Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Civil Engineers
Ground Improvement 161
February 2008 Issue GI1
Pages 43–49
doi: 10.1680/grim.2008.161.1.43
Paper 700029
Received 23/07/2006
Accepted 15/08/2007
K. S. Beena K. K. Babu
Keywords: embankments/ Reader in Civil Engineering, Research Scholar, School of
geotechnical engineering/ School of Engineering, Engineering, Cochin
geotextiles, membranes & geogrids Cochin University of Science University of Science and
and Technology, Kochi, India Technology, Kochi, India
The results of an experimental investigation to explore Transmittivity The product of water permeability along the
the effectiveness of coir geotextile vertical drains for geotextile plane and thickness of the
ground improvement are reported. The time settlement geotextile.
behaviour of clayey soil, as influenced by coir geotextile Warp Set of yarns running length-wise of a fabric
drains, is summarised and the construction and Weft Set of yarns running width-wise of a fabric
installation details are also discussed. Two types of coir Wide width Uniaxial test in which entire width of a
drains, a circular type and a rectangular type, using two tensile strength 200 mm wide specimen is gripped in clamps
varieties of coir geotextiles were tested in three to ensure a gauge length of 100 mm with a
configurations, namely a single drain and triangular and strain rate of 10 mm/min.
rectangular patterns. It was observed that the time for
consolidation was very much reduced due to the
installation of coir drains irrespective of the type of coir 1. INTRODUCTION
geotextile used, type of coir drain and the layout of the The rapid increase in population and associated development
drains. Furthermore, in addition to ease of construction activities has resulted in the scarcity of good sites for
these drains are eco-friendly and will not pose any construction. The activities are now forced to concentrate in
environmental problems. lowland areas having very low strength and high
compressibility. Thus it is essential to modify the soft soil
before commencing construction activities, to prevent undue
settlement and in turn, failure—both functional and
NOTATION structural. Ground improvement techniques can play a vital
Cross machine Direction of the geosynthetic in a direction role in solving many geotechnical problems encountered
direction perpendicular to its long manufacturing or during the implementation of any infrastructure development
machine direction. project.
Ends The threads, which lie along the length of
woven fabric. Of the various forms of ground improvement techniques
Machine Direction of the geosynthetic in a direction of available, pre-loading is the most successful one. The main
direction its long manufacturing. disadvantage of this method is that the time required for
Permittivity The amount of water moving across a consolidation is very long and also the surcharge load required
geotextile in unit time through unit area at is significantly high. In many cases, to keep pace with the
unit head. speed of construction activities, pre-loading may not be always
Picks Weft or filling yarn, which lies across the a viable solution. In such cases, the presence of a vertical drain
length of a fabric. can greatly reduce the pre-loading period. The installation of
Runnage Length of the yarn in metres to weigh 1 kg. vertical drains leads to a reduction of the length of the
Scorage It is the indication of thickness or thinness of drainage path in a radial direction. As the consolidation time is
yarn. It is the number of strands that can be inversely proportional to the square of the length of the
accommodated in a span of 900 mm (36 in.) drainage path, the period of loading required to achieve
without overlapping divided by 20. stabilisation in soft soil is considerably reduced.
Secant The ratio of change in load per unit width to
modulus a stated value of strain, usually 10% More than 140 million metres of prefabricated vertical drains
Strip tensile Uniaxial test in which entire width of a have been installed as part of the soil improvement work for
strength 50 mm wide specimen is gripped in clamps to the Changi East land reclamation project in Singapore. Chu et
ensure a gauge length of 200 mm with a al.1 described the factors controlling the selection of
strain rate of 10 mm/min. prefabricated vertical drains (PVDs), the quality control testing
Tenacity The fibre strength as force per linear density for them, selection of design parameters, adaptability of some
Tex This is the universal unit for yarn count; it is of the design criteria, smear effect etc., based on the Changi
the weight in grams per kilometre of yarn experience.
Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu 43
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Most of the PVDs used for ground improvement applications 2. PREFABRICATED VERTICAL DRAINS USING COIR
are of the polymeric type. The main disadvantage of the GEOTEXTILES
polymeric type of drains is that the capacity may be effectively
surplus to requirements. In such situations, deliberate and 2.1. Coir geotextiles
designed use of geosynthetic, which has a predictable reduction Coir, a ‘generic’ member of the geosynthetics family, is made
in capacity with time, is a good engineering solution. 2 Li and from coconut fibres extracted from the husk of coconut fruit. Coir
Rowe3 discussed the advantages of the combined use of both is a hard and tough fibre with a length of 150–280 mm and
PVDs and geosynthetics reinforcements in embankments. Based diameter varying between 0.1 to 0.5 mm. It is a multi-cellular
on model tests, Fang and Yin4 reported the variations in fibre containing 30 to 300 or more cells in its total cross-section,
delayed pore water pressure under a constant pressure during which is polygonal to round in shape. The properties of coir fibre
the loading and unloading stages. Bo5 developed a single basic are given in Table 1. Coir geotextiles are manufactured by a series
equation to obtain the required average discharge capacity and of processes, namely retting, spinning and weaving. They are of
it was found that the required discharge capacity is of the order woven and non-woven type. Non-woven coir geotextiles are
of 10 6 m/s for a 100 mm width drain. Hawlader et al.6 made directly from the fibre without it first being spun into yarn.
conducted a parametric study to identify the influence of Woven coir geotextiles are manufactured from four types of coir
viscosity and smear on the consolidation process of clays with yarn made from white coir. Two varieties of woven coir
vertical drains. Design charts for determining drain spacing are geotextiles designated as H2M6 and H2M8 were used for the
described by Zhu and Yin.7 present experimental work. The properties of the coir geotextiles
were determined in the laboratory as per BS specifications 15 and
The increasing application of geosynthetics, however, has the are tabulated in Table 2.
disadvantage of high cost and the material is petroleum based
and is not eco-friendly. 8 The increasing environmental 2.2. Preparation of drains
awareness and sustainability, together with the high cost of Two types of coir geotextile drains were suggested for the
petroleum products, are causing the developing countries to present investigation. One was of circular type and the other
investigate the possible utilisation of substitutes made from was of rectangular type. The circular drains were made by
natural products. wrapping the coir geotextiles twice over a rigid polyvinyl
chloride (PVC) pipe, diameter 50.8 mm, which is withdrawn
Coir is an abundantly available and renewable resource, which after installation. To keep the geotextiles in position it was tied
is more durable than jute as it has a higher content of lignin. with very thin binding wires at 200–250 mm intervals. For
Under water, coir has been shown to retain its strength for easy penetration of drains a perforated metallic cone was used.
about eight to ten years. Although the survivability concept is
more important in the case of geotextile functions, studies To make a rectangular type of drain, three wooden reapers with
indicate that, in most of the separation applications, the critical dimensions 200 mm 3 100 mm, made from bamboo strips or
period in the life of a geotextile is during construction rather waste wood cuttings, were placed with a 20 mm clear gap
than during service life. 9 Usually, if the geotextile survives the between them. This was glued to the coir geotextiles and
construction-induced stresses, it will also withstand the in- wrapped around in four layers. The ends were glued to avoid
service stresses. With regard to natural geotextiles, durability is separation. A perforated metallic V-shaped shoe was placed at
not a matter of concern where a short service life is required, as the ends at the time of installation to facilitate easy penetration.
in the case of drainage for consolidation of soft compressible The cross-sections of the drains are shown in Fig. 1.
