Professional Documents
Culture Documents
flickr cc 59937401@N07
Why did Board of Innovation
When should I use it?
make a tool to explore ways to find new revenues?
As an agency specialised in business model innovation, we support This flowchart will be most effective in one of the following 2 use cases:
our clients to develop sustainable new revenue streams. By asking • You have a new idea and you are wondering if you can monetise it.
the right questions, different options to ‘cash in on your new idea’ will • You already developed your business model and you would like to
arise. Unfortunately, we can’t be everywhere at the same time. That’s challenge your current monetisation strategy.
why we made a flowchart to help you and your team to discuss the
alternative monetisation tactics & pricing options. Note: This is not a scientific tool. Don’t expect the ultimate solution.
Of course! How Will users have to give their Do you believe other companies Do you dream of
can I let them personal details in order to use would have interest in targeting Check! making even more
your product/service? your user base? money with this idea?
pay otherwise?
14. Advertising
Not really...
Do you think your users could No! Ads, are
feel uncomfortable if all their It's not about the
you crazy?
friends know that they use ability to pay. I'm
Obviously...
your product/service ? Do you want more than one just not sure if
contact moment with your 15. Affiliate/
everyone will pay! Referral
user? Shht... user data
Not relevant Do you generate user-data
is our competitive
for my product! relevant for others?
High chance that you'll advantage! Remember:
Not Advice to
find more reasons for You can only walk
necessary! Do you want to offer a 16. Data Resell trusted
users to pay! product/service to people No! this road once!
8. Privacy/ partner
that can't afford it?
Anonymity is fine!
For example:
They would be
devastated if Does your product/service Exactly! 17. Matchmaking
remember previous use of a platform
their user data user? (eg. memory card) Yes,
Are there any complementary Do you want to have an
was lost! services/products to your offer Yes! integrated solution that seems Integrated
Can the user receive a higher Not at all, they already 1. Early Exit
7. Loss/Aversion status by using the product? In fact, yes!
use everything they have! Does your product need a critical Is it your goal to have
Absolutely! Nope! Definitely!
amount of users to show it's value? direct revenue from this
product/service?
What would that mean ! What would that mean ! What wou
regret this! want them to pay? Your journey requires
than the smell F*ck off!
a teleportation! Find
of fresh money
Hmmm... the exit...
in the morning... Making money on your product seems to be a tough one. Ever played Monopoly?
Get out of your comfort zone! It's innovate or die.
Close...
! !
11. Helping peers/ 12. Exclusivity/ but yet so far...
9. Mystery/Surprises
Gifts Limited Availability
#Awesome! You have some Would you like proof of Damn right
Do you want the user to own the
options that your users Yes! interest from your users
might be willing to pay for.
product once they pay?
before you launch? about that!
What would that mean ! What would that mean ! What wou
for your idea?
for your idea?
for yo
! !
Rules of the game: Rules of the game: Try to imagine… Try to imagine… Try to
• Start from a concrete idea • Check cards to understand the
• Continue until you are at a location where monetisation principle if you need some
you have been already (vicious cycle!) clarification or examples.
Rules of the game:
• Check all answers before choosing a path • It’s totally ok to peak into the revenue
• Take all outcomes into consideration
• Don’t judge yet, seriously! cards that you didn’t have as an outcome For example:
• Translate10. the theoretical
Convenience/ shortcuts outcome
from the flowchart ;)
into concrete ways to earn money
• Ask all team members to come up
Download all files for free: with their own translation
What would that mean ! What would that mean ! What wou
www.boardofinnovation.com/FindNewRevenue for your idea?
for your idea?
for yo
! !
Try to imagine… Try to imagine… Try to
Free! Value
For the user. Proposition
#1 Vanity/Reputation Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Pro and Business versions of Windows do not differ that much in features, Gamers of World of Warcraft often pay to fit in, for exclusivity, to show
while Pro is priced much higher than the basic version. But wait… Do you commitment or simply to show off to the starters (aka .#noobs) in the game.
want to be the one opening your ‘Windows Home Edition’ with a new client? It’s all about perception!
