You are on page 1of 5

International Journal of Research in Engineering, Science and Management 516

Volume-3, Issue-4, April-2020


www.ijresm.com | ISSN (Online): 2581-5792

A Review on Hybrid Grid-Connected


Renewable Energy Systems
K. Saravanan
Associate Professor, Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Dr. M.G.R. Educational and
Research Institute, Chennai, India

Abstract: Rapid industrialization, together with globalization, cell, etc. The major advantage of the grid-connected hybrid
urbanization and explosive growth human population has caused power system is that even if anyone of the energy sources fails
greater stress on the world energy demand. The increasing to generate power and supply to the load, the other sources
demand for energy resulted in the exploitation of natural
resources including fossil fuels. The utilization of these non- could continue to provide uninterruptible supply at any point in
renewable resources is increasing the risks related to global time. Thus, the overall sustainability of the power system is
warming and climate change. In recent years’ organizations are guaranteed by ensuring continuous supply to the distribution
increasingly focusing on green energy as an alternative to system.
conventional energy sources like coal, diesel, petrol, and natural
gas. Research shows that with the support of an efficient power 3. Review of Studies on Hybrid Grid Connected
management and control system renewable energy resources
Renewable Energy Systems
based energy system can be designed with better efficiency and
reliability to overcome the present crisis. Some of the important research works on hybrid grid
The objective of this paper is to review the current status of connected renewable energy systems that guided the current
research in the Micro-grid connected Hybrid Renewable Energy research are reviewed in this section.
(HRE) generation system. A micro-grid is built by integrating
T. F. El-Shatter et al. [1] have designed and simulated a
different renewable energy systems like wind energy, solar power,
fuel cell technology, Ultra-capacitor, etc. hybrid power generation system consisting of Photovoltaic
(PV) system and fuel cell (FC) system. The proposed model
Keywords: Fuel cells, Hydro power, Micro-grids, Solar used electrolyzer for hydrogen generation. In the proposed
photovoltaic system, Ultra-capacitor, Wind energy. model, Fuzzy regression model (FRM) was applied for
maximum power point tracking in order to derive maximum
1. Introduction power from solar PV arrays. The design also included a
Increasing focus toward the concept of green energy in the controller that ensures continuous supply of power to the load
society has fueled further research on how efficiently the from solar PV array, or fuel cell, or both. The innovation in the
renewable energy resources can be used to the maximum proposed system lies in the provision of isolation circuit that
potential. The intermittent nature of the availability of isolates the electrolyte from the electrolysis cell to prevent
renewable energy from sources like wind, and solar has corrosion of electrolyzer’s electrodes after sunset.
necessitated the technique of integrating several renewable D. Sapiro et al. [2] have developed an integrated photovoltaic
energy systems from different sources. The quantum of benefits – electrolyzer - fuel cell system for delivering continuous,
and potentiality of such integration has been phenomenal. The consistent and eco-friendly power to facilities located in remote
main areas of focus in designing an efficient electrical power areas. The suitability of the module for telecommunications and
system using renewable sources include generation, medical facilities in remote location was also successfully
distribution, management, control, and storage of power from tested.
different sources effectively and efficiently. O. C. Onar et al. [3] have stated for sustained power
generation various renewable energy sources like wind, fuel
2. Hybrid Grid Connected Renewable Energy Systems cell (FC) and ultra-capacitor (UC) systems has to be combined
Hybrid Renewable Energy Systems (HRES) is built by in an efficient manner. They suggested that UC bank can be
integrating two or more renewable or conventional energy integrated with wind turbine as the output power from the wind
sources and connecting to a common grid. The main advantage turbine depends on the wind speed and varies from time to time.
of HRES is that such integration can successfully exploit the This ensures that performance of the system is unaffected under
operating characteristics of the energy sources and produce all conditions. The dynamic model consisting of wind/FC/UC
better efficiency. A hybrid energy system can be realized using hybrid power generation system used power flow controllers.
different renewable energy sources like solar, wind, tidal, fuel In this work, a novel topology has been developed to account
for voltage fluctuations due to rapid changes in wind speed. The
International Journal of Research in Engineering, Science and Management 517
Volume-3, Issue-4, April-2020
www.ijresm.com | ISSN (Online): 2581-5792

system has effectively suppressed effects because of proposed system, PV system continuously feeds electrolyze to
fluctuations in the equipment side voltage. The system showed produce hydrogen and transfers energy to the load side if
excellent performance under variable wind speed and load possible. When the PV system fails to meet the load demand,
power requirements and can be used in remote areas with no FC system provides power to meet the remaining load.
interconnectivity as a standalone isolated power system or as a Whenever the PV system cannot completely meet load
cogeneration power system. demands, the FC system can be used to meet the load demands.
