Professional Documents
Culture Documents
February 1998
Compressor Manual
First Edition December 1988
First Revision March 1991
Second Revision December 1992
Second Edition December 1996
Restricted Material
Technical Memorandum
The information in this Manual has been jointly developed by Chevron Corporation and its Operating
Companies. The Manual has been written to assist Chevron personnel in their work; as such, it may be
interpreted and used as seen fit by operating management.
Copyright 1988, 1991, 1992, 1996 CHEVRON CORPORATION. All rights reserved. This document
contains proprietary information for use by Chevron Corporation, its subsidiaries, and affiliates. All other
uses require written permission.
Section Date
Volume I:
Section 50 December 1996
Section 100 December 1996
Section 200 December 1996
Section 300 December 1996
Section 400 December 1988
Section 500 December 1988
Section 600 December 1988
Section 700 December 1988
Section 800 December 1988
References December 1988
Appendix A March 1991
Appendix B December 1988
Appendix C December 1996
Appendix D March 1991
Appendix E December 1988
Appendix F December 1988
Appendix G December 1988
Appendix H December 1988
Appendix I December 1988
Appendix J December 1988
Appendix K December 1988
Appendix L December 1988
Volume I: (continued)
Appendix M December 1988
Appendix N December 1988
Appendix O March 1991
Appendix P February 1998
Volume II:
Section 2000 December 1996
Section 2100 December 1988
List of Standard Drawings and Forms See the list in the Standard Drawings
and Forms sectionof this manual.
Current revision dates are shown for
Forms. Current Revision numbers are
shown for Standard Drawings.
Safety Instruction Sheets December 1988
Information about Specification Disks December 1996
Previous
Owner: Title:
Last First M.I.
Current
Owner: Title:
Last First M.I.
Company: Dept/Div:
Name
Address
Phone
References
Appendices
Appendix A Reciprocating Compressor Performance Program
Appendix B Sample Problem
Appendix C Equation List and Nomenclature
Appendix D Conversion Factors
Appendix E Physical Factors
Appendix F Generalized Compressibility Charts
Appendix G Compressibility Charts
Appendix H Thermodynamic Property Charts
Appendix I Miscellaneous Charts
Appendix J Reciprocating Compressor Lubrication
Appendix K Distance Piece/Packer Venting For H2S
Appendix L Reliability and Availability Analysis
Appendix M Equipment Vendors
Appendix N Maintenance Checklists
Appendix O Centrifugal Compressor Performance Program
Appendix P Separator Vessel and Filter Design Guide
Abstract
The purpose of this section is to define how this manual is organized in order to
help the reader quickly find appropriate information. A Quick-Reference Guide
(Figure 50-1) is provided to highlight areas of the manual pertaining to most jobs.
Organization
The Compressor Manual is part of a four-volume set on machinery:
• Pumps
• Compressors
• Drivers
• General Machinery and Support Systems
These manuals are interrelated; therefore, a list of cross references has been devel-
oped to assist you in finding related subject matter. (Please refer to the Cross-Refer-
ence Chart, Figure 50-2.)
Each machinery manual is organized using different-colored tabs to accommodate
each user in finding the appropriate level of information quickly. In summary:
• White tabs identify general-purpose topics.
• Blue tabs are Engineering Guidelines.
• Gray tabs are used for Specifications, Data Sheets, Data Sheets Guides, and
related industry standards (API).
• A Red tab is included for local documents.
Part II—Specifications
This part of the manual contains: 1) general instructions for specifying and
purchasing compressors; 2) model specifications, data sheets, and data-sheet
instructions that can be copied or modified to local preferences; 3) industry stan-
dards (API) for commonly-employed compressors; 4) computer sizing disk.
Abstract
This section is an overview of dynamic (centrifugal and axial) and positive displace-
ment compressors and an overview which directs readers to more detailed informa-
tion on specific categories found in subsequent sections of the manual.
This section also provides background information on the principles of compres-
sion, including a discussion of thermodynamics. It is not essential that you read this
entire section, but you may wish to use it as reference material when selecting a
compressor.
To confirm your initial selection of a new compressor, you may find that unique site
requirements or economic factors pose serious problems for the original choice of
machine. Accordingly, it may be necessary to evaluate two or more categories (or a
combination of categories) of machines for a given application.
Contents Page
110 Introduction
111 Background
Most work involving compressors falls into one of three categories:
1. Purchasing and installing new compressors.
2. Troubleshooting problems during startup or while in service.
3. Modifying compressors to resolve problems or to accommodate operational or
service changes (different flow, gas pressures, etc.).
The overall goal in all three cases is the same: To maximize profits while providing
safe, reliable equipment which satisfies operating requirements and local environ-
mental constraints. Profitability is a long-term goal involving the following factors:
1. Meeting safety and environmental needs (including noise restrictions)
2. Initial cost
3. Installation and commissioning expense
4. Energy consumption (this is a major expense on compressors)
5. Reliability
6. Maintaining production (this is often the overwhelming economic factor)
7. Operability (troublesome equipment wastes resources that can be spent on prof-
itable work)
8. Starting up on time, the first time, in critical services
9. Maintenance expense
10. Operating flexibility
Although each of these factors must be considered when making decisions, there is
some degree of conflict between them. For example, buying an inexpensive unit
may keep initial costs down but it may also be less reliable and require frequent
maintenance. On the other hand, buying the ultimately reliable compressor may be
prohibitively expensive in up-front costs and unnecessary to ensure acceptable
performance.
Use judgment when deciding which factors are the most important. It is especially
important to communicate with the people responsible for operating and main-
taining the unit. Their input on the relative priority of the above factors is invalu-
able. In the end, however, engineering judgment will always be necessary.
Sub-section 154 contains additional information which illustrates how these factors
impact the overall cost.
The range of application of compressors varies widely, with inlet pressures from
vacuum to several thousand pounds per square inch (psi) and discharge pressures
from less than atmospheric to well beyond 15,000 psi. The gases handled vary from
hydrogen, with a molecular weight of 2, to refrigerants and unusual gases having
molecular weights in the low hundreds. The sizes, types, and construction of
compressors vary greatly to accommodate this diversity of service.
• Rotary
– Screw
– Sliding Vane
– Liquid Ring
– Roots (Straight Lobe) Blower
A reciprocating positive displacement machine is shown in Figure 100-3. Two
rotary positive displacement machines are shown in Figures 100-4 and 100-5.
Fig. 100-2 Cut-away of a Six-stage Vertically-split Fig. 100-3 Balanced-Opposed Horizontal Motor-
Centrifugal Compressor Driven, Four-Cylinder Reciprocating
Compressor, Plan View (Courtesy of
Dresser Rand)
Refer to Sections 200 and 300 for more detailed discussions on centrifugal and
reciprocating compressors.
131 Introduction
The principles of compression are based on thermodynamics. Compressing gases
involves complications that pumping liquids does not. The compressible nature of
gases requires us to account for their more complex behavior through the applica-
tion of thermodynamic principles.
Fig. 100-4 Cut-Away of a Two-Lobe Rotary Positive Fig. 100-5 Helical Lobe Rotary Positive Displacement
Displacement Compressor (Courtesy of Compressor (Courtesy of Howell Training
Roots Div., Dresser Industries) Group)
the size of the driver and the mechanical design of the compressor. Both are
critical design factors in new applications and rerates.
4. The thermodynamic properties of a mixture of gases can be estimated, based
on the properties of the individual components. Most compression applications
involve mixtures.
5. In gases with water vapor, the water content also needs to be accounted for.
The following sub-sections review fundamental concepts which apply to all
compressors.
pV = WRT
(Eq. 100-1)
where:
p = absolute pressure in pounds per square foot
V = volume in cubic feet
W = weight in pounds
R = Ro/M = constant for specific gas
Ro = universal gas constant = 1545.3 (ft.-lb./lb mol °R)
T = absolute temperature in degrees Rankine (°R)
M = molecular weight
For a continuous flow process, Equation 100-1 is modified as follows
PQ = 10.73wT
----------------------
M
(Eq. 100-2)
where:
Q = actual volumetric flow rate in cubic feet per minute (ACFM)
w = weight flow, pounds per minute and,
P is now in psia
To correct for deviations from a “perfect” gas, a compressibility factor, Z, is added
to Equation 100-2. Z is an empirical factor to correct the equation for actual, real
gases which deviate from “perfect.”
10.73wTZ
PQ = --------------------------
M
(Eq. 100-3)
For example:
At standard conditions (14.7 psia, 60°F) the factor (Z) of most gases is generally
assumed to be 1.0. However, some gases deviate appreciably even at standard condi-
tions. For example, normal butane has a Zo value of 0.975 (Zo denotes the factor at
standard conditions).
Values for Z are available in charts for the gas being compressed. If a chart is not
available, or if the gas is a mixture, generalized compressibility charts may be
used. To use these charts, it is necessary to compute the so-called reduced pressure
and temperature as follows[v]
P
P r = -----
Pc
(Eq. 100-4)
where:
T
T r = ------
Tc
(Eq. 100-5)
Pr = Reduced pressure
P = Actual absolute pressure, psia
Pc = Critical pressure of the gas, psia
Tr = Reduced temperature
T = Actual absolute temperature, °R
Tc = Critical temperature of the gas, °R
Appendices F and G contain a collection of compressibility curves for specific
gases and generalized charts. The critical temperature and pressure of a gas mixture
are explained in the next sub-section.
The compressibility of some pure gases, notably steam and ammonia, cannot
be accurately predicted using the generalized charts. However, steam tables and
an individual chart for pure ammonia are available. When the water vapor or
ammonia content of a mixture is small (5% or less), the generalized charts may be
used for the mixture with relatively good accuracy.
For gas mixtures containing hydrogen or helium, effective values of critical pres-
sure and temperature for helium and hydrogen must be used to derive acceptable
accuracy from the generalized charts. These effective values are included in
Appendix F.
N1 N2 N3
X 1 = -------- , X 2 = -------- , X 3 = -------- , etc.
Nm Nm Nm
(Eq. 100-6)
where:
Nm = Total moles in a mixture
N1, etc. = Number of moles of each individual component
A “mole” is actually a number of molecules (about 6 x 1023 ). A “mole fraction” is
the ratio of molecules of one component in a mixture. For example, if the mole frac-
tion of methane in natural gas is 0.90, this means that 90% of the molecules are
methane. Since volume fractions are equivalent to mole fractions, the mixture
is also 90% (by volume) methane.
The mixture fractions could also be calculated on a mass or weight basis. The mole
(volume) basis is used in compressor calculations because it is a simpler, less
confusing method.
The molal specific heat is used to determine the k value (ratio of specific heats) as
follows. The k value is often called the adiabatic exponent, and is a value used in
the calculation of horsepower, adiabatic head, and adiabatic discharge temperature.
(Refer to Isentropic [Adiabatic] Compression.) The k value is:
Cp MC p ( m ) MC p ( m )
k = ------ = ----------------------------------- = ---------------------------------------
Cv Ro MC p ( m ) – 1.986
MC p ( m ) – -------- -
778
(Eq. 100-7)
where:
MCp(m) = Molal specific heat (heat capacity) of mixture at constant pressure
778 = Conversion factor, ft-lb/BTU
Cp = Specific heat at constant pressure
Cv = Specific heat at constant volume
Ro = See Equation 100-1 for R o definition
MCp(m) should be taken at the desired temperature (usually the average of suction
and discharge temperature). This aspect will be covered in Isentropic (Adiabatic)
Compression. Note that the k value of the mixture must be determined by first
determining the molal heat capacity of the mixture (see Figure 100-6). It is a
common mistake to multiply the k values of the individual gas components by their
respective mole fractions to determine the k value of the mixture.
Specific Gravity
The specific gravity of the gas mixture is determined by dividing the molecular
weight of the mixture by that of air.
Mm
S.G. = -------------
28.96
(Eq. 100-8)
Humidity
For air compressors it is usually necessary to account for water vapor content. It is
important to know the moisture content accurately when a process requires a defi-
nite quantity of dry air. Furthermore, the moisture in the inlet air affects the power
requirement, and water drop-out in intercoolers and aftercoolers.
Note that water-vapor content must also be accounted for as a component in
process streams, if present. In those cases, the content is usually available from
process engineering, gas and chemical engineering, etc.
The following information discusses how to account for water content in air.
Relative humidity, in percent, may be determined from the following relationship:
Pv
% R.H. = --------- ( 100 )
P sat
(Eq. 100-9)
where:
Pv = Partial pressure of actual water vapor content
Psat = Partial pressure of water vapor when air is fully saturated at the
temperature of interest (can be found in steam tables)
Specific Humidity is the ratio of the weight of the water vapor content to the
weight of dry air at the existing conditions of pressure and temperature, and is deter-
mined as follows:
Wv 18 P v
S.H. = ---------- = ------------- ---------------
W da 28.96 P – P v
Pv
= 0.622 ---------------
P – Pv
(Eq. 100-10)
where:
Wv = Weight of water vapor
Wda = Weight of dry air
P = Total pressure of the gas mixture (usually atmospheric), in abso-
lute
Relative and specific humidity may be obtained from a psychrometric chart when
the wet bulb and dry bulb temperatures are known. However, most psychrometric
charts are based on the International Standard sea-level pressure of 14.7 psia, and
are, therefore, accurate only for that barometric pressure.
For example, if a standard (14.7 psia) psychrometric chart were used for conditions
of 5000 feet elevation (12.23 psia), 80°F dry bulb, and 60°F wet bulb, the indicated
specific humidity would be low by about 25%, and the relative humidity low by
10%.
If the altitude is more than 200 or 300 feet above sea level, the following equation
should be used instead of a psychrometric chart:
P – P v ( wb )
- ( t – t wb )
P v = P v ( wb ) – ------------------------------------
2830 – 1.44t wb
(Eq. 100-11)
where:
Pv(wb) = Vapor pressure in psia corresponding to wet bulb temperature
(from steam tables)
t = Dry bulb temperature, °F
twb = Wet bulb temperature, °F
Knowing Pv, the relative and specific humidities can be calculated with
Equations 100-9 and 100-10. The volumetric or mole percent of the water vapor
can be calculated from Equation 100-6 as follows:
Pv
mol % H 2 O = ------ ( 100 )
P
(Eq. 100-12)
The mole percent of dry air is then 100 minus the mole percent of the water vapor.
The other properties of the mixture of air and water vapor (molecular weight, MCp,
etc.) may then be calculated.
• Moles/Hour (MPH)
• SCFM
• ACFM
• Weight Flow
MMSCFD
MMSCFD denotes millions of standard cubic feet per day, where “standard”
means 14.7 psia and 60°F. This notation is often used in gas plant, gas transmission,
and refinery applications.
Moles/Hour (MPH)
Process engineers often use MPH in material balance computations. (A “mole” is a
fixed quantity of molecules. This concept greatly simplifies process calculations.) A
mole of any gas occupies approximately 379.4 cubic feet at standard conditions
(14.7 psia, 60°F), and it has a weight in pounds equal to the molecular weight of the
gas. For example, a mole of methane (CH4) would have a volume of 379.4 cubic
feet at standard conditions, and that volume would weigh 16.04 pounds. Knowing
the moles per hour, the MMSCFD may be determined from:
MPH ( 379.4 ) ( 24 )-
MMSCFD = ------------------------------------------
10 6
(Eq. 100-13)
SCFM
SCFM denotes standard cubic feet per minute, and is frequently used in compres-
sion work.
ACFM
Actual cubic feet per minute (ACFM) at the inlet, often called Q, is related to the
physical size of the compressor. Several design parameters are based on Q. ACFM
at inlet is also abbreviated ICFM. ACFM at the compressor discharge is sometimes
of interest, and in this manual it will be abbreviated DCFM (discharge cubic feet
per minute).
However, note that ICFM is the more appropriate term to use when referring to
inlet conditions. In many cases, ACFM is often used interchangeably with ICFM. If
there is any doubt, be sure to get clarification.
SCFM may be converted to ACFM, or Q, by:
Q 1 = ACFM
14.7 T 1 Z 1
= ( SCFM ) ---------
P - --------
520 Z 0
- ------
1
(Eq. 100-14)
where:
P1, T1, Z1 = Absolute pressure (psia), absolute temperature (°R), and
compressibility at the condition of interest.
Zo = Compressibility at standard conditions.
Refer to the nomograph in Appendix D for quick conversions between ICFM and
SCFM.
Weight Flow
Weight flow, w, may be calculated from any conditions of interest using the
following equation (derived from Equation 100-3):
P1 Q 1 M
w = --------------------------
10.73T 1 Z 1
(Eq. 100-15)
Refer to the nomograph in Appendix D for quick conversions between weight flow
and inlet cubic feet per minute.
Weight flow can also be determined from SCFM:
square centimeter or Newtons per square meter are used. (Conversion tables are
included in Appendix D.)
The matter of standard conditions is further confused by the ISO conditions for
base-rating a combustion gas turbine. These conditions are 760 mm Hg Absolute,
15°C, and 60% relative humidity. The rated flow through the compressor on the
front end of a gas turbine is universally based on ISO conditions.
