Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER - 1
INTRODUCTION
1. Introduction
Bacteria, fungi and dust mites can create various problems like odors, can cause
allergic reactions, stains on fabric surface due to bacterial growth. The microbial
growth is also very serious problem in outdoor applications of textiles like
awnings, tents, or lawn furniture and leads to discoloration and degradation.
Floorings, tufted carpets / automotive carpets, rugs are also a source for the
bacterial growth on surface. The fungi or bacterial growth can be seen on the moist
areas below the carpets or flooring materials and gives foul smell and sometimes it
reduces the serviceability of the product. Also the carpets, rugs, bathmats can hold
the dirt and moisture inside the structure or on the fibres that also can create bad
odours and surface staining with microbial growth.
The Needle punched Nonwovens with different GSM (for different applications)
will be developed by using staple Polyester fibers of 1.5 D, 3D, 6D denier. The
developed nonwovens will be subjected to chemical finishing of antimicrobial
agents to meet the requirements of the various applications like in shoe insole,
interlinings for jackets, automotive AC filter fabrics, milk & beverage filtration
application etc. Also an attempt will be made to make inherent antimicrobial
nonwoven by using inherent antimicrobial fibers.
An attempt will be made to explore the applications of the Zinc Pyrithone to make
antimicrobial needle punched nonwoven fabrics. This will restrict the bacterial
growth over the fabric surface and a problem of bad odors in the cabin air filters
used in car & even in other various applications of nonwoven can be addressed
easily. With this development of antimicrobial nonwovens a bacterial development
over the fabric surface will be restricted and a problem of odors in various
applications of nonwoven can be addressed easily. (Applications of nonwovens are
like sleeping bags, jackets, automotive AC, shoe insoles, sleeping bag liners, milk
& beverage filtration application, floor carpets etc).
Bacteria, fungi and dust mites can create problems and cause many different issues.
They mainly create an odors in mattress, automotive AC, floor carpets, shoe
insoles, cause allergic reactions also that can create stains on surface of upholstery.
An attempt will be made by developing antimicrobial nonwovens which can tackle
the problem.
1.3 Objectives
1.4 Scope
With this development of antimicrobial nonwovens a bacterial development over
the fabric surface will be restricted and a problem of odors in various applications
of nonwoven can be addressed easily. (Applications of nonwovens like sleeping
bags, jackets, automotive AC, shoe insoles, milk & beverage filtration application,
sleeping bag liners etc.)
CHAPTER - 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
Nonwovens are sheet of fibres, or the continuous filaments or the chopped yarns of
any origin that have been formed into the web by any means and bonded together
by any means, except weaving or knitting. Nonwoven fabrics are mainly flat,
porous sheets that are made directly from separate fibers or from molten plastic or
sheet or web structures bonded together by entangling of fiber or filaments either
mechanically, thermally or chemically except by weaving or knitting and they
don’t require converting the fibers to yarn [1, 2].
Normally the nonwovens are manufactured at higher production rate and at lower
processing cost. The first commercial use of nonwovens was to replace the
expensive woven filters in automotive industry. The nonwovens have wide
applications and are classified on the basis of usage life time can be either durable
&disposable. Major applications includes sanitary napkins, caps, gowns, wipes,
apparel interlinings, padding and backing, agricultural applications, automotive
headliners and upholstery, filters for various applications, envelopes, thermal
insulation linings, house wraps, roofing products and geo textiles. The Filtration is
one of the most dynamic sectors for nonwovens due to their adaptability;
nonwoven materials play an important role in filtering both air and liquids.
Nonwovens plays vital role in filtration to improve indoor air quality & helps filter
the drinking water by removing viruses and bacteria. Nonwovens also play an
important role in medical applications like blood dialysis. [3, 4].
There can be chances of development of growing bacteria, fungi and dust mites
nonwoven structures, which can create problems and cause many different issues
like odors in various applications of nonwovens such as sleeping bags liners,
jackets liners, automotive air conditioner, shoe insoles, building and construction,
geo-textiles, mattress, disposable towels, bedding, upholstery, carpets, curtains,
pillows, acoustic insulation, military fabrics, tenting, carpets, thermal liners, caps,
jackets, work wear, sportswear, fleeces, architectural fabrics, awnings, canopies,
scrubs, automotive carpets, masks, window covering, filters etc.
