Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pingali Venugopal
Ending the War between Sales and Marketing:
Harvard Business Review
• Marketing blames the salesforce for its poor execution of an otherwise brilliant
rollout plan. The sales team, in turn, claims that marketing sets prices too high and
uses too much of the budget, which instead should go toward hiring more
salespeople or paying the sales reps higher commissions.
• Marketing believes the salesforce is myopic and blind to the future (Kotler,
Rackham, and Krishnaswamy 2006).
Pingali Venugopal
Why Sales and Marketing Are at Odds or Even War
by Steve W. Martin
• Sales and marketing efforts are at odds. The marketing team lectures the sales
department, saying that if only the salespeople followed their advice, their
problems would have been solved. Meanwhile, the sales department always says
it needs something else from marketing.
—HBR Blog Network
Pingali Venugopal
The Conflict between Sales and Marketing
Pingali Venugopal
• The root cause of this situation is that sales and marketing have different
perspectives.
• Each group often undervalues the other’s contributions.
• This lack of alignment ends up hurting corporate performance.
Pingali Venugopal
Marketing
• Creating a brand
• Creating loyalty
Pingali Venugopal
• So marketing involves changing behaviour: Long term
• Selling involves satisfying current behaviour: Short term
Pingali Venugopal
Marketing versus Selling
Pingali Venugopal
Sales and Distribution Management: Aligning
Marketing and Selling
Pingali Venugopal
Chapter 2: Marketing and Selling
Process of Marketing: Changing Behaviour
Picking
Legalistic
Heuristics
Brand Loyalty
Pingali Venugopal
Quality Evaluation
Pingali Venugopal
Search Attributes
Pingali Venugopal
Experience Attributes
Source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdiRfDagxSA
Pingali Venugopal
Credence Attributes
Pingali Venugopal
Information Collected for Decision-making
Pingali Venugopal
Concepts
Pingali Venugopal
Product Involvement
Pingali Venugopal
Product Performance Risk
Pingali Venugopal
Social Risk
Pingali Venugopal
Purchase Involvement
Purchase involvement, on the other hand, refers to the consumer's interest in the purchase process.
The level of involvement influences the purchase decision making process.
• Visibility - displays
• Consumer Promotion
• Sales Promotions
• Kiosks
Pingali Venugopal
Primarily there are 4 types-of-consumer-behavior – article reference
Generalized Framework – Buying Behaviour – Linking with Process of Marketing
Pingali Venugopal
Process of Marketing – Attribute strategy
High
differences Build search attributes Build Experience
between attributes
brands
Pingali Venugopal
Process of Marketing – involvement strategy
High
differences Increase purchase Add product
between involvement involvement
brands
Pingali Venugopal
Summary of Marketing Strategy
Pingali Venugopal
Process of Marketing: Changing Behaviour
Picking
Legalistic
Heuristics
Brand Loyalty
Pingali Venugopal
Considerations for Selling for Consumer Decision Process
Considerations for Details Required for Effective Selling for Each Consumer Decision
Selling Process
Decision sequence Between product, brand and store
Place utility From where does the buyer want to purchase? (The characteristics of
the outlet from where the buyer wants to purchase the product).
Time utility When does the buyer want to purchase? (Time: a buyer can wait if the
brand is not available).
Power Who has the power? (Between brand and store)
Trade schemes What is the objective of the trade schemes which would encourage
the trade to ‘push the brand’.
Role of the price for Significance of price for the end consumer.
the end consumer
Consumer schemes What type of consumer scheme(s) would influence the buyer?
Pingali Venugopal
Picking Behaviour
Pingali Venugopal
Variety-seeking Behaviour
Pingali Venugopal
• With addition of search attributes, buyers move into variety-seeking behaviour.
Pingali Venugopal
Objective of Consumer Schemes for Variety-seeking Behaviour
Schemes
Consumption Experimentation
cycle fixed behaviour
Pingali Venugopal
Impulse
Pingali Venugopal
Subcontracted & Problem Solving decisions
If the buyer is not knowledgeable to make a decision, then the buyer goes into
subcontracted decision process
Problem
Expert Expert
Pingali Venugopal
Moving from Low Involvement to High Involvement
Creating Different Marketing Products
Pingali Venugopal
Subcontracted Decision Process
Pingali Venugopal
Problem-solving Behaviour
Pingali Venugopal
Habit
Pingali Venugopal
Product Characteristics and the Consumer Effort for Purchases
No information search.
High differences Evaluation is predominantly on Evaluation is predominantly on
between brands Search attributes. experience attributes.
Pingali Venugopal
Selling as per Generalized Framework
Pingali Venugopal
Conflict of Marketing and Selling
High differences
between brands Search attributes Experience attributes
Pingali Venugopal
For Example: Price and Discounts
• The marketing wants the salesforce to ‘sell the price’ as opposed to ‘selling
through price.’
• The salespeople usually favour lower prices because they can sell the product
more easily.
• Research has shown that deep discounts do cause the consumer to believe that
something is wrong and thereby reducing the quality perception (marketing
effort).
• So giving wrong trade or consumer schemes would conflict with the marketing
process.
Pingali Venugopal
Salesforce
Deployment
Salesforce Deployment Working of Deployment Decisions
Involves
• Allocating of the selling effort Allocation of 2000 accounts X 25 sales calls/account
• Determining the size of the Sales Force Selling Effort = 50,000 sales calls required to cover
• Designing the Sales Territories
Sales Force 50,000 sales calls required
Size 1,250 sales calls/salesperson = 40 persons
A Traditional calculation
A SMART calculation
• If there are 39 Size 1 (weekly turnover more than 30K), 451 Size 2 (weekly
turnover more than 10K but less than 30K), and 1,541 Size 3 outlets (weekly
turnover less than 10K), are there in a small town. Call frequency (no. of times
the outlets to be visited) for 1, 2, 3 outlets are 4 (weekly), 4 (weekly), 2
(fortnightly) per month. In-store time by outlet type are 20,15,10 minutes, we
assume that we will cover the outlets 100%, then
– No of total visit ?
– Total in-store time per month ?
• A salesman works 22 days a month, 480 minutes a day, thus working time per
month in minutes is 9600 minutes, if his travel time is 100 minutes &
administrative work time is 80 minutes a day then
– His monthly in-store time will be ?
