Republic of the Philippines

BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY

Pablo Borbon Main II, Alangilan Batangas City
College of Engineering, Architecture & Fine Arts
www.batstate-u.edu.ph Tel. No. (043) 425-0139 loc. 118

SUMMARY OF COMMENTS, SUGGESTIONS AND REVISIONS

Efficacy of Calcium Oxide from Kuhol (Ampullariidae) Shells as Solid Catalyst for Transesterification of Tubang- Bakod
(Jatropha curcas) seed oil

Falcon, Emmanuel F., Pulhin, Arienne S.,Umali, Jonalyn B.

PAGE MEMBER OF THE

CHAPTER COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS REVISIONS REMARKS
NO. PANEL
The researchers checked
Preliminary Make sure that the names of the panelist thoroughly the names of
iii Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
Page are all correct. the panel and corrected
the misspelled name.
Remove some unnecessary parts in The researchers removed
1 Chapter I. the unnecessary parts in Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
Chapter 1.
I
The researchers provided
Provide the operational definitions of the
8 the operational definitions Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
terms indicated in Chapter 1.
of the terms in Chapter 1.
The researchers indicated
In the methodology, indicate the secondary in the methodology the
3 39 data used and the sources where it was studies used and the Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
derived. sources where the
secondary data obtained.
 The researchers indicated
Indicate the replicates or trials of testing in in the results the number Dr. Erma B. Quinay
43
the result of purity of calcium oxide. of replicates used.

The researchers provided

Indicate the reason why the 0% catalyst Dr. Erma B. Quinay
the explanations and
concentration is not chosen as the best
49 interpretations based from
catalyst concentration that gave the highest
4 gathered data and
yield of biodiesel. Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
observations.

The researchers
43, 44, Make an intelligent assumption based on interpreted the gathered
Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
49, 51 the literature as to what be the result in your secondary data according
study. to the study.

The researchers added in

Dr. Erma B. Quinay
their recommendation the
Recommend that the produced biodiesel need of analyses for the
from varying catalyst concentrations should produced biodiesel from
62
be tested to further identify which catalyst varying catalyst
concentration produced the best quality of concentrations to further
biodiesel. identify the best quality of Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez
5 biodiesel.

The researchers
recommended the use of
62 Suggest the use of acid-derived catalyst to acid-derived catalyst to Dr. Erma B. Quinay
further improve the existing study. further improve their
study.
 The researchers indicated
Recommend the addition of more varying
in their recommendation
catalyst concentrations to see the trend of
the addition of more
the results of which the catalyst will give the Engr. Naneth J.
62 varying catalyst
highest yield of biodiesel and further identify Aguado
concentrations to further
the infliction point of results.
identify the infliction point
of the results.

Noted by:

Ms. Rhoda G. Pangan

Thesis Adviser

Verified by:

Dr. Erma B. Quinay Dr. Elisa D. Gutierrez Engr. Naneth J. Aguado

Chairperson ` Member Member