Kingdom of Saudi Arabia ‫المملكة العربية السعودية‬

Ministry of Education ‫وزارة التعليم‬

University of Hail ‫جامـعـة حـائل‬
College of Nursing ‫كلية التمريض‬

INTERDISCIPLINARY PROFESSIONAL ETHICS (NURS 523)

Rubric for Presentation and Discussion with Peers

Assessment Task Assessment Score

□ Rubric for Presentation and Discussion with Peers 20%

Student Name:
Student ID:
Date:
Overall Grade:

Assessment Rubric:

ITEM POOR ACCEPTABLE IDEAL CLO STUDENT’S

(0.0) (1.0) (2.0) GRADE
1) Did not identify Partially Comprehensively 1.3
Identification any of the identified some identified all of the
of ethically ethically of the ethically ethically relevant
relevant facts relevant facts relevant facts facts surrounding
surrounding surrounding surrounding the assigned case.
the assigned the assigned the assigned
case. case. case.
2) Failed to Identified a Identified at least 1.3
Identification identify any single ethical two ethical issues
of ethical ethical issues issue in the in the assigned
issues in the in the assigned assigned case. case.
assigned case. case.
3) Presentation Did not present Presented a Presented at least 1.3
of arguments any of the single two arguments in
in the assigned arguments argument in the assigned case.
case. present in the the assigned
assigned case. case.
4) Utilization of Failed to utilize Utilized an Utilized at least 2.3
an ethical an ethical ethical two different
decision- decision decision- ethical decision-
making making model making model making models to
model/s to to any of the to identify the identify the best
identify the ethical issues best solution to solutions to at least
best solution in the assigned an ethical issue two ethical issues
to the ethical case. in the assigned in the assigned
issue/s in the case. case.
assigned case.
5) Presentation Failed to Presented a Presented solutions 2.3

Page 1 of 3

Accredited University by the ASIC on Accredited BSN Program by

March 27, 2017 AHPGS on February 15, 2018
 Kingdom of Saudi Arabia ‫المملكة العربية السعودية‬
Ministry of Education ‫وزارة التعليم‬
University of Hail ‫جامـعـة حـائل‬
College of Nursing ‫كلية التمريض‬

INTERDISCIPLINARY PROFESSIONAL ETHICS (NURS 523)

Rubric for Presentation and Discussion with Peers

of the best identify the solution to a to at least two

solution to best solution single ethical ethical issues in the
each of the to any of the issue in the assigned case.
ethical issues ethical issues assigned case
in the assigned in the assigned
case. case.
6) Defending Did not defend Defended or Defended or 1.3
or rationalizing or rationalize rationalized the rationalized the
the best the best best solution to best solution to at
solution to solution to any a single ethical least two ethical
each of the ethical issue in issue in the issues in the
ethical issues the assigned assigned case assigned case by
in the assigned case by by referencing referencing them
case by referencing it it to a single to at least two
referencing it to an ethical ethical different ethical
to an ethical principle or principle or principles of codes.
principle or code. code.
code.
7) Presenting a Failed to Presented a Presented a 1.3
recommended recommend a recommended recommended
course of course of course of course of action for
action for the action for the action for the the best solution
identified best identified best best solution identified at least
solution to solution to any identified for a two ethical issues
each of the of the ethical single ethical in the assigned
ethical issues issues in the issue in the case.
in the assigned assigned case. assigned case.
case.
8) Eliciting peer Did not elicit Partially Comprehensively Not Applicable
participation in peer elicited peer elicited peer
answering participation in participation in participation in
questions answering answering answering
found at the questions questions questions found at
end of the found at the found at the the end of the
assigned case. end of the end of the assigned case.
assigned case. assigned case.
9) Facilitate Failed to Facilitated Facilitated Not Applicable
discussion of facilitate a discussion of discussion of
answers to discussion of answers to two answers to all
questions answers to any (2) of the questions found at
found at the of the questions the end of the
end of the questions found at the assigned case with
Page 2 of 3

Accredited University by the ASIC on Accredited BSN Program by

March 27, 2017 AHPGS on February 15, 2018
 Kingdom of Saudi Arabia ‫المملكة العربية السعودية‬
Ministry of Education ‫وزارة التعليم‬
University of Hail ‫جامـعـة حـائل‬
College of Nursing ‫كلية التمريض‬

INTERDISCIPLINARY PROFESSIONAL ETHICS (NURS 523)

Rubric for Presentation and Discussion with Peers

assigned case. found at the end of the classmates.

end of the assigned case
assigned case with
with classmates.
classmates.
10) Failed to Composed a Composed a well- Not applicable
Composition of compose a fairly- structured power
a well- well- structured point presentation
structured, and structured, and power point free of grammatical
grammatically grammatically presentation errors for the case
correct power correct power with some analysis and
point point grammatical discussion with
presentation presentation errors for the peers.
for the case for the case case analysis
analysis and analysis and and discussion
discussion with discussion with with peers.
peers. peers.
TOTAL GRADE FROM A PERFECT SCORE OF 20

Evaluator’s Name: ________________________________

Evaluator’s Signature: _______________________________

Page 3 of 3

Accredited University by the ASIC on Accredited BSN Program by

March 27, 2017 AHPGS on February 15, 2018