– How many Salesmen territories are derived ?
Estimate requirements ~ Headcount / Workload Calculation Tool
Let us calculate
Total time 61090
Grade # of O/L Frequenc Total # of In store Total # of mins/
y/month visit/ month time / call month
Required to minutes
1 39 4 156 20 mins 3120 mins cover 100%
2 451 4 1804 15 mins 27060 mins outlets
3 1541 2 3082 10 mins 30820 mins
Divided by Divided by
Total 2031 5042 61090 mins
Number Of 9.25
Territories
Required
Headcount /Workload Calculation Tool
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define Local
Set KPI Implement
Territory
Framework and Review
Boundaries
Step 1 of Territory Design
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define
Local Set KPI Implement
Territory Framework and Review
Boundaries
Step 2 of Territory Design
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define
Local Set KPI Implement
Territory Framework and Review
Boundaries
Step 3 of Territory Design
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define
Local Set KPI Implement
Territory Framework and Review
Boundaries
Step 4 of Territory Design
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define
Local Set KPI Implement
Territory Framework and Review
Boundaries
Step 5 of Territory Design
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
Define
Local Set KPI Implement
Territory Framework and Review
Boundaries
To succeed you need a tailor-
made…
Salesorganization
& hierarchy
structure...
Sales Organization Concepts are the foundation of hierarchy structure…
Regional HR Manager
Management Levels
Manager
Span of Control
Management Levels
Regional Sales Regional Sales
Manager Manager
Advantages
• Efficiency in performing selling
activities
Disadvantages
• Geographic duplication
• Customer duplication
• Need for coordination
Geographic Sales Organization
Advantages
• Low Cost
• No geographic duplication
• No customer duplication
Disadvantages
• Limited specialization
• Customer emphasis
Market Sales Organization
National Sales Manager
Advantages
• Salespeople develop better
understanding of unique
customer needs
Disadvantages
• High cost
• Geographic duplication
Functional Sales Organization
National Sales Manager
Advantages
• Sales force with varied skills
• High customer & product focus
approach
Disadvantages
• Geographic duplication
• Customer duplication
• Need for coordination
Strategic Account Management
National Sales
Manager
Management Levels
Regional Sales Head of Key
Manager (GT) Accounts (OT)
Advantages
• Understanding of unique
customer needs/solution
Disadvantages
• High cost
• Non replaceable skills
Hybrid Sales Organization Structure
CEO
Finance Controller
Sales Capability
Sales Manager Regular Accounts Office Equipment Office Supplies Regional Manager - Foods & Manager – Other E
Industrial Sales Sales Manager Sales Manager Sales Manager Key Account Managers (4) Grocery formats
Practitioner’s approach
Intermediaries are a critical part of our Route-to-Market decisions in
many markets to reach fragmented outlet universe
Example INDIA
Tier A (>1m) Tier B (0.1-1m) Tier C (<0.1m) Rural
[12% of population] [9% of population] [8% of population] [71% of population]
F&B PLAYERS
Distributors/Franchisee/Stockiest
Redistributors/Sub stockiest
Wholesalers
Nestlé DSD/Van Sales Nestlé DSD/Pre-Sales Logistic Operator Distributor Pre-Sales Door-to-Door
*NOTE: Nestle may recommend resale prices, however, Distributors must be free
to independently set prices and terms & conditions with their customers
The Role of The Nestle Distributor
• Carry adequate stock of product to meet customer demand
• Obtain market distribution, at prices and margins competitive
with alternative products, within agreed distribution
parameters by:
• Trade channel
• Outlet type
• Provide sales force coverage geared to:-
• Achieving distribution objectives
• Covering all suitable current and new outlets to make the brands
available
• Providing display and merchandising support
• Provide sales data to Nestlé to assist in the profitable growth of
the business
• Represent Nestlé in an ethical and professional manner
Page 80
The Role of The Nestle
Distributor
• Deploy sufficient resources to adequately cover the assigned
territory
• Distribute efficiently, meeting the needs of the trade channels
• Extend competitive trade credit according to local custom and
practice
• Work to achieve agreed objectives in respect of:
• Sales volume
• Distribution by channel / outlet type
• Trade Standards
• Efficient use of Trade spend
• Promote the brands through promotional activity, working within
agreed guidelines, or to agreed strategy plans and budgets
• Provide competitive market and trade structure intelligence reports
to the company
Page 81
The Role of The Nestle
Distributor
• Manage key customers within agreed guidelines and in the best
interest of the company's brands
• Jointly train staff in product knowledge, professional skills in
sales, marketing and management
• Participate in the annual sales planning process, providing local
expertise and input and transparent performance reports
• Provide an organisational structure, both in quality and
numbers, capable of achieving agreed objectives and
implementing agreed plan
• Provide a level of service that meets the requirements of
customers within each trade channel
• Operates in an efficient manner to deliver profitable outcomes
Page 82
We have identified five Distributor
operating models that are available in
the Markets
Dedicated Sales
Exclusive Rep
Dedicated (Nestle only)
(Cover Non-
(Represent Nestlé's
Competing
portfolio only) Dedicated Sales
Portfolio)
Rep
(Nestle only)
Types of Distributor
Exclusive
(Cover Non- Non-Dedicated
Competing Sales Rep
Portfolio) (Shared with
Syndicated other Agencies)
(Represent Nestle's
and other Dedicated Sales
manufacterrers) Rep
Non-Exclusive (Nestle only)
(Cover Competing
Portfolio) Non-Dedicated
Sales Rep
(Shared with
other Agencies)
However the preferred models are only those which have dedicated sales representatives
83
Implementation RouteMap
We distinguish between two variants:
• whether your market has a Distributor Network or
• whether your market has no Distributor Network
Terminate Select Manage
Situation
No Analysis
& & &
Replace Appoint Review
Review Performing
to
Yes Current
Standards
Distributors
Manage
S Situation
Does your
Yes Analysis
&
T Market
Review
A have a Tools
Distributor &
R Network ?
