You are on page 1of 11

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/251679596

Floods and flood management in Pakistan

Article  in  Physics and Chemistry of the Earth Parts A/B/C · December 2012


DOI: 10.1016/j.pce.2011.08.014

CITATIONS READS

122 13,038

2 authors:

Muhammad Atiq Ur Rehman Tariq Nick van de Giesen


Victoria University Melbourne Delft University of Technology
29 PUBLICATIONS   206 CITATIONS    486 PUBLICATIONS   10,133 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Ensemble Forecast for Control of Water Systems View project

FloodCitiSense: Early warning service for urban pluvial floods for and by citizens and city authorities View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Muhammad Atiq Ur Rehman Tariq on 21 January 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect

Physics and Chemistry of the Earth


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pce

Floods and flood management in Pakistan


Muhammad Atiq Ur Rehman Tariq ⇑, Nick van de Giesen
Water Resources Management Section, Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Flooding is the most devastating natural hazard in Pakistan and the recent flooding has demonstrated its
Available online 3 September 2011 severeness. Floods are common throughout the country. However, their characteristics differ from region
to region. Flooding behavior of the major basins and flood management at the national level are investi-
Keywords: gated in this article. Monsoon rainfalls are the main source of floods in the Indus Basin, while Mediter-
Flood management ranean Waves and Cyclones, which are generated over the Arabian Sea, induce flooding in the Kharan
Pakistan Basin and the Makran Coastal Area. Fluvial floods in the Indus Basin have caused major economic losses.
Indus Basin
Pakistan’s government has spent vast resources on relief operations and flood works since the country
Kharan Basin
Makran Coastal Area
came into existence in 1947. A number of provincial and federal acts, ordinances, accords, and treaties
shape the national flood policy. Institutional setup for flood hazard and crisis management has evolved
over the years. Nevertheless, data show no major reduction in the flood-to-damage ratio. The inter-link-
age of structural and non-structural measures and their combined efficiency must be analyzed and opti-
mized for more effective flood management.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction The hydrology of floods is linked to weather and climate as well


as to physiographic features (Shah and Gabriel, 2002). A brief over-
In August 2010, Pakistan suffered one of the most severe floods view of related geographical features is provided to interpret the
in its history. Floods are the most frequently occurring and damag- flooding characteristics. The country can be divided into three
ing natural hazards in the country. Of all population who are af- physiographical regions (Framji and Mahajan, 1969):
fected by natural hazards, 90% are subjected to flooding (Haider,
2006). In the recent flooding, almost 1800 persons died and finan- (i) Mountains in the north and north-west 241,647 km2.
cial damages were in the range of tens of billions US dollars. (ii) Plateau of Baluchistan in the south-west 242,683 km2.
According to available official statistics, about 8000 people lost (iii) Indus River plains 311,766 km2.
their lives and economical losses amounted to approximately $10
billion between independence in 1947 and the 2010 flooding (Baig, The spatial variability of rainfall throughout the country is high.
2008). These estimates are carried out at the local administration Of the total area, 59.3% can be classified as rangeland, which re-
level and uncertainty in these values is unknown. Although no ma- ceives less than 200 mm annual rainfall (Umrani, 2001; ISDR,
jor flood had occurred since 1995, the devastating flooding in 2010 2005). In the north of the country, the Himalaya Range receives an-
demonstrated the continuous presence of flood risks. nual rainfall between 760 mm and 1270 mm (ISDR, 2005) and con-
The nature of flooding varies according to geography. Fluvial tributes almost 72% of the mean annual flow in the Indus River
floods in the Indus plain prove most devastating as the terrain is flat, System (WWF, 2010). These rainfall data are based on the national
densely populated, and economically developed. Hill torrents (flash meteorological network. The spatial distribution of stations over
flooding) are the second most destructive type of flood. Hill torrents the country is not uniform. Stations in developed areas and mete-
threaten large areas of the country (Fig. 1) and claim human lives orologically important locations generally comply with World
most frequently. Floods due to cyclones and intensive localized rain Meteorological Organization (WMO) standards. Southern Punjab,
are dominant at other locations. Exceptionally high floods have also Baluchistan, and northern Sindh receive the lowest amounts of
occurred due to the breaching of some of the small dams, e.g. the Sha- rain. Rainfall increases again towards the coast. Three types of
di Kor dam in Pasni, which breached on February 11, 2005, washing weather systems influence the precipitation in catchments which
away more than 135 people (IFRC, 2005; Javed and Baig, 2005). produce floods in Pakistan. These weather systems are

(i) Monsoon depressions originating from the Bay of Bengal


⇑ Corresponding author. Address: Room 4.91, Building of Civil Engineering and (the most important system).
Geosciences, Stevinweg 1, 2628CN, Delft, The Netherlands.
(ii) Westerly waves coming from the Mediterranean Sea (Winter
E-mail addresses: Atiq.Tariq@yahoo.com (M.A.U.R. Tariq), N.C.vandeGiesen@
rains).
TUDelft.NL (N. van de Giesen).

1474-7065/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pce.2011.08.014
12 M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

Nomenclature

D.G. Khan Dera Ghazi Khan PKR Pakistani Rupee (currency unit)
EIRR Economic Internal Rate of Return $ United States Dollar
FEWS Flood Early Warning System WAPDA Water And Power Development Authority
FFC Federal Flood Commission WMO World Meteorological Organization
FPSP Flood Protection Sector Project
NADP Normal Annual Development Plan Conversion rate
NESPak National Engineering Services Pakistan 1$ 80 Pakistani Rupees
NWFP North West Frontier Province

(iii) Seasonal lows from the Arabian Sea (Cyclones). flow of 175 km3/yr. Table 1 presents a brief overview of the major
rivers in the Indus Basin.
The country has four distinct climate seasons. April, May, and Seasonally, flows fluctuate from 3000 m3/s to 34,000 m3/s
June are extremely hot and dry months. July, August, and Septem- (FFC, 2009). Annual river flows at rim stations (first gauging sta-
ber are hot and humid with intense heat and heavy but scattered tion after a river enters into Pakistan) fluctuate between
rainfall (monsoon). The cool and dry period starts in October and 120 km3/yr and 230 km3/yr (MoWP, 2002b). Rainfall in the Indus
continues through November. December, January, and February Basin occurs during the monsoon and cold weather seasons, but
are the coldest months of the year. severe floods only occur in the monsoon season. High flows are
Hydrologically, the country can be divided into three major experienced in the summer due to the increased rate of snow-
units: Indus Basin, Kharan Basin, and Makran Coastal drainage melts and monsoon rainfalls. About 82% of the annual water
area. Flooding characteristics of these basins vary greatly and re- flows during the summer months (MoWP, 2002c). In this period,
quire in-depth understanding. heavy rainfall in the upper catchments located across the border
in Kashmir (Indian) often causes floods. Sometimes heavy
showers occur in areas just within Pakistan. As a consequence,
2. Fluvial floods in the Indus Basin the rivers expand into their entire floodplains. The flooding
behavior of the major rivers differs according to catchment char-
The total watershed area of the Indus is 944,000 km2, 60% of acteristics and the types of installed river training facilities. In
which lies in Pakistan (MoE, 2003). The Indus, with its major trib- low elevation catchments (Sutlej, Ravi, and Jhelum), maximum
utaries Jhelum, Chenab, Sutlej, and Ravi, has an average annual snowmelt occurs in April–June and does not coincide with the

