You are on page 1of 54

Republic of the Philippines

Philippine Statistics Authority

MONITORING OF THE SUSTAINABLE


DEVELOPMENT GOALS (SDGS)
IN THE PHILIPPINES

SDG Seminar Series


N Hotel, Cagayan De Oro City
August 29, 2019
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority

Outline of Presentation
I. Background
II. Initiatives of the PSS
a) Global Consultation
b) Philippine Consultation
III. Philippine SDG Indicators for Initial Monitoring
IV. Localizing SDG Monitoring

V. Some Efforts and Next Steps

2
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

15 Years 8 Goals 21 Targets 60 Indicators


UN Millennium Declaration
Millennium Summit, September 2000
(189 countries committed – the PHILIPPINES included)

Millennium Development Goals (MDG)

Achieve by 2015
3
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

Status of MDG indicators as of November 2017


indicator 1.2
Poverty gap ratio
indicator 1.3
Share of poorest quintile in national consumption
indicator 1.4
Growth rate of GDP per person employed
Indicators indicator 1.5
Employment-to-population ratio
Proportion of own-account and contributing family workers in total
indicator 1.7
that were
employment
achieved
indicator 1.9b Proportion of population below national subsistence
indicator 3.1a Ratio of girls to boys in primary education
indicator 3.1a.1 Ratio of girls to boys in elementary participation rates
indicator 7.5 Ratio of area protected to maintain biological diversity to surface area
indicator 8.12 Debt service as a percentage of exports of goods and services
indicator 8.14 Telephone lines subscribers per 100 population
indicator 8.15 Cellular phone subscribers per 100 population
indicator 5.5a Antenatal care coverage (at least one visit )
indicator 5.6 Unmet need for family planning
indicator 7.1 Proportion of land area covered by forest
indicator 7.2 Consumption of ozone-depleting CFCs (ODP tons)
Indicator 3.1b Ratio of girls to boys in secondary education
Indicator 3.1c Ratio of girls to boys in tertiary education
4
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

Status of MDG indicators as of November 2017


indicator 1.1a Proportion of population below national poverty threshold
indicator 1.6 Proportion of employed population living below the national
poverty threshold
indicator 1.8 Prevalence of underweight children under 5 years of age using
Child Growth Standards (CGS)
Indicators indicator 1.9 Percent of household with per capita energy less than 100%
adequacy
that were not
indicator 2.1 Net enrolment ratio in primary education
achieved
indicator 2.2 Proportion of pupils starting grade 1 who reach grade 6 (Cohort
Survival Rate)
indicator 2.2a Primary completion rate
indicator 7.6 Number of species threatened with extinction
indicator 3.2 Share of women in wage employment in the non-agricultural
sector
indicator 3.3 Proportion of seats held by women in national parliament
indicator 6.6a Prevalence associated with malaria
indicator 6.8a Prevalence associated with tuberculosis
indicator 7.9a Proportion of families with access to secure tenure

5
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

UN Sustainable Development Summit, Sept 2015


United Nations Conference on
Sustainable Development
Rio+20, Earth Summit 2012

launch a process to
develop a set of 15 Years
SDGs, which were to
build upon the MDGs 17 Goals
and converge with
the post 2015 169 Targets
development
agenda.

Achieve by 2030
6
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

Transforming Our World: The


2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development

“This Agenda is a plan of


People
action for people, planet
and prosperity. It also seeks Planet
to strengthen universal
peace in larger freedom. All
Prosperity
countries and all
stakeholders, acting in Peace
collaborative partnership,
will implement this plan." Partnership

7
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority

Number of Goals 8 17
Number of Targets 21 169

Number of Indicators 60 232


Economic growth, social
General scope/focus Social inclusion & environmental
protection

Developing countries, Entire world (rich and


Target countries particularly the poorest poor)
232
Result of consultation process among:
Produced by a group of -193 UN Member States
Formulation experts -Civil society
-Other stakeholders