Techniques
T
Pre-requisites
Select Manage
Situation
No Analysis
& &
Appoint Review
84
Source of GROWTH for Consumer Goods
Geography
New cities, new markets,
new areas extensions
Products Outlets
New channels, type of
outlets extensions
Shopper
Consumer
New shoppers &
consumers extensions
Source of Growth – outlet product relationship
Outlets
Existing New
KPI KPI
Wider Range/SKUs Wider Reach
Wholesale vs. Distributor – a comparative study
Strength Weaknesses
Strengths Weaknesses
• MAIN MARKETS
• SCHOOLS, COLLEGES • HOTELS & RESTAURANTS
• CINEMA HALLS • BUS STOPS
• RAIL STATIONS • OFFICE AREAS
• AIRPORTS • MALLS
• WHOLE SELLERS • HOSPITALS
• TOURIST SPOTS
• PETROL PUMPS
Outlet Classification & Mapping
• List all outlets ( use DSRs for listing )
• Identify relevant outlets where Nestle can sell
• Find out where nestle is available (YES) and Nestle is not available (NO)
• Place all YES outlets basis channels
• Embed Chanel strategy (e.g. Must Have SKUs, coverage frequency etc.)
• Make routes maps for optimum coverage
89
Outlet Classification & Mapping – TIME FACTOR
Time Breakdown:
Unproductive Time.
Morning time Morning Stem In Route Time Afternoon Afternoon
in Depot time in the
Time Stem Time
depot
Outlet Classification & Mapping – TIME FACTOR
Time spent at the store is the most important time of the day because
1. Account Management & development
2. Order Generation
3. Apply Merchandising Standards
4. Product Delivery
5. Cash recovery
A lot of Routes are not delivering due to planning, Salesman run long distances
nobody thinks to re-design Distribution Route
Outlet Classification & Mapping
Identify completion coverage days and market closed days
AREA - 2
TUESDAY- CADBURY
THURSDAY - PERFETTI
SATURDAY- NUTRINE
AREA - 1
MONDAY - CADBURY AREA - 3
TUESDAY - PERFETTI WEDNESDAY - CADBURY
FRIDAY - NUTRINE WEDNESDAY - PERFETTI
SUNDAY - MARKET CLOSED THURSDAY- NUTRINE
Re-mapping of Routes
• When Required ?
• What are the SIGNALS? If…
• Outlets give you feedback on coverage gaps
• DSR tells you on his heavy workload
• Competition is snatching space from us
• Strike Rate / SKU / AOS is not increasing
• Regular cash flow is decreasing
2. Document Analysis
• Strike Rate / SKU / AOS / Turnover / Cash Flow
96
Route Mapping Cycle
Route Mapping
Mapping / Re mapping
is a
Continuous Process
Route Monitoring
Tips
1. Don’t Re map ALL ROUTES TOGETHER
2. Don’t Re map UNNECESSARILY
3. Keep in mind Competitor's COVERAGE DAY for that market
4. Keep close watch on Outlet feedback / Strike Rate / SKU / Turnover
5. Make it a CONTINUOUS PROCESS ~ This is not an ONE TIME AFFAIR
Sales Quota
Practitioner’s approach
Sales Quota
• Top down
or
• Bottom up
or
• Combination of both
How Often Should a Distributor Business Plan Be
Prepared?
• Once a year
Situation Analysis
Where are we now?
SWOT Analysis
What are our
capabilities
& resources?
Objectives
Where do we
want to be?
Strategies
How will we
get there?
Action Plan
What has to be done?
Who will do it?
When does it have
to be done by?
Developing the Distributor
Business Plan
Where are we Situation Analysis
right now?
Where do we Objectives
want to be?
This can be thought of as the current “state of play” at this Distributor. This can be
viewed from two areas: Internally & Externally.
Internally Externally
• What are current sales (value &
• Are there any economic issues that
volume) compared with this time last
may impact on demand?
year? Last month? The targeted
sales? • Are our competitors taking action
• This can be further broken down by that is impacting on our business?
segment, category & product level to
• Are our Distributors’ competitors
identify problems & opportunities
taking action that is impacting on
• Highlights
our business?
• Issues that are hindering the business
• Market growth assumptions • Legislation
• Channel growth assumptions
• Brand growth
The SWOT Analysis SWOT Analysis
What are our
capabilities
& resources?
• The SWOT Analysis is probably one of the most useful strategic tools
we can use – if we use it correctly.
• Many people do a SWOT as an activity in itself, and fail to utilize it to
lead to action.
• As a tool, each element of the SWOT should lead to an action.
We can do We could do
S O
W T
=
Strategic Options
An Example Of A Check List For
A Strengths / Weaknesses Analysis
Strengths
Weaknesses
Example - Strengths
As perceived by the Distributor looking at Nestlé versus it’s competitor
STRENGTHS
Which means we should take the following
Findings
action to capitalise on
1. Maggi has about 75% of the market and it’s key Continue to capitalise on brand strength and remind
SKUs (100g Mas/400g Mas) are big sellers Distributor of the return it generates for his business
2. Nestle provides a team of Merchandisers to help Should ensure that we continue to use the Merchandising
my sales team. team for sales building activities
3. Nestle provides us with a dedicated sales person Build a stronger relationship between the sales person and
who only looks after my FS business the Distributor so that the Distributor sees the sales person
as part of his team
4. Better settlement of claims Remind the CD of the quick rotation of capital and returns
he generates. Should focus on investing on a good DS
immediately
Example
only
Example - Weakness
As perceived by the Distributor looking at Nestlé versus it’s competitor
WEAKNESSES
Which means we should take the following
Findings action to support / eliminate
1.Strict policies, no chance Must make him clear on the benefits of strictly
of divulging the policies adhering to codes and legislation. Help him to
for increased sales understand long term benefits out of this adherence
3.Too many documents that Should focus on specific documents and make him
do nothing specific for me understand HIS benefits out of those
Example
only
Opportunities & Threats - Something That Nestlé Can
Influence The Distributor On
Changes in the “market” situation Which means we should…
Opportunities
Threats
Example - Opportunities
2.Cadbury’s facing manufacturing Help him to proactively indent for more stocks
constraints to exploit the void
3.Household disposable income is Identify those brands which may appeal to the
increasing in the territory shopper and ensure there are no gaps in the
range.
