Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 1 of 19
LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE AND AWARENESS OF THE RESIDENTS IN SELECTED CITIES IN NEGROS
OCCIDENTAL ON THEIR HEALTHCARE RIGHTS
Alyssa Gwen M. Geroso1, Arielle Ciara B. Bajada1, Arturo Jr. D. Dejos1, Ilah Marie M. Dignos1,
Jiah Lorren T. Buenconsejo1 and Kaiye Angela T. Espora1
1
Colegio San Agustin – Bacolod, Philippines
Abstract:
Background and Aims: Determining one's level of awareness and knowledge towards Healthcare rights
is important throughout treatment as people often are unaware of their individual rights because such
rights are either not clearly stated or are contained in a bundle of paperwork that patients must sign
before registration. The study determined the extent of one’s level of awareness and knowledge
towards Healthcare rights in the three different cities namely: Bacolod City, Sagay City and Escalante City
considering variables such as the age group, sex, level of education, city of residence, if they have ever
been a patient or have visited a healthcare facility and monthly family income.
Methods: A total of 754 respondents male and female of ages 20 to 59 were qualified as the study’s
respondents. The survey questionnaires were analyzed with the use of the frequency and percentage,
Results: Out of the supposed 1,150 respondents, only 754 were gathered and qualified to participate in
the study. From these 754 respondents, using median and absolute deviation, the study found out that
in terms of age group, those who are 25-29,30-34,35-30,40-44,45-49,50-54,55-59 are fully aware and
knowledgeable than ages 20-24. Based on sex, females are fully aware as well as fully knowledgeable of
their rights than men but when taken as a whole both are moderately aware and knowledgeable. On the
level of education, respondents who have completed their high school education, which includes college
undergraduates, are fully aware and knowledgeable of their healthcare rights than elementary and
college graduates. As for the city of residence, despite Sagay being a third-class component city, they
Page 2 of 19
are fully aware as well as fully knowledgeable compared to Escalante City and Bacolod City. Based on
whether the respondents have been a patient or has visited a healthcare facility, the study found that
those who did not experience being a patient or have visited a healthcare facility are more aware and
knowledgeable. Lastly, based on the monthly family income, those who belong to the upper-middle
class are fully aware and knowledgeable as compared to those who belong to other categories.
Conclusions: Considering variables such as the age group, sex, level of education, city of residence, if
they have ever been a patient or have visited a healthcare facility and monthly family income
Introduction:
According to the World Health Organization [14], health is an important aspect of our human
rights and our notion of what it means to live a dignified life. One of the fundamental rights of every
human being, regardless of ethnicity, religion, political belief, economic or social status, is to enjoy the
best possible standard of health. This means that every patient has the right to be treated properly and
without discrimination. The promotion and protection of patient rights have become an essential and
Many countries' healthcare systems have defined certain rights for patients, and healthcare
practitioners are required to respect these rights when providing services [9]. Several declarations and
professional ethical guidelines have also been developed to ensure that all patients' fundamental human
rights and humanitarian treatment are protected and promoted. Despite these attempts to establish
and disseminate charter of patient rights, multiple studies from various countries have revealed
concerns such as patient rights violations and a lack of awareness of the patient rights legislation and its
Page 3 of 19
To protect patients' rights, the Philippines Magna Carta of Patient's Rights and Obligations of
2008, also known as Senate Bill 2371 [10], was enacted. The following rights are listed in this policy: (1)
Right to Appropriate Medical Care and Humane Treatment; (2) Right to Informed Consent; (3) Right to
Privacy and Confidentiality; (4) Right to Information; and (5) Right to Choose a Health Care Provider and
Facility.
The Universal Health Care Act [11] was signed into law in 2019 to ensure that all Filipinos have
fair access to high-quality, affordable healthcare goods and services and protection from financial risk. It
also assures that all Filipinos are health-literate, have access to suitable living environments, and are
These rights that were implemented are beneficial to the people. However, regardless of how
excellent the law is, it will never be effective until people are aware of it. People should be aware that
they are protected from health discrimination under the law. If individuals continue to be unaware of
their rights, especially those from rural areas and those with limited education, they are at risk being
exploited.
