You are on page 1of 25

C

1
H A P T E R

Introduction to
Electromagnetic Testing

Marvin W. Trimm, Westinghouse Savannah River


Company, Aiken, South Carolina (Parts 1 and 2)
Holger H. Streckert, General Atomics, San Diego,
California (Part 3)
Andrew P. Washabaugh, Jentek Sensors, Waltham,
Massachusetts (Part 2)
PART 1. Nondestructive Testing

The idea of future usefulness is relevant


Definition to the quality control practice of
sampling. Sampling (that is, less than
Nondestructive testing (NDT) has been 100 percent testing to draw inferences
defined as comprising those methods used about the unsampled lots) is
to test a part or material or system nondestructive testing if the tested sample
without impairing its future usefulness.1 is returned to service. If the steel is tested
The term is generally applied to to verify the alloy in some bolts that can
nonmedical investigations of material then be returned to service, then the test
integrity. is nondestructive. In contrast, even if
Strictly speaking, this definition of spectroscopy used in the chemical testing
nondestructive testing includes of many fluids is inherently
noninvasive medical diagnostics. nondestructive, the testing is destructive if
Ultrasound, X-rays and endoscopes are the samples are poured down the drain
used by both medical and industrial after testing.
nondestructive testing. Medical Nondestructive testing is not confined
nondestructive testing, however, has come to crack detection. Other discontinuities
to be treated by a body of learning so include porosity, wall thinning from
separate from industrial nondestructive corrosion and many sorts of disbonds.
testing that today most physicians do not Nondestructive material characterization
use the word nondestructive. is a growing field concerned with material
Nondestructive testing is used to properties including material
MOVIE. investigate specifically the material identification and microstructural
Need for integrity or properties of the test object. A characteristics — such as resin curing, case
nondestructive number of other technologies — for hardening and stress — that have a direct
testing. instance, radio astronomy, voltage and influence on the service life of the test
amperage measurement and rheometry object.
(flow measurement) — are nondestructive
but are not used specifically to evaluate
material properties. Radar and sonar are
classified as nondestructive testing when Methods and Techniques
used to inspect dams, for instance, but
Nondestructive testing has also been
not when they are used to chart a river
defined by listing or classifying the
bottom.
various techniques.1-3 This sense of
Nondestructive testing asks “Is there
nondestructive testing is practical in that it
something wrong with this material?” In
typically highlights methods in use by
contrast, performance and proof tests ask
industry.
“Does this component work?” It is not
In the Nondestructive Testing Handbook,
considered nondestructive testing when
the word method is used for a group of test
an inspector checks a circuit by running
techniques that share a form of probing
electric current through it. Hydrostatic
energy. Ultrasonic test methods, for
pressure testing is another form of proof
example, use acoustic waves faster than
testing, one that sometimes destroys the
sound. Infrared and thermal testing and
test object.
radiographic testing both use
Another gray area that invites various
electromagnetic radiation, each in a
interpretations in defining nondestructive
defined wavelength range. A technique, in
testing is future usefulness. Some material
contrast, has features that adapt the
investigations involve taking a sample of
method to the application.
the tested part for a test that is inherently
Through-transmission immersion testing
destructive. A noncritical part of a
is a technique of the ultrasonic method,
pressure vessel may be scraped or shaved
for example.
to get a sample for electron microscopy,
for example. Although future usefulness
of the vessel is not impaired by the loss of
material, the procedure is inherently Purposes of
destructive and the shaving itself — in
one sense the true test object — has been Nondestructive Testing
removed from service permanently. Since the 1920s, the art of testing without
destroying the test object has developed

2 Electromagnetic Testing
from a laboratory curiosity to an developments have contributed to its
indispensable tool of fabrication, growth and acceptance.
construction, manufacturing and
maintenance processes. No longer is Increased Demand on Machines
visual testing of materials, parts and
complete products the principal means of In the interest of greater performance and
determining adequate quality. reduced cost for materials, the design
Nondestructive tests in great variety are in engineer is often under pressure to reduce
worldwide use to detect variations in weight. This can sometimes be done by
structure, minute changes in surface substituting aluminum alloys, magnesium
finish, the presence of cracks or other alloys or composite materials for steel or
physical discontinuities, to measure the iron but such light parts may not be the
thickness of materials and coatings and to same size or design as those they replace.
determine other characteristics of The tendency is also to reduce the size.
industrial products. Scientists and These pressures on the designer have
engineers of many countries have subjected parts of all sorts to increased
contributed greatly to nondestructive test stress levels. Even such commonplace
development and applications. objects as sewing machines, sauce pans
The various nondestructive testing and luggage are also lighter and more
methods are covered in detail in the heavily loaded than ever before. The stress
literature but it is always wise to consider to be supported is seldom static. It often
objectives before details. How is fluctuates and reverses at low or high
nondestructive testing useful? Why do frequencies. Frequency of stress reversals
thousands of industrial concerns buy the increases with the speeds of modern
testing equipment, pay the subsequent machines and thus parts tend to fatigue
operating costs of the testing and even and fail more rapidly.
reshape manufacturing processes to fit the Another cause of increased stress on
needs and findings of nondestructive modern products is a reduction in the
testing? safety factor. An engineer designs with
Modern nondestructive tests are used certain known loads in mind. On the
by manufacturers (1) to ensure product supposition that materials and
integrity and in turn reliability, (2) to workmanship are never perfect, a safety
avoid failures, prevent accidents and save factor of 2, 3, 5 or 10 is applied. However,
human life (see Figs. 1 and 2), (3) to make a lower factor is often used that depends
a profit for the user, (4) to ensure on considerations such as cost or weight.
customer satisfaction and maintain the New demands on machinery have also
manufacturer’s reputation, (5) to aid in stimulated the development and use of
better product design, (6) to control new materials whose operating
manufacturing processes, (7) to lower characteristics and performance are not
manufacturing costs, (8) to maintain completely known. These new materials
uniform quality level and (9) to ensure
operational readiness.
These reasons for widespread and
profitable nondestructive testing are FIGURE 2. Boilers operate with high internal steam pressure.
sufficient in themselves but parallel Material discontinuities can lead to sudden, violent failure
with possible injury to people and property.

FIGURE 1. Fatigue cracks contributed to damage to aircraft


fuselage in flight (April 1988).

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 3


could create greater and potentially Rising Costs of Failure
dangerous problems. For example, an
Aside from awards to the injured or to
aircraft part was built from an alloy whose
estates of the deceased and aside from
work hardening, notch resistance and
costs to the public (because of evacuation
fatigue life were not well known. After
occasioned by chemical leaks) consider
relatively short periods of service, some of
briefly other factors in the rising costs of
the aircraft using these parts suffered
mechanical failure. These costs are
disastrous failures. Sufficient and proper
increasing for many reasons. Some
nondestructive tests could have saved
important ones are (1) greater costs of
many lives.
materials and labor, (2) greater costs of
As technology improves and as service
complex parts, (3) greater costs because of
requirements increase, machines are
the complexity of assemblies, (4) greater
subjected to greater variations and to
probability that failure of one part will
wider extremes of all kinds of stress,
cause failure of others because of
creating an increasing demand for
overloads, (5) trend to lower factors of
stronger or more damage tolerant
safety, (6) probability that the failure of
materials.
one part will damage other parts of high
value and (7) part failure in an integrated
Engineering Demands for Sounder automatic production machine, shutting
Materials down an entire high speed production
line. When production was carried out on
Another justification for nondestructive
many separate machines, the broken one
tests is the designer’s demand for sounder
could be bypassed until repaired. Today
materials. As size and weight decrease and
one machine is tied into the production
the factor of safety is lowered, more
of several others. Loss of such production
emphasis is placed on better raw material
is one of the greatest losses resulting from
control and higher quality of materials,
part failure.
manufacturing processes and
workmanship.
An interesting fact is that a producer of
raw material or of a finished product
sometimes does not improve quality or
Applications of
performance until that improvement is Nondestructive Testing
demanded by the customer. The pressure Nondestructive testing is a branch of the
of the customer is transferred to materials sciences that is concerned with
implementation of improved design or all aspects of the uniformity, quality and
manufacturing. Nondestructive testing is serviceability of materials and structures.
frequently called on to deliver this new The science of nondestructive testing
quality level. incorporates all the technology for
detection and measurement of significant
Public Demands for Greater Safety properties, including discontinuities, in
items ranging from research specimens to
The demands and expectations of the finished hardware and products in service.
public for greater safety are apparent By definition nondestructive test methods
everywhere. Review the record of the provide a means for examining materials
courts in granting high awards to injured and structures without disruption or
persons. Consider the outcry for greater impairment of serviceability.
automobile safety, as evidenced by the Nondestructive testing makes it possible
required automotive safety belts and the for internal properties or hidden
demand for air bags, blowout proof tires discontinuities to be revealed or inferred.
and antilock braking systems. The Nondestructive testing is becoming
publicly supported activities of the increasingly vital in the effective conduct
National Safety Council, Underwriters of research, development, design and
Laboratories, the Occupational Safety and manufacturing programs. Only with
Health Administration and the Federal appropriate nondestructive testing
Aviation Administration in the United methods can the benefits of advanced
States, as well as the work of similar materials science be fully realized. The
agencies abroad, are only a few of the information required for appreciating the
ways in which this demand for safety is broad scope of nondestructive testing is
expressed. It has been expressed directly available in many publications and
by passengers who cancel reservations reports.
following a serious aircraft accident. This
demand for personal safety has been
another strong force in the development
of nondestructive tests. Classification of Methods
The National Materials Advisory Board
(NMAB) Ad Hoc Committee on
Nondestructive Evaluation adopted a