As per World Health Organization, the allergens are the fourth most common
chronic illness globally. The bacteria, fungi and dust mites can get developed over
it and create different problems, like allergic reactions, odors, stains on the
upholstery used in cars. Microbial growth is also big problem with the outdoor
applications of the textiles, like, tents, lawn furniture, awnings and leads to
discoloration and reduces the life of the product.
The filters used in air conditioner in car also a possible surface on which bacterial
growth, can takes place, also at the time of the pollen season there are more than
3,000 different types of pollens in one milliliter of air. It’s very high load on the
the filter. Which is polluting the air inside the vehicle; people today suffer from
allergic reactions due to pollen, bacteria and mold fungi this can be big issue in
road safety because if the driver suddenly sneeze, there can be distraction for
approximately about two seconds and that restricts the ability of driver to respond
and the braking distance can be more than usual. For same the protection of the
driver and passengers against pollen and bacteria requires the use of efficient cabin
air filters for automotive application. [5].
The flooring, carpets and rugs can frequently be a source of unwanted microbes.
Fungi can grow in moist areas under carpets and create odours. Carpets, rugs,
bathmats can trap dirt and moisture within the fibres, leads to create odours and
staining on surface. Nonwoven finds applications across a wide range of end-use
applications as few examples below [6].
Fabrics used for industrial or outdoor applications are often require antifungal
treatment & normally done by Isothiazolinone and thiabendazole, have good
antifungal properties but not effective against bacterial attack.
All the technologies have their pros and cons regarding the required degree of
antimicrobial effectiveness, along with the way they can be incorporated during the
manufacturing process. Single ingredient or product formulation will be suitable
for all the applications. The optimisation of different actives can lower overall use
of antimicrobial, which gives economical savings and most importantly, deliver
superior performance of the antimicrobial activity. Antibacterial agents should be
diluted exactly as per required antimicrobial activity. Solutions that are too weak
may be ineffective and too strong solutions can be dangerous when it comes in
human contact. Also it is very important that the antibacterial agent will make easy
contact with the microbes.[9, 10].
The anti-microbial agents used on fabric can destroy the bacteria and prevent the
breeding process. Nano silver colloids and nano silver treated nonwovens have
good bacteriostatic properties. Antibacterial treatment of nonwoven fabrics is
easily achieved by the nano silver colloidal solution. Nanotechnology is concerned
with various materials shows unique physical, chemical, biological properties, but
it is costly process and cannot be used for commercial products manufacturing.
This raises many issues about new materials for achieving specific functionality
and selectivity. Nano materials have excellent potential because of their potential
applications.
There are primarily two major types of antimicrobial routes available to the
nonwovens industry. These include either the non-leachable or leachable types.
Leachable antimicrobials are not chemically bonded with the fabric and can be
easily removed with moisture. Antimicrobials can increase the value and
performance of the nonwovens, but inherent antimicrobials can cause variety of
risks of environmental and toxicological concerns.
2.5.1 Mattress:
Microbial odors are associated with mattress is due to perspiration, dead skin and
organic matters. These problems are persistent because laundering of the mattress
is done less frequently. The major organisms associated with mattress are the
fungal organisms, but bacteria may cause problems under special conditions [11].
2.5.2 Flooring, carpets: Floorings, carpets and rugs can be normally source of
microbes. Fungi’s can easily grow on moist areas under soft flooring materials and
create musty odours. A carpet, rugs, bathmats holds dirt and moisture on fibres,
leading to odours and stains due to microbial growth on surface, when not properly
cleaned or dried.
With proper design and choice of materials the effects of microorganisms in most
civil engineering applications can be minimized. In most cases polypropylene
nonwoven fabrics are available for applications including rail road stabilization,
drainage liners, pond liners and erosion control. Microbial degradation of the
polypropylene fabrics will not happen but the microorganisms (bacteria and fungi)
can grow on the surface of these materials and affects the water transport property
of nonwovens.[12, 13].
Antimicrobial treated nonwoven cover stock and baby diapers can minimize odor
associated with microbial breakdown of urine. Also it can help for effective in
control of microbes associated with mildew infections and diaper rash & more
hygienic product can be offered to the consumer.
Prasad Upasani, et.al, carried out an experiment on zinc oxide nanoribbon (ZnO
NR)–multiwall carbon nanotube composite film was prepared by filtration
technique. The composite film displayed a strong antimicrobial property and
porous structure, which has potential application as an antimicrobial bandage
material. [12, 13].
The nano-scale particles can provide a narrow size distribution which is good for
uniform deposition on the material. Although the process of using solution
chemistry can be a practical route for the synthesis of nano-scale particles of many
materials, issues such as the control of size, distribution of particles, agglomeration
of the particle during and after synthesis and separation of these particles from the
reactant needs further analysis. [14].