Example
only
Example - Threats
2.Higher opportunities are Must discuss with the CDs for strategies to retain
causing high turnover at Sec good Sec. Sales force thru increased salary and
force level achievable incentives
Example
only
Identify & Rank The Top 10 Factors and Actions
SWOT Factors Action Required
1. S Maggi has about 75% of the market and it’s Continue to capitalise on brand strength and remind
key SKUs (100g Mas/400g Mas) are big Distributor of the return it generates for his business
sellers
2. S Nestle provides us with a dedicated Build a stronger relationship between the salesperson and the
salesperson who only looks after my Distributor so that the Distributor sees the salesperson as part
business of their team
3. S Better settlement of claims Remind the CD of the quick rotation of capital and returns he
generates. Should focus on investing on a good DS
immediately
4. W Strict in policies, no chance of divulging the Must make him clear on the benefits of strictly adhering to
policies for increased sales codes and legislation. Help him to understand long term
benefits out of this adherence
5. O New Office area has come up Ensure we know of all new outlets nearby the Office areas &
ensure they are being visited by us
6. O Household disposable income is increasing Identify those brands which may appeal to the shopper and
in the territory ensure there are no gaps in the range
7. T Arrival of Modern Retailers leading to a Inform our Distributors of practices in other countries and the
possible shake-up in the industry ways we are handling the situations there
8. T Higher opportunities are causing high Must discuss with the CDs for strategies to retain good Sec.
turnover at Sec force level Sales force thru increased salary and achievable incentives
9. T Out of home consumption in coffee Nescafe may become less remembered as a major brand to a
speciality shops such as Barista, Café new generation of drinkers. Customer needs to be reassured
Coffee Day is rising and threatening in that Nescafe is still top of mind and we should plan lots of
home Nescafe consumption. activity to align Nescafe branding to the new generation
10 S Nestle provides a team of Merchandisers Should ensure that we continue to use the Merchandising
to help my sales team. team for sales building activities
Objectives Objectives
Where do we
want to be?
118
Strategies - Set Targets for Execution
• SECONDARY Parameters for setting targets
• Contribution ( last month / week sales ~ SKU wise )
• Newly enlisted outlets
• New Products / SKUs
• Promotions
• Display
• Activities
• Seasonality / Festivals / Trend
• Competition coverage gaps ~ opportunity
• Area Dev. ( New township / Garment factory etc )
• Competence / Experience of your DSR
119
Action Plan
Action Plan
What has to be done?
Who will do it?
When does it have
to be done by?
Management of Sales Quota
Sales Quota
“A sales quota is the sales goal set for a product line, company division, or
sales representative. It is primarily a managerial device for defining and
stimulating the sales effort.”. … Kotler
Principles of quota setting
1. setting of sales quotas is a challenge to the sales manager and should be
handled with precision and adequate skill
3. it must be simple to understand both to the manager and the sales people
4. quotas set above the achievable limit often demotivate and result in high
turnover in the organization
5. Leadership Competencies
These competences focus on those behaviors that are core to be effective in the
specific role. These are mapped as per position level
6. Functional Competencies
To enable employees to understand the core competencies and associated
behaviors essential for success within their functional (sales) area.
5 IMPORTANT things to focus while recruiting and selecting sales people
The building blocks of successful onboarding are often called the Four
C’s. The degree to which each organization leverages these four building
blocks determines its overall onboarding strategy, with most firms falling
into one of three levels.
1. Passive
2. Hi-potential
3. Pro active
1. The first lever for successful onboarding is self-efficacy, or self-confidence, in job performance. To the degree that a new employee feels confident in doing the
job well, he or she will be more motivated and eventually more successful than less confident counterparts. Organizations should target specific onboarding
programs to help boost employees’ confidence as they navigate new organizational waters. Self-efficacy has an impact on organizational commitment,
satisfaction and turnover.
2. A second task-related lever is role clarity—how well a new employee understands his or her role and expectations. Performance will suffer if expectations are
ambiguous. Therefore, role clarity (or its flipside, role ambiguity) is a good indication of how well-adjusted a new employee is, and measuring role clarity can help
organizations stop potential performance problems before they get worse, leading to poor job attitudes.
3. Social integration is the third lever for successful onboarding. Meeting and starting to work with organizational ‘insiders’ is an important aspect of learning about
any organization. In addition, new employees need to feel socially comfortable and accepted by their peers and superiors.
4. Knowledge of and fit within an organizational culture is the fourth aspect of onboarding. Every company has a unique culture, so helping new hires navigate that
culture—and their place within it—is essential. Understanding an organization’s politics, goals and values, and learning the firm’s unique language are all
important indicators of employee
In every step the sales
person needs to bridge the
knowledge and skill gaps…
Enter priority 1
Enter priority 2
Enter priority 3
Priority
Priority
Priority
Desired
Desired
Desired
Current
Current
Current
Initial
Initial
Initial
GAP
GAP
GAP
Ensures a shopper focus and champions category thought leadership
Drive Category and Shopper Knowledge 0 0 0 0 0 0
within Nestlé commercial plans and processes.
Integrated Customer Relationships and Ability to establish and maintain influential relationships between
0 0 0 0 0 0
Collaboration Nestlé and the customer.
Functional
Grows the business and optimizes resources ensuring Nestlé meets
Drive Sustainable Profitable Growth 0 0 0 0 0 0
sales and profit objectives over time.
Chart Stand
Implementation
□ Paper for flip chart stands 50 sheets per stand = 200 sheets
□ White Board with portable stand 3 (2x1m)
Presenter`s
□ Marker Pens (Sharpie - black) 1 item / participant (small for cards) Table
Chart Stand
□ Binders 3'' (Consider NCE branded version) 1 by participant
Competency based workshop designing process
Final output of step 4 – Training Calendar
Motivation
for Sales
People…
Key Management Principle
Performance is based on
1. opportunity
2. ability Motivation is the force within us that activates our behavior.
3. motivation It is a function of three distinct components, Intensity,
Direction, and Persistence.
Motivation
basic salary
2. The hygiene factors are necessary conditions to achieve a state of neutrality and address the question “why work here”.
Equity Theory
Equity (inequity) is defined as the belief that one is treated fairly (unfairly) in
relation to others.