4 Electromagnetic Testing
system that classified techniques into six others); (4) physical and mechanical
major method categories: visual, properties (reflectivity, conductivity,
penetrating radiation, magnetic-electrical, elastic modulus, sonic velocity and
mechanical vibration, thermal and others); (5) composition and chemical
chemical/electrochemical.3 A modified analysis (alloy identification, impurities,
version is presented in Table 1.1 elemental distributions and others);
Each method can be completely (6) stress and dynamic response (residual
characterized in terms of five principal stress, crack growth, wear, vibration and
factors: (1) energy source or medium used others); (7) signature analysis (image
to probe the object (such as X-rays, content, frequency spectrum, field
ultrasonic waves or thermal radiation); configuration and others); and
(2) nature of the signals, image or (8) abnormal sources of heat.
signature resulting from interaction with Material characteristics in Table 1 are
the object (attenuation of X-rays or further defined in Table 2 with respect to
reflection of ultrasound, for example); specific objectives and specific attributes
(3) means of detecting or sensing to be measured, detected and defined.
resultant signals (photoemulsion, The limitations of a method include
piezoelectric crystal or inductance coil); conditions to be met for method
(4) means of indicating or recording application (access, physical contact,
signals (meter deflection, oscilloscope preparation and others) and requirements
trace or radiograph); and (5) basis for to adapt the probe or probe medium to
interpreting the results (direct or indirect the object examined. Other factors limit
indication, qualitative or quantitative and the detection or characterization of
pertinent dependencies). discontinuities, properties and other
The objective of each method is to attributes and limit interpretation of
provide information about one or more of signals or images generated.
the following material parameters:
(1) discontinuities and separations (cracks, Classification Relative to Test
voids, inclusions, delaminations and
others); (2) structure or malstructure Object
(crystalline structure, grain size, Nondestructive testing techniques may be
segregation, misalignment and others); classified according to how they detect
(3) dimensions and metrology (thickness, indications relative to the surface of a test
diameter, gap size, discontinuity size and object. Surface methods include liquid

TABLE 1. Nondestructive testing method categories.


Categories Objectives

Basic Categories

Mechanical and optical color, cracks, dimensions, film thickness, gaging, reflectivity, strain distribution and magnitude, surface
finish, surface flaws, through-cracks
Penetrating radiation cracks; density and chemistry variations; elemental distribution; foreign objects; inclusions; microporosity;
misalignment; missing parts; segregation; service degradation; shrinkage; thickness; voids
Electromagnetic and electronic alloy content; anisotropy; cavities; cold work; local strain, hardness; composition; contamination;
corrosion; cracks; crack depth; crystal structure; electrical conductivities; flakes; heat treatment;
hot tears; inclusions; ion concentrations; laps; lattice strain; layer thickness; moisture content;
polarization; seams; segregation; shrinkage; state of cure; tensile strength; thickness; disbonds; voids
Sonic and ultrasonic crack initiation and propagation; cracks, voids; damping factor; degree of cure; degree of impregnation;
degree of sintering; delaminations; density; dimensions; elastic moduli; grain size; inclusions;
mechanical degradation; misalignment; porosity; radiation degradation; structure of composites;
surface stress; tensile, shear and compressive strength; disbonds; wear
Infrared and thermal anisotropy, bonding; composition; emissivity; heat contours; plating thickness; porosity; reflectivity;
stress; thermal conductivity; thickness; voids; cracks; delaminations; heat treatment; state of cure;
moisture; corrosion
Chemical and analytical alloy identification; composition; cracks; elemental analysis and distribution; grain size; inclusions;
macrostructure; porosity; segregation; surface anomalies
Auxiliary Categories
Image generation dimensional variations; dynamic performance; anomaly characterization and definition; anomaly
distribution; anomaly propagation; magnetic field configurations
Signal image analysis data selection, processing and display; anomaly mapping, correlation and identification; image
enhancement; separation of multiple variables; signature analysis

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 5


penetrant testing, visual testing, grid volumetric methods performed on the
testing and moiré testing. completed object or component will
Surface/near-surface methods include tap, reveal few rejectable discontinuities.
potential drop, holographic, Volumetric methods include radiography,
shearographic, magnetic particle and ultrasonic testing, acoustic emission
electromagnetic testing. When surface or testing and less widely used methods such
near-surface methods are applied during as acoustoultrasonic testing and magnetic
intermediate manufacturing processes, resonance imaging. Through-boundary
they provide preliminary assurance that techniques include leak testing, some

TABLE 2. Objectives of nondestructive testing methods.

Objectives Attributes Measured or Detected

Discontinuities and Separations


Surface anomalies roughness, scratches, gouges, crazing, pitting, imbedded foreign material
Surface connected anomalies cracks, porosity, pinholes, laps, seams, folds, inclusions
Internal anomalies cracks, separations, hot tears, cold shuts, shrinkage, voids, lack of fusion, pores, cavities, delaminations,
disbonds, poor bonds, inclusions, segregations
Structure
Microstructure molecular structure; crystalline structure and/or strain; lattice structure; strain; dislocation; vacancy;
deformation
Matrix structure grain structure, size, orientation and phase; sinter and porosity; impregnation; filler and/or reinforcement
distribution; anisotropy; heterogeneity; segregation
Small structural anomalies leaks (lack of seal or through-holes), poor fit, poor contact, loose parts, loose particles, foreign objects
Gross structural anomalies assembly errors; misalignment; poor spacing or ordering; deformation; malformation; missing parts
Dimensions and Metrology
Displacement; position linear measurement; separation; gap size; discontinuity size, depth, location and orientation
Dimensional variations unevenness; nonuniformity; eccentricity; shape and contour; size and mass variations
Thickness; density film, coating, layer, plating, wall and sheet thickness; density or thickness variations
Physical and Mechanical Properties
Electrical properties resistivity; conductivity; dielectric constant and dissipation factor
Magnetic properties polarization; permeability; ferromagnetism; cohesive force, susceptibility
Thermal properties conductivity; thermal time constant and thermoelectric potential; diffusivity; effusivity; specific heat
Mechanical properties compressive, shear and tensile strength (and moduli); Poisson’s ratio; sonic velocity; hardness; temper
and embrittlement
Surface properties color, reflectivity, refraction index, emissivity
Chemical Composition and Analysis
Elemental analysis detection, identification, distribution and/or profile
Impurity concentrations contamination, depletion, doping and diffusants
Metallurgical content variation; alloy identification, verification and sorting
Physiochemical state moisture content; degree of cure; ion concentrations and corrosion; reaction products
Stress and Dynamic Response
Stress, strain, fatigue heat treatment, annealing and cold work effects; stress and strain; fatigue damage and life (residual)
Mechanical damage wear, spalling, erosion, friction effects
Chemical damage corrosion, stress corrosion, phase transformation
Other damage radiation damage and high frequency voltage breakdown
Dynamic performance crack initiation, crack propagation, plastic deformation, creep, excessive motion, vibration, damping,
timing of events, any anomalous behavior
Signature Analysis
Electromagnetic field potential; intensity; field distribution and pattern
Thermal field isotherms, heat contours, temperatures, heat flow, temperature distribution, heat leaks, hot spots, contrast
Acoustic signature noise, vibration characteristics, frequency amplitude, harmonic spectrum, harmonic analysis, sonic
emissions, ultrasonic emissions
Radioactive signature distribution and diffusion of isotopes and tracers
Signal or image analysis image enhancement and quantization; pattern recognition; densitometry; signal classification, separation;
and correlation; discontinuity identification, definition (size and shape) and distribution analysis;
discontinuity mapping and display

6 Electromagnetic Testing
infrared thermographic techniques,
airborne ultrasonic testing and certain
techniques of acoustic emission testing.
Overview of Other
Other less easily classified methods are Nondestructive Testing
material identification, vibration analysis Methods
and strain gaging.
To optimize the use of nondestructive
No one nondestructive testing method
testing it is necessary first to understand
is all revealing. In some cases, one
the principles and applications of all the
method or technique may be adequate for
methods. This volume features
testing a specific object or component.
electromagnetic testing (Fig. 3) — only
However, in most cases, it takes a series of
one of the nondestructive test methods.
test methods to do a complete
The following section briefly describes
nondestructive test of an object or
several other methods and the
component. For example, if surface cracks
applications associated with them.
must be detected and eliminated and if
the object or component is made of
ferromagnetic material, then magnetic
particle testing would be the appropriate FIGURE 3. Electromagnetic testing: (a) representative setup
choice. If the material is aluminum or for eddy current test; (b) in-service detection of
titanium, then the choice would be liquid discontinuities.
penetrant or electromagnetic testing.
However, if internal discontinuities are to (a)
be detected, then ultrasonic testing or Primary electromagnetic field
radiography would be the selection. The Coil in eddy current probe
exact technique in each case would
depend on the thickness and nature of
the material and the types of
discontinuities that must be detected. Direction of
primary current

Value of Nondestructive
Induced field
Testing
The contribution of nondestructive
testing to profits has been acknowledged
in the medical field and computer and
aerospace industries. However, in
Direction of eddy
industries such as heavy metals, although currents
nondestructive testing may be reluctantly Conducting specimen
accepted, its contribution to profits may Eddy current strength
decreases with
not be obvious to management. increasing depth
Nondestructive testing is sometimes
thought of only as a cost item and can be (b)
curtailed by industry downsizing. When a
company cuts costs, two vulnerable areas
are quality and safety. When bidding
contract work, companies add profit
margin to all cost items, including
nondestructive testing, so a profit should
be made on the nondestructive testing.
The attitude toward nondestructive
testing is positive when management
understands its value.
Nondestructive testing should be used
as a control mechanism to ensure that
manufacturing processes are within design
performance requirements. When used
properly, nondestructive testing saves
money for the manufacturer. Rather than
costing the manufacturer money,
nondestructive testing should add profits
to the manufacturing process.