During use, this surface bacteria transfers to textiles worn next to the skin. There,
in a warm, dark and moist environment, the bacteria breed, particularly after
aerobic activity. Sweat and sweaty clothes smell because it contains bacteria
effluent like ammonia. Anti-microbial agents in clothing can destroy these bacteria
and prevent the breeding process. However, anti-microbial clothing must strike a
balance to be both effective and safe. A migrating anti-microbial can destroy
everything it contacts, including the good and necessary bacteria needed for
healthy skin. The role is to destroy the bacteria in the clothing, stop the breeding
process but to leave the skin bacteria intact. [15] [16].
The nonwoven fabrics can be made antimicrobial easily by using nano-sized silver
colloidal solution. Nanotechnology can be used on various materials, with less
effect on physical, chemical, and biological properties of the fabrics due to their
nano size. This raises many issues about new materials for achieving specific
functionality and selectivity. Such multidisciplinary insights are stimulating
progress in nano bio-technology, and the emerging field of nanotechnology is
leading to new approaches in textile engineering [17,18].
Functional finishing of textiles are very much required of the technical textiles,
finishes imply chemical and mechanical processes that impart various performance
properties to fabrics that have not existed, for example, water repellency, water
proofing, abrasion resistance, flame resistance, or immunity to bacteria or fungi .In
general, functional finishes usually need to be more durable than normally
expected. Antibacterial finishes are applied to textiles for three major reasons: to
control the spread of disease and the danger of infection following injury, to
control the development of odour from perspiration, stains on textile materials and
to control the deterioration of textiles for fabrics made from natural fibers are
pronto be attacked by mildew.
Needle-punched nonwoven fabrics are the major filters in industry. The kinds of
needle-punched filter fabrics being produced recently are unique and more
particular than ever before. High temperature liquid filter fabrics made from
aramid or glass fibers. The needle-punched filter fabrics used for filtering blood.
However, polyester filter bags are what most of the companies in this field are
producing. Because a great deal of needle punching is involved in the filter
industry, medical products, and home furnishings fields, it is clear how sensitive
this industry is to increases in costs and interest rates. Most needle-punched fabrics
would be improved by high quality sanitation.
Another very important consideration is whether the antibacterial agent will easily
make contact with the microbes. Heavy metals are usually toxic and very reactive
with proteins, particularly at sulfhydryl groups. Silver, for instance, is useful as an
antiseptic and disinfectant. The ability of microorganisms to grow in the presence
of metal content might result in specific mechanisms of resistance. Such
mechanisms include alterations of chemical structure or toxicity by changes in the
redox state of the metal ions. However, colloidal silver is much milder and less
toxic to humans than other inorganic materials [18, 19, 20].
CHAPTER – 3
PLAN OF WORK
3. 1 introduction
Proposed Work
9 Conclusion.
3. 2 Flow chart
Statistical Analysis
Conclusion
3.3. Materials
c. Antimicrobial chemicals:
Zinc oxide & Zinc pyrithione (or pyrithione zinc) is fungistatic (inhibits the
division of fungal cells) and bacteriostatic (inhibits the bacterial cell division)
properties.
Chemical structure: C10H8N2O2S2Zn & Solubility in water: 8 ppm (pH 7)
Bath pH : 5.0-5.5
Bath Temperature : 30-40 ºC
Drying Temperature : 160 ºC for 2 min
Needle-punching process
Nonwovens are produced by using four steps raw material preparation web
formation web bonding finishing.
The fibrous webs, mainly bulky, are produced by processes through carding, and
cross-lapping. Needle punching is the mechanical bonding method in which, the
interlocking of fibre and intermingling of fibers will be done by means of barbed
needles.
In the needle-punching process, the mechanical interlocking will be done by
thousands of barbed needles repeatedly punching on web. The web of fibers will
be fed to the needle loom. In needle loom consists of feed rolls, finger plate,
needle boards, needles, bed plate, stripper plate, and pair of delivery rolls.
Bonding takes place on the nonwoven web by the penetration of the barbed needle
into the web layers. In process of they make upward and downward motions the
needles travels through the holes present on the bed plate and stripper plate in
between the web will be held.
