Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SPE 25546
This paper was prepared for presentation at the SPE Middle East Oil Technical Conference & Exhibition held in Bahrain, 3-6 April 1993.
This paper was selected for presentation by an SPE Program Committee following review of information contained in an abstract submitted by the author(s). Contents of the paper,
as presented, have not been reviewed by the Society of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to correction by the author(s). The material, as presented, does not necessarily reflect
any position of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members. Papers presented at SPE meetings are SUbject to publication review by Editorial Committees of the Society
of Petroleum Engineers. Permission to copy is restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words. Illustrations may not be copied. The abstract should contain conspicuous acknowledgment
of where and by whom the paper is presented. Write Librarian, SPE, P.O. Box 833836, Richardson, TX 75083-3836, U.S.A., Telex, 163245 SPEUT.
307
PRACTICAL HORIZONTAL CEMENTING TODAY SPE 25546
Oil-based muds may be the preferred system when Solids settling is not limited to the drilling mud, but also
drilling poorly consolidated formations or where there are occurs in the cement slurries if proper precautions are not
compatibility problems between the formations and the observed. Proper slurry design is of utmost importance
drilling fluids. Borehole stability may also be less not only to prevent particle settling, but also to help
affected through reduced drag or torque stresses when insure appropriate rheologies for efficient placement and
oil-based systems are used. These muds, though mud removal, as well as providing zero free water to help
conducive to effective formation control, are rarely provide top-side integrity in the annulus. Cement slurries
compatible with cement slurries and often leave the that have free water and/or settling tendencies can result
casing and formation of interest in an oil-wet condition. in water channels on the top side of a horizontal annulus,
This necessitates the use of properly designed spacers, or an area of reduced compressive strength cement
not only to provide compatibility with the mud and which may not provide the annular seal required for zonal
cement, but also to leave the casing and bore-hole wall isolation during stimulation treatments. It is imperative
in a water-wet state so that adequate cement bonds to that well-suspended, zero free water slurries be used in
both may be achieved. horizontal cementing applications.
Some brine-based, low solids muds incorporating Unstable slurries (those which exhibit tendencies to
formation compatible additives may be appropriate for settle) caused considerable expense to North Sea
some zones. However, to be successful, any fluid used operators when cement solids were found inside the
for drilling must provide effective solids removal, be casing. Wiper plug failure was first blamed for this
readily adjustable to meet a variety of well requirements, problem, but even more durable plugs failed to eliminate
must have consistent density and viscosity, and yet still the solids.
be economical.
Casing centralization is also severely affected by gravity
Optimum drilling mud properties, proper mud by allowing the casing to sag between the centralizers.
conditioning, and improving displacement practices have This not only provides a non-uniform annular geometry
been studied for many years. 3 -7 Other studies considered which complicates flow mechanics from a solids removal
mud solids and cuttings settling.3.8 The common standpoint, but also complicates mud removal during
conclusions these studies present are that mud cementing operations. Non-circular cross-section
conditioning, rheology control, centralization, careful hole wellbores have been suggested by Sauer. 2 These
cleaning, compatible spacer selection, and flow rates contribute to centralization problems as well as providing
sufficient to induce turbulence, are each critical to job excellent channels for solids deposition. Due to the fear
success. of increased drag caused by the large number of
centralizers in a horizontal well, many times the number
Deposition of solids in the wellbore is one of the most of centralizers is decreased or centralizers may even be
severe problems in horizontal wells. Settling of barite or eliminated. Reluctance to move pipe, either by
drill cuttings causes the mud on the low side of the reciprocation or rotation, is another major factor
annulus to have a higher density than the mud on the top contributing to cementing failures.
side. The amount of solids, or channel size, appears to
be a function of the rate of deposition and the rate of Improperly designed spacer systems and cement slurries
particle erosion by hydrodynamic forces. 3 Even though can cause cement job failures in otherwise perfectly
smaller particles may remain in suspension, larger planned and executed jobs. Spacer systems must be
particles may not, and in horizontal systems they compatible with the drilling fluid in order to prevent
accumulate in the narrowest part of the annulus, which forming a highly viscous interface which may promote
further diminishes the capability of the mud to remove mud channeling, must have flow properties conducive to
them from the well. 9 Mud and settled drill solids which the removal and suspension of settled solids, and be
are not properly removed from the wellbore with the drill stable for extended periods of time at wellbore
string can be a hindrance in getting casing to bottom in temperatures.
horizontal wells and these settled solids will be much
more difficult to remove once casing is placed into the Clearly the problems encountered in horizontal well
well. The best approach to minimize the settling problem cementing are critical and present significant chance for
is a properly designed mud system which is able to failure to obtain a proper annular seal. The second
adequately transport solids and drill cuttings from the portion of this paper will illustrate methods to combat
well. these obstacles.