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 7


Visual Testing of minute surface openings by capillary
action. The cavities of interest can be very
Principles. Visual testing (Fig. 4) is the
small, often invisible to the unaided eye.
observation of a test object, either directly
The ability of a given liquid to flow over a
with the eyes or indirectly using optical
surface and enter surface cavities depends
instruments, by an inspector to evaluate
principally on the following: cleanliness
the presence of surface anomalies and the
of the surface, surface tension of the
object’s conformance to specification.
liquid, configuration of the cavity, contact
Visual testing should be the first
angle of the liquid, ability of the liquid to
nondestructive testing method applied to
wet the surface, cleanliness of the cavity
an item. The test procedure is to clean the
and size of surface opening of the cavity.
surface, provide adequate illumination
and observe. A prerequisite necessary for Applications. The principal industrial uses
competent visual testing of an object is of liquid penetrant testing include
knowledge of the manufacturing processes postfabrication testing, receiving testing,
by which it was made, of its service in-process testing and quality control,
history and of its potential failure modes, maintenance and overhaul in the
as well as related industry experience. transportation industries, in-plant and
machinery maintenance and in testing of
Applications. Visual testing provides a
large components. The following are some
means of detecting and examining a
of the typically detected discontinuities:
variety of surface discontinuities. It is the
surface discontinuities, seams, cracks, laps,
most widely used method for detecting
porosity and leak paths.
and examining for surface discontinuities
associated with various structural failure
mechanisms. Even when other Magnetic Particle Testing
nondestructive tests are performed, visual Principles. Magnetic particle testing
tests often provide a useful supplement. (Fig. 6) is a method of locating surface
When the eddy current testing of process and slightly subsurface discontinuities in
tubing is performed, for example, visual ferromagnetic materials. It depends on the
testing is often performed to verify and fact that when the material or part under
more closely examine the surface
condition. The following discontinuities
may be detected by a simple visual test:
surface discontinuities, cracks, FIGURE 5. Liquid penetrant indication of
misalignment, warping, corrosion, wear cracking.
and physical damage.

Liquid Penetrant Testing


Principles. Liquid penetrant testing (Fig. 5)
reveals discontinuities open to the
surfaces of solid and nonporous materials.
Indications of a wide variety of
discontinuity sizes can be found regardless
of the configuration of the work piece and
regardless of discontinuity orientations.
Liquid penetrants seep into various types

FIGURE 4. Visual test using borescope to


view interior of cylinder. FIGURE 6. In magnetic particle testing, particles gather where
lines of magnetic force leak from discontinuity.

Magnetic particles

S N
N S

Crack
Legend
N = north pole
S = south pole

8 Electromagnetic Testing
test is magnetized, discontinuities that lie caused by variation in composition. These
in a direction generally transverse to the variations in the absorption of the
direction of the magnetic field will cause a penetrating radiation can be monitored
leakage field to be formed at and above by detecting the unabsorbed radiation
the surface of the part. The presence of that passes through the object. This
this leakage field and therefore the monitoring may be in different forms.
presence of the discontinuity is detected The traditional form is through radiation
with fine ferromagnetic particles applied sensitive film. Radioscopic sensors provide
over the surface, with some of the digital images. X-ray computed
particles being gathered and held to form tomography is a radiographic technique.
an outline of the discontinuity. This Applications. The principal industrial uses
generally indicates its location, size, shape of radiographic testing involve testing of
and extent. Magnetic particles are applied castings and weldments, particularly
over a surface as dry particles or as wet where there is a critical need to ensure
particles in a liquid carrier such as water freedom from internal discontinuities. For
or oil. example radiography is often specified for
Applications. The principal industrial uses thick wall castings and weldments for
of magnetic particle testing include final, steam power equipment (boiler and
receiving and in-process testing; for turbine components and assemblies).
quality control; for maintenance and Radiography can also be used on forgings
overhaul in the transportation industries; and mechanical assemblies, although with
for plant and machinery maintenance; mechanical assemblies radiography is
and for testing of large components. Some usually limited to testing for conditions
of the typically detected discontinuities and proper placement of components.
are surface discontinuities, seams, cracks Typically detected discontinuities and
and laps. conditions include inclusions, lack of
fusion, cracks, corrosion, porosity, leak
Radiographic Testing paths, missing or incomplete components
and debris.
Principles. Radiographic testing (Fig. 7) is
based on the differential absorption of
penetrating radiation — either Ultrasonic Testing
electromagnetic radiation of very short Principles. Ultrasonic testing (Fig. 8) is a
wavelength or particulate radiation nondestructive method in which beams of
(X-rays, gamma rays and neutron rays) — sound waves at a frequency too high to
by the part or object being tested. hear are introduced into materials for the
Different portions of an object absorb detection of surface and subsurface
different amounts of penetrating radiation discontinuities in the material. These
because of differences in density and acoustic waves travel through the material
variations in thickness of the part or with some attendant loss of energy
differences in absorption characteristics (attenuation) and are reflected at
interfaces. The echoes are then analyzed
to define the presence and locations of
FIGURE 7. Representative setup for radiographic testing. discontinuities.
Applications. Ultrasonic testing of metals
is widely used, principally for the
Radiation source
detection of discontinuities. This method
can be used to detect internal
discontinuities in most engineering
metals and alloys. Bonds produced by
welding, brazing, soldering and adhesives
can also be ultrasonically examined.
Inline techniques have been developed for
monitoring and classifying materials as
acceptable, salvageable or scrap and for
process control. Other applications
Specimen include testing of piping and pressure
Void vessels, nuclear systems, motor vehicles,
machinery, structures, railroad rolling
stock and bridges and thickness
measurement.

Leak Testing
Principles. Leak testing is concerned with
the flow of liquids or gases from
Image plane Discontinuity images pressurized or into evacuated
components. The principles of leak testing

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 9


involve the physics of fluid (liquids or subsidiary methods of leak testing,
gases) flowing through a barrier where a entailing tracer gas detection (Fig. 9),
pressure differential or capillary action pressure change measurement,
exists. Leaking fluids (liquid or gas) can observation of bubble formation and
propagate from inside a component or other means.
assembly to the outside, or vice versa, as a Applications. Like other forms of
result of a pressure differential between nondestructive testing leak testing has an
the two regions or as a result of impact on the safety and performance of
permeation through a barrier. a product. Reliable leak testing decreases
Leak testing encompasses procedures costs by reducing the number of reworked
that fall into these basic functions: leak products, warranty repairs and liability
location, leakage measurement and claims. The most common reasons for
leakage monitoring. There are several performing a leak test are to prevent the
loss of costly materials or energy; to
prevent contamination of the
FIGURE 8. Classic setups for ultrasonic testing: environment; to ensure component or
(a) longitudinal wave technique; (b) shear wave technique. system reliability; and to prevent the
potential for an explosion or fire.
(a)
Acoustic Emission Testing
Principles. Acoustic emissions are
mechanical waves produced by sudden
movement in stressed materials. The
classic sources of acoustic emission are
discontinuity related deformation
Crack
processes such as crack growth and plastic
deformation. Sudden movement at the
source produces a stress wave that radiates
out into the structure and excites a
Time sensitive piezoelectric sensor. As the stress
in the material is raised, emissions are
Bolt generated. The signals from one or more
sensors are amplified and measured to
Back surface produce data for display and
interpretation.

FIGURE 9. Leakage measurement dynamic leak testing using


Transducer vacuum pumping: (a) pressurized system mode for leak
Crack testing of smaller components; (b) pressurized envelope
mode for leak testing of larger volume systems.