To be included in the study, the respondents must be an official resident of the three cities
included in the research locale. Such respondents shall only be between 20-59 years old. Excluded in this
study are indigenous people, those that are homeless or are considered as refugees or displaced,
individuals with incurable diseases, and individuals who are unemployed. The characteristic of
unemployed is based on the definition given by Virola [13] for the Philippine Statistics Authority. Self-
employed individuals such as public transportation drivers (i.e. tricycle drivers), street and market
vendors, and online sellers are also included in the study. Additionally, according to the Bureau of Labor
Page 4 of 19
and Statistics [4], Students are neither classified as employed or unemployed because they are not
currently looking for a job, which is why they fall under the category of ‘Persons not in the labor force’.
For this reason, people who are currently finishing a degree or a full-time student will be included in the
study, although they have no job as defined by Virola [13] and as long as they are within the designated
Ethical Consideration
The study had undergone research review through the Ethics Committee of Colegio San Agustin-
Bacolod and are still awaiting the clearance from the Committee.
Statistical Analysis
The frequency distribution and percentage frequency distribution is utilized for the first objective
in the study to determine the distribution of the respondents between the variables in the study in
terms of their age group, sex, level of education, city of residence, if they have ever been a patient or
have visited a healthcare facility, and monthly family income which will be interpreted as their income
groups. The median and median absolute deviation (MAD) method was used to answer the second and
third objectives because the data set of the study is not normally distributed.
RESULTS:
A total of 754 collected respondents made up this study; 320 (42.4%) were from Bacolod City,
235 (31.2%) were from Escalante City and 199 (26.4%) were from Sagay. All respondents completed the
researchers' survey questionnaires, which are provided in three (3) different languages for ease of
comprehension. Tables 1-6 will represent the Level of Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights
of the Respondents according to Age, Sex, Level of Education, City of Residence, Healthcare Visit and
Table 1. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents according to Age Group
Page 5 of 19
Awareness Knowledge
Moderately
20-24 443 4 0.4 Moderately Aware 3.73 0.53
Knowledgeable
Moderately
25-29 110 4.235 0.53 Fully Aware 4 0.47
Knowledgeable
Moderately
35-39 36 4.435 0.6 Fully Aware 3.965 0.635
Knowledgeable
Moderately
40-44 37 4.4 0.53 Fully Aware 4.2 0.4
Knowledgeable
Moderately
45-49 23 4.6 0.8 Fully Aware 4 0.47
Knowledgeable
Moderately
50-54 27 4.53 0.6 Fully Aware 4.2 0.6
Knowledgeable
Moderately
55-59 20 4.435 0.4 Fully Aware 4 0.53
Knowledgeable
Moderately
Total 754 4.13 0.53 Moderately Aware 3.93 0.53
Knowledgeable
Those who are 25-29, 30-34, 35-30, 40-44, 45-49, 50-54, 55-59 are fully aware knowledgeable than
ages 20-24. Ages 30-34 are fully knowledgeable than other age groups. The age groups which have the
highest median of 4.73 is of ages 30-34 for the awareness and knowledge. While those ages 20-24 got
the lowest median of 4 for knowledge and ages 40-44 also got the lowest median of 0.4 for the
knowledge.
Table 2. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents according to Sex
Page 6 of 19
Awareness Knowledge
Moderately
Male 268 4.00 0.53 Moderately Aware 3.80 0.53
Knowledgeable
Moderately
Female 486 4.20 0.53 Moderately Aware 3.93 0.50
Knowledgeable
Moderately
Total 754 4.13 0.53 Moderately Aware 3.93 0.53
Knowledgeable
Females have a higher level of awareness with a median of 4.20 than males. But, males are
more knowledgeable with a median of 0.53 than females. When taken as a whole, both sexes showed
that they are moderately aware and knowledgeable of their rights as a patient.