Source: http://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/summit/

8
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

The 17 Sustainable Development Goals

9
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

The 17 Sustainable Development Goals

10
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

The 17 Sustainable Development Goals

11
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority I. Background

Indicator framework
• The revised SDG framework developed by
the IAEG-SDGs was adopted by the UNSC at
its 48th session on 10 March 2017, which
includes 232 unique indicators
• Member States, INCLUDING THE PHILIPPINES,
will develop indicators at regional, national
and sub-national levels to complement the
global indicators, taking into account
national circumstances.
• Member States have pledged to leave no
17 169 232 one behind
• disaggregation by income, sex, age ,
Goals Targets Indicators race, ethnicity, migratory status,
(unique) disability and geographic location,
whichever relevant

12
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 13
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS
Participation in the Global Consultation
OPTION 01
1.1. The Philippines served as Co-Chair of the
UN Interagency Experts Group on SDGs (IAEG-
OPTION 01
SDGs)
1.2. Participation in various international fora
1.3. Accomplishment of questionnaires
1.4 PSA-UNSD Project on “Enhancing National Statistical
OPTION 01

Capacity to measure, monitor, assess and report on


OPTION 01
progress on achieving post-2015 goals and targets for
Sustainable Development”
1.5 UNSD- ESRI Project on developing a Philippine SDG
OPTION 01
Hub
1.6 PSA-ITU Project on “Big Data for Measuring the
OPTION 01
Information Society”
1.7 Reporting to the High Level Political Forum held on
July 2016 and July 2019
www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 14
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Advocacy of the Global SDG Indicators

PSA Central Office and ACADEME


1 Field Offices 2 - University of the Philippines
- Ateneo de Manila University
- Polytechnic University of the Philippines

Multisectoral Committee on
SDGs and Nutrition
3 International Human
Development Commitments
4

SDG on Disaster Risk


5 Related Indicators 6 NSDS WORKSHOP

Various Government LOCAL GOVERNMENT


7 Agencies 8 UNITS

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Legal Frameworks for Data


a) Presidential Proclamation of the Civil Registration and Vital Statistics
Decade 2015-2024, March 2015

b) “Approving and Endorsing to the Office of the President the Philippine


Statistical Development Program 2011-2017 Update”- PSA Board
Resolution NO. 14-2015

15
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 16
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Institutional Organization for the SDGs

The PSA Board enjoined all concerned government


instrumentalities to provide the necessary data
support to monitor the country’s performance vis-
à-vis the SDGs based on the indicator framework
that shall be determined by the NEDA, PSA and
other government agencies.

– PSA Resolution No. 4 Series of 2016

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Strong
partnership/
collaboration

17
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS
Strong partnership/ collaboration

Official repository of SDG


indicators in the Philippines
Compile and maintain SDG
Indicators Database and
SDG Watch
Coordinate the generation
and improvement of SDG
indicators

Call on the international


community, private sector,
and civil society for
assistance and advocacy
18
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS
Strong partnership/ collaboration
Analyze the SDG
indicators for policy-
making
Methodological
research
Capacity Building
Compilation/
generation of data
•Relevance of SDG
monitoring to public
policy
•Integration of the SDG
framework in planning
& programming 19
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS
Strong partnership/ collaboration
Funding Support and
Technical assistance
Methodological
research
Statistical advocacy
Raising public
awareness on SDGs
Activities/Investments to
support achievement of
the SDG
Statistical advocacy
Compilation/
generation of data 20
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 21
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Establishment of the Philippine SDG Focal Points


(SDGFP)

❑ Consists of permanent and alternate focal


persons from 34 national government
agencies

❑ The SDGFP plays a vital role in the


methodological developments of SDG
indicators and in the efficient updating of the
SDG Watch and Database

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 22
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Establishment of PSA SDG Team

Advisers Overall Coordinator

• National Statistician • Technical Specialists


• Deputy National Statistician on SDGs,
• Assistant National Statistician Poverty and Human
• Director, Development Statistics
Statistical Methodologies Unit Division
• Director,
International Cooperation Unit
Members
Team Leader • Sector Specialists for each Goal
• PHDSD • Demographic and Health
• Division Chief, • Social Development Statistics Division Statistics Division
Poverty and Human • Crops Statistics Division • Income and Employment
• Vital Statistics Division Statistics Division
Development • Expenditure Accounts Division • Population and Housing
Statistics Division • Employment Demand Statistics Division Census Division
(PHDSD) • Industry Statistics Division • Statistical Standards Division
• Price Statistics Division • International Cooperation Unit
• Labor Standards and Relations • Knowledge Management and
Statistics Division Communications Division

