Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Design
1
02/12/21
Research Design
02/12/21
Research Process
02/12/21
Lecture 3
Research Design
Reasoning:
Epistemology: Positivism, Inter-pretivism Deductive/Inductive
, pragmatic
Purpose:
Exploratory,
Descriptive,
Explanatory,
Approach
Strategy: Experiment,
case study, Survey,…
02/12/21
Research Reasoning
■ Deductive
■ Inductive
02/12/21
Deductive Reasoning
02/12/21
Deductive Reasoning
8
02/12/21
Deductive Reasoning
9
02/12/21
Deductive
Reasoning
1
02/12/21
0
Deductive Reasoning
From
vague
To
specific
1
02/12/21
1
Deductive Examples
1. A consumer products firm believes that professional
women are overloaded with family and work
responsibilities and strapped for time. Therefore, they
advertise that their hair coloring product can be
applied in less time than their competition's hair
coloring product.
2. A human resources department has identified public
speaking skills as an important qualifier for a
particular position. They decide to require candidates
to make an oral presentation on a predetermined topic
as a part of their second interview.
3. Management is committed to professional
development for staff members and therefore mandates
that a formal professional development plan is
incorporated into all performance reviews.
02/12/21
Inductive Reasoning
1
02/12/21
3
Inductive Reasoning
• Observing that something is true many times,
then concluding that it will be true in all instances
• Using the data to make a prediction
02/12/21
Inductive
Reasoning
02/12/21
Inductive Reasoning
From
specific
To
vague
02/12/21
Inductive Examples
■ Every windstorm in this area comes from the north. I
can see a big cloud of dust in the distance. A new
windstorm is coming from the north.
■ The chair in the living room is red. The chair in the
dining room is red. The chair in the bedroom is red. All
the chairs in the house are red.
■ Every time you eat peanuts, you start to cough. You are
allergic to peanuts.
■ Every cat that you've observed purrs. Therefore, all cats
must purr.
■ John is an excellent swimmer. His family has a
swimming pool. John's sister Mary must also be an
excellent swimmer.
02/12/21
Purpose of the Study
■ Descriptive
■ Exploratory
■ Explanatory (Causal)
02/12/21
The importance of theory
02/12/21
Descriptive Study
02/12/21
Descriptive Study
02/12/21
Descriptive Study
02/12/21
Descriptive Study
■ Example:
– A bank manager wants to have a profile of the
individuals who have loan payments outstanding for 6
months and more. It would include details of their
average age, earnings, nature of occupation,
full-time/part-time employment status, and the like.
This might help him to elicit further information or
decide right away on the types of individuals who
should be made ineligible for loans in the future.
02/12/21
Exploratory Study
02/12/21
Example on Exploratory
research:
The manager of a multinational corporation wants to know
if the work ethic values of employees working in its
branch in India is different than those of its main branch
in NewYork.
02/12/21
Explanatory study
02/12/21
Research Approach
■ Quantitative approach is likely to be associated with a deductive approach
to test a theory, using quantitative data (Saunders et al., 2012).
■ Quantitative researchers may employ strategies such as surveys and
experiments and collects data with tools that produce statistical data
(Creswell, 2012). This approach involves cause and effect thinking,
hypotheses and questions, and the test of theories.
■ This approach is suitable to establish, confirm or validate relationships and it
allows generalization of conclusions in human and social behaviors that
contribute to theory. It also enables flexible data analysis such as statistical
and comparative analysis (Thomas, 2010).
■ Quantitative approach deals mainly with numbers rather than meanings and
personal experiences. Methods associated with such approach include
experiments and questionnaires, where information is easy to statistically
analyze and are fairly reliable. This approach does not provide deep
description or generate new theories (Kiguba et al., 2012).
02/12/21
Research Approach
■ Qualitative approach involves that researchers were interested in studying
human behavior and the social world inhabited by human beings however,
they found difficulties to explain human behavior in measurable terms
therefore this approach dealing with the opinions, experiences and feelings
of individuals.
■ Qualitative researchers may employ strategies of inquiry such as case study,
grounded, and producing subjective data, non-numerical information and
implicit knowledge (Ghauri and Grønhaug, 2010).