Fig. 100-7 Theoretical Compression Paths on P-V Diagram for Different Processes
In practice, the isentropic and polytropic methods of analysis are both usable for
designing and predicting the performance of compressors.
It turns out that the isentropic (adiabatic) method is commonly applied to posi-
tive displacement compressors, because these machines are often equipped
with a cooling system that cools the casing or cylinder during compression,
making the actual temperature rise approach that of the theoretical adiabatic
process.
The polytropic process is typically applied to dynamic compressors in which
there is no cooling during the compression that takes place in any individual
stage. (There may be cooling between each stage or series of stages, but not within
a given stage.)
The positive displacement and centrifugal categories of compressors are covered in
further detail in Sections 200 and 300 of this manual.
P1 V1 = P2 V2 = Constant
(Eq. 100-17)
“Head” is a term often used for the work input to the compression process. The
units of head are foot-pounds (force) divided by pounds (mass). In general practice,
the unit of head is usually taken as “feet.” The theoretical head for an isothermal
process is:
Hisot = RT1 ln r
(Eq. 100-18)
where:
P
r = -----2- = pressure ratio
P1
Equation 100-18 may be used to evaluate other compression processes with various
amounts of cooling.
P1V1k = P2V2k = C
(Eq. 100-19)
where:
C = constant
k
= ratio of specific heats (see Sub-section 133)
Z1 + Z2
k-----------
–1
- ------------------
-
r k – 1 2
H ad = RT 1 --------------------------
k–1
------------
k
(Eq. 100-20)
where:
Had = adiabatic head, ft.
k–1
------------
x = r k –1
(Eq. 100-21)
where:
x = a factor created for convenience
T2(theo) = T1 (x + 1)
(Eq. 100-22)
where:
T2(theo) = adiabatic discharge temperature (theoretical absolute discharge
temperature assuming 100% adiabatic efficiency)
T 2 = T 1 1 + --------
x
η ad
(Eq. 100-23)
where:
ηad = adiabatic efficiency
T2 = Actual discharge temperature, °R
wH ad
Ghp = --------------------------
33 ,000η ad
(Eq. 100-24)
where:
Ghp = gas horsepower
Notice that Equation 100-20 has been corrected by an average compressibility,
(Z1 + Z2) / 2. Averaging is a fairly accurate approximation of the correction
required.
Because of the non-ideal (non-perfect) behavior of many gases, the k exponent does
not remain constant during compression. For air, diatomic gases, and inert gases,
the change in k is small when the pressures are moderate. However, for most hydro-
carbon gases, the variance of k during compression is substantial. The usual correc-
tion is to calculate k using MCp (see Equation 100-7) at the average of the
compressor (or stage) suction and discharge temperature. MCp values at 14.7 psia
are given in the Appendix of this manual.
Using the MCp at atmospheric pressure and average compression temperature for
compressor head and power calculations is sufficiently accurate for most applica-
tions. However, for very high pressures or other unusual conditions, further correc-
tions are necessary. Such corrections will be covered under Polytropic
Compression.
Adiabatic Efficiency
Since the change in entropy is not zero in an actual adiabatic compression process,
an adiabatic efficiency (ηad) is used in Equation 100-23 and 100-24. In order to
calculate MCp at average compression temperature, it is necessary to estimate the
adiabatic efficiency to arrive at a discharge temperature per Equation 100-23. If the
estimate is inaccurate, a second iteration may be required.
Thermodynamic Diagrams
Thermodynamic-property diagrams account directly for deviations of a real gas
from ideal relationships. These diagrams are a plot of gas properties, commonly
including: enthalpy, entropy, pressure, and temperature. Occasionally, a special
diagram is developed for a widely used gas mixture such as a refrigerant. However,
note that few charts are available for mixtures, and this method is therefore not
commonly used for hydrocarbon mixtures.
When a diagram is used to predict changes of state during compression, compress-
ibility and variance of k are not needed because these variables are already factored
into the diagrams. In general, then, this method is more accurate than
Equation 100-20, and when charts are available, it is certainly more convenient.
Diagrams are often used in compressor calculations for heavier hydrocarbon gases
such as propane and propylene that tend to deviate considerably. Diagrams for
many pure gases are well established. The Appendix includes an assortment of
these diagrams.
The following equations pertain to the use of diagrams for compressor calculations.
Note that for an isentropic process, there is no change in entropy, S.
S2(theo) - S1 = 0
(Eq. 100-25)
where:
S2(theo) = S1 = entropy at suction conditions
∆h(theo)= h2(theo) - h1
(Eq. 100-26)
where:
h1 = enthalpy at suction conditions, Btu/lb
h2(theo) = theoretical enthalpy at discharge pressure and S1, Btu/1b
∆h ( theo )
h 2 = -------------------- + h 1
η ad
(Eq. 100-27)
where:
h2 = actual enthalpy at discharge pressure and temperature, Btu/lb
ηad = adiabatic efficiency
Note that the actual discharge temperature T2 may now be found on the thermody-
namic diagram at the point corresponding to h2 and P2.
Polytropic Relationships
The polytropic compression process is described mathematically as follows.
n n
P1 V1 = P2 V 2 = C
(Eq. 100-29)
where:
n = polytropic exponent
k–1
η p = ------------
k
------------
n–1
------------
n
(Eq. 100-30)
where:
ηp = polytropic efficiency
n–1
H poly = RT 1 r n – 1 Z + Z
------------
1 2
-------------------------- -------------------
n–1 2
------------
n
(Eq. 100-31)
where:
Hpoly = polytropic head, ft.
n–1
------------
T 2 = T1 r n
(Eq. 100-32)
wH poly
Ghp = ----------------------
-
33 ,000η p
(Eq. 100-33)
In Equation 100-30, k is ordinarily taken at the average compression temperature
by most compressor manufacturers. Therefore, when estimating overall flange-to-
flange performance, use k at average flange-to-flange temperature to yield results
very close to those of stage-by-stage calculations. In the case of single-stage
machines, the difference between k at inlet temperature and average temperature is
generally very small. Accordingly, in this manual, k at average compression temper-
ature will be used.
ηp
H poly = H ad --------
η ad
(Eq. 100-34)
The relationship between polytropic and adiabatic efficiencies is:
k–1
------------
r k –1
η ad = ----------------------
k-----------
– 1
-
kη p
r –1
(Eq. 100-35)
This relationship is graphically represented by Figure 100-8.
cating, centrifugal, etc.), in cases where the category has not been determined.
These equations can be used to estimate energy requirements and compression
temperatures.
4. Rigorous, detailed analyses and calculations to determine compression
energy, power required, gas temperatures, pressure rise, and mechanical
stresses. These analyses are done by equipment vendors and are beyond the
scope of this manual.
profile in detail with the operating, or project representative to assure that all factors
have been considered. If a process flow diagram is unavailable, make a sketch of
the flow circuit. If you question the pressure drop allowances, review the calcula-
tions with the operating, or project representative. Refer to the Fluid Flow Manual
for information on pressure drop calculations.
It is extremely important that you accurately determine the suction pressure. For
example, if a four-stage reciprocating compressor is sized for compression from 20
to 4400 psia, and the actual suction pressure turns out to be 25 psia, the actual
weight flow will be 25% higher, and the horsepower required 19% higher than
predicted.
Step 1.
Convert flow rate to ICFM using Equation 100-3 (also see Equations 100-32,
100-33 and 100-34).
Step 2.
Calculate overall pressure ratio, roa = final discharge pressure/suction pressure
(absolute pressures must be used).
Step 3.
Calculate discharge temperature, T2, using Equation 100-32 and an adiabatic effi-
ciency, ηad,of 0.75 for all types of machines except reciprocating. Use ηad = 1.0 for
reciprocating compressors. (Note that absolute temperatures in Rankine must be
used.)
The 0.75 efficiency is an arbitrary value that is convenient for making an initial
rough estimate. An ηad of 1.0 for reciprocating is suitable for most applications as
this machine tends to achieve nearly perfect adiabatic temperature rise when a
coolant is circulated through the cylinder jacket. (However, do not use ηad = 1.0 for
power calculations. See Step 10.)
Step 4.
If the discharge temperature is less than 300°F the application can most likely be
achieved in one step of compression, without intercooling, with a centrifugal or
rotary compressor. For reciprocating machines, the discharge temperature for a
single cylinder should be less than 300°F.
Selection Notes:
• Generally used for air service - high volume and relatively low pressure. Typical pressure ratios for air service
are 2.5 to 7. High pressure ratio is about 14.
• Is more efficient than centrifugal.
• Is usually physically smaller and lighter in weight than centrifugal for same duty.
• Speed is somewhat higher than that of centrifugal for same duty.
• Two casings can be put in tandem arrangement, but it is seldom done.
• Some designs have provisions for intermediate nozzles for intercooling or sidestreams, but this feature is not
often employed.
• Very narrow stable operating range at constant speed - about 12%.
• Some designs utilize one or more centrifugal impellers on the high-pressure end of the rotor. This feature
greatly improves stable operating range.
• Can be fitted with variable stator vanes on first through fifth (and higher) stages to widen performance map.
Machines so fitted are often operated at constant speed.
• Relatively quiet operation.
• Typical applications: Large air compressors, such as FCC or coker air blowers. Front-end air compressor for
combustion gas turbines (not specified separately)
Step 5.
If Step 4 indicates that intercooling is not necessary, refer to Figure 100-11 and
select the type of compressor. Then proceed to Step 10.
Step 6.
If the temperatures cited in Step 4 are exceeded, more than one step of compression
will probably be required (note that the word “step” is used to denote a section of
the compression duty to avoid confusion with compression “stages.”) Each row of
blades in an axial machine or each impeller in a centrifugal compressor is called a
“stage.” Whereas each cylinder of a reciprocating machine is usually called a
stage; and each casing of two rotary compressors in tandem is called a stage. The
number of steps or sections can be estimated by assuming an equal pressure ratio
for each step. Use 2% allowance for pressure drop between the steps. By trial-and-
error method, use the following equation and Equation 100-12 to determine the
number of steps keeping the discharge temperature at 300°F or less:
1
---
r oa n
r = ------------------------
-
( 0.98 ) n – 1
(Eq. 100-36)
where:
r = pressure ratio of each step
roa = overall pressure ratio
n = number of steps ; 2,3,4..
n - 1 = number of intercoolers
Step 7.
Calculate suction and discharge pressure for each step of compression using the r
determined in Step 6 and taking a 2% pressure drop between each step.
Step 8.
Calculate ICFM for each compression step. The suction temperature for the first
step should be known. If suction temperature for succeeding steps is unknown, use
15°F plus the temperature of available cooling water; or if cooling with air coolers
is desired, use 25°F plus the design maximum ambient temperature. If these values
are not yet known, use 100°F as suction temperature of succeeding steps.
Step 9.
Refer to Figure 100-11 and select the compressor category that will satisfy the
ICFM and discharge pressure for all compression stages. Generally, it is desirable
that one type of compressor will handle all steps. Refer the initial selection back to
the process designer (if available) to insure the selection is compatible with the
process requirements. Occasionally, it may be necessary to use a combination of
types such as axial for the low-pressure (LP) step and a centrifugal for the high-
pressure (HP) step. Another example would be a centrifugal and a reciprocating for
LP and HP steps, respectively.
Step 10.
Calculate weight flow using Equation 100-15 and assume that this value is constant
for all compression steps. Calculate adiabatic head and Ghp for each step using
Equation 100-20 and 100-24. For the first estimate, it is convenient to use adiabatic
relationships for all types of compressors to minimize computations. Also,
compressibilities can be neglected in most cases unless the gas deviates widely.
Add the Ghp's to find the total Ghp for the compression duty.
Step 11.
Review Figure 100-12 through 100-16 which may help resolve the choice of the
compressor when the application falls into an overlapped area.
Step 12.
At this point, some thought should be given to reliability and availability of the
compression system. (See Appendix L for more information.) If the service is
deemed to be critical, the following number of machines are typically used:
Axial and Centrifugal: One 100% unit
Reciprocating: Three 50% or two 100% units
Rotary: Same as reciprocating (Rotary are seldom
used in critical service.)
For a general purpose service, one 100% unit is the usual choice. In some instances,
the capacity may vary widely on a seasonal basis, or it may build up over a period
of years. In such cases, it may be economical to use more smaller sized units.
Step 13.
Proceed to the section of the manual corresponding to the selection made in the
above steps (Sections 200 or 300). Review this information to verify and refine the
selection.
Step 14.
If the type of driver is known, make sure that it is compatible with the size and
rating of the type of compressor selected. If the type of driver is unknown, use
Sub-section 170 preliminarily and then refer to the Driver Manual. Due to limita-
tions of the driver or size of the compressor train, it may be necessary to use two or
more equally sized trains for the required compression capacity. This step should be
considered along with Step 12.
Step 15.
When the application involves the introduction of sidestreams (e.g., refrigeration
compressor), it is necessary to calculate the properties of the mixture of the two gas
streams at the entrance of the next section or stage of compression.
Step 16.
Contact at least two vendors for each type of compressor selected. Have each
vendor prepare preliminary selections, and submit order-of-magnitude prices and
estimated performance information. If it becomes evident that a small process
design change might save a considerable amount of money, the change should be
referred to the process designer. In some cases the process design can be conserva-
tive and a slight modification may allow a substantial savings.
Examples
The usual approach is to calculate the present value and accumulate them on an
annual basis for the desired number of years. Figure 100-17 shows the results of an
economic study for two different categories of air compressors for 500 ACFM.
In Figure 100-17 observe that the installed cost of this reciprocating compressor is
50% higher than that of the screw machine, but the accumulated costs are equal
when considering a period longer than 2-1/2 years. (Note also that using unit costs
such as $/HP or $/ICFM in terms of installed costs would be very misleading.) Effi-
ciency directly affects power costs which is the dominant component of the
overall accumulated expenses.
Figure 100-18 shows the total expenses for two life-cycle periods for three catego-
ries of compressors in a large air compression duty. In this comparison, the recipro-
cating and centrifugal machines are even in costs for a five-year cycle, despite the
fact that the installed cost of the reciprocating machine is twice that of the others.
But when considering the 15-year case, efficiency takes over, making the recipro-
cating compressor the least costly.
Figure 100-17 and 100-18 do not show any particular unit costs or trends for
air compressors or compressors for other gases. Their only purpose is to demon-
strate the need for an economic analysis. For critical services, the requirements for
reliability or safety may overrule the choice determined by the other economic
factors, such as purchase price, energy, etc.
Quite often, economic factors, or the methods for determining them, will have
already been established by the sponsors of a given project. If so, the economic
study will be simplified. In some cases, the project may rule that a study is not
required. At any rate, the economics of the proposed installation should be
reviewed with the operating, or project representative.
Fig. 100-17 Life Cycle Costs for Light-duty Reciprocating and Rotary Screw Compressors for a 500 ICFM (Nominal)
125 psig Air Compressor. Example Only.
This graph displays the total compressor costs (purchase, installation, energy consumption, and mainte-
nance), when totaled for different assumed project lives. The total costs are displayed in terms of
“present value.” This is the amount that would be needed up front to pay all the costs over the project life,
assuming, the money compounded at the cost of capital (10%), and were spent to pay the respective
costs.
This chart shows that the reciprocating compressor costs more initially, but when you consider the future
power consumption, the screw compressor will actually cost more. This is because the reciprocator is
more efficient, and will consume less power over the years.
Fig. 100-18 Life Cycle for Heavy-duty Reciprocating, Rotary Screw, and Centrifugal Compressors for a 1500 ICFM
(Nominal) 125 psig Air Compressor. Example Only.
Note: This graph depicts two cases of “present value” for assumed project lives of 5 and 15 years.
(Present value is explained in Figure 100-17.)
This chart shows that: 1) installed costs are a minor part of the total compressor expense, even at a very
short project life of 5 years, and 2) the reciprocating compressor becomes more attractive as longer
project lives are assumed. Like Figure 100-17, this is because the higher efficiency of the reciprocator
pays off in power consumption over the operating life of the compressor (despite typically higher mainte-
nance expense).
Fig. 100-20 Typical Plot Dimensions and Weights of Centrifugal Compressor Casings
Dimensions for Horizontally- and Vertically-Split Centrifugal Compressors
Horizontally Split (1)
ICFM Width, ft Length, Ft Weight, lbs
3-stg 8-stg 3-stg 8-stg
20 - 40K 8 7 11 24K 40K
9 - 20K 6 6 9 13K 20K
4 - 9K 4 5 6 7K 10K
0.5 - 4K 4 4 6 6K 9K
(1) and (2)
Vertically Split
Weights @
Casing Rating, Width, ft Length, ft 750 psi 3000 psi 6000 psi
9 - 20K 6 7 29 35 50
4 - 9K 5 6 22 33 41
0.5 - 4K 4 5 18 22 25
(1) Width dimensions shown are across support feet.
(2) Based on 5-stage casing.
