2. Victoriano v. Elizalde Rope, 59 SCRA 54 3. PBM Employees Org. v. PBM, 51 SCRA 189 4. Eastern Shipping Lines v. POEA, 166 SCRA 523 5. PLDT v, NLRC, et al., G.R. NO. 80609, Aug. 23, 1988 6. Agabon v. NLRC, G.R. 158693 (2004) 7. Carino v. ACCFA, L-19808, Sept. 29, 1965 8. Ang Tibay v. CIR, 69 SCRA 635 9. PAL V. NLRC, 95985, Aug. 13, 1993 10. Manila Electric Co. v. Quisumbing, G.R. 127598, January 1999 11. Brotherhood Labor Unity Movement v. NLRC, GR- 48645, Jan. 7, 1987 12. LVN Pictures v. Phil. Musicians’ Guild, 1 SCRA 132 13. Dy Keh Beng v. Int’l Labor & Marine Union, L-32245, May 18 922, 1979 14. Investment Planning v. SSS, L-19124, Nov. 18, 1987 15. Insular Life Assurance Co. Ltd. V. NLRC, GR 84484, Nov. 15, 1989 16. Sonza v. ABS-CBN Broadcasting, G.R. 138051, June 10, 2004. 17. CARIÑO vs. ACCFA, L-19808, 29 September 1966 18. Nacague vo. Sulpicio Lines, G.R. 172586, (2010) 19. People v. Panis, 142 SCRA 664 20. VIR-GEN SHIPPING AND MARITIME SERVICES v. NLRC, 115 SCRA 347, 125 SCRA 557 21. WALLEM SHIPPING v. MIN. OF LABOR. 102 SCRA 835 22. PAN PACIFIC OVERSEAS RECRUITING SERVICES v. ATIENZA. 153 SCRA 325 23. PHIGRECIAN SERVICES AND TRANSOCEAN SERVICES v. NLRC. 139 SCRA 285 24. AMBRAQUE INT’L PLACEMENT AND SERVICES v. NLRC, 77970 28 Jan. 1988 25. SERRANO v. GALLANT MARITIME SERVICES, 167614, 24 March 2004 26. PERT/CPM Manpower v. Vinuya, GR 197528, 2012 27. P.I. Manpower Placement v. NLRC, 276 SCRA 451 28. People v. Chua, 680 SCRA 575, 2012 29. Pp. v. Ocden, GR 173198, 1 June 2011 30. Pp. v. Hu, G.R. 182232, 6 Oct. 2008 31. Pp. v. Ortiz-Miyake, 32. Sunace International Management Services v. NLRC, 480 SCRA 146 (2006) 33. Pp. v. Ortiz-Miyake, 344 Phil. 598, 808-609 34. SAN MIGUEL v. DEMOCRATIC LABOR UNION. 8 SCRA 613 35. LARA v. DEL ROSARIO, 94 PHIL. 778 36. PAN AM v. PAN AM EMPLOYEES, 11 PHIL. 126 37. NASSCO v. CIR, 17085, 30 Dec. 1961 38. RED V COCONUT v. CIR, 70 SCRA 38 39. SHELL OIL WORKERS UNION v. SHELL, 29 SCRA 292, 40. MAFINCO TRADING CORP v. OPLE, 6 SCRA 522 41. PALEA v. PAL, 70 SCRA 244 42. BAGUIO WATER DISTRICT v. TRAJANO, 127 SCRA 730 43. OCEANIC PHARMACEUTICAL EMPLOYEES UNION v. INCIONG, 94 SCRA 270 44. CEBU INST. OF TECHNOLOGY v. OPLE 156 SCRA 532 45. JOSE RIZAL COLLEGE v. NLRC, 156 SCRA 27, 46. DURABILT RECAPPING PLANT v. NLRC, 152 SCRA 328 47. FILSYN v. NLRC, GR 113347, 14 June 1996 48. DBP v. NLRC, 82763-64, 19 March 1990 49. Republic v. Peralta, 150 SCRA 37 50. CHARTERED BANK EMPLOYEES v. OPLE, 138 SCRA 547 51. BPI Employees Union v. NLRC, 171 SCRA 556, 569 52. Atty. Taganas v. NLRC, GR 118746, 7 September 1995. 53. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. Employees Union v. NLRC, GR 102636, 1993 54. Bankard Employees Union-Workers Aliance v. NLRC, 423 SCRA 148 (2004) 55. Insular Hotel Employees Union v. Waterfront, GR 174040-41, 2010 56. State Marine v. Cebu, G.R. -12444 (1966 (20113) 57. Royal Plant Workers Union v. Coca-Cola Bottlers, Inc. Cebu Plant, GR 198783 (2013) 58. Supreme Steel v. Nagkakaisang Manggagawa, GR 1185556 (2011) 59. Duncan v. Glaxo Welcome, G.R. No. 162994, (2004) 60. DY v. NLRC, L-68544, 27 Oct. 1986 61. DAYAG V. HON. CANIZARES, L-124193, 6 March 1998 62. MAINLAND CONSTRUCTION vs. MOVILLA, 118088, 23 November 1995. 63. PEPSI vs. JUDGE MARTINEZ, L-58877. 15 March 1982 64. SMC vs. NLRC, 80774, 31 May 1988. 65. SUARIO vs. BPI, L-50459 25 August 1989. 66. PRIMERO vs. IAC, 72644, 14 December 1987 67. SOCO vs. MCD, L-53364-65, 16 March, 1987 68. CABE vs. TUMANG, L-57682, 18 March 1985. 69. MOLAVE vs. JUDGE LARON, 65377, 28 May 1984 70. ANG TIBAY vs. CIR, L-46496, 27 February 1940 71. SM AGRI vs. NLRC, 74806 9 January 1989 72. ST. MARTIN FUNERAL HOME vs. NLRC, 130866, 18 September 1998 73. BORJA ESTATE vs. SPS. BALLAD, 152550, 8 June 2005 74. UERM-MMC vs. NLRC, 110419, 3 March 1997 75. ACDA vs. MOL, L-51607, 15 December 1982 76. CW TAN MFG. vs. NLRC, 79596 10 February 1989, ABBOTT LABORATORIES vs. NLRC, 76959, 12 October 1987 77. PACIFIC MILLS vs. NLRC, 88864, 17 January 1990. 78. VELOSO v. DOLE, 87297, 5 August 1991 79. VOLKSCHEL vs. BLR, L-45824, 19 June 1985 80. ADAMSON vs. CIR and ADAMSON, L-35120, 31 January 1984 81. TROPICAL HUT EMPLOYEES' UNION vs. TROPICAL HUT, L-43495-99, 20 January 1990 82. VILLAR vs. HON. INCIONG, L-50283-84, 20 April 1983 83. AJELCO vs. MOLE AND MAGKAISA-ADLO, 77231, 31 May 1989 84. ICMC vs. HON. CALLEJA, 85750, 28 September 1990 85. ARIZALA vs. CA, 43633-34, 14 September 1990 86. UP vs. HON. FERRER-CALLEJA, 96189, 14 July 1992 87. FRANKLIN BAKER COMPANY vs. HON. TRAJANO, 75039, 28 January 1988 88. METROLAB INDUSTRIES vs. HON. CONFESSOR, 108855, 28 February 1996 89. TMPCWA vs. NLRC ,158786, 58789, October 19, 2007 90. SSS vs. CA, 85279, 28 July 1989 91. SAMAHAN vs. NLRC, 119467, 1 February 2000 92. NAT'L FEDERATION OF SUGAR WORKERS vs. OVEJERA, L-59743, 31 May 1982 93. UNION OF FILIPRO EMPLOYEES ET AL. vs. NESTLÉ, 88710-13, 19 Dec 1990 94. Liwayway Publication v.Permanent Concrete Workers