Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recent citations
- Annette Oertle and Katherine Szabó
LETTER
due to high elevations and low population densities assessments). Reef island dynamics were also tracked
(Barnett and Adger 2003, Nunn et al 2014). using mass centre analysis (Paris and Mitasova 2014)
The Solomon Islands in the Western Pacific com- to determine the centroid of each island over time.
prise over 1000 predominantly volcanic islands, many Historical sea-level data and projections for the 21st
reaching over 500 m elevation. The human population century for the Solomon Islands are available from a
of 560 000 is spread across 28 000 km2 making it recent assessment of climate change in the Pacific
amongst the most sparsely populated of Pacific Island (Australian Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO 2014).
nations. Despite this low population density, the These regional projections used similar methodology
majority of human settlements are located in low- (documented in McInnes et al 2015) to the Inter-
lying coastal areas, and reef islands are becoming governmental Panel on Climate Change Fifth Assess-
increasingly densely populated due to restricted flat ment Report (Church et al 2013). Ages of trees
land adjacent to the coast. Rates of sea-level rise in the (Casuarina equisetifolia and Sonneratia alba) from
Solomon Islands over the past two decades are three islands were estimated using bomb-pulse radio-
amongst the highest globally, averaging 3 mm yr−1 carbon techniques to date the heartwood and better
since 1950 and 7–10 mm yr−1 since 1994 (Becker understand the historic context of shorelines (see sup-
et al 2012). plementary table 3).
Anecdotal accounts exist of extreme shoreline
changes over the past decade from scientists and local Wind and wave hindcast data
inhabitants across all provinces of the Solomon
Islands. Understanding the extent and rate of recent Estimates of wave energy flux (W m−1) for the period
shoreline changes on the islands of the western Pacific 1980 to 2009 at two locations (1. Roviana: latitude
is an important step towards assisting these vulnerable −8.39979, longitude 157.26700; and 2. Isabel: latitude
communities to adapt to the unprecedented rate of −7.33312, longitude 159.00030) were sourced from
sea-level rise and associated climate changes (e.g. the CAWCR Wave Hindcast 1979–2010 data (Source:
winds and waves) expected over the coming century. Australian Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO as
described by Durrant et al 2013). These locations
Methods provide an indication of the wave climate at the
Roviana and Isabel study sites during this period. Data
This study focussed on two areas of the Solomon for these locations were extracted from the nested grid
Islands with the highest density of exposed reef islands, (4 arcmin ∼7 km) for the Australian region. Data for
Isabel and Roviana. We surveyed twenty reef islands the 1979 calendar year was discarded to ensure
on the barrier reefs along the north-west coast of artefacts associated with the spin-up and initial condi-
Isabel, twelve reef islands on the barrier reef of Roviana tions of the underlying model were avoided. Direc-
Lagoon and Nuatambu and Mararo communities on tional wave energy flux data for each site were
the adjacent volcanic islands of Choiseul and Malaita arithmetically averaged over three different 10 yr
respectively (figure 1). Only two of the sites (Nua- periods (1980–1989, 1990–1999, 2000–2009) to inves-
tambu and Mararo) are populated, whilst the sites in tigate decadal changes in the average magnitude and
Isabel and Roviana have no known history of contin- direction over this 30 yr timeframe. Average wave
uous human habitation. The islands in Roviana are energy vectors (aligning with the direction of wave
used on a daily basis by nearby communities for travel) were plotted for each site with 0° representing
fishing, whilst the islands in Isabel are infrequently wave travel to the north (true north) direction and 90°
visited on a weekly-monthly basis by fishers with no representing wave travel to the east direction.
significant disturbance of coastal vegetation by fishers
observed. Results
Historical aerial photographs from 1947 to 1962
were sourced from the Solomon Islands Government Five of the twenty vegetated reef islands along the
Ministry of Housing, Lands and Survey archives. In barrier reef on the exposed, northern coast of Isabel
addition, high resolution satellite imagery was sourced have been totally eroded away in recent decades
for each site for 2002 (Ikonos 0.8 m resolution), 2011 (supplementary table 2), leaving no supratidal sub-
(Nuatambu-Quickbird 0.6 m, other sites-Worldview- strate and dead tree trunks resting on hard reef
2 0.5 m resolution) and 2014 (Worldview-2 0.5 m platform. A further six islands on Isabel had declined
resolution). Historical photos were georeferenced in area by more than 20% between 1947 and 2014.