308
SPE 25546 F. KETTLe M. EDWARDS, R. COVINGTON
309
PRACTICAL HORIZONTAL CEMENTING TODAY SPE25546
properties of the spacer necessary to adequately erode as stages of thin spacer and densified viscous spacer may
much of the highly gelled, partially dehydrated mud and also offer improved hole cleaning in eccentric situations
filtercake as possible. In some spacer tests, neither by utilizing the density difference as an aid in removing
water nor viscous flushes increased displacement mud from the wide and narrow side of the annulus. The
efficiency, while others showed pumping large volumes spacer example in the previous paragraph is a good
of thin flushes did improve displacement efficiency. 4.8 example of alternating density with increased contact
Each mud system is unique, and with thorough lab time in the range of 20 to 30 minutes, which has shown
testing in conjunction with past experience in the area, vast improvement in horizontal cement job success in the
spacer designs can be improved. North Sea.
310
SPE 25546 F. KETTL. M. EDWARDS, R. COVINGTON
some6 as improving the success in their given areas. mentioned earlier where cement solids were found to
These ECP's should not be used in place of proper have settled in the casing during the job. One report5
attention to each area listed above. It should be states requirements of cement yield point exceeding 15
considered an additional aid in ensuring that sufficient Ib/100 fe to control settling,
zonal isolation is achieved.
Cementing long horizontal intervals often requires a
cement slurry with a low yield point to reduce friction
Slurry Design pressure while pumping, in an effort to avoid exceeding
the equivalent circulation density of the well. Additives
Proper slurry design is critical to the success of a are available to aid in designing slurries in this manner.
cementing job. While some deficiencies may be tolerable Caution should be used when designing thin slurries to
in vertical wells, horizontal wells are not forgiving and the protect against settling or free water.
highest quality slurry must be used. Essential parameters
include zero free water at formation temperature and Proper attention must also be given to standard testing
minimal settling. such as thickening time, compressive strengths, and fluid
loss. It is not uncommon for fluid loss values of less than
The room temperature free water test in API 30 ml/30 minutes to be used. Numerous gas migration
Specification 1OA14 is not applicable nor is the Operating control additives are now available and should be
Free Fluid test in API Specification 10. 16 After incorporated into the slurry design as needed.
conditioning at expected well conditions, the slurry is
transferred to a graduated cylinder and allowed to stand
at room conditions where it gradually cools during the Cement Additives
test period. Since slurry properties may change with
cooling, it would seem more realistic to maintain the Recent developed slurry additives have widened design
slurry at 194 0 F for the remainder of the test, or at well capabilities significantly. Fluid loss additives are now
temperatures if the equipment is available to pressurize available for any degree of salinity desired and for very
the test. Deviation angle has also been shown to affect wide temperature ranges. Some are non-retarding and/or
free fluid data,16 and tests should be conducted at 45 0 non-viscosifying, thus allowing fluid loss control not
deviation. It is suggested that a duplicate test be previously available. Latex systems are now available for
conducted at the wellbore deviation to assure zero free use at temperatures exceeding 375 0 F.
fluid. Free fluid may show up not as clear water, but as
a thin portion of cement-colored fluid containing well Other additives that have significant application are those
dispersed cement fines. This type of slurry should be which counteract temperature thinning seen with some
rejected or adjusted to eliminate this phenomenon slurries at elevated temperatures. Fume silica or special
because the less dense portion at the top may not heavyweight materials have proven beneficial in providing
provide the strength required for a proper seal, and may slurry stability for horizontal applications. It is now
provide a path for well fluid movement. This could also possible to design heavy weight slurries with reasonable
leave the casing exposed to corrosion from down hole flow properties and still maintain the weighting material
water contact. in suspension. Fume silica and improved surfactants
have increased the design capabilities for low density
Slurry stability must also be considered an integral part of and/or foamed cement slurries where these have
the design and various procedures have been devised to application.
examine slurry settling characteristics. The "BP Method"
uses a cylinder filled with slurry which is then cured Also available are a new range of cement expansion aids
under well conditions until the cement sets. 17 The set which can be used to help prevent long-term gas
cement sample is then sectioned and a density profile of migration and reduce micro-annuli. Other new materials
the set cement is then determined. Recent laboratory are useful for delaying gel strength build up after the
data indicated a 1.90 S.G. designed slurry containing slurry is in place, which is beneficial in controlling
cement, dispersant, fluid loss additive, fume silica, and short-term gas migration. Non-lignin, non-cellulose
non-lignin retarder exhibited only 0.016 S,G. density retarder chemicals have been developed to provide more
profile difference using the "BP Method." Other methods predictable slurry response and improved control over
of obtaining pass/fail settling tests are used by others. thickening time.
