining. Oil distribution of the bitumen was mapped by the
seeps in the region were documented in the middle Société des Pétroles de Madagascar (SPM), which
of the 19th Century but detailed studies into the undertook the systematic exploration of
potential of Bemolanga did not begin until the Madagascar by geological surface mapping,
1960s. The field is an exhumed oilfield, which was geophysical (gravity and magnetic) surveys, and
originally formed by drape over a basement high or the drilling of 39 wells (Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza,
by wrench faulting to give a transpressional-fold 1984; WIN, 2005).
anticline or flower-structure. The tar sands occupy
an area of >424 km2 and lie beneath up to 50 m of In 1962, SPM opened two quarries and set up a
non-impregnated, lateritic sandstones. The highly small pilot processing plant at Bemolanga in an
viscous, 11 °API bitumen occurs in the uppermost attempt to find the most suitable recovery process
Karroo succession in stacked, 150-600 m-thick, (Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza et al., 1980). The
fluvio-deltaic, channel sandstones of the Upper methods used in exploitation and processing of the
Triassic Isalo Formation. The sands have average Canadian Athabasca tar sands were tested without
porosities of 19.5% and average permeabilities of significant success. In 1965, the French company,
446 mD. Pay thickness averages ~30 m and the ELF-RE attempted air injection, but with
bitumen content is 2-9 wt.%. Since 1961, a number discouraging results. In 1972-74, two further pilot
of feasibility studies involving a variety of oil projects involving the application of heat (800-1100
extraction techniques have been undertaken, both °F) without the need for fine crushing of the
in the laboratory and at a pilot plant, including hot- bituminous sandstones were each undertaken by
water washing, air combustion and low-temperature the University of Tananarive and by the Oil Shale
solvent extraction. Although these processes can Corporation USA, both with positive results. SPM
produce 0.3-0.5 barrels of 22-29 °API oil from a ton ended its involvement in Madagascar in 1974 and
of sand, they are prohibitively expensive and it exploitation of the Bemolanga deposit has been
remains to be demonstrated that the field can be under the supervision of the state-owned Office des
economically exploited. As of early 2006, the Mines Nationales et des Industries Stratégiques
Bemolanga Field was undeveloped. (OMNIS) since 1976. Since 1977, the Bemolanga
deposit has been appraised by >10,000 shallow
Exploration History boreholes and several successful oil extraction
feasibility studies in which >5300 extraction
The Bemolanga Tar Sands of Madagascar first analyses have been undertaken (Andrianasolo-
appeared in written records in 1842, which reported Ralaimiza, 1984).
Basin Evolution and Petroleum Systems moved southward relative to Africa along the Davie
Fracture Zone (Fig. 1).
The Bemolanga Tar Sands are located in the
northern part of the Morondava Basin, which is one Most of the Early Cretaceous was a period of slow
of three basins that form a passive margin along the or non-deposition, coincident with the separation of
western coast and offshore areas of Madagascar Seychelles/India from Eastern Madagascar. Post-
(Figs. 1 and 2). The stratigraphic succession and rift uplift resulted in the emergence of the cratonic
tectonic history of Madagascar are directly related hinterland and the beginning of a long period of
to the progressive break up of Gondwana and the fluvio-deltaic/marine clastic progradation. During
subsequent rifting and southward drifting of the Turonian-Coniacian, widespread basaltic
Madagascar away from Africa. Continued magmatism and renewed uplift and seaward tilting
subsidence and tilting to the west, in response to of Madagascar was probably caused by its
the rifting of India during the Late Cretaceous, has separation from India. This uplift and tilting
led to the deposition of thick Mesozoic and continued throughout much of the Tertiary and
Cenozoic sequences along the passive margin. resulted in subaerial erosion of the updip margin of
the Cretaceous wedge, to leave Precambrian
Latest Carboniferous to Late Permian rifting basement exposed over much of central and
resulted in horst and graben formation and the eastern Madagascar (Figs. 1 and 2). In the offshore
deposition of thick sequences of fluvio deltaic, coal area deposition was dominated by carbonates and
swamp, and terrestrial clastics of the Sakoa and fine clastics, with multiple unconformities,
Lower Sakamena formations of the Karroo particularly within the Lower Tertiary section, related
Supergroup. Differential tectonic movement slowed to continuing tectonics. Uplift also caused partial or
in Late Permian times, when the only significant complete loss of landward closure on pre-existing
marine incursion in the Karroo sequence resulted in onshore structures and the progressive elevation of
the deposition of the Middle Sakamena Formation. the Bemolanga and Tsimiroro palaeo-oil
Redbeds and lacustrine source rocks in the Upper accumulations to near surface levels (Jeans and
Sakamena and Isalo formations continued to be van Meerbeke, 1993; Stone and LeRoy, 2003).