Fig. 1. Map of Pakistan showing main hydrological and geopolitical features.


M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20 13

Table 1
Main features of the Indus River System. Sources: WAPDA annual report 2000, FPSP-II/C report 2008, and FFC annual report 2008.

Sutlej Ravi Chenab Jhelum Indus


a a
Origin Tibet HP HP Kashmir Tibet
Discharge to Chenab Chenab Indus Chenab Arabian Sea
Length (km) 1500 900 1240 820 3200
Basin area (km2) 122,000 40,000 67,500 63,500 727,000
Avg. annual flow (km3/yr) 3.05 4.46 25.17 24.33 83.15
Dams in India Bhakra, Pongb Thein Salal, Baglihar – –
Dams in Pakistan – – – Mangla Tarbela
No. of barrages 2 2 5 1 6
a
Himachal Pradesh, India.
b
Pong Dam on the Beas River (Major tributary of the Sutlej River).

Fig. 2. Annual peak flow data of main rivers (1921–2010).

monsoon rains (July through September). In high altitude catch- In the upper and mid reaches of the Indus Basin, it is generally
ments (Indus and Chenab), snowmelt contributes significantly the tributaries like the Jhelum and the Chenab rivers that cause
to flood flows. Maximum snowmelt in the Indus and Chenab ba- flooding rather than the Indus River itself. Since these rivers are
sins is experienced in July and floods of high magnitude are gen- also snow-fed, an early monsoon may combine with peak snow-
erated due to monsoon rainfalls. The flood peaks of the different melt runoff to exacerbate flooding. Generally, heavy rainfalls are
rivers usually do not coincide. However, when they do coincide, limited to the Chenab, Jhelum, Ravi, and Sutlej River catchments.
widespread flooding occurs. Occasionally, low atmospheric pressure crosses further north into
Floods in the Indus and Jhelum basins are largely controlled the Indus River catchment like in the recent case of flooding.
by the Tarbela and Mangla dams. There is almost no control Intense rainfall produced exceptionally high flood peaks, which re-
(in Pakistan) over the Chenab, Ravi, and Sutlej rivers, which re- sulted in flash flooding in North West Frontier Province (NWFP,
sults in flooding problems in monsoon season. The Chenab has now Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa) and fluvial flooding in Punjab and
historically given rise to the most floods (Fig. 2) because of the Sindh provinces. Fluvial flooding caused losses by inundating large
lack of any controlling structures and large flows induced by agricultural and residential areas, by damaging lifelines and pow-
the combination of rain and snowmelt. India owns the exclusive erhouses, and by eroding land along the riverbanks.
water rights of the Ravi and Sutlej rivers under the Indus Water The nature of fluvial floods in the upper Indus Plain differs from
Treaty (1960). Because of that, there is practically very little flow that of the lower Indus Plain. In the upper Indus, the bed level is
in these rivers (Haq and Nasir, 2003). Average annual flows ob- lower than the adjoining lands. When a flood occurs, floodwater
served at the rim stations are about 3.15 km3/yr in the Ravi Riv- spilling over the riverbanks generally returns to the rivers in the
er and 0.02 km3/yr in the Sutlej River (Mir et al., 2010). Floods of upper part of the Indus Basin. However, in the lower part of the In-
higher intensity are observed on the Ravi River after the Treaty. dus in Sindh province, spills do not return to the river. This lack of
According to annual peak flows data at the Balloki Barrage, of return flow extends the duration of inundation, resulting in larger
the seven most severe floods on the Ravi River (1922–2004), damages. Although flood protection by embankments has been
six floods occurred after effectuation of this treaty in 1973. provided along almost the entire length in Sindh province and at
The reason behind this increase is not known and should be sub- many locations in the upper areas, bund breaches can still occur
ject of further study. The decreasing width of these rivers and (Haq and Nasir, 2003; Khan, 2007b; FFC, 2009). Such breaches of-
vanishing flows encourage encroachments for residential and ten cause greater damage than would have occurred without
industrial purposes, but an episode of severe flood may wipe bunds because of their unexpected nature and intensification of
out these developments. land use following the provision of flood protection.
14 M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