A salesperson’s choice of effort to be expended is a result of a comparison between his output-input
ratio and the output-input ratios of others.
Output of A (e.g. pay, recognition) Output of B (e.g. pay, recognition)
Input of A (e.g. effort, loyalty) = Input of A (e.g. effort, loyalty)
A salesperson who perceives to be inequitably treated can change his input, output, alter the
perceptions of self and/or others, change comparisons or leave the situation.
Motivational theories addressing the issue: ‘how’ do salespeople choose their actions?”
Expectancy Theory
1. Expectancy is the salesperson’s perception that a certain amount of effort will lead to successful
performance (e.g. Can I do it?)
2. Instrumentality refers to salesperson’s perception of the probability that performance will lead to
certain outcomes or rewards (e.g. What do I get for doing it?)
3. Valence is the perceived attractiveness (or unattractiveness) of an outcome or reward (e.g. How much
do I value the reward?)
Motivational theories addressing the issue: ‘why’ do salespeople choose their actions?”
Attribution Theory
3. Need for respect (e.g. need to be seen as experts who can give advice)
4. Need for routine (e.g. need to follow a routine that must not be interrupted)
6. Need for stimulation (e.g. need to seek outside stimulation and challenges)
7. Need for honesty (e.g. need to believe in the rightness of their practices)
Practitioner’s approach...
Total Reward Management – The Workforce Deal
Positive Workplace
Total Pay - People Focus
- Base Pay - Leadership
- Variable Pay - Work itself
- Benefits - Colleagues
- Recognition - Involvement
- Trust and commitment
- Open Communication
Reward Management Principle
• Non-FMCG companies
• Citibank
• American Express
• ICICI Prudential
• Bharti
• GE Money
“Pay for Person”
• In determining the increase in base pay the
following 4 factors need to be considered:
Sustained Contribution
External Competitiveness
Internal Competitiveness
Salary History
“Pay for Performance”
Overall package – Key Drivers
8. To motivate salespeople
Evaluation
raters
• Helps salespeople
better understand their Salesperson
ability to add value to
their organization and
their customers
Performance Cycle Tools
SMART
Business
Objectives Set Personal OSM
Performance
Objectives*
Coaching and Feedback is ongoing and occurs at each stage of the Cycle
186
Key Issues in Evaluating and
Controlling Salesperson Performance
• Outcome-Based Perspective
• Focuses on objective measures of results
• with little monitoring or directing of salesperson behavior
by sales managers
• Behavior-Based Perspective
• Incorporates complex and often subjective assessments of
salesperson characteristics and behaviors
• with considerable monitoring and directing of salesperson
behavior by sales managers
Dimensions of Salesperson
Performance Evaluation
Behavioral Results
Salesperson
Performance
Professional
Profitability
Development
Criteria for Performance Evaluation
Behavior :
Results:
198
Sales Organization Effectiveness
versus Salesperson Performance
Salesforce
Environmental Control
Factors System
Salesforce
Salesforce Sales
Salesforce Selling
Outcome Organization
Characteristics Behavioral
Performance Effectiveness
Performance
Salesforce
Nonselling
Organizational Behavior
Factors Performance
Let’s go to the case…
Channel Strategy & Design
This session talks about:
Distribution Pricing
Marketing
strategy Strategy
Mix
(Wholesale/Retail/Consumer)
Promotion
Strategy
(Push/Pull)
Implications for Channel Design
Consumer and B2B Marketing Channels
Contributions of Intermediries
• Provide Economic Value
• Provide Social Value
• Provide Marketing Support
• Impact Supply-chain Management
• Add Value to the Market Offering
Key Functions Performed in Marketing Channels
Marketing Communications
• Advertising the Product
• Providing Visibility & Displays
• Providing a sales force that offers information & service to customers
Inventory Management
• Ordering appropriate merchandise assortment
• Maintaining adequate stock to meet customer demand
• Storing merchandise in an appropriate facility
Physical Distribution
• Delivering products
• Coordinating delivery schedules to meet customer expectations
• Arranging for the return of defective merchandise
Key Functions Performed in Marketing Channels
Market Feedback
• Serving on manufacturer advisory boards
• Informing other channel members of competitive activity
• Participating in test market evaluations
Financial Risk
• Offering credit
• Managing risks related to product loss or deterioration
• Managing risks related to product safety and liability
Types of Marketing Channels
• Direct Channels
• Indirect Channels
• Single Marketing Channels
• Multiple Marketing Channels
• Vertical Marketing Systems
Companies Using Direct Marketing Channels
Companies Using Indirect Marketing Channels
Companies Using Vertical Marketing Systems
Evaluating Channel Alternatives
• Evaluation of Availability
Determining Channel Structure
1. Financial Evaluation
Channel Power
• Reward Power
• Legitimate Power
• Expert Power
• Referent Power
• Coercive Power
• Channel Leader Power
Channel Conflict
Channel Cooperation
Evaluate Legal and Ethical Issues
• Intense competition
• Sales volume
• Stock levels (shelf and backstock)
• Descriptions of in-store displays and promotional materials
• Competitor activity
• Plano gram compliance (shelf location, number of facings present, number of SKUs present,
missing/inaccurate shelf tags)
• Pricing
• In-store location of products
• Product damage
Importance of an Audit
The benefits of conducting retail audits are two-fold.
• On the one hand, they serve as a tool for suppliers to ensure that retailers are complying with pre-established
agreements on product placement, pricing, and promotion.
• On the other hand, they allow brands to accurately measure their success in the retail environment.
Equally advantageous is the priceless commodity of data that audits provide, though our data is only as
good as our method of collecting it. By taking the steps to aggregate quality data from various retail
locations over time and comparing results, managers can make actionable decisions that reduce
inefficiencies and ultimately drive sales.
Merchandising Report - This type of store audit is primarily concerned with the brand’s performance. Reps
use merchandising reports to log:
• Inventory levels & Stock-outs
• Condition of products
• Amount of available shelf space
• Units ordered
• Retail price
• General shelf appearance
Retail Market Questionnaire
Promotional Report - If a brand is holding a sale or other type of special promotion, it’s important to track its
success so as to know how it’s performing in the short-term and how to improve in the future. It’s key to
report on:
• The type of promotion being used (tasting, demo, price reduction, etc.)