■ In other word, this approach is more suitable to understand people’s mind
sets as the research topic is more concerned with interaction or process, or is
complex, hard to quantify, or sensitive (Lahouati, 2012). Furthermore, it is
mainly used to understand how people think and experience (Saunders,
et.al.2012).
02/12/21
Research Approach
02/12/21
Research Approach
Quantitative Qualitative
02/12/21
Research Design
Purpose:
Exploratory,
Epistemology: Positivism, Inter-pretivism Descriptive,
, pragmatic Explanatory,
Reasoning:
Deductive/Inductive
Approach
Strategy: Experiment,
case study, Survey,…
02/12/21
Research Strategies
■ Experiments
■ Survey Research
■ Case studies
■ Grounded theory
■ Action research
■ Ethnography
■ Analysis of Archival
02/12/21
Experiments
02/12/21
Survey
■ It allows considerable amount of data collection
from a high population in an economic way.
■ In addition, this strategy is a popular and common
in business research is usually associated with the
deductive approach. It is used to answer questions
such as what, where, who, and how much/many.
■ Surveys are the most common methodological
tools in explanatory studies.
■ Besides, it determines whether the information
found is more generalizable or specific to certain
unique corporations. It is possible to generate
findings that are representative of the whole
population at a lower cost than collecting the data
for the whole population, which makes it a suitable
vehicle for the research at hand.
02/12/21
Case studies
■ Case studies focus on collecting information
about a specific object, event or activity, such
as a particular business unit or organization.
■ In case studies, the case is the individual, the
group, the organization, the event, or the
situation the researcher is interested in.
■ The idea behind a case study is that in order to
obtain a clear picture of a problem one must
examine the real-life situation from various
angles and perspectives using multiple methods
of data collection.
02/12/21
Grounded theory
■ It is a systematic set of procedures to develop
an inductively derived theory from the data.
Important tools of grounded theory are
theoretical sampling, coding, and constant
comparison.
■ Theoretical sampling is “the process of data
collection for generating theory whereby the
analyst jointly collects, codes, and analyzes the
data and decides what data to collect next and
where to find them, in order to develop his
theory as it emerges”.
02/12/21
Action research
■ It is sometimes undertaken by consultants who want to initiate
change processes in organizations. In other words, action research
methodology is most appropriate while effecting planned changes.
■ Here, the researcher begins with a problem that is already
identified, and gathers relevant data to provide a tentative problem
solution. This solution is then implemented, with the knowledge
that there may be unintended consequences following such
implementation.
■ The effects are then evaluated, defined, and diagnosed, and the
research continues on an ongoing basis until the problem is fully
resolved. Thus, action research is a constantly evolving project with
interplay among problem, solution, effects or consequences, and
new solution. A sensible and realistic problem definition and
creative ways of collecting data are critical to action research.
02/12/21
Archival and Ethnography
■ Archival research makes use of administrative
records and documents as the principal source of
data. Although the term ‘archival’ has historical
connotations, it can refer to recent as well as
historical documents. An archival research strategy
allows research questions that focus upon the past
and changes over time to be answered.
■ Another strategy called Ethnography requires the
researcher to be immersed in the study setting to
understand the phenomenon being studied
(Easterby- Smith et al., 2008; Metzler and Seaman,
2013).
02/12/21
Time Horizon
■ Cross-sectional studies
■ A study can be undertaken in which data are gathered just
once, perhaps over a period of days or weeks or months, in
order to answer a research question. Such studies are called
one-shot.
■ Longitudinal studies
■ The researcher might want to study people or phenomena at
more than one point in time in order to answer the research
question. Here, because data are gathered at two different
points in time. It is carried longitudinally across a period of
time. Such studies, as when data on the dependent variable
are gathered at two or more points in time to answer the
research question.
02/12/21
Data Collection Methods
Primary / Secondary
02/12/21
Observation
•It is also a process of watching the behavior patterns
of people, objects, and occurrences with or without
questioning or communicating with them.
02/12/21
Participant observation
■ Complete participants: sees you as a
researcher attempting to become a
member of the group in which you are
performing research.