3. Flash floods in the Indus and Kharan basins caused by Westerly waves during the winter months. The river
beds are dry for most of the year. Intense flash floods do occur
Flash floods typically hit the hilly areas of NWFP, Baluchistan, but are infrequent. Some bunds have been constructed to serve
Kashmir, and Punjab. Kashmir and NWFP receive high average an- as flood diversion or abatement measures. During a severe flood,
nual rainfall, whereas the steep and barren terrain of Baluchistan most of the embankments and flood walls constructed to protect
and Dera Ghazi Khan (D.G. Khan) watersheds typically produce se- orchards or abadies (residential areas) are washed away. As flash
vere flash floods, causing damage to infrastructure, settlements, floods of high intensity are rare, people are not prepared for disas-
and loss of human and animal lives. Flash flooding in the Indus Ba- ter responses, which results in more destruction and losses.
sin, is confined to the tributaries of the Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab Pishin Lora Basin is a major river basin in Baluchistan
rivers. Most areas in NWFP, Kashmir, and Baluchistan and some (16,928 km2 with 10 sub-basins) spread over five districts with a
areas in Punjab endure flash floods. Flash floods are relatively total population of about 1.2 million (ADB, 2008). As this basin cov-
lethal, e.g., more than 230 people died due to flash floods in the ers the area with Baluchistan’s main economic activities and high
Pothohar Plateau (Islamabad, Rawalpindi, and NWFP areas) in population concentration, the disturbance due to floods is high.
2001 (IFRC, 2002). According to flood loss data of the Federal Flood
Commission (FFC), about 60% of the casualties were reported in 4. Floods due to cyclones in Makran Coastal Area
NWFP during the 2010 flood due to flash flooding. Consolidated
economic loss and casualty data has not been compiled nationwide The coastal area of Pakistan stretches over a length of 1046 km
and very little flood discharge data for hill torrents is available. It is between 62°E and 68°E (Rehman and Bhattarai, 2005). Makran in
extremely difficult to measure such peak flows with conventional the south of Baluchistan is a semi-desert coastal strip with an area
methods due to their short duration and their unpredictability. of 123,025 km2 and a length of 750 km along the Arabian Sea (Shah
Floods in the NWFP are mainly hill torrents due to steep bed and Gabriel, 2002). The region is sparsely populated, with much of
slopes, which greatly increase flood velocity and severely erode the population being concentrated in small ports and fishing vil-
the banks. To save the areas from erosion, spurs have been con- lages. Away from the coast, the narrow coastal plain rises very rap-
structed by the provincial government with the funds provided idly into several mountain ranges. The entire length of the
by the federal government. Fluvial floods in NWFP are limited to coastline is subjected to tropical cyclones. The Makran Coastal Ba-
Nowshera and some parts of Charsadda, Peshawar (by the Kabul sin includes the Dasht, Hingol, and Porali rivers, which discharge
River), and Dera Ismail Khan (by the Indus River). In the rest of individually into the Arabian Sea (MoWP, 2002a) with an average
NWFP, flash flooding is a common disaster along with landslides annual flow of 3.5 km3/yr. The climate is dry with very little rainfall
and torrential rains (PMD, 2009). Some dikes have been provided and can be classified as arid with warm summers and mild winters.
for flood diversion or abatement and to minimize the effects of tor- The monsoon rainfall increases with the increase in longitude
rential rains and consequent floods. Other severe flash flooding oc- along the coastline, whereas winter rainfall decreases with the in-
curs in Dera Ismail Khan along the Indus. These hill torrents have crease in longitude. The average annual rainfall is approximately
an average annual flow of about 1 km3/yr (MoWP, 2002a). A bat- 150 mm or even less along the Makran Coast.
tery of spurs has been constructed on the right bank of the Indus Floods in coastal areas are associated with cyclones and high
River (FFC, 2009). Large numbers of spurs and a few embankments tides. The Makran Coastal Areas have occasionally been hit by se-
have been constructed along the Swat, Kurrum, and Kabul rivers vere cyclones. Cyclones generated in the Arabian Sea produce tor-
and their tributaries. rential rains throughout the region. One cyclone is expected per
The area of the Pothohar plateau (in north Punjab) often expe- year in the Arabian Sea. About 75% of these cyclones end up at
riences flash flooding. Islamabad and Rawalpindi have endured the Omani coast on the western Arabian Sea and the remaining
flash floods from the Nullah Lai, which nearly flows through the 25% curve clockwise and cross the coast near the Rann of Kutch
centers of both cities. The low-lying areas in Rawalpindi along (MoE, 2003). No severe tidal floods have been recorded so far.
the Nullah Lai are even affected by small floods. Extreme floods The coastal areas of Sindh are the most vulnerable and most ex-
in Nullah Lai were observed in 1981, 1988, 1997, and 2001 (Kamal, posed to cyclones. The period from 1971 to 2001 saw 14 cyclones
2004). The hill torrents generated in Suleiman Ranges (Baluchistan (ISDR, 2005). One severe cyclone in 1997 impacted Makran (Gawa-
and Afghanistan) hit the districts of D.G. Khan, Layyah, and Rajan- dar and Kech) and then crossed into the Kharan Basin up to the
pur in Punjab province. As the catchment area that generates tor- Chaghai and Dalbadin districts. The Nihang and Kech rivers caused
rents is quite far away from the above mentioned districts, widespread flooding in a region approximating 8000 km2 (PMD,
sometimes, weather conditions in the catchment area and affected 2009). The recent floods due to two consecutive cyclones caused
areas are very different. In such cases, these torrents appear with- tremendous damage. Cyclone Gonu struck the coast on June 4,
out any weather symptom or warning sign. D.G. Khan hill torrents 2007 and inflicted damage in the Sur Bandar area of Gawadar
have an average annual flow of 1 km3/yr (MoWP, 2002a). These (Khan, 2007a). Cyclone Yemyin on June 26, 2007 is among the
floods have destroyed bridges, settlements, and agricultural land worst recorded so far. It affected 2.5 million people and made
along riverbanks and have deposited huge amounts of debris into 250,000 homeless (UNESCO, 2007). The cyclone hit the catchment
the rivers. area of the Mirani Dam (Dasht River). Substantial rainfall occurred
All of Baluchistan Province, with its barren and steep land, is during the storm, causing serious flooding in the Dasht River. The
subject to hill torrents. The Nari, Kaha, and Gaj rivers are part of Pakistan Meteorological Department data showed rainfall of
the Indus drainage system located in the north-eastern edges of 172 mm over the storm period (2 days) at Turbat Airport in Baluch-
the province. Contrary to the rest of Baluchistan, the Kachi area istan. The rainfall event was the highest rainfall recorded in the last
is highly fertile and needs floods for irrigation (Jarrige, 1997). 90 years (NDMA, 2007). The storm moved from east to west, mov-
Kharan Basin (within Pakistan) covers an area of 121,860 km2 ing from the Kech River’s catchment to the Nihing River’s catch-
and includes part of the Kharan Desert and Pishin Basin in west ment, the two main tributaries of Dasht River. As mentioned
Baluchistan. Average annual rainfall throughout the desert is less earlier, intense cyclones do not occur often, but they can cause
than 100 mm (Khosa, 2000) and average inland drainage is about large-scale damage and cyclone Yemyin was one such example.
1 km3/yr (Shah and Gabriel, 2002; UNITAR, 2004). The flow regime This cyclone caused flash flooding in various districts of the
in the rivers is typified by spring runoff and occasional flash floods Baluchistan and Sindh provinces.
M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20 15