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 23
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Conduct of National Consultation/Assessment


11-12 Multi-Sectoral Workshop
May 2016 • Conduct data assessment of the Global SDG Indicators by
accomplishing the SDG matrix based on the Philippine context
• Provide initial proxy and supplemental indicators

Multi-Sectoral 22 Oct 9-12 Oct Technical Workshop


2015 2015 Initially identify relevant SDG indicators and
Workshop
Identify relevant SDG indicators to provide inputs to the global indicator
framework
be monitored in the Philippines
Technical Workshop
Sept
Initial identification of data needed
2014
for the monitoring of the initial 17
June SDGs.
Technical Workshop
2015
Review and discuss the zero-draft of Technical Workshop
Sept
the outcome document for the UN 2013 Review and discuss the initial
Summit global post-2015 development
agenda goals and target

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 24
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

a. Content of SDG Matrix

TIER classification based on the Frequency of data collection


national and regional perspective (e.g., annual, every 2 years,
(Tier 1,2, or 3) every 3 years)
Accountable organization on
Available levels of disaggregation
(national, regional, provincial, achieving the target
municipal, sex, others)
. Relevance
Definition
(In the PDP or in the RDP)
(Global, National)

Method of computation Prioritization


(for Tiers 2 and 3)
(Global and National)

Level/s of disaggregation needed


Responsible for data collection
to make the indicator relevant
Data compiler, data provider

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Multi-sectoral Workshop on SDGs


b. The Philippine SDG Matrix (1/2)

25
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Conduct of National Consultation/Assessment


Technical
Technical
Country Workshop Bilateral
Workshop
Workshop Meetings

Assessment of Data Revolution Development of Bilateral Meetings


WASH Indicators Roadmap for the Metadata for Tier 1 with Major Data
SDGs indicators Source Agencies
• Finalize assessment
of WASH and • Discuss various tools
• Development of • Discussion of the
wastewater and techniques
metadata of SDG results of the Multi-
Indicators in SDG 6 towards building a
indicators identified Sectoral Workshop on
framework Philippine Data
as Tier 1 in the goals and indicators
Revolution Roadmap
Philippine context including identified
for the SDGs
proxy and supplemental
indicators and metadata
July 2016 December 2016
October 2016
December 2016

26
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Conduct of National Consultation/Assessment


Technical Workshop

NEDA-PSA
Workshop

• Preparation of
final Philippine
SDG indicators
for approval of
the PSA Board

April 2017

27
Republic of the Philippines II. Initiatives of 28
Philippine Statistics Authority the PSS

Reference Documents in the Assessment of the Initial List


of Philippine SDG Indicators

PSDP 2011-2017
UPDATE

Chapter 5: Ensuring People-Centered, Clean, and Efficient Governance


Chapter 6: Pursuing Swift and Fair Administration of Justice
Chapter 7: Promoting Philippine Culture and Values
Chapter 8: Expanding Economic Opportunities in Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisherie
Chapter 9: Expanding Economic Opportunities in Industry and Services through
Trabaho and Negosyo
Chapter 10: Accelerating Human Capital Development
Chapter 11: Reducing Vulnerability of Individuals and Families
Chapter 12: Building Safe and Secure Communities
Chapter 13: Reaching for the Demographic Dividend
Chapter 14: Vigorously Advancing Science, Technology, and Innovation
Chapter 15: Ensuring Sound Macroeconomic Policy
Chapter 16: Leveling the Playing Field through a National Competition Policy
Chapter 17: Attaining Just and Lasting Peace
Chapter 18: Ensuring Security, Public Order, and Safety
www.companyname.com Chapter 19: Accelerating Infrastructure Development
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Chapter 20: Ensuring Ecological Integrity, Clean and Healthy Environment
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