The use of a stable slurry eliminated the problem
311
PRACTICAL HORIZONTAL CEMENTING TODAY SPE 25546
Proper slurry design often requires extensive laboratory in field mixing capabilities have greatly expanded the
examination of the various parameters to arrive at the types of slurries than can be mixed while offering
desired results. In some cases, it may be extremely improved slurry consistency.
difficult or impossible to meet all the slurry properties
that would be considered ideal. It is imperative that the Design improvements and greater tub capacity on
maximum possible lead time is provided before any recirculating type mixers and axial flow mixing systems
particular job so that slurries can be optimized. (also adaptable to the recirculators now in use) can
readily mix some slurries that were previously only
mixable with batch mixers. This has greatly expanded
Instrumentation & Computer Aids the capability to design for well conditions with less
consideration for the type of mixing equipment required.
Perhaps the most vital information required for suitable The axial flow mixers have also shown greatly improved
cement slurry design is an accurate bottomhole mixing energy, reduced dust in the mixing tub, and
circulating temperature. Downhole temperature recorders reduced the amount of air entrained in the slurry.18
have been designed for easy operation and to provide Automatic density control units feature improved
accurate data. They are surface programmed for instrumentation and computer control of the mixers to
optimum data gathering by using a personal computer. provide the capability to control slurry density to within
The recorder can free-fall downhole, be run on a tool 0.1 Ib/gal and change from lead slurry densities to tail
bundle, or be placed on wireline. Temperatures are slurry densities with very narrow transition intervals.
recorded during circulation to obtain BHCT and/or during
static times to record BHST. The recorders are retrieved
by either tripping out the drillpipe or by fishing with a Miscellaneous Equipment
wireline overshot and the data then recovered with the
computer. 21 This will help eliminate the possibility of Cementing heads or plug containers can contribute to
excessive under or over-retardation of the slurry. Many increased job success. Double-plug heads may be
cement additives are extremely temperature dependent stacked to allow the use of wiper plugs to isolate the
and incorrect temperature data may lead to cement interface between mud-spacer, spacer-cement, and
slurries failing to perform as designed. cement-displacement fluid. When used with remote
actuators, the cementing operation can be conducted
Numerous computer aids are now readily available and without shut-down times to release plugs. The additional
should be incorporated into any job design. Centralizer plugs allow the spacer to remain uncontaminated while
programs will give proper spacing required to achieve a in the casing and therefore provides better displacement
given standoff. Cement job simulators are now very and mud removal in the annulus. 18 Elimination of
detailed and can accurately estimate expected surface shut-down times prior to cementing assists in prevention
pressures, equivalent circulating densities, flow regimes of solids deposition or mud gelation under static
at given points in the wellbore, and free-fall conditions. 3 Once hole conditioning is complete, the
characteristics of the job. This tool becomes more transition to pumping spacer and cement should be done
important in designing slurries for long horizontal intervals as quickly as possible.
to ensure that the ECD is not exceeded.
Hydraulically operated multiple stage tools which require
Improved surface instrumentation and job data gathering no opening plug are available to assist in effective
capabilities now provide the capability for thorough job cementing operations. This offers obvious advantages
recording and post job evaluation. This information over free-fall opening plug models used in vertical wells.
allows the identification of specific problem areas such as A hydraulically opened tool used along with an inflatable
channeling or lost circulation which can be addressed packer element was used successfully by one operator. 20
prior to the next job.
Matson and Bennet suggest hydraulically set liner
Mixing Equipment hangers which require no surface pipe movement are
preferable to mechanically set hangers. 18 Gust and
Once the slurry has been designed and the computer aids MacDonald 12 describe problems and solutions when using
and job simulations have been completed and accepted mechanically set hangers for horizontal wells and
as suitable for the particular well conditions, it then conclude that proper centralization of the hanger is
becomes necessary to run the job. Recent developments important to ensure the slips set properly. Another
312
SPE 25546 F. KETTL. M. EDWARDS. R. COVINGTON I
conclusion is that liner movement during cementing REFERENCES
improves the quality of the job. A special running tool
allows liner movement, rotation or reciprocation, to help 1. Abass, H.H., "Non-Planar Fracture Propagation From
in running pipe through horizontal sections. This tool is a Horizontal Wellbore", SPE paper 24823 presented at
released either hydraulically or with a backup mechanical the Annual Technical Conference of the Society of
system. Petroleum Engineers in Washington, DC, Oct. 1992.