5. Flood management arrangements rehabilitation process are used in addition to the above-mentioned
expenditures.
After independence, devastating floods occurred in 1950, 1956, According to the planning and approval criteria of the FFC, new
and 1957. Due to limited resources and institutional arrangements, flood projects are executed under two categories: either need-
no comprehensive flood management plan was initiated at the na- based measures to address local flood problems or integrated mea-
tional level. Until 1976, flood protection and management was the sures under the NFPP. Priorities are given to those measures which
sole responsibility of provincial governments. This changed after serve areas of high economic losses, human suffering, and socially
the annihilating floods of 1973, which claimed 474 lives and and economically vulnerable groups. Since the NFPP plans are
caused damages of 160 billion Pakistani Rupees (PKR) (approxi- mostly financed through loans from the Asian Development Bank,
mately $2 billion) (FFC, 2009). A unified countrywide approach the measures are not sanctioned unless they have an economic
was initiated to manage the flood problem. As a result, a long-term internal rate of return (EIRR) of at least 12% (FFC, 2009) in compli-
principal plan was prepared in 1978 at the national level. The pres- ance with bank criteria. The EIRR of a project can be defined as the
ent flood management arrangements can be discussed under three average annual effective compounded return rate of investments.
aspects: EIRR serves to enable a direct comparison of investments and ben-
efits, which typically have a different temporal distribution. EIRR is
1. Flood management measures. very common indicator in a cost-benefit analysis. Protection stan-
2. Legislative framework. dards adopted in Pakistan are 50-years for flood protection struc-
3. Institutional setup. tures and 100-years for vital river training structures and bridges
(Halcrow et al., 2001). The planning and approval criteria are the
same throughout the country, but there are different practices lo-
5.1. Flood management measures cally in design, construction, and maintenance of bunds, studs,
and spurs.
The flood management measures in Pakistan are mainly com-
prised of flood protection embankments, spurs, studs, and ad- 5.1.1. Structural measures
vanced flood-forecasting techniques. Various flood protection Numerous efforts have been made in the past to train rivers and
structures were built by the provincial governments to solve local protect the adjoining areas from river erosion and flood damages,
flood problems (Baig, 2008). Since the establishment of FFC in but large-scale variations in river discharge and sediment concen-
1977, flood management has been practiced according to an inte- trations have led to eroding river plains. Traditionally, flood man-
grated approach at the national level. A long-term National Flood agement has relied heavily on the provision of structural
Protection Plan (NFPP) was prepared in 1978. The NFPP contained measures for flood containment. Structural measures are em-
phased implementation in the form of sub-plans known as the ployed on a large-scale and include construction of embankments,
‘‘ten-year National Flood Protection Plans’’ (NFPPs). An estimated spurs, dikes, gabion walls, floodwalls, dispersions, diversion struc-
expenditure of over PKR 17.8 billion (approximately $220 million) tures, delay action dams, bypass-structures, and channelization of
has been spent on flood works, rescue and relief not included, floodwaters. River training has mainly been executed with the help
under different programs since 1977 (FFC, 2009). A number of of embankments and spurs. Embankments are constructed wher-
flood protection works have been completed and some are still ever over-bank flooding is the major problem and spurs are con-
in the implementation phase. The provinces receive financial and structed to counter land erosion and regulate the river’s main
technical support provided by the FFC to address the flooding course. About 6719 km of embankments have been constructed
problem. along major rivers and their tributaries. In addition, more than
So far, three NFPPs have been executed covering periods from 1375 spurs have been constructed to protect these embankments
1978 to 1987 (NFPP-I), 1988 to 1997 (NFPP-II), and 1998 to 2007 (FFC, 2009). Details of embankments and spurs at provincial and
(NFPP-III). Under NFPP-I, 350 flood protection schemes (individual national levels are provided in Table 2. Economical and efficient
structure repaired or constructed) were implemented at a cost of measures have been implemented based on their suitability for lo-
PKR 1.73 billion (approximately $22 million) (Shaikh, 2008). cal conditions. For the most part, earthen dikes have been con-
NFPP-II was carried out under two sub-projects, namely, the Nor- structed along the main rivers.
mal Annual Development Plan (NADP) and the Flood Protection Flood protection bunds have generally been constructed either
Sector Project-I (FPSP-I). Under FPSP-I, 170 schemes (costing PKR to protect headworks, irrigation structures, or certain towns and
2541 million, approximately $32 million) have been completed un- villages. Controlled breaching of embankments is also practiced
der the NADP and 257 schemes (costing PKR 4860 million, approx- to avoid unwanted breach. In the upper Indus Basin, the main riv-
imately $61 million) have been executed. Three sub-projects were ers flow in a south-west direction. The general slope is southwards,
carried out under NFPP-III (1998–2007). 101 schemes (costing PKR meaning that most of the canals stem from the left banks of the riv-
4165 million, approximately $52 million) under FPSP-II, 362 ers. Breaching is usually produced on the right banks to avoid dev-
schemes (costing PKR 3415 million, approximately $43 million) astation, as most of the development is also on the left side where
under the NADP and development of a flood forecasting and warn- the canal irrigation system is located. A double line of flood
ing system for Lai Nullah in Islamabad/Rawalpindi (PKR 348 mil- embankments have been constructed along (almost) both banks
lion, approximately $4.5 million) have been completed for this of the Indus in Sindh province stretching from the Guddu Barrage
plan (FFC, 2009). These plans have been financed by the govern-
Table 2
ment and some donor agencies. The execution of the flood protec-
Details of embankments and spurs at the provincial and national levels. Sources: FFC
tion works is the responsibility of the provincial agencies, while annual report 2008.
decision making and control of funds lie with the federal govern-
Province Embankments (km) Spurs (No.)
ment. The approving authority for each single sub-project is also
the federal government. About PKR 17.8 billion (unadjusted, Punjab 3334 494
Sindh 2422 46
approximately $222 million) has been spent on flood management
NWFP 361 185
measures since 1977 and about PKR 30 billion (approximately Baluchistan 602 650
$375 million) is planned for NFPP-IV (2008–2017) (Shaikh, 2008;
Total in Pakistan 6719 1375
FFC, 2009). Financial resources, employed in rescue, relief, and
16 M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

Fig. 3. Locations of telemetric gages, HF radios, weather radars, and river structures.