(b) (a)
Envelope

Leak detector
System
under
Crack
test

Source of tracer gas

(b)
Entry surface Envelope

Crack System
under
test
Leak detector

a b
Skip distance
where a = b
Source of tracer gas

10 Electromagnetic Testing
The source of acoustic emission energy such processes as solidification, friction,
is the elastic stress field in the material. impact, flow and phase transformations.
Without stress there is no emission. Therefore acoustic emission testing is also
Therefore, an acoustic emission test used for in-process weld monitoring;
(Fig. 10) is usually carried out during a detecting tool contact and tool wear
controlled loading of the structure. This during automatic machining; detecting
can be a proof load before service; a wear and loss of lubrication in rotating
controlled variation of load while the equipment; detecting loose parts and
structure is in service; a fatigue, pressure loose particles; detecting and monitoring
or creep test; or a complex loading leaks, cavitation and flow; preservice
program. Often a structure is going to be proof testing; inservice weld monitoring;
loaded hydrostatically anyway during and leak testing.
service and acoustic emission testing is
used because it gives valuable additional Infrared and Thermal Testing
information about the expected
performance of the structure under load. Principles. Conduction and convection
Other times, acoustic emission testing is are the primary mechanisms of heat
selected for reasons of economy or safety transfer in an object or system. However,
and a special loading procedure is electromagnetic radiation is emitted from
arranged to meet the needs of the acoustic a heated body when electrons in that
emission test. body change to a lower energy state.
Thermal testing involves the
Applications. Acoustic emission is a
measurement or mapping of surface
natural phenomenon occurring in a wide
temperatures when heat flows from, to or
range of materials, structures and
through a test object. Temperature
processes. The largest scale events
differentials on a surface, or changes in
observed with acoustic emission testing
surface temperature with time, are related
are seismic and the smallest are small
to heat flow patterns and can be used to
dislocations in stressed metals.
detect discontinuities or to determine the
The equipment used is highly sensitive
heat transfer characteristics of an object.
to any kind of movement in its operating
For example, during the operation of an
frequency (typically 20 to 1200 kHz). The
electrical breaker, a hot spot detected at
equipment can detect not only crack
an electrical termination may be caused
growth and material deformation but also
by a loose or corroded connection
(Fig. 11). The resistance to electrical flow

FIGURE 10. Acoustic emission testing setup in which eight


sensors permit computer to calculate location of crack FIGURE 11. Infrared thermography of
propagation. automatic transfer switches of emergency
diesel generator. Hot spots appear bright in
thermogram (inset).
Acoustic
event
Preamplifier
Sensor

Computer

Test
object
Preamplifier

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 11


through the connection produces an
increase in surface temperature of the
connection.
Applications. There are two basic
categories of infrared and thermal test
applications: electrical and mechanical.
The specific applications within these two
categories are numerous. Electrical
applications include transmission and
distribution lines, transformers,
disconnects, switches, fuses, relays,
breakers, motor windings, capacitor
banks, cable trays, bus taps and other
components and subsystems. Mechanical
applications include insulation (in boilers,
furnaces, kilns, piping, ducts, vessels,
refrigerated trucks and systems, tank cars
and elsewhere), friction in rotating
equipment (bearings, couplings, gears,
gearboxes, conveyor belts, pumps,
compressors and other components) and
fluid flow (steam lines; heat exchangers;
tank fluid levels; exothermic reactions;
heating, ventilation and air conditioning
systems; leaks above and below ground;
cooling and heating; tube blockages;
environmental assessment of thermal
discharge; boiler or furnace air leakage;
condenser or turbine system leakage;
pumps; compressors; and other system
applications).

Other Methods
There are many other methods of
nondestructive testing, including optical
methods such as holography,
shearography and moiré imaging; material
identification methods such as chemical
spot testing, spark testing and
spectroscopy; strain gaging; and acoustic
methods such as vibration analysis and
tapping.

12 Electromagnetic Testing
PART 2. Management of Electromagnetic Testing

9. precise dimensional measurement of


Selection of symmetric, machined or ground and
polished metallic parts, such as
Electromagnetic Testing4 bearings and bearing races, small
Electromagnetic tests are an important mechanism components and others.
and widely used method within the broad
field of nondestructive materials testing.
The electromagnetic test method includes Advantages of Electromagnetic
several subsidiary methods, sometimes Testing
called submethods or techniques: eddy Modern eddy current and electromagnetic
current testing, remote field testing, flux test techniques offer low cost means for
leakage testing, alternating current field high speed, large scale testing of metallic
measurement testing and microwave materials such as those used in nuclear,
testing. Of these several submethods, aerospace, marine, high pressure, high
conventional eddy current testing is the temperature and high speed engineering
most widely used. Magnetic particle systems where premature failures could
testing is an electromagnetic test that represent economic disasters or the
industry administers as a separate endangering of human life. The method’s
method. special suitability for testing of
Applications of eddy current tests in automobiles, engines, machine parts and
industry are numerous and widespread. consumer products has long been
The total number of test measurements recognized.
made annually by this nondestructive test Like other nondestructive methods,
method may exceed that of all other eddy current tests permit measurements
methods combined. Eddy current testing of material properties and dimensions and
is used for the following: detection of discontinuities. In general,
1. noncontacting measurement of the electromagnetic tests provide nearly
thickness of metallic foils, sheets, instantaneous measurements. The test
plates, tube walls and machined parts speed and modern signal analysis permit
from one side only; such analysis to be performed in real
2. measurement of the thickness of time. Consequently, the method can be
coatings over base materials where the used in production lines to test swiftly
coating and base material have moving bars, tubes, sheets, plates, welds
significantly different electrical or and other symmetric parts. These parts
magnetic properties; either pass through test coils or are
3. identifying or separating materials by scanned by moving test probes. The
composition or structure; automation of eddy current testing and
4. detecting material discontinuities that test data evaluation permits mass testing
lie in planes transverse to the eddy of similar parts at high rates, with
currents, such as cracks, seams, laps, economies not attainable by other
score marks or plug cuts, drilled and commonly used nondestructive tests. The
other holes and laminations at cut results can be optimized for automation
edges of sheet or plate; of test systems, for sorting of test parts,
5. identifying and controlling heat for control of manufacturing processes
treatment conditions and evaluation and for automatic documentation for
of fire damage to metallic structures; process control and statistical quality
6. determining depths of case hardening control.
of steels and some ferrous alloys; Small, portable forms of eddy current
7. locating hidden metallic objects such test instrumentation provide simple and
as underground pipes, buried bombs rapid means for (1) manual quality tests
or ore bodies, or metallic objects by individual operators and
accidentally packaged in foodstuffs; (2) mechanized test systems to sort mixed
8. timing or locating the motions of lots of materials, to follow deterioration of
hidden parts of mechanisms, counting materials and equipment in service and to
metallic objects on conveyor lines or verify process quality.
detecting metallic missiles in flight;
and

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 13


Limitations of Eddy Current Tests primary paths are (1) service companies,
(2) consultants and (3) in-house programs.
Limitations of eddy current tests are a
Although these are the primary paths,
direct consequence of the specific nature
some programs may, routinely or as
of the test and of the response of
needed, require support personnel from a
electrically conductive test materials to
combination of two or more of these
the externally applied, time varying
sources. Before a final decision is made,
magnetic fields used to excite eddy
advantages and disadvantages of each
current flow. In general, eddy current tests
path must be considered. Therefore the
are applicable only to test materials with
following details must be considered.
significant electrical conductivity, such as
metals and alloys and composites with
conducting layers or reinforcing fibers. Service Companies
They can be used, however, to measure
thicknesses of nonconducting layers on 1. Who will identify the components
the surface of conducting metallic within the facility to be examined?
materials by the liftoff effect in which the 2. Will the contract be for time and
coating separates the test probe from the materials or have a specific scope of
conducting material by the thickness of work?
the nonconductive coating or sheet 3. If a time and materials contract is
material. awarded, who will monitor the time
Eddy current tests provide maximum and materials charged?
test sensitivity for the surface and near 4. If a scope of work is required, who is
surface layers of the test material adjacent technically qualified to develop and
to the source of excitation. In some cases approve it?
it may be difficult or impossible to 5. What products or documents (test
penetrate to the center of thick specimens reports, trending, recommendations,
because of skin effect and attenuation of root cause analysis and others) will be
the electromagnetic field at certain depths provided once the tests are completed?
below the surface. Eddy current tests tend 6. Who will evaluate and accept the
to be insensitive to laminar product (test reports, trending,
discontinuities, which lie parallel to the recommendations, root cause analysis
induced eddy currents. They do tend to and others) within the service
respond, however, to discontinuities that company?
lie transverse to the flow of eddy currents 7. Do the service company workers
within test materials, where these possess qualifications and
discontinuities interrupt, lengthen or certifications required by contract and
distort the current flow paths. by applicable regulations?
8. Do the service company workers
require site specific training (confined
space entry, electrical safety, hazardous
Management of materials and others) or clearance to
enter and work in the facility?
Electromagnetic Testing 9. Does the service company retain any
Programs liability for test results?
Management of an electromagnetic
testing program will require consideration
of many items before a program can
Consultants
produce the desired results. Six basic 1. Will the contract be for time and
questions must be answered before a true materials or have a specific scope of
direction can be charted. They are as work?
follows. 2. If a scope of work is required, who is
1. Are regulatory requirements in place technically qualified to develop and
that mandate program characteristics? approve it?
2. What is the magnitude of the program 3. Who will identify the required
that will provide desired results? qualifications of the consultant?
3. What provisions must be made for 4. Is the purpose of the consultant to
personnel safety and for compliance develop or update a program or is it to
with environmental regulations? oversee and evaluate the performance
4. What is the performance date for a of an existing program?
program to be fully implemented? 5 Will the consultant have oversight
5. Is there a cost benefit of responsibility for tests performed?
electromagnetic testing? 6. What products (trending,
6. What are the available resources in recommendations, root cause analysis
personnel and money? and others) are provided once the tests
are completed?
Once these questions are answered, then a
recommendation can be made to
determine the best path forward. Three

