You are on page 1of 70

ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 1

FEU Roosevelt, Cainta, Philippines

ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES OF ARALING

PANLIPUNAN TEACHERS IN PUBLIC SECONDARY SCHOOLS

OF BARAS DISTRICT DIVISION OF RIZAL

By

Sheryl G. Iballa

And

Dr. Alma Emerita Dela Cruz

October 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 2

CHAPTER I

THE PROBLEM

Introduction

Educators with the skills, knowledge, and attitudes to value the diversity among
students will contribute to an educational system designed to serve all students well. Our
nation can no longer be satisfied with success for some students; instead we must cultivate
the strengths of all.

—NEA President Dennis Van Roeke

Societies have different cultures and change throughout history. Culture as a

concept is defined by sociologists and anthropologists emphasizing different

dimensions focusing mainly on its symbolic dimensions. It is viewed as a real

phenomenon that may be seen in material objects, or as an abstraction from behavior

as observed in the activities of people. It is the basic parameter between human

beings and lower animals (Panopio, MacDonald, & Raymundo, 1994).

Culture is learned, social, shared, transmitted, continuous, accumulative,

integrated, changing, responsive, varied, and gratifying. It is not inherited

biologically; instead it is acquired by people through the process of socialization. It

develops in society through social interaction from one generation to the next. It is

the product of continuous process evolving from the past flowing to the next

centuries. It remains changing with different speeds that vary according to society

and generation. It responds to the changing conditions of the environment for

adaptation and survival. Culture includes different elements such as symbols, values,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 3

norms, and language. Symbols refers to anything to which people attach meaning

and use to communicate with others. It includes words, objects, gestures, sounds or

images. Language is the basic foundation of human culture development by using

systematized speech communication both verbal and non-verbal in form. Values

serves as guidelines for decision-making, goal setting, and taking course of action

(Doda, 2005). These elements are not isolated from each other, instead they are

organized and patterned to fit each other.

Contemporary Philippine Culture is diverse in character. The historical and

geographical background of the Philippines as a country resulted to the diverse

culture of over a hundred ethnic groups and a mixture of both from long colonial rule

and visits by foreign merchants and traders (Barrows, 1905).

The Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) recorded that the total population

of the Filipinos is 104,256,076 as of July 2017 divided according to ethnicity,

religion, and languages. The majority of the people are of Malay race. The largest of

these groups are the Visayans,, Tagalogs, Ilocanos, Bicolanos, Moros,

Kapampangans, Pangasinense and the Zamboanguenos. The indigenous people

groups comprise the minority are mestizo of Spanish, American, Japanese, Chinese,

Indian, Latino, and Arab descent. All these groups have their own unique culture,

beliefs, and history which contributed to the Philippine culture. In their veins run the

rich Christian values of European culture, the pragmatic and democratic values of the

Americans, and the spiritual values of Asian People (Andres T. and Andres P.,

1987). The Komisyon Ng Wikang Filipino has reported 135 ethnic languages all

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 4

over the Philippines of different varieties. In 2015, it was reported that there were

80.58% Roman Catholics, 10.8% were Protestants, 5.57% Islamic while the rest

were of different Christian denominations including Iglesia Ni Cristo, Evangelicals,

and the likes.

Region IV-A CALABARZON is the main destination for long-distance

movers in the country, which constitutes 27.7%, followed by Metro Manila (19.7%)

and Central Luzon (13%) (Philippines Statistics Authority 2012). Based on the

results of the 2010 Census on Domestic and International Migrants in the Philippines

there were 1.4 million long-distance movers counted. The main destination for long-

distance movers is Calabarzon, which absorbs 27.7% of them (Philippines Statistics

Authority 2012).

The Rizal Provincial Government reported that the province of Rizal ranks

third in terms of population size in Region IV-A accounting to 19.85% with annual

growth rate of 4.10%. The fast growing municipalities are Rodriguez (9.65),

followed by Teresa (5.73), San Mateo (4.40), Antipolo (4.22), Taytay (3.98),

Angono (3.73), Pililia (3.63), Baras (3.55), and Binangonan (3.41). These population

size resulted from spilled-over population of Metro Manila and the proximity of

these municipalities to Metro Manila and the emergence of different commercial and

industrial establishments. Based on the 2015 Census of Population of PSA Rizal

Province population was 2,884,227 with 2.88% population growth rate. This high

population growth rate in Rizal is attributed mainly to the rapid subdivision

development in the province. As of 2008, there were 992 housing subdivisions in the

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 5

province with the city of Antipolo having the highest at 476, followed by Cainta with

113, San Mateo with 99, Taytay with 85, Angono with 71, Teresa with seven, Baras

with six, Morong with five and Pililia with three subdivisions catering to different

types of migrants: high, middle, and low income groups. The Municipality of Taytay

has the highest density among the fastest growing settlements while Baras has the

lowest density but with an annual growth rate of 3.555, which is higher than the

provincial average.

Background of the Study

The existence of diverse cultures of people in the province of Rizal is mainly

attributed to several factors. The migration of different people to the province,

specifically to the municipality of Baras, has added to the existing culture and

traditions of the native people created cultural gap leading to misunderstanding and

discrimination.

This dilemma is also evident in the education sector especially in the school

setting, in which both teachers and learners have diverse cultures resulting from the

unpredictable and uncontrollable transfer from one place to another not to mention

the effects of global trend. This resulted to cultural gap in the schools as a growing

number of educators struggle to better serve students from cultures other than their

own in response to dramatic demographic changes that have created culturally

diverse schools in many areas of the province. This cultural gap has a great impact

on students’ academic performance and behavior. Tumapon (2016), emphasized the

different sources of complexity or diversity in the classroom such as gender, religion,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 6

socio-economic status, and communication patterns. In a non-sectarian school,

enrollees may come from various churches. Some teachers ask their students to recite

prescribed prayers different from other students’ beliefs and practice. A Muslim

student would not make the sign of the cross as Catholics do. A Jehovah witness

member would not display honor to the Philippine flag. Thus far, we have slightly

dealt with complexities in the classroom. Socio-economic status draws a big

difference between students. Regional origins is also a factor since each region has

differences in culture as in communication patterns– for example,where the

Cebuanos would not have the honorifics po or ho or kayo in addressing the elderly

which does not mean they are less respectful in their manner of speech as compared

to those from Luzon. Similarly, people in Luzon address an elderly differently, in the

second person and in the plural form. Based on the above statement, it is very vital

for a teacher to acquire language competencies to better understand his learners. As

cited by Bernardos ( 2011), language competence is a pre-requisite to have a

productive and satisfying experience since language serves different functions such

as; to manipulate the environment to cause certain events to happen, to convey or

present reality as one sees it, social communication to allow social contacts among

people, express feelings, emotions, personality, and other reactions and invite

creative system of persons such as composing songs, writing poetry, novels and the

like.

In the same vein, Garcia (2018), reiterated the importance of having enough

knowledge about the diverse personality, ideas, preference, and family background

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 7

of students to be consistent in the effective ways of dealing with diverse learners in

order to build a stronger foundation in the holistic aspect of their lives. This setting

demonstrates the challenges of educating students of diverse cultures and sub-

cultures throughout the country.

As the diversity of students within the school population increases, the need

for teachers to provide cultural competence in their programming, daily interactions

and overall classroom environment must also grow (Leighton and Harkins, 2010).

Teachers need to improve knowledge and skills to enhance, improve and explore

their teaching practices.

In the Philippines, the teachers’ competencies are already specified in the

National Competency Based Teacher Standards (NCBTS). These competencies were

created to set standards on a set of behaviors, attitudes and skills that teachers must

have in order for them to perform better as teachers. The NCBTS is anchored on the

core values of Filipino teachers and the principles of effective teaching and learning.

There are seven domains that serve as indicators of teachers’ performance; two of

these are related to cultural competence: Social Regard for Learning and Diversity of

Learners. Social Regard for Learning describes the social interaction of teachers with

students. For Diversity of Learners, teachers are expected to facilitate the learning

process even with diverse learners. The sub domains include: the teacher is familiar

with learners’ background knowledge and experiences, and the teacher demonstrates

concern for holistic development of learners. However, there is a need to identify

further appropriate cultural competencies and micro skills of teachers. When these

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 8

cultural competencies are specified, and evaluated, teachers are better guided in their

practice to meet the needs of their diverse learners.

Having been an Araling Panlipunan teacher for twelve years, the researcher

has been exposed to the above issues. The researcher taught in a private school for

two years at San Jose Del Monte Bulacan, in a public school for two years at Lipa

City Batangas, and for two and a half months at the Municipality of Taytay Rizal

before she finally settled in her present station in 2012 at Baras, Rizal where

students are diverse since it is a relocation site.

This prompted the researcher to conduct this study because she believes that

understanding cultural competencies will enable teachers to have a positive

interaction with their students. By recognizing and respecting their students’

individual differences and using this knowledge and skills about their differences,

teachers can design diverse sets of learning activities to improve student’s

performance and behavior.

Statement of the Problem

This study focused on the cultural competencies of Public Secondary Araling

Panlipunan teachers in Baras District, Province of Rizal. Specifically, this study

sought to answer the following questions:

1. What is the demographic profile of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in

the Public Secondary Schools in Baras District Province of Rizal in terms of:

1.1 Educational Attainment

1.2 Numbers of years in service

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 9

1.3 Trainings, seminars and other related activities and programs

attended related to cultural competence attended

2. What is the level of cultural competencies of Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in Public Secondary Schools in Baras District Province of Rizal as assessed

by the teacher-respondents in terms of:

2.1. Awareness of beliefs and attitude;

2.2. Skills;

2.3. Knowledge;

2.4 Language;

3. Is there any significant difference in the level of cultural competence

of Araling Panlipunan teachers in public secondary schools in Baras District

Province of Rizal as assessed by themselves in terms of the following variables when

grouped according to profile:

3.1 Educational Attainment;

3.2 Number of years in service;

3,3 Trainings, seminars and other related activities and programs

attended related to cultural competencies

4. What are the challenges encountered by the Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in the acquisition and practice of cultural competencies in the Public

Secondary Schools in Baras District in Division of Rizal?