to a few kilometers before the river forms its delta. The embank- water management practices in the watershed and upstream oper-
ments have been further compartmentalized to contain ations. Being a low riparian country, flood management options are
inundation. limited and flood prediction is complicated in Pakistan. Therefore,
Floods in the upper reaches of the Indus and Jhelum rivers have main emphases have been put on precise flood forecasting and an
been attenuated since the construction of the Mangla and Tarbela early warning system. Flood warning is mainly the responsibility of
dams in 1967 and 1974, respectively. Though the storage capaci- the Flood Forecasting Division of Pakistan Meteorological Depart-
ties of these dams are decreasing due to sedimentation, they still ment but the Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA)
play an important role in flood management. The useful lives of also contributes to improve the ability to forecast. The flood early
these dams are expected to expire in 2050 and 2060 for Mangla warning system was initiated in 1975 when a real-time VHF telem-
and Tarbela dams respectively (MoWP, 2002c; Haq and Abbas, etry system was introduced for hydrological data collection from
2008; Hashmi et al., 2009). Their effectiveness in flood control is 16 river gauges and 24 rain gauges (Fig. 3) (NESPak, 2008). A total
subject to their storage capacities, adopted reservoir operation of about 40 stations were established at all rim stations and within
practices, and intensities of floods. Although these dams are multi- the Mangla Dam catchment area. The number was gradually re-
purpose, their prime function is to store water for irrigation and duced to about 20 due to maintenance problems. The Flood Early
power generation. The operation planning of these dams has not Warning System (FEWS) was updated under FPSP-II in 1998 in
yet been optimized to control floods downstream. cooperation with the NESPak-Deltares Consortium. FEWS is a
The Mirani Dam was constructed in 2006 on the Dasht River for physically-based hydrodynamic model using real-time data. The
the storage of hill torrent water for irrigation purposes in Baluch- meteor-burst based communication system was integrated into
istan. It enabled irrigation supplies on both sides of the river and the FEWS through the WAPDA’s ‘‘Surface Water Hydrology Project’’
minimized flood damages in the floodplain (Majeed and Khan, in 1998. About 22 high frequency radio sets were installed to serve
2008). About 12 sub-projects of protecting bunds and delay action as a double support for automatic gauging and the telemetry sys-
dams were constructed in Baluchistan under FPSP-II (Contijoch, tem (ADB, 2008). The high frequency radio system works as a back-
2008). The harnessing of hill torrents in D.G. Khan has also been up for telemetry and the meteor burst system.
studied by the National Engineering Services Pakistan (NESPak) Currently, comprehensive and effective land-use planning con-
in 1984 and by the Japan International Cooperation Agency in trols do not exist in Pakistan. Development of flood risk zoning for
1992 (MoWP, 2002b). NESPak accomplished another countrywide the main rivers was initiated under FPSP-II. So far, hazard maps for
feasibility study on hill torrents in 1998. The study area was di- 5-year and 50-year return periods have been compiled. Calibration
vided into 14 hill torrent zones in the Federal Areas, NWFP, Punjab, and risk assessment of these maps is planned in the forthcoming
Sindh, and Baluchistan (Fig. 1). Structural work has been com- NPFP. Interpretation and legislation regarding flood zoning will
pleted in a few sub-zones of D.G. Khan (e.g., Kaha and Mithawan). be carried out afterwards.
The larger and more productive part of the flood-producing
5.1.2. Non-structural measures upper catchments of the Sutlej, Ravi, and Chenab rivers lies across
All the major rivers in Pakistan are trans-boundary and flow the border in Kashmir (Indian) (Fig. 3). Precise and timely
through India. The shape of a flood wave mainly depends upon measurement of precipitation in those areas is critical for effective
M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20 17

functioning of FEWS. A weather radar unit at Sialkot was installed Recent policies dealing with crises are the Emergency Services
with the ability to detect the position of clouds and precipitation Ordinance (2002) and National Disaster Management Ordinance
within a radius of 230 km. This radar covers catchment areas of (2006), which provide the national strategy for dealing with emer-
about 17 tributaries. A 10 cm S-band Doppler Weather Surveillance gencies. A Draft National Water Policy by the Ministry of Water
Radar unit, installed in 1997 at Lahore, provides rainfall data about and Power (MoWP) in 2002 was prepared to address most of the
the Sutlej, Beas, Ravi, and Chenab catchments from across the bor- water-related issues in the country, including flooding. This policy
der (NESPak, 2008). Floods in the Jhelum River occur mainly due to emphasizes all necessary structural and non-structural measures
heavy rainfall with very short lead-time. Therefore, a weather ra- for flood management and the need for stakeholder participation
dar unit at Mangla was put up during FPSP II to provide quantita- in the flood management process, as well as enhanced flood aware-
tive rainfall forecasts. More radar units have been planned to cover ness in the community. It also recommends replacement of various
the hill torrent generating catchments of D.G. Khan, NWFP, and water-related acts with a simple unified law that enables clearer
Baluchistan. understanding and subsequent application of the law (Rehman
A number of control structures have been constructed in India, and Kamal, 2005). A number of strategies, visions, initiatives, and
making the operation of rainfall or runoff models more compli- plans have also been prepared, including the Ten Year Perspective
cated. An agreement was signed in 1989 between the two coun- Plan (by the Planning Commission in 2001) and Vision 2025 (by
tries to share river flow and rainfall data for flood forecasting the WAPDA in 2001).
(Awan, 2003). The ‘‘zero flood warning’’ manual was also accom- Pakistan has a very important agreement with neighboring In-
plished to homogenize the flood warning procedures and emer- dia. The partition of the subcontinent created a conflict over the
gency action plans under FPSP II (Awan, 2003; FFC, 2007). water distribution rights of the Indus Basin. This trans-boundary
Tackling the flood problem within flood managing bodies seems water issue between Pakistan and India was addressed with a tem-
to become a smoother and better organized process. The setting porary ‘‘Standstill agreement 1947’’, the ‘‘Inter-Dominion Accord
up of standard operating procedures may produce better inter- 1948’’, and eventually the Indus Water Treaty, which was signed
agency cooperation and coordination. with the help of the World Bank in 1960. Six main rivers, the Indus,
The Mangla and Tarbela dams were constructed for irrigation Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej, along with their tributaries,
and power generation operations. Current reservoir operation are covered in this agreement. According to this treaty, the exclu-
practices do not play any substantial role in flood management. sive rights of water use for the three western rivers (Indus, Jhelum,
The clear example is the recent flooding 2010, in which the Tarbela and Chenab) were given to Pakistan and rights for three eastern
dam did not play any significant role in reducing flooding down- rivers (Ravi, Bias, and Sutlej) were awarded to India. Compensation
stream. Improved reservoir operation of the Mangla dam to facili- to the eastern rivers was managed with a number of link canals.
tate flood management was included in FPSP-II, but now has been
postponed due to a Mangla dam raising project. Pre-flood releases 5.3. Institutional arrangements
on the basis of the flood forecasts can create required flood storage
capacity. Improved planning of reservoir operations for the Mangla Many federal and provincial institutes are involved (directly or
and Tarbela dams is included in the next NFPP to enhance their role indirectly) in flood management activities. Based on the nature of
in flood management. services and support provided, these institutes can be grouped un-
The Pakistan Meteorological Department issues daily satellite der risk-managing and crisis-managing institutes. Risk-managing
cloud pictures from the polar orbiting meteorological satellites institutes deal with structural and non-structural measures,
on its website to inform the general public. In case of cyclones, whereas crisis-managing institutes are concerned with rescue, re-
warnings are issued quickly. Cyclone detection radar is used for lief, and rehabilitation operations.
tropical cyclone monitoring. Japan has donated radar equipment
to the WMO regional center for Bangladesh and Pakistan. This ra- 5.3.1. Hazard managing institutes
dar had contributed substantially to the detection, monitoring, The Federal Flood Commission was established in 1977 and as-
and forecasting of tropical cyclones in the country. Pakistan is a signed the task of preparing the NFPPs on a countrywide basis.
member of the WMO and the ESCAP (Economic and Social Com- Their specific jobs are to construct flood protection and river train-
mission for Asia and the Pacific) Panel on Tropical Cyclones which ing works, improve the weather radar data collection system, and
aims to promote measures to improve tropical cyclone warning create awareness and adaptability among the local population. The
systems in the Bay of Bengal and the Arabian Sea. A technical plan FFC has played the main role in the country’s flood management
aimed at the development and improvement of the cyclone warn- since 1977. Normally, flood protection schemes are prepared by
ing system in the region has been drawn up by the panel (WMO, provincial governments (Provincial Irrigation and Drainage
2008). Authorities) or concerned federal agencies. These schemes are then
reviewed and approved by the FFC, either on an emergency basis or
5.2. Legal framework in the context of a group of projects. Flood protection plans in Paki-
stan are prepared on a countrywide basis by consultants under the
According to the Constitution of Pakistan, water is a provincial supervision of the FFC. Funding is provided by the FFC and execu-
government responsibility, but the federal government also per- tion of these projects is carried out by provincial agencies. The FFC
forms a number of tasks and responsibilities in the water sector, monitor and evaluate these works. These projects can be executed
mostly relating to international and inter-provincial matters. The as an individual independent project or as a subproject of the NFPP.
federal government, through the WAPDA, the Indus River System The approach followed by the FFC encompasses both structural
Authority (IRSA), and the FFC performs coordinated planning, and non-structural measures. Non-structural measures mainly
development, and management of water and hydropower re- pertain to the establishment of modern flood forecasting and
sources. The legal framework for carrying out these tasks is pro- warning systems to provide timely and reliable flood information
vided by the WAPDA Act (1958), the Environmental Protection to the flood mitigation agencies and to the public.
Act (1997), the Indus River System Authority Act (1992), and by The Provincial Irrigation and Drainage Authorities (1997) are
the Constitution under various articles on inter-provincial coordi- an upgraded form of the Provincial Irrigation Departments with the
nation and resolution of conflicts through the Council of Common extended scope of irrigation and drainage management. The
Interests. Provincial Irrigation and Drainage Authorities play an important
18 M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