14 Electromagnetic Testing
7. Who will evaluate the consultant’s a supervisor’s initial or signature after
performance (test reports, trending, each step. The following is a typical
recommendations, root cause analysis format for an industrial procedure.
and other functions) within the 1. The purpose identifies the intent of the
sponsoring company? procedure.
8. Does the consultant possess 2. The scope establishes the latitude of
qualifications and certifications items, tests and techniques covered
required by contract and by applicable and not covered by the procedure.
regulations? 3. References are specific documents from
9. Does the consultant require site which criteria are extracted or
specific training (confined space entry, documents satisfied by
electrical safety, hazardous materials implementation of the procedure.
and others) or clearance to enter and 4. Definitions are needed for terms and
work in the facility? abbreviations that are not common
10. Does the consultant retain any knowledge to people who will read the
liability for test results? procedure.
5. Statements about personnel requirements
In-House Programs address specific requirements to
perform tasks in accordance with the
1. Who will determine the scope of the procedure — issues such as personnel
program, such as which techniques qualification, certification, access
will be used (eddy current, flux clearance and others.
leakage and others)? 6. Equipment characteristics, calibration
2. What are the regulatory requirements requirements and model numbers of
(codes and standards) associated with qualified equipment must be specified.
program development and 7. The test procedure provides a sequential
implementation? process to be used to conduct test
3. Who will develop a cost benefit activities.
analysis for the program? 8. Acceptance criteria establish component
4. How much time and resources are characteristics that will identify the
available to establish the program? items suitable for service.
5. What are the qualification 9. Reports (records) provide the means to
requirements (education, training, document specific test techniques,
experience and others) for personnel? equipment used, personnel performing
6. Do program personnel require activity, date performed and test
additional training (safety, confined results.
space entry or others) or 10. Attachments may include (if required)
qualifications? items such as report forms, instrument
7. Are subject matter experts required to calibration forms, qualified equipment
provide technical guidance during matrix, schedules and others.
personnel development? Once the procedure is completed,
8. Are procedures required to perform typically an expert in the subject matter
work in the facility? evaluates it. If the procedure is judged to
9. If procedures are required, who will meet identified requirements, the expert
develop, review and approve them? will approve it for use. Some codes and
10. Who will determine the technical standards also require the procedure to be
specifications for test equipment? qualified — that is, demonstrated to the
satisfaction of a representative of a
regulatory body or jurisdictional
authority.
Test Procedures for
Electromagnetic Testing
The conduct of facility operations Test Specifications for
(in-house or contracted) should be
performed in accordance with specific
Electromagnetic Testing4
instructions from an expert. This is An electromagnetic specification must
typically accomplished using written anticipate a number of issues that arise
instructions in the form of a technical during testing.
procedure. In many cases, codes and
specifications will require a technical Means of Induction and Detection
procedure to perform required tests. of Magnetic Fields
The procedure process can take many
forms, including general instructions that Electromagnetic nondestructive test
address only major aspects of test methods use either static or time varying
techniques. Or a procedure may be electromagnetic fields as a probing
written as a step-by-step process requiring medium (1) to explore the properties of
test materials, (2) to locate discontinuities

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 15


or (3) to detect variations in geometry and To achieve this goal, the probability of
dimensions of test materials. The finding a rejectable discontinuity must be
magnitudes, time lags, phase angles and high and the inspector must be both
flow patterns of the resulting fields are proficient in the testing process and
sensed by using probes such as sensing motivated to perform with maximum
coils or solid state magnetic field detectors efficiency. A reckless inspector may accept
(such as hall effect devices). parts that contain discontinuities, with
the result of possible inservice part failure.
Eddy Current Test Frequencies A conservative inspector may reject parts
that contain rejectable discontinuities but
A single electromagnetic test system can the inspector also may reject parts that do
be used for many different measurements not contain rejectable discontinuities,
through the selection of test frequencies. with the result of unnecessary scrap and
These frequencies are those of the repair. Neither scenario is desirable.
excitation current applied to the coils of
the electromagnetic test probes.
Frequency is measured in hertz (Hz),
where 1 Hz = 1 cycle per second. Most Electromagnetic Testing
industrial electromagnetic tests are made
in the frequency range between 5 Hz and Standards
10 MHz. Traditionally, the purpose of specifications
Most types of electromagnetic test and standards has been to define the
equipment provide either variable requirements that goods or services must
frequency oscillators or several fixed meet. As such, they are intended to be
frequency steps. Thus, appropriate test incorporated into contracts so that both
frequencies can be readily selected by the the buyer and provider have a well
user to meet special test requirements. defined description of what one will
Low excitation frequencies are used to receive and the other will provide.
penetrate deeper within a conducting test Standards have undergone a process of
material. High test frequencies can be peer review in industry and can be
used for selective examination of near invoked with the force of law by contract
surface regions, testing of thin materials or by government regulation. In contrast,
and for testing of materials that have low a specification represents an employer’s
electrical conductivities. instructions to employees and is specific
to a contract or work place. Specifications
Interpretation may form the basis of standards through a
review process. Standards and
Interpretation may be complex, especially specifications exist in three basic areas:
before a procedure has been established. equipment, processes and personnel.
The interpreter must have a knowledge of
the following: (1) the underlying physical 1. Standards for equipment include
process, (2) techniques and equipment criteria that address probes, artificial
used to obtain the data and displays, discontinuities and test results.
(3) details about the item being examined Reference standards are work pieces
(configuration, material characteristics, that contain artificial discontinuities
fabrication process, potential for instrument calibration and test
discontinuities and intended service procedure verification.
conditions) and (4) acceptance criteria. 2. ASTM International and other
organizations publish standards for
test techniques. Some other standards
are for quality assurance procedures
Ensuring Reliability of Test and are not specific to a test method
or even to testing in general. Tables 3
Results and 4 list some standards used in
When a test is performed, there are four electromagnetic testing. The United
possible outcomes: (1) a rejectable States Department of Defense has
discontinuity can be found when one is replaced most military specifications
present; (2) a rejectable discontinuity can and standards with industry consensus
be missed even when one is present; (3) a specifications and standards. A source
rejectable discontinuity can be indicated for nondestructive testing standards is
when none is present and (4) no the Annual Book of ASTM Standards.5
rejectable discontinuity is found when 3. Qualification and certification of test
none is present. A reliable testing process personnel are discussed below with
and a qualified inspector should find all specific reference to recommendations
discontinuities of concern with no of ASNT Recommended Practice
discontinuities missed (no errors as in No. SNT-TC-1A.6
case 2 above) and no false calls (case 3
above).

16 Electromagnetic Testing
largely dependent on the skills and
Personnel Qualification knowledge of the inspector.
The American Society for
and Certification Nondestructive Testing (ASNT) has been a
One of the most critical aspects of the test world leader in the qualification and
process is the qualification of test certification of nondestructive testing
personnel. Nondestructive testing is personnel for many years. By 1999, the
sometimes referred to as a special process. American Society for Nondestructive
The term simply means that it is very Testing had instituted three major
difficult to determine the adequacy of a programs for the qualification and
test by merely observing the process or certification of nondestructive testing
the documentation generated at its personnel.
conclusion. The quality of the test is

TABLE 3. Electromagnetic testing standards published by ASTM International.

Miscellaneous
E 543, Standard Practice for Agencies Performing Nondestructive Testing
E 1004, Standard Practice for Determining Electrical Conductivity Using the Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Method
E 1312, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Ferromagnetic Cylindrical Bar Product above the Curie Temperature
E 1316, Standard Terminology for Nondestructive Examinations: Section C, Electromagnetic Testing
E 1571, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic Examination of Ferromagnetic Steel Wire Rope
E 1606, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Copper Redraw Rod for Electrical Purposes
E 1629, Standard Practice for Determining the Impedance of Absolute Eddy Current Probes
F 673, Standard Test Methods for Measuring Resistivity of Semiconductor Slices or Sheet Resistance of Semiconductor Films with a Noncontact
Eddy-Current Gage
Coating Thickness
B 244, Standard Test Method for Measurement of Thickness of Anodic Coatings on Aluminum and of Other Nonconductive Coatings on Nonmagnetic
Basis Metals with Eddy-Current Instruments
B 499, Standard Test Method for Measurement of Coating Thicknesses by the Magnetic Method: Nonmagnetic Coatings on Magnetic Basis Metals
B 659, Standard Guide for Measuring Thickness of Metallic and Inorganic Coatings
E 376, Standard Practice for Measuring Coating Thickness by Magnetic-Field or Eddy-Current (Electromagnetic) Test Methods
Geophysical Measurements
D 4748, Standard Test Method for Determining the Thickness of Bound Pavement Layers Using Short-Pulse Radar
D 6429, Standard Guide for Selecting Surface Geophysical Methods
D 6432, Standard Guide for Using the Surface Ground Penetrating Radar Method for Subsurface Investigation
D 6565, Standard Test Method for Determination of Water (Moisture) Content of Soil by the Time-Domain Reflectometry (TDR) Method
D 6639, Standard Guide for Using the Frequency Domain Electromagnetic Method for Subsurface Investigations
D 6726, Standard Guide for Conducting Borehole Geophysical Logging — Electromagnetic Induction
Material Identification
E 566, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Sorting of Ferrous Metals
E 703, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Sorting of Non-Ferrous Metals
E 1476, Standard Guide for Metals Identification, Grade Verification, and Sorting
Tubular Products
A 135, Standard Specification for Electric-Resistance-Welded Steel Pipe
E 215, Standard Practice for Standardizing Equipment for Electromagnetic Examination of Seamless Aluminum-Alloy Tube
E 243, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Copper-Alloy Tubes
E 309, Standard Practice for Eddy-Current Examination of Steel Tubular Products Using Magnetic Saturation
E 426, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Seamless and Welded Tubular Products, Austenitic Stainless Steel and
Similar Alloys
E 570, Standard Practice for Flux Leakage Examination of Ferromagnetic Steel Tubular Products
E 571, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Nickel and Nickel-Alloy Tubular Products
E 690, Standard Practice for In Situ Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Nonmagnetic Heat Exchanger Tubes
E 1033, Standard Practice for Electromagnetic (Eddy-Current) Examination of Type F — Continuously Welded (CW) Ferromagnetic Pipe and Tubing
above the Curie temperature
E 2096, Standard Practice for In Situ Examination of Ferromagnetic Heat-Exchanger Tubes Using Remote Field Testing

