Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transposed conductor
255
(2006), and at the same time the recommended values of the Power transformers of 112 MVA for hydro power plant
permitted noise levels by NEMA - National Electrical „Bajina Bašta“ have been examined by Electrical
Manufacturers Association Standards TR1 (1998) must be Engineering Institute „Nikola Tesla“ from Belgrade, together
met. Recommended values of the permitted noise levels of with representatives from several accredited European
power transformers are defined depending on the power of institutions for high voltage tests, during which functional
the particular transformer, test voltage and cooling method characteristics have been verified according to the standards
(Table 1). With the increase of power of power transformer as well as noise level which power transformers produce
also increases the permitted noise level (Table 2). during operational time.
Table 1 Permissible noise level for 100 MVA transformer
with ODWF cooling 2. NOISE OF POWER TRANSFORMERS
Test voltage The noise that power transformers produce is defined by IEC
350 450 750 900 1175 1300
kV 60076-10 (2001) standard and is determined by three basic
Permissible
78 80 81 82 83 84 parameters:
noise dB
Sound pressure level method (Lp),
Table 2 Permissible noise level for 300 MVA transformer Sound power level method (LW) and,
with ODWF cooling Sound intensity method (LI).
Test voltage
kV
350 450 750 900 1175 1300 Sound pressure level is calculated according to:
Permissible p p
noise dB
83 85 86 87 88 89 Lp = 10 lg ( p )2 = 20 lg ( p ) [dB],
0 0 (1)
Revitalization of hydropower plants, thermal power plants where: p – is the sound pressure [Pa] and p0 – is reference
and transmission distribution networks and high voltage sound pressure p0 = 20 • 10-6 [Pa].
transformer substations is usually based on installation of The sound power level LW is calculated according to:
new power transformers with modern construction, which
LW = 10 lg (W ) [dB],
meets all the requirements of international standards. The W0 (2)
only Serbian factory of power transformers – ABS Minel where: W – represents the sound power [W] and W0 – is
Transformatori in Ripanj manufactures power transformers reference sound power W0 = 10-12 [W].
with power of up to 400 MVA and voltage level of up to 400 Sound intensity level LI is calculated according to:
kV based on its own construction solutions, for EPS (Electric
Power Industry of Serbia), EMS (Electric power networks of LI = 10 lg ( I ) [dB],
I0 (3)
Serbia), and as well for markets in the region, the European where: I – is sound intensity [W/m2] and I0 – is reference
Union, Russia and countries of the former republics of the value of sound intensity I0 = 10-12 [W/m2].
Soviet Union and countries of north Africa [1]. Currently in
the realisation phase is the largest project in the field of The sound level A (LpA, LWA, LIA) is frequency adjusted
electric power in Serbia, the revitalization of HE „Bajina value of calculated sound level that takes into account
Bašta“ project, which is executed by the Austrian company nonlinear sensitivity of the human ear to different sound
Andritz Hydro. Within revitalization of all four aggregates of frequencies. Human ear is the most sensitive to frequencies
hydro power plant, already two power transformers of power around 1000 [Hz], and is less sensitive to lower and higher
112 MVA, voltage level of 242/15.65 kV, have been frequencies. For a particular frequency of sound level A
installed. These transformers were designed and stands:
manufactured in ABS Minel Transformatori factory in LpAf = Lpf + ΔLf , (4)
Ripanj, while remaining two power transformers are in where: Lpf - is not adjusted linear value of sound level and
production phase (Figure 2). ΔLf – is correction to be taken on the basis of empirical
values per octave.
The total noise level in the case of multiple sound sources
(LWA1, LWA2, LWA3, ...) can be calculated according to the
following formula:
0,1LWAi . (5)
LWA = 10 lg Σ10
For n equal noise sources of level the total noise level is
LWA = LWA0 + 10 lg n . (6)
Measurements of power transformer’s noise are performed
according to IEC 60076-10 (2001) standard, which describes
the measurement procedure in great detail. Measurements are
performed during tests for short circuit at nominal current at
a distance of 300 [mm], 1000 [mm] or 2000 [mm] from
contour – the main radiation plane of transformer’s trunk.