Fig. 4. Flood losses details at national level against severe flooding years.

role in flood mitigation by performing design, construction, and centers and flood centers at district and union levels. In fact, the
complete maintenance of river training and flood protection works. Relief Department functions through control and coordination of
These also provide the flow measurement of rivers, canals, and the personnel and resources of other government departments
drains for flood forecasting. In addition, their role in crisis manage- generally organized in form of committees.
ment is to prepare flood emergency plans before, during, and after The Emergency Relief Cell works at the federal level and mainly
the floods. deals with the planning and assessment of relief requirements for
The Water and Power Development Authority is involved in major disasters. The scope of their activities covers stock piling of
the flood forecasting process by providing river and rain data from basic necessities needed during an emergency, establishing emer-
its telemetric gauge sites within the upper catchments of Indus and gency funds, and assisting international donors in their relief ef-
Jhelum rivers. The safety of the Mangla and Tarbela dams are the forts. The provincial governments and local administrations
top priority for this data collection. It is also involved in providing provide relief for disasters. The National Disaster Plan from 1974
inflow and outflow data from the Mangla and Tarbela dams and covers procedures, organizational set-up, and standard procedures
the Chashma barrage. for the monitoring of disaster operations.
The Flood Forecasting Division of the Pakistan Meteorological The Army provides necessary help to civil authorities to carry
Department collects hydro-meteorological data from various na- out rescue and relief operations during and after floods. The Army
tional and international sources and then processes data to pro- also takes part in pre-flood season surveys and inspections of the
duce flood forecasts and warnings. Flood warning dissemination flood protection works. It is the responsibility of the provincial
is solely the responsibility of the chief meteorologist to avoid ru- government to provide all support equipment (boats, life jackets,
mors and misinformation about floods. vehicles, tents, etc.) to the Army for these operations. During the
flood season, the Army sets up flood emergency cells at each corps
headquarters. In the case of major floods, the Army is responsible
5.3.2. Crisis managing institutes for actuating controlled breaching of pre- defined flood bunds to
Crisis management is mainly performed through a set of admin- divert the peak away from the cities. Although, there exists no
istrative entities. Therefore, it will be convenient for international standard procedure, the breaching is decided on the basis of exist-
readers if administrative divisions in Pakistan are described before ing and forecasted flood stages with the mutual consultation of lo-
discussing the existing institutional setup. The country is divided cal officials of civil administration, irrigation department, and
into five provinces each having their own political government. army. The Army has been playing a vital role in flood relief activi-
These Provinces are further divided into ‘Divisions’ that, in turn, ties in 2010 flood since the start of this disaster. Their relief activ-
consist of ‘Districts’. Both divisions and districts are only adminis- ities demands intense cooperation with organizations that provide
trative levels headed by ‘Commissioners’ and ‘Deputy Coordination flooding information. There are also a number of departments
Officers’ without political representation. Each district is further which are assigned special tasks during floods.
divided into ‘Tehsils’ and Tehsils into ‘Unions’ that are represented
by elected Councilors.
The Provincial Relief Departments are responsible for flood 6. Analyses and discussions
preparedness, rescue and relief plans. The department arranges
surveys to ensure that all flood protection bunds are satisfactorily The overall data of lives lost and villages flooded (Fig. 4) shows a
maintained before the flood season. It sets up flood warning decreasing trend from 1950 to 2009, which may be due to
M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20 19

Fig. 5. Details of area flooded and crop area flooded at district level for major rivers.