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 10

Hypothesis

From the problems stated, the study tested the null hypothesis that:

There is no significant relationship between the level of cultural

competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers and the following factors:

a. Educational Attainment;

b. Number of years in service;

c. Trainings, seminars and other related activities and programs attended

related to cultural competencies

Significance of the Study

The results of the study will benefit Araling Panlipunan teachers and learners

since cultural competence centers on the skills and knowledge to effectively serve

students from diverse cultures. Assessing teachers' cultural competence is a vital step

in developing culturally competent practices to deliver effective pedagogies and

interventions for different types of learners. For administrators, curriculum planners

and future researchers, the findings of the study will facilitate the formulation of

guidelines and programs that will enhance the cultural competence among teachers.

Scope and Delimitations

The study explored the level of cultural competencies of AP teachers.

Further, it identified issues and concerns met by the respondents in the acquisition

and practice of cultural competencies.

The respondents consisted of all Araling Panlipunan Junior High School

Teachers from Public Secondary Schools in Baras District, province of Rizal.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 11

Demographic survey and questionnaire was utilized to determine the Araling

Panlipunan Teachers’ profile and cultural competencies in terms of awareness,

knowledge, and skills.

The researcher used an adapted and modified questionnaire checklist on the

competencies of AP-HEKASI Teachers developed by Edmund Olevario in his

Master’s Thesis entitled “ A study of the competencies of Araling panlipunan –

HEKASI Teachers in the Public Elementary Schools in the second District of Las

Piñas City: Basis for a proposed competency Development Program” and the

“Cultural Competence Self Assessment Checklist developed by Central Vancouver

Island Multicultural Society in Canada.

Definition of Terms

For a better understanding of this study, the following terms were defined

operationally:

Araling Panlipunan. The subject taught in Public Secondary Schools from

grade seven to ten which deals with Asian History, World History, Economics, and

Contemporary Issues.

Competence. This refers to sufficiency of knowledge, skills and attitude of

the AP teachers in providing the appropriate lesson suited to students needs.

Competencies. These are sets of knowledge, skills and attitude set by the

National Standards for Social Studies Center and the Department of Education,

Philippines that must be possessed by teachers

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 12

Cultural Competencies. These are sets of knowledge, skills and attitude that

an Araling Panlipunan teacher must possess to be culturally responsive

Culturally Responsive Teaching. This describes teaching in which

academic knowledge and skills are situated within the lived experience and frame of

reference of students.

Educational Attainment. It refers to the degree earned by teachers classified

as Bachelors, Masters and Doctorate relevant to teaching.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 13

CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

This chapter contains discussion on related literature and studies, Synthesis,

Conceptual Framework and Definition of terms relevant to cultural competence of

Araling Panlipunan Teachers.

On Culture

In order to better understand the concept of cultural competence it is ideal to

know first the concept of culture. As cited by Lum (1999), culture is how different

groups of people live in a certain society prescribing ways of behaving or norms of

conduct, beliefs, values, and skills. It is how life patterns of social and interpersonal

relationships hand over from generation to generation within a group of people.

Likewise, Abocol, R. & Añonuevo R., (2015) emphasize that culture is the

organization of different societal relationships created by different institutions and

structures using political, economic and ideological practices.

Culture is viewed as a lens which influences individual life’s perception

based from their different experiences and cultural backgrounds in terms of

language, values, personality, family patterns, world view, sense of time and space,

and rules of interaction (Moule,2012).

In the research done to explore the connections between the skills student

teachers acquire and the application of these newly developed skills to professional

practices, Salmona et.al., (2015) found out that participation in cultural based events

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 14

is part of a complex decision making process. Moreover, a variety of cultures that

now exist in schools requires new teachers to obtain and apply a skill set that

promotes and understand the many definitions of culture. A better understanding of

this process may strengthen curricula and improvements in teacher education

program delivery and further enhance higher education study-abroad international

partnerships.

On Cultural Competence and Competencies

Cultural competence refers to the ability of teachers to successfully teach

students who come from cultures other than their own. This entails developing

certain personal and interpersonal awareness and sensitivities, learning specific

bodies of knowledge, and mastering a set of skills which taken together, underlie

effective cross-cultural teaching (Moule, 2012). Given the fundamental nature of

attitudes and beliefs, it is likely these factors should be assessed during the teacher

selection process, while training programs can be utilized to address the knowledge

and skills components. Relative to the development of cultural competence in

individual teachers are the five basic skills areas essential for cross-cultural teaching:

Awareness and acceptance of differences, Self-Awareness, Dynamics of Difference,

Knowledge of the Student’s Culture, and Adaptation of Skills. Awareness and

acceptance of differences wherein educators are moving towards cultural

competence by broadening his perspective which acknowledges the simultaneous

existence of different realities and value complexity. For Self-Awareness which

focuses on understanding one’s own behavior shaped by cultural norms and values

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 15

and reinforced by family and community traditions (Moule, 2012). Appreciate the

impact of their own ethnicity and racial attitudes on potentials clients and actively

work to limit the impact of such factor (Diller, 2007). Dynamics of Difference which

involves knowing what can go wrong in cross-cultural communication and knowing

how to set it right by responding to differences in cultural style with openness and

respect. Knowledge of the Student’s Culture which identify the cultural information

from the context of the student’s cultural group by being open in order to bridge the

cultural gap (Moule, 2012). Individual are active in educating themselves in regards

to client’s culture to understand behavior in its own context (Diller, 2007).

Adaptation of Skills which involve adjustment in the learning process to fit cultural

values of the students in order for them to relate to the concepts being learned

(Moule, 2012).

Cultural competence is not a new idea anymore because it has been referred

to as “ethnic sensitive practice”, “cross-cultural awareness practice”, “ethnic

competence”, “ethnic minority practice”, “intercultural communication”, “cross-

cultural counseling”, “multicultural counseling”, “cultural diversity”, “culturally

responsive”, and “cultural proficiency” in the past as mentioned by Diller (2007). It

is a set of harmonious behaviors, attitudes, and policies that come together in a

system, agency, or among professionals and enable the system, agency, or

professionals to work effectively in cross-cultural situations.

Cultural competence or cultural diversity competence is concerned with

cultural awareness coupled with the skills needed to interact successfully with people

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 16

of diverse cultural backgrounds living and working in the same place (Hogan, 2013).

To achieve high cultural competence, teachers should be able to acknowledge the

immense influence of culture, assess cross-cultural relations and be vigilant

concerning the dynamics that results from cultural differences, expand their cultural

knowledge and incorporate this knowledge into their everyday practice and adapt the

diversity among the students. It is the collection of three components:

attitudes/beliefs, knowledge, and skills used in working with diverse groups of

people (Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J., 2010). It aims to learn new patterns of

behavior and effectively applying them in the appropriate settings and having the

capacity to function effectively in other cultural contexts.

Public schools with diverse student populations should assess the cultural

competence of pre-service teachers in teacher education institutions for a culturally

responsive teaching (Bustamante, 2016).

The introduction of cross-cultural competence in adult education in Southeast

Asia should take into consideration the unique value and belief system of the people

in the region. Since the Philippines is a country that subscribes to the principle of

democracy, social justice, and progressive transformation of its society it must

therefore accept, if not embrace, multiculturalism ( Panahon II, 2011 ).

On Culturally Competent and Responsive Teachers

Several researches have established the importance of cultural competency in

improving students’ academic and behavioral outcomes resulting to an increase in

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 17

identifying effective methods for growing culturally responsive practices in K-12

education.

According to Cooper (2007), with the increasing complexity of student

diversity educator must go beyond knowledge of self, of one’s student, their families

and communities in order to develop critical cultural competence which entails

teachers’ abilities to engage in a self-reflection about their cultural identities and

experiences and also in critical reflection to surface personal biases and to form

visions and beliefs that guide, and even transform, educational practices in diverse

settings; explore the cultural backgrounds of their students, families, and the

communities and find ways to negotiate their roles as teachers and administrators to

leverage students’ strengths and assets to maximize learning; and transform their

individual practices in classrooms, schools, and in their local educational settings by

using systematic, thoughtful, and innovative practices and collaborations. Moreover,

culturally responsive educators reject color-blind construct by recognizing ethnic

groups, their students’ origin and incorporate students’ languages and cultures in

their teaching. Culturally responsive educators acknowledge that being colorblind is

detrimental to their students’ academic, social, emotional, and psychological

development and limits their professional development and disposition. With this

educators will learn to see students for who they are, and they become and value the

strengths they acquire from their diverse cultural backgrounds. They negotiate the

cultural conflict that their positions of power often represent by accepting the fact

that not all their students are of the same level and status. They reject the myth of

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 18

meritocracy by encouraging students to work hard by providing them content and

skills and encourage to keep on going despite different barriers. Lastly, they reject

deficit-based thinking by valuing the identities of their students and treat them

equally and go beyond traditional practices (Cooper,2007).

Culturally responsive schools should support teachers’ skill-building through

professional development that reinforces culturally competent practices. The national

Center for Culturally Responsive Educational Systems (NCCRESt) highlights six

“Principles of professional learning to prepare culturally responsive teachers

(Hanover Research, 2014). These principles are: Improving learning within a

diverse, multicultural community, engaging in joint, productive activity through

discourse, inquiry, and public professional practice, facet of daily living, not a

compartmentalized activity, improved learning for students who have been

marginalized from the academic and social curricula of the public school system,

influences decisions about what is taught and why, and focuses on the diffusion of

professional knowledge to build sustainable educational communities focused on

improving learning outcomes for all students and their families.