Fig. 2 Step-up transformer 112 MVA on H2 unit of HE During tests, mainly sound pressure level LpA and sound
“Bajina Basta” manufactured by ABS Minel Transformatori power intensity LIA are being measured. The main plane of
Ripanj
256
radiation is imaginary surface that surrounds the 3. Aerodynamic and hydraulic noise of the cooler –
transformer’s tank and passes through vertical projection of which is generated by the operation of pump units
the line around transformer at defined distance (Figure 3). for water cooling or fans for air cooling.
For transformers with natural cooling the measurement points Magnetostriction is a phenomenon that results in a change of
are at a distance of 300 [mm] from the main plane of dimensions of material being in the magnetic field, and in the
radiation. For dry transformers, for security reasons, the case of transformers it results in changes of dimensions of
distance should be 1000 [mm]. transformer’s sheet of magnetic core. The changes are in few
A = 5860 mm μm/m for typical transformer’s sheet. The value of
magnetostriction depends on magnetic induction (Figure 4),
type of transformer’s sheet and mechanical strains that arise
due to the effect of electromagnetic forces. Magnetic forces
are generated within the joints of pillars and yokes of
magnetic core.
2U
Magnetostriction, μm/m
2V 1.0
2W
0.5
Magnetic induction, T
Magnetostriction, μm/m
Time, s
H = 4640 mm
257
where: Sr - is nominal power of transformer, k1 and k2 – are Tightening of yokes with screw connection of the side metal
empirical coefficients, α – represents relative load (load profiles leads to fixing the transformer’s sheets in yoke,
current / nominal current). while tightening of pillars is done by polymer tapes (Figure
Aerodynamic noise of the fan significantly contributes to the 7). Half-polymerized poliglas tape is used for tightening the
total noise level of the transformer. The level of fan noise magnetic core, because later while heating the magnetic core
depends on: the speed of fan blades rotation, blade size, it gets fully polymerized and shortened, which leads to very
construction and number of blades, the ways of setting the strong tightening of transformer’s sheets in pillars of
fan on the cooler. The frequency spectrum of fan noise is magnetic core. Heating at 140 0C for 120 minutes polarizes
considerably wider than the one belonging to magnetic core. the half-polymerized tape.
Frequency of the first harmonic is calculated according to the
formula:
f1 = n Nb (9)
where: n - is the number of revolutions per second, Nb - is the
number of fan blades.
Transformer’s noise level resulting from the fan noise can be
calculated according to the formula: L
L
LWA(fan) = LWA,0 + 10 lg n
(10)
where: LWA,0 – is the noise level of one fan (determined under
real operating conditions - the fan on the cooler) while and n
- is the number of fans.
The total transformer’s noise level is calculated by adding the
noise from all sources (magnetic core, windings, fans) with
the assumption that all noise sources are independent. a b
258
By tightening the yokes of the magnetic core with screws modelling, and especially through simulations and 3D FEM
made of anti-magnetic material (Figure 8) there is one part of modelling of electrical, electromagnetic and thermal
transformer’s sheet on the upper surface that remains not phenomena in transformer’s windings, and in different
tighten because of the yoke’s circular cross section (Figure working conditions (Figure 10).
9). The flat surfaces of the lower yoke are coated with epoxy
or wood glue, in order to reduce vibrations of the sheet’s
ends which are not tighten. The upper yoke must be
dismantled because of repair, thus the flat surfaces of the
upper yoke are not coated with glue [2].
259
In most cases, the dynamic excitation generates vibrations of Parts of windings are loaded like a beam with continuous
the windings that have high amplitude and can cause damage load that makes the deflection.
to the isolation, or in extreme cases - short-circuit voltage, till Insert
Pad
breaking the conductor and total damage of the windings Mount
(Figure 13).
a b
260
Coupled field analysis
Electromagnetics Fluid-Structure-Coupling
Clamping frame
Magnetic stray Current-carrying
flux conductor Radiation of sound pressure waves
Upper yoke support
Flitch plate
261
where: D – is a diameter of the fan, n - number of revolutions
per second, p - the number of motor poles.