Table 3. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents according to the Level
of Education
Page 7 of 19
Awareness Knowledge
Median
Level of Median Abs-
N Median Abs- Interpretation Median Interpretation
Education Deviation
Deviation
Elementary Somewhat
4 3.73 0.53 Moderately Aware 3.00 0.47
Graduate Knowledgeable
Highschool Moderately
295 4.27 0.60 Fully Aware 3.80 0.47
Graduate Knowledgeable
College Moderately
401 4.07 0.47 Moderately Aware 3.93 0.53
Graduate Knowledgeable
Moderately
Total 754 4.13 0.40 Moderately Aware 3.93 0.53
Knowledgeable
Respondents who have completed their high school education, which includes college
undergraduates, have the highest level of awareness and knowledge regarding healthcare rights. This
result is followed by college graduates, then elementary and those who have not completed any level of
education. Respondents who have completed their high school education got the highest median of 4.27
in awareness which is interpreted as fully aware while college graduates got the highest median of 3.93
and is interpreted as moderately aware. Moreover, respondents who have completed their elementary
education got the lowest median of 3.73, which is interpreted as moderately aware. College graduates
and respondents who have not completed any level of education have the most consistent responses
Page 8 of 19
with the Median Absolute Deviation value of 0.47, and the high school graduates have the most
inconsistent responses with a Median Absolute Deviation value of 0.60 in the awareness while college
graduates as well as those elementary and high school graduates have the most inconsistent responses.
Table 4. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents according to the City of
Residence
Awareness Knowledge
Moderately Moderately
Bacolod City 320 4.13 0.53 3.80 0.50
Aware Knowledgeable
Moderately Moderately
Escalante City 235 4.07 0.47 3.87 0.53
Aware Knowledgeable
Moderately
Sagay City 199 4.27 0.47 Fully Aware 4.00 0.53
Knowledgeable
Moderately Moderately
Total 754 4.13 0.40 3.93 0.53
Aware Knowledgeable
Respondents who are residing in Sagay City are fully aware and knowledgeable regarding
patient’s rights than those who live in Bacolod and Escalante City who are both moderately aware of
their rights. Sagay City has a median of 4.27 in the awareness and 4.00 in knowledge. Also having an
Table 5. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents in relation if the
Page 9 of 19
Awareness Knowledge
If the Respondents
have visited or was a Media Median Abs- Median Abs-
N Interpretation Median Interpretation
patient before in a n Deviation Deviation
healthcare facility
Moderately Moderately
Yes 570 4.07 0.53 3.90 .69693
Aware Knowledgeable
Moderately Moderately
No 184 4.20 0.40 4.00 .80851
Aware Knowledgeable
Moderately Moderately
Total 754 4.13 0.53 3.93 0.53
Aware Knowledgeable
Those who have not been a patient before or visited a healthcare facility has been found to be
more aware and knowledgeable with a median of 4.20 in awareness and 4.00 in knowledge than those
who have been a patient or visited a healthcare facility with a median of 4.07 in awareness and 3.90 in
knowledge.
Table 6. Awareness and Knowledge on Health Care Rights of the Respondents according to the
Page 10 of 19
Awareness Knowledge
Media Media
Monthly Family Media n Abs- Media n Abs-
Interpretation N Interpretation Interpretati
Income n Deviati n Devia
on tion
Between PhP
Low income Moderately Moderate
10,957 - PhP 217 4.13 0.53 3.80 0.47
(but not poor) Aware Knowledgea
21,914 per month
Between PhP
Lower middle Moderately Moderate
21,915 - PhP 229 4.07 0.47 3.87 0.53
income Aware Knowledgea
43,828 per month
Between PhP
Middle middle Moderately Moderate
43,829 - PhP 119 4.20 0.60 4.00 0.53
class Aware Knowledgea
76,699 per month
Between PhP
Upper Middle Moderate
77,700 - PhP 66 4.30 0.47 Fully Aware 4.07 0.53
Class Knowledgea
131,484 per month
Between PhP
Upper Income Moderately Moderate
131,485 to PhP 35 4.13 0.53 3.87 0.40
(but not rich) Aware Knowledgea
219,140 per month
Those who belong to a monthly family income that ranges between PhP 77,700 - PhP 131,484
per month are fully aware and moderately aware of their rights as patients than those who belong to
less than PhP 77,700, Between PhP 131,485 to PhP 219,140 and atleast PhP 219,141 per month.