Culturally Responsive Teaching engages students from diverse backgrounds

using teaching methodologies that can relate to their cultural heritages and

educational experiences and considers the cultural characteristics, experiences, and

perspectives of ethnically, and diverse students in order to have an effective learning

(Wilson, McChesney and Brown, 2017). Samuels (2018) elaborated the

characteristics of Culturally Responsive Pedagogy which is a student-centered

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 19

approach focusing on cultural references and recognizes the importance of students’

cultural backgrounds and experiences in all aspects of learning aiming on the

promotion of students’ engagement, enrichment, and achievement embracing a

wealth of diversity, identifying and nurturing students’ cultural strengths, and

validating students’ lived experiences and their place in the world.

In Philippine Education, the Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2013 or RA

10533 mandates an education that is “learner-oriented and responsive to the needs,

cognitive and cultural capacity, circumstances, and diversity of learners.” The

Department of Education issued the Department Order No. 43 s. 2013 that calls for

the inclusiveness of basic education through the implementation of programs for the

gifted, learners with disabilities, Muslim learners, indigenous peoples, and learners

under difficult circumstances. This policy requires teachers to become culturally

responsive in their teaching methodologies to institutionalize inclusive education.

Araling Panlipunan Teachers’ Competence and competency

The existence of teaching competency standards represents quality teaching

which advances students’ achievements and success. Ministries of Education around

the world set specific standards for teachers’ competency which shows the

expectations on how teaching is supposed to be practiced within a specific scale of

acceptable level and in order to produce good effects especially on improving

students’ learning. The teachers’ competency reflects the quality and caliber of

teachers of a country. The excellence of education in an institution inseparable from

the excellence of its faculty. The character of an institution depends heavily on the

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 20

vigor and commitment of its teaching staff. An institution cannot offer quality

education without high caliber and dedicated teachers (Idul, 2018). Teaching

competencies are defined as the level of integration of knowledge, skills, and

attitudes (Magno, 2013).

The National Council for the Social Studies describes and explains the

national standards for Social Studies teachers consisting two types: The Subject

Matter Standards and the Pedagogical Standards. In Subject Matter Standards, Social

Studies teachers should have wide kowledge about the content and possess the skills

in teaching the subject. Pedagogical Standards, is the ability of teachers in utilizing

appropriate teaching strategies to become effective. The Subject Matter Standards

are of three types: thematic standards, disciplinary standards, and programmatic

standards for initial licensure. One of the thematic standards is “Culture and Cultural

Diversity” which emphasize that Social studies teachers should possess the

knowledge, capabilities, and dispositions to organize and provide instruction at the

appropriate school level for the study of culture and cultural diversity.

Southeast Asian Ministers of Education Organization (SEAMEO

INNOTECH, 2010) was tasked to study and explore the commonalities in teaching

competency standards across the region in pursuit of international development

goals. SEAMEO INNOTECH has identified five common domains of teaching

competency standards for Southeast Asia namely: professional knowledge,

professional skills, personal sharacteristics, professional/personal ethical standards

and values, and Professional development and lifelong learning. Moreover, the

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 21

general area competencies of Southeast Asian teachers in the 21st century are

facilitating the development of learner’s and career skills, dreating a conducive

learning environment, facilitating learning, preparing appropriate lesson plans in line

with the school vision and mission, developing higher order thinking skills,

developing and utilizing teaching and learning resources, enhancing ethical and

moral values, assessing and evaluating learner performance, engaging in professional

development, networking with stakeholders especially with parents, and managing

students’ welfare and other tasks.

Based on the Philippine Education For All 2015 National Plan of Action, the

Philippine Government should provide basic competencies to everyone to achieve

functional literacy for all. This will be done through the four-component objectives

namely: universal coverage of out-of-school youth and adults in the provision of

learning needs; universal school participation and total elimination of dropouts and

repetition in Grades 1 to 3 ; universal completion of full cycle of basic education

schooling with satisfactory achievement levels by all at every grade or year;

commitment by all Philippine communities to the attainment of basic education

competencies for all – Education for All by All. To achieve these goals, nine urgent

and critical tasks categorized into general classes were formulated. One of these

tasks is that teachers should promote practice of high quality teaching.

The Department of Education recently issued a DepEd Order entitled

“National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for

Teachers” which engage teachers to actively embrace a continuing effort in attaining

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 22

proficiency cognizant to K to 12 Reform, ASEAN Integration, globalization, and the

character of 21st Century learners. Relatively, Magno (2013) pointed out that in the

Philippines, the set of teacher competencies are stated as one of the domains of the

National Competency Based Teaching Standards (NCBTS). There are seven

domains that serve as indicators of teachers’ performance. Two of these are related

to cultural competence; Social Regard for Learning in which teachers serves as

positive role models which describes the social interaction of teachers with students

and the Diversity of Learners.

Ali, M.F.B., Ahmad,A.R. and Seman, A.A. (2017), explained that among

teachers’ knowledge domain is the pedagogical knowledge of the content consisting

of knowledge about conception and the purpose of teaching a subject, knowledge on

student understanding, knowledge about curriculum and knowledge on teaching

strategy. Effective teaching is the result of a teacher’s skill in using pedagogy

suitable to the needs of his students’ learning styles.

As discussed by Altarejos (2017), teachers’ competencies may hinder or

improve the learning of students with their mastery of the subject matter,

communication skills and school-community linkages. She further emphasized the

importance of assessing teachers’ competencies to meet their full potentials.

In the study conducted by Murcia et.al (2015), the authors argue that it is

very essential to have processes for evaluating performance methodologies that

respond to the educational and professional needs. This is similar to basic education

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 23

teachers should be active in the aforementioned evaluation to improve their

teaching strategies to optimize quality in the tertiary education.

The results of the research conducted by Olegario ( 2016 ) on the

competencies of Araling Panlipunan- HEKASI Teachers in the Public Elementary

Schools in Las Pinas showed that most of the respondents as rated by themselves

and their principals were competent in all four aspects of competencies, namely:

General Competencies, Teaching Geography, Civics, and History.

On Araling Panlipunan/Social Studies as a Subject

As stipulated in DepEd Order No. 20 s.2014, Social Studies or Araling

Panlipunan is described as a subject that aims to show deep understanding of the

primary ideas and current issues in teaching History, Government, Culture and the

Society of the Asian Region; History of the World; Concepts of Economics and

National Growth and development and current issues and concerns of the society.

The New Basic Education Curriculum clearly elucidates the scope and

themes of Araling Panlipunan which is adapted from the National Council for Social

Studies (2002). It consists of: People, Places, and Environments; Time, Continuity,

and Change; Culture and Cultural Diversity; Individual Development and Identity;

Individuals, Groups, and Institutions; Power, Authority, and Governance;

Production, Distribution, and Consumption; Civic Ideals and Practices and Global

Connections to develop learners’ skills such as creativity, critical thinking, logical

decision making, inquiry and research skills, historical competence, and

communication skills.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 24

According to the study conducted by Crisolo, Camposano, & Rogayan

(2017), social studies is still relevant today as it provides knowledge, promotes

values formation, fosters cultural sensitivity, encourages community participation

and broadens global perspective. Moreover, participants claimed that Araling

Panlipunan promotes cultural heritage, fosters economic efficiency, serves as a

source of meaningful information and brings people back to the past.

Synthesis

Araling Panlipunan as a subject was defined differently by different authors

and organizations but they targeted the same goal which is to develop a responsible

citizens who are globally competitive. Through this discipline, students acquire

knowledge, skills and attitudes that will make them deal effectively with the different

issues of the society.

To establish quality education, schools and educators should be culturally

responsive. Cooper (2011) and Moule (2012) both agreed that in order to be

culturally responsive one must possess the skills of awareness and acceptance of

differences, self-Awareness, dynamics of difference, knowledge of the student’s

culture and adaptation of skills .

The study conducted by Murcia et.al (2015) is parallel to the present study

since it assesses teachers in response to their educational and professional needs. The

researcher agree that teachers should be active in the aforementioned evaluation to

improve their teaching strategies to optimize quality education by being culturally

responsive.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 25

Considering the current study, it is critical for Araling Panlipunan teachers to

have in-depth understanding of the concept of cultural competence to employ

culturally responsive teaching for their students. Educators should use culturally

relevant instructional materials and practices to have effective communication with

diverse learners because students learn best when course content relates to their own

context (Hanover Research, 2014).

Theoretical Framework

The study is anchored on the Conscious Competence Theory of Broadwell.

As cited by Altajeros (2017), Conscious Competence Theory explains the process

and stages of learning a new skill such as ability, behavior and the like. Every

individual possesses natural strengths and preferences which affects their attitudes

and commitment towards learning as well as developing their own competence. We

experience different levels of challenges in progressing through learning stages. This

theory supports this study since it tries to explain how to learn and develop

competence in different disciplines like in the field of teaching. Teachers pass

different stages of competency until they become highly competent and effective.

Neophyte teachers at first have ‘unconscious competence’since they are not fully

aware of their own skills and abilities until moving to the ‘consciousness

competence’ stage wherein they will realize the relevance of equipping themselves

with the necessary skills to improve their performance to better serve their learners

Moreover Erick Ericsson's Theory of Expertise explains that the amount of

practice and experience in the development of expertise incorporated with quality in

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 26

the form of sustained deliberate practice is more important. Expert performance

reflects the mastery of the available knowledge or current performance standards and

relates to skills that master teachers and coaches know how to train. The finding that

expert performers in very different domains reflect the acquisition of similar

mediating mechanisms for their performance presumes that there are specific

components necessary for the acquisition of any form of expert performance or

knowledge (Theiler, 2016). Ericsons’ theory supports this study because of the

possibility and discovery of the different contributory factor to achieve expert

performance in the teaching field through the career life of an educator with the aid

of deliberate practice.