deposits. 10 The greatest advantages of coir geotextile are its
availability, economic price range, and eco compatibility. It can 3. TEST PROGRAMME
be tailor-made to match the end users’ technical requirements The experimental work aimed to find the reduction in the
in terms of porometry, permittivity, strength, etc. 11 consolidation settlement time due to the provision of coir
geotextile drains in loose and sensitive soils. Although not
The uses of coir geotextiles in improving the bearing capacity impossible, it is very difficult to conduct tests in the field due
and other strength aspects of soil are well established. 12–14 to the difficulty in mobilising the equipment and also taking
However, the effect of coir in stabilising the clay stratum readings continuously. To bypass these difficulties and to have
through the acceleration of
consolidation has been little
studied. In this paper the Physical properties Chemical properties
effectiveness of vertical
drains using a natural Density 1400 kg/m3 Water soluble 5.25%
geotextile, namely coir Tenacity 0.1 N/tex Pectin and related compounds 3.30%
Breaking elongation 30% Hemi cellulose 0.25%
geotextile, is discussed,
Moisture regain at 65% relative humidity 10.5% Cellulose 43.44%
based on an extensive Swelling (diameter) in water 5% Lignin 45.84%
research programme. Two Specific gravity 1.15 Others 1.92%
types of drains made of two Porosity 40%
varieties of coir geotextiles, Young’s modulus 4.5 GN/m2
which had different mesh
* Source: Rao and Balan. 11
sizes and densities, were
studied in different Table 1. Properties of coir fibre*
configurations.
44 Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Property H2M6 H2M8
10 mm Property Value
20 mm 20 mm 20 mm 20 mm 20 mm
Soil type CL
Specific gravity 2.72
Coir geotextile
Coir geotextile Free swell index 8.25%
Liquid limit 34%
Wooden reaper Plasticity index 12%
20 mm ⫻ 10 mm Shrinkage limit 18%
section 50·8 mm Æ
Table 3. Properties of soil used
the load evenly over the entire surface. A surcharge load was
applied in order to produce a pressure of 10 kPa. The load was
applied with the help of a winch.
(a) (b)
The soil used for the investigation was low compressible clay
(CL) with high silt content procured from the Marad area in Loading arrangement
Cochin, India. The properties of soil were determined in the
LVDT
laboratory and are summarised in Table 3. The soil was soaked
in water for three to five days and made into a thick slurry Perforated steel plate 38 mm thick
form. The slurry was transferred into the tank in small
Coir geotextile
quantities and was stirred well to remove the entrapped air to
Perforated steel plate 5 mm thick
the maximum possible degree. This was continued until the
Filter paper
tank was filled to a depth of 750 mm. Three days rest period
Coir geotextile drain
was given before commencing the experiment, so that the
slurry formed a natural state of stability. Rice husk
Soil
Mild steel tank
After installing the drains in the desired configuration, the
650 mm ⫻ 650 mm ⫻ 850 mm
surface was levelled and a filter paper was placed over it to
cover the entire area. A perforated steel plate, 5 mm thick, was 650 mm
placed above this and two layers of coir geotextiles were then
placed on top of this to act as a drainage blanket. Finally a Fig. 2. Details of test set-up
perforated metallic plate, 38 mm thick, was placed to distribute
Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu 45
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
depth and simultaneously the pipe was slowly withdrawn for that
depth. During field installations, this can be done using a chute.
Fig. 3 explains the sequence of installation for the circular
vertical drains. In the case of the rectangular type of drains the
V-shaped shoe was placed over the soil surface. The drain was
placed centrally in the groove and pressed to the required depth
in stages as explained in Fig. 4. As there was no withdrawal of the
casing pipe and filling of the drains, the installation of the
rectangular drain was found to be simpler.
Ground surface
Initially the settlement characteristics were studied without
using the coir drains. Then the experiments were repeated with 1 2
one drain at the centre, three drains in a triangular pattern and
four drains in a rectangular pattern. Both types of drain,
namely circular and rectangular, were used for the study. The
layout of drains is shown in Fig. 5.
3
After conducting the tests the soil surrounding the drains was
removed and it was observed that the rectangular drains
remained intact after loading, whereas the circular drain
showed the formation of a minor kink. No other damage was
observed after the test. 4
46 Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
650 mm 650 mm 650 mm
settlement, say 10 mm, for
circular drains using H2M8
50·8 mm Ø 325 mm coir geotextile, it was found
50 .8 mmΦ
that reductions of around 70,
74 and 82% were noted for
325 mm
650 mm
single, rectangular and
50·8 mm Ø triangular patterns,
R1
52 respectively. It should be
.4
noted that the radial drainage
Circular drain
paths for single, rectangular
and triangular patterns were
650 mm 650 mm 650 mm 300, 205 and 127 mm,
325 mm
respectively. Similar trends
were also found for the
rectangular type of drain (Fig.
