FLYER

15th EDITION – SEPTEMBER 2015

MES Product Survey 2015

The invaluable guide to accelerate the

evaluation of your potential MES solution
Flyer MES Product Survey 2015

CONTENT, PRODUCTS & VENDORS No. Product Vendor

1 Aegis FactoryLogix Aegis Software
CONTENT 2 Ampla Schneider Electric
SUMMARY 3 APIS Prediktor AS
1 INTRODUCTION 4 AquiWEB Astrée Software
1.1 MES Product Survey 5 aspenONE Aspen Technology
1.2 Objectives 6 ATS CM4D ATS International B.V.
1.3 Participants
7 ATS Inspect ATS International B.V.
1.4 MES Product Selection
8 ATS Intelligence ATS International B.V.
1.5 Reading Guide
2 OBSERVATIONS AND TREND 9 Camstar Manufacturing Siemens
2.1 Business Issues 10 CAS-MES Shenyang Institute of Automation (SIA)
2.2 Manufacturing Maturity 11 CAT Squared MES CAT Squared
2.3 Metrics Matter 12 Clinicopia Catalent CTS Informatics, Inc
2.4 Business Case or Justification for MES 13 cmNavigo Critical Manufacturing, S.A.
2.5 Global Manufacturing
14 COOX / MESbox ORDINAL Software
2.6 Collaborative Manufacturing
2.7 Industrie 4.0 and Advanced Manufacturing 15 cpmPlus ABB Ltd
2.8 Internet of Things 16 D2000 Entis IPESOFT s.r.o.
2.9 Big Data 17 DABOM ACS Co., Ltd.
2.10 Security 18 Delfoi Planner Delfoi Oy/Ltd
2.11 Energy management (ISO 50001) 19 DELMIA Apriso Dassault Systèmes
2.12 Sustainability and LEAN
20 DIAMES CSM Systems AG
2.13 Cloud and SaaS
3 MANUFACTURING EXECUTION SYSTEMS (MES) 21 edinn M2 edinn global, s.l.
3.1 Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES) 22 Evolutio Siemens Industry Software Ltda
3.2 Blueprint Architecture and Value Adding Roadmap 23 Eyelit Manufacturing™ Eyelit Inc.
3.3 Multi-Site Template Based MES 24 EZ-MES EazyWorks LLC
3.4 Importance of domain expertise 25 FactoryTalk Rockwell Automation
4 STANDARDS AND BEST PRACTICES
26 Floormation Infinite Functions, Inc.
4.1 CGI’s Manufacturing Atlas
4.2 MESA International 27 FORCAM FORCE FORCAM GmbH
4.3 MESA Global Education Program 28 GOSystems Frontmatec A/S
4.4 MESA Manufacturing Operations Models 29 Hydra MES MPDV Mikrolab GmbH
4.5 ISA95 Standard 30 IBS:prisma MES Siemens Industry Software GmbH (QMS Software)
4.6 B2MML Standard 31 InFrame Synapse camLine Dresden GmbH
4.7 Validation and Regulatory Compliance
32 Intuition Honeywell Process Solutions
4.8 Serialization
4.9 MES and ERP 33 Legato Gefasoft AG
4.10 Demarcation between ERP and MES: R’s and C’s 34 LG CNS ezMES LG CNS
4.11 MES and LIMS 35 LineWorks Suite camLine GmbH
4.12 MES and Enterprise Asset Management (EAM) 36 Marco Trac-IT Marco Limited
4.13 MES, PDM and PLM 37 MEScontrol.net BrightEye
4.14 MES and Warehouse Management
38 MESplus Miracom Inc Co., Ltd.
4.15 MES and Data Historians
39 Mestec SaaS MES Mestec Limited
4.16 Integration Approaches
5 RESULTS OF THE 2015 SURVEY 40 MOM4 NearSoft Ltd
5.1 Summary 41 MOM95 KÖHL Maschinenbau AG
5.2 Scope of the Questionnaire 42 MV2 Paper-Less, LLC
5.3 Production and Logistical Typologies 43 NGIMES ATACHI SYSTEMS
5.4 Industry Sectors
44 nMetric Suite nMetric™, LLC
5.5 Preconfigured Solutions
45 Nova-LIMS Novatek International
5.6 MESA Compliance
5.7 MESA Strategic Initiatives 46 Objective Objective International NV
5.8 ISA95 Compliance 47 Operator Operator Systems ApS
5.9 Configurability 48 Oracle MES Oracle
5.10 Quality Assurance Systems of the Vendors 49 PAS-X Werum IT Solutions GmbH
5.11 Validation and Regulatory Compliance 50 PC-Factory MES PPI-Multitask Sistemas e Automação Ltda
5.12 ISO 50001 (Energy Management)
51 PI System OSIsoft, LLC
5.13 Projects
5.14 Deployment and Multi-Site Roll-Out 52 PILOT Suite Felten GmbH
5.15 Helpdesk and Support 53 Plex Manufacturing Cloud Plex Systems, Inc.
5.16 Languages 54 POMSnet POMS Corporation
5.17 Platforms 55 PRODAC PRODAC Systems - ENDIMO ltd.
5.18 Databases 56 Proficy for Manufacturing GE Intelligent Platforms Software
5.19 Technology
57 ProMANAGE Doruk Automation and Software Inc.
5.20 Architecture
5.21 Integration Approach 58 PSImetals PSI Metals GmbH
5.22 Mobile Solutions 59 Quartis Optima BODET-OSYS
5.23 Incident Management 60 Qubes Creative IT
6 DETAILS PER PRODUCT 61 SAP ME SAP AG
6.1 Product Information Sheets 62 SAP MII SAP SE
6.2 ISA95 Compliance Details
63 Shopfloor-Online Lighthouse Systems Ltd
6.3 Scores for Support of Manufacturing Operations
7 ANNEXES 64 SIMATIC IT Siemens AG
65 SWD-PES SW-Development Ltd
66 Syncade Suite Emerson Process Management
67 Traceability Made Easy Manufacturing Automation and Software Systems Group
68 TrakSYS Parsec Automation Corp.
MESA COMPLIANCE 69 Veri95 Movilitas (Inxites BVBA)
70 Wonderware MES Schneider Electric Software
71 Yokogawa MIPP Yokogawa Electric Corporation