Fig. 100-21 Typical Dimensions for Centrifugal Compressors—Horizontally- and Vertically-Split Units
Fig. 100-22 Approximate Plot Areas and Weights of Typical Reciprocating Compressors
Frame Horsepower No. of Cylinders RPM Average Footprint (1) Average Weight (1) and (2)
500 2 900 14′W x 5′L 13500 lbs
1000 2 514 14′W x 9′L 26000 lbs
5000 4 327 22′W x 14-1/2′L 120000 lbs
10,000 6 257 26′W x 20′L 210000 lbs
(1) Does not include driver
(2) Frame plus average size cylinders
160 Packaging
Packaging is a technique used to minimize construction time and labor costs at the
installation site. It consists of placing the compressor, driver, auxiliaries, and
control system on one or more skids (baseplates). Piping, tubing, and wiring are
routed between the various equipment items on each skid, and are then brought to a
minimum number of terminal points on the perimeter of the skid. These terminal
points facilitate connecting the package to the system at the jobsite.
The size and complexity of packaged equipment range from a simple air
compressor package rated at a few hundred horsepower to a large and complicated
package containing a gas compressor driven by a large mechanical drive gas turbine.
When packaging is applied on a large scale to a major project, the concept is known
as modularization or modular construction. This approach has particular applica-
tion to projects in remote areas where the availability of skilled labor is either low
or costly and difficult to implement. Modular construction takes advantage of the
availability of skilled labor at major industrial centers throughout the world. In addi-
tion to potential labor cost reductions, this approach provides the opportunity to
improve the overall project schedule.
Modular construction is used extensively for offshore platforms and onshore facili-
ties such as those on Alaska's North Slope and in jungle and desert locations.
Typical compressor module weights are 25 to 300 tons. One large module for the
North Slope contained a compressor for low-pressure separator gas, a 33,000 HP
gas turbine, gas coolers and scrubbers, and all auxiliaries, piping, and controls. This
module weighed 2600 tons and was 60 ft. x 110 ft. x 100 ft. high.
Module or package size and weight are limited by factory handling capability, trans-
portation constraints, and the capacity of jobsite lifting or moving apparatus.
Console-mounted lube- and seal-oil systems for compressors are good examples of
smaller packages. Figure 100-23 provides some general weights and dimensions
which may be used for early estimates.
Fig. 100-23 Typical Packaged Seal/Lube Oil System Weight and Dimensions
Nominal Oil Flow,
gpm L x W x H, ft Dry Wt, Kips Operating Wt,Kips
25 14 x 8 x 7 8.5 10.0
50 18 x 9 x 8 12.0 15.9
75 19 x 9 x 8 14.0 18.5
100 20 x 10 x 8 16.0 22.0
150 22 x 11 x 8 18.0 27.0
20 24 x 12 x 8 20.0 32.0
300 32 x 12 x 8 35.0 60.0
400 40 x 12 x 8 52.0 92.0
Figures 100-24 and 100-25 list some estimating weights and dimensions for recipro-
cating compressors (with and without coolers) with various drivers. Figure 100-26
shows typical dimensions and weights for integral gas engine driven reciprocating
compressors. Figure 100-27 and 100-28 provide similar information for centrifugal
compressors including turbine drives and enclosures.
Fig. 100-24 Typical Reciprocating Packages with Coolers Weight and Dimensions (900 RPM Separable
Compressors)
Driver HP L x W x H ft Weight Kips MMSCFD
Engine 1200 34 x 13 x 16 100 19.1
Engine 565 35 x 12 x 14 60 2.3
Engine 500 30 x 12 x 14 47 4.7
Engine 450 30 x 18 x 18 55 1.8
Engine 415 30 x 12 x 13 48 5.2
Motor 350 20 x 12 x 14 51 2.0
Fig. 100-25 Typical Reciprocating Packages without Coolers Weights and Dimensions (900 RPM Separable
Compressors)
Driver HP L x W x H ft Weight Kips MMSCFD
Engine 2,600 38 x 12 x 10 106.0 13.2
Engine 1,000 35 x 13 x 12 71.0 9.5
Turbine 2,000 35 x 12 x 12 100.0 17.0
Turbine 1,000 50 x 12 x 12 80.0 11.6
Motor 2,000 22 x 12 x 10 89.5 12.5
Motor 900 26 x 12 x 8 49.0 12.5
Fig. 100-27 Typical Dimensions for Centrifugal Compressors Horizontally-Split Units and Vertically-Split Units
Estimated Maximum Skid Add Skids
Maximum 3 Wheels Add per Wheel Weights for 3 Wheels Weight per Each
ICFM L x W x H, ft. lbs. Inches with Motor Driver Kips Add'l Wheel, Kips
Horizontally-Split Units
2,600 4.2 x 3.5 x 2.0 300 4 10.8 0.2
5,850 5.5 x 4.5 x 3.5 1300 6 13.1 0.2
13,000 6.3 x 5.3 x 4.0 2,000 7 15.0 0.3
23,000 5.5 x 7.0 x 5.8 1,850 7 16.5 0.3
35,000 7.4 x 6.5 x 6.0 4,000 9 18.6 0.4
Vertically-Split Units
5,000 5.0 x 4.3 x 4.6 1,000 4 16.8 0.2
5.0 x 5.0 x 5.0 1,400 4 16.8 0.2
6.0 x 5.2 x 5.8 2,200 5 19.5 0.3
6.4 x 6.0 x 7.0 4,500 6 21.7 0.4
10,000 5.5 x 5.6 x 6.0 2,000 5 18.0 0.3
6.2 x 6.2 x 6.3 3,400 6 20.1 0.4
6.9 x 7.3 x 7.2 6,400 6 21.7 0.4
23,000 6.7 x 6.7 x 6.3 2,500 8 18.6 0.4
8.0 x 7.5 x 7.2 4,200 8 22.4 0.5
Fig. 100-28 Typical Gas Turbine-Driven Centrifugal Compressor Dimensions and Weights
Turbine-Compressor Skid Ancillary Equipment Dimen-
ISO HP Model Speed, rpm Dimensions L x W x H, ft sions L x W x H, ft
4,250 33 0.8
16,000 96 1.6
4,900 74
4,900 81
Fig. 100-31 Common Compressor Drivers and Drive Fig. 100-32 General Area of Application of Induction
Arrangement Options and Synchronous Motors (Courtesy of
Dresser-Rand)
Electrical motors
1. Figure 100-32 shows the general areas of application for induction and
synchronous motors in terms of horsepower and speed.
2. Induction motors have a lagging power factor and a high starting current which
may present difficulties for some electrical systems.
3. Synchronous motors have leading power factor which is often an advantage for
the electrical system. Brushless excitation is usually employed.
4. Motor drivers should not be used for applications requiring frequent starts.
Typical allowable starts vary from four per hour for a 100 HP motor to two per
day for a 1000 HP motor.
5. Designs are available for higher than normal starting torques, but these are
accompanied by higher inrush or starting currents.
6. Refer to the Driver Manual regarding starting, breakdown, pull-in, and pull-out
torques which must be considered in compressor applications.
7. Type of enclosures, atmospheric conditions, insulation, service factors, and
hazardous area classification are all important application factors. Refer to the
Driver Manual for detailed information. It is usually unnecessary to consider
these factors in depth in the initial driver selection.
8. Two-pole motors in the 500 to 10,000 HP range have had some serious
vibration problems, and are not recommended. Consult a Company
specialist if a two-pole motor in this range is being considered.
Steam Turbines
1. Steam turbines are excellent drivers for centrifugal compressors because the
turbine design can usually be tailored to match the compressor's speed. Steam
turbines are also well suited to the higher speed rotary compressor. Steam
turbines have occasionally been used to drive reciprocating compressors with
ratings to 9000 HP. A double reduction gearbox is required for such applica-
tions.
2. There are two main classes - condensing and non-condensing. Non-condensing
turbines are also known as backpressure or topping turbines. Non-condensing
turbines generally need a steam pressure ratio (absolute inlet pressure divided
by exhaust pressure) of at least two. Some condensing machines have steam
extraction or admission sidestreams. Again, the pressure ratio should be at least
two for inlet and sidestream pressures.
3. There are two types of blading - impulse and reaction. Impulse-type is some-
what less efficient, but is generally favored for mechanical drivers in the
7. The steam rate, SR, in pounds per horsepower-hour (lb/HP-hr) may be esti-
mated by:
2545
SR = --------------------------------
( h1 – h2 ) ( ηi )
(Eq. 100-37)
where:
h1 = turbine inlet enthalpy of steam, Btu/lb
h2 = theoretical enthalpy at turbine exhaust at same entropy as at inlet
steam condition.
ηi = turbine isentropic efficiency
8. Two turbine casings are sometimes driven in tandem to achieve the number of
stages, power, and speed required by the driven equipment.
power turbine is “free”, i.e., there is no mechanical connection between the gas
generator and the power turbine. It should be noted that the gas generator
section can be a modified aircraft jet engine. Such machines are known as aero-
derivative gas turbines. Some aircraft engines have twin spools, so that a gas
turbine using such an engine would technically have three shafts. However,
such machines are usually referred to generically as “two-shaft.”
Because of the light weight nature of the gas generator in the aero-derivative
turbine, the machine speed can be increased very rapidly from self-sustaining
speed (typically 25-30% of rated speed). The acceleration rates from this level
to operating speed of the power turbine can be in the range of 10-30 seconds if
desired. On the other hand, a heavy-duty turbine may require 10-20 minutes of
warm-up time for the same speed change.
2. The power turbine is often directly coupled to a centrifugal or axial
compressor. The compressor design can usually be tuned to match the gas
turbine's speed. Also, the speed of the two-shaft turbine can be adjusted
slightly for the purpose of matching with very little penalty in power capability
and efficiency. In cases where the speed difference is too large, a gearbox is
used.
3. Occasionally, combustion gas turbines have been used to drive reciprocating
compressors. This arrangement requires a double reduction gearbox to accom-
modate the speed differences.
4. Refer to the Driver Manual for power output ratings, fuel consumption rates,
and environmental considerations for gas turbines. Gas turbines can be used in
combined cycle schemes to improve overall thermal efficiency of the system.
Also refer to the Driver Manual for information on combined cycles utilizing
gas turbine drives.
Oscillatory Torque
The torque of a reciprocating compressor oscillates significantly during one revolu-
tion of the crankshaft. This condition is usually represented by a torque effort
diagram (see Figure 100-35). The shape of the torque oscillation curve is a func-
tion of the number of degrees between each crankshaft throw, the number of
throws, and the loading of the compressor cylinders. The amplitude of the torque
wave tends to increase as capacity is reduced by cylinder unloading. If the driver is
an induction or synchronous motor, the torque oscillations could cause harmful
current pulsations in the electrical system. Figure 100-36 shows the variation in
current for a typical motor-driven reciprocating compressor. The remedy for exces-
sive oscillations is to provide sufficient rotating inertia by adding a flywheel or
increasing the moment of inertia of the motor rotor. Limits for current pulsation are
covered in API 618 .
Rotary compressors also cause a pulsating torque although the frequency is higher
and the amplitude is lower than the corresponding values for reciprocating
machinery.
Fig. 100-37 Rotor Response Plot (Courtesy of the American Petroleum Institute)
The joining of the compressor and driver shafts can have a significant effect on the
overall critical response of the coupled-up system. A critical speed analysis is
conducted by the manufacturer(s), and is sometimes performed in parallel by an
outside consultant. Although this analysis can be highly complex, it is manageable
with current technology, and the results are reasonably reliable.
Gearboxes
When a gearbox is employed in a compressor train, it can stimulate torsional vibra-
tion due to manufacturing imperfections. It can also be the victim of torsional vibra-
tion if the torque variation is sufficient to cause tooth separation in the gear mesh.
Gearboxes also cause a power loss of about 1-1/2 - 2% for single reduction units,
and about 3% for double reduction machines. Trains with gearboxes take more
space and have been troublesome in the past in a number of applications.
In view of these disadvantages, the application engineer may be dissuaded from
selecting a train of equipment that requires a gearbox. It is indeed a worthwhile
effort to search for equipment that does not require gearing. On the other hand,
there have been cases where this effort was carried too far such that unqualified
equipment was force-fitted into a gearless train resulting in a new set of problems.
While it is true that gearboxes have been responsible for excessive machinery down-
time in some installations, manufacturing techniques and analytical methods have
improved to the extent that gearbox reliability is now generally compatible with
that of compressors and drivers. Moreover, use of a gearbox will usually allow the
compressor and driver to operate at ideal speeds. The overall efficiency is thus
improved and the gear's power loss is often more than redeemed.
Vertical Vessels
The vertical liquid/gas separator in Figure 100-38 is the most basic configuration
for knockout vessels found in compressor suction systems. This design utilizes
gravity separation as the primary method of separation and a mist elimination pad
to coalesce aerosols as the secondary separation method. The figure illustrates the
orientation of vessel internals and the standard dimensions recommended for proper
liquid/gas separation and control.
The advantages of the vertical separator include:
• Less plot space
• Greater surge volume length for effective level control and to protect against
liquid “slugs”
• Increased vertical disengagement space between the liquid level and the mist
elimination pad
• Centrifugal separation is easily incorporated
Appendix P contains a concise design guide for designing separator vessels. This
design guide is not intended to replace a process design manual for separators.
When possible, it is recommended that engineers take advantage of computer
programs such as “SEPDES” for design optimization.
Horizontal Vessels
Horizontal separator vessels as shown in Figure 100-39, are seldom used as basic
knockout vessels. Space and foundation requirements make them costly and
impractical for basic service. They are commonly applied when the process
requires a large volume of liquid to be removed from the gas.
The advantages of horizontal separator vessels include:
• Greater liquid holding volume
• Increased coalescer surface area
• Flow is perpendicular to gravitational forces
One difficulty with horizontal vessels is that they are not easily modified to isolate
accumulated liquids from the disengagement space. For this reason, centrifugal
separation is not a practical design option in horizontal vessels. To assist in
isolating accumulated liquid from the gas flow path, a dipleg or “udder” is some-
times incorporated. Appendix P contains a design guide for designing separator
vessels.
Retrofit Considerations
High efficiency filters are recommended as an addition to the knockout pot to
further enhance the quality of the gas to be compressed. Although high efficiency
filters have demonstrated resiliency to liquid flooding, systems that have the poten-
tial to “slug” large amounts of liquid should have an appropriately sized knockout
vessel equipped with a mist elimination device upstream to protect against liquid
overload. Many knockout vessels found in the field are inadequately sized or
improperly designed because the worst-case plant conditions were not considered.
Gas Temperature
The knock-out vessel and line between the vessel and compressor should be insu-
lated to prevent condensation from external cooling. If beneficial, the line and the
vessel can be heat traced as well. Reciprocating compressor jacket water should be
maintained at an elevated temperature to prevent condensation on the cylinder
walls. API 618 requires jacket water to be at least 10 F above the inlet gas tempera-
ture to prevent condensation. In many applications, this temperature is greater than
the cooling water available at the site. If this is the case, a cooling water console
with closed loop circulation is one solution.
Abstract
This section discusses engineering principles, types of machines and configura-
tions, and performance characteristics. It contains sufficient information, when used
in conjunction with Company specifications, to understand how to specify and
apply centrifugal compressors including auxiliaries and support systems.
The discussion is primarily aimed at heavy-duty multistage units, but the informa-
tion can be applied to smaller and less severe-duty compressors as well.
Contents Page
U2
H = K -------
g
(Eq. 200-1)
where:
ft.-lb.f
H = head, ---------------
lb.m
U = impeller tip speed in ft/sec
K = a constant
g = 32.174 (ft-lb: mass) / (lb: force) (sec2)
Note “Head” is a term often used for the work input to a compression process.
The units of head are foot-pounds (force) divided by pounds (mass). In general
practice, “head” is usually taken as “feet.”
Manufacturers generally define performance of individual impellers in terms of:
• Head coefficient µ - a function of actual work input and stage efficiency
• Flow coefficient φ - a non-dimensional function of volume flow and rotational
speed
Figure 200-3 represents a typical individual impeller curve. The head coefficient
typically varies from about 0.4 to 0.6. The surge line in the figure is discussed in
Sub-section 224. Using the head coefficient, the head can now be shown as:
µU 2
H = ----------
g
(Eq. 200-2)
n–1
------------
r n –1
µU 2
H poly = ---------- = Z avg RT 1 --------------------------
g n–1
------------
n
(Eq. 200-3)
where:
Z1 + Z2
Z avg = -------------------
2
= average compressibility
As mentioned in Section 100, the polytropic process is typically used for centrif-
ugal compressors (rather than the adiabatic process).
k–1
------------
k
η p = ------------
n–1
------------
n
(Eq. 200-4)
Fig. 200-4 Impeller Inlet and Outlet Flow Vector Triangles (From Compressors: Selection & Sizing, by Royce Brown
1986 by Gulf Publishing Company, Houston, TX. Used with permission. All rights reserved.)
Fig. 200-5 Forward, Radial, and Backward Curved Blades (From Compressors: Selection & Sizing, by Royce Brown
1986 by Gulf Publishing Company, Houston, TX. Used with permission. All rights reserved.)
Impellers with backward leaning blades, are more commonly used for most centrif-
ugal compressors because of their increased stable operating range ( Figure 200-6).