• The duration of the promotion
• The featured product SKUs
• In-store position
• Sales results
• General effectiveness of the promotion. Are consumers engaging with our brand? Are retailers complying with the
placement of promotional materials?
Competitor Survey - One audit that brands shouldn’t overlook is the competitor survey, which can reveal
invaluable insight into how our brand stacks up against others in its category. It’s a good idea to identify:
• Who our direct and indirect competitors are in the store
• Competitors’ pricing strategies
• How many facings competitors have on the shelf. Is our brand being significantly overshadowed?
• Where competitors’ products are located in the store. Do they have prime placement at eye-level or near a checkout
counter? Are they located in a high- or low-traffic area?
• Any promotions competitors are running
Steps in the audit process
After realizing the inherent value of retail audits, how can our company guarantee that it’s executing them properly? Consider the following
procedure to help our team make the most of every store visit.
1. Articulate our goals. Determine the main objectives of our retail audit. Are you primarily concerned with monitoring competitor activity? Or do you care about how quickly our
products are moving off the shelf? Put in writing exactly what you are trying to measure through the audit and assign numeric or qualitative values to each goal as a parameter for
success.
2. Design audit criteria. Select the exact questions you will be asking in the audit and the acceptable answer types. Will you use “yes/no” questions, have reps write-in responses, or use
a scale such as 1-5? Avoid frivolous questions; only ask for information that can help our business improve (i.e. brand performance, competitor activity, retailer compliance, etc.) See
below for an example of the level of detail to include in our survey questions.
3. Schedule appointments. Once you know what you’re trying to gain from the retail audit, it’s time to make it happen. Aim for consistency in terms of who you send to which accounts.
This way, individual reps can become extremely knowledgeable about their stores and build a rapport with store management. Recognize that some retailers might want to be
notified before reps will be visiting their store. Also be mindful to schedule reps for an appropriate number of audits as determined by their assigned territory.
4. Gather data and photos. Make sure reps collect data that directly corresponds to the goals and criteria you’ve laid out. It might make sense to have some retail survey questions be
marked as “mandatory” if they’re extremely significant to company objectives. Including photos in audits is a great way to depict exactly what’s happening in a store at any given
time, and promotes accountability and compliance. Review the mediums reps are using to collect data and consider how to optimize them, ideally using software (more on this
below).
5. Evaluate results. Once audits are completed, organize our data in an easily digestible format. Numerical values can be depicted graphically, whereas notes could be tagged by a select
quality. Check to see how the results you’ve achieved stack up against our pre-determined KPIs.
6. Implement changes. After analyzing the findings, execute on what needs to be done in the short term. For example, perhaps you discover that a particular SKU is performing
significantly worse than others across several locations and you decide to pull it from shelves immediately. Alternatively, long-term business decisions can be made after you’ve
amassed data over a lengthier time period.
7. Repeat the process. After conducting several retail audits, you’ll be able to make adjustments to our retail audit process as needed to tailor it to our company’s unique needs.
Regularly conducting audits will allow our business to be as agile and rapidly adjust to the ever changing retail landscape.
Three Types of Data
In order to guarantee our retail auditing process is effective, make sure you and our team are equipped to
understand the data you'll be collecting. There are three types of retail execution data to focus on:
observational, activity, and sales data.
• Observational Data paints a picture of the in-store conditions our reps are observing and reporting on. This data
includes stock levels, number of facings, competitive activity, and more.
• Activity Data refers to the specific actions our team is taking in the field to improve execution in the store. Measuring
and tracking these actions is key to understanding what is impacting our sales and how.
• Sales Data is simply how much of each product is sold over a certain period at certain store locations -- something you
are likely already tracking. But it takes on new meaning when associated with our team’s Observational and Activity Data
-- giving you a sense of which activities and store conditions lead to the highest sales.
Advantages of Retail Audit Software
Historically, business have used pen and paper for retail auditing, which presents a number of avoidable
challenges, such as:
• Need to transcribe findings into a digital format after the fact
• Risk of losing or damaging paper
• Higher risk of human errors
• Delayed transmission of data from the field to decision-makers
These flaws in retail audit methodology make it hard for brands to replenish orders, alter their
merchandising strategy, or handle retailer compliance issues on the fly. To combat these issues, companies
can make use of technology. Choosing the right software for our company will be dependent on its specific
demands, but any solution should be equipped with the following functionalities:
• What are the advantages and challenges when goals and strategies are set globally and the
tactics are made locally?
•
• What type of organizational structure is required to handle coordination between global and
local teams?
• Is tying the compensations of GMs and regional directors with country’s profit goals a prudent
strategy? What are the advantages and pitfalls? Let us discuss with Exhibit 1
• Points to ponder
• What are the advantages and challenges when the process of budget allocation for local
marketing plans got changed from brand expansion targets to a certain percentage of sales?
• Apart from innumerable projects, what could have been a better strategy to focus on growths?
• What are the short and long term advantages and pitfalls of cost cutting initiatives?
• Points to ponder
• UniGlobe’s target shoppers - strengths and weaknesses (let us discuss with Exhibit 2 data)
• Points to ponder
• Let us discuss the efficacy of Sales Department (with Exhibit 3). Do you think the operation could
be made more simplistic?
• Do you think the sales operation structure would invite channel conflicts – vertical, horizontal ?
• Points to ponder
• Do you think UniGlobe’s trading terms with distributors support the objectives of SLS division?
• Points to ponder
• How would you handle the complexity of lower incremental margin vs. huge potential of sales?
• What could have been an effective strategy (both short & long term)?
Technology led transformation
Article Review:
The transformation of professional selling: Implications for leading the modern sales organization
Javier Marcos Cuevas
In Practitioner’s eyes
Key drivers of change in professional selling
• New buyer behavior and rising customer requirements
• Sophisticated and more powerful buyers seeking to achieve savings and to capture more value
• Procurement becoming a strategic function
• Value creation traditionally embedded in a product or service now manifested ‘in use’
• Sales Force Automation (SFA) refers to software apps for sales management.