against stable features in the most recent high resolu- Hetaheta, Sogomou and Kale experienced the largest
tion satellite image for each site. The vegetation edge of loss of island area between 1947 and 2014, declining in
each island for each historical image was digitised and size by 155 790 m2 (62%), 110, 930 m2 (55%) and
used as a long-term shoreline change proxy (Liu 48 890 m2 (100%) respectively (table 1 and figure 2).
et al 2014) (see supplementary table 1 for uncertainty Change in the twelve islands in Roviana was mixed
2
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Figure 1. Map of study sites. (a) Map of the Solomon Islands relative to south Pacific region indicating study sites (•) in Choiseul
(Nuatambu), Malaita (Mararo) and Isabel Provinces, (b) inset of study sites across northern Isabel. Sites from east to west: 1. Rehana,
2. Zollies, 3. Sogomou, 4. Sogomou ite, 5. Sogomou Fa, 6. Kumarara, 7. Sasahura Fa, 8. Sasahura ite, 9. Golora, 10. Retu, 11. Hetaheta,
12. Kakatina, 13. Rapita, 14. Kukudaka, 15. Kale, 16. Korapagho, 17. Kologhose, 18. Ghebira, 19. Bates, 20. Suki, (c) inset of study sites
in Roviana. Sites from east to west: 22. Piraka, 23. Nusa Ghele, 24. Pukuni, 25. Ovio, 26. Varilangge, 27. Ighisi, 28. Panao, 29.
Homhombu, 30. Hopei, 31. Kunkundu Hite, 32. Kunkundu Nomana, 33. Nusa Lavata.
with six islands growing slightly (<20%) and six south-east or easterly direction between 1947 and
islands declining slightly (<20%). 1962. The centroid of Kale on Isabel was displaced
The rate of loss of seven islands on Isabel, for 293 m on a bearing of 207° between 1947 and 2011
which time series imagery exists (1947, 1962, 2002 and before the remaining sediment was transported off the
2014), increased from a mean of 0.1% pa between reef platform into deep water. Likewise, the centroid of
1947 and 1962, 0.5% pa between 1962 and 2002 to Sogomou was displaced 550 m along a bearing of 224°
1.9% pa between 2002 and 2014 (figure 3). Islands in and the centroid of Hetaheta was displaced 244 m
Roviana did not experience a change in the rate of loss along a bearing of 255° over the same time period. The
over the study period, with island loss rates averaging centroid of these three islands initially moved in a
0.1% pa, −0.2% pa and 0.1% pa across the three time south-southeast direction between 1947 and 1962
periods. before moving rapidly in a west-southwesterly direc-
The centroid of the seven islands on the northern tion between 1962 and 2014 (figure 4). The islands of
coast of Isabel with >50% loss moved in a south, Zollies, Rehana, Kakatina and Rapita all disappeared
3
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Table 1. Island area and loss over time. Area (edge of vegetation) of islands with greater than 20% change from 1947 to 2014 based on aerial
and satellite imagery.
Site 1947 1962 2002 2011 2014 Area lost since 1947 (m2) Overall loss (%)
Figure 2. Coastal recession of Sogomou and Kale. (a) Coastline recession on Sogomou Island between 1947 and 2014, (b) view from
the eroding eastern end of Sogomou looking back towards the remainder of the island, (c) coastline recession on Kale Island between
1947 and 2014. Note: Kale Island was completely displaced by 2014.
between 1962 and 2002 (table 1). Severe coastal reces- Discussion
sion on the eastern shoreline of Nuatambu village
occurred between 2011 and 2014 resulting in ten At least eleven islands across the northern Solomon
houses being lost to the sea (supplementary figure 2). Islands have either totally disappeared over recent
Wave energy flux in Roviana was relatively low decades or are currently experiencing severe erosion.
with a generally north-westerly wave climate of 0.22, However, islands in the more sheltered Roviana area
0.28 and 0.18 W m−1 in 1980–1989, 1990–1999 and of the southern Solomon Islands did not experience
2000–2009 respectively. Wave energy flux at Isabel was significant coastal recession. Understanding the dri-
twenty-fold higher than Roviana with a generally vers of this rapid shoreline recession and contrasting
south-westerly wave climate of 4.9, 4.4 and 4.2 W m−1 erosion rates between different areas within this region
in 1980–1989, 1990–1999 and 2000–2009 respectively is critical to provide a foundation for local adaptation
(figure 5). strategies. Climate change induced sea-level rise is
4
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Figure 3. Annual rate of areal change for seven islands in Isabel (red boxes) and five islands in Roviana (green boxes) for periods
1947–1962, 1962–2002 and 2002–2014.