14
Number of motor poles
12 p=6
D = 1000 mm
D = 800 mm
10 D = 600 mm
Air flow, Q, m3/s
6 p=6
p = 16
4
Fig. 22 Example of a part of the Certificate for noise
p = 16 p=6 measurements of 112 MVA power transformer for HE
2
„Bajina Basta“
p = 16
0 Modelling of the magnetic core, windings and solutions for
40 50 60 70 80 90 100 increasing the stiffness of the transformer’s active part is a
Noise level of fan, LWA, dB constant challenge to the designers, who are looking for an
Fig. 21 Noise level depending on the diameter of the rotor, optimal solution between functional performances, cost of
the number of poles and the cooling capacity of the fan materials and production costs, bearing in mind that in recent
times the world market price for power transformers has been
In addition to this, reducing fan’s noise can be achieved significantly reduced compared to the period of 4-5 years
through balancing the rotating masses, quality bearing and ago, despite the fact that all manufacturers are installing the
stable structure for binding the fan with housing of the transformer’s sheet of the same characteristics, that the
radiator for cooling. copper price is the same for all producers, that we all use
Weidmann isolation materials, Nynas transformer’s oil and
7. CONCLUSION Reinhausen regulators.
Around thirty years ago, as part of the then known Institute
for Machine Tools and tooling (IAMA) in the framework of ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
scientific research program VIBEX - Protection against noise The results presented in this paper are part of research
and vibration, within living and working environment, one of activities within roject TR37020 – „The development of
direction for the research was the protection of the methodologies and means for noise protection of urban
transformer’s noise in urban areas. These surveys also areas“, which is funded by Ministry of Education and
included the distribution transformers that are installed in Science, Government of the Republic of Serbia. The authors
transformer substations 10/04 kV in inhabited areas. Usually wish to express their gratitude to Serbian Ministry of
the solution for reducing the noise and vibrations was sought Education and Science for support through project TR37020.
through elastic reliance of the transformer’s active part, also
with complete transformer substation’s isolation techniques
REFERENCES
with special anti-acoustical materials. Termination of
existence of the Institute IAMA and its orientation to the [1] Lj. Lukic, N. Pejcic, “A New Generation of
study program of industrial production of machine tools and Transformers with Wound Core Patented by ABS Minel
computer control systems, the research program for Trafo Serbia”, Paper on call, Proc. 7th International
protection against noise and vibration has entered into Symposium Nikola Tesla, pp. 51-56, 23. November 2011,
stagnation. Belgrade, 2011.
At that time, the noise and vibration studies haven’t been [2] Lj. Lukić, M. Djapić, “Transportation and Manipulation
focused in the area of large power transformers, which are Processes in the Overhaul of Energy Transformers”,
designed at the factory Minel Transformers in Ripanj Proc. The Seventh Triennial International Conference
according to Westinghouse license. Today in the Heavy Machinery HM2011, A Session – Railway
development of power transformers standards in the field of Engineering, Volume 7, pp. 25-32, Kraljevo - Vrnjacka
noise are imposed by major companies from most developed Banja, June 29th - July 2nd, 2011.
countries in the world, that’s why the designers from Minel [3] R. Žičkar, „Optimization in design process of industrial
Transformers factory have developed original methods for transformers“, Master thesis, University of Zagreb,
calculation and design solutions that fully provide the Faculty of mechanical engineering and shipbuilding,
permissible level of noise and all other functional Zagreb, 2011.
characteristics required by international standards (Figure
22). [4] W. M. Zawieska: A Power Transformer as a Source of
Noise, International Journal of Occupational Safety and
Ergonomics (JOSE), pp. 381–389, Vol 13, No 4, 2007.
262