Free! Value
#2 Loss/Aversion
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
A technique used by drugs dealers for many years and also known as locking-in
customers: give something for free (or cheap) and provide lots of hassle (€ or
effort) when they want to change to a different alternative.
1. Dropbox 2. Seven
Dropbox is the most expensive player in the cloud storage market, but they
Seven is a fitness app with a goal to workout each day for 7 months. If you
were first and everyone integrated 3rd party services with their dropbox
miss a day, you lose a heart. Once you lose your 3 hearts, you have to start
account. Who knows what might stop working once you switch to an
again from zero. Expert tip: Extra hearts can be bought ;).
alternative?
Free! Value
For the user. Proposition
#3 Privacy/Anonymity Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
When you don’t want other people to find out who is using the service, users
might want to pay for this matter.
Anonymity is crucial when you want to hide what you are doing.
Vanilla Visa is a gift or reward card that works the same as a normal
DateMeKenya has the anonymity feature only available for their paying
creditcard but without identification. Fees are higher than regular credit
members. You don’t want your husband/wife to find out that you are dating,
cards but the money is untraceable.Expert hint: Extra hearts can be bought ;).
right?
Free! Value
For the user. Proposition
#4 Mystery/Surprises Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Giving people a reason to believe that they might win a lottery creates customer
experience. Not knowing what’s coming can often be exciting!
Birchbox is a subscription service that sends you (or someone that received it No payment trigger that the gaming industry doesn’t use! In this mystery
as a gift) a monthly box full of cosmetics. You won’t know what’s inside until crate you have a (small) chance of finding rare items (eg. crystal sword). You
you open it and that’s why it’s so much fun to find in your mailbox. might call it a virtual lottery.
Free! Value
#5 Convenience/ For the user. Proposition
You want to send a camera to your brother abroad but you hate the hassle
The power of ‘Zynga-like’ games is the simple choice e.g. when you want to
with sending? Shyp will be your best friend! You simply take a picture of the
grow a plant you can: grind (click 5000x), spam (invite 50 friends for double
camera, choose the destination and Shyp comes to pick it up within 30
speed) or pay (#coins).
minutes.
Free! Value
#6 Helping Peers/ For the user. Proposition
Think about this as paying a round of drinks in a pub with your friends. You will
get instant social status as a result. Giving something valuable to someone you
care about creates satisfaction.
You check Baekdal Plus, a website full of in-depth research articles and you
A small world is a social network for the #UltraRich. If you are not part of it,
find a highly relevant article for your colleague. Baekdal Plus lets you share
you wont be ‘one of them’. To get access, you need an invite. To get an invite,
that $20 article for free if you have subscription ($9/month). Great deal, isn't
you need to pay. Get it?
it?!
Free! Value
#7 Exclusivity/
For the user. Proposition
Vertu offers a phone for a stunning €12 000 and you know what? People pay! Instead of selling copies to all their fans, Wu-Tang Clan released just one copy
The reason: it’s your key to exclusive services (e.g. a concierge to call in any of its secret Album. Musea can rent the album to offer fans to listen the
circumstance) and events. album once for $40/time.
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
#8 Non monetary
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
There is no such thing as a free lunch! Apart from direct revenue, companies
launch products/services for other reasons: user base, prestige, contact details,
etc.
1. Whatsapp
Mobile messaging with friends all over the world is becoming
Service more popular than social media. WhatsApp had 450Mio users
HQ
Inc (and their address book) when acquired by Facebook for
$16Bio. Fact: WhatsApp had no revenue model at that time.
MyStartup.com 5 Consumer
#9 Tip jar/Donation
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Some products need a lot of users to function appropriately. Some people will
highly appreciate what they get. Giving these people a chance to show this
appreciation in a gift (€) is a tip jar/donation.