• It is computer software that helps organizations manage their sales process. Usually as part of a CRM system, it
creates an automated flow that tracks new customers, or leads, from their initial inquiry through the sales
process.
• Sales automation lets you effectively manage your leads, creating efficiency in the workplace with team
collaboration that drives the sales process. It’s about reducing the manual processes and making sure your leads
are followed up in a timely manner, so you never miss another deal.
• Sales automation helps you prioritize your workload, ensuring time is not wasted with duplication of effort or in
manual data entry and in sifting through information.
Purpose of Sales Force Automation (SFA)
• Sales force automation tools are meant to assist sales teams in the selling process. Ultimately, the purpose of sales
force automation is to allow companies to sell more of their products. It does this in three main ways:
• Allow sales teams to focus on the most important tasks: By freeing up sales team members from administrative
tasks, sales force automation tools allow reps to spend more time on the activities more likely to result in sales.
For example, calling prospects, setting up meetings, or working on strategies.
• Streamline the sales process so the most effective strategy is always used: Sales force automation can also make
the sales process more efficient which can lead to sales. Team members may forget to send follow up calls or
emails. However, when set-up correctly, sales force automation tools should not have this issue.
• Allow managers to get insight into the effectiveness of the sales process: The reporting and analysis tools found in
most sales force automation software allow those in charge of sales teams to see what is working and make
adjustments to things that aren’t. This can lead to an overall far more effective sales strategy.
What does Sales Force Automation (SFA) do?
Contact Management - With all the information your need at your fingertips you’ll never miss another sale
• Find and track every customer, contact and communication instantly, then set tasks to follow up, and share with your team.
• Advanced search across your contacts, accounts, opportunities and tasks to quickly find what you need.
• Email integration to automatically capture your emails to and from your contacts to the CRM.
• Use geo-locations on Google Maps to find nearby accounts when planning our customer meetings.
• Keep track of your calls and meetings by setting tasks to follow up, or assign them to others in your team.
• Record all your interactions and activities to maintain a full account history and timeline.
• Customize your CRM to reflect your business by adding custom fields to your contact information data.
Task Management - Task management tools to organize everything and delight your customers
With SFA task management, when you create a task or reminder in the customer’s account it integrates with your calendar.
So when you open the task all the customer’s data and past communications are there in front of you. Once the task is
completed it is automatically added to the account record, creating a complete history of your interactions.
• Set up CRM tasks for yourself to follow up or assign them to others in your team.
• View and manage your tasks from your CRM dashboard and view outstanding tasks across your team.
• Record meetings, calls, emails and any other exchanges in the activity timeline.
• Automatically capture your emails to and from your contacts into the company account record.
Effectively manage and track every sales opportunity through each stage of your sales process to successful closure. Manage and track your
sales opportunities to effectively prioritize your sales effort. You get visibility of your sales team’s pipelines right through the sales process.
You can create sales opportunities showing the value of the deal, set and update the probability of the sale and also add weighted values. As
a result, our intuitive CRM system will help you create more accurate forecasts and close more leads. Creating quotations and invoicing
directly from your opportunities means no more switching between systems to get the paperwork done.
• Estimate the probability of success for each sales opportunity and track it through your pipeline.
• Add weighted values to give a sales forecast for the coming months and year.
• Opportunity History automatically tracks any changes to each sales opportunity as it passes through the pipeline.
• Set User Permission Levels to set security levels for all your team and control who has access to your data.
• Customize the stages of your sales process so your pipeline accurately reflects your business.
• Generate quotations documents directly from your opportunities and send them to your contacts.
• Sales automation is most effective when used in conjunction with Marketing Automation. This is where you can fine tune your customer
experience(CX) strategy, providing a seamless customer journey by integrating all your platforms, for example, your website, booking platform and
social media.
• Having arrived at your website or social page your new lead may be completing a signup form that flags their interest in your product or service.
• Using marketing automation your web form and social leads are integrated directly with your CRM system, so the new inquiry is immediately
logged as a prospect. Using Drip Marketing you might send a personalized, automated “thank you” message and create a task for a sales person to
follow up.
• You might also be applying integrated lead scoring and lead enrichment software that will help you prioritize the best leads for your business.
• To help prioritize your sales activity you can use lead scoring to assess which ones are most likely to turn into sales.
• It’s likely that when you look at your new leads, in your mind you consider their fit with your product based on a variety of criteria in
your qualification process.
• This could be their location, size of business, role of the inquirer, budget available and other considerations of their abil ity to buy. If you are
running marketing campaigns you may look at who has opened your messages, clicked through on your weblinks or even who has responded to
you.
• But rather than manually assessing this information you could score the various information and activity to give each lead a rating. Your sales
people might then just check this figure before picking up the phone to follow up. This is known as lead scoring and is a goo d use of cloud
automation.
Team Collaboration - the more the better
• Sales Force Automation has come into its own with the arrival of cloud technology. Accessing the CRM system through your
internet browser means you can retrieve the data wherever you are, seeing the latest updates. You can have multiple users
all accessing and editing a customer’s account at any one time, creating a central hub for your business.
• This is particularly useful if you have a remote workforce. Sales professionals working from home or on the road can login
and see the same information as their colleagues at head office. There’s no need to synchronize the data as everything is
updated in real-time.
Components of Sales Force Automation
Components of Sales Force Automation
• Activity Tracking and Alerts: Track and prioritize meetings and activities associated with your
contacts. Benefit from alerts that keep you on top of your customer commitments.
• Opportunity tracking: Track probability of close, products, lead source, status, and more for
every opportunity for total visibility and control of your sales pipeline.
• Dynamic sales pipeline management: See a complete, visual representation of your sales
pipeline at-a-glance to project revenue, adjust your strategy, and quickly focus your efforts.
• Sales Reporting: See dynamic, visual snapshots of real-time metrics covering sales
productivity and performance, sales pipeline health, top performing products, win/loss
analysis, and more with interactive, graphical dashboards.
7 advantages of automation – the ultimate advantage of Customer Management
• Improved Use of Resources
• Constant Accessibility
• When sales and marketing ethics are mentioned, the first thing that often comes to mind is fraud or,
more specifically, avoiding it, but there’s more to ethical behavior in business.