deposited until Early Jurassic times (Fig. 3), when
NE-SW and N-S Karroo trends were reactivated by The exact origin of the Bemolanga oil remains
the onset of rifting, as East Gondwana began to uncertain because of its advanced biodegraded
separate from West Gondwana. Following a marine state. However, oil and source rock extract analysis
transgression, localized salt basins developed in suggests that the oils are derived from Karroo
restricted conditions but were succeeded by a source rocks, probably the shales of the Lower
regionally extensive Middle Jurassic (Dogger) Triassic Middle Sakamena Formation, which
carbonate platform and sandy nearshore contain Type III/II kerogens and generally have
equivalents, which unconformably overlie eroded TOCs of 0.2-0.5%, more rarely up to 2%
Karroo tilted fault-blocks (Fig. 4). Following a major (Raveloson et al., 1991; Jeans and van Meerbeke,
Late Jurassic transgression, the carbonate platform 1993). Oil from the Middle Sakamena Formation
was covered by prograding Upper Jurassic-Lower was generated mainly during the Aptian to Eocene,
Cretaceous marine marls and limestones overlain with migration from west to east, since maturity is
by sand-shale sequences, reflecting the onset of greatest in the west. The Middle Sakamena
post-rift subsidence and the development of the Formation is still in the oil window in the northern
Majunga Basin passive margin and the Morondava Morondova Basin and in the gas window in the
Basin passive/transform margin, as Madagascar deeper southern part (Raveloson et al., 1991).
Shirley, 2003; TGD/NOPEC, 2006). In-place 25 years, SPM and then OMNIS have undertaken
reserves estimates are wide-ranging because they numerous mining and engineering feasibility
are dependent on assumptions regarding studies. Exploitation would involve removal of the
overburden thickness, impregnated thickness and overburden, drilling and blasting of the tar sands,
bitumen content. Variations in these properties before crushing and grinding to adequate
across the field allow it to be subdivided into eleven granulometry, and extraction of the bitumen from
areas (I-XI) (Fig. 8) (Rakoto-Andriantsilavo et al., the ore. Globally accepted extraction processes for
1995). In order to estimate full field reserves, an tar sands were piloted at Bemolanga, both in the
extensive reserve evaluation was undertaken on laboratory and at a pilot plant, and include hot-water
Zone VI where the overburden thickness was washing, air combustion and low-temperature
favourable, the impregnated layer was >5 m thick (~150 °F) solvent extraction. An early pilot
and the bitumen content was >5.5% (Rakoto- undertaken in 1961-62 by SPM, involved crushing,
Andriantsilavo et al., 1995). ‘Proven’ reserves of hot-water washing and secondary fines separation,
15.7 million tons (~100 MMB) of bitumen from 255 and gave a recovery efficiency of 80%, although
million tons of tar sands from an area of 5.6 km2 major difficulties appeared during the fines
were estimated through the drilling of 155 wells processing which were never resolved
(Table 1) (Rakoto-Andriantsilavo et al., 1995). The (Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza et al., 1980). Subsequent
bitumen is 11 °API, has a density of 0.982-1.105 thermally based and solvent-based processes have
g/cm3, and a very high viscosity of 2300 cp at 302 also been successfully applied, producing 0.3-0.5
°F. It has sulphur contents of 0.4-1.4 wt.% and is barrels of 22-29 °API oil from a ton of sand
composed of 27% asphaltenes, 28% resins and (Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza, 1984). However, the
45% oily components (Figs. 9 and 10) processes are prohibitively expensive, costing
(Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza et al., 1980; Andrianasolo US$28-31 per barrel. Pending the development of
et al., 1985). an economic extraction process, the Bemolanga tar
sand may be used locally as a raw material for road
With the intention of setting up a plant to process construction (Rakoto-Andriantsilavo et al., 1995).