Figure 4. Movement of the centroid of seven islands on the north-west coast of Isabel between 1947 and 2014.
anticipated to be one of the greatest challenges for evidence of heightened erosion or reduction in island size’
humanity over the coming century. Whilst it has been (McLean and Kench 2015). These islands were located
shown that sediment accretion may help atoll reef across the Central Pacific in areas with 1–5 mm yr−1
islands adapt to higher sea levels over recent decades sea-level rise where net accretion occurred on most
(Kench et al 2015), it is likely current rates of sea-level islands and only small (<1 ha) islands were actively
rise will be exceeded during this century (figure 6). To eroding (McLean and Kench 2015). Several documen-
date, the responses of the islands of Melanesia to sea- ted cases of island accretion can be attributed to
level rise have been poorly studied, a recent review of anthropogenic influences such as reclamation (Biribo
island change studies in the Pacific indicated ‘little and Woodroffe 2013). In contrast, the majority of
5
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Figure 5. Average daily swell wave energy vectors offshore from (a) Roviana and (b) Isabel in 1980–89 (black arrow), 1990–99 (red
arrow) and 2000–09 (blue arrow).
uninhabited islands from the northern Solomon increase over the course of this century we can expect
Islands were actively eroding across all size classes, that many areas will experience sea-level rise rates
including those over 25 ha in size (figure 7). Large similar to or larger than the 7 mm yr−1 recently
Casuarina equisetifolia and Sonneratia alba trees observed in the Solomon Islands for all but the very
(>40 cm dbh) were present on the shoreline of all of lowest emission scenarios. Local inter-decadal varia-
the actively eroding islands and dating of selected trees bility and tectonic movements will be superimposed
indicated shoreline stability over the past 150–250 yr on these higher rates of global mean sea level, resulting
until the recent erosion documented here (supple- in periods when local rates of rise will be substantially
mentary table 3). larger than that observed over the last two decades.
El Niño/Southern Oscillation events result in sig- Therefore, we see the current conditions in the
nificant interannual variations in sea level in the wes- Solomon Islands as providing insight into the future
tern equatorial Pacific (Barnard et al 2015) (including impacts of accelerated sea-level rise.
the Solomon Islands, figure 6) superimposed on the Relative sea-level rise can also be the result of tec-
longer term (multi-decadal) sea-level trends of up to tonics, the Solomon Islands are in a particularly tecto-
3 mm yr−1 (Church et al 2006, Becker et al 2012). Mer- nically active part of the globe with the convergence of
rifield et al (2012) used tide gauge data to demonstrate the Pacific Plate, Solomon Arc block and Australian
that the rate of western equatorial Pacific sea-level rise Plate causing localised crustal deformations (Tregon-
increased significantly from relatively low values over ing et al 1998) manifesting as either island subsidence
the 1950–1990 period to much larger values since or uplift (Taylor et al 2008). Whilst the Isabel study site
1990. While there is significant interannual variability, is considered to be in a more tectonically benign area,
the tide gauge and altimeter data indicate a rapid rise without active volcanoes, the Roviana site experienced
in sea levels in the Solomon Islands between 1994 and an 8.1 megathrust earthquake in 2007 which led to the
2014 of about 15 cm (average of 7 mm yr−1). Projected reef islands of Roviana subsiding by up to 60 cm (Tay-
sea-levels for the Solomon Islands indicate a rise of lor et al 2008). Island subsidence can compound sea-
24–89 cm between 1996 and 2090, dependent on level rise rates and make these tectonically active
future greenhouse gas emissions (Australian Bureau of islands particularly vulnerable under accelerated sea-
Meteorology and CSIRO 2014) (figure 6). The higher level rise scenarios. However, the apparent resilience
local rate of historical rise is the result of both a larger of islands in Roviana to subsidence, despite observed
global averaged rate of sea-level rise (Church and increases in coral cover on adjacent reefs attributed to
White 2011) and also stronger trade winds since 1990 deeper water (Saunders et al 2015), and only 1
(Merrifield and Maltrud 2011) which are directly rela- (±1.4) mm yr−1 of vertical tectonic uplift measured in
ted to the decreasing Pacific Decadal Oscillation index Honiara since 2008 (Jia et al 2015), suggests subsidence
(Zhang and Church 2012). These PDO and ENSO is not the primary driver of coastal erosion observed in
conditions may ease in the Solomon Islands in coming this study.