■ Complete observer: you wouldn’t reveal
the purpose of your activity to those you
are observing. However, unlike the
complete participate role, you wouldn’t
take part in the activities of the group.
02/12/21
Observation
Advantages Disadvantages
02/12/21
Survey
02/12/21
Research interviews
Definition
‘An interview is a purposeful discussion between two
or more people’
■ It is a useful data collection method, especially during the
exploratory stages of research. It is important to train the
interviewers with care in order to minimize interviewer
bias in such ways as voice inflections, differences in
wording, and interpretation. Good training decreases
interviewer bias.
■ Significance of establishing
personal contact
02/12/21
Interviewing competence
Approaches to questioning
1. Open questions: it allows participants to define and
describe the situation or event. An open is designed to
encourage the interviewee to provide an extensive and
developmental answer and may be used to reveal attitudes
or obtain facts. It encourages the interviewee to reply as
they wish. An open question is likely to start with or
include, one of the following words: ‘what’, or ‘how’, or
‘why’,.
Example:
■ Is your customer satisfied with online banking services? How do
you know?
■ What are the procedures that clients have to go through to create an
online bank account?
■ What are the main quality criteria that should be fulfilled in an
e-banking
02/12/21
website?
Approaches to questioning
2. Probing questions:Can be used to explore responses that are of
significance to the research topic. They may be worded like open
questions but request a particular focus or direction.
■ Example: Do
you think the information on your bank
is well provided through your bank’s website?
How would this criterion affect you and your
customers? Why?
3. Specific and closed questions:These types of questions
are simpler to those used in structured interviews. They can be used to
obtain specific information or to confirm a fact or opinion.
02/12/21
Types of Interview
02/12/21
Research purpose
02/12/21
Focus Group
02/12/21
Moderator for Focus Group
02/12/21
Focus Group Process
Phase Action
02/12/21
Advantages and Challenges of
Focus Groups
Advantag Can be conducted relatively quickly
es and easily; may take less staff time
than in-depth, in-person interviews;
allow flexibility to make changes in
process and questions; can explore
different perspectives; can be fun
Challenge Analysis is time consuming; possibly
s biasing the data; group may be
influenced by moderator or dominant
group members
02/12/21
Panels
• Panels, like focus groups, are another source of data collection.
• Individuals are chosen to serve as panel members for a research study. Panels
(of members) meet more than once but focus groups meet for a one-time
group session.
• In cases where the effects of certain interventions or changes are to be
studied over a period of time, panel studies are very useful.
• Example: if the effects of a proposed advertisement for a certain brand of
coffee are to be assessed quickly, the panel members can be exposed to the
advertisement and their intentions of purchasing that brand assessed.
• It is can be taken as the response that could be expected of consumers if, in
fact, they had been exposed to the advertisement.
• A few months later, the product manager might think of introducing a change
to the flavor of the same product and might explore its effects on this panel.
Thus, a continuing set of “experts” serves as the sample base or the sounding
board for assessing the effects of change. Such expert members compose the
panel.
02/12/21
Advantages and disadvantages of
audio-recording Observation/
Interviews
02/12/21
Questionnaire
■ Definition
A questionnaire is written set of questions to
which the respondent records his answers
■ Steps
1. Determine the content of the questionnaire
2. Determine the wording of the questions
3. Determine the question sequence
4. Write cover letter
02/12/21
Use of questionnaires
■ For explanatory
Can establishor
respondent.
descriptive
rapport and motivate
research Doubts
Personally administered
can be clarified.
Less expensive when administered to Take time and effort.
questionnaires
groups of respondents.
Almost 100% response rate ensured.
Anonymity of respondent is high.
■ Linked with other
Anonymity methods in a
is high.
Wide geographic regions can be Response rate is almost always low.
multiple-methods research design
reached. Token gifts can be enclosed A 30% rate is quite acceptable.
to seek Cannot clarify questions.
Mail questionnaires
compliance. Follow-up procedures for
Respondent can take more time to nonresponses
respond at convenience. Can be are necessary.
■ To collect responses from a large
administered electronically, if desired.