Forward and radial blades are seldom used in petrochemical applications.
Machine output is always affected by combined losses, such as:
• Mechanical loss
• Aerodynamic loss
• Friction and shock loss
Mechanical losses, such as those from a journal or thrust bearing, affect the power
input required, but do not influence the head-capacity curve. Aerodynamic losses
that do influence the shape of the curve consist mainly of wall friction, fluid shear,
seal losses, recirculation in flow passages, and shock losses. Shock losses are the
result of expansion, contraction, and change of direction associated with flow sepa-
ration, eddies, and turbulence. Friction and shock losses are the predominant
sources of the total aerodynamic losses.
Figure 200-7 illustrates the affect of these combined losses in reducing the theoret-
ical head.
Friction losses can be reduced by improving surface finishes. Shock losses may
sometimes be mitigated by further streamlining of flow passages. These techniques
will improve efficiency and tend to reduce the surge point, but they are costly, and
there is a point of diminishing returns. The Company specification does not allow
the manufacturer's quoted performance to include efficiency improvements due to
impeller polishing.
casing and rotor can be removed from either the up- or down-connected vertically-
split outer casing without disturbing process piping.
Both the horizontally and vertically-split casing designs allow removal of bearings
and shaft-end seals for maintenance without disassembly of major casing compo-
nents.
Figure 200-12 gives a comparison of pressure vs. capacity for multistage horizon-
tally- and vertically-split casing construction. The size/rating comparisons are
Overhung-Impeller Types
Single-stage, overhung-impeller (impeller located outboard of the radial bearings,
opposite the driver end) designs are available in pressure ratings to approximately
2000 psi and capacities to 50,000 cfm.
Another type of centrifugal compressor is the integrally-geared configuration. This
is an overhung-impeller type built around a gear box, with the impellers attached to
gear pinion shafts and the impeller housings mounted on the gear box. Possible
configurations include two, three, four, and even five stage designs with capacities
to 30,000 cfm and pressures to 250 psig. These have typically been used as pack-
aged-air or nitrogen compressors. The overall arrangement of this type varies signif-
icantly between manufacturers.
Major features of the integrally geared design include:
• Open impellers—maximum head developed
• volute diffusers for optimum efficiency
• different pinion speeds to optimize impeller efficiency
221 General
Figure 200-13 presents a centrifugal compressor performance map, using API 617
nomenclature. The family of curves depicts the performance at various speeds
where N represents RPM, and:
• Vertical axis—Head: polytropic head, pressure ratio, discharge pressure, or
differential pressure; and
• Horizontal axis—Inlet Capacity: called “Q” or “Q1” shown as actual inlet
volume per unit of time ACFM or ICFM where “A” is actual, or “I” is inlet.
Note that inlet flow volume, or capacity, is based on a gas with a particular molec-
ular weight, specific heat ratio, and compressibility factor at suction pressure and
temperature.
The curve on the left represents the surge limit. Operation to the left of this line
is unstable and usually harmful to the machine.
A capacity limit or overload curve is shown on the other side of the map. The area
to the right of this line is commonly known as “stonewall” or “choke”. Operation
in this area is, in most instances, harmless mechanically, but the head-producing
capability of the machine falls off rapidly, and performance is unpredictable.
Surge and stonewall should not be confused. Although machine performance is seri-
ously impaired in either case, they are entirely different phenomena. These are
covered in more detail later in this section.
Terms frequently used to define performance are “stability range” and “percent
stability”. Referring again to Figure 200-13, the rated stability range is taken as
QD - QS where QD is the rated point and QS is the surge point along the 100%
speed line. The percent stability expressed as a percentage is:
Q D – QS
- × 100
% stability = --------------------
QD
(Eq. 200-5)
Fig. 200-13 Typical Centifugal Compressor Performance Map (Courtesy of the American Petroleum Institute)
Theoretically, an impeller should produce the same head, or feet of the fluid, regard-
less of the gas weight. However, in practice, a wheel will produce somewhat more
head (than theoretical) with heavy gases, and less with lighter gases. Gas compress-
ibility, specific heat ratio, aerodynamic losses, and several other factors are respon-
sible for this deviation. Manufacturers should apply proprietary correction factors
when the effect is significant. This effect contributes to variance from the well-
known fan laws or affinity laws. (See the next sub-section.)
Notice in Figure 200-14 that the heavier gas causes surge at a higher Q/N, that is, it
reduces stability. The opposite is true of a lighter gas. Similar non-conformance can
sometimes be observed when the wheel is run at tip speeds considerably higher or
lower than an average design speed. The higher tip speed would surge at higher
Q/N, and the lower tip speed would surge at a lower Q/N.
Figure 200-15 illustrates the effects of using movable inlet guide vanes. Notice that
as the head or discharge pressure is reduced, the surge volume (defined by the
dashed line) is also reduced. The effect is similar to that of speed reduction on a
variable speed machine. Inlet throttling, although less efficient, will produce similar
curves.
Centrifugal compressors recognize actual inlet cubic feet per minute (ACFM at
inlet conditions, or ICFM). Performance curves are most commonly plotted using
Fig. 200-15 Constant Speed Machine with Variable Inlet Guide Vanes
ACFM. This means that a curve is drawn for a specific set of suction conditions,
and any change in these conditions will affect the validity of the curve.
Performance curves often plot discharge pressure on the vertical axis, and flow
(ACFM) on the horizontal axis. To estimate performance for varying suction pres-
sures, the curve should be converted to pressure ratio on the vertical axis. This can
be done by dividing the discharge pressures on the vertical axis by the suction pres-
sure on which the original curve was based. The effect of a small variation in
suction temperature can be estimated by using a ratio of absolute temperatures with
the original temperature in the denominator. This ratio is used to correct the inlet
capacity on the X-axis by multiplying inlet capacities by the temperature ratio.
For a rough estimate for molecular weight changes of less than 10%, the pressure
ratio on the curve can simply be multiplied by the ratio of the new molecular
weight over the original. Unless there are gross changes in the gas composition
causing large changes in specific heat ratio, this estimating method will only have
an error of 1 - 2% for pressure ratios between 1.5 and 3. For more accurate esti-
mates, a curve with polytropic head on the vertical axis must be obtained.
Remember that any change that increases the density of the gas at the inlet will
increase the discharge pressure and the horsepower. Also, the unit will tend to surge
at a slightly higher inlet volume.
224 Surge
Surge is a situation that can destroy a compressor. It is a critical factor in design of
the compressor and its control system. It is also a critical operating limit.
Surge is a condition of unstable flow within the compressor, resulting in flow
reversal and pressure fluctuations in the system. This occurs when the head (pres-
sure) developed by the compressor is less than that required to overcome down-
stream system pressure. At surge, continuous “forward” flow is interrupted.
While surge is caused by aerodynamic instability in the compressor, interaction
with the system sometimes produces violent swings in flow, accompanied by pres-
sure fluctuations and relatively rapid temperature increase at the compressor inlet.
Surge affects the overall system and is not confined to only the compressor. There-
fore, an understanding of both the external causes and the machine design is neces-
sary to apply an adequate anti-surge system.
The compressor surge region was previously identified in Figure 200-13. In
Figure 200-17 lines depicting three typical system operating curves have been
added. The shapes of these curves are governed by the system friction, and pressure
control in the particular system external to the compressor.
Fig. 200-17 Typical Centrifugal Compressor Performance Map Showing Surge Cycle
A compressor will operate at the intersection of its curve and the system curve.
To change the point at which the compressor operates:
1. Change the speed or variable geometry of the compressor, thus relocating the
compressor curve; or
2. Change the system curve by repositioning a control valve or otherwise altering
the external system curve.
Frequency of Surge
Frequency of the surge cycle varies inversely with the volume of the system. For
example, if the piping contains a check valve located near the compressor discharge
nozzle, the frequency will be correspondingly much higher than that of the system
without a check valve. The frequency can be as low as a few cycles per minute up
to 15 or more cycles per second. Generally, the higher the frequency, the lower the
intensity. The intensity or violence of surge tends to increase with increased gas
density which is directly related to higher molecular weights and pressures, and
lower temperatures. Higher differential pressure generally increases the intensity.
ferential distance around the diffuser (Figure 200-18). If this distance becomes
longer for any reason, the flow is exposed to more wall friction which dissipates the
kinetic energy. As flow is reduced, the angle is reduced which extends the length of
the trajectory through the diffuser (Figure 200-19). When the flow path is too long,
insufficient pressure rise (head) is developed and surge occurs.
Fig. 200-18 Design Condition Velocity Triangles (Reproduced with permission of the Turbomachinery Laboratory.
From Proceedings of the Twelfth Turbomachinery Symposium, Texas A&M University, College Station,
TX, 1983)
Occasionally, vaned diffusers are used to force the flow to take a shorter, more effi-
cient path. Figure 200-20 shows the flow pattern in a vaned diffuser. The vaned
diffuser can increase the aerodynamic efficiency of a stage by approximately 3%,
but this efficiency gain results in a narrower operating span on the head-capacity
curve with respect to both surge and stonewall. The figure also shows how the path
of a particle of gas is affected by off-design flows. At flows higher than design,
impingement occurs on the trailing side of the diffuser vane creating shock losses
which tend to bring on stonewall. Conversely, flow less than design encourages
surge, due to the shock losses from impingement on the leading edge of the vane.
Despite adverse effects on surge, the vaned diffuser should be applied where effi-
ciency is of utmost importance, particularly with small high-speed wheels.
Stationary guide vanes may be used to direct the flow to the eye of the impeller.
Depending upon the head requirements of an individual stage, these vanes may
direct the flow in the same direction as the rotation or tip speed of the wheel, an
action known as pre-rotation or pre-swirl. The opposite action is known as
Fig. 200-19 Flow Trajectory in a Vaneless Diffuser (Reproduced with permission of the Turbomachinery Laboratory.
From Proceedings of the Twelfth Turbomachinery Symposium, Texas A&M University, College Station,
TX, 1983)
counter-rotation or counter swirl. Guide vanes set at zero degrees of swirl are
called radial guide vanes.
The effect guide vanes have on a compressor's curve is illustrated in Figure 200-21.
Note that pre-rotation reduces the head or unloads the impeller. Pre-rotation tends
to reduce the surge flow. Counter-rotation increases the head and tends to increase
the surge flow.
The effects of surge can range from a simple lack of performance to serious
damage to the machine and/or the system. Internal damage to labyrinths,
diaphragms, thrust bearing and the rotor can be experienced. Surge often excites
lateral shaft vibration. It can also produce torsional damages to such items as
couplings and gears. Externally, devastating piping vibration can occur causing
structural damage, mis-alignment, and failure of fittings and instruments.
Surge can often be recognized by check valve hammering, piping vibration, noise,
wriggling of pressure gages or ammeter on the driver. Mild cases of surge are some-
times difficult to discern.
225 Stonewall
Another major factor affecting the theoretical head-capacity curve is choke or
stonewall. The terms surge and stonewall are sometimes incorrectly used inter-
changeably, probably due to the fact that serious performance deterioration is
observed in either case.
A compressor stage is considered to be in stonewall, in theory, when the Mach
Number equals one. At this point the impeller passage is choked and no more flow
can be passed. Industry practice normally limits the inlet Mach Number to less than
0.90 for any specified operating point.
We are concerned with two important items in defining stonewall: the inlet-gas
velocity incidence angle, and the inlet-gas Mach Number.
The vector diagram (Figure 200-22) shows an inlet-gas velocity vector which lines
up well with the impeller blade at design flow.
Fig. 200-22 Inlet Gas Velocity Vector – Design Flow (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
The ratio of the inlet gas velocity (relative to the impeller blade) to the speed of
sound at inlet is referred to as the relative inlet Mach Number.
V rel
Mach No. = ----------
a1
(Eq. 200-6)
where:
a1 = g k ZRT 1
= speed of sound at inlet
As flow continues to increase, the incidence angle of the relative gas velocity, with
respect to the impeller blade, becomes negative as shown in Figure 200-23. The
negative incidence angle results in an effective reduction of the flow area and
impingement of the gas on the trailing edge of the blade, contributing to flow sepa-
ration and the onset of choke.
Fig. 200-23 Inlet Gas Velocity Vector – Negative Incidence Angle (Onset of Choke) (Cour-
tesy of the Elliot Company)
It is important to note the choke effect is much greater for high molecular weight
gas, especially at low temperatures and lower k values. For this reason, maximum
allowable compressor speed may be limited on high molecular weight applications,
with a corresponding reduction in head per stage.
Fig. 200-25 Polytropic Efficiency vs. Inlet Volume Flow (Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Estimate overall efficiency from Figure 200-25, using average CFM from:
n–1 k–1
------------ = ------------
n kη p
(Eq. 200-8)
n–1
------------
r n –1
H p = z avg RT 1 ---------------------
n–1
------------
n
(Eq. 200-9)
where:
Hp = Polytropic Head in feet
n–1
------------
T2 = T1 r n
(Eq. 200-10)
wH p
GHP = -----------------------
33 ,000η p
(Eq. 200-11)
where:
w = weight flow in lbs./min.
Estimate brake horsepower using:
BHP = GHP + bearing loss + oil seal loss
where bearing loss is determined from Figure 200-26, and oil seal loss is deter-
mined from Figure 200-27. The casing size in the figures is selected by comparing
the cfmavg with the flow range in Figure 200-24
233 Head/Stage
Although special impeller designs are available for higher heads, a good estimate
for the typical multistage compressor is approximately 10,000 ft/stage. This is
based on an assumed impeller flow coefficient of 0.5 and a nominal impeller tip
speed of 800 fps.
The actual head per stage varies between manufacturers and individual impeller
designs, ranging from 9,000 to 12,000 feet for 28 to 30 molecular weight gas at
normal temperatures.
Head per stage is limited by:
• impeller stress levels
• inlet Mach Number
Fig. 200-26 Bearing Losses vs. Casing Size and Speed (Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Fig. 200-27 Oil Seal Losses vs. Casing Size and Speed (Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Figure 200-28 identifies the impeller stresses at various rotational speeds. Reduced
yield strengths required for corrosive gas will correspondingly reduce maximum
head per stage through reduction in speed.
234 Stages/Casing
The maximum number of stages per casing should normally be limited to eight. It
is usually limited by rotor critical speeds, although in a few cases temperature can
be a limiting factor.
Most multistage centrifugal compressors operate between the first and second criti-
cals (flexible shaft rotor). Figure 200-29 shows the location of critical speeds in
relation to the operating speed range. API specifies the required separation between
critical speeds and the compressor operating range. As the bearing span is increased
to accommodate additional impellers, the critical speed decreases, with the second
critical approaching the operating range. While some manufacturer's bulletins indi-
cate as many as 10 or more stages per casing, designs exceeding eight impellers per
case should be carefully evaluated against operating experience from similar units.
Fig. 200-29 Rotor Response Plot (Courtesy of the American Petroleum Institute)
Casings
The following is a summary of casing materials and their applications.
1. Cast Iron
• Limited to low pressure applications for non-flammable, non-toxic gases.
• Limited in location and size of main and sidestream connections to available
patterns.
2. Cast Steel
• Quality is difficult to obtain.
• X-ray inspection requirements increase costs.
• High-rejection rate or involved repairs can extend deliveries.
3. Fabricated Steel
• Used for both horizontally- and vertically-split casings.
• Improved quality control possible.
• Delays associated with rejection or repair of castings are avoided.
• Variable stage spacing provides minimum bearing span for required stages.
• Main and sidestream nozzle size and location are not limited by pattern avail-
ability.
4. Forged Steel
• Used for small vertically-split casing sizes where application involves very
high pressures.
All centrifugal compressor casings used to be cast. But, due to the problems associ-
ated with quality control on large castings, coupled with improved fabrication tech-
niques and costs, many manufacturers converted to fabricated steel casings,
especially on the larger frame sizes.
Nozzles
Inlet and outlet nozzles are available in a variety of configurations, depending on
the manufacturer. They are normally flanged. (Typical arrangements are shown
later in this section.) API 617 covers requirements for flange type, and ratings of
main and auxiliary connections.
The increased use of fabricated cases has provided additional flexibility in nozzle
orientation.
If the installation permits, the following should be considered:
1. Horizontally-split units with process connections in the lower half (down-
connected) allow removal of the top half, and internals including rotor, without
disturbing the process piping.
2. If overhead process piping is required, the use of vertically-split barrel
compressor casings still allow removal of the inner casing and access to the
internals without removing process piping. Fabricated casing design makes the
vertically-split unit a cost-effective alternative for larger medium pressure
applications.
Stage
The heart of the centrifugal compressor is the impeller “stage”. The stage is made
up of the following parts (illustrated in Figure 200-31):
• inlet guide vanes
• impeller
• diffuser
• return bend (crossover)
• return channel
The stage can be separated into two major elements:
• The impellers which are mounted on the shaft as part of the rotor.
• The stationary components including the inlet nozzle and other components
mentioned above.
Fig. 200-31 Centrifugal Compressor Stage Components (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
The inlet volute, or return channel, guides the gas to the eye of the impeller, and
aided by the guide vanes, distributes the flow around the circumference of the
impeller eye.