According to Draganidis and Mentzas as mentioned by Russo (2016),

competency model is a list of competencies which are derived from observing

satisfactory or exceptional employee performance for a specific occupation. The

model can provide identification of the competencies employees need to develop in

order to improve performance in their current job or to prepare for other jobs via

promotion or transfer. Competencies are grouped into three categories: Knowledge

which concerns everything that can be learned from educational/formative systems

and training courses and everything which involves cognitive processes; Know-how

which is related to personal experiences and working conditions; Behavior which

refers to individual characters, talents, human traits, or qualities that drive someone

to act or react in a certain way under certain circumstances.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 27

Moreover, Metsanen (2011, as cited by Soininen, A. 2012) presents cultural

competence in three factors which includes knowledge, skills and attitudes and

qualities a teacher should have. Knowledge competencies includes awareness on

cultural differences; background information on students, situation in country of

origin; idea of studying culture; recognition of cultural shock; prejudice in learning

process; process of acculturation and different interaction and communication

methods. Skills includes flexible pedagogical skills; planning curriculum for

heterogeneous group; different teaching methods; different interaction and

communication skills; conflict resolution; interaction in unpredicted situations;

interaction with different people and high language Skills. Attitudes includes self-

awareness on effects of own culture; equality; tolerance towards stress and conflicts;

tolerance towards cultures and flexibility; sense of humor; tolerance to cope with

uncertain situations; tolerance to function in unpredicted situations and facing people

without prejudice.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 28

Conceptual Framework

Teachers’ Demographic Cultural Competencies


Profile of AP Teachers
assessed by themselves
 Educational Attainment
 No. of years in the service  Awareness of beliefs
 Trainings, seminars and and attitude
other related activities and  Knowledge
programs related to  Skills
cultural competence
attended

Problems/Challenges

Recommendations

Figure 1 . The Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in

Public Secondary Schools of Baras Rizal

The study sought to describe the cultural competencies of Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in public secondary schools of Baras Rizal by assessing their educational

attainment, no. of years in service and trainings, seminars and other related activities

and programs related to cultural competence attended by Araling Panlipunan

Teachers. Cultural Competences comprise awareness of beliefs and attitudes, skills

and knowledge (Hanover Research, 2014). As cited by Evola (2012), emphasized

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 29

that Attitudes/Beliefs component of cultural competence is defined as “an

understanding of one’s own cultural conditioning that affects personal beliefs,

values, and attitudes”; while the Knowledge component is defined as “understanding

and knowledge of the worldviews of culturally different individuals and groups”; and

the Skills component is defined as the “use of culturally appropriate

intervention/communication. This clearly explains that teachers’ attitudes and beliefs

regarding cultural issues, their cultural knowledge, and possession of the skills to

function in a multicultural environment are all essential components of cultural

competence.

The researcher determined the challenges or problem encountered by AP

teachers in the acquisition and practice of cultural competencies.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 30

CHAPTER III

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

In order to have a clear view of the study, presented in this chapter are the

research design, setting of the study, description of the subjects, sampling technique,

instrumentation utilized, and statistical treatment used in response to the objectives

of the study.

Research Design

This study used the descriptive comparative approach in collecting the data

needed. This design is appropriate because the intention is to describe the level of

cultural competence of Araling Panlipunan teachers in relation to their educational

attainment, number of years in service, and trainings and seminars attended. The

researcher examined the differences that exist among variables.

Data gathering was done through the use of adapted-modified questionnaire-

checklists as an instrument.

Research Locale

The study was conducted in the Public Secondary Schools in the District of

Baras Province of Rizal. In particular it was held at three Public Secondary Schools

in Baras, Rizal which includes Baras National High School, Baras-Pinugay

Integrated High School, and Baras-Pinugay Phase 2 National High School.

According to the official website of the Department of Interior and Local

Government Region IV-A CALABARZON, Baras is a 4th class municipality of the

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 31

Province of Rizal which is bounded by the City of Antipolo on the north, on the east

by the Municipality of Tanay, and on the west by the Municipality of Morong. It is

around 51 kilometers from the Luneta Grandstand and 21 kilometers from the

Provincial Government Center. It is s located at the foothills of the Sierra Madre

Mountains and is described as a funnel-like shape which dips into the Laguna de

Bay. The Poblacion area in the southern end of the town is where the settlements and

human activities are concentrated. Residences, commercial establishments, the local

government center, institutional centers and the historic church of Baras are all found

here. Amidst all these, winds the Baras River. At the southernmost, the Baras tip dips

into the waters of grand old Laguna de Bay. Small fishing villages, marshlands, and

fish pens intermingle in this area.

It is politically subdivided into ten (10) barangays namely; Evangelista, Rizal, San

Jose, Santiago, San Salvador, Concepcion, San Juan, San Miguel, Mabini, and

Pinugay.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 32

. Figure 2 Location Map of Baras, Rizal

The Public Secondary Schools in Baras District in the Division of Rizal is

divided into three such as Baras National High School which is the pioneering school

located in Sitio Malalim, Barangay San Juan, Baras-Pinugay National High School

,later named as Baras-Pinugay Integrated High School, and Baras-Pinugay Phase 2

National High School. The last two are located in Barangay Pinugay.

Participants of the Study

The respondents of the study are fifteen (15) AP Teachers in the Public

Junior High School Baras District Division of Rizal.

The researcher utilized the purposive sampling technique by including all the

Araling Panlipunan teachers in the District. Table 1 presents the frequency

distribution of the AP teachers in Baras District.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 33

Table A: Frequency Distribution of Araling Panlipunan Teachers as


Respondents in Baras District province of Rizal

No. of. AP
Name of School Teachers
Respondent
Baras National High School 5
Baras Pinugay Integrated High School 5
Baras-Pinugay Phase 2 National High School 5
TOTAL 15

Research Instrument/s

The researcher used an adapted and modified questionnaire checklist on the

competencies of AP-HEKASI Teachers developed by Edmund Olevario in his

Master Thesis entitled “A study of the competencies of Araling Panlipunan –

HEKASI Teachers in the Public Elementary Schools in the second District of Las

Piñas City: Basis for a proposed competency Development Program” and the

“Cultural Competence Self Assessment Checklist” developed by Central Vancouver

Island Multicultural Society in Canada.

The level of cultural competencies in terms of awareness of beliefs and

attitude, skills and content-knowledge was measured using a five-point Likert-type

scale with corresponding appropriate verbal interpretation as indicated below:

Range Verbal Interpretation


4.20 – 5.00 Highly Competent
3.40 – 4.19 Competent
2.60 – 3.39 Moderately Competent
1.80 – 2.59 Fairly Competent
1.00 – 1.79 Least Competent

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 34

The challenges encountered by Secondary Araling Panlipunan Teachers in

Baras were measured using a five-point Likert-type scale with corresponding

appropriate verbal interpretation as indicated below:

Range Verbal Interpretation

4.20 – 5.00 Always Available

3.40 – 4.19 Very Often Available

2.60 – 3.39 Sometimes Available

1.80 – 2.59 Rarely Available

1.00 – 1.79 Not Available

Validation of the instruments was done by Araling Panlipunan and Social

Science Teachers who are Masters’ degree holders who are not included in the study

in order to have a clear, concise, and reliable research instrument.

Data Gathering Procedure

The researcher consulted Dr. Barbara Wong-Fernandez for advice about the

instrument. The researcher was advised to adapt and modify an existing validated

questionnaire-checklist by asking permission from authors. The researcher was able

to get permission from Edmund Olevario to adapt the questionnaire he developed in

his Master Thesis in De La Salle University, Dasmarinas, Cavite entitled “A study

of the competencies of Araling Panlipunan – HEKASI Teachers in the Public

Elementary Schools in the second District of Las Piñas City: Basis for a proposed

competency Development Program”. The researcher was able to get a copy of the

said questionnaire personally sent by the author through Facebook messenger. The

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 35

researcher also ask permission from Jennifer Fowler, Executive Director of Central

Vancouver Island Multicultural Society in Canada via email to adapt and modify the

“Cultural Competence Self Assessment Checklist developed by their organization.

With this the researcher was able to come up with a modified questionnaire from the

two instruments to suit the needs of her respondents.

The adapted-modified survey checklist underwent content validation among

the experts in the field of Araling Panlipunan and Social Science and was further

refined with the help of the adviser and panel members.

After the validation of the instrument, the researcher secured permission from

the Department of Education both Division Office of Rizal and District of Baras to

conduct the study. The survey-checklist was administered by the researcher to the

respondents during her school to school visitation.

Data gathered were tallied, interpreted and analyzed applying the appropriate

statistical tools.

Treatment of Data

In response to the statement of the problem of this study, the gathered data

were treated statistically using the following tools.:

Frequency and Percentage Distribution was used to determine the

demographic profile of Araling Panlipunan teachers in the public secondary schools

in Baras District D of Rizal in terms of: Educational Attainment, No. of years in

service, and Trainings, seminars and other related activities and programs related to

cultural competence attended. Frequency was the actual response to question for

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 36

which the respondent ticked his choice in the questionnaire. Percentage was used as

descriptive statistics to describes a part of the whole.

To measure the level of cultural competencies of Araling Panlipunan teachers

in public secondary schools in the Baras District as assessed by teachers themselves

in terms of Awareness of beliefs and attitude, Skills, and Knowledge and challenges

encountered by the selected Araling Panlipunan Teachers in the acquisition and

practice of cultural competencies in the public secondary schools in Division of

Rizal weighted mean was utilized. Weighted Mean measured the respondent’s

assessments by multiplying each value in the group by the appropriate weight factor.