1. Wikipedia
HQ
Inc
Information
5
MyStartup.com Consumers
Donation
2. Amazon Smile
#10 Barter
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
1. homeexchange.com
HQ
Inc
Platform
Product Product
MyStartUp.com
5
Commission
Consumer Consumer
Product
#11 Freemium
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Segmenting your user base in users that get the service for free and users that
pay, is called a freemium business model. The paying customers usually have
access to superior features.
1. Spotify
2. Dropbox
Dropbox gives more online space to their PRO users that paid
for the service. Meanwhile, Business users have unlimited
space and extra services for teams to collaborate.
Free! Value
#12 Pay-what-you- For the user. Proposition
2 Examples to turn theory into practice
Similar to donation but with a stronger focus on revenues, not users. Here you
get to choose what you pay for the product. Only works when variable costs are
negligible (e.g. music, games, virtual books, software, etc.)
1. Humble Bundle
Humble Bundle offers book and game bundles for a price that
you choose yourself. If you are one of the top payers, you
receive limited bonus books/games.
HQ
Inc
Information
5
MyStartup.com Consumers
Money
2. 8k design agency
Offer what you want for their services and they pick the offers
they like. Apart from money, value drivers for 8k could be:
availability of their designers, big brands for their portfolio, etc.
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
For the user. Proposition
#13 Get one-Give one Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Sometimes you want to target a user segment that simply can’t afford your
product in any way. The decision to make another segment pay double has been
made for charity: laptops, flash lights, etc.
2. Starbucks campaign
#14 Advertising
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
The user becomes the product. Companies pay to reach the customers of your
service. The desired result is to drive consumer behaviour with respect to a
commercial offering.
1. Metro News
2. Pinterest
When referring your customers to another company, you are driving their sales.
Depending on the product and program, 5-10% of the product price, is a good
indicator of the lead fee you’ll receive.
1. FindGift.com
FindGift helps people to find the right gift. Once the service
guided you to what you want to buy, you will be directed to the
website of their partner. If you buy, FindGift gets paid.
2. ASAP54
ASAP54 is the Shazam for fashion. If you see something you like,
the app will tell you what it is and where you can buy it. Often
you will even get a direct buying link. Well, that’s convenient
(and #smart). Good integration is the key!
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
1. PatientsLikeMe
PatientsLikeMe offers a valuable (and free) P2P service for
people searching for the best treatment of their disease.
Anonymous data is sold to pharma, so they can come up with
better treatments as well.
2. Data Coup
When matching 2 relevant parties to each other, both value your service and
might pay for it. Dating platforms are the best known example of matchmaking
platforms.
5
1. Jobr
Money
Jobr is a ‘Tinder’ for jobs matching companies with open
applications (and looking for ‘the perfect applicant’) with
applicants searching for ‘their perfect job’.
Consumer
Service
HQ
Inc
Experience Experience
My organization
Service
2. Babelverse
Consumer
5
A marketplace always has clear supply and demand. Bringing these 2 sides
together might require a platform (marketplace) or a serviceprovider (broker)
The one delivered most value to is mostly the one that pays the commission fee
(buyer, seller or both).
HQ
Inc 1. Airbnb
Platform Commission
Money
Consumer Consumer
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
This is how most products are sold. You pay a one time fee and you own the
product or you receive access to a lifetime service.
1. A banana
You buy it. You draw a face on it to extent it’s lifetime for 3
more minutes. You eat it. You’re done.
HQ
Inc
Service Product
MyStartUp.com 5
Consumer
One-Time Fee
2. VPN Unlimited
#20 Subscription
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
A subscription is a service you sell in a certain timeframe. The service can vary:
receiving a newspaper every day, using a cloud service (software), being able to
call car assistance when needed, etc.