Summary of SDG Indicators Assessment


Tier Classification of Indicators at the National Tier I – with established
Level*
methodology , regularly
collected
41.8%
(102 indicators)
Tier II - with
29.1% established
24.6% (74 indicators)
methodology, data not
(55 indicators)
regularly collected

4.51% Tier III - no established


(13 indicators)
methodology,
methodologies are
Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Not Applicable
*Results of the series of consultative/assessment workshops based on the 244 SDG indicators
being developed/tested

29
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

7 2 13 6 8 3 4 8 4 7 3 1 4 1 10 8 13
Number of indicators
* Updated based on consultations/bilateral meetings with data source agencies

30
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

Distribution of the Tier 2 and 3 indicators, by A – Indicator is in the PDP and PSS
inclusion in the PDP and PSS Statistical Capacity has some initial activities or already
80 has concrete plans to address data
gap
70
B- Indicator is NOT in the PDP
60 (including the PDP results matrix)
but PSS has some initial activities or
Number of indicators

50 already has concrete plans to


24 52 address data gap
40

4 C-Indicator is NOT in the PDP


30 (including the PDP results matrix)
and PSS DOES NOT HAVE activities or
20 concrete plans yet to address data
25 1
gap
10 18
6 D- Indicator is in the PDP (including
0
the PDP results matrix) and PSS
Tier 2 Tier 3
DOES NOT HAVE activities or
A B C D concrete plans to address data gap

31
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators


“Approving and Adopting the Initial List of Sustainable Development Goals for Monitoring
in the Philippines” - PSA Board Resolution no. 09, Series of 2017

17GOALS
97 155
TARGETS INDICATORS
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators

63.6%
(102 indicators)

17.4% 16.1%
(28 indicators) (25 indicators)

Global (Tier 1) Proxy Supplemental

33
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators

Number of Indicators
34
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators
Distribution of the Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators,
by data source agency

Other Sources 1%

PSA - 33%
Other
government
agencies
66%

35
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG 36
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators
Distribution of the Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators

155 Philippine SDG indicators


BY SOURCE OF PRIMARY DATA,
Admin Data 66%

Survey 23%

Admin data and Survey 5%

Admin data and Census 6%

BY AVAILABLE DISAGGREGATION
Regional 66%

Provincial 42%

By Sex 84%
www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG 37
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators
Distribution of the Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators

BY AVAILABLE DISAGGREGATION (in percentage)

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG 38
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators
Distribution of the Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators

BY SOURCE AGENCY (in percentage)

www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines III. Initial SDG
Philippine Statistics Authority
Indicators
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 29 30

Goal 1

Goal 2

Goal 3

Goal 4

Goal 5

Goal 6

Goal 7

Goal 8

Goal 9
68 out 155
Goal 10 indicators are in
Goal 11 the PDP Results
Goal 12
Matrix
Goal 13

Goal 14

Goal 15 Legend: Philippine SDG indicator in the


Goal 16 draft PDP
Goal 17
Philippine SDG indicator not
in the draft PDP
39
Republic of the Philippines IV. Localizing
Philippine Statistics Authority
SDG monitoring
Initiatives on the localization
Advocacy of SDGs through the DILG activities
• Regional Workshops on Regional Strategic Priorities and
SDG Alignment (1 August – 8 September 2017)
• Provincial Strategic Direction Setting Conference
Workshops (16 August – 30 September 2017)
• Localization of the Regional Development Plan (Sept.-Nov.
2018)

Conduct of Regional SDG Assessment Workshops


• Assessment of the SDG indicators
• Identification of the proxy and supplemental indicators
• Initial list of core regional SDG indicators was presented
in the Regional Statistics Committee Summit last
September 4-5, 2018.
40
Republic of the Philippines IV. Localizing
Philippine Statistics Authority
SDG monitoring

CoRe-SDGIs
• minimum set of SDG indicators for sub-national
compilation and dissemination to facilitate sub-
national comparisons to help monitor the achievement
of the SDGs
• selected indicators should be broadly consistent with
Initial List of Philippine SDG Indicators as approved
by the PSA Board Resolution no. 09, Series of 2017