• Sales ethics can take your entire company to the next level. By embedding ethical culture into your
organization, you’ll set the foundation for customer loyalty, higher morale among your sales reps and
marketing team, and even sustainable growth.
• To make that happen, you’ll need to take some specific steps. In this article, we’ll outline benefits,
examples and steps to take to implement an ethical culture in your business.
What is sales ethics?
• Sales ethics refers to a set of behaviors that ensure that every lead, prospect and customer is treated with
respect, fairness, honesty and integrity.
• It means that, as a salesperson or marketer, you put the people you sell to first. You respect their choices
and opinions instead of forcing your agenda on them.
• When you consider the long game, ethical behavior in sales makes sense—you build loyalty and trust with
customers because you’re doing right by them. The outcome? Higher customer spend, more engaged
employees and lower costs of running the business.
• By adopting an ethical approach to sales, you’re making a clear statement: you want to sell to customers
that want to buy from you instead of selling by any means necessary.
What is ethical behavior when it comes to sales?
• What does ethical behavior look like in a real-life sales team? Here are some examples to follow.
• Picture this: You’re on a sales call. It’s going well and you’ve built a great rapport with your prospect. But then they ask you for more
insights into your product’s specifics, including features, capabilities and pricing options.
• You may feel tempted to say exactly what your prospect wants to hear just to close the sale, even if it’s not completely true. For example,
you could exaggerate the results other customers got with the product or completely make up figures.
• Not only does this make your product attractive, but it also makes you sound smart. What could go wrong?
• The answer: a lot. When the customer uses your product, they won’t just realize you were dishonest—they’ll lose trust in the entire
company.
• Many customers will never do business with a company again after just one negative experience. These unhappy customers may also
overload your customer support department with complaints and refund requests.
• The fallout doesn’t end with a lost customer. A study by American Express revealed that Americans tell an average of 15 people about a
poor service experience, but only 11 about a good experience.
• Instead of winning a happy, satisfied customer, you’ll end up with a negative referral engine.
What is ethical behavior when it comes to sales?
• Don’t attack your competitors
• “Why should I pick you over your competitor?” is a question you’ll hear more times than you want to.
• Slander and criticize your competitor for everything they do worse than you
• Use this as an opportunity to show your knowledge of available options and why your product stands out, brings better results and is
more suited to the prospect’s needs
• Belittling your competitors won’t make you look better in your prospect’s eyes. Instead, they’ll see you as dishonest and unethical.
• Case studies and success stories of existing customers that switched from a competitor to you
• A feature comparison, with an explanation of why your product is a better match to your prospect’s pain points
• What makes you and your product unique, like on-boarding, product documentation, walkthroughs and anything else that makes your
customer’s experience exceptional
• Simply put: make your product stand out because it’s good, not because your competitors are bad.
What is ethical behavior when it comes to sales?
• Adopt the Serve Don’t Sell Method
• The sales process is fundamentally about helping buyers make informed decisions. According to Liston Witherill, creator of the Serve
Don’t Sell Method, this approach lifts the pressure from sales reps to sell anything.
• The Serve Don’t Sell (SDS) Method is made of five stages you can follow in sequence:
• Fit: define your Perfect Fit Client (PFC) using demographic and psychographic factors such as job title, industry, company size,
beliefs, core problems, previous experience
• Discovery: establish your prospect’s personal and organizational pain points, why this change needs to happen now, their goals,
objectives and motivations
• Offer: include your prospect’s pain points and goals, how you can help, examples of similar previous clients, options of working
with you and a Q&A section
• Agreement: send a written proposal, collect and address unmet needs and get a signed contract
• Transition: onboard and prepare your client, establish points of contact and send supporting materials and documentation that will
make them more successful
• When you build a customer base packed with people and companies you can actually serve and help, you’ll build relationships that
work both ways.
• From your customer’s perspective, you’ll make a genuine difference in their life or business. And from your company’s perspective, you’ll
have a loyal customer that’s happy to keep paying for what you offer.
• In other words, you won’t sell just for the sake of selling; you’ll grow your company in an ethical, honest way in the long run.
How to foster an ethical culture in your sales team and business?
• Growing and managing your company in an ethical manner is no easy feat. Building an ethical culture needs to happen from every facet
of the company. It also has to be intentional.
• Here are the main ways you can make ethics in sales a habit for your company.
• Setting sales goals is essential to moving the entire company forward. When you use the SMART approach in setting goals—making them
specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and time-based—they can be huge motivators for your sales team.
• But when you set ambitious sales quotas and don’t outline a solid plan detailing how to achieve them, you’re setting yourself up for
failure.
• At best, you’ll end up with bad, high-churning deals. You might also see a drop in your sales team morale, from a dip in performance and
a longer sales cycle to an increase in tension.
• The worst-case scenario? Driving your sales team to commit fraud. Just remember the Wells Fargo scandal, in which bank tellers opened
thousands of fraudulent accounts due to mathematically unrealistic quotas:
• “[...] there were only about 11,500 potential customers in the area, and 11 other financial institutions. The quotas for the bankers at Guitron’s
branch totaled 12,000 Daily Solutions each year, including almost 3,000 new checking accounts. Without fraud, the math didn’t work.”
• Process of Increasing Product Involvement
• Increasing risk associated with purchasing untried brand
increases the importance of the product class.
• Increasing risk is about highlighting the consequences
of taking an unfavourable action.
• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSGnbl95w0Q
• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaI2JEV3Yuo
•
Straight Commission: Plan Variations Straight Commission: Rates
• There may be multiple forms of latent conflict that are present before a conflict episode… for example:
• Competition for scarce resources (i.e. there is only one best retailer prize but many are competing)
• Autonomy control (i.e. my company forces me to follow compliance of visibility but I need freedom).
• Goal divergence (i.e. many retailers were put on a task group together, but we cannot reach a decision together)
Perceived Conflict
• Conflict may exist with or without the perception of those involved. For example, there might be
situations where people perceive conflict to exist, but after speaking, they realize that there was
indeed no difference in opinions, and in fact, no conflict whatsoever. In this case, the stages of conflict
do not proceed. This type of perception issue can be resolved through improved communication.
• However, conflict may not be perceived or noticed when it actually exists. To become felt conflict, it
must be perceived in some way.