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 17


1. Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A 2. ANSI/ASNT CP-189, Standard for
provides guidelines for personnel Qualification and Certification of
qualification and certification in Nondestructive Testing Personnel
nondestructive testing. This resembles SNT-TC-1A but also
recommended practice identifies the establishes specific attributes for the
specific attributes that should be qualification and certification of
considered when qualifying nondestructive testing personnel.
nondestructive testing personnel. It However, CP-189 is a consensus
requires the employer to develop and standard as defined by the American
implement a written practice National Standards Institute (ANSI). It
(procedure) that details the specific is recognized as the American standard
process and any limitation in the for nondestructive testing. It is not
qualification and certification of considered a recommended practice; it is
nondestructive testing personnel.6 a national standard.7

TABLE 4. Some standards for electromagnetic testing.


Issuing Organization Representative Standards and Related Documents

American National Standards Institute ANSI B3.1, Rolling Element Bearings — Aircraft Engine, Engine Gearbox, and Accessory
Applications — Eddy Current Inspection
American Petroleum Institute API 510, Pressure Vessel Inspection Code: Maintenance Inspection, Rating, Repair and Alteration
API 570, Piping Inspection Code: Inspection, Repair, Alteration, and Rerating of In-Service Piping
Systems
API 650, Welded Steel Tanks for Oil Storage
API 1104, Welding, Pipelines and Related Facilities
American Society for Nondestructive Testing ASNT Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A
ANSI/ASNT CP-189, ASNT Standard for Qualification and Certification of Nondestructive Testing
Personnel
American Society of Mechanical Engineers ANSI/ASME B31.1, Power Piping
ANSI/ASME B31.3, Process Piping
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code: Section V — Power Boilers: Article 8, Eddy Current
Examination of Tubular Products
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code: Section XI — Inservice Inspection of Nuclear Vessels.
N-553-1, Eddy Current Surface Examination Section XI, Division 1
ASME PTC 19-1, Performance Test Codes, Supplement on Instruction and Apparatus
American Welding Society AWS D1.1, Structural Welding Code — Steel
ASTM International See Table 3
Canadian General Standards Board CAN/CGSB-48.9712, Non-Destructive Testing — Qualification and Certification of Personnel
48.14-M86-CAN/CGSB, Advanced Manual for: Eddy Current Test Method Amendment No. 1
May 1997 R(1997)
Chinese National Standards Z8005100, General Rules for Eddy Current Testing
Deutsche Institut für Normung DIN 54141-3, Non-Destructive Testing; Eddy Current Testing of Pipes and Tubes; Procedure
European Association of Aerospace Industries AECMA PREN 2002-20, Aerospace Series Test Methods for Metallic Materials: Part 20: Eddy
Current Testing of Circular Cross-Section Tubes, Edition P 1
European Committee for Standardization EN 12084, Non-Destructive Testing — Eddy Current Testing — General Principles and Guidelines
International Organization for Standardization ISO 9712, Nondestructive Testing – Qualification and Certification of Personnel
Japanese Standards Association JIS Z 2314, Test Methods for Performance Characteristics of Eddy Current Testing Instruments
Society of Automotive Engineers SAE ARP 891A, Determination of Aluminum Alloy Tempers through Electrical Conductivity
Measurement (Eddy Current) (R 1988)
SAE ARP 1926, Cure Monitor, Electrical Methods
SAE ARP 4402, Eddy Current Inspection of Open Fastener Holes in Aluminum Aircraft Structure
SAE ARP 4462, Barkhausen Noise Inspection for Detecting Grinding Burns
SAE AS 4787, Eddy Current Inspection of Circular Holes in Nonferrous Metallic Aircraft Engine
Hardware
SAE DFT K-89AW, Eddy Current Inspection of Circular Holes in Nonferrous Metallic
SAE J 425, Electromagnetic Testing by Eddy Current Methods, Information Report; March 1991
United States Department of Defense MIL-P-85585, Probes, Eddy Current, Unshielded, Single Coil, Absolute
MIL-STD-1537B, Electrical Conductivity Test for Verification of Heat Treatment of Aluminum
Alloys, Eddy Current Method
MIL-STD-2032, Eddy Current Inspection of Heat Exchanger Tubing on Ships of the United States
Navy
MIL-STD-2195, Inspection Procedure for Detection and Measurement of Dealloying Corrosion on
Aluminum Bronze and Nickel-Aluminum Bronze Components

18 Electromagnetic Testing
3. The ASNT Central Certification Program Training Programs. Personnel being
(ACCP), unlike SNT-TC-1A and CP-189, considered for initial certification should
is a third party certification process complete sufficient organized training to
that identifies qualification and become thoroughly familiar with the
principles and practices of the specified
certification attributes for Level II and nondestructive test method related to the
Level III nondestructive testing level of certification desired and applicable
personnel. The American Society for to the processes to be used and the products
Nondestructive Testing certifies that to be tested.
the individual has the skills and Examinations. For Level I and II personnel, a
knowledge for many nondestructive composite grade should be determined by
test method applications. It does not simple averaging of the results of the
remove the responsibility for the final general, specific and practical examinations
determination of personnel described below. Examinations administered
qualifications from the employer. The for qualification should result in a passing
employer evaluates an individual’s composite grade of at least 80 percent, with
skills and knowledge for application of no individual examination having a passing
grade less than 70 percent. The examination
company procedures using designated for near vision acuity should ensure natural
techniques and equipment identified or corrected near distance acuity in at least
for specific tests.8 one eye such that the applicant can read a
minimum of jaeger size 2 or equivalent type
and size letter at a distance of not less than
Selections from Recommended 305 mm (12 in.) on a standard jaeger test
Practice No. SNT-TC-1A chart. This test should be administered
annually.
To give a general idea of the contents of
Practical Examination for NDT Level I and II.
these documents, the following items are The candidate should demonstrate ability to
specified in the 2001 edition of operate the necessary nondestructive test
Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A. (The equipment and to record and analyze the
following text has been excerpted and resultant information to the degree
adapted. The original text is arranged in required. At least one selected specimen
outline format and includes should be tested and the results of the
recommendations that are not specific to nondestructive test analyzed by the
electromagnetic testing.) candidate.
Scope. This recommended practice has been Certification. Certification of all levels of
prepared to establish guidelines for the nondestructive test personnel is the
qualification and certification of responsibility of the employer. Certification
nondestructive test personnel whose specific of nondestructive test personnel shall be
jobs require appropriate knowledge of the based on demonstration of satisfactory
technical principles underlying the qualification [in accordance with sections
nondestructive tests they perform, witness, on education, training, experience and
monitor or evaluate. This document examinations] as described in the
provides guidelines for the establishment of employer’s written practice. Personnel
a qualification and certification program. certification records shall be maintained on
file by the employer.
Written Practice. The employer shall
establish a written practice for the control
and administration of nondestructive
testing personnel training, examination and
certification. The employer’s written practice TABLE 5. Recommended training and experience for
should describe the responsibility of each electromagnetic testing personnel according to
level of certification for determining the Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A.6
acceptability of materials or components in
accordance with the applicable codes, Level I Level II
standards, specifications and procedures.
Education, Training, Experience High school graduatea 40 h 40 h
Requirements for Initial Qualification. Two years of collegeb 24 h 40 h
Candidates for certification in Work experiencec 210 h 630 h
nondestructive testing should have
sufficient education, training and a. Or equivalent.
experience to ensure qualification in those b. Completion with a passing grade of at least two years of engineering or
nondestructive testing methods for which science study in a university, college or technical school.
they are being considered for certification. c. Minimum work experience per level. Note: for Level II certification, the
Table 6.3.1A [Table 5 in this volume, for experience shall consist of time as Level I or equivalent. If a person is
being qualified directly to Level II with no time at Level I, the required
electromagnetic testing] lists the
experience shall consist of the sum of the times required for Level I and
recommended training and experience Level II and the required training shall consist of the sum of the hours
factors to be considered by the employer in required for Level I and Level II.
establishing written practices for initial
qualification of Level I and II individuals.