Adobe Creative Suite has had a ‘single purchase for life’ for a
long time. Now they switched to a cloud service: you only pay
for what you need for the time you need it. According to Adobe
it’s cheaper. Disclaimer: They are lying :).
HQ
Inc
Service
MyStartUp.com 5
Consumer
Subscription
#21 Leasing
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Customers receive a physical product for a limited period to fulfil their needs.
Within the leasing period, a product can only serve the needs of one customer
(exclusive use).
1. LeasePlan
5
Inc HQ
Inc
Company MyStartUp.com 5
Consumer
2. Lease a Jeans
Not much people think about it, but leasing is a revenue model
used for other goods as well: diamonds, bags, jackets and yes,
jeans as well. Hint: check www.mudjeans.com
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
#22 Pay-per-use
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Some products are only used a limited amount of times per customer (a car is idle
97% of the time on average). Paying only for the times you need a product/
service creates flexibility and increases the value per use.
1. Blendle
HQ
Inc
Service
MyStartUp.com 5
Consumer
Did you know that the average car is idle 97% of the time?
Paying only for that 3% does makes sense! Our world would
need 30 times less cars. Here: a car vending machine in China
where you pay $3,5 per hour.
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
For the user. Proposition
#23 Dynamic pricing Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
A pricing strategy with highly flexible prices for products or services based on
different variables: demand-based, time-based , profile-based, etc.
1. Qatar Airways
Price based on
HQ
Inc one or multiple variables
My organization Consumer
Service
2. SF Park
When customers are not able to pay for the entire product, you can allow them
to buy it together with peers. Another variation of buying together with peers is
‘group buying’ to achieve a discount on everyones product or service.
HQ
Inc
Shared Product
MyStartUp.com Consumer
5
Consumer
Product
2. Share a car
Owners
This could be your car-sharing calendar: brown is your
neighbour’s holiday in Spain. Red are your important meetings
in Paris. The rest of the time the car is available.
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
#25 Pre-Sales
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
1. The Dash
HQ
Inc
Service % Commission
Small Reward
5
Community
Member
Small Micro-Funding
Large Reward
Fund Seeker
Community 2. Pave
5 Member
Large Macro-Funding Funding Pave is a service to fund students for expensive universities. As
Crowd a student, you pay part of your wage to the investors once your
start earning.
Free! Value 2 Examples to turn theory into practice
For the user. Proposition
#26 Up-selling Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
aka. Add-ons. Some customers might have deeper pockets than you think.
Always allow them them to spend all the money they have! The gaming industry
understands this aspect, the music industry does not.
1. Audi
HQ
Inc
The entry level Audi R8 has a ‘modest’ price tag of €120k. By
Free/Cheap Product requesting a more luxury interior, extra options or some extra
horse power, you will have to pay extra. An Audio R8 full option
would cost you more than €250k.
MyStartUp.com 5 Consumer
Low Price
Upgrade
2. Wordpress Support
5
#27 Razor-blade
For the user. Proposition
Third Party
Pricing tactic
pays the bill
Revenues are spread over the lifetime of a product. After a flat fee, customers
have recurring expenses they can’t refuse. (e.g. Razor blades, coffee pads,
updates GPS devices, etc.)
1. Nespresso
“An update is still cheaper then a new GPS system, right?” This
is exactly how Tomtom and Garmin made big money for years.
Users choose to either pay or use outdated maps.
their if onta n
user ct m t more t
data ome han Do y
was nt on o
lost Doe user with yo e wou u believ
! ? ur ld ha e
s
rem your pr ve in other c
o
emb odu It's
not your terest in mpanie
High user er prev ct/serv abou user t s
chan
ce t
? (eg io
. me us use e
ic Not abilit t th base argeting
find hat mor o y to e ?
mor you'l y ca f a nece pay.
e re l rd) ssar just I'm
ason y! not Not Chec
user s fo s ure really k!
s to r ever if ...
pay! yone
Not Do y will p
relev ay!