41
Republic of the Philippines IV. Localizing
Philippine Statistics Authority
SDG monitoring
Criteria for Initial CoRe-SDGIs
identifying
1) Indicators that are commonly available & tagged as
Tier I in all regions;
2) Philippine SDG indicators that were identified as
available at the regional level based on the National
Multi-sectoral Workshops and the baseline
information at the national level is already available
in our SDG Watch;
3) Classified as tier 1 in majority (70%) of the regions
based on assessment submissions;
4) If data will be coming from official statistics
(national surveys or administrative-based data
collection) known to have regional disaggregation.
42
Republic of the Philippines IV. Localizing
Philippine Statistics Authority
SDG monitoring

Initial CoRe-SDGIs

14 Goals
42 Targets
70 indicators
(62 unique indicators)
43
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
44
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Development of the Philippine Statistical Development


Program 2018-2023

PSDP 2018-2023

Chapter 26 – Sustainable Development Goals


www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
45
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Philippine Statistical Research and Training Institute


Project on SDG Indicators

A Five Year Research and Training


PSRTI Program for the Philippine Statistical
System to Measure the Sustainable
- Undertake capacity building Development Goals
activities to help PSA and other - Conduct of methodological research
agencies generate indicators to to address data gaps on SDGs
monitor the country’s/region’s (initially 41 indicators)
performance vis-à-vis the SDGs
- Trainings for local government
- Conduct methodological
researches to address issues in units/academe, which will include
generating the SDG indicators the teachers in advocating the SDG
indicators
www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
46
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Initiatives in Addressing data gaps


Measurement of MPI Admin-based data
• Training on the development • Improvement of admin-based
PSDP data to respond to the various
of methodology
2018-2023 data requirements in the SDG
Improving surveys framework
• Evidence and data on gender
Enhancing data collection
equality (EDGE)
• Time Use and completed • Adoption of the 2013 Master
trainings questions in the LFS Sample
• WASH Module on Annual •Adoption of computer-aided
Poverty Indicators Survey (APIS) personal interview (CAPI) in
• Food Security Module on the collection
National Nutrition Survey (NNS)
Improving the CRVS as data Localization of statistics Open Data Source
source
• possibility of generating allows users to find specific
• Provincial Statistical information from a rich collection
maternal mortality rate and System Dev’t
www.companyname.com of datasets
most health indicators © 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Dissemination Mechanisms

47
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Dissemination Mechanisms https://psa.maps.arcgis.com

48
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Dissemination Mechanisms
SDG WATCH

49
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

Philippine SDG Indicators Brochure

50
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
51
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps

DRAFT Philippine SDG Data Flow


❑ A national data flow (NDF) and reporting
mechanism of the SDG indicators guided by the
global data flow is currently being developed by
the PSA and the SDGFP;

❑ Data source agencies are enjoined to provide


relevant data/information and metadata for
each of the SDG indicators with the data
disaggregation needed to their respective PSA
SDG Team sector specialist for validation;
www.companyname.com
© 2016 Jetfabrik Multipurpose Theme. All Rights Reserved.
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority V. Next Steps

For the 141 Tier 2 and 3 indicators,

• Technical guidance will be sought from the IAEG-SDGs


on the development of methodology for indicators
without methodologies yet

• Ensure that other indicators with established


methodologies but are not regularly generated in the
Philippines will be considered in the development of the
Philippine Statistical Development Plan (PSDP) 2018-
2023

52
Republic of the Philippines V. Some Efforts
Philippine Statistics Authority and Next Steps
Revision of the Advance Data
Review of the Philippine SDG
Planning Tool (ADAPT) for SDGs
indicators (Tier 1, 2 and 3)
08 01 SDG Data
• Regional SDG Watch Disaggregation
• Regional Capacity
building
07 02 Project with ADB
using Big Data

Consultative Forum Finalize the


on the Core Regional
SDG Indicators 06 03 Philippine SDG
Data Flow
05
Updating of the: 04
• SDG Watch; Handbook on
• SDG Database; SDG monitoring
• SDG Webpage. 5353
Republic of the Philippines
Philippine Statistics Authority

Maraming
Salamat Po!
PSA Website:
psa.gov.ph

54

You might also like