Discussions
Page 11 of 19
The study is focused on determining the level of awareness and knowledge of the residents of
Bacolod City, Sagay City and Escalante City. In this study, the researchers considered variables such as
the age group, sex, level of education, city of residence, if the respondents have ever been a patient or
have visited a healthcare facility, and monthly family income as determining factors for awareness and
knowledge. After an in-depth investigation, collection, and analysis of data for this study, the
researchers were able to come up with findings that can aid in answering the objectives of this study.
The knowledge and awareness data of the study was interpreted as skewed or not normally
distributed. The level of awareness of the respondents according to their age group showed that those
between the age group of 30-34 years old are observed to have the highest level of awareness with a
median of 4.73 and is considered as fully aware whereas those age group which falls between 20-24
years old have the lowest median of 4, which is deemed as moderately aware. For their Median
Absolute Deviation, the highest value is 0.8 which falls under the age group of 45-49 years old. This
result is considered as the one having the most inconsistent responses while those that are between the
age group of 20-24 years old and 55-59 years old are found to have the lowest Median Absolute
Deviation which is 0.4 and is found to have the most consistent responses. In terms of level of
knowledge according to their age group, the results of the study showed similarities found in its
awareness counterpart, wherein the age group that has the highest level of knowledge belong to those
that are between ages 30-34 years old with a median value of 4.33. The age group that got the lowest
level of awareness are those that belong between the age group of 20-24 years old which got the
median value of 3.73. For their Median Absolute deviation, the age group that got the highest value of
0.7 are those that are between the age group of 30-34 years old which is considered to have the most
inconsistent responses and those that got the lowest value of 0.13 are those age group that are
between 40-44 years old which is deemed to have the most consistent responses. According to the
study of Agrawal et al. [1], younger adults were more aware than any other age groups. In the said
Page 12 of 19
study, the younger adults are those that are 18-35 years old, 107 participated and got the percentage of
30.6%. Same as true with the study of Yaghobian et al. [16] where age affects the level of awareness of
the respondents.
The level of awareness of the respondents according to their sex showed that females have a
higher level of awareness followed by males. When taken as a whole, both sexes showed that they are
moderately aware of their rights as a patient. In terms of knowledge, females are observed in the study
to be more knowledgeable with the median value of 3.93 than males who have the median value of
3.80. Moreover, females also have more consistent responses with a Median Absolute Deviation value
of 0.50 than males who have 0.53. The study of Agrawal et al. [1] also shows that females are more
aware of their rights. This also does holds true with the study of Ebrahimi et al. [6] in terms in the level
of knowledge.
The level of awareness according to the level of education of respondents showed that
respondents who have completed high school education, which includes college undergraduates, are
fully aware about their healthcare rights. It is followed by elementary and college graduates, and those
who have not completed any level of education are interpreted as moderately aware of healthcare
rights. While respondents who have completed their elementary education got the lowest median with
3.73 that is interpreted as least aware. College graduates are the most knowledgeable about their
healthcare rights with the median value of 3.93 and Elementary graduates are the least knowledgeable
about their healthcare rights with a median value of 3.00. According to Gallego & Vázquez-Navarrete [8],
Bateni et al. [3], and Tabassum et al. [12], respondents with low educational attainment are interpreted
as the least likely to be aware of their healthcare rights. Similarly, in this study, the respondents with
two of the lowest educational attainment are the least aware of their healthcare rights.
The level of awareness according to the city of residence showed that the respondents who are
residing in Sagay City are fully aware regarding patient’s rights than those who live in Bacolod and
Page 13 of 19
Escalante City who are both moderately aware of their rights. Sagay City has a median value of 4.27 and
a median absolute deviation of 0.47 compared to the cities of Escalante and Bacolod which has a median
of 4.07 and 4.13 respectively, and a median absolute deviation of 0.47 and 0.53 respectively. Moreover,
those who live in Bacolod City had more samples compared to Escalante City which had 235 samples
and Sagay City which had 199 samples. In this study, all three cities demonstrated a moderate
knowledge regarding patient’s rights with Sagay City being the highest among the three and Bacolod
City being the lowest. In contrast with the results of this study, Fotaki [7] showed that respondents from
an urban city are the best and well-informed when it comes to their rights, which does not hold true in
this study as Sagay City have the most aware respondents, even if it is only considered as a 3 rd class-
component city.