improvements in flood management. According to the Centre for and who benefits’. On the other hand, the project approval guide-
Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters – International Disaster lines set by FFC (FFC, 2009) carry strategic biases that are aimed
Database EM-DAT (1980–2000), the ratio between the number of at protecting locations and infrastructure of greater economic,
deaths and population exposed to floods in Pakistan is lower than political, and strategic significance, at the cost of areas and com-
Afghanistan, Bangladesh, India, and China (Pelling et al., 2004). munities with lesser influence and importance. For a project to
Whereas flood losses at the worldwide level demonstrate an qualify the acceptance criteria, it must have an EIRR above a
increasing trend (Pielke, 2006), flood losses in Pakistan showed a threshold, usually set by donor agencies. Self-reliance and risk-
decreasing trend until the recent flood. The sense of safety induced based approaches are not yet part of project acceptance criteria.
by the decrease in floods resulted in increased vulnerability of soci- The social and economic infrastructure of Pakistan depends on
ety. As a result, life losses and financial losses were exceptional the waters of Indus Basin. Alarming records of historical flood
during the 2010 flood, given the flood levels, which were not losses (Fig. 4) show the seriousness of the flood problem. Measures
exceptionally high (Figs. 2 and 4). have been taken for flood management, but there is no serious ef-
Flood loss data at district level show that historic fluvial floods fort to increase the system’s ability to cope with the fluctuations in
of the major rivers seldom claim lives, whereas regular annual annual and seasonal flows in the Indus River System. Pakistan’s
losses are mainly agricultural. Total areas flooded and flooded current water storage capacity is around 12% of annual availability.
cropped areas can be used as good indictors to assess the impacts No major dam has been constructed since the completion of Tarbe-
of flood management at district level. Therefore, flooded areas and la Dam in 1974. Construction of new dams and reservoirs has been
crop areas flooded at district level have been charted for major riv- hindered by inter-provincial disputes. The country was suffering
ers upstream from the river confluence (Fig. 5) to evaluate trends severe draught and water shortage shortly before it was hit by
in flood losses. Some reductions in the flooded areas have been no- the devastating flood in 2010.
ticed, overall. Historical trends show that the country observes
alternate flood rich and flood poor periods. It is also worth noting
that there has been no major flood since 1995 and that the flood in 7. Conclusions and recommendations
2010 occurred after a prolonged dry spell.
Though both structural and non-structural measures have been Flood management in Pakistan is a task that requires both vast
implemented to reduce flood losses, available statistics show that resources and comprehensive understanding of the flood problem.
flood management in Pakistan basically revolves around structural The nature of floods varies drastically throughout the country due
measures with a primary focus on flood prevention (MoWP, to contrasting physiographic, climatic, hydrologic, demographic,
2002c). Crisis management strategies are mainly comprised of res- and socio-economic factors. The present approach for flood man-
cue and relief actions. However, no solid strategy has been devel- agement incorporates both structural and non-structural mea-
oped to enhance the flood fighting abilities of individual sures, yet their inter-linkage and combined efficiency still need
communities. Flood mapping has been initiated but still no final to be optimized. The efficiency of any proposed measure should
and authentic product has been produced to integrate flood map- be evaluated for its integration into existing measures to achieve
ping into existing flood management. New initiatives for structural efficient and economically viable solutions.
and non-structural measures are taken continuously but lack of Change in flow regime due to low flows in eastern rivers after
continuity and maintenance mostly results in failure. Poor mainte- the Indus Water Treaty and enhanced flood protection measures
nance of telemetric system, dikes, and FEWS are among the exam- have attracted economic activities and settlements in floodplains.
ples. Dike failures and malfunctioning of FEWS for flood warning Flood management arrangements are concentrated around the
due to poor maintenance and negligence have been observed dur- Chenab and Jhelum rivers because of the frequent and devastating
ing 2010 flooding (Tariq and van de Giesen, 2010). nature of flooding. Those floodplains that have not faced flooding
Funds are controlled and provided by the federal government over a considerable time are under extremely high risk. Vulnerabil-
through FFC and there is no consideration in terms of ‘who pays ity on such locations has increased due to a false sense of safety.
20 M.A.U.R. Tariq, N. van de Giesen / Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 47–48 (2012) 11–20