1. Successful horizontal cementing is now achieved 3. Keller, S.R., Crook, R.J., and Haut, R.C., Kulakofsky,
throughout the world. D.S., "Problems Associated With Deviated-Wellbore
Cementing", SPE paper 11979 presented at the Annual
2. Successful cementing of horizontal casing presents Technical Conference of the Society of Petroleum
problems that require particular attention during the Engineers in San Francisco, CA, Oct. 1983.
design and execution of the cementing process.
Mechanical, chemical, and rheological technology is 4. Crook, R.J., Keller, S.R., and Wilson, M.A.,
available to meet these challenges and do the job n Solutions to Problems Associated with Deviated-
properly. Wellbore Cementing", SPE paper 14198 presented at the
Annual Technical Conference of the Society of Petroleum
3. To obtain a good cement job, one needs to consider Engineers in Las Vegas, NV., Sept. 1985.
all of the mechanical elements discussed in this paper, as
well as the design of the drilling fluid, spacer, and cement 5. Jones, R.R., "Horizontal Cementing--Design and
slurry. Displacement Practices for Higher Success Rates and
Reduced Costs", presented at the World Oil 3'd
4. Laboratory studies of the drilling fluids, spacers, and International Conference on Horizontal Well Cementing,
cement slurries are imperative. Downhole conditions Houston, Tx., Nov., 1991.
must be simulated as accurately as possible. It is
essential that accurate downhole information 6. Smith, T.R., and Ravi, K.M., "Investigation of Drilling
(temperature, hole size, etc.) is made available. Fluid Properties to Maximize Cement Displacement
Efficiency", SPE paper 22755 presented at the Annual
5. Field operations must be carried out with the highest Technical Conference of the Society of Petroleum
degree of quality and professionalism to help assure that Engineers in Dallas, TX, Oct. 1991 .
the job goes according to plan.
7. Zurdo, C., and Georges, C., "Mud and Cement for
6. Computer models are available to aid in the design of Horizontal Wells", SPE paper 15464 presented at the
centralizer spacing, job simulation before execution, and Annual Technical Conference of the Society of Petroleum
post job analysis. These aids are an essential part of job Engineers in New Orleans, LA, Oct. 1986.
planning.
8. Parcevaux, P., "Guides Emerge for Cementing
7. Horizontal cementing must be approached as a single Horizontal Strings", Oil & Gas Journal Technology, Oct.
problem where all the contributing factors are identified 19, 1987, pp. 35-41.
and a total horizontal system concept is applied as a
single solution. 9. Martin, M., Georges, C., Brisson, P., and Konirsch.,
0.: "Transport of Cuttings in Directional Wells,"
SPEIIADC 16083 presented at the SPEIIADC Drilling
Conference, New Orleans, March 1987.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
313
PRACTICAL HORIZONTAL CEMENTING TODAY SPE 25546
10. Ravi, K.M., Beirute, R.M., and Covington, R.L., 21. Tilghman, S. and Tucker, J., TechLetter, Halliburton
"Erodability of Partially Dehydrated Gelled Drilling Fluid Services Internal Publication, Sept 1, 1990
and Filter Cake", SPE paper 24571 presented at the
Annual Technical Conference of the Society of Petroleum 22. Crook, R., TechLetter, Halliburton Services Internal
Engineers in Washington, DC, Oct. 1992. Publications, Feb. 1, 1990.
11. Wilson, W.N., and Jan, Y., "Model Study Improves 23. Torsvoll, A., Olaussen, S.A., and Almond, S.W.:
Cement Placement Design in Highly Deviated Wellbores" , "Keys to a Successful Cement Job for a Horizontal Liner
IATMI International Symposium on Horizontal Well on Statfjord A Platform, Well A-37A: A Case History",
Technology, Bandung, Indonesia, July 1991 SPEIIADC paper 21970 presented at the 1991 SPEIIADC
Drilling Conference, Amsterdam, March 11-14.
12. Gust, D.A., and MacDonald, A.R., "Rotation of a
Long Liner in a Shallow Long Reach Well", SPE 17183
presented at the IADCISPE Drilling Conference in Dallas,
TX, Feb. 1988.
314