decades to produce sea-level rise rates closer to the glo- The rapidly eroding islands identified in Choiseul
bal average. However, as eustatic rates of sea-level rise and Isabel are all exposed to northerly swell and wind
6
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Figure 6. Sea level in the Solomon Islands between 1950 and 2100. Sea level in the Solomon Islands from reconstruction (following the
approach of Church et al 2004 and Church and White 2011), satellite altimeter (Church and White 2011), tide gauge and projections
of 21st century sea level rise for the four emission scenarios used in the IPCC AR5. The dashed lines are an estimate of interannual
variability in sea level (5%–95% uncertainty range about the projections) and indicate that individual monthly averages of sea level can
be above or below longer-term averages.
events that at times can be severe (Smithers and receding shorelines and inundation from extreme
Hoeke 2014), with twenty-fold higher wave energy at water levels (Hoeke et al 2013). Inundation severity
Isabel compared to Roviana (figure 5). The largest net and frequency has become unacceptable for several
erosion since 1947 occurred on Sogomou, Hetaheta communities and relocation has occurred on an
and Kale Islands on Isabel, causing erosive displace- ad hoc basis. In Nuatambu village on northern Choi-
ment in a south-south-westerly direction. Centroid seul over 50% of houses have been washed into the
shifting of these islands in a consistent direction ocean as a result of dramatic shoreline recession. Resi-
(opposite to dominant wave direction) suggests ero- dents of Nuatambu described the shoreline recession
sion is not solely a result of sea-level rise (figures 4 as incremental over several years, rather than related to
and 5). Wave energy can interact synergistically with a specific storm or wave event as experienced else-
localised sea-level rise (through changing wave refrac- where in the region (Hoeke et al 2013). Many families
tion dynamics and more wave energy propagating have relocated to the adjacent high volcanic island of
across reef crest onto the coast) to exacerbate coastal Choiseul; however some economically disadvantaged
erosion (Storlazzi et al 2015) and thus may be a key dri- families have re-built temporary housing in increas-
ver of the rapid coastal recession in the Solomon ingly vulnerable areas of Nuatambu. The relocation to
Islands. Further work is required to determine the the adjacent high island has not been conducted in a
relative importance of extreme wave events or incre- systematic way to ensure this small insular community
mental changes in incident wave energy and their remains intact; instead families have moved to areas of
interactions with sea-level on shoreline dynamics of land they have customary tenure claims over. In the
islands. case of Nuatambu, families have spread out over five
Coastal erosion in the Solomon Islands over recent separate areas in small hamlets. In Mararo village on
decades is causing unprecedented threats to the biota eastern Malaita relocation as a result of coastal erosion
on these fragile islands and the subsistence commu- has been more orderly with the entire community
nities who inhabit them. The isolation from predators making the decision to relocate from the coast to a
that these offshore islands provide makes them critical high elevation site 20 m above sea level. Interestingly
nesting habitats for many endangered sea turtles and in this case the community had historically lived in a
birds. The south Pacific’s largest rookery of Hawksbill high elevation site prior to being encouraged by mis-
turtles on the nearby Arnavon islands has been threa- sionaries down to the coast in the early 20th century.
tened in recent years due to substantial beach reces- In addition to these village relocations, Taro, the capi-
sion (Poloczanska et al 2009). In addition to ecological tal of Choiseul Province is set to become the first pro-
impacts, over the past two decades, many coastal com- vincial capital globally to relocate residents and
munities have become increasingly vulnerable to services due to the threat of sea-level rise.
7
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Figure 7. Island change in the Central Pacific and Solomon Islands. Summary data of island area and percentage decadal change at
seven atoll sites in the Central Pacific (modified from McLean and Kench 2015) and Solomon Islands (this study). Island-change data
within the highlighted ±3.0% band width is not considered significant.
8
Environ. Res. Lett. 11 (2016) 054011
Church J A and White N J 2011 Sea-level rise from the late 19th to Merrifield M A, Thompson P R and Lander M 2012 Multidecadal
the early 21st century Surv. Geophys. 32 585–602 sea level anomalies and trends in the western tropical Pacific
Church J A, White N J, Coleman R, Lambeck K and Geophys. Res. Lett. 39 L13602
Mitrovica J X 2004 Estimates of the regional distribution Nunn P D, Aalbersberg W, Lata S and Gwilliam M 2014 Beyond the
of sea level rise over the 1950–2000 period J. Clim. 17 core: community governance for climate-change adaptation
2609–25 in peripheral parts of Pacific Island Countries Reg. Environ.