One method of adjusting the stage performance, is to use different guide vane
angles. This changes the angle of incidence on the impeller which in turn varies the
head, efficiency, and stability. There are three types of fixed guide vanes; radial,
against-rotation, and with-rotation. The influence of various guide vane angles on a
given impeller head characteristic is shown in Figure 200-32.
Diaphragms
The stationary members inside the casing are called diaphragms. The diaphragm
includes a diffuser for the gas as it leaves the impeller, and a channel to redirect the
gas through the return bend and return channel into the next stage. Diaphragms can
be either cast or fabricated, with cast diaphragms normally made of iron. Normally,
diaphragms are not exposed to high pressure-differentials, and therefore are not
highly stressed. Diaphragms should be made of steel where high-differentials may
exist (such as back-to-back impellers).
Impellers
The impeller is the most highly stressed component in the compressor. Available
types vary widely, although the three basic types are designated as open, semi-
open and closed:
Fig. 200-32 Head-Capacity Characteristics of Constant Speed Centrifugal Compressor with Capacity Regulated by
Variable Inlet Vane Angle (Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Open impellers have the vanes positioned in a radial direction and have no
enclosing covers on either the front or back sides.
Semi-open impellers usually have the vanes positioned in a radial or backward
leaning direction and have a cover on the back side which extends to the periphery
of the vanes. The radial blade, semi-open impeller provides for a maximum amount
of flow and head in a single stage, even in large diameter impellers (Figure 200-33).
Fig. 200-33 Impeller Types – Closed and Semi-Open Backward Leaning (Courtesy of
Dresser-Rand)
Closed impellers have enclosing covers on both the front and back side. This is the
most common type in our large process compressors. The blades are usually back-
ward leaning, although they may be radial. Forward leaning blades are normally
used only in fans or blowers. (See Figure 200-33)
Single-inlet impellers take the gas in an axial direction, on one side of the impeller
only, and discharge the gas in a radial direction.
Double-flow impellers take the gas in an axial direction, on both sides of the
impeller, and discharge the gas in a radial direction. They are, in effect, the equiva-
lent of two single-inlet impellers placed back-to-back and, in general will handle
twice the flow at the same head as a single-inlet impeller of the same diameter oper-
ating at the same speed.
Some impeller designs utilize a three-dimensional blade or vane configuration,
which varies the inlet blade angle from hub to outside diameter, thereby providing
optimum aerodynamic geometry, and improved performance over that of two-
dimensional designs.
Centrifugal compressor impellers discharge gas radially, but the gas enters in an
axial direction. An axial flow element called an inducer is sometimes incorporated
into the impeller. This combination is called a mixed-flow impeller. This configura-
tion results in increased efficiency in high-flow applications.
In the past, riveted impeller construction was used in a large number of applica-
tions. Today, construction with welded components is more common.
Rotor
The rotor is made up of the shaft, impellers, impeller spacers, thrust collar, and the
balance drum. Figure 200-34 shows several rotor configurations with various
impeller types.
If a rotor always operates below the lowest critical speed, it is known as a stiff-
shaft rotor. In contrast, a rotor with a normal operating range above one or more of
its criticals is a flexible-shaft rotor. Most multistage centrifugal compressors have
flexible-shaft rotors; and therefore, must pass through at least one critical during
start-up or shutdown. From an operational point of view, stiff shafts would be pref-
erable. However, it is not practical since the shafts would become prohibitively
large.
Shafts
Shafts are made from alloy steel forgings, finished by grinding or honing to
produce the required finish. Special requirements are detailed in API 617 for
balancing and concentricity during rotor assembly. Impellers are normally mounted
on the shaft with a shrink fit with or without a key, depending on the particular
manufacturer and compressor frame size. Most manufacturers use shaft sleeves to
both locate impellers and provide protection for the shaft in the event of contact
with internal labyrinth seals.
Special attention must be given to minimizing mechanical and electrical runout at
the shaft area observed by proximity probes. See the General Machinery Manual
for more information on mechanical/electrical mount.
Fig. 200-34 Centrifugal Compressor Rotor Configurations (Courtesy of the Elliot Company)
Radial Bearings
Radial bearings on centrifugal compressors are usually pressure lubricated. For
ease of maintenance, they are horizontally- split with replaceable liners or pads.
The liners or pads are usually steel backed with a thin lining of babbitt.
Since centrifugal rotors are relatively light, bearing loads are low. This often leads
to instability problems which must be compensated for by the bearing design. Due
to instability, the straight-sleeve bearing is used only in some slow-speed units with
relatively short bearing spans. The pressure-dam sleeve bearing, and the tilting-
pad bearing are two commonly used designs which improve rotor stability.
The top half of the pressure-dam design is relieved as shown in Figure 200-35,
creating a pressure point where the dam ends. This conversion of oil-velocity into
pressure adds to rotor stability by increasing the bearing load.
Fig. 200-35 Pressure Dam Sleeve Bearing Liner (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
The tilting-pad bearing shown in Figure 200-36 is usually made up of five indi-
vidual pads, each pivoted at its midpoint. By adjustments to the shape of the pads
and bearing clearance, bearing stiffness and damping characteristics can be
controlled. This bearing is successful in applications where the pressure-dam
design is inadequate.
Fig. 200-36 Tilting-Pad or Pivoted Shoe Radial Journal Bearing (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Thrust Bearing
The tilting pad is the most common thrust bearing used in centrifugal compressors.
The flat land and tapered land bearings are used less frequently. Figure 200-37
shows a tilting-pad bearing, consisting of a thrust collar (collar disk) attached to the
rotor shaft, and a carrier ring which holds the pads. A button on the back of the pad
allows the pad to pivot freely, thus allowing adjustment to varying oil velocity at
different compressor speeds. A further refinement to the basic design is the self-
equalizing bearing shown in Figure 200-38. An equalizing bar design allows the
bars to rock until all pads carry an equal load.
Balance Piston
Figure 200-39 represents the pressure profile acting on a centrifugal compressor
impeller, showing net pressure and net thrust pattern. This pressure pattern on the
impeller results in a net thrust force towards the suction end of the machine. The
total net thrust is the sum of the thrusts from all the individual impellers.
The rotor's thrust is handled by the thrust bearing. However, in most multistage
compressors, a very large, if not impractical, thrust bearing would be required to
handle the total thrust load, if not otherwise compensated. Therefore a thrust
Fig. 200-37 Button-Type Tilting-Pad Thrust Bearing (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Fig. 200-38 Self-Equalizing Tilting-Pad Thrust Bearing (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Fig. 200-39 Impeller Pressure and Thrust Patterns (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
develops a force which opposes the normal thrust force, thus greatly reducing the
net thrust transmitted to the thrust bearing.
Thrust compensation can be regulated by controlling the balance piston diameter.
However, there are usually physical and design limitations. Normally a balancing
force less than the total impeller thrust (approximately 75%) is selected to maintain
the rotor on one face of the thrust bearing for all operating conditions. Otherwise,
the rotor could bounce back and forth between the thrust faces as process condi-
tions vary.
Interstage Seals
Internal seals are installed on multistage centrifugals to prevent leakage between
stages, thereby improving performance. Labyrinth seals are commonly used, being
located at the impeller eye and at the shaft between stages. Figure 200-41 illustrates
internal labyrinth seals.
Fig. 200-40 Centrifugal Compressor Balance Drum Fig. 200-41 Interstage Seals (Courtesy of Dresser-
(Balance Piston) (Courtesy of the Howell Rand)
Training Group)
Shaft End-Seals
Centrifugal compressors use shaft end-seals to:
1. Restrict or prevent leakage of air or oil vapors into the process gas stream.
2. Restrict or prevent leakage of process gas from inside the compressor.
Various types of seals are used, depending on the gas being compressed, the pres-
sures involved, safety, operating experience, power savings, and process require-
ments.
Shaft end-seals are separated into two broad categories:
• the restrictive seal which restricts but does not completely prevent leakage; and
• the positive seal designed to prevent leakage.
Restrictive seals are usually labyrinths. They are generally limited to applications
involving non-toxic, non-corrosive, abrasive-free gases at low pressures. In some
cases, ports for injection or withdrawal of the gas are used to extend the range of
effectiveness. Some possible arrangements are shown in Figure 200-42.
Another form of the restrictive seal is the dry carbon ring seal, often used on over-
hung single-stage compressors where maximum sealing and minimum axial shaft
spacing are important. Since this seal can be held to close clearances, leakage is
less than with the labyrinth seal. Also, less axial shaft space is required (see
Figure 200-43).
Positive seals, while varying somewhat in design between manufacturers, are either
liquid-film or mechanical contact type.
The liquid-film type is shown in Figure 200-44. A schematic of a seal system is
shown in Figure 200-45. Sealing oil is fed to the seal from an overhead tank located
at an elevation above the compressor set to maintain a fixed five psi (typically)
differential above “seal reference” pressure. (Seal reference pressure is very close
to suction pressure.)
The oil enters between the seal rings and flows in both directions to prevent inward
leakage to the process gas or outward leakage of the gas to the atmosphere. “Buffer
ports” are often available for injection of an inert gas to further ensure separation of
the process from the sealing medium. The oil-film seal is suitable for sealing pres-
sures in excess of 3000 psi. (See Figure 200-46 for an illustration of a buffer-gas
injection.)
The tilting-pad oil seal (shown in Figure 200-47) is a design that recognizes that in
some cases the seal operates as a bearing. It can be used in high-pressure, high-pres-
sure-rise applications to improve rotor stability.
The mechanical contact seal (Figure 200-48) is used at pressures up to 1000 psi,
and has the added feature of providing more positive sealing during shutdown.
Sealing is provided by means of a floating carbon ring seal riding between a
stationary and a rotating face. The seal medium (oil) functions primarily as a
coolant. Seal oil differential is controlled by a regulator rather than an overhead
tank.
Fig. 200-42 Ported Labyrinth Seals (Courtesy of the Fig. 200-43 Buffered Dry Carbon-Ring Seal (Courtesy
Elliott Company) of the Elliott Company)
Fig. 200-44 Liquid (Oil) Film Seal (Courtesy of Dresser- Fig. 200-45 Oil Film Seal Schematic (Courtesy of
Rand) Dresser-Rand)
Fig. 200-46 Oil Film Seal with Buffer to Separate Seal Oil from Bearing Oil (Courtesy of
Dresser-Rand)
242 Configurations
Configuration refers to the relationship between the inlet, discharge, and side
streams to the mechanical arrangement of the compressor. This will be clarified by
the following examples.
Figure 200-49 shows a typical cross-section of a multistage centrifugal compressor.
This is called a “straight-through” compressor because flow goes in one end and
out the other.
Another common configuration is the “compound,” or “Out-and-In” type
(Figure 200-50). This arrangement allows removal of the total gas stream for inter-
cooling, power savings, or processing, and re-entry for additional compression.
Note the additional spacing required for flow extraction and re-entry. Although
some designs can minimize the effect, this reduces the maximum number of impel-
lers available for compression.
The “sidestream compressor” shown in Figure 200-51 allows the introduction or
extraction of partial flows at intermediate levels to satisfy various process require-
ments. The number of sidestreams in a single casing is limited only by available
spacing. This arrangement adds the complexity of requiring mixed temperature
calculations to determine impeller performance downstream of sidestream inlets.
The “double-flow” configuration effectively doubles the capacity of a given frame
size ( Figure 200-52). The compressor is divided into two sections, the inlet flow
entering at either end, and discharging through a common discharge nozzle at the
center of the casing. The impellers in each section face in opposite directions,
achieving thrust balance at all operating conditions. While flow is doubled, the
number of stages available for increasing head is cut in half. The use of the double-
flow option should be carefully evaluated against other alternatives.
The compressor in Figure 200-53 utilizes what is commonly called the “back-to-
back” impeller arrangement. This type has advantages in high pressure-rise applica-
tions where thrust balancing becomes difficult using a conventional thrust bearing
and balancing drum. Since the back-to-back impellers produce opposing thrust
forces, the net thrust is significantly reduced, eliminating the need for a balance
Example
In Figure 200-55 a typical system resistance curve has been added to performance
curves indicating the effect of a change in inlet pressure. The solid curve shows
original performance while the lower curve shows the effects of a reduced inlet
pressure. Calculations using fan laws (assuming a constant inlet volume flow)
would indicate revised operation at point C. However, since the compressor would
actually seek a new operating point at the intersection of its revised performance
curve and the system curve, the resulting operation would be at point B.
If the effects of the system curve are large, estimates made using the fan laws will
be significantly in error.
Fig. 200-55 Effect on Performance Due to Change in Pressure (From Compressors: Selection & Sizing, by Royce
Brown 1986 by Gulf Publishing Company, Houston, TX. Used with permission. All rights reserved.)
overall casing performance. For determination of the surge volume, use the overall
curve.
In most situations, it is desirable to have an individual anti-surge recycle line
around each casing (or around each section of compression of compound casings).
It is not practical for one anti-surge control to accommodate two casings or sections
at operating conditions significantly removed from the rated point. In addition, the
overall operating stability range can be improved because the anti-surge controls
can be set for the stability range of each casing rather than the overall range for all
casings.
API 614, Lubrication, Shaft-Sealing, and Control Oil Systems for Special Purpose
Applications, and Specification CMP-MS-4762 cover the design, manufacture, and
testing of the overall system, as well as individual components. Used as a reference,
they provide guidelines based on user experience which can easily be scaled down
or tailored to fit any requirement.
The system may be designed either as a console or baseplate-mounted package,
with all components mounted on a single baseplate, or alternately as a multiple-
package arrangement, with system components separated into individually pack-
aged units. In this case the individual component packages are piped together in the
field.
Oil return lines must slope toward the reservoir(s) to allow gravity draining. This is
often overlooked when piping is being laid out. Also, be careful to avoid “head
knockers” when laying out pipe.
Off-shore applications may require a system mounted integrally with the
compressor/driver baseplate, with off-mounted air coolers.
The console arrangement, because of its compact layout, may limit or restrict
access to various components making maintenance difficult. The multiple-package
arrangement allows greater flexibility in locating the individual packages for
improved maintenance access. A major disadvantage of the multiple-package
arrangement is that the complete system is seldom shop tested and therefore perfor-
mance is not verified prior to arrival on site.
Careful attention at all phases from initial specification through installation and
startup will contribute significantly to trouble-free compressor train startup and
operation. Historical maintenance data from many compressor installations indicate
approximately 20 to 25% of centrifugal compressor unscheduled downtime results
from instrument problems (many of these associated with operation and control of
the lube and seal system).
When designing or modifying a system, obtain specific input from the field
regarding site requirements, preferences, and operating experience. They may have
already modified the basic system to correct problems experienced, found a partic-
ular type or brand of instrument that functions better under their site conditions, or
standardized on components to reduce spare parts inventories, etc.
The following highlights areas requiring special attention:
1. For critical or non-spared equipment, include a main and an identical full-sized
auxiliary oil pump (not to be confused with an emergency oil pump which is
normally of much smaller capacity, sized only to handle lube and seal require-
ments during coast-down). A popular drive arrangement for turbine-driven
compressors is a steam-turbine driven main oil pump with an electric motor
driven auxiliary. This arrangement has the advantage that auto-start control of
the electric motor driven unit is relatively simple and reliable with rapid accel-
eration to full speed and rated pressure output. For installations where steam is
not available, several alternate drive combinations are used, including motor,
shaft-driven, and in a few cases air or gas expanders. With motor driven main
and auxiliary pumps, each should be supplied by an independent power source.
2. Consider adequate oil-flow to bearings and seals during coast-down following
a trip of the auxiliary pump. The two approaches used most often involve
either an emergency oil pump or overhead rundown tanks.
Overhead rundown tanks are typically located to provide an initial pressure
(head) equal to the low oil pressure trip pressure. API requires capacity to be
sufficient to supply oil for a minimum of three minutes. In the majority of
cases this is adequate.
A second method is an emergency oil pump. This pump would probably be DC
motor driven, with power supplied by a battery backed UPS system.
3. Manufacturers often insist that the response time of a motor driven auxiliary
pump is sufficient to avoid pressure decay tripping the main unit, and therefore
accumulators are not required. However, several tests have shown this not to be
the case. The option should always be held open so that accumulator require-
ments are based on the system demonstrating acceptable stability during the
prescribed testing.
4. The system rundown tanks, and the accumulators are sometimes confused. The
rundown tanks provide lubrication and cooling to bearings and seals during
coast-down. The accumulator is designed to maintain system pressure within
specified limits during transient conditions or upsets, thus avoiding machinery
trips.
5. When oil seals are used, the manufacturer is normally asked to guarantee a
maximum value for this inner seal-oil leakage. The guaranteed value is often
found to be considerably lower than actual leakage on test or following startup.
Since size of the degassing tank is based on this leakage rate, the tank often
ends up being undersized.
API specifies that the degassing tank be sized for a minimum of three times the
guaranteed inner seal oil leakage. Actual leakage, however, has in some
instances exceeded quoted values by more than 10 times. The manufacturer's
sizing criteria should be verified based on review of leakage-rate tests for
similar seals.