The product were summed up and divided by the total number of respondents.

Analysis of Variance was used to find out if there any significant difference

in the level of Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers Cultural

Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers as assessed by themselves in terms

of the following variables grouped according to their Educational Attainment, No.

of years in service, and Trainings, seminars and other related activities and

programs related to cultural competencies attended by Araling Panlipunan Teachers

in public secondary schools assessed by themselves and their school heads.

Ethical Considerations

The teacher-respondents were given a brief description of the objectives and

methods used in the study which gave them an idea of what to expect from their

involvement in the conduct of the study.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 37

Confidentiality of the information from the respondents was assured. Data

was treated in a private and fair manner by protecting and valuing their welfare.

The privacy of all individuals was highly considered and their identity

remained anonymous throughout the study.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 38

CHAPTER IV

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter contains information about the results of the study and the

analysis and interpretation of data gathered with the use of the adapted statistical

measures. The presentation includes a narrative discussion of the results and

implications of the data gathered which are illustrated in tables.

Problem No. 1. The demographic profile of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in


Public Secondary Schools in Baras District province of Rizal as
the respondents in terms of the following:

1.1 Educational Attainment

1.2 Number of years in service

1.3 Trainings, seminars, programs and other activities related to

cultural competence attended.

Table 1.1 Demographic Profile of the Respondents in terms of Educational


Attainment

Educational Attainment Frequency Percentage


With Doctoral Units 1 6.7%
Master’s Degree Graduate 1 6.7%
With Master’s Degree Unit 3 20.0%
Bachelor’s Degree Graduate 10 66.7%
Total 15 100%

Table 1.1 presents the frequency and percentage distribution of the

respondents with respect to their educational attainment. As revealed by the data, ten

(10) respondents, comprising the majority attained Bachelor’s Degree or 66.7% of

the total population, 20% has Masters’ Degree units, only one respondent or 6.7%

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 39

finished Masters’ Degree and one or 6.7% has doctoral units. The findings imply that

majority of the respondents have not yet pursued post graduate education which can

be attributed to financial incapability, lack of motivation or preoccupation with too

much paper works and other tasks aside from teaching.

Table 1.2: Demographic Profile of the Respondents in terms of Number of Years in


the Service
No. of Years in the Service Frequency Percentage
30 yrs and above 1 6.7%
26-29 yrs
21-25 yrs
16-20 yrs 1 6.7%
11-15 yrs 1 6.7%
6-10 yrs 2 13.3%
5 yrs and below 10 66.7%
Total 15 100%

In terms of length of service, Table 1.2 shows that majority of the

respondents have been in the service for five (5) years and below comprising 66.7%

of the total population. This means that most of the Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in Public Secondary Schools of Baras District are generally new and young

in the teaching profession. The result of the data can be explained by the fact that the

two schools in Baras District are newly established especially Baras-Pinugay Phase 2

National High School in which majority of the teachers are newly hired.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 40

Table 1.3: Demographic Profile of the Respondents in terms of Training, and


Seminars Attended Related to Cultural Competence
No. of Trainings Frequency Percentage
International Level
None 13
1
2 1 6.7%
3 1 6.7%
Total 15 100%
Nation al Level
None 12 80%
1 2 13.3%
2 1 6.7%
Total 15 100%
Regional Level
None 12 80%
1 3 20%
Total 15 100%
Division Level
None 14 93.3%
2 1 6.7%
Total 15 100%
District Level
None 13 86.7%
1 2 13.3%
Total 15 100%
School Level
None 14 93.3 %
1 1 6.7%
Total 15 100%

Table 1.3 shows that most of the Secondary AP Teachers in Baras District

have had very few number of trainings and seminars related to cultural competence

for the past five years ranging from school to international level. The results indicate

that there are limited number of trainings and seminars designed for AP teachers

related to cultural competencies.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 41

Problem No. 2. The level of cultural competence of Araling Panlipunan


teachers in public secondary schools in Baras District Province
of Rizal as assessed by teachers themselves in terms:
2.1 Awareness of beliefs and attitude
2.2 Skills
2.3 Knowledge
2.4 Language

Table 2.1: Level of Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in Baras


District as Perceived by the respondents in Terms of Awareness of
Beliefs and Attitude
Competencies WM VI
1. Value Diversity: I view difference among my learners as a positive and
C
cause for celebration 4.47
2. Self-knowledge: I have a clear sense of my own ethnic, cultural and racial
HC
identity. 4.60
3. Share one’s culture: I am aware that in order to teach more about others
especially my students I need to understand and be prepared to share my HC
own culture. 4.73
4. Discomfort Awareness: I am aware of my discomfort when I encounter
differences in race, color, religion, sexual orientation, language, and C
ethnicity. 4.13
5. Assumptions: I am aware of the assumptions that I hold about people of
C
cultures different from my own. 4.20
6. Stereotypes: I am aware of my stereotypes as they arise and have
C
developed personal strategies for reducing the harm they cause. 4.27
7. Reflect on own culture informs judgment: I am aware of how my cultural
perspective influences my judgment about what are ‘appropriate’, C
‘normal’, or ‘superior’ behaviors, values, and communication styles. 4.13
8. Accept ambiguity: I accept that in cross cultural situations there can be
uncertainty that can make me anxious. It can also mean that I do not C
respond quickly and take the time needed to get more information. 4.07
9. Be Curious: I take any opportunity to put myself in places where I can
learn about difference and create relationship with my students and HC
colleagues. 4.60
10. Aware of my rights, privileges and responsibilities: I understand that I am
a person with rights, privileges, and responsibilities as a Filipino teacher. I HC
should be responsible of my actions. 4.80
Composite Mean 4.40 C
Legend: Highly Competent (HC)=4.50-5.00, Competent (C) =3.50-4.49,
Moderately Competent (MC) = 2.50-3.49, Fairly Competent (FC)=1.50-2.49,
Least Competent (LC)=1.00-1.49

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 42

Table 2.1 presents the level of cultural competencies of Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in Baras District as assessed by themselves in terms of Awareness of

Beliefs and Attitude. As reflected from the table, most of the respondents’ level of

cultural competence reached the competent level in terms of awareness of beliefs

and attitude.

The result implies that respondents are conscious of their own beliefs and

attitude although majority of the respondents are just five years below in the service.

Similarly, the Conscious Competence Theory of Broadwell (n.d.) reinforced the

result that every individual possesses natural strengths and preferences which affects

his attitudes and commitment towards learning as well as developing his own

competence. We experience different levels of challenges in progressing through the

learning stages. This theory is relevant to this study since it tries to explain how to

learn and develop competence in different disciplines in the teaching profession.

Teachers acquire different competencies until they become highly competent. (as

cited by Altajeros, 2017).

Culturally competent individuals move towards broadening their perspective

which acknowledges the simultaneous existence of different realities and value

complexity ( Moule, 2012). They are aware of the existence of cultural differences,

accept their reality and value and actively use them in helping others (Diller, 2007).

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 43

Table 2.2: Level of Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in Baras


District as Assessed by Themselves in Terms of Skills
Competencies WM VI
1. Adapt to different situations: I am developing ways to interact respectfully
C
and effectively with individual and groups of learner. 4.33
2. Challenge discriminatory behavior: I can effectively intervene when I C
observe my students and colleagues behaving discriminatory manner. 3.93
3. Communicate across cultures: I am able to adapt my communication style C
to effectively communicate with students and colleagues who
communicate in ways that are different from my own. 4.13
4. Become engaged: I am actively involved in initiatives that promote
C
understanding among members of diverse group specifically my students. 4.07
5. Act Respectfully in cross-cultural situations: I can act in ways that
C
demonstrate respect for the culture and beliefs of others. 4.40
6. Practice cultural protocol: I can design and employ culturally responsive
C
pedagogy. 4.07
7. Be flexible: I can work hard to understand the different perspective of my
C
learners and consult with my diverse colleagues. 4.27
8. Adaptive: I know and use a variety of relationship building skills to create
C
connections with my learners and colleagues who are different from me. 4.27
9. Contextualize and indigenize: I design and employ classroom activities C
based on the context of my students and use indigenous materials. 4.13
10. Family and Community Involvement: I design and employ activities that C
encourage involvement of family members and community stakeholders. 3.93
Composite Mean 4.15 C
Legend: Highly Competent (HC)=4.50-5.00, Competent (C) =3.50-4.49,
Moderately Competent (MC) = 2.50-3.49, Fairly Competent (FC)=1.50-2.49,
Least Competent (LC)=1.00-1.49

Table 2.2 presents the level of cultural competencies of AP Teachers in Baras

District as perceived by the respondents in terms of skills. The table shows that all

respondents’ level of cultural competence are competent in terms of skills.

The statistical results explain that all of the respondents are competent in all

cultural skills. The teacher-respondents have competent ability to use content

knowledge for culturally-responsive teaching. This further explains that they are

aware of the importance of employing culturally-responsive pedagogy. Likewise,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 44

Samuels (2008) explained the key features of culturally responsive pedagogy which

refers to a student-centered approach focusing on cultural references and recognizes

the importance of students’ cultural backgrounds and experiences in all aspects of

the teaching-learning process. Moreover, Wilson, McChesney, and Brown (2017)

emphasized that in order to have an effective learning, teachers shall engage students

from various backgrounds using teaching methodologies that can relate to their

cultural heritages and context.

This study is consistent with the Competency Model by Russo as mentioned

by Draganidis and Mentzas (2016). AP teachers are culturally competent in terms of

skills regardless of their teaching experience. The Competency Model explains that

competencies can be derived from observing satisfactory or exceptional employee

performance. The model can provide identification of the competencies employees

need to develop in order to improve performance in their current job or to prepare for

other jobs via promotion or transfer. Competencies can be learned from educational

systems and training courses. The paradigm shift in tertiary education which give

more exposure to education students in the field gives them more opportunity to

observe and acquire the necessary skills they need for their employment.