Church J A, White N J and Hunter J R 2006 Sea-level rise at tropical Change 14 221–35
Pacific and Indian Ocean islands Glob. Planet. Change 53 Paris P and Mitasova H 2014 Barrier Island dynamics using mass
155–68 center analysis: a new way to detect and track large-scale
Durrant T, Hemer M, Trenham C and Greenslade D 2013 CAWCR change ISPRS Int. J. Geo-Inf. 3 49–65
Wave Hindcast 1979–2010 v7(CSIRO) (doi:10.4225/08/ Poloczanska E S, Limpus C J and Hays G C 2009 Vulnerability of
523168703DCC5) marine turtles to climate change Advances in Marine Biology
Ford M 2012 Shoreline changes on an urban atoll in the central vol 56 (San Diego, CA: Elsevier) ch 2, pp 151–211
Pacific Ocean: Majuro Atoll, Marshall Islands J. Coast. Res. 28 Saunders M I, Albert S, Roelfsema C M, Leon J X, Woodroffe C D,
11–22 Phinn S R and Mumby P J 2015 Tectonic subsidence provides
Hoeke R K, McInnes K L, Kruger J C, Mcnaught R J, Hunter J R and insight into possible coral reef futures under rapid sea-level
Smithers S G 2013 Widespread inundation of Pacific islands rise Coral Reefs 35 155–67
triggered by distant-source wind-waves Glob. Planet. Change Smithers S G and Hoeke R K 2014 Geomorphological impacts of
108 1–11 high-latitude storm waves on low-latitude reef islands—
Jia M, Dawson J, Twilley B and Hu G 2015 Pacific Sea Level observations of the december 2008 event on Nukutoa, Takuu,
Monitoring Project: CGPS Coordinate Time Series Analysis Papua New Guinea Geomorphology 222 106–21
Report (Canberra: Geosciences Australia) Storlazzi C D, Elias E P L and Berkowitz P 2015 Many Atolls may be
Kench P S, Thompson D, Ford M R, Ogawa H and McLean R F 2015 uninhabitable within decades due to climate change Sci. Rep.
Coral islands defy sea-level rise over the past century: records 5 14546
from a central Pacific atoll Geology 43 515–8 Taylor F W, Briggs R W, Frohlich C, Brown A, Hornbach M,
Le Cozannet G, Garcin M, Yates M, Idier D and Meyssignac B 2014 Papabatu A K, Meltzner A J and Billy D 2008 Rupture across
Approaches to evaluate the recent impacts of sea-level rise on arc segment and plate boundaries in the 1 April 2007
shoreline changes Earth-Sci. Rev. 138 47–60 Solomons earthquake Nat. Geosci. 1 253–7
Liu X, Xia J, Wright G and Arnold L 2014 A state of the art review on Tregoning P, Tan F, Gilliland J, Mcqueen H and Lambeck K 1998
high water mark (HWM) determination Ocean Coast. Present-day crustal motion in the Solomon Islands from GPS
Manage. A 102 178–90 observations Geophys. Res. Lett. 25 3627–30
Mann T and Westphal H 2014 Assessing long-term changes in the Webb A P and Kench P S 2010 The dynamic response of reef islands
beach width of reef islands based on temporally fragmented to sea-level rise: evidence from multi-decadal analysis of
remote sensing data Remote Sens. 6 6961–87 island change in the Central Pacific Glob. Planet. Change 72
McInnes K L, Church J, Monselesan D, Hunter J, O’Grady J, 234–46
Haigh I and Zhang X 2015 Information for Australian impact Wong P P, Losada I J, Gattuso J-P, Hinkel J, Khattabi A,
and adaptation planning in response to sea-level rise Aust. McInnes K L, Saito Y and Sallenger A 2014 Coastal systems
Meteorol. Oceanographic J. 65 127–49 and low-lying areas Climate Change 2014: Impacts,
McLean R and Kench P 2015 Destruction or persistence of coral Adaptation, and Vulnerability Part A: Assessment Report of the
atoll islands in the face of 20th and 21st century sea-level rise? Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ed C B Field et al
Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Clim. Change 6 445–63 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Merrifield M A and Maltrud M E 2011 Regional sea level trends due Zhang X and Church J A 2012 Sea level trends, interannual and
to a Pacific trade wind intensification Geophys. Res. Lett. 38 decadal variability in the Pacific Ocean Geophys. Res. Lett. 39
L21605 L21701