6. For centrifugal lube-oil pumps, the pump head should be compared to the
maximum allowable filter pressure drop (of dirty filters) to ensure that suffi-
cient oil flow is provided to the machinery as the filters become dirty.
7. Shaft-driven main lube-oil pumps are not recommended, since any mainte-
nance or repair of this pump requires the machine be shutdown.
Fig. 200-58 Effects of Changing Gas Conditions at Fig. 200-59 Constant Speed Performance Curves
Constant Speed (Courtesy of the Elliott (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Company)
Parallel Operation
Parallel operation of two or more compressors adds additional complexity to the
control system evaluation.
Slight variations in compressor performance characteristics, piping configuration,
and instrument settings can cause one unit to take all the load, thus forcing the
others into recycle, or alternately causing endless “hunting” between units.
For example, if one unit starts to recycle slightly ahead of the other and suction
temperature is increased due to the recycle, its capability to produce head will be
reduced, thereby locking this unit into recycle. Alternately, if suction temperature is
reduced by recycle, head output is increased forcing the other unit into recycle,
starting a back-and-forth swing between units.
Simulation studies are often necessary because of the complexity involved in
matching parallel compressors. Direct your efforts toward developing the least
complex control logic that will meet process and operating requirements. One
common approach is to base load one unit, allowing the second unit to take process
swings.
Fig. 200-60 Variable Speed Performance Curves (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
The most common systems are those described in the General Machinery Manual.
Virtually all new centrifugal compressors come with some monitoring system.
271 Capacity
While impellers and internal stationary components can be relocated and new ones
added, the casing nozzle sizes are fixed. The maximum capacity that can be
handled with a reasonable pressure drop is therefore dependent on the nozzle size
and related to inlet gas velocity.
Inlet velocity is dependent on gas conditions, allowable noise levels, and inlet
piping configurations. An acceptable rule-of-thumb is a maximum of 140 ft/sec for
air or lighter gases and approximately 100 ft/sec for heavier hydrocarbons.
The actual inlet gas velocity can be calculated from:
Q
V = 3.06 -------
D2
(Eq. 200-12)
where:
Q = ACFM in ft3/minute at inlet pressure, temperature, Z, MW
D = inside diameter of the nozzle, in inches
If side load or compound inlets are involved, inlet gas velocity should be checked
for all inlet connections.
272 Pressure
Next, check the pressure rating of the existing unit:
During manufacture, the casing was hydrotested to 1-1/2 times the maximum oper-
ating pressure (nameplate rating). If the pressures involved in the rerate exceed the
nameplate rating, it will be necessary to re-hydrotest the casing for the new condi-
tions.
Note the following items:
• It may be necessary to check with the manufacturer to confirm that the casing
design pressure is adequate for rerating and rehydrotesting.
• Compressor operating characteristics, relief valve settings, or settle out pres-
sures may set the maximum operating pressure.
• If set by compressor characteristics, use pressure rise to surge at maximum
continuous speed.
• Side stream or compound compressors may have been hydrotested by sections
with a different pressure for each. Check each section for compatibility with
new conditions.
Check the compressor to determine its capability of producing the head required.
Use Equation 200-3 to calculate the head for the rerated condition based on the
desired pressure ratio. An attempt may be made to re-use some or all of the existing
impellers, based on an overall polytropic efficiency of 70% for the initial estimate.
Initially estimate the speed from the affinity law (see later discussion regarding
speed limitations):
H p 1---
N 2 = N 1 --------2 2
Hp
1
(Eq. 200-13)
where:
N1 = original speed
N2 = rerated speed
Hp1 = head for rerated pressure
Hp2 = head for original pressure
This same procedure will work for applications involving side loads or intercooling
between sections. The head for each section is determined based on the conditions
for that section, and the total head is the sum of the individual section heads.
273 Power
Since motor drivers are seldom oversized, anything more than a minor power
increase may require a new motor. This requires close evaluation of proposed
process changes to see if necessary improvements can be achieved while still
staying within the driver's capabilities.
In contrast, turbines and gears can usually be modified to provide increased power.
Although turbine data sheets will sometimes provide information regarding
maximum steam flow or uprate capabilities, discussions with the manufacturer may
be required.
From Equation 200-11, you can see that gas horsepower (GHP) is directly propor-
tional to weight flow (w) and head (H), or:
w 2 H p2
GHP 2 = GHP 1 ----------------
-
w 1 H p1
(Eq. 200-14)
For example, if weight flow is increased by 10% and head is increased by 10%, the
power requirement is increased by:
1.10 x 1.10 = 1.21 or 21%
Furthermore, a driver power margin of 10% is recommended. Therefore, the total
recommended requirement is increased by:
1.21 + 10% (1.21) = 1.33 or 33%
274 Speed
Finally, review the speed based on impeller stress and compressor critical speeds.
Impeller stress levels are related to the impeller tip-speed as discussed in
Section 240. While the maximum allowable tip speeds vary with manufacturer,
impeller design, and material, a good rule-of-thumb for impellers with backward
leaning blades is 900 ft/sec maximum tip velocity.
Determine impeller tip speed by:
DN
u = ---------
229
(Eq. 200-15)
or, using the 900 ft/sec., maximum speed is:
299 ( 900 )
N max = -----------------------
D
(Eq. 200-16)
Maintain the following critical speed separation margins:
• Any critical speed at least 20% below any operating speed
• Any critical speed at least 20% above maximum continuous speed
Revamping of the rotor may have some effect on critical speeds; however, ignore
this effect for the initial feasibility estimate.
280 Foundations
This sub-section provides a basis for establishing the dynamic forces to be used by
civil engineers in foundation design calculations. Soil mechanics, natural frequency
calculations, bearing pressure, concrete strength, and other design factors are not
covered here. Refer to the Civil and Structural Manual for such information. Foun-
dations, anchor bolts, and grouting are discussed in the General Machinery Manual.
In addition to knowing the dimensions and weights of the machinery to be
supported, engineers designing the foundation must know the magnitude, direction,
and frequency of the dynamic forces that the machinery will exert on the founda-
tion.
The importance of foundations to a compressor installation cannot be overem-
phasized. Foundations attenuate vibratory forces generated by the machinery, and
reduce transmission of these forces to the surrounding plant and equipment. Foun-
dations also keep the machinery in alignment.
To perform these essential functions throughout the life of the installation, the foun-
dation must be sized to support the weight of the machinery while imposing a toler-
able bearing pressure on the soil or structure. It must be properly designed so that
the system, consisting of the foundation, soil, machinery, and piping, is not at or
near a resonant condition. It is particularly important on offshore structures, which
may be susceptible to resonance from the machinery vibration.
The purchaser of the machinery is normally responsible for the design of the foun-
dation. The vendor or manufacturer of the machinery will seldom take this
responsibility because his expertise is not in this field. It would not be in his
best interest to accept the risks associated with the design. Additionally, the
vendor does not have specific knowledge about the soil conditions at the site.
Dynamic Forces
The dynamic force generated by the rotor(s) of rotary and dynamic compressors is
related to the running speed and the vibration of the rotor. Because of the
complexity of the subject, it is impossible to accurately predict the behavior of a
rotor system with one or two simple equations.
Fortunately, however, standards have been developed for allowable limits of vibra-
tion for new machinery. One of the most widely used standards is the API limit for
dynamic and rotary machines:
1
---
A v = 2, or 12000
--------------- 2, whichever is less
N
(Eq. 200-17)
where:
Av = Peak-to-peak amplitude (displacement) of vibration in mils
(0.001 inches)
F = 4.3 × 10 –8 N 2 W R A v
(Eq. 200-18)
where:
F = Dynamic force, lbs
N = RPM
WR = Weight of rotor, lbs
The force calculated is actually a rotating vector, and it should be assumed that it is
acting perpendicularly at the center of the rotor. It should also be assumed that there
will be a 50% reaction at each bearing from the unbalanced rotating force. The reac-
tions at the machine's hold-down bolts can then be resolved.
Figure 200-61 shows the resolution of these forces to bearing reactions. The latter
reactions are transmitted to the foundation via soleplates or baseplate and anchor
bolts. Note that Equation 200-18 can also be applied to the rotors of turbine drivers
and gearboxes.
Occasionally the foundation designer may want to add a factor above the dynamic
force determined by Equation 200-18, although Equation 200-18 is quite conserva-
tive. Five times the API vibration limit has been used as a design criterion in some
cases where there were special concerns about the design. This would provide a
safety factor of 1.67 beyond Equation 200-18. To make the calculation, substitute
7.1 for 4.3 in Equation 200-18.
Other Considerations
The question sometimes arises about whether the foundation would survive if a
large chunk of metal, such as a piece of an impeller or turbine blade(s), were
thrown off the rotor while running at full speed. A second question might be
whether the foundation should be designed to accommodate such an occurrence.
Foundations usually will survive such accidents, although some repairs to anchor
bolts, hold-down bolts, or bearing pedestals may be necessary. Generally, such
occurrences are not taken into account in the design. The forces involved are
extremely high, and it is impossible to predict their magnitude. It is suggested that
bolting and structures be checked for adequacy at 10 times rated torque. This value
is often used on turbine-generator foundations, because a short circuit can cause an
290 Materials
Selection of casing material is influenced by the service involved. Steel casings are
required by API 617 for air or nonflammable gas at pressure over 400 psig or calcu-
lated discharge temperature over 500°F (anywhere in the operating range), and for
flammable or toxic gas. Stainless steel and high nickel alloys are generally used for
low temperature refrigeration units. A materials guideline which covers recom-
mended materials for compressor components is included as an Appendix of API
617.
Although manufacturers have a background of experience in applying materials and
manufacturing processes to special applications, never assume the manufacturer
completely understands your process.
Include a complete process gas analysis, with emphasis on corrosive agents, and
water vapor, together with any anticipated variation in composition, off-design or
alternate operating conditions, or possible process upsets. Specifications should
encourage the manufacturer to offer alternatives or comment based on their experi-
ence.
When defining the operating environment, also consider the possibility of contami-
nant build-up during compressor shutdown which might contribute to subsequent
component failure. For example, the addition of water or cleaning chemicals during
a unit shutdown may add one of the components that lead to a sulfide stress
cracking failure (see Sub-section 291).
API imposes specific design limitations for corrosive gas applications. However,
actual operating experience may dictate addition or modification to these require-
ments.
API also contains an appendix of material specifications for major compressor
component parts.
The following discussion will help you recognize applications where the potential
for problems may exist. Detailed descriptions of the failure mechanisms mentioned
is beyond the scope of this manual. (See the Materials Manual.)
The use of inhibitors has been investigated, although in most cases the practical
solution for operation in this environment has been a change of material.
Studies indicate that for materials with yield strengths between 100,000 to 110,000
psi, stress levels required for sulfide cracking are near the yield strength. In
contrast, materials with yield strengths of 140,000 psi exhibited susceptibility at
stresses as low as 30,000 psi.
Continuing studies have resulted in establishing the generally accepted API 617
guidelines, which limit material yield strength to 90,000 psi or less, and a hardness
not exceeding Rockwell C22.
Note that in 1987, sulfide cracking caused the loss of a critical compressor
supporting a major hydroprocessing facility, costing several million dollars. The
cause was impeller stage pieces with too high a yield strength.
Nickel based steel alloys are generally used, with suitable alloys available for both
fabricated and cast casings, for temperatures to approximately -150°F. Special
nickel alloys and austenitic stainless steels may be used for temperatures to -320°F.
Fig. 200-62 Impeller Stresses at Various Speeds of Rotation (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Also review other component materials for compatibility with the operating temper-
ature range. The materials appendix of API 617 is an appropriate guide for material
selection since temperature limits specified indicate limits commonly applied by
compressor manufacturers.
An unusual example of the application of low temperature material requirements is
an air compressor located in a cold climate region. Although this compressor might
be located in an enclosed (even heated) building, it could be exposed to inlet air
temperatures well below -50°F. Suction throttling would further reduce inlet temper-
atures.
Where reduced maximum yield strength and hardness are specified, apply the same
requirements to any welding and repair procedures.
295 Impellers
Centrifugal compressor impellers are most commonly made from alloy steel forg-
ings of AISI 4140 or 4340. Materials such as AISI 410 stainless steel and precipita-
tion hardened stainless steels (including Armco 17-4 pH or 15-5 pH) may be used
in situations where corrosion resistance is required. Austenitic stainless steels,
monel, and aluminum, although somewhat limited in their application, are used in
some special cases. Figure 200-63 identifies the chemical analysis of various
impeller materials. Figure 200-64 provides a listing of mechanical properties.
297 Coatings
Coatings are not widely used to improve corrosion or erosion resistance of
compressor internals. Problems include:
• surface preparation prior to coating
• maintenance of critical tolerances
• balancing coated components
• protection of coating during handling
• modification of established manufacturing procedures
Selection of compatible materials or material properties is generally the most prac-
tical approach.
Fig. 200-63 Chemical Analysis of Impeller Materials (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Fig. 200-64 Mechanical Properties of Impeller Materials (Courtesy of the Elliott Company)
Abstract
This section discusses engineering principles, types of reciprocating compressors,
configurations, and performance characteristics. It contains sufficient information
for understanding how to specify and apply reciprocating compressors including
auxiliaries and support systems.
Contents Page
310 Introduction
Section 100 provided general information and fundamental compression equations
applicable to all types of compressors. This section presents additional equations,
charts, and recommendations specifically related to reciprocating compressors. The
machinery covered is limited to crosshead compressors having power ratings from
approximately 150 to several thousand horsepower, with speeds ranging from 250
to 1000 RPM. With engineering judgment, much of the information presented can
be applied to machines with ratings below 150 HP and speeds to 1500 RPM.
The purpose of Section 300 is to provide information to assist the reader in:
• Making initial estimates of power consumption, number of stages, cylinder
sizing, and plot area for a proposed new compressor installation.
• Evaluating retrofits and modifications to re-rate existing compressors for new
service conditions.
• Troubleshooting performance problems occurring on existing equipment.
Figure 300-1 shows a cross-section of a typical single-cylinder (one crankthrow)
compressor, and includes the basic nomenclature that will be used throughout this
section.
Fig. 300-1 Typical Reciprocating Compressor (From Ingersoll-Rand Compressor Catalog, 1977. Courtesy of
Dresser-Rand)
where:
C = percent clearance
Vc = clearance volume, cubic inches
Vcyl = displacement volume, cubic inches
1
E v (theo.) = 100 – C r k – 1
---
(Eq. 300-2)
Fig. 300-2 Steps in the Cycle of a Reciprocating Compressor (From Compressors: Selection & Sizing, by Royce
Brown 1986 by Gulf Publishing Company, Houston, TX. Used with permission. All rights reserved.)
where:
P P
r = -----2- or -----d- = pressure ratio
P1 Ps
Cp
k = ------
Cv
1
Z ---
E v = 97 – F r – C -----s- r k – 1
Zd
(Eq. 300-3)
where:
Ev = volumetric efficiency, in percent
Zs = compressibility at suction conditions
Zd = compressibility at discharge conditions
F = 2.4 for mol. wt. < 10
= 1.4 for mol. wt. 10 to 30
= 1.0 for mol. wt. > 30.1
r = pressure ratio
Equation 300-3 is similar to the formula in the GPSA Handbook. The main differ-
ence is that F in Equation 300-3 adjusts for internal gas slippage which varies
inversely with molecular weight.
Mechanical Corrections to Ev
Equation 300-3 applies to lubricated cylinders. Non-lubricated cylinders have a
lower Ev due to greater piston-to-liner clearances, and other factors. For non-lube
applications, change the 97 in Equation 300-3 to 94.
Speed also affects Ev. Equation 300-3 applies to slower speed machines up to 600
RPM. For 1000 RPM machines, Ev is about 3% less, and the Ev determined from
Equation 300-3 should be multiplied by 0.97.
ICFM = Q = VdEv
(Eq. 300-4)
where:
Vd = displacement rate, CFM
Ev = volumetric efficiency expressed as a decimal.
Note When Ev appears in an equation, it is expressed as a decimal value, not a
percent.
(Refer also to Section 100, Equations 100-14 and 100-15 for other Q relationships.)
• Bhp/MMCFD - brake horsepower per million cubic feet per day (14.4 psia
and actual suction temperature)
• Bhp/MMSCFD - brake horsepower per million standard cubic feet per day
(14.7 psia and 60°F)
When the capacity is given in MMSCFD, it may be converted to MMCFD as
follows:
14.7 T s Z rc
MMCFD = MMSCFD ---------- --------
14.4 520 Z
- --------
o
(Eq. 300-5)
where:
Ts = Actual suction temperature, °R
Zrc = Compressibility at reference conditions of 14.4 psia and actual
suction temperature
Zo = Compressibility at 14.7 psia and 60°F
Z rc
Note -------
- can usually be taken as 1.0 with negligible error
Zo
If the capacity is given in SCFM, or pounds per minute, MMCFD can be calculated
as follows:
( SCFM )T Z rc
MMCFD = ----------------------------s -------
-
353 ,742 Z o
(Eq. 300-6)
wT s Z rc
MMCFD = ------------------
932 M
(Eq. 300-7)
where:
w = weight flow in lbs/minute
M = molecular weight
When the flow rate in MMCFD, and Bhp/MMCFD are known, brake horsepower
can be calculated from:
MMCFD can be converted to ICFM (inlet cubic feet per minute), or Q as follows
(bearing in mind that MMCFD is equal to 106 cubic feet/day):
14.4 Z s
Q = ( MMCFD ) ( 10 6 ) ---------- -------- --------------------------
day
P Z 1 ,440 min.
s rc
10 4 Z
= ( MMCFD ) -------- -------s-
P Z
s rc
(Eq. 300-9)
where:
Ps = Suction pressure in psia
(Notice that division of 14.4 by 1440 results in 1/100 which simplifies the arith-
metic, and it is for this reason that 14.4 psia is used as a convenient reference pres-
sure for MMCFD.)