J. D. Maclay et al. [4] have developed a photovoltaic (PV) Further, if the load demand increases further beyond the limits
powered stand-alone system by integrating photovoltaic of FC capacity, UC can be utilized to meet the overall demand
modules with reversible fuel cells, batteries and ultra- in load. This work focused on the long and short-term storage
capacitors. Also evaluated the proposed system in terms of strategies using FC systems and appropriate design of power
capital costs, sizing techniques, control strategies, etc. controllers and control strategies to develop an autonomous
B. Paul and J. Andrews [5] have examined the techniques in power system. In this work both mathematical and electrical
attaining maximum power transfer between photovoltaic array models were proposed. The entire model was developed in the
by directly coupling with PEM Electrolyzer stack. They MATLAB, Simulink and SimPower Systems environment.
determined an optimal configuration of series- parallel J. Lagorse et al. [9] have developed a hybrid standalone street
connection involving PV panels and PEM cell. Practically, four lighting system that couples three power sources like
PV modules with 75 W capacity was directly coupled with five photovoltaic, battery and fuel cell. The main focus of the work
PEM electrolyzer stacks of 50 W capacity. The study predicted was conducting optimization analysis to identify the cheapest
the energy transfer between the units both theoretically and sizing configuration using algorithms like genetic algorithm
measured the actual energy transfer experimentally. and simplex algorithm. A simulated model was developed and
O. C. Onar et al. [6] have modelled and simulated a hybrid validated using various hybrid configurations.
power system consisting of the combination of wind turbine W. X. Shen [10] performed sizing optimization of solar
(WT), photovoltaic (PV), fuel cell (FC) and ultra-capacitor photovoltaic (PV) array and battery in a standalone solar
(UC) systems for grid-independent applications. In order to photovoltaic system. Using energy efficiency model, the study
achieve maximum control system is used to achieve adequate calculated loss of power supply probability (LPSP) of power
performance for the overall system. In this work, control system system for different sizing combinations of solar array and
has been designed to improve the overall performance and battery. Finally, the study was successful in identifying optimal
deriving maximum available energy from the WT and PV LPSP for the specified load demand.
sources. The system has the provision to store the excess energy J. Hui et al. [11] have developed a Hybrid Wind-Solar
using ultra-capacitor and for the electrolyzer cells to produce Energy System that uses New Multi-Input Rectifier Stage
hydrogen. During the time when the energy produced from WT Topology. In the proposed system configuration, a fusion of
and PV systems becomes inadequate to meet the load demand, Cuk and SEPIC converters was used. The new converter
stored hydrogen was supplied to the FC system to produce eliminated the need for separate input filters to remove
power. The control system ensures that the mismatch in the load frequency harmonics. The proposed converter configuration
demand when fed by FC system is compensated using Ultra- provides excellent support for step up/down operations for PV
capacitor bank. The authors have carried out several and wind input. The fused multi-input rectifier stage enables
simulations by careful designing and sizing of hybrid systems extraction of maximum power from the wind and solar
to function under different loading and meteorological irradiation using Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT). In
conditions. The advantage of this work included design of an this work, adaptive MPPT algorithm was developed for the
energy management strategy that took care of deficiencies of wind system and a standard perturb and observe method was
each of the renewable systems. In this work, modeling and used for the PV system. Simulation were carried out to analyze
simulations were carried out using MATLAB / Simulink and the performance of the proposed system.
SimPower Systems software packages. A. Ganguly et al. [12] have modeled and analyzed the
C. H. Li et al. [7] have analyzed the performance of three performance of a greenhouse-integrated power system
stand-alone photovoltaic (PV) power systems by employing consisting of solar photovoltaic (PV) panels, electrolyzer bank
different energy storage technologies like Fuel Cell (FC) and and Polymer Electrolyte Membrane (PEM) fuel cell stacks.