The findings were in consonance with the belief of the Department of

Education that the success of any educational system greatly relies on the

competence of its teachers. In order to realize this, DepEd institutionalized the

Teacher Induction Program (TIP) which provides activities that enhances teachers’

knowledge, skills, values and commitment to the teaching profession. Ferrer,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 45

Abulencia and Hermosisima (2018), recommended to the DepEd the

implementation of the TIP for new teachers in public schools in reference to the

results of their study which showed that new teachers encounter different challenges

such as handling large classes, student differences, and classroom management

which may result to incompetency since most of them have no teaching experience

or are transferees from private schools. The implementation of the TIP enhances

teachers’ knowledge, skills, values, and commitment to the profession as well as

improving students’ performance. This program helped the ten respondents who are

new in the service to be competent in the profession.

Table 2.3: Level of Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in Baras


District as Assessed by Themselves in Terms of Knowledge
Competencies WM VI
I possess competent knowledge about the social studies thematic standards in a
local perspective namely:
1. People, Places, and Environments 4.33 C
2. Time, Continuity, and Change 4.00 C
3. Culture and Cultural Diversity 4.13 C
4. Individual Development and Identity 4.00 C
5. Individuals, Groups, and Institutions 3.87 C
6. Power, Authority, and Governance 4.07 C
7. Production, Distribution, and Consumption 4.00 C
8. Civic Ideals and Practice 4.13 C
9. Global Connections 3.87 C

Composite Mean 4.04 C


Legend: Highly Competent (HC)=4.50-5.00, Competent (C) =3.50-4.49,
Moderately Competent (MC) = 2.50-3.49, Fairly Competent (FC)=1.50-2.49,
Least Competent (LC)=1.00-1.49

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 46

Table 2.3 presents the level of cultural competencies of AP Teachers in Baras

District as Assessed by themselves in Terms of Knowledge. The table shows that all

respondents’ are competent in terms of knowledge.

The results explain that teacher-respondents have a wide knowledge about

the different aspects of social studies despite the fact that majority of the respondents

are neophytes. The teachers’ total composite mean of 4.04 falling under competent

level can be explained by the implementation of new hiring guidelines for teachers in

the public schools, a move underlies the success of any education system greatly

relies on the competence of its teachers. In view of this, the hiring system was

improved to meet the professional standards to make sure that the teachers that will

be hired are able to contribute meaningfully to the development of the students and

the teaching profession. Teacher applicants are evaluated according to education,

teaching experience, licensure rating, specialized training and skills, interview,

demonstration teaching and communication skills attested by experts in the field.

This rigorous system has contributed to roster of competent newly hired teachers in

public school.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 47

Table 2.4: Level of Cultural Competencies of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in Baras


District as Assessed by Themselves in Terms of Language
Competencies WM VI
I possess competencies about the ff:
1. Familiarity towards learners’ spoken language characteristics C
3.73
2. Use of variety on language forms ranging from formal to informal C
3.67
3. Understand how to interpret verbal and written communications in a
large context
C
4.13
4. Understand the social meaning of utterances 3.87 C
5. Fluency in speaking, writing, listening, and reading of the local
C
language/s 3.80
Composite Mean 3.84 C
Legend: Highly Competent (HC)=4.50-5.00, Competent (C) =3.50-4.49,
Moderately Competent (MC) = 2.50-3.49, Fairly Competent (FC)=1.50-2.49,
Least Competent (LC)=1.00-1.49

Table 2.4 presents the level of cultural competencies of Araling Panlipunan

Teachers in Baras District as perceived by the respondents in terms of language. The

table shows that all respondents are competent in terms of language as revealed in

their composite mean of 3.84.

Problem No. 3. Significant difference in the level of cultural competence of


Araling Panlipunan teachers in public secondary schools in
Baras District Province of Rizal as assessed by teachers
themselves in terms of following variables when grouped
according to profile?
3.1 Awareness of beliefs and attitude
3.2 Skills
3.3 Knowledge
3.4 Language

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 48

Table 3.1: Significant Difference in the Level of Competence of Araling


Panlipunanan Teachers as Assessed by Teachers themselves when
grouped According to Profile

Computed Sig.
Profile ANOVA (p- Interpretation Decision
Value value)
Awareness of Beliefs and Attitude
Educational 4.50 0.034 Reject the Null
Attainment Significant Hypothesis
No. Years in 1.21 0.532 Not Do not Reject the
Teaching Significant Null Hypothesis
Trainings 1.08 0.542 Not Do not Reject the
Significant Null Hypothesis
Skills
Educational 5.65 0.032 Reject the Null
Attainment Significant Hypothesis
No. Years in 0.45 0.895 Not Do not Reject the
Teaching Significant Null Hypothesis
Trainings 1.89 0.547 Not Do not Reject the
Significant Null Hypothesis
Knowledge
Educational 4.67 0.045 Reject the Null
Attainment Significant Hypothesis
No. Years in 1.78 0.312 Not Do not Reject the
Teaching Significant Null Hypothesis
Trainings 2.34 0.456 Not Do not Reject the
Significant Null Hypothesis
Language
Educational 4.68 0.043 Reject the Null
Attainment Significant Hypothesis
No. Years in 1.24 0.546 Not Do not Reject the
Teaching Significant Null Hypothesis
Trainings 1.45 0.435 Not Do not Reject the
Significant Null Hypothesis
Note: p-value ≤ 0.05 – significant, p-value > 0.05 – not significant

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 49

Table 3.1 presents the results of the ANOVA value that determined if there is

a significant difference in the level of cultural competence of AP teachers in public

secondary schools in Baras District Province of Rizal as perceived by the

respondents in terms of awareness of belief and attitude, skills, knowledge and

language when grouped according to educational attainment, number of years in

teaching and seminars and trainings attended.

As can be seen from the results, there is a significant difference in the level of

cultural competence of AP teachers when grouped according to educational

attainment since the computed p-value of 0.034 for awareness of beliefs and attitude;

0.032 p-value for skills; 0.045 p-value for knowledge and 0.043 p-value for language

competencies are less than 0.05. This result is in line with the study made by Gorham

(2001, as cited by Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J. 2010), which claimed that teachers

with higher levels of education have higher levels of cultural competence than

teachers with less education. This implies that teachers who have earned advanced

degrees other than bachelor’s degree show a deeper level of understanding of

cultural diversity. Teachers who have advanced degrees are equipped with a keener

insight into the theoretical and the practical knowledge and skills about culturally-

responsive pedagogy.

The result ultimately disagrees with the study conducted by Olegario, E.

(2016) which claimed that AP Teachers who are new in the service have low

competencies as perceived by the teacher-respondents and their respected principals

because they lacked experience.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 50

However, there is no significant difference in the level of cultural

competence of AP teachers when grouped according to number of years in teaching

and trainings attended since the computed p-value is greater than alpha 0.05. This is

in line with the study of Dejaeghere, J & Zhang, Y (2008) which reveals that cultural

competence is not related to years of teaching experience. Likewise, Schim (2005,

as cited by Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J. 2010), found that cultural competence is not

significantly associated with experience. Moreover, Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J.

(2010), elaborated that novice teachers have gained competence from the changing

nature of teacher education curriculum that they had in their tertiary education which

include competencies to be culturally-responsive. The veteran teachers may have had

tertiary education which did not focus on cultural competencies but have learned

from their years of experience and exposure in the field with diverse learners and

colleagues. Furthermore, the results of this study is consistent with the findings of

Wilson, P. (2014) which found out that there is no significant differences in teachers’

total cultural competence levels and demographic responses related to years of

teaching experience and training. Consequently, Ang and Dyne (2008, as mentioned

by Allison, L. (2012), explained that new teachers are more culturally aware when

interacting with students from different cultures than teachers with long experience.

The bases for these differences is the age gap between the two groups of teachers.

Teachers who are new in the teaching profession are more culturally sensitive and

aware than their older colleagues since they are more exposed to changing

demographics as well as to the new curriculum focus on cultural sensitivity.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 51

Consequently the ongoing paradigm shift of learning competency based standards in

Philippine Higher Education which aims to expose undergraduate students to various

domains of knowledge and ways of comprehending social and natural realities,

developing in the process, intellectual competencies and civic capacities.

On the other hand, the study conducted by Teasley, M., Baffour, T., & Tyson

E. (2005) reveals that the number of years of experience was a predictor of culturally

competent practice in school. Similarly, Aziz (2014) argued that teachers with

training were more competent than teachers having no training. Likewise,

Dejaeghere, J & Cao,Y (2009), found out that there is a significant change in

teachers’ competence when the school district implemented intercultural training

initiatives. This explains that the training programs initiated by the district increase

the educators’ level of competence.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 52

Table No. 3.2: Post Hoc analysis on the Level of Competence of Araling
Panlipunanan Teachers as Assessed by Teachers themselves when grouped
According to Profile

Category Computed Sig (p - Interpretation Decision


T- Test value)
Value
A vs B 1.546 0.326 Not Significant Do not Reject Ho
A vs C 3.537 0.045 Significant Reject Ho
A vs D 3.528 0.047 Significant Reject Ho
B vs C 4.326 0.034 Significant Reject Ho
B vs D 3.216 0.041 Significant Reject Ho
C vs D 1.436 0.325 Not Significant Do not Reject Ho

Legend:
Doctoral Units (A), Masters Degree (B), With Master Degree Units (C), Bachelors Degree (D)

Table 3.2 presents the Post Hoc on the level of competence of Araling

Panlipunan teachers according to their educational attainment.