50,000 tons of tar sand per day and produce 15,000 As of November 2005, the Bemolanga Field had not
BPD of synthetic crude over an exploration period of been developed (SPE, 2005).
KEY REFERENCES
Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza, H., 1984, Heavy-oil and bitumen projects in Madagascar, in Meyer, R.F., ed.,
Exploration for heavy crude oil and natural bitumen: Regional Resources, AAPG Studies in Geology, no 25, v.
1, p. 137-141.
Andrianasolo-Ralaimiza, H., Rakoto-Andriantsilavo, M.D., and Raveloson, E., 1980, The bitumen and heavy
oil deposits in Madagascar - feasibility and prospects of the Bemolanga deposit, in Meyer, R.F., Steele, C.T.,
and Olson, J.C., eds., The future of heavy crude oils and tar sands: McGraw-Hill, New York, p. 139-150.
Andrianasolo, H.R., Raveloson, E., Rakotoarison, S., and Lalaharisaina, J.V., 1985, Geology and mining of
Bemolanga tar sands; physico-chemical studies, in Khazoom, A., ed., 3rd International Conference on Heavy
Crude and Tar Sands, Long Beach, v. II, p. 846-857.
Jeans, P.J.F., and van Meerbeke G.L.E., 1993, Geological evolution and hydrocarbon habitat of the Majunga
Basin and Karroo corridor, Madagascar: Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B.V. The Hague:
http://www.pj-exploration.com/madagascar.htm.
Kamen-Kaye, M., 1983, Mozambique-Madagascar geosyncline, II: petroleum geology: Journal of Petroleum
Geology, v. 5, p. 287-308.
OMNIS, 2005, Madagascar – Opportunities for hydrocarbon exploration and mineral resources: Office des
Mines Nationales et des Industries Stratégiques promotional brochure, 16 p.
Rakoto-Andriantsilavo, M.D., Lalaharisaina, J.V., and Spariharijaona, A., 1995, New perspective for the
development of Bemolanga tar sand project, Proceedings 6th UNITAR International Conference on Heavy
Crude and Tar Sands, Houston, v. 1, p. 47-51.
Ramanampisoa, L., and Radke, M., 1992, Thermal maturity and hydrocarbon generation in rocks from the
sedimentary basins of Madagascar: Journal of Petroleum Geology, v. 15, p. 379-396.
Raveloson, E.A., Rouviere, F., Ruiz, J.M., and Lena, L., 1988, Bemolonga bitumen and Tsimiroro heavy oil
study: Proceedings 4th UNITAR/UNDP Conference on Heavy Crude and Tar Sands, Edmonton, Paper no. 83,
p. 1-14.
Raveloson, E., Rakotoarison, S., Ramorofidy, J., Raharijaona, R., Andrianmanantena, J., and Ramanampisoa,
L., 1989, Contribution of geochemical studies undertaken on Bemolanga tar sand deposit and Tsimiroro heavy
oil field for hydrocarbon exploration in Madagascar: Proceedings 4th UNITAR/UNDP Conference on Heavy
Crude and Tar Sands, Edmonton, Paper no. 84, p. 1-15.
Raveloson, E., Ranasy, J., Spariharijaona, A., and Ramanampisoa, L., 1991, Bemolanga and Tsimiroro source
rocks and hydrocarbon generation: Proceedings 5th UNITAR/UNDP Conference on Heavy Crude and Tar
Sands, Caracas, v. 1, p. 357-367.