ant ! prod ou wan
uct/ t to
offe
Abso
lutely that service ra Ads,
can't to
! Yes, affo people are
Can rd it Do y you 14. A
th that ? ou g craz
stat e user r wou rele enerate y?
dver
tisin
us b
y us eceive a be u ld g
sefu Exa vant u
for o ser-dat
e sta ing t
he p higher l! ct ly! a
tu ther
user s only b rodu
ct?
s? Shh
t... u
base e Do y ser
of yo relevant o is o data
ur p res ur use ur c
omp
rodu
ct? Don't user ources rs have No! etitiv
forg s) no th no adva e
to c et Nop rma e comp n mone ntag
heck e! lly w a t e!
this ould ny (or o ary
one have th
No!
Amo as w Did to p er
ngst ell! yo Not ay fo
sign u deve at a r? Are
ever ific lop ll, th
t
serv here an
yone the b antly m a featu use
! or re ever ey a ices y co 16. D
est a
ltern e conve /produc ythin lread /p m
g th y that roduct plemen ata R
esell
ative nien t ey h your st ta
Wo u
ld user t than ave! user o your o ry Adv
hare users v s ha
ve?
s ex
pect ffer
the p alu ?
rodu e the po In fa My trus
ct w s c t, y prod Yes!
ith t sibility es! uct part
heir t they is all n
peer o D
s? O ne need
! inte o you w is fin
Hell Lapt grat ant t
yeah op P e
! No... er Ch
ild to b d solut o have a
Doe e yo ion t n
ur o
13. G
et s
amo your pr wn o hat seem
Wha Give one - unt fferin s
! No, ta one of us oduct n g? Yes,
it w box bout of ers t ee
o sh d a crit Integ
ould with ferin ow it ic rate
lowe wha out tell g a 's va al d
r th t's in in lue? Solu
e side g tion
value ? 3. Ba Nop
! rter e, no Defin
Char critic itely! It's
Not ity? mas al not
kno No t s ne abou
wing hank eded the t
10. C wha s! ! Is it
mon
onv t's c
omin Serio dire your go ey!
Sho enience is a g usly? ct re al to
rtcu / lway We
v
prod enue fr ave
h
ts s k not are
of e ind living Is th uct/ o
serv m this
xcitin Midd in th e va ice?
g! le Ag e r
non iabel co
es a -exis s
nym tent t per ex
Sou ore! or n t
nds eglig ra user
like ible?
gamb Tha
ling! t's w
F *c k We hy
12 off! do h we Of c
Limit . Exclus ave mak ours
extr som e e!
ed A ivity/ a co e soft
vaila sts.. ware
bilit
y . !
Can
9. M part you thin
yste of yo k 5. Pa
ry/S ur u of featu y-w
urpr You ser b r ha
wan t-you-
2.Tip
ises Mak
ing m won ase es that
oney regr 't wou o
ld pa nly
t
Get on y Hmm et t
out our his! y for
of yo m .. ?
ur co produ . Didn't
mfo ct
rt zo seems I say Yes!
t wan
hese
ne!
It's i o be a to t th I don
nno em 't Afra
vate ugh one to p id th
Clos ay?
colou
e... or d .
but ie. won
yet 't re
so f enou
rs?
ar... gh d
ona
#Aw 4. Fr
eso eem
opti me! Yo Ever ium
playe
migh ons tha u have d M
t be t so Go onop
willi your us me back oly?
ng t
o pa rs
e to s Your
tart
y for ! jour
.
a te ney
lepor requ
Fre ires
Do y tatio
or th e! n! Fin
Will ou w
th Not a the d
exclu e user h prod nt the u exit..
e us
Download all files for free:
sive ave really uct o se .
er. this right to he
t ! nce r to ow
they n
Thir prod u
uct? se pay? the
ome ne Wo
ssec u
arely inte ld you li
t !
b
rest k
from e proof