Battery. The modelling of three hybrid power systems viz. Using an array of solar photovoltaic panels, electric power was
PV/Battery system, PV/FC system, and PV/FC/Battery system. generated and the excess energy after meeting the requirements
The results of performance evaluation indicate that of the greenhouse during peak sunshine hours was used to feed
PV/FC/Battery hybrid system is highly efficient, cost effective the electrolyzer bank to generate hydrogen gas. The hydrogen
and require less PV modules. gas in turn was consumed by the PEM fuel cell stack to provide
M. Uzunoglu et al. [8] have focused on the hybridization of power during the energy deficit hours. The study performed
alternate energy sources by integrating photovoltaic, fuel cell several analysis to predict performance of the integrated system
and ultra-capacitor systems for stand-alone applications. In the under different climatic conditions for the specified location
International Journal of Research in Engineering, Science and Management 518
Volume-3, Issue-4, April-2020
www.ijresm.com | ISSN (Online): 2581-5792

Kolkata, India. The study shows that the proposed hybrid artificial neural network (ANN) and fuzzy logic controllers to
integrated power system could help supplying power to the ensure efficient power flow between hybrid power system and
stand-alone greenhouses in a self-sustained manner. energy storage elements as per the load requirements. The
B. Panahandeh et al. [13] have modelled and simulated a neural network controller was used to derive maximum power
hybrid power system consisting of photo voltaic and wind point (MPP) for different types of photovoltaic (PV) panels
energy systems combined with hydrogen storage. They used based on Levenberg Marquardt learning algorithm. In this
Alternative Power Library (APL) for simulations. The library work, fuzzy logic controller was deployed for distributing
of APL was used to develop models for the simulation of power among the hybrid system and managing the charging and
regenerative power supply systems. The work also discharging current flow for performance optimization. In
demonstrated the efficient integration of hydrogen storage path addition, the fuzzy logic controller was also used to enhance the
in hybrid system operation. performance and life of PEMFC by controlling the stack
R. F. Coelho et al. [14] have developed a grid-connected temperature. In this work, the performance of perturb and
renewable energy system which comprised of five units a 1 kW observe (P&O) algorithm with two different controller
photovoltaic (PV) array and a 1 kW wind turbine (WT). The techniques namely linear PI and non-linear passivity-based
power generated from the units like photovoltaic array, wind controller (PBC) was compared with the proposed MPPT
turbine and fuel cell was processed by independent DC-DC controller system.
converters and fed to a common DC bus. The researchers used N. H. Samrat et al. [18] have proposed a standalone hybrid
a 1.2 kW fuel cell (FC) and a super capacitor bank (SCB) as photovoltaic (PV), Wave energy conversion system with
backup instead of battery units in order to ensure that dc critical energy storage. In the proposed hybrid renewable power
load was supplied continuously. They operated SCB as system, bidirectional buck-boost DC-DC converter (BBDC)
temporary storage device for short term operations. In addition, was used for controlling and maintaining constant dc-link
SCB was used as 120 Hz voltage ripple attenuation. In this voltage. The main controller also helps in accumulating the
work, dc bus power was delivered to the main grid with excess hybrid power using an array of battery banks and
appropriate power factor. The work has discussed on the MPPT supplying this excess power to the system load during the
strategies adopted for PV and WT generators and the control shortage of hybrid power. In this work, a three-phase complex
strategies for the system operation on grid-connected and vector control scheme voltage source inverter (VSI) was
standalone modes. PSIM software was used to model the designed and developed to control the load side voltage in terms
system and validate the results. of the frequency and voltage amplitude. Based on the
Y. Shivrath et al. [15] have developed a hybrid energy system simulation results using Matlab/Simulink, the study proved that
that integrated solar and wind energy generation system. The the hybrid system was capable of working under the variable
proposed hybrid system was optimally designed for a weather and load conditions effectively.