The barbed needles mounted on a board, with the upward and downward stroke
punches the fibres into the web. The web is trapped between bed plate and stripper
plate while needling process. The needles enter and leave from the web which is
supported by bed plate & stripper plate helps to remove web from needles. The
web is pulled out through the needle loom by delivery rolls and given for
subsequent process. The primary component of needle punching process is barbed
needle. In order to provide better bonding and mingling effect, the needle, barbs
and working blades play important role to punch the fibres to form peg on the
structure of needle punched nonwovens the in web and provides the mechanical
properties to the structure. Fig 3.1. Shows the schematic diagram of needle loom
on which needle punch nonwoven fabric is manufactured.
The needle punched non woven prepared by passing through the following steps –
Feeding:
Fibres were opened and spread on the floor for the preparation of fibres for
carding. The fibres were fed to carding machine in predetermined quantity by
electric auto scale controlled system.
Carding:
Fibres were fed into the carding machine. There the fibres are opened by the wires
points of the series of rotating cylinders and get aligned in parallel direction
(machine direction).A web is formed on card, which further given by doffer to the
cross lapper.
Cross Lapping:
The fibres webs were cross lapped several times by cross lapper to increase the
strength in cross direction. The number of layers depends on required GSM,
thickness and uniformity of non woven fabric.
Web Feeding:
The layered web fibres formed on cross lapper will be delivered to needle
punching loom by means of web feeding device. The web feeding mechanism
protects the layered web from deformation.
Pre-Needling:
The fibres will be mainly fed through number of needle punching looms. The pre-
needle punching is done to interlock the fibres entangle fibres in various layers
using low needle density. The process of the pre-needling is an optional process
but this process mainly improves the quality and provides better mechanical
properties to the needle punched nonwovens. The pre-needling process reduces
the web thickness; the mechanical strength is also gets increased and more
uniform structure can be manufactured by pre- needling the fabric.
Needle Punching:
The pre punched web of fibres will be subjected to further finishing punching
through other needle punching looms placed in series. The fabric gets needle
punched successively to get the fabric. The Needle punch nonwoven fabric
manufacturing process have, lower cost of production, low bulk density, porous,
better absorbency, less stiffness and better thermal insulation. The tensile and
tearing strength normally will be more in cross direction as compared to the
machine direction and vice versa in case of elongation. Stiffness is normally more
in cross direction as compared to the machine direction. Bending length depends
on compactness of fabric; more compact fabric provides more bending length.
Abrasion loss will be more in nonwoven fabric because it was made merely by the
entanglement of the fibres without any subsequent finish like resin coating which
could make it more abrasion resistant.
The mechanical properties of the needle punched nonwoven felt or fabric are
many depends on the processing parameters on needle punching line like, the
number needles and the barbs present on needles, type of needle, the punch
density, needling speed , depth of penetration, strokes and fiber types are other
important parameters. One of the most significant attribute of the needle punched
nonwovens fabric is their high porosity and high pore size distributions. The good
air permeability is also important property of needle punched nonwoven fabrics
for the use in filtration. Better dimensional stability, liquid and gas permeability,
good drape ability, easy mold ability, good acoustic and excellent thermal
properties, excellent mechanical properties make needle punched nonwovens
suitable to be used in various technical textiles applications and major applications
are like automotive application for acoustic and insulation, building construction,
home furnishing applications, geo-textiles, shoe insoles, blankets, solid / liquid
filters, thermal insulation.
The polysters fibres will be used for manufacturing the needle punch nonwoven
fabric. Needlepunch nonwoven fabric will be manufactured by using three basic
process carding, web formation and web bonding. Needle punch nonwoven fabric
will be manufactured on Trutzschler Nonwoven Machine shown in figure.
Zinc Pyrithoneis mainly nonionic material, was then diluted to get the different
strengths to apply on nonwoven fabrics by Pad Dry Cure
The strength of antimicrobial chemical was tested as per antimicrobial test and it
was found that 15 gpl was optimum chemical concentration to make the fabrics
antimicrobial.
Process parameters:
Bath pH : 5.0-5.5
Bath Temp. : 30-40 ºC
Drying: 160 ºC for 2 min
3.7 Testing
Initially we conducted some tests as per the ASTM standards to know the actual
fabric properties are as follows-
3.7.1 Denier
The fiber denier calculated by using micron value. The micron value determines by
using microscope to get a diameter of the fiber in micron. The microscope is
shown in figure 3.5.
The nonwoven fabric GSM, calculated as per ASTM 6242 standards, i.e. mass per
unit area (areal density in grams per square meter). The specimen of the size 10X
10 cm was cut randomly from different places and weighted in electronic balance
with an accuracy of 0.001 g and an average of 5 readings was taken.