Union, L-25003, Oct. 23, 1981 95. SAN MIGUEL vs. NLRC, 119293, 10 June 2003 96. PEOPLE'S INDUSTRIAL vs. PI & CIR, 37687, 15 March 1982 97. NFL vs. NLRC, 113466, 15 December 1997 98. IBM vs. NLRC, 91980, 27 June 1991 99. UNIVERSITY OF SAN AGUSTIN EU-FFW vs. CA, 169632, 28 March 2006 100. MOISES DE LEON vs. NLRC, 70705, 21 2August 1989, 101. CISELL KIAMCO vs. NLRC, ET AL., 129449, 29 June 1999 102. BAGUIO COUNTRY CLUB CORP vs. NLRC, ET AL., 171664, 28 February 1999 103. PHILIPPINE GEOTHERMAL, INC. vs. NLRC, 82643-67, 30 August 1990 104. WACK-WACK GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB vs. NLRC, ET. AL.149793, 15 April 2005 105. TOMAS LAO CONSTRUCTION, ET AL. vs. NLRC, 116781, 5 September 1997 106. MERCADO, SR. vs. NLRC, 79869, 5 September 1991 107. BRENT SCHOOL, INC. vs. HON. ZAMORA, ET AL., L-48494, 5 February 1990 108. PHIL. TOBACCO FLUE-CURING REDRYING CORP vs. NLRC, 127395. 10 December 1998 109. PUREFOODS CORP. vs. NLRC, 122653, 12 December 1997 110. BUISER vs. LEOGARDO, L-63316, 31 July 1984 111. MARIWASA vs. LEOGARDO, 74246, 26 January 1989 112. OCTAVIANO vs. NLRC, 88636, 3 October 1991 113. A PRIME SECURITY SERVICES, INC. v. NLRC, 107320, 19 January 2000 114. UST vs. NLRC, 85519, 15 February 1990 115. SMC vs. NLRC, 87277, 12 May 1989 116. PTT vs. LA PLANA, 76645, 23 July 1991 117. CENTURY TEXTILE MILLS vs. NLRC, 77859, 25 May 1988 118. LOADSTAR SHIPPING vs. MESANO, 138956, 7 August 2003 119. WILTSHIRE FILE CO. INC. vs. NLRC, 82249, 7 February 1991 120. PLDT vs. NLRC, 80609, 23 August 1988 121. AGABON vs. NLRC, 158693, 17 November 2004 122. JAKA FOOD vs. PACOT, ET. AL., 151378, 28 March 2005 123. KING OF KINGS TRANSPORT v. Mamac, GR 166208, June 29, 2007 124. Perez v. PT&T, GRN 152048, April 7, 2009 125. MORAL v. MOMENTUM PPROPERTIES MANAGEMENT. GRN 226240, March 6, 2019 126. INDUSTRIAL TIMBER vs. ABABON, 164518, 30 March 2006 127. WENPHIL CORP. V. NLRC, 80587, 8 F3B. 1989 128. Serrano v. NLRC, 117040, 27 Jan. 2000 129. Itogon-Suyoc Mines v. Sañgilo-Itogon, 21489, 30 August 1968 130. Mercury Drug. Co. v. CIR, 23357, 30 April 1974 131. Pines City Educational Center v. NLRC, 96779, 10 Nov. 1993 132. Bustamante v. NLRC, 111651, 28 November 1996 133. Session Delights Ice Cream and Fast Foods v. CA, 172149, 8 Feb. 2010 134. Nacar v.NLRC, 189781, 13 August 2013 135. Llora Motors v. Drilon, L-82895, Nov. 7, 1989 136. Pantranco v. NLRC and Zuniga, L-95940, July 24, 1996 137. Jaulbe v. Silliman Univ. L-156934, March 16, 2007.