standalone drip irrigation system. The system was designed to M. Sharafi and T. Y. ELMekkawy [19] have proposed
power a submersible pump that consumes 2.4 units of energy particle swarm optimization (PSO) based simulation approach
per day. In this work, the authors have undertaken cost for multi-objective optimization of hybrid renewable energy
optimization of the proposed hybrid system in order to provide systems (HRES) consisting of different systems like wind
guidelines for small scale wind-solar hybrid system turbine, photovoltaic (PV) panels, fuel cell (FC), diesel
manufacturers. generator, batteries, electrolyzer and hydrogen tank. The
A. Menshsari et al. [16] have designed a hybrid energy authors used ε-constraint method in order to reduce the total
system consisting of water storage based hydroelectric power cost of the system, unmet load, and fuel emission in a
system, wind energy and solar energy system. The authors have simultaneous fashion. The study also included stability analysis
identified and assessed the important parameters required for to analyses the sensibility of different parameters in the
optimal performance of the proposed power system in order to developed model. The proposed PSO based multi-objective
achieve economical operation. They used ant colony algorithm optimization approach was computationally efficient and
for realizing optimality and for minimization of operating and simple.
execution costs. The simulation results has revealed the J. K. Shiau et al. [20] have proposed a fuzzy-logic-based
successful design and deployment of a small renewable voltage-regulated solar power maximum power point tracking
hydroelectric, wind and solar resources based on hybrid (MPPT) system for hybrid power systems. The hybrid system
hydrogen storage that provides reliable load supply and considered in the study was a solar voltaic power system and
improved system reliability throughout the year. battery system. They optimized the design of the hybrid power
E. M. Natsheh [17] have proposed a novel adaptive scheme system in such a way that the solar photovoltaic power system
for energy management of hybrid power systems comprising of feeds power to the electric motor continuously at a
solar PV array, wind turbine, battery storage, and proton predetermined level when it has sufficient power. However,
exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC). The focus of this work when the solar voltaic power was inadequate, maximum power
was on designing an effective management strategy based on point (MPP) was activated in the proposed work so that solar
International Journal of Research in Engineering, Science and Management 519
Volume-3, Issue-4, April-2020
www.ijresm.com | ISSN (Online): 2581-5792

voltaic system extracts maximum power output. In addition, power plant using wind turbine system and photovoltaic
battery backup was used to compensate for the inadequacy in technology, integrated with an energy storage system. The
the power. The MPP technique developed in the study was a capacity of the hybrid plant was 200 kW (190 kW by
variant of the incremental conductance MPP condition in which photovoltaic and 10 kW by wind turbine). The capacity of the
the voltage-regulated MPPT system was designed as a feedback energy storage capacity was 400 kWh. They conceived the
control system. The purposed MPP technique based on fuzzy hybrid renewable power generation system with the mission to
controller required MPP condition and voltage regulation guarantee power minimum fluctuations and reduce amounts
requirements as the system inputs. Entire system was designed spend on electricity purchases. They also proposed a thermo-
and simulated using MATLAB/SIMULINK model. In addition, economic simulation model using TRNSYS environment for
a piecewise linear electric circuit simulation (PLECS) tool for determining the best system configuration and increasing the
controlling the dc motor velocity was developed to verify the economic profitability by considering the time-dependent
voltage-regulated solar power MPPT system. tariffs applied to the electricity exchanged with the grid and the
Y. Varetsky et al. [21] have proposed a hybrid renewable possibility to store electricity.
energy system for micro grid applications using wind turbine,
photovoltaic generator and energy storage system. In the 4. Conclusion
proposed system, statistic indices of wind speed and solar In this paper, a detailed review of the existing hybrid micro-
irradiation data was used to simulate power flow in the system. grid renewable energy system is presented. The review has
The climate characteristics were implemented in the clearly shown that the majority of the existing hybrid grid
mathematical model using the statistic indices. The simulation systems are developed by integrating two or three renewable
of the proposed model show that the model can be used as a tool power resources like wind/solar, solar/fuel cell, etc. This has
for sizing components of the hybrid renewable energy system lead to design and develop an HRES consisting of a maximum
and predicting the energy management in the chosen sites. number of renewable sources like solar, wind, fuel cell, ultra-