325 mm
8). This may be due to the fact
650 mm
100 mm
10 mm that the horizontal drainage
path was a minimum in a
staggered triangular layout in
comparison with the other
Rectangular drain pattern of arrangements, as
can be observed from Table 5.
Fig. 5. Layouts of coir geotextile drains
4.3. Types of coir
geotextiles
added as the PVC pipe was withdrawn. Furthermore, the two Two types of coir geotextiles were used for the study. Six
wooden pieces of the rectangular drains were likely to make experiments were performed using drains made of H2M8 and
the collection of water in the drain more difficult. six others with drains made of H2M6. Figs 9 and 10 show the
time settlement behaviour of drains made of the two types of
Considering the performance of the circular and rectangular coir geotextiles when using single drain and triangular patterns,
drains in terms of damage during installation and loading, it respectively. When a single drain was used both H2M8 and
was found that the installation of rectangular drains was easier H2M6 generally performed in a similar way, as can be seen from
than the circular ones and also, after the loading, the Fig. 9. In the case of the triangular pattern, H2M8 performed in
rectangular drains were found to be in an intact position a better manner when the circular type of drain was used, as
whereas the circular drains showed minor distortion. shown in Fig. 10, whereas only a nominal difference was
observed in the case of rectangular drains. This was considered
4.2. Pattern of arrangement to be due to the large mesh size opening of H2M6 coir geotextile
In order to study the effect of layout of drains, three different and less rigidity. Being more flexible, more kinks could be
patterns were tried, namely one at the centre, three drains in a formed while using H2M6 and the rice husk inside the drain
triangular pattern and four drains in a rectangular pattern. Fig. could spread out through the mesh openings of the geotextile.
7 shows the results for a typical case of circular drains made of The stiffness of the rectangular type of coir drains, due to the
H2M8 coir geotextile. It was observed from the figure that the wooden reapers/bamboo strips inside the drain, prevented the
triangular pattern showed a better performance. Comparing the drain from forming kinks. A similar trend was also shown for
performance in terms of reduction in time for a specified the rectangular layout pattern as shown in Fig. 11.
Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu 47
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Elapsed time: min Pattern of arrangement Drainage path: mm
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
0 Circular drain Rectangular drain
Soil only
Circular drain
Single 300.0 320.0
Rectangular drain
Triangular 127.0 147.5
5
Rectangular 204.4 229.8
Settlement: mm
Settlement: mm
10
Fig. 6. Time–settlement behaviour of drains placed at centre
15
Elapsed time: min Soil only
H2M8 circular
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 20 H2M6 circular
0
H2M8 rectangular
Soil only
One drain at centre H2M6 rectangular
5 Three drains in triangular pattern 25
Four drains in rectangular pattern
Fig. 9. Influence of type of coir geotextiles on behaviour of
10
Settlement: mm
15
30
10
Fig. 7. Effect of layout of drains: circular type of drains
Settlement: mm
15
30
6
Settlement: mm
10
12 5. CONCLUSION
As they are biodegradable the coir geotextiles were eco-
14 friendly and were cheap in comparison with the polymeric
counterparts. The use of coir geotextile for vertical drains is an
16
appropriate technology, which provides employment to the less
Rectangular drain using H2M8 able sections of society. This type of drain is particularly suited
18
to countries having a large production of coconut.
Fig. 8. Effect of layout of drains: rectangular type of drains
Based on the extensive laboratory investigations carried out on
48 Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Elapsed time: min REFERENCES
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 1. CHU J., BO M. W. and CHOA V. Practical considerations for
0 using vertical drains in soil improvement projects. Journal
of Geotextiles and Geomembranes, 2004, 22, No. 1–2,
Four drains in rectangular pattern 101–117.
5
2. MWASHA A. and SARSBY R. W. Time dependent behavior of
embankment reinforced with limited life geotextiles.
Proceedings of the RICS Foundation Construction and
Settlement: mm
10
Building Research Conference, School of the Built
Environment, University of Wolverhampton, 2003.