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 19


Recertification. All levels of nondestructive (d) radiographic testing; (e) ultrasonic
testing personnel shall be recertified testing” and that the “system described in
periodically in accordance with the this International Standard may also
following: evidence of continuing apply to visual testing (VT), leak testing
satisfactory performance; and reexamination
in those portions of the examination
(LT), neutron radiography (NR), acoustic
deemed necessary by the employer’s NDT emission (AE) and other nondestructive
Level III. Recommended maximum test methods where independent
recertification intervals are three years for certification programs exist.” The
Level I and II and five years for Level III. applicability of ISO 9712 to
The minimum number of questions electromagnetic testing therefore depends
that should be administered in the on activity of the national certifying body.
written examination for eddy current test
personnel is as follows: 40 questions in
the general examination and 20 questions
in the specific examination. The number
Safety in Electromagnetic
of questions is the same for Level I and Testing
Level II personnel. To manage an electromagnetic testing
These recommendations from program, as with any testing program, the
Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A are first obligation is to ensure safe working
cited only to provide a general idea of the conditions. The following are components
specific items that must be considered in of a safety program that may be required
the development of an in-house or at least deserve serious consideration.
nondestructive testing program. Because
the items are paraphrased, those 1. Before work is to begin, identify the
developing a personnel qualification safety and operational rules and codes
program should consult the complete text applicable to the areas, equipment and
of SNT-TC-1A and other applicable systems to be tested.
procedures and practices. If an outside 2. Provide proper safety equipment
agency is contracted for electromagnetic (protective barriers, hard hat, safety
test services, then the contractor must harnesses, steel toed shoes, hearing
have a qualification and certification protection and others).
program to satisfy most codes and 3. Before the test, perform a thorough
standards. visual survey to determine all the
hazards and to identify necessary
safeguards to protect test personnel
Central Certification and equipment.
Another standard that may be a source for 4. Notify operative personnel to identify
compliance is contained in the the location and specific material,
requirements of the International equipment or systems to be tested. In
Organization for Standardization (ISO). addition, it must be determined
The work of preparing international whether signs or locks restrict access
standards is normally carried out through by personnel. Be aware of equipment
technical committees of the International that may be operated remotely or may
Organization for Standardization, a be started by time delay.
worldwide federation of national 5. Be aware of any potentially explosive
standards bodies. Each ISO member body atmosphere. Determine whether it is
interested in a subject for which a safe to take test equipment into the
technical committee has been established area.
has the right to be represented on that 6. Do not enter any roped off or no entry
committee. International organizations, areas without permission and
governmental and nongovernmental, in approval.
liaison with the International 7. When working on or around moving
Organization for Standardization, also or electrical equipment, the inspector
take part in the work. should remove pens, watches, rings or
Technical Committee ISO/TC 135, objects in pockets that may touch (or
Non-Destructive Testing Subcommittee fall into) energized equipment.
SC 7, Personnel Qualification, prepared 8. Know interplant communication and
international standard ISO 9712, evacuation systems.
Nondestructive Testing – Qualification and 9. Never let unqualified personnel
Certification of Personnel.9 In its statement operate equipment independently
of scope, ISO 9712 states that it from qualified supervision.
“establishes a system for the qualification
and certification, by a certification body,
of personnel to perform industrial
nondestructive testing (NDT) using any of
the following methods: (a) eddy current
testing; (b) liquid penetrant testing;
(c) magnetic particle testing;

20 Electromagnetic Testing
10. Keep a safe distance between the
inspector and any energized
equipment. In the United States, these
distances can be found in documents
from the Occupational Safety and
Health Administration, the National
Fire Prevention Association (National
Electric Code),10 the Institute of
Electrical and Electronics Engineers
(National Electrical Safety Code)11 and
other organizations.
11. Be aware of the personnel
responsibilities before entering a
confined space. All such areas must be
tested satisfactorily for gas and oxygen
levels before entry and periodically
thereafter. If odors are noticed or if
unusual sensations such as ear aches,
dizziness or difficulty in breathing are
experienced, leave the area
immediately.
Most facilities in the United States are
required by law to follow the
requirements in the applicable standard.
Two Occupational Safety and Health
Standards in the United States that should
be reviewed are Occupational Safety and
Health Standards for general industry12 and
the Occupational Safety and Health
Standards for the Construction Industry.13
Personnel safety is always the first
consideration for every job.

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 21


PART 3. Units of Measure for Electromagnetic
Testing

Origin and Use of SI TABLE 6. SI base units.


System Quantity Unit Symbol
In 1960, the General Conference on Length meter m
Weights and Measures established the Mass kilogram kg
International System of Units. Le Systéme Time second s
International d’Unités (SI) was designed so Electric current ampere A
that a single set of measurement units
Temperature kelvin K
could be used by all branches of science,
engineering and the general public. Amount of substance mole mol
Without SI, this Nondestructive Testing Luminous intensity candela cd
Handbook volume could have contained a
confusing mix of obsolete
centimeter-gram-second (CGS) units,
imperial units and the units preferred by TABLE 7. SI derived units with special names.a
certain localities or scientific specialties.
SI is the modern version of the metric Relation
system and ends the division between to Other
Quantity Units Symbol SI Unitsb
metric units used by scientists and metric
units used by engineers and the public.
Capacitance farad F C·V–1
Scientists have given up their units based
Catalytic activity katal kat s–1 ·mol
on centimeter and gram and engineers
made a fundamental change in Conductance siemens S A·V–1
abandoning the kilogram-force in favor of Energy joule J N·m
the newton. Electrical engineers have Frequency (periodic) hertz Hz 1·s–1
retained their ampere, volt and ohm but Force newton N kg·m·s–2
changed all units related to magnetism. Inductance henry H Wb·A–1
Table 6 lists the seven SI base units. Illuminance lux lx lm·m–2
Table 7 lists derived units with special Luminous flux lumen lm cd·sr
names. Table 8 gives examples of Electric charge coulomb C A·s
conversions to SI units. In SI, the unit of
Electric potentialc volt V W·A–1
time is the second (s) but hour (h) is
Electric resistance ohm Ω V·A–1
recognized for use with SI.
For more information, the reader is Magnetic flux weber Wb V·s
referred to the information available Magnetic flux density tesla T Wb·m–2
through national standards organizations Plane angle radian rad 1
and specialized information compiled by Power watt W J·s–1
technical organizations.14-17 Pressure (stress) pascal Pa N·m–2
Radiation absorbed dose gray Gy J·kg–1
Multipliers Radiation dose equivalent sievert Sv J·kg–1
Radioactivity becquerel Bq 1·s–1
In science and engineering, very large or
very small numbers with units are Solid angle steradian sr 1
expressed by using the SI multipliers, Temperature, celsius degree celsius °C K
prefixes of 103 intervals (Table 9). The Timea hour h 3600 s
multiplier becomes a property of the SI Volumea liter L dm3
unit. For example a millimeter (mm) is
a. Hour and liter are not SI units but are accepted for use with the SI.
0.001 meter (m). The volume unit cubic
b. Number one (1) expresses dimensionless relationship.
centimeter (cm3) is (0.01 m)3 or 10–6 m3.
c. Electromotive force.
Unit submultiples such as the centimeter,
decimeter, dekameter (or decameter) and
hectometer are often avoided in scientific
and technical uses of SI because of their
variance from the 103 interval. However,
dm3 and cm3 are commonly used. Note
that 1 cm3 is not equal to 0.01 m3.
Nevertheless, in equations, submultiples

22 Electromagnetic Testing
TABLE 8. Examples of conversions to SI units.
Quantity Measurement in Non-SI Unit Multiply by To Get Measurement in SI Unit

Angle minute (min) 2.908 882 × 10–4 radian (rad)


degree (deg) 1.745 329 × 10–2 radian (rad) MOVIE.
Area square inch (in.2) 645 square millimeter (mm ) 2 Radian of circle.
Distance angstrom (Å) 0.1 nanometer (nm)
inch (in.) 25.4 millimeter (mm)
Energy British thermal unit (BTU) 1.055 kilojoule (kJ)
calorie (cal), thermochemical 4.184 joule (J)
Power British thermal unit per hour (BTU·h–1) 0.293 watt (W)
Specific heat British thermal unit per pound 4.19 kilojoule per kilogram per kelvin (kJ·kg–1·K–1)
degree fahrenheit (BTU·lbm–1·°F–1)
Force (torque, couple) foot-pound (ft-lbf) 1.36 joule (J)
Pressure pound force per square inch (lbf·in.–2) 6.89 kilopascal (kPa)
Frequency (cycle) cycle per minute 60–1 hertz (Hz)
Illuminance footcandle (ftc) 10.76 lux (lx)
phot (ph) 10 000 lux (lx)
Luminance candela per square foot (cd·ft–2) 10.76 candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
candela per square inch (cd·in.–2) 1 550 candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
footlambert (ftl) 3.426 candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
lambert 3 183 (= 10 000/π) candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
nit (nt) 1 candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
stilb (sb) 10 000 candela per square meter (cd·m–2)
Radioactivity curie (Ci) 37 gigabecquerel (GBq)
Ionizing radiation exposure roentgen (R) 0.258 millicoulomb per kilogram (mC·kg–1)
Mass pound (lbm) 0.454 kilogram (kg)
Temperature (difference) degree fahrenheit (°F) 0.556 kelvin (K) or degree celsius (°C)
Temperature (scale) degree fahrenheit (°F) (°F – 32)/1.8 degree celsius (°C)
Temperature (scale) degree fahrenheit (°F) (°F – 32)/1.8) + 273.15 kelvin (K)