A. U. Moon and R. R. Shaha [22] have developed a novel capacitor, and battery storage into a single DC network.
design of the front-end rectifier for hybrid renewable energy Besides, the application of soft computing techniques like fuzzy
system which included wind and photovoltaic systems. The logic controller systems (FLCS) can be used to enhance the
proposed model used Cuk-SEPIC fused converter which performance of renewable energy systems like solar
eliminated the need for input filters to filter out high frequency photovoltaic energy systems by optimizing the performance of
harmonics components. In addition, the fused multi-input maximum power point tracking capability. This review is a part
rectifier stage enhances maximum extraction of power from of a large work on the design of a micro-grid connected hybrid
solar and wind energy sources using Maximum Power Point renewable energy generation system using different
Tracking (MPPT) technique. The study used an adaptive MPPT components like solar arrays, wind energy, fuel cells, capacitor
algorithm for the wind energy system and a standard perturb bank, etc.
and observe method for the PV system.
S. S. Martin et al. [23] have modeled, simulated and References
developed control strategy for a hybrid power system (HPS) [1] T. F. El-Shatter, M. N. Eskandar, and M. T. El-Hagry, “Hybrid PV/fuel
consisting of wind energy conversion system (WECS), solar cell system design and simulation”, Renewable Energy, vol. 27, no. 3, pp.
photovoltaic system (SPV) and biodiesel generator (BDG) with 479-485, July, 2002.
capacity of 400 W along with storage battery backup of 200 [2] D. Shapiro, J. Duffy, M, Kimble, and M. Pien, “Solar-powered
regenerative PEM electrolyzer/fuel cell system”, Solar Energy, vol. 79,
Ah/24 V. They designed hybrid power system using wind no. 5, pp. 544-550, Jan. 2005.
turbine (Capacity: 300 W), photovoltaic panels (Capacity: 50 [3] O. C. Onar, M. Uzunoglu, and M. S. Alam “Dynamic modeling, design
W), permanent magnet synchronous generator (PMSG), power and simulation of a wind/fuel cell/ultra-capacitor-based hybrid power
generation system”, Journal of Power Sources, vol. 161, no. 1, pp. 707-
converters and maximum power point tracking (MPPT) 722, May 2006.
controllers. In the proposed work, Perturb and observe (P&O) [4] J. D. Maclay, J. Brouwer, J and G. S. Samuelsen, “Dynamic modeling of
algorithm was applied for deriving maximum power from PV hybrid energy storage systems coupled to photovoltaic generation in
residential applications”, Journal of Power Sources, vol. 163, no. 2, pp.
and Tip speed ratio (TSR) controller was used for the WECS. 916-925, Feb. 2007.
The performance of the proposed HPS was evaluated under [5] B. Paul and J. Andrews, “Optimal coupling of PV arrays to PEM
different conditions by varying wind speed and solar radiations. electrolysers in solar–hydrogen systems for remote area power supply”,
International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 490-498,
In the proposed system, biodiesel generator was operated only 2008.
when the charge of the battery backup goes below 45%. A [6] O. C. Onar, M. Uzunoglu, and M. S. Alam, “Modeling, control and
Hysteresis technique was employed for controlling biodiesel simulation of an autonomous wind turbine/photovoltaic/fuel cell/ultra-
capacitor hybrid power system”, Journal of Power Sources, vol. 185, no.
generator startup using variation of the battery storage. Several 2, pp. 1273-1283, Sept. 2008.
simulation studies were carried out in order to prove the power [7] C. H. Li, H. J. Zhu, G. Y. Cao, S. Sui and M. R. Hu, “Dynamic modeling
reliability under all conditions using renewable energy systems. and sizing optimization of stand-alone photovoltaic power systems using
A. Buonomano et al. [24] have proposed a hybrid renewable hybrid energy storage technology”, Renewable energy, vol. 34, no. 3, pp.
815-826, June. 2009.
International Journal of Research in Engineering, Science and Management 520
Volume-3, Issue-4, April-2020
www.ijresm.com | ISSN (Online): 2581-5792
[8] M. Uzunoglu, O. C. Onar, and M. S. Alam, “Modeling, control and evaluation of reliability index of system using ant colony algorithm”,
simulation of a PV/FC/UC based hybrid power generation system for International Research Journal of Applied and Basic Science, vol. 4, no.
stand-alone applications”, Renewable Energy, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 509-520, 11, pp. 3582-3600, 2013.