15 3. LI A. L. and ROWE K. R. Combined effects of reinforcements
on prefabricated vertical drains on embankment
Soil only performance. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 2001, 38,
H2M8 circular
20 No. 6, 1266–1282.
H2M6 circular
H2M6 rectangular
4. FANG Z. and YIN J. H. Physical modeling of consolidation
H2M8 rectangular of Honkong marine clay with prefabricated vertical drains.
25 Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 2006, 43, No. 6, 638–652.
5. BO M. W. Discharge capacity of prefabricated vertical
Fig. 11. Influence of type of coir geotextiles on behaviour of drains and their field measurements. Journal of Geotextiles
drains (rectangular layout)
and Geomembranes, 2004, 22, No. 1–2, 37–48.
6. HAWLADER B. C., IMAI G. and MUHUNTHAN B. Numerical
study of the factors affecting the consolidation of clay with
two types of coir geotextile drains, which were made of two vertical drains. Journal of Geotextiles and Geomembranes,
different varieties of woven coir geotextiles in different 2002, 20, No. 4, 213–239.
configurations, the following conclusions are made. 7. ZHU G. and YIN J. H. Design charts for vertical drains
considering the construction time. Canadian Geotechnical
Journal, 2001, 38, No. 5, 1142–1148.
(a) Of the two types of coir geotextile drains tried, the circular-
8. LEE S. L., KARUNARATNE G. P., RAMASWAMY S. D., AZIZ M. A.
type drain was found to be more efficient, although the
and GUPTA N. C. D. Natural geosynthetic drain for soil
rectangular type was easier to install in the soil.
improvement. Journal of Geotextiles and Geomembranes,
(b) The triangular layout was found to be more efficient than
1994, 13, No. 6–7, 457–474.
central and rectangular layouts.
9. KOERNER R. M. Designing with Geosynthetics, 5th edn.
(c) The performance of the drains with H2M8 coir geotextiles
Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, 2005.
was better than that with H2M6 coir geotextiles.
10. DATYE K. R. and GORE V. N. Application of natural
(d ) It was found that for 10 mm settlement to take place under
geotextiles and related products. Journal of Geotextiles and
a pressure of 10 kPa, the time required for the case of
Geomembranes, 1994, 13, No. 6–7, 371–388.
circular drains installed in a triangular fashion was only
11. RAO G. V. and BALAN K. (eds). Coir Geotextiles—Emerging
half of the time required without drains.
Trends. The Kerala State Coir Corporation, Alleppy, Kerala,
India, 2000.
In general the time for consolidation was very much reduced 12. AYYAR T. S. R., JOSEPH J. and BEENA K. S. Bearing capacity
due to the provision of circular and rectangular coir drains in of sand reinforced with coir rope. Proceedings of the 1st
all the configurations studied. Combining all parameters it was Indian Geotextile Conference on Reinforced Soil and
found that circular-type coir geotextile drains using H2M8 coir Geotextiles. Bombay, 1988, A11–A16. Publishing Co. Pvt,
geotextiles installed in a triangular pattern gave the maximum New Delhi, India.
output in terms of reduction in consolidation time. 13. KURIEN N. P., BEENA K. S. and KRISHNAKUMAR K. Settlement
of reinforced sand in foundations. Journal of Geotechnical
and Geo-environmental Engineering, ASCE, 1997, 123, No.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 9, 818–827.
The research work described in this paper was funded by the 14. BEENA K. S. and BABU K. K. Studies on the performance of
All India Council for Technical Education, Ministry of Human coir geotextiles in subgrade soil. Proceedings of the Golden
Resources, Government of India, New Delhi under the Research Jubilee Conference on Coir Geotextiles, Coir Board, Kochi,
and Development Scheme. The assistance given by the authors’ India, 2003.
colleagues and laboratory staff at N.S.S College of Engineering, 15. BRITISH STANDARDS INSTITUTION. Methods of Testing of
Palakkad and at Cochin University of Science and Technology, Geotextiles and Related Products. BSI, London, 1987–1990.
Kochi, India are gratefully acknowledged. BS 6906 (Part 1 to Part 7).
Ground Improvement 161 Issue GI1 Testing coir geotextile drains for soft ground improvement Beena • Babu 49
Downloaded by [ York University] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.