The 2010 flood in the upper Indus was due to exceptional intensive Hydraulic Engineering & Research (IAHR) Biennial Congress, Vancouver, British
Columbia.
rainfall in the catchments of the Kabul and Swat rivers which was
IFRC, 2002. Info Bulletin No. 2/02; Pakistan: Flash floods. International Federation of
not covered by Doppler Weather Surveillance Radar units. The Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.
Doppler Weather Surveillance Radar network should be extended IFRC, 2005. Pakistan: Floods. International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent
to cover north western areas of the Indus Basin to enhance the Societies, Islamabad.
ISDR, 2005. A review of disaster management policies and systems in Pakistan, The
capability and reliability of FEWS and the same system should be World Conference on Disaster Reduction. International Strategy for Disaster
established for the hill torrent areas of the Kharan Basin after car- Reduction, Kobe, Japan, p. 44.
rying out feasibility analyses. Jarrige, J.F., 1997. Excavation at Mehrgarh – Pakistan. In: Leeuw, J.E.V.L.-D. (Ed.),
South Asian Archaeology 1975. Brill Academic Publishers, pp. 76–87.
Currently, there exists no well defined criterion to initiate new Javed, S., Baig, M., 2005. Pasni dam bursts: heavy rains kill 150 in Pakistan. Pakistan
measures. Political processes and influence shape flood manage- Times e-paper. Times group of publicationers, Islamabad.
ment planning. The situation worsens as funding is not a responsi- Kamal, A., 2004. Pakistan: Lai Nullah basin flood problem, Islamabad – Rawalpindi
cities, Integrated flood management. The Associated Programme on Flood
bility of floodplain inhabitants. A race to secure more measures is Management, p. 24.
unavoidable. In addition, the protection of high value areas at the Khan, A., 2007a. Preliminary damage assessment report Yemyin and Gonu cyclones
cost of low priority areas promotes unlawful breechings of dikes, Makran coastal wetlands complex, in: Garstang, R. (Ed.). The Ministry of
Environment’s Pakistan Wetlands, Islamabad.
which was also observed during the flood in 2010. To overcome Khan, M.A., 2007b. Disaster preparedness for natural hazards: Current status in
the problem, the risk-based approach must be incorporated to han- Pakistan. International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD)
dle flood problems within available resources. Resources required Kathmandu, Nepal.
Khosa, W.K., 2000. Kharan desert. The Federation of American Scientists. <http://
for flood management must be generated from water users and
www.fas.org/nuke/guide/pakistan/facility/kharan.htm>.
floodplain inhabitants and dependency on donors must be avoided. Majeed, Z., Khan, A.I., 2008. Dam failures due to flash floods and it’s review for
Comprehensive standard operating procedures must be formu- Mirani dam project, Impacts of climate change on water resources management
lated based on risk and self reliance. in the region, Damascus, Syria.
Mir, H., Latif, S., Mahmood, A., Hussain, S., 2010. Flood report 2010, Flood reports.
Expansion of structural and non-structural measures is extre- Pakistan Meteorological Department, Flood Forecasting Division, Lahore,
mely important to enhance the efficiency of the flood management Pakistan, p. 34.
system. Flood zoning and flood mapping projects must be com- MoE, 2003. Pakistan’s initial national communication on climate change. Ministry of
Environment, Islamabad, Pakistan, p. 92.
pleted on priority basis. Necessary legal and institutional support MoWP, 2002a. Detailed strategy formulation, Pakistan water sector strategy.
must be provided to flood mapping and flood zoning. New dams Ministry of Water and Power, Office of the Chief Engineering Advisor,
are necessary for improvement in water management in general Islamabad, p. 290.
MoWP, 2002b. Medium term investment plan, Pakistan water sector strategy.
and for effective flood management in particular. Ministry of Water and Power, Office of the Chief Engineering Advisor,
Unfortunately, maintenance and functioning of flood measures Islamabad, p. 193.
have been neglected. High priorities must be assigned for the prop- MoWP, 2002c. National water sector profile, Pakistan water sector strategy.
Ministry of Water and Power, Office of the Chief Engineering Advisor,
er functioning of measures. FEWS is a state of the art model. Its Islamabad, p. 136.
proper functioning and full utilization must be assured. Compre- NDMA, 2007. National Disaster Management Authority Press Briefing – August
hensive flood management plans must be prepared and executed 2007, Islamabad, Pakistan.
NESPak, 2008. Second flood protection sector project – package C strengthening
without waiting for another devastating flood.
flood forecasting, management and warning system. Federal Flood Commission
Concluding, a risk-based pro-active approach is required to of Pakistan, Islamabad, p. 151.
achieve sustainable flood management. Pelling, M., Maskrey, A., Ruiz, P., Hall, L., 2004. Reducing disaster risk: A challenge
for development. United Nations Development Programme, Bureau for Crisis
Prevention and Recovery, New York, USA.
References Pielke, Roger A., Jr., 2006. Understanding and attribution trends and projections. In:
Workshop on Climate Change and Disaster Losses, Hohenkammer, Germany.
ADB, 2008. Pakistan: Second flood protection sector project. In: Leonard, R.K. (Ed.). PMD, 2009. Monsoon contingency planning update 2009. Pakistan Meteorological
Operations Evaluation Department, Asian Development Bank, p. 137. Department, Islamabad.
Awan, S.A., 2003. Integrated flood management case study Pakistan: Flood Rehman, H.U., Bhattarai, R., 2005. Modeling and socio-economic impact analysis of
management - River Chenab from Marala to Khanki. The Associated floods in coastal cities under sea level rising scenarios: a case study of Karachi,
Programme on Flood Management, 30. Pakistan. In: International Symposium on Floods in Coastal Cities under Climate
Baig, M.A., 2008. Floods and flood plains in Pakistan. In: 20th International Congress Change Conditions, Bangkok, Thailand, pp. 29–36.
on Irrigation and Drainage, Lahore, Pakistan. Rehman, H., Kamal, A., 2005. Indus Basin River System: Flooding and flood
Contijoch, M., 2008. Balochistan small scale irrigation project, in: Bernard, C.A., mitigation. In: 8th International River Symposium 2005, Brisbane, Australia.
Brizzi, A. (Eds.), Irrigation and drainage. World Bank, p. 137. Shah, S.M.S., Gabriel, H.F., 2002. Floods in Pakistan, Fencing Floods in South Asia:
FFC, 2007. Annual Flood Report 2006. Federal Flood Commission Pakistan, Disaster Preparedness through Risk Communication, p. 27.
Islamabad, Pakistan, p. 36. Shaikh, I.B., 2008. Water management for mitigating floods & droughts. In: South-
FFC, 2009. Annual Flood Report 2008. Federal Flood Commission Pakistan, Asian Regional Workshop on Climate Change and Disaster Risk Management,
Islamabad, Pakistan, p. 57. Kathmando, Nepal.
Framji, K.K., Mahajan, I.K., 1969. Irrigation and Drainage in the World: A Global Tariq, M.A.U.R., van de Giesen, N., 2010. Why Pakistan deserves generosity. The
Review, second ed. International Commission on Irrigation & Drainage, New Great Debate UK. Reuters Group Limited, London, UK.
Delhi, India. Umrani, A.P., 2001. Living with droughts, Daily Dawn. DAWN Group of Newspapers,
Haider, N., 2006. Living with disasters: Disaster profiling of districts of Pakistan. Karachi.
National Disaster Management Authority Islamabad, Pakistan, p. 65. UNESCO, 2007. Balochistan and Sindh floods: Progress report September 2007.
Halcrow, Euroconsult, NDC, 2001. Capacity building for integrated river UNESCO, Islamabad, Pakistan.
management and subprojects implementation design criteria and UNITAR, 2004. The Indus river basin, Training workshop on wetlands, biodiversity
methodology: Package B Second Flood Protection Sector Project II. Federal and water: New tools for the ecosystem management. Kushiro International
Flood Commission, Islamabad, Pakistan. Wetland Centre, Kushiro, Japan.
Haq, I.u., Abbas, S.T., 2008. Sedimentation of Tarbela & Mangla reservoirs. In: WMO, 2008. Tropical cyclone operational plan for the Bay of Bengal and the Arabian
Pakistan Engineering Congress, 70th Annual Session Proceedings Paper No 659, Sea, Tropical cyclone programme. World Meteorological Organization, Geneva,
pp. 25–46. Switzerland, p. 92.
Haq, N.u., Nasir, S., 2003. Water resources of Pakistan, IPRI Factfile. The Islamabad WWF, 2010. Hydrology of the Northern Areas, Northern Areas of Pakistan. World
Policy Research Institute Pakistan, Islamabad. Wide Fund for Nature. <http://www.wwfpak.org/nap/dnap_freshwater_
Hashmi, H.N., Hussain, F., Ghani, U., Mughal, S.M., 2009. Optimization of Mangla hydrology.php>.
reservoir capacity by raising dam height. In: 33rd International Association of

View publication stats

You might also like