The level of awareness in relation to if the respondents have visited a healthcare center or was a
patient showed that the extent of awareness of respondents in relation to having visited a healthcare
facility or experienced being a patient in such facilities. It shows that people who have not experienced
being a patient or have never visited a healthcare facility have a higher median of 4.20 and lower
median absolute deviation of 0.40 than patients who have visited a healthcare facility or experienced
being a patient. In their study, they have used frequency to show the results while in this study, the
researchers used the median and abs-deviation in presenting the data. Moreover, it shows that there
are more people who have visited a healthcare facility or experienced being a patient than those who do
not. Those who have not visited a healthcare facility or experienced being a patient are more
knowledgeable than those who experienced being a patient or have visited a healthcare facility.
The level of awareness according to monthly income showed that those who belong to a
monthly family income that ranges between PhP 77,700 - PhP 131,484 per month are more fully aware
of their rights as patients than those who belong to less than PhP 77,700. A descriptive study by Gallego
& Vázquez-Navarrete [8] in Colombia that compared two cross-sectional studies in 2000 and 2010,
Page 14 of 19
showed that the most disadvantaged groups are those of low socioeconomic status and are the least
likely to be aware of their rights. In their study, the researchers used a univariate analysis, frequencies
and percentages estimated for each year. Their sample also comprised male and female users but of
different ages ranging from 13 to more than 65 years of age. While in this study, the data was collected
within two weeks, and the age group is between 20-59 years old, male and female. Moreover, it shows
that those who belong to a monthly family income interpreted as poor had the lowest knowledge on
their healthcare rights as compared to the upper middle class with 4.07 showing that they are more
knowledgeable.
Conclusion
Taking everything into account, the study discovered that in terms of age group, when it comes
to their healthcare rights, those between the ages of 20 and 24 are the least aware and knowledgeable,
while those between the ages of 30 and 34 are the most aware and knowledgeable. Females are more
aware and informed about their rights than males, yet both are relatively aware and knowledgeable
when viewed as a whole. On the basis of the level of education, college graduates are shown to be more
aware and knowledgeable than individuals who have completed less than a bachelor's degree. As for the
city of residence, despite being classified as a third-class component city, Sagay City was discovered to
be fully aware and knowledgeable when compared to Escalante City and Bacolod City. Based on
whether the respondent has been a patient or has visited a healthcare facility, the study found that
those who have done neither are fully aware and knowledgeable, higher than their counterpart. Lastly,
based on the monthly family income, those who belong to the upper-middle class are fully aware and
Overall, the residents' total awareness of their patient rights was found to be moderate in this
study. The same is also true in terms of knowledge, with data indicating that residents as a whole had a
moderate knowledge of patient rights. When compared to the outcomes of most research concerning
Page 15 of 19
patient rights awareness and knowledge, these findings are satisfactory. Despite this, there should still
be efforts made for future improvement, as there are still numerous areas identified in this survey that
appear to reveal individuals still having insufficient knowledge of their patients' rights.
Acknowledgements
The completion of the work could not have been possible without the assistance of people
whose names may not all be mentioned. Their contributions were very-well appreciated and
acknowledged. The group would like to express their deepest gratitude particularly to the following: Mr.
Alain P. Juayang, Ms. Desiree Diel; and Mr. Paolo Hilado for their kind and understanding spirit and for
providing invaluable guidance throughout this research. It is the researchers’ privilege to work on the
research under their guidance. Secondly, the researchers would like to acknowledge the guidance of Mr.
Eduardo Bacodio Jr. as the statistician of the paper, without whom interpretation of the data would not
have been possible. The researchers are also grateful to their parents, relatives and friends who shared
their love, prayer and support either morally and emotionally. Above all, praise and thank God, the
Almighty, the source of their knowledge and wisdom, for his shower of blessings throughout the
research process.
The researchers declare no conflict of interest or funding from any institution or agency.
Data Availability
The researchers declare that the data supporting the findings of this study are available within
the study.