02/12/21
Guidelines for Questionnaire
Design
1. Principles of Wording
02/12/21
ii. Positively and Negatively Worded Questions
02/12/21
iii. Double-Barreled Questions
■ It’s a question that asks about more two or more issues but leaves room
for just a single answer. Basically, whenever you force people to
answer two questions (disguised as one) with a single answer, you’re
asking a double barreled question.
“Do you think there is a good market for the product and that it will sell
well? ”could bring a “yes” response to the first part (i.e., there is a good
market for the product) and a “no” response to the latter part (i.e., it will
not sell well for various other reasons).
■In this case, it would be better to ask two questions: (1) “Do you think
there is a good market for the product?” and (2) “Do you think the product
will sell well?”
■ How well do you get along with your managers and coworkers?
■ How pleased are you with your salary and work environment?
02/12/21
Ambiguous Questions
Even questions that are not double-barreled might be ambiguously
worded and the respondent may not be sure what exactly they
mean. An example of such a question is “To what extent would you
say you are happy?” Respondents might find it difficult to decide
whether the question refers to their state of feelings at the
workplace, or at home, or in general.
Recall- Dependent Questions
Some questions might require respondents to recall experiences from the past
that are hazy in their memory. Answers to such questions might have bias. state
when he first started working in a particular department and for how long, he may not be
able to give the correct answers and may be way off in his responses.
02/12/21
Social Desirability
Questions should not be worded such that they elicit socially
desirable responses, For instance, a question such as “Do you
think that older people should be laid off?” would elicit a
response of “no”
Length of Questions
Finally, simple, short questions are preferable to long ones. As a rule
of thumb, a question or a statement in the questionnaire should not
exceed 20 words, or exceed one full line in print.
Leading Questions
Questions should not be phrased in such a way that they lead the
respondents to give the responses that the researcher would like or
want them to give. An example of such a question is: “Don’t you
think02/12/21
that in these days of escalating costs of living, employees
Leading Questions
02/12/21
Question Sequence
Sequencing of Questions
The sequence of questions in the
questionnaire should be such that the
respondent is led from questions of a
general nature to those that are more
specific, and from questions that are
relatively easy to answer to those that are
progressively more difficult.
02/12/21
Classification Data or Personal Information
Classification data, also known as personal information or
demographic questions, elicit such information as age, educational
level, marital status, and income. Unless absolutely necessary, it is
bet not to ask for the name of the respondent.
Information on Income and Other Sensitive Personal Data
Information of a very private and personal nature such as income,
state of health, and so on, should be asked at the end of the
questionnaire.
02/12/21
Good Introduction
A proper introduction that clearly discloses the identity of the
researcher and conveys the purpose of the survey is absolutely
necessary. (Cover letter)
02/12/21
Pretesting of Structured Questions
02/12/21
Pilot Test
■ Test the questionnaire on a small sample of your subjects
first. If this is not possible, at least test it on some
colleagues or friends. The aim here is to detect any flaws
in your questioning and correct these prior to the main
survey. The piloting may enable you to convert an
open-ended question in to a closed question by
determining the range of possible answers. You may also
be able to perform a trial analysis on your pilot sample
and hence test out all your analysis procedures.
■ Having done your pilot survey, you can make
amendments that will help to maximise your response rate
and minimise your error rate on answers.
02/12/21
■Electronic Questionnaire Design and Surveys
Online questionnaire surveys are easily designed and administered when
micro-computers are hooked up to computer networks. Data disks can
also be mailed to respondents, who may use their personal computers for
responding to the questions.
02/12/21
Multi-methods of Data Collection
02/12/21
■Organizing Questions, Giving Instructions and Guidance,
and Good Alignment
five sections:
02/12/21
Validity and Reliability Test
for Survey
■ Both tests; validity and reliability tests enhance the accuracy of
the assessment and evaluations.
■ Validity and reliability are important in evaluating measurement
instruments. Thus, as a first step, data should be tested to know if
it is valid or not.
■ Validity is “concerned with the extent to which an instrument
measures what it is intended to measure” (Tavakol et al., 2011,
p.53). It refers to the extent to which an instrument measures
what it is supposed to measure correctly.