KEY REFERENCES
(continued)
SPE, 2005, Madagascar bid round will attract E&P interest: SPE Review, November, p. 4-5: http://www.spe-
uk.org/images/speuk/articles/52/SPE_Review_1105.pdf.
Stampfli, G.M. and Borel, G.D., 2002, A plate tectonic model for the Paleozoic and Mesozoic constrained by
dynamic plate boundaries and restored synthetic oceanic isochrons: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, no.
196, p. 17-33:
http://www-sst.unil.ch/research/plate_tecto/alp_tet_main.htm.
Stone, R.A., and LeRoy, S.D., 2003, Madagascar deepwater, Part I: Deepwater basin confirmed far off western
Madagascar: Oil & Gas Journal, March: http://ogj.articles.printthis.clickability.com.
TGS/NOPEC, 2006, Petroleum geology and geophysics of the Mozambique Channel: promotional brochure:
http://www.petromarex.com/projects/moz/Mozambique_Brochure.pdf.
Walters, E.J., 1974, Review of the world's major oil sands deposits, in Hills, L.V., ed., Oil sands fuel of the
future: Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, Memoir, no. 3, p. 240-263.
Table 1 - Estimated reserves of Bemolanga Zone VI and its extension (Andrianasolo et al., 1985).
BEMOLANGA
AFRICA
8
MADAGASCAR - UPPER TRIASSIC ISALO FM RESERVOIR BEMOLANGA 9
AFRICA
6 km 6 km
ZONE
MOZAMBIQUE
BASEMENT
FRACTURE
m
6k BEMOLANGA
TAR SANDS
TSIMIRORO
D AV I E
H E AV Y O I L
m
6k
BASEMENT
PA N D E - T E M A N E
GAS FIELD
Fault
6 km Sediment thickness
Volcanics
Oceanic crust
Figure 1 - Sediment thickness in the Mozambique Channel showing the general structural trends in western
Madagascar and the location of the Bemolanga Field (TGS/NOPEC, 2006).
ANTSIRANANA
AMBILOBE
AFRICA BASIN
AM
PA
SIN
DO
MAJUNGA
VA
BASIN
FA
UL
Mahajanga
16°S
Ma
haja
Mananara
mb
a
EAST
Bets
COAST
BASIN
ibok
BEMOLANGA Lake
a
Alaotra
Iko
TSIMIRORO
pa
Maintirano
Toamasina
MORONDAVA
BASIN
20°S Mahanoro
Mania
Morondava
INDIAN
T
UL
FA
BY
Ma
ng
OCEAN
OM
oky
IAK
RA
NO
TS
LT
AR
FAU
AF
VA
AU
LT
Farafangana Jurassic
Onilahy Riv
er
Tropic of Capricorn Isalo II
Sakamena Fm.
FAULT
NOPAS
Precambrian
DA
basement
VI ZO
E
Y
FR NE
Volcanics
AC
Fort Dauphin
TU
RE
Figure 2 - Simplified geological map of Madagascar, showing the location of the Bemolanga Field near the
boundary between the Morondava Basin and the Majunga Basin (Ramanampisoa and Radke, 1992).
200 m
A Majunga
L
E
N
Bebao
N
BEMOLANGA
A
Tsimiroro
Antsalova
H
200 m
C
Morondava
E
U
Post-Karroo
Karroo
I
Basement
B
200 m Bathymetry
M
Onilahy
A
N
Z
20
O
0m
0 200 km
M
B BEMOLANGA
S N
Onilahy Mandabe Antsalova Bebao
CALL.
JURASSIC
MIDDLE
BELO
BATH. ISALO
BAJO.
LOWER
LIAS ISALO
TRIASSIC ? ? ?
SAKAMENA SAKOA
PERMIAN
SAK. BASEMENT
CARB. U
Marine facies
Continental facies of Karroo interval
Marine horizon
"Lagoonal" (estuarine ?) horizon
Figure 3 - Surface hydrocarbon occurrences in the Karroo sediments of western Madagascar, with simplified
S-N section showing the Karroo stratigraphy in the Morondava Basin (Kamen-Kaye, 1982).