Combining Equations 300-4, 300-8 and 300-9:
Bhp ( 10 4 )Z S
Q = V d E v = -------------------------------------------------------------
-
( Bhp ⁄ MMCFD )Z rc ( P s )
(Eq. 300-10)
where:
Vd = displacement rate, CFM
Ev = volumetric efficiency as a decimal
Note Zrc is often taken as 1.0 in Equations 300-9 and 300-10 as a simplifying
assumption. The error is usually small.
A number of formulas and charts have been developed over the years for deter-
mining Bhp/MMCFD. (Note that Bhp/MMCFD is often shortened to Bhp/MM.)
Most of the recently published charts and equations have been for large motor-
driven, low-speed, heavy-duty machines for critical refinery and chemical plant
services covered by API 618. These relationships are also generally applied to large
low-speed integral gas-engine compressors.
The Bhp/MM curves are used along with several correction factors to account for
specific gravity, low-inlet pressure, etc. Additional correcting factors are often
applied for smaller frames with higher speeds.
Computer programs have also been developed to calculate the theoretical horse-
power and power losses associated with specific types of valves, and mechanical
friction. The resulting power predictions are much more accurate than the Bhp/MM
curves and the correction factors, and the computer methods continue to be
improved. By the mid-1980's, the major manufacturers were using computer
methods on most applications.
The manufacturers consider their valve designs and loss factors to be proprietary,
and they are, therefore, not available. However, fairly good estimates can be made
using updated Bhp/MM curves or formulas with some corrections.
r = roa 1/n
(Eq. 300-12)
where:
roa = overall compression ratio
Equation 300-11 will also provide a rough estimate of horsepower for gases with
higher specific gravities or for lower stage compression ratios, with modification.
For specific gravities between 0.8 and 1.0 use a multiplication factor of 20 instead
of 22 in the equation. Likewise, use a factor of 16 to 18 for stage compression
ratios between 1.5 and 2.0.
k–1
r -----------
k – 1
-
46.9 Zs + Zd
----------------------- = ---------- -------------------------- ------------------
Bhp
MMCFD Z k–1 2
rc ------------
k
(Eq. 300-13)
where:
Cp
k = ------ at 14.7 psia and average compression temperature T s + Td
-----------------
-
Cv 2
Equation 300-13 includes a correction for a mechanical efficiency of 93%. (In other
words, if the compressor frame and cylinders had zero mechanical losses or 100%
mechanical efficiency, the 46.9 constant in Equation 300-13 would be 43.6.) The
93% is an arbitrary average. Actual mechanical efficiency can vary significantly
with machine selection. See Section 330, “Compressor Types and Performance
Characteristics.”
Figures 300-4, 300-5, and 300-6 are graphic representations of Equation 300-13,
less compressibility effects. These figures are similar to figures found in the GPSA
Handbook and other handbooks, and may be used instead of Equation 300-13 to
determine the uncorrected BHP/MMCFD.
Fig. 300-4 Basic Bhp/MM for Gas Compressors 150 HP and Above
Note: This chart applies to Class A machines, as defined in Figure 300-3, and also applies to Integral-
Engine Compressors. Refer to Sub-section 323 for further instructions, and for corrections to this chart
for specific gravity, moisture, and non-lubricated cylinders.
Fig. 300-5 Basic Bhp/MM for Gas Compressors 150 HP and Above
Note: This chart applies to Class A machines, as defined in Figure 300-3, and also applies to Integral-
Engine Compressors. Refer to Sub-section 323 for further instructions, and for corrections to this chart
for specific gravity, moisture, and non-lubricated cylinders.
Fig. 300-6 Basic Bhp/MM for Gas Compressors 150 HP and Above
Note: This chart applies to Class A machines, as defined in Figure 300-3, and also applies to Integral-
Engine Compressors. Refer to Sub-section 323 for further instructions, and for corrections to this chart
for specific gravity, moisture, and non-lubricated cylinders.
Corrections to Equation 300-13. There are several potential factors which may be
accounted for in order to obtain a more accurate horsepower estimate. See
Equation 300-20 for the total adjusted horsepower. The corrections are described as
follows.
Valve Loss Corrections. Valve losses tend to increase with increasing gas density.
Molecular weight (specific gravity) and inlet temperature affect density. These
effects can be taken into account with an addition to the basic Bhp/MM. For Class
A compressors, this correction is as follows:
4 ,320 ( SG )
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ---------------------------
T s Z rc
(Eq. 300-15)
When Specific Gravity < 1.0
3 ,624 ( SG ) + 696
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ------------------------------------------
T s Z rc
(Eq. 300-16)
The corrections in Equations 300-15 and 300-16 are appropriate for cylinders
having good valve flow characteristics. However, if the valves are not properly
selected for the compressor application, or if the machine's service conditions differ
significantly from the original design conditions, the corrections may not provide
an accurate prediction of compressor power. Excessive pressure pulsations can also
affect the accuracy of predictions.
Class B compressors, with higher speeds, often have higher valve losses. Methods
of predicting horsepower for Class B machines vary from simply adding 5% to the
Bhp/MM, regardless of the gas, to a set of additions related to specific gravity. The
latter method is the one used by the GPSA Handbook (Refer to the “References”
section of this manual).
While the GPSA method will provide fairly good predictions for average cases,
inlet temperature is not accounted for, and applications with higher pressure ratios
tend to be overcorrected. Corrections similar to those for low-speed compressors
are also available. Following are additions to the basic Bhp/MM which have been
used in the industry for Class B compressors:
6 ,027 ( SG )
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ---------------------------
T s Z rc
(Eq. 300-17)
(The correction calculated is applied in Equation 300-14.)
When Specific Gravity <1.0
5 ,672 ( SG ) + 335
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ------------------------------------------
T s Z rc
(Eq. 300-18)
Figures 300-7 and 300-8 may be used in place of Equations 300-15, 300-16,
300-17, and 300-18 for valve loss corrections for Class A and B machines. They
neglect compressibility effect (Zrc = 1).
Moisture Correction. When the gas being compressed contains water vapor, the
vapor content should preferably be included in the gas analysis. When it is
included, there is no need to correct the Bhp/MM for moisture. If it is not included,
a moisture correction should be made. The moisture correction is typically used in
air compressor calculations. The moisture correction factor is:
Ps
MF = ----------------
-
Ps – Pv
(Eq. 300-19)
where:
MF = Moisture correction factor
Ps = Suction pressure, psia
Pv = Vapor pressure of water at suction temperature (from steam
tables/charts).
The moisture factor must be calculated for each stage. After the first stage, it is
usually assumed that the gas is saturated (relative humidity = 100%) with water
vapor as it leaves the intercooler. Note that there will be water drop-out at each
intercooler.
Correction for Non-lubricated Cylinders. Another correction factor is applied
when the cylinders are not lubricated. The commonly used non-lube correction
factor (NLCF) is a multiplier of 1.05. This factor is widely accepted in the industry.
Although there is some evidence that a well-engineered non-lube design will only
require 1 - 2% more power, using 1.05 is recommended unless you know the correc-
tion should be less.
Fig. 300-7 Addition to Basic Bhp/MM to Correct for Valve Losses in Class A Compressors, as defined in
Figure 300-3.
Fig. 300-8 Addition to Basic Bhp/MM to Correct for Valve Losses in Class B Compressors, as defined in
Figure 300-3.
Total Corrected Power. The total adjusted Bhp/MM per stage is then:
Bhp
Total adjusted -----------
MM
k–1
------------
td = ( ts + 460 )r k – 460
(Eq. 300-21)
where:
ts and td are in Fahrenheit.
This equation is applicable for machines with ideal cylinder cooling, and may be
used as a first approximation for all applications. If more accurate estimates are
needed, refer to Section 360 of this manual, “Application and System Consider-
ations” where cylinder cooling and deviations from Equation 300-21 are discussed.
Refer to Figure 300-9 for a graphic representation of Equation 300-21.
Fig. 300-9 Theoretical Discharge Temperatures Single-Stage Compression (Read r to k to ts to td) (Courtesy of
GPSA)
k
t d + 460 ------------
r = ------------------- k – 1
t s + 460
(Eq. 300-22)
Figure 300-9 may also be used to find r (pressure ratio) corresponding to a given
discharge temperature limit.
Adding intercoolers to a centrifugal compressor tends to save horsepower. With
reciprocating compressors, however, there will seldom be any benefit in adding
intercoolers beyond those needed to maintain discharge temperature limits. The
reasons are: (1) reciprocating compressors are already highly efficient, and adding
an intercooler adds pressure drop which offsets the power savings, and (2) addition
of a stage requires additional cylinder(s), pulsation dampers, knockout drum and
piping.
The rod-load limit can affect the number of stages since the combined rod loading
is related to the differential pressure across the cylinder. Increasing the number of
stages obviously reduces the differential pressure of each stage. Quite often a rod
loading problem can be solved by using two cylinders for one compression stage. In
this case, the differential pressure would remain the same, but piston area, upon
which the differential pressure acts, would be reduced. Rod loading is covered in
further detail in Sub-section 350, “Selection Criteria.”
Sometimes a compressor application has more than one suction or discharge
pressure level. For example, in an oil field gas system, the compressor may take
different quantities of gas from the separator at two pressures, say 40 and 250 psig.
This machine could also be required to deliver a portion of the gas at 1000 psig for
gas lift, and the remainder at 2500 psig for injection back into the formation. In this
case, these pressures would set the interstage pressures so that the sidestreams are
accommodated. Note also that two stages might be required between the 40 and
250 psig levels (depending on suction temperature and k value) to stay below the
discharge temperature limits.
Allowable Working Pressure. Occasionally a given pressure ratio might be
achieved in one stage with satisfactory discharge temperature and rod loading, but
an actual cylinder does not exist to handle both the capacity (ICFM) and pressure.
In these situations, it is necessary to use two stages, or use two smaller single-stage
cylinders depending on hardware and economics.
Single-Acting
Cylinder displacement can be calculated:
π
V cyl = --- D 2 S = 0.785D 2 S
4
(Eq. 300-23)
where:
Vcyl = displacement, cubic inches
D = piston diameter, inches
S = stroke, inches
The displacement rate can be calculated:
π D 2 SN D 2 SN
V d = --- --------------- = ---------------
4 1 ,728 2 ,200
(Eq. 300-24)
where:
Vd = displacement rate, CFM
N = RPM
Double-Acting
Cylinder displacement is calculated:
( 2D 2 – d 2 )SN
V d = -----------------------------------
2 ,200
(Eq. 300-26)
( D 2 – d 2 )SN
V d = --------------------------------
1 ,100
(Eq. 300-28)
The percent clearance varies from about 8% to well over 30% among the many
classes of cylinders available. There is no rule of thumb to relate percent clearance
to diameter with much accuracy. However, for rough estimates use:
• 20% for diameters up to eight inches
• 15% for eight to 20 inches
• 12% in excess of 20 inches
The common approach to cylinder sizing is to make an educated guess at Ev, and
then solve for the displacement rate using Equation 300-4. Cylinder diameter can
then be calculated using Equations 300-24, 300-26, 300-28, as appropriate. This
approach may have to be repeated two or three times to arrive at a combination that
satisfies a given inlet flow quantity, Q.
As cylinder diameters do not come in an infinite number of increments, it is
customary to select the next largest increment. In multistage machines, depending
on the size of increments, oversizing of an initial stage is sometimes balanced by
slightly undersizing the subsequent stage, assuming the interstage pressure level is
not fixed (by a sidestream for example).
331 Types
There are two basic types of reciprocating compressors distinguished by the style of
piston and the linkage between the piston and crankshaft. One type covers the
lighter-duty machines having trunk-type (automotive-type) single-acting pistons
lubricated by crankcase oil, with no crossheads. These machines are typically used
for air compression to 125 psig, although cylinders are available for working pres-
sures to 6000 psig, for various gases. They operate at speeds in the range of 1200 to
1800 RPM and have ratings to about 125 HP. This type of machine is not often used
for petroleum gas service, therefore, it is not described further in this manual.
The other type of reciprocating compressor is a heavy-duty crosshead-type
machine where each piston is usually double-acting, and is connected to the
crankpin by a piston rod, crosshead, and connecting rod. The cylinders are lubri-
cated by a force-feed lubricator. Refer to Figure 300-1 for a cross-section of a
typical single-cylinder reciprocating compressor.
Crosshead-type machines may be categorized into four broad classes:
• Class A – API 618 type of heavy-duty process gas machine.
• Class B – Often called “separable,” are normally used in oil and gas field oper-
ations.
• Class C – Similar to Class A, but the frames are smaller. Used in both process
and oil field services.
usually small but can be as much as 10 - 15% if the parasitic loss is proportionally
high.
Bypassing, suction throttling, and varying speed are other means of capacity control
that are external to the compressor. These methods are occasionally used for recip-
rocating compressors. Speed control is available only on units with variable-speed
drivers, such as internal combustion engines.
Reciprocating compressor performance is usually presented in a tabulation of data
showing Bhp's and capacities for various pressure conditions and gas compositions.
Also, if there are clearance pockets or many unloading steps to accommodate
highly variable pressure conditions, curves may be furnished by the vendor (similar
to Figures 300-13 and 300-14).
Valve Losses
Figure 300-15 shows a PV diagram with an “ideal” valve system. Note that there is
no valve loss as shown in Figure 300-16. The valves open and close instantaneously
at the exact moment required.
However, in reality, it is virtually impossible to obtain an ideal PV diagram. In an
actual compressor cylinder, the valves do not open and close instantaneously; they
Fig. 300-13 Typical Performance with Fixed Clearance Fig. 300-14 Typical Performance with Variable Volume
Pocket on Head End of One Cylinder Clearance Pocket on Head of One Cylinder
may lag behind the optimum open or close timing, either due to weak or overly
strong springs. For example, if the springs are too stiff, the valve may not remain
fully open but will close prematurely. Real valves also present a restriction to flow
which, combined with any plates that do not open fully, could cause a greater pres-
sure drop across the valve, thus increasing the power consumption. In addition,
volumetric efficiency is reduced.
The compression efficiency of a cylinder depends largely on the valve losses. Manu-
facturers have made vast improvements in analytical techniques to optimize valve
design. Optimized valve designs have effected up to a 15% improvement in
Bhp/MM for some applications.
Figure 300-16 is a typical PV diagram showing valve losses. Suction and discharge
valve loss is represented by Areas A-F-E and B-C-D. The amount of loss is a func-
tion of the flow rate, drag coefficient and mass of the valve elements, valve-spring
stiffness, pressure drop, gas pulsations, effective valve flow area, and compressor
speed. Therefore, calculation of valve losses is not a straightforward process. It
requires a complex computer program with empirical factors related to each
specific valve design and cylinder.
Whenever possible, each cylinder should have at least two suction and two
discharge valves per end (four suction and four discharge valves total for a double-
acting cylinder). A greater number of valves will reduce the effect of a broken valve
on cylinder performance and rod loading. In some small bore cylinders, it may be
impossible to provide more than one suction and one discharge valve per end. If
this is the case, ask the vendor if clearance can be added to a larger cylinder with
more valves to achieve the same inlet capacity. In extreme cases, it may be possible
to reduce the stroke on a particular crank throw in order to utilize a larger cylinder.
Rod loading may be adversely affected, however.
288V
V = ---------------d-
A
(Eq. 300-29)
where:
V = average gas velocity, FPM
Vd = cylinder displacement rate, CFM
A = product of the actual lift, valve opening periphery, and the
number of suction valves per cylinder, Square Inches
Figure 300-17 shows the lift area in a plate type valve. The product of the actual lift
and valve periphery is the valve lift area. These values are furnished by the
compressor valve manufacturer. When the valve lift area is not the smallest area in
the valve flow path, the average inlet valve area is calculated on the basis of the
smallest area.
Note The 288 factor in the valve velocity formula in Paragraph 2.7.1 of API 618
is correct. For many years API, GPSA, and other references erroneously used a
constant of 144 in the formula. The 144 was wrong because the original formula
was based on all suction valves of a cylinder being open at the same time. Actually,
only half the valves are open at any given time in the cycle.