Aug. 2009. [17] E. M. Natsheh, “Hybrid power systems energy management based on
[9] J. Lagorse, D. Paire, and A. Miraoui, “Sizing optimization of a stand- Artificial Intelligence”, Ph.D. dissertation, Dept. Elect. Eng., Manchester
alone street lighting system powered by a hybrid system using fuel cell, Metropolitan University, 2013.
PV and battery”, Renewable Energy, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 683-691, 2009. [18] N. H. Samrat, N. B. Ahmad, I. A. Choudhury and Z. B. Taha, “Modeling,
[10]W. X. Shen, “Optimally sizing of solar array and battery in a standalone control, and simulation of battery storage photovoltaic-wave energy
photovoltaic system in Malaysia”, Renewable Energy, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. hybrid renewable power generation systems for island electrification in
348-352, 2009. Malaysia”, The Scientific World Journal, 2014.
[11] J. Hui, A. Bakhshai and P. K. Jain, “A hybrid wind-solar energy system: [19] M. Sharafi and T. Y. ELMekkawy, “Multi-objective optimal design of
A new rectifier stage topology”, in Proc. IEEE Annual Applied Power hybrid renewable energy systems using PSO-simulation based approach”,
Electronics Conference and Exposition (APEC), 2010, pp. 155-161. Renewable Energy, vol. 68, pp. 67-79, 2014.
[12] A. Ganguly, D. Misra and S. Ghosh, “Modeling and analysis of solar [20] J. K. Shiau, Y. C. Wei and M. Y. Lee, “Fuzzy controller for a voltage-
photovoltaic-electrolyzer-fuel cell hybrid power system integrated with a regulated solar-powered MPPT system for hybrid power system
floriculture greenhouse”, Energy and Buildings, vol. 42, no. 11, pp. 2036- applications”, Energies, vol. 8, no. 5, pp. 3292-3312, 2015.
2043, 2010. [21] Y. Varetsky and Z. Hanzelka, “Modeling Hybrid Renewable Energy
[13] B. Panahandeh, J. Bard, A. Outzourhit and D. Zejli, “Simulation of PV– System for Micro Grid”, in Proc. of International Conference on
Wind-hybrid systems combined with hydrogen storage for rural Renewable Energies and Power Quality, vol. 1, no. 13, 2015, pp. 429–
electrification”, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, vol. 36, no. 432.
6, pp. 4185-4197, 2011. [22] A. U. Moon and R. R. Shaha, “Integration of Wind Solar Hybrid &
[14] R. F. Coelho, L. Schimtz and D. C. Martins, “Grid-connected PV-wind- Challenges to Grid Connectivity & It’s Mitigation”, Journal of Network
fuel cell hybrid system employing a supercapacitor bank as storage device Communications and Emerging Technologies (JNCET), vol. 6, no. 8,
2016.
to supply a critical DC load”, in Proc. of 33rd International
[23] S. S. Martin, A. Chebak, A, A. El Ouafi and M. Mabrouki, “Modeling and
Telecommunications Energy Conference (INTELEC), 2011, pp. 1-10.
simulation of hybrid power system integrating wind, solar, biodiesel
[15] Y. Shivrath, P. B. Narayana, S. Thirumalasetty and D. E. L. Narsaiah,
energies and storage battery”, in Proc. IEEE International Renewable and
“Design & integration of wind-solar hybrid energy system for drip
Sustainable Energy Conference (IRSEC), 2016, pp. 457-463.
irrigation pumping application”, International Journal of Modern
[24] A. Buonomano, F. Calise, M. D. d’Accadia and M. Vicidomini, “A hybrid
Engineering Research (IJMER), vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 2947-2950, 2012.
renewable system based on wind and solar energy coupled with an
[16] A. Menshsari, M. Ghiamy, M. M. M. Mousavi and H. A. Bagal, “Optimal
electrical storage: Dynamic simulation and economic assessment”,
design of hybrid water-wind-solar system based on hydrogen storage and
Energy, vol. 155, pp. 174-189, 2018.

You might also like