2009 2011 2013 2015

6 80 - 100%

5 60 - 80%

4 40 - 60%

3 20 - 40%

2 0 - 20%

1
PLC, DCS
and Status

Production Units
Product Tracking

Performance

Management

Data Collection
and Acquisition

Management

Logistics focused:
Resource
Allocation

Management

Controls:
and Genealogy

Analysis

Dispatching
Process

TMS, WMS
Quality

Labor

cgi.com
© 2015 CGI GROUP INC 2
 Flyer MES Product Survey 2015

Products ISA-95 COMPLIANCE

60%
  Production Part 3 - Activity Models
50% Maintenance
Quality
40% Inventory

30%
Out-of-the-box + Configurable
20%
100%
2007
10%
2009
80%
2011
0% Support of
<=20% 20-40% 40-60% 60-80% >80% activities 2013
60%
2015

40%

OTHER GRAPHS
20%
Focus on Industry Sectors
0%
Production Maintenance Quality Inventory

70%

60%
Validation and
50%
Regulatory Compliance
40%
100% 2003
30% 90% 2006

80% 2009
20%
2012
70%
10% 2015
60%
0% 50%
Food & Beverage

Automotive

Cons.Packed

Machinery &

Aerospace &

Pers.Care
Other Life

Bulk/Petro
Electronics

Medical Device

Fine Chemicals

Paper & Pulp

Oil&Gas

Mining

Press & Printing

Building & Infra

Utilities & Public

Photovoltaic
(Bio)Pharma-

Plastics & Rubber

Metals (primary)

Semiconductor

(secondary)

Textile / Clothing /
Chemical
Home &

Science
Defense
Tooling

Metals
ceutical

Solar,
Goods

40%
Shoes

30%

20%

10%

0%
Platforms, Databases, Deployed
FDA
Developed
GAMP
21 CFR Part 11
Compliant
Validation
Dossier

Architecture and Technology

100% 100%
2003 2003
2006 2006
80% 80% 2009
2009
2012
2012
60% 60% 2015
2015

40% 40%

20% 20%

0% 0%
Win 2003 Win 2008 Win 2012 Unix Linux AS/400 Open VMS Oracle SQL-server Progress Informix Ingress Sybase DB/2

100% 2003
100% 2003
2006
2006
2009
2009 80%
80% 2012
2012
2015
2015
60% 60%

40% 40%

20% 20%

0% 0%
Client/ Load Distributed DNA Thin Client Web based SOA Com-techn ODBC Microsoft JAVA AJAX HTML5
Server Balancing Architecture architecture* platform* platform**

cgi.com
© 2015 CGI GROUP INC 3
Flyer MES Product Survey 2015

Mobile Solutions
100% 2009
2011
2013
80% 2015
Exp.2016

60%

40% 100%

80%

60%
20%
40%

20%
0%
Management

Data Collection /

Management
Product Tracking

Performance
and Status

Production Units
Resource
Allocation

Management
and Genealogy

0%
Analysis

Dispatching
Process

Acquisition

Labor
Quality
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
(exp)

Business Logics GUI Reporting

Out-of-the-box Out-of-the-box Out-of-the-box
5% 5% 10%
Configurable Configurable Configurable
10% 10%
With libraries With libraries With libraries
Custom made Custom made 15% Custom made

45%
20%
55%
30%
65%

30%

PRODUCT INFORMATION SHEETS

- Vendor Details - USPs (Product & Vendor)
- Product Details - Alliances For all
- ISA-95 Compliance - Interfaces 71 products!
- Configurability - Energy Management (ISO 50001)
- MESA Compliance & Strategic Initiatives - Major Functions and Industry Sector Solutions
- Implementation & Deployment - Specific Industrial Processes
- Specific Implementation Aspects - Mobile Solutions
- Tools for Implementation and Maintenance - Supported/Unsupported Aspects
- Product Improvements - Reference Project

ORDER INFORMATION
An electronic version of the report "MES Product Survey 2015" can be ordered via:
- Website of CGI’s MES Centre of Excellence: www.cgi.com/en/manufacturing
- Website of MESA International: www.mesa.org
After receipt of your payment of € 500,= or US$ 750,= (excl. VAT) the report (in printable PDF format) will be send via e-mail.
Premium members of MESA International can purchase the report for US$ 375,= (via MESA's website).

CONTACT INFORMATION
CGI MES Centre of Excellence Phone: +31 88 564 5278
PO Box 7015 E-mail: jan.snoeij@cgi.com
6801 HA Arnhem gerard.ipskamp@cgi.com
The Netherlands

Founded in 1976, CGI is a global IT and business process services provider delivering high-quality business consulting, systems integration and
outsourcing services. With 68,000 professionals in 40 countries, CGI has an industry-leading track record of on-time, on-budget projects, aligning
our teams with clients’ business strategies to achieve top-to-bottom line results.

cgi.com
© 2015 CGI GROUP INC 4