02/12/21
Validity Test
02/12/21
Reliability Test
■ Reliability concerns the extent to which a measurement of
a phenomenon provides stable and consist result
(Carmines and Zeller, 1979). Reliability is also concerned
with repeatability. For example, a scale or test is said to be
reliable if repeat measurement made by it under constant
conditions will give the same result (Moser and Kalton,
1989)
■ The most commonly used internal consistency measure is the
Cronbach Alpha coefficient.
■ Hair et al. (2007) include that Cronbach Alpha for each
construct should exceed 0.70.
02/12/21
■ What is your favorite product?
■ If you could change one thing about [product], what would it be?
■ Which other options were you considering before [product or company name]?
■ How would you feel if we did not offer this product, feature, or service?
02/12/21
RESEARCH
ETHICS
02/12/21
Ethics
02/12/21
Ethics
02/12/21
It is the researcher’s ethical responsibility to safeguard
the story teller by maintaining the understood purpose
of the research…
The relationship should be based on trust between the
researcher and participants.
02/12/21
Guidelines for designing
Questionnaire: Cover Letter
■ The cover letter is the introductory page of the
questionnaire
■ It includes:
– Identification of the researcher
– Motivation for respondents to fill it in
– Confidentiality
– Thanking of the respondent
02/12/21
Cover letter Example (Questionnaire)
02/12/21
Concluding the Questionnaire
The questionnaire should end on a courteous note, reminding
the respondent to check that all the items have been
completed, as per the example below.
Example
I sincerely appreciate your time and cooperation. Please check to
make sure that you have not skipped any questions inadvertently,
and then drop the questionnaire in the locked box, clearly marked
for the purpose, at the entrance of your department.
Thank you!
02/12/21
You are invited to participate in a research project being conducted by Mary Smith, a
graduate student in the Department of Counseling at The University of Akron. The purpose
of this research is to find out how individuals decide on what type of counseling is
appropriate for them.
If you decide to participate, you will be asked to complete an anonymous web-based survey.
The survey should take no more than 30 minutes and I hope to recruit 100 participants.
The survey will not collect any identifiable information and no one will be able to connect
your responses to you. Your anonymity is further protected by not asking you to sign and
return a consent form. Your completion of the survey will serve as your consent. Please keep
this cover letter for future reference.
If you have any questions about this study, you may call me at 330-972-1111 or my advisor,
Dr. Jones, at 330-972-2222. This project has been reviewed and approved by The University
of Akron Institutional Review Board. If you have any questions about your rights as a
research participant, you may call the IRB at (330) 972-7666.
Please return the survey in the enclosed envelope. Thank you for your participation.
02/12/21
02/12/21
Ethical Approval Form:
Project summary:
The purpose of this research project is to investigate the impact of electronic service quality
dimensions on e-banking websites in Egypt. It highlights the e-banking quality problems in
public and private banks by focusing on electronic service quality dimensions in the Internet
banking websites from both perspectives customers and Internet banker providers. Based on
reviewing the previous researches and secondary data, the current dimensions of electronic
service quality will be examined through designing and conducting both a structured
questionnaire, where data will be statistically analysed using SPSS and AHP and a
semi-structured interview, where data will be interpretively analysed using NVivo. Then, a
system dynamic approach will be applied using Powersim software. Research findings
should allow the researcher to determine, add and/ or eliminate the e-service quality
dimensions as needed. Finally, conclusions will be drawn by answering the research
questions and recommendations will be proposed.
02/12/21
Why have you been asked to participate?
You have been asked to participate because you fit the profile of
the population being studied; that is participants are between the
ages of 18 and above 65.
02/12/21
Project risks
The research involves the completion of questionnaires and participation in a
semi-structured interview which will be documented for later analysis.
It does not seek to collect any sensitive data on respondents and participants; this
study is only concerned with the Internet banking service quality and will not
discuss any immoderate behaviours. We do not think that there are any significant
risks associated with this study. However, if the respondents do feel that any of the
questions are inappropriate then the respondent can stop at any time. Furthermore,
the participant can change his/her mind and withdraw from the study at any time;
the researcher will completely respect participant’s decision.
02/12/21
How we protect your privacy?
❖ Assessment of risk
❖ Confidentiality,
❖ Informed consent
❖ Data access and ownership.
02/12/21