The air permeability of nonwoven fabric was tested by standard ASTM D737-04
test method on TEXTEST FX3300 air permeability tester (figure 3.7). The area for
testing was 38 cm2 and the applied pressure was 125 Pa. The air permeability of a
fabric is the volume of air measured in cm3 passed per second through 1 square
centimeter area of the fabric at a pressure of 1cm of water.
The contact time selected for the test would be effective in significantly reducing
microbial counts during application.
This test is performed both with treated and untreated samples of the test material.
According to the AATCC 100 test method, 1 ml of microbial suspension at about
1000,000 CFU/ml will be inoculated on the fabric test specimen.
At a given time, bacteria’s are extracted with the help of a diluted neutralizer
medium.
CHAPTER 4
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
4. Introduction
The experimentation of this work was conducted as per the plan of work shown in
chapter 3. As per plan, various GSM of needle punch nonwoven samples are
manufactured on Truzschler nonwoven machine using 100% polyester fibres. The
manufactured needle punch nonwoven fabrics were treated chemically to make it
antimicrobial. The strength of antimicrobial chemical was tested as per
antimicrobial test and it was found that 15 gpl was optimum chemical
concentration to make the fabrics antimicrobial.
The fabric samples tested for various characteristics as per the ASTM standards.
Needles punch fabrics, made up with 1.5D, 3D, 6D 100 % PET fiber. By using
above nonwoven technology various samples were produced with different GSM.
The table no.4.1 shows the properties of fibers used.
4.2. Grams per Square Meter (GSM) of Needle punch nonwoven fabrics
The nonwoven fabric GSM, calculated as per ASTM 6242 standards, i.e. mass per
unit area (areal density in grams per square meter).The specimen of the size 10X
10 cm was cut randomly from different places and weighted in electronic balance
with an accuracy of 0.001 g and an average of 5 readings was taken.
Table 4.2 Grams per Square Meter (GSM) of Needle punch nonwoven fabric
350
300
250
200
Axis Title
150
100
50
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
treated 51.02 51.7 51.5 101.0 102.1 101.0 151.2 153.6 152.8 204.0 203.1 202.8 254.0 253.1 253.2
untreated 55.87 57.71 59.71 107.6 113.3 120.1 164.2 173.1 183.2 226.1 237.2 249.3 278.1 283.1 294.2
Figure 4.2 Grams per Square Meter (GSM) of Needle punch nonwoven fabric
2
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
Axis Title
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Treated 0.81 0.83 0.8 1.02 1.09 1.06 1.2 1.22 1.19 1.43 1.39 1.4 1.71 1.77 1.68
Untreated 0.78 0.8 0.78 0.97 1.01 0.98 1.15 1.17 1.13 1.35 1.32 1.34 1.59 1.62 1.59
These results may be because of the low melt fibers in the fabric melts after drying
process due to this they are unable to contribute to the strength of the fabric.
From the statistical analysis of the data we can conclude that antimicrobial
treatment affects on the tensile strength of needle punch nonwoven fabric in both
machine and cross direction but the difference is insignificant.
Table 4.4 Tensile Strength (N) in Machine Direction of Needle punch nonwoven
600
500
400
Axis Title
300
200
100
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Treated 167.1 165.9 162.5 249.7 245.3 246.2 366.4 370.0 369.7 423.1 421.8 426.1 488.9 484.7 490.4
Untreated 174.1 172.0 171.3 258.0 256.3 259.1 381.0 388.7 387.6 445.8 447.5 446.5 510.4 509.8 511.1
Table 4.5 Tensile Strength (N) in cross direction of Needle punch nonwoven
800
700
600
500
Axis Title
400
300
200
100
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Treated 287.1 284.3 283.1 356.6 358.1 360.1 421.8 426.1 424.8 559.5 564.9 566.5 730.8 735.6 728.6
Untreated 294.3 293.4 294.1 368.3 370.1 369.3 432.1 436.8 438.5 576.1 579.2 572.3 742.0 744.5 738.1
Due to the pad – dry – cure process the fabrics are subjected to the heat while
drying & curing that may lead to breaking of the thermally fused low melt fibre
bonding with the regular polyester fibres. That reduces the contribution to bonds to
the tearing strength.
From the statistical analysis of the data we can conclude that antimicrobial
chemical treatment affects on the tearing strength of needle punch nonwoven fabric
in both machine and cross direction but the difference is insignificant.