There is a significant difference between the level of cultural competence of

the respondents with Doctoral units and with Master’s degree units based on the p-

value of 0.045. Likewise, the difference in the level of cultural competence of the

respondents with doctoral units and bachelor’s degree was found to be significant as

revealed by the computed p-value of 0.047. Similarly, there is a significant difference

between the level of cultural competence of the respondents with Master’s degree

and with Master’s degree units based on the p-value of 0.034. There is also a

significant difference in the cultural competence of the respondents with Masters’

degree and Bachelor’s degree as revealed by the computed p-value of 0.041.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 53

However, the data show that there was no significant difference between the

respondents with doctoral units and master’s degree groups ( p= 0.326) and with

masters’ degree units and bachelors’ degree groups (p= 0.325).

The data provides statistically significant evidence that the cultural

competence of AP teachers are not the same for all educational level. Overall the

data shows significant difference in cultural difference when grouped according to

educational attainment.

Problem No. 4. Challenges encountered by the Araling Panlipunan teachers in


the acquisition and practice of cultural competencies in the
public secondary schools in Baras District in Division of Rizal.

Table 4: Challenges Encountered by Araling Panlipunan Teachers in Acquisition


and Practice of Cultural Competencies
Problems/Challenges on the acquisition and practice of Cultural WM VI
Competencies
1. Availability of functional library 3.20 SA
2. Availability of sufficient instructional materials that is culturally
SA
responsive 3.07
3. Availability of training, workshops, seminars and other activities
about cultural competencies SA
2.93
4. Availability of mentor/s who are expert in the discipline 3.20 SA
5. Availability of community linkages and support 3.07 SA
Composite Mean 3.09 SA

Legend: Always Available (AA)=4.50-5.00, Very Often Available (VOA) =3.50-4.49,


Sometimes Available (SA) = 2.50-3.49, Rarely Available (RA)=1.50-2.49,
Not Available (NA)=1.00-1.49

Table 4 shows that the weighted mean of the responses of the teacher-

respondents range from 2.50 to 3.49. Respondents perceived that functional library,

sufficient instructional materials, training, workshops, seminars and other activities,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 54

mentors, and community linkages and support are sometimes available which are

revealed by the composite mean of 3.09.

The results of the study show that the respondents are competent in terms of

awareness of beliefs and attitude, skills, knowledge and language according to their

perception; however they were less able to demonstrate their acquisition of a higher

level of cultural competencies because it of the lack of availability of diverse

resources from the school and community. The findings of this study is in line with

the study of Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J. (2010) which pointed out that a higher

level cultural competence is impaired by different internal and external problems

encountered by teachers such as schedules, lack of implementation skills training,

lack of administrative support, and lack of motivation to implement the skills.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 55

CHAPTER V

SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions, and

recommendations based on the results of the study.

Summary of Findings

Among the important findings of this research were:

1. On the demographic profile of Araling Panlipunan Teachers in

Public Secondary Schools in Baras District province of Rizal as the respondents

in terms of:

1.1 Educational attainment

The survey-checklist accomplished by the respondents yielded the

information that ten (10) or 66.7% of the total population obtained Bachelor’s

Degree, 20% has Masters’ Degree units; one (1) or 6.7% finished Masters’

degree, and one(1) or 6.7% has doctoral units.

1.2 Number of years in service and trainings

In terms of length of service,10 out of the 15 respondents, or 66.7% of

the total population, have been in the service for five(5) years and below.

Two(2) or 13.3% of the respondents have been in the service for 6-10 years,

one(1) or 6.7% is between 11-15 years in the service, one or 6.7% has served

from 16-20 years and only one(1) or 6.7% has been in the service for 30

years.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 56

1.3 Number of years in service and trainings, seminars, programs

and other activities attended related to cultural competence attended.

Most of the AP Teachers in Baras District have attended only a few

number of trainings and seminars related to cultural competence for the past

five years ranging from school to international level.

2. On the level of cultural competence of AP teachers in public

secondary schools in Baras District Province of Rizal as assessed by the

respondents in terms of:

2.1. Awareness of beliefs and attitude,

The teacher-respondents were found to be competent in terms of

awareness of beliefs as revealed by the composite mean of 4.40. However, for

self-knowledge, which obtained a weighted mean of 4.60, 4.73 for sharing of

culture, 4.60 for curiosity and 4.80 for awareness of rights, privileges and

responsibilites, the respondents were showm to be highly competent.

2.2 Skills

The teacher-respondents were found to be competent in terms of

cultural skills in all criteria as revealed by the obtained composite mean

values of 4.15

2.3 Knowledge

The teacher-respondents were found to be competent in terms of

knowledge in all criteria as revealed by the obtained composite mean values

of 4.04 .

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 57

2.4 Language

The teacher-respondents were found to be competent in terms of

language in all criteria as revealed by the obtained composite mean values of

3.84 .

3. On the significant difference in the level of cultural competence of

AP teachers in as perceived by respondents in terms of following variables when

grouped according to profile.

3.1. Educational attainment

For educational attainment, the following computed p-value for the

given variables were obtained: awareness of beliefs and attitude (p=0.034);

skills (p=0.032); knowledge (p=0.045); and language (p=0.043). Each of the

p-values is lower than the level of significance of 0.05 which means that

there is a significant difference in the level of cultural competence of the

respondents when grouped according to educational attainment. This shows

that education plays a vital role in the acquisition of competence.

3.2. Number of years in teaching

For the number of years in teaching, the following p-values for the

given variables were obtained: awareness of beliefs and attitude (p=0.532);

skills (p=0.895); knowledge (p=0.312); and language (p=0.546). Each of the

p-values is higher than the level of significance of 0.05 which means that

there is no significant difference in the level of cultural competence of the

respondents when grouped according to number of years in teaching. Number

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 58

of teaching experience does not affect the level of competence of the

respondents.

3.3. Seminars and trainings

For seminar and trainings attended, the following p-values were

obtained awareness of beliefs and attitude (p=0.542); skills (p=0.547);

knowledge (p=0.456) ;and language (p=0.435). Each of the p-values is higher

than the level of significance of 0.05 which means that there is no significant

difference in the level of cultural competence of the respondents when

grouped according to seminars and trainings attended.

4. On the challenges encountered by AP teachers in the acquisition

and practice of cultural competencies in public secondary schools in Baras

District Division of Rizal.

In the acquisition and practice of cultural comptence , the AP teachers

encountered problems and challenges such as the lack of functional library,

sufficient instructional materials that are culturally responsive, seminars and training,

expert mentors and community linkages and support. These resources or means of

support were perceived as sometimes available as revealed by the computed

composite mean of 3.09.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 59

Conclusions

Based on the foregoing findings, the following conclusions were drawn:

1. Majority of the population of AP teachers in Baras District are

generally new in the service, have no post graduate degree and lack seminars and

trainings related to cultural competencies.

2. AP teachers are culturally competent in terms of level of awareness of

beliefs and attitude, skills, knowledge and language.

3. There is a significant difference in the level of cultural competence of

Araling Panlipunan teachers in terms of awareness of beliefs and attitude, skills,

knowledge and language when grouped according to educational attainment.

There is no significant difference in the level of cultural competence of

Araling Panlipunan teachers in terms of awareness of beliefs and attitude, skills,

knowledge and language when grouped according to number of years in teaching

and seminars and trainings attended.

4. The respondents encountered problems/challenges in the acquisition

and practice of cultural competence. These challenges covers availability of

functional library, sufficient instructional materials that are culturally responsive,

seminars and training, expert mentors, and community linkages and support.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 60

Recommendations

In the light of the conclusions drawn from the study, the following are hereby

recommended:

1. Conduct projects and programs that will focus on rekindling the

interest and spirit of teachers for professional growth such as pursuing post graduate

studies for the benefit of the students and community.

2. Since the results showed that AP Teachers are culturally competent,

they should employ pedagogies and practices that will immerse students in the

diverse cultures of the community.

3. Future research could examine the level of cultural competence of AP

teachers and other teachers by providing assessment tools for the students, peers,

parents and school administrators to have a 360° evaluation.

4. Design a program on community-based learning by creating

community linkages and partnership.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 61

REFERENCES

Abocol, R. & Añonuevo R., (2015). Gender politics in Edilberto K. Tiempo’s to be

free: A cultural studies reading. The Normal Lights Journal on Teacher

Education, Vol.9, No.1 Philippine Normal University, Manila, Philippines

Ali, M.F.B., Ahmad, A.R. & Seman, A.A. (2017). Teachers’ competencies in

teaching and learning history. Open Journal of Social Sciences. Retrieved

from https://www.researchgate.com Jan.26, 2019

Allison, L. (2012). An investigation of cultural competence in teachers. Wayne State

University Dissertation

Altarejos, J.M., (2017). Teachers’ competencies and students’ academic

performance in Social Studies in Selected Secondary Schools: Basis for a

teachers’ training model. Unpublished master’s thesis. Eulogio Rodriguez

Institute of Science and Technology.

Andres, T. & Andres P. (1987). Understanding the Filipino. New Day Publishers.

Quezon City, Philippines

Aziz, F. (2014). Impact of training on teachers’ competencies at higher education

level. Retrieved from www.researchgate.net September 28,2019

Bakhru, K. M. (2017). Personal competencies for effective teaching: A review

based study” educational quest: An Int. J. of Education and Applied Social

Science: 8, Special Issue, pp. 297-303

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 62

Baraceros, E. L. (2016). Practical research 2. Rex Printing Company, Inc.

Sampaloc, Manila, Philippines.

Barrows, D., P. (1905). A history of the Philippines. New York City: American

Book Company

Bernardos (2011). An assessment of the language competence of hotel and restaurant

management students. Unpublished master Thesis Philippine Normal

University.