such as centimeter (cm) or decimeter (dm)


are often avoided because they disturb the
convenient 103 or 10–3 intervals that TABLE 9. SI prefixes and multipliers.
make equations easy to manipulate. Prefix Symbol Multiplier
In SI, the distinction between upper
and lower case letters is meaningful and yotta Y 1024
should be observed. For example, the zetta Z 1021
meanings of the prefix m (milli) and the exa E 1018
prefix M (mega) differ by nine orders of peta P 1015
magnitude. tera T 1012
giga G 109
mega M 106
SI Units for kilo k 103
hectoa 102
Electromagnetic Testing deka (or deca)a
h
da 10
decia d 10–1
CGS Units centia c 10–2
Table 10 gives examples of milli m 10–3
centimeter-gram-second (CGS) units. micro µ 10–6
These units are not accepted for use with nano n 10–9
the SI. Furthermore, no other units of the pico p 10–12
various CGS systems of units, which femto f 10–15
includes the CGS electrostatic, CGS atto a 10–18
electromagnetic and CGS gaussian zepto z 10–21
systems, are accepted for use with SI
yocto y 10–24
except such units as the centimeter (cm),
gram (g) and second (s) that are also a. Avoid these prefixes (except in dm3 and cm3) for
defined in SI. science and engineering.
The oersted, gauss and maxwell are
part of the electromagnetic

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 23


TABLE 10. Units from the centimeter-gram-second (CGS) system of units and not accepted for use with SI. Factor to
convert each CGS unit to SI unit is given.
Physical Quantity CGS Unit Multiply by SI Unit SI Symbol

Basic CGS Units


Magnetic field intensity oersted (Oe) 103·(4π)–1 ampere per meter A·m–1
Magnetic flux maxwell (Mx) 10–8 weber Wb
Magnetic flux density gauss (G) 10–4 tesla T
Magnetic potential difference gilbert (Gb) 10·(4π)–1 ampere A
Electromagnetic CGS Units
Capacitance abfarad 109 farad F
Charge abcoulomb 10 coulomb C
Conductance abmho 109 siemens S
Current abampere 10 ampere A
Inductance abhenry 10–9 henry H
Magnetic field intensity abampere per centimeter 103 ampere per meter A·m–1
Potential abvolt 10–8 volt V
Resistance abohm 10–9 ohm Ω
Electrostatic CGS Units
Capacitance statfarad 1.112 650 × 10–12 farad F
Charge statcoulomb 3.3356 × 10–10 coulomb C
Conductance statmho 1.112 65 × 10–12 siemens S
Current statampere 3.335 641 × 10–11 ampere A
Inductance stathenry 8.987 552 × 1011 henry H
Potential statvolt 2.997 925 × 102 volt V
Resistance statohm 8.987 55 × 1011 ohm Ω

three-dimensional CGS system. When


only mechanical and electric quantities
are considered, these three units cannot TABLE 11. Conversion of Units for
strictly speaking be compared each to the Conductivity σ and Resistivity ρ.
corresponding unit of SI, which has four From Unit Operation To Get Unit
dimensions.
Ampere per Meter Replaces Oersted. One Conductivity Unit to Conductivity Unita
ampere per meter (A·m–1) equals about S·m–1 (S·m–1) × 10–6 MS·m–1
one eightieth of an oersted (Oe). The S·m–1 (S·m–1) × (1.724 × 10–6) %IACS
relationship is 1 Oe = 1000·(4π)–1 A·m–1 = MS·m–1 (MS·m–1) × 106 S·m–1
79.57747 A·m–1. MS·m–1 (MS·m–1) × 1.724 %IACS
Tesla Replaces Gauss. One tesla (T) equals %IACS %IACS × (5.800 × 105) S·m–1
ten thousand gauss (G). 1 G = 10–4 T = %IACS %IACS × 0.580 MS·m–1
0.1 mT. Conductivity Unita to Resistivity Unit
Weber Replaces Maxwell. One weber (Wb) S·m–1 1 ÷ (S·m–1) Ω·m
equals 108 maxwell (Mx). 1 Mx = 10–8 Wb S·m –1 (1 × 108) ÷ (S·m–1) µΩ·cm
= 0.01 µWb = 10 nWb. MS·m–1 (1 × 10–6) ÷ (MS·m–1) Ω·m
MS·m–1 (1 × 102) ÷ (MS·m–1) µΩ·cm
Conductivity and Resistivity %IACS (1.724 × 10–6) ÷ %IACS Ω·m
In the twentieth century, the conductivity %IACS 172.4 ÷ %IACS µΩ·cm
of a given metal was conventionally Resistivity Unit to Conductivity Unita
expressed as a percentage of pure copper’s Ω·m 1 ÷ (Ω·m) S·m–1
conductivity with reference to the Ω·m (1 × 10 ) ÷ (Ω·m)
–6 MS·m–1
International Annealed Copper Standard Ω·m (1.724 × 10 ) ÷ (Ω·m)
–6 %IACS
(IACS).18 In SI, conductivity is expressed µΩ·cm (1 × 108) ÷ (µΩ·cm) S·m–1
in siemens per meter (S·m–1). The µΩ·cm (1 × 102) ÷ (µΩ·cm) MS·m–1
conductivity of pure copper (100 percent
µΩ·cm 172.4 ÷ (µΩ·cm) %IACSa
IACS) is 58 MS·m–1.
Resistivity Unit to Resistivity Unit
Resistivity is the inverse of
conductivity and is expressed in ohm Ω·m (Ω·m) × 108 µΩ·cm
meter. Table 11 gives the formulas for µΩ·m (µΩ·m) × 10–8 Ω·m
conversion to and from units for a. %IACS: percentage of International Annealed Copper
conductivity and resistivity. Standard.18

24 Electromagnetic Testing
References

1. Nondestructive Testing Handbook, 13. 29 CFR 1926, Occupational Safety and


second edition: Vol. 10, Nondestructive Health Standards for the Construction
Testing Overview. Columbus, OH: Industry [Code of Federal Regulations:
American Society for Nondestructive Title 29, Labor]. Washington, DC:
Testing (1996). United States Department of Labor,
2. Wenk, S.A. and R.C. McMaster. Occupational Safety and Health
Choosing NDT: Applications, Costs and Administration; United States
Benefits of Nondestructive Testing in Your Government Printing Office.
Quality Assurance Program. Columbus, 14. IEEE/ASTM SI 10-1997, Standard for Use
OH: American Society for of the International System of Units (SI):
Nondestructive Testing (1987). The Modernized Metric System. West
3. Nondestructive Testing Methods. Conshohocken, PA: ASTM
TO33B-1-1 (NAVAIR 01-1A-16) International (1996).
TM43-0103. Washington, DC: 15. Taylor, B.N. Guide for the Use of the
Department of Defense (June 1984). International System of Units (SI).
4. Nondestructive Testing Handbook, National Institute of Standards and
second edition: Vol. 4, Electromagnetic Technology Special Publication 811,
Testing. Columbus, OH: American 1995 edition. Washington, DC: United
Society for Nondestructive Testing States Government Printing Office
(1986). (1995).
5. Annual Book of ASTM Standards: 16. Taylor, B.N., ed. Interpretation of the SI
Section 3, Metals Test Methods and for the United States and Federal
Analytical Procedures. Vol. 03.03, Government and Metric Conversion
Nondestructive Testing. West Policy. NIST Special Publication 814,
Conshohocken, PA: ASTM 1998 Edition. Washington, DC: United
International (2001). States Government Printing Office
6. Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A. (1998).
Columbus, OH: American Society for 17. Taylor, B.N., ed. The International
Nondestructive Testing (2001). System of Units (SI), 2001 edition. NIST
7. ANSI/ASNT CP-189, Standard for Special Publication 330. Washington
Qualification and Certification of DC: United States Government
Nondestructive Testing Personnel. Printing Office (2001).
Columbus, OH: American Society for 18. IEC 60028, International Standard of
Nondestructive Testing (2001). Resistance for Copper. Geneva,
8. ASNT Central Certification Program Switzerland: International
(ACCP), Revision 3 (November 1997). Electrotechnical Commission (2001).
Columbus, OH: American Society for
Nondestructive Testing (1998).
9. ISO 9712, Nondestructive Testing —
Qualification and Certification of
Personnel. Geneva, Switzerland:
International Organization for
Standardization.
10. NFPA 70, National Electric Code, 2002
edition. Quincy, MA: National Fire
Prevention Association (2001).
11. National Electrical Safety Code, 2002
edition. New York, NY: Institute of
Electrical and Electronics Engineers
(2001).
12. 29 CFR 1910, Occupational Safety and
Health Standards [Code of Federal
Regulations: Title 29, Labor.]
Washington, DC: United States
Department of Labor, Occupational
Safety and Health Administration;
United States Government Printing
Office.

Introduction to Electromagnetic Testing 25

You might also like