HYDROCARBONS
SOURCE ROCK
PRESENT DAY
AGE DEEP WATER COAST INTERIOR LOCATIONS TECTONICS
Ng
INDIA DRIFT
TT
Pg MARIARANO-1
MAEVARANO-1
UPPER
MAROVOAY
RIFT
CRETACEOUS
MARAVOAY-1
TULERIE-1
?
W.NANAMBOLO-1
LOWER
SOFIA-1
MADAGASCAR DRIFT
?
? ?
UPPER
MIDDLE
III
IHOPY-1
ISALO II
SAG
UPPER
TRIASSIC
LIGNITIC SH
TSIMORORO
L. MIDDLE
ISALO I BEMOLANGA
U FAILED
RIFT
SAKAMENA
MANANDAZA-1
UPPER
L
CONTINENTAL BASIN
PERMIAN
?
SAKOA
PC
LOWER
CARB.
UPPER
Figure 4 - Stratigraphy of Madagascar, showing the main hydrocarbon occurrences (OMNIS, 2005).
A 45° 46°
Majunga
45°
Cap
San André
R
BEMOLANGA
TAR SANDS BEMOLANGA
A
18° BAP-5
C
CDB-1
BAP-11
S
BAP-13
A
Mozambique
G
Channel
18°
Cretaceous basalt
20°
A
Morandava ?
A
Tsimiroro Basement
0 200 km
Maraboaly
0 30 km
CDB-1
B BAP-13
300 300
BAP-5
y
?
cla
Elevation (m AMSL)
275 ? green clay 275
n
ee
? BAP-11
gr
?
s
nd
r sa
pe
up
?
Elevation (m AMSL)
250 ? ? 250
?
? ?
lo
?
w
ds
er
? an
sa
225 rs 225
nd
e
s ? low
s
and
ers ? ?
low ? ? ?
200 200
lay
lay
al c
lc
bas
ba
sa
sa
ba
lcla
Clay
y
0 5 km
Sandstone
Tar (bitumen)
Figure 5 - (A) Location and generalized domal shape of the Bemolanga Field. (B) Simplified N-S correlation of
the Isalo II reservoir unit through the Bemolanga Field (Kamen-Kaye, 1983).
Isalo l
Sakamena G r a n i t e
Gabbro
Basement
1000
~20 km
Figure 6 - Schematic NW-SE cross-section through the Bemolanga Field (Andrianasolo et al., 1985).
THICK-
BITUMEN
AGE GROUP FM LITHOLOGY NESS LITHOLOGICAL DESCRIPTION CONTENT
(m)
10 Intermediate clay
2-7%
20 Lower intermediate clay
K A R R O O
25 Basal clay
2-5%
U P P E R
400 Sandstone
I S A L O
PRECAMBRIAN
Figure 7 - Stratigraphy of the Bemolanga Field (Kamen-Kaye, 1983; Andrianasolo et al., 1985).
Ran
obe
Rive
r
940 940
Mits
iotka
Rive
r
I
III II
930 930
II bis IV
VI
VII VIII
920 920
River IX
anambaho
M XI
0 5 10 km
Figure 8 - Probable extent of the tar sands in the Bemolanga region and the subdivision of the Bemolanga
Field into eleven main reserve areas (Rakoto-Andriantsilavo et al., 1995). The reserve areas are defined by
differences in overburden thickness, tar sand thickness and bitumen content.
AROMATICS
80 20
60 40
40 60
20 80
NITROGEN-
SATURATES OXYGEN-SULPHUR
80 60 40 20 COMPOUNDS
Bemolanga
Figure 9 - Ternary diagram showing the composition of the Bemolanga bitumen (Raveloson et al., 1989).
C30
C20
C24
C20
C24
A
C30
Figure 10 - Gas chromatograms of the saturate fraction of: (A) Bemolanga bitumen; compared to
(B) conventional light crude (Raveloson et al., 1988). The Bemolanga bitumen has a profile typical of a
biodegraded hydrocarbon.