80
70
60
50
Axis Title
40
30
20
10
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Treated 37.1 38.4 35.1 43.5 42.1 44.4 48.1 46.6 49.3 56.5 55.1 58.3 66.3 69.3 63.7
Untreated 34.9 36.2 32.6 40.6 39.1 41.8 43.1 42.5 44.2 52.3 51.3 52.3 62.4 61.2 58.9
Table 4.7 Tear Resistance in Cross Direction (N) of Needle punch nonwoven
90
80
70
60
Axis Title
50
40
30
20
10
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Treated 57.9 56.3 59.5 62.9 62.3 63.5 66.1 65.3 66.9 69.5 71.5 70.2 74.6 76.7 75.1
Untreated 54.9 53.2 56.6 59.6 58.4 60.8 63.1 63.2 63.9 66.3 69.3 67.3 71.4 72.7 71.9
From the statistical analysis of the data we can conclude that chemical treatment
affects on the bursting strength of needle punch nonwoven fabric but the difference
is insignificant.
Table 4.8 -Bursting strength-bursting pressure (kPa) of Needle punch nonwoven fabrics
700
600
500
Axis Title
400
300
200
100
0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3 E1 E2 E3
Series1 287.9 284.2 285.6 367.6 362.3 363.5 410.7 412.3 414.5 533.4 548.5 545.9 594.8 590.2 592.6
Series2 283.9 281.2 281.6 363.6 357.3 359.5 405.2 408.1 409.5 525.4 538.5 538.9 587.8 584.2 585.6
CHAPTER 5
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE SCOPE
5.1 Conclusion
The properties of the nonwoven fabric do not get affected significantly, that
makes this Zinc Pyrithone based chemical suitable for the treatment on
polyester fibre.
Further this chemical can be used as a low cost & feasible solution for
making fabrics suitable for various applications like in Geo-textiles, medical
textiles etc.
CHAPTER 6
REFERENCES
1. https://www.edana.org/discover-nonwovens/what-are-nonwovens. Retrieved on
07/07/2019
http://www.indiantextilejournal.com/articles/FAdetails.asp?id=4864. Retrieved
on 08/07/2019
https://www.jeffjournal.org/INJ/inj99_1.pdf
6. https://ultra-fresh.com/antimicrobial-applications/antimicrobial-fabric-
treatment/Retrieved on 08/07/2019
9. http://www.aegisasia.com/wp,content/uploads/how_antimicrobial_treatment_ca
Science, Engineering and Technology, Vol. 3, Issue 4, April 2014, Page 11535-
11541
12. Prasad Upasani, T.V. Sreekumar, V.G. Gaikar, Neetu Jha, Preparation of
productshttps://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/af/90/ab/4bbb7667aedf63/
Retrieved on 08/07/2019
material.htmRetrieved on 09/07/2019
CHAPTER 7
PAPER PUBLICATION
CHAPTER: ANNEXURE – I
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 2286.44 152.4293 5488.162
Column 2 15 2603.21 173.5473 7236.025
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 3344.774 1 3344.774 0.525735 0.474422 4.195972
Within Groups 178138.6 28 6362.093
Total 181483.4 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 18.6 1.24 0.102429
Column 2 15 17.58 1.172 0.08456
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 0.03468 1 0.03468 0.370932 0.547407 4.195972
Within Groups 2.61784 28 0.093494
Total 2.65252 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 5319.945 354.663 16345.83
Column 2 15 5078.57 338.5713 14774.36
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 1942.056 1 1942.056 0.12481 0.726521 4.195972
Within Groups 435682.6 28 15560.09
Total 437624.7 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 7249.603 483.3069 27087.89
Column 2 15 7088.68 472.5787 27019.79
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 863.2071 1 863.2071 0.031907 0.859518 4.195972
Within Groups 757507.5 28 27053.84
Total 758370.7 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 754.46 50.29733 117.2025
Column 2 15 703.9349 46.92899 101.0557
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 85.09286 1 85.09286 0.779745 0.384738 4.195972
Within Groups 3055.616 28 109.1291
Total 3140.709 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 998.91 66.594 40.05003
Column 2 15 953.2749 63.55166 39.43681
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 69.41875 1 69.41875 1.746673 0.196993 4.195972
Within Groups 1112.816 28 39.74342
Total 1182.234 29
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 15 6594.79 439.6527 13725.49
Column 2 15 6510.97 434.0647 13361.37
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 234.1931 1 234.1931 0.017292 0.896321 4.195972
Within Groups 379215.9 28 13543.43
Total 379450.1 29
Director H.O.D.