Authors’ Contribution
The study was carried out in collaboration with all authors. AGMG, ADD, IMMD and JLTB did
Chapter 1. AGMG, ACBB, IMMD and JLTB did Chapter 2. AGMG and ACBB did Chapter 3. ACBB , ADD.
IMMD, JLTB and KATE did the interpretation and analysis of data. AGMG has contributed to the journal
Page 16 of 19
contents, action plan, questionnaire and made the PowerPoint presentations. ACBB has contributed on
the research instrument, appendices, supervised the overall research process and revisions and editing
of the manuscript. ADD has contributed to the statistical tools, acknowledgment, journal contents and
questionnaire. IMMD has contributed to the ethical clearance and recommendations. JLTB has
contributed to the questionnaire, research locale, recommendations, action plan, summary and
managed the journal and poster contents. KATE corrected the study’s tenses and grammar. All the
authors did the data collection, helped in the REC assessment forms and editing the manuscript.
References:
1. Agrawal, U., D'Souza, B. C., & Seetharam, A. M. Awareness of Patients' Rights among Inpatients
of a Tertiary Care Teaching Hospital- A Cross-sectional Study. Journal of clinical and diagnostic
https://doi.org/10.7860/JCDR/2017/24961.10544.
2. Al-Saadi, A. N., Slimane, S., Al-Shibli, R. A., & Al-Jabri, F. Y. Awareness of the Importance of and
Adherence to Patients' Rights Among Physicians and Nurses in Oman: An analytical cross-
sectional study across different levels of healthcare. Sultan Qaboos University medical journal.
3. Bateni, S., Sajadi, Z., & Hoseini, M. Patient’s Knowledge about Patients’ Rights Legislation. Health
4. Bureau of Labor and Statistics. How the Government Measures Unemployment. U.S. Bureau of
5. Council of Europe. Details of Treaty No.005. Council of Europe. 2014. Retrieved from
https://www.coe.int/en/web/conventions/full-list/-/conventions/treaty/005.
Page 17 of 19
6. Ebrahimi, S., Fozooni, H., & Hosseini, S. (Knowledge on Patients’ Rights in Medical Interns: A
https://sites.kowsarpub.com/thrita/articles/57837.html.
7. Fotaki M. Users’ perceptions of health care reforms: Quality of care and patient rights in four
regions in the Russian Federation. Social Science & Medicine. 2006; 63(6), 1637-1647. Retrieved
from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.04.033.
8. Gallego, M. E., & Vázquez-Navarrete, M. Awareness of the healthcare system and rights to
healthcare in the Colombian population. Gaceta Sanitaria. 2013; 27(5), 398-405. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaceta.2012.11.012.
9. Joolaee, S., Tschudin, V., Nikbakht-Nasrabadi, A., & Parsa-Yekta, Z. Factors affecting patients'
rights practice: the lived experiences of Iranian nurses and physicians. International Nursing
10. Philippines Magna Carta of Patient’s Rights and Obligations of 2008: Senate Bill 2371. Senate of
11. Universal Health Care Act of 2019: Republic Act No. 11223. Retrieved from
https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/downloads/2019/02feb/20190220-RA-11223-RRD.pdf.
12. Tabassum, T., Ashraf, M., & Thaver, I. Hospitalized Patients' Awareness Of Their Rights-A Cross
Sectional Survey In A Public And Private Tertiary Care Hospitals Of Punjab, Pakistan. Journal of
13. Virola, R. A. WHO ARE THE UNEMPLOYED IN THE PHILIPPINES? (How to identify them using the
https://psa.gov.ph/sites/default/files/vol9_18.pdf.
14. World Health Organization. Health is a fundamental human right. 2017. Retrieved from
https://www.who.int/news-room/commentaries/detail/health-is-a-fundamental-human-right.
Page 18 of 19
15. Woogara J. Human rights and patients' privacy in UK hospitals. Nursing ethics. 2001; 8(3), 234–
16. Yaghobian, M., Kaheni, S., Danesh, M., & Rezayi Abhari, F. Association between awareness of
patient rights and patient's education, seeing bill, and age: a cross-sectional study. Global
https://doi.org/10.5539/gjhs.v6n3p55.
Page 19 of 19