Bonney, E.A et.al (2015). The relationship between the quality of teachers and pupils

academic performance in the STMA Junior High Schools of the Western

Region of Ghana. Journal of Education and Practice. Vol.6, No.4 Retrieved

from https://www.researchgate.com September 27, 2019

Bustamante et.al. (2016). Evaluation of a cultural competence assessment for

Preservice Teachers. Retrieved from https://www.tandfonline.com Jan.26,

2019

Cooper, J., He, Y., & Levin, B. (2011). Developing critical cultural competence:

A Guide for 21st-Century Educators. Corwin, United States of America

Dejaeghere, J & Cao,Y (2009). Developing U.S. teachers’ intercultural competence:

Does professional development matter?. International Journal of Intercultural

Relations. www.elsevier.com’loacte/ijintrel

Dejaeghere, J & Zhang, Y (2008). Development of intercultural competence among

US American teachers: Professional development factors that enhance

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 63

competence. Intercultural education, v19 n3 retrieved from

https://www.eric.ed.gov

Dela Cruz, B.C., (2017). Teaching Competency and performance of Teachers in the

Division of Muntinlupa: Basis for Professional Development Training

program” Unpublished master thesis. Eulogio Rodriguez Institute of Science

and Technology.

Department of Education (2014). Additional information and corrigendum to Deped

Order No.31,s.2012: Policy guidelines on the implementation of grades 1 to

10 of the K to 12 basic education curriculum effective school year 2012-2013.

Retrieved from www.deped.gov.ph. Department of Education Order No. 20

S.2014. Jan. 26, 2019

Department of Education (2013). Department of Education Order No.43 series of

2013. Implementing rules and regulations of RA 10533.. Retrieved from

www.deped.gov.ph. Jan. 26, 2019

Department of Education (2017). Department of Education Order No.42 series of

2017. National adoption of professional performance standards for teachers.

Retrieved from www.deped.gov.ph. Jan. 26, 2019

Department of Education (2017). Department of Education Order No.43 series of

2017. Teacher Induction Program. Retrieved from www.deped.gov.ph.

September 21, 2019

Department of Interior and Local Government – Region IV-A CALABARZON

(2014). Baras: Historical background and geographic location. Retrieved

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 64

from http://calabarzon.dilg.gov.ph/133-old-lgus/old-rizal-lgus?start=12. Jan.

26, 2019

Diller, J.,V. (2007). Cultural Diversity: A primer for the human services”. Third

Edition Brooks/Cole Cencage Learning. Canada

Doda, S. (2005). Introduction to sociology. Ethiopia Public Health Training

Initiative.

Domingo, M.Q., (2017). Teachers’ competencies and students’ academic

performance in public secondary schools in the division of Calamba City:

Basis for a proposed Growth-Oriented Training Program”. Unpublished

master’s thesis. Eulogio Rodriguez Institute of Science and Technology.

Farroq U. (2011). What is culture, definition, features & characteristics. Retrieved

from www.studylecturenotes.com March 17, 2019

Ferrer, J., Abulencia, A. & Hermosisima, M.V. (2018). Beginning teacher induction

practices in the context of large classes”. Retrieved from

www.researchgate.net/publication Sept.22, 2019

Garcia J. (2018). Diversity of learners. Sun.Star Pampanga. Retrieved from

www.sunstar.net

Hanover Research (2014). Strategies for building cultural competency.p2-18.

Washington D.C. retrieved from http://gssaweb.org January 26, 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 65

Hogan, M. (2013). Four Skills of Cultural Diversity Competence: A Process for

Understanding and Practice. Fourth Edition Brooks/Cole Publishing

Company

Idul, A. (2018). Teachers’ competencies and academic performance of the

elementary learners in Imus, Cavite: Basis for a training program.

Unpublished master’s thesis. Eulogio Rodriguez Institute of Science and

Technology.

Indexmundi, B. (2018). Philippine demographics profile 2018. Retrieved from

http://www.indexmundi.com Philippines Demographics Profile. January 26,

2019

Laird, S., E. (2008). Anti-Oppressive Social Work: Guide for developing cultural

competence”. SAGE Publication Ltd.

Leighton, L. & Harkins, M.J. (2010). Teachers’ perceptions of their cultural

competencies: An investigation into the relationships among teacher

characteristics and cultural competence”. Mt. St. Vincent University.

Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.com Jan.26, 2019

Lum, D. (1999). Culturally competent practice: A Framework for Growth and

Action Brooks/Cole Publishing Company.

Magno, C. (2013). Standards of Teacher Competence on Student Assessment in the

Philippines. The assessment handbook Vol.10 De la Salle Araneta University

Retrieved from www.researchgate.net Jan. 26, 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 66

Moule, J. (2012). Cultural competence: A primer for educators. 2nd Edition

Wadsworth, Cencage Learning, United States of America

Murcia, J.A. M., Torregrosa, Y. S., & Pedreno, N.B. “Questionnaire evaluating

teaching competencies in the university environment. Evaluation of teaching

competencies in the university”. New approaches in educational research.

4(1). January 2015 pp. 54-61. DOI: 10.7821/near.2015.1.106

National Council for the Social Studies (1994). “National Curriculum Standards for

Social Studies: Introduction. Retrieved from http://www.socialstudies.org.

Jan. 26, 2019

Olegario, E. (2016). A Study of the competencies of Araling Panlipunan HEKASI

teachers in the public elementary schools in the second district of Las Piñas

City: Basis for a proposed competency development program. Unpublished

master’s thesis. De La Salle University – Dasmarinas, Cavite

Panahon II, A. (2011). Developing Cross Cultural Competence in Adult Learning in

the ASEAN Context. Published master Thesis. Ateneo De Manila University

Graduate of School Business.

Panopio, MacDonald, & Raymundo (1994). General Sociology: Focus on the

Philippines, Third Edition. Quezon City.

Parto, L. (2016). Teachers’ competencies in relation to pupils’ academic

performance in San Pedro Central Schools S.Y. 2013-2015. Unpublished

master’s thesis. Philippine Normal University.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 67

Philippine Statistics Authority (2012). Domestic and International Migrants in the

Philippines: Results from the 2010 Census Retrieved from

http://www.psa.gov.ph Jan. 26, 2019

Philippine Statistics Authority (2015). Population of Region IV-A - CALABARZON

(Based on the 2015 Census of Population) retrieved from

https://psa.gov.ph/content/population-region-iv-calabarzon-based-2015-

census-population Jan. 26, 2019

Province of Rizal (2019). General Information. Retrieved from

www.rizalprovince.ph Jan. 26, 2019

Ramirez M. (20016). Cultural diversity and education in an increasingly globalizing

world: from the perspective of a ‘developing country’. Globalization and

Education Pontifical Academy of Sciences, Extra Series 28, Vatican City

Retrieved from www.pas.va/content/dam/accademia/pdf/es28/es28-

ramirez.pdf

Republic of the Philippines Congress ( 2012 ). An act enhancing the Philippine basic

education system by strengthening its curriculum and increasing the number

of years for basic education appropriating funds therefor and for other

purposes. Or RA 105333. Retrieved from http://www.officialgazette.gov.ph.

Jan. 26, 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 68

Russo D. (2016). Competency measurement model. European conference on quality

in officials statistics. Madrid, Spain. Retrieved from www.ine.es

Salmona, M., Partio, M., Kaczynski, D., & Leonard, S.N. (2015). Developing

Culturally Competent Teachers: An International Student Teaching Field

Experience. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 40(4). DOI:

10.14221/ajte.2015v40n4.3

Samuels, A. J. (2018). Exploring Culturally Responsive Pedagogy: Teachers’

Perspectives on Fostering Equitable and Inclusive Classrooms. SRATE

Journal Winter 2018/Volume 27(1) p.22-30 Retrieved from

http://files.eric.ed.gov

Soininen, A. (2012). A descriptive study on cultural competence of teachers in

english degree program. Diaconia University

SEAMEOINNOTECH Raising Teacher Standards in Southeast Asia: Eleven

Country Audit. Retrieved from www.seameo.innotech.org . Jan. 26, 2019

Tangal (2018). Teachers’ Competencies and students’ academic performance in

MAPEH 10 in selected schools in the Province of Oriental Mindoro: Basis for

a training Plan. Unpublished master’s thesis. Eulogio Rodriguez Institute of

Science and Technology.

Teasley, M., Baffour, T., & Tyson, E. (2005). Perceptions of cultural competence

among urban school social workers: Does experience make a difference?

Retrieved from www.researchgate.net/publication September 28, 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 69

Theiler J. (2016). A comparative study: Ericsons’ Theory of expertise and Gardners

theory of multiple intelligences, University of Nebraska. Retrieved from

www.dwb4.unl.edu

Tumapon T. (2016). Coping with complexity in the classroom: On cultural

diversity.Manila Times. Retrieved from https://www.manilatimes.net/coping-

complexity classroom-cultural-diversity/299538/

United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (2015). Philippine

education for all 2015: Implementation and challenges. Retrieved from

www.planipolis.iiep.unesco.org. Jan. 26, 2019

Wilson, P. (2014). The relationship between the teachers’ levels of cultural

competence and the nomination/referral process for gifted identification of

culturally and linguistically diverse students. Virginia Commonwealth

University. Retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org. September 28,

2019

Wilson, S. McChesney, J. and Brown, L. (2017). Cultural Competencies and

Planning for Teaching Mathematics: Preservice Teachers Responding to

Expectations, Opportunities, and Resources. Journal of Urban Mathematics

Education July 2017, 10 (1) , pp. 95–112. Retrieved from www.eric.ed.gov

Jan. 26, 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890


ASSESSMENT ON THE CULTURAL COMPETENCIES 70

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3687890

You might also like