In reviewing bids for compressors, look for large differences in average valve veloc-
ities among the proposed machines. Small differences such as 5000 versus 6000
FPM are probably not significant. But if one vendor consistently quotes velocities
twice those of another vendor, find out why. Also, determine whether they are
quoting “average” or “effective” valve velocities.
Running Gear
The internal moving parts are often called the running gear. A typical set of
running gear is shown in Figure 300-18. Note that a balancing weight(s) (usually a
circular plate, not shown) can be added at the threaded end of the crosshead.
Lubrication of Running Gear. Lubrication is normally accomplished with a pres-
surized system using the sump of the compressor frame as the reservoir. API 618
describes requirements for the system components. Although many systems do not
necessarily meet the requirements of API 618, the diagram included in API 618
shows a typical system schematic arrangement.
Whether a single oil filter or duplex filters are to be furnished is usually a matter of
plant preference, based on the criticality of the service and number of machines
applied to the service. Unlike centrifugal-compressor systems, twin oil coolers are
seldom used in reciprocating compressor systems.
Splash type systems are sometimes used to lubricate the running gear of smaller
machines (200 HP or less).
Pistons
One-piece pistons are made of cast iron, or steel for small diameters and high-
differential pressures. They are also sometimes used when it is necessary to add
weight for balancing to reduce reciprocating shaking forces. (Figure 300-19 illus-
trates three styles of pistons.)
Two-piece designs are used for ease in casting and weight control. They are made
of aluminum or cast iron, and are generally applied for diameters above 10 inches.
Aluminum is used to reduce reciprocating mass.
The three-piece segmental design incorporates a ring carrier. They are used to
facilitate installation of rider rings (wear bands) which, when required, are placed
on each side of the carrier. In this way, the rider band can be thicker because it does
not have to be stretched over the outside diameter of the piston.
Another piston design worth mentioning is the labyrinth piston for non-lube
service. This piston has no rings, and is used only in vertical machines. It has a
large number of labyrinth grooves to limit blow-by. The blow-by is slightly more
than that of ringed pistons, but the advantage is in low piston maintenance. The
labyrinth compressor is manufactured only by Sulzer in Switzerland, and is used in
rather special services such as oxygen at relatively low pressures.
Piston-to-Rod Attachment
Rods are attached to pistons with a single extension of the rod through the piston
(see Figure 300-18), or with multiple through-bolts as shown in Figure 300-20. The
advantages of multiple bolts are:
1. The smaller bolts are much easier to accurately tension.
2. Adequate pre-stress levels are reliably maintained.
3. Loading by the bolts is more evenly distributed in the piston.
Fig. 300-20 Pistons with Multiple Thru-bolts (Courtesy of the Cooper Cameron Corporation.)
This feature is especially useful for large diameter aluminum pistons with large
diameter rods. Such pistons with the single through-bolt attachment sometimes
have nut-loosening problems after a number of temperature cycles. Factors contrib-
uting to this looseness are the difficulty of properly torquing one large nut, and
possible non-squareness of the nut's face with the piston surface.
Crankshafts
Crankshafts are one-piece forgings or castings, although provisions are usually
made for removable counterweights.
Reciprocating machines have two kinds of motion - rotational and reciprocating
(translational). In rotational motion, a rotating force is caused when there is an
unbalanced weight at some distance from the center of rotation. The imbalance
involved in the rotational motion of one crankthrow of the compressor consists of
the weights of the crankpin, crankshaft webs, and a portion (usually about 2/3) of
the connecting rod. Counterweights are sometimes used to compensate for the off-
centered weights of these components. (Figure 300-21 illustrates these terms.)
The components involved in translational motion are the piston, piston rod, cross-
head, and the remaining portion (usually about 1/3) of the connecting rod. A fluctu-
ating force results when these parts are accelerated and decelerated as the piston
travels back and forth.
For a single-cylinder compressor, the forces caused by both kinds of motion can be
resolved into two sets of forces, primary and secondary, acting both horizontally
and vertically.
Primary forces result from the rotational motion, and their frequency is that of
running speed. Secondary forces result from translational motion, and their
frequency is two times running speed due to the acceleration and deceleration
during each stroke of the piston. Secondary forces act only along the axis of the
cylinder.
Now, if a horizontally opposed compressor has two cylinders, a force couple can be
generated by the unbalanced force of each cylinder acting in opposite directions
and separated by the distance between the crankthrows. Figure 300-22 shows a
primary couple for a two-throw machine having equal reciprocating weights on
each throw. It also shows how counterweights can be added to the crank webs to
reduce the primary couple.
Pistons on opposite adjacent throws are often not of the same diameter, so their
weights are unequal. Figure 300-22 shows the location where a balance weight
could be added to equalize the reciprocating weights. Dissimilar piston materials
can also be used to equalize the weights.
It is seldom practical to fully compensate for forces and couples with counter-
weights and balance weights. The design becomes more complex where the
machine has more than two throws. The resultant magnitudes of the unbalanced
forces and couples, then, depend on:
• the number of throws,
• the angular orientation of the crankpins with respect to each other,
• the distance between the throws,
• the difference in reciprocating weights, and
• the amount of counterweighting that can be applied.
Figure 300-22 shows the simple case of a two-throw machine with a crankpin orien-
tation of 180 degrees. As the number of throws increases, the effect of crankpin
orientation on forces and couples gets quite complicated. Figure 300-23 qualita-
tively shows these effects for some of the more common crank arrangements with
equal and unequal reciprocating weights.
Selecting the best arrangement from Figure 300-23 is not always the complete
answer to the matter of shaking forces and couples. For example, for a four-throw
machine, the 180 degree “flat” crankshaft is obviously the best choice from the
standpoint of shaking forces and couples, and it eliminates the need for counter-
weights. However, the “flat” crankshaft causes all cylinders to be compressing at
the same time. Hence, the torque-effort diagram (see Section 100, Figure 100-35)
of the compressor may have undesirable oscillations from the standpoint of the
driver. The “flat” crankshaft might require the addition of a large flywheel effect to
the driver system, larger crankshaft diameter, and a special coupling to attenuate the
oscillations. Therefore, the 90-degree arrangement might be more economical for
an application that is not sensitive to shaking forces and couples. On the other hand,
if the application is offshore, or onshore with undesirable soil conditions, the “flat”
crankshaft will likely be the best choice.
A question that often arises concerns the number of main bearings. There are two
configurations in Figure 300-21. One has two main bearings and a common web
between the throws; the other has three main bearings, both for a two-throw crank-
shaft.
The advantage of the two-bearing design is that the throws are closer together, so
the magnitude of the couple is less than that of the three-bearing design. With the
three-bearing design, however, the crankshaft is more uniformly supported so that
shaft deflection and bending stresses are less than that of the two-bearing design.
The three-bearing arrangement has more places to attach counterweights to reduce
the primary couple, but can the added complexity be justified? Opinions vary, but
the fact remains that both designs are common, and both work.
Note that with a main bearing between each throw, the frame can have odd and
even numbers of throws. When two throws have a common web, only even
numbers of throws are possible.
Piston Rods
The piston rod (Figure 300-18) is a principal component in the running gear. The
primary design factor regarding piston rods is a phenomenon loosely called “rod
loading” described in detail in Sub-section 351. As the rod is subjected to high
alternating stresses (compressive and tensile), its surface finish must be extremely
smooth to avoid stress intensification, which could lead to fatigue failure. The
threads on the rod where it attaches to the crosshead are critical for the same reason.
For hardness and surface finish specifications for commonly used rod materials,
refer to API 618 and/or Section 800. For clean non-corrosive gas service, AISI-
Fig. 300-23 Effect of Crank Arrangements on Forces & Couples (typical only) (Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
4140 carbon steel is a typical rod material. For this material, guidelines for the
allowable stress at the root area of the threads at the crosshead are:
Thread Type Stress, psi
Cut 6000
Cut-and-ground 7500
Rolled 8000
The finger type suction valve unloader (Item C of Figure 300-24) is applied to all
suction valves on a cylinder end. This type is sometimes called a “suction valve
depressor”. When actuated, the fingers push down on the suction valve plate(s), and
hold them open. Again, the gas flows back to suction during the compression stroke.
The plug-type tends to be more reliable than the finger-type. Valve plate failure can
be caused by the concentrated loads where the fingers push on the plate. The disad-
vantage of using plug-type unloaders is that there is less overall available valve area
in the cylinder, resulting in higher valve losses.
One European compressor valve manufacturer markets a “stepless” controller for
their valve unloaders. In this scheme, the finger type unloader holds the suction
valve plate open for a specific length of time corresponding to the desired capacity.
Since the suction valves are not allowed to close at the normal time (at or near
bottom dead center), in effect, the displacement of that end of the cylinder is
reduced. Therefore, it is theoretically possible to provide an infinite number of
capacity steps depending on valve timing.
The stepless system has been applied to quite a few installations in Europe, but it
has not gained much favor in the domestic petroleum applications due to its
complexity. One USA manufacturer offers a similar stepless control system, but it
is typically applied only to storage (pump-in, pump-out) compressors having contin-
ually varying suction and discharge pressures.
There are two kinds of clearance devices: clearance pockets and clearance
spacers. Pockets can be fixed or variable volume. (Figure 300-25 shows examples
of fixed and variable volume pockets.) Fixed volume pockets can be either manu-
ally or pneumatically (air or gas) operated.
Variable volume pockets are normally only manually operated. Hydraulic actua-
tion has been tried, but the results have generally been unfavorable. Variable
volume pockets are applied only to the head end of a cylinder, because it is physi-
cally impossible to locate them on the crank end. Occasionally, variable-volume
pockets may be capable of more adjustment than required for the load step.
Opening the pocket too far can cause overheating problems because the volumetric
efficiency becomes too low. External mechanical stops can be installed to limit
handwheel travel to the length required in the capacity control design.
Fixed volume pockets are normally applied to the head end for the same reason,
although fixed pockets can be applied to suction valve caps on either the head or
crank ends. Fixed-clearance pockets often look like an ell-shaped piece of pipe,
pointed upwards to prevent liquid accumulation. This type of pocket can be
installed by the manufacturer, or as a field retrofit.
Valve cap pockets require a special suction valve with an opening at the center of
the seat so that the pocket volume is in direct communication with the cylinder's
interior when the pocket is opened. Installation of valve cap pockets on discharge
valves is not recommended because of the possibility of collection of oil or liquids
in the pockets.
Clearance spacers are sometimes used to increase the clearance volume. A spacer
can be installed between the cylinder head and cylinder body. Also, a compressor
valve can be designed with a two-piece yoke (hold-down for valve). By using one
piece of the yoke as a spacer, the valve seat and guard can be moved farther away
from the cylinder bore, thus increasing the clearance. A shutdown is required to
change clearance with spacers.
D. Manual fixed volume clearance pocket E. Pneumatically operated fixed volume clearance pocket
(Courtesy of Dresser-Rand) for valve cap
(Courtesy of the Cooper Cameron Corporation)
Compressor Valves
Valves are manufactured by the original equipment manufacturer (OEM), and by
non-OEM suppliers. The compressor will almost always be supplied with OEM
valves, but non-OEM valves are often retrofitted to solve a particular problem, or
when a unit is re-rated. Occasionally, non-OEM valves are specified on new
machines to match existing equipment or to solve known problems. For more infor-
mation on various types of compressor valves, see Section 354.
Compressor Cylinders
Cylinder design is dependent mainly on the working pressure and diameter range.
Cylinder bodies can be castings of gray iron, nodular (ductile) iron, or steel. Forged
and fabricated steel cylinders are also available for higher pressures. Figure 300-26
shows a variety of cylinders. All of these cylinders have liners. Many of the cylin-
ders offered for high-speed compressors (Class B and D) do not have liners.
Note that cylinders are available in the tandem arrangement having two sizes of
pistons. This rather uncommon arrangement allows two cylinders to be placed on
one crankthrow. Usually both pistons are single-acting, but in some designs only
one of the two will be double-acting.
Non-lube Cast Iron Cylinder with Two-compartment Distance Piece for Medium Pressure
(Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Fig. 300-27 Piston Rings and Rider Rings (Courtesy of the Cooper Cameron Corporation)
Piston Rings
Rider Rings
The “angle” cut is generally preferred, and is the most commonly used. For smaller
lower-pressure cylinders, the “step” cut is used, although care must be taken in the
design to avoid joint breakage. The “seal” cut provides the best seal, but is more
expensive.
Pressure in the cylinder acts on the piston rings, and assuming that the ring does
some sealing, there will be a pressure drop from one side of the ring to the other.
This pressure difference results in a net “pressure induced force” holding the ring
against the side of the piston groove and outward against the cylinder bore (refer to
Figure 300-28).
Fig. 300-28 Pressure Induced Forces Acting on a typical Compression Piston Ring (Courtesy of the ASME)
Figures 300-29 through 300-31 provide some typical dimension ranges for piston
rings and piston clearance. The latter is governed mainly by the coefficient of
thermal expansion of the piston material. In general, the ring should not protrude
from the piston groove by more than 25% of its thickness.
Rider rings and piston rings are almost always of the same material. Rider rings
must be designed so that they do not act as a piston ring. Otherwise, wear will
occur too rapidly. Solid rider rings are not prone to outward expansion, but cut rider
rings must be vented with holes or slots to bleed off pressure. Figure 300-32 and
Figure 300-33 are examples of typical thicknesses for solid and cut rider rings
versus cylinder diameter.
Rider-ring width is determined by the bearing pressure. Figure 300-34 shows piston
ring and rider ring arrangements on the rider ring. The bearing pressure is generally
limited to five psi for PTFE in non-lube services and 10 psi for lubricated cylinders
(see API 618). These pressures are based on the weight of the piston plus one-half
the weight of the rod divided by 0.87 DW (where D is the piston diameter, and W is
the width of all rider rings on the piston).
Fig. 300-32 Compilation Band-type (Solid) Rider Rings Radial Thickness (Courtesy of the ASME)
Fig. 300-33 Compilation Joined (Cut) Rider Ring Radial Thickness (Courtesy of the ASME)
Fig. 300-34 Typical Arrangements for Piston & Rider Rings (Courtesy of the ASME)
Packing
On double-acting cylinders (and some single-acting), the piston rod must be sealed
to reduce gas leakage from inside the cylinders. This seal is called pressure
packing. It is of the full-floating design so that the packing rings follow any lateral
motion of the piston rod.
As with piston rings, PTFE is used extensively for packing rings. Figure 300-35
shows the forces on a packing ring. Figure 300-36 shows a typical arrangement of
packing rings. The back-up ring limits deformation of the packing ring, and is
usually not required below 500 psi. The back-up ring is sometimes made of bronze
for better heat dissipation.
Fig. 300-35 Pressure Induced Forces Acting on a Typical Packing Ring (Courtesy of the ASME)
Fig. 300-36 Typical Radial Cut & Tangent Cut Packing Sets with Back-up Ring (Courtesy of the ASME)
Packing cases with vent and buffer arrangements are shown in the Appendix of API
618. Figure 300-37 shows a packing case with passages for coolant. Guidelines for
when cooled packing is applied are included in the text of API 618 (also see Specifi-
cation CMP-MS-1626).
Fig. 300-37 Pressure Packing Case with Coolant Passages (Courtesy of the ASME)
Wiper packing is also shown on the diagrams in API 618. The purpose of this
packing is to minimize leakage of crankcase oil.
Distance Pieces
The distance piece (refer to Figure 300-1) separates the cylinder from the cross-
head guide (doghouse). It provides a housing for both wiper packing and pressure
packing. The distance piece prevents entry of compressed gas into the crankcase,
and provides access for maintenance of the packing and piston rod.
Four types of distance pieces (with corresponding diagrams) and their applications
are covered in API 618. Vent and purge connections are shown on the API 618
diagrams. Further information on venting and purging is provided in Section 360,
“Application and System Considerations.”
Bearings
Main and connecting rod bearings for the larger heavy-duty frames are split-
sleeve precision insert type (refer to Figure 300-18). The most common materials
are cast iron/babbitt or steel/babbitt. Occasionally, aluminum bearings are used.
Aluminum bearings require better oil filtration as they are sensitive to dirt.
Although sleeve bearings are the most common, API 618 allows rolling-element
(anti-friction) main bearings for Class A machines up to a rating of 200 HP. Rolling-
element bearings are used in some Class B machines for ratings in excess of 1000
HP.
Refer to the General Machinery Manual for additional information on both types of
bearings.
Fig. 300-38 Cylinder Arrangements Used for Various Reciprocating Compressors. Dots on Connecting Rods Indicate
Crossheads (From Hydraulics Pnematics, “Air Compressors, Conditioning, Costs and the Crunch” ed.
N.R. Stull 1976)
Fig. 300-39 Low-Speed Horizontally-Opposed Compressor (From Compressed Air & Gas Data ed. by A.W. Loomis
1982 by Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Fig. 300-41 A “V”-angle Arrangement of an Internal Gas-engine Driven Compressor (From Compressed Air & Gas
Data ed. by A.W. Loomis 1982 by Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
API 618 gives definitions for the terms “combined rod loading,” “gas load,”
“inertia force,” and “rod reversal.” Combined rod loading is the important term as
it is the net effect of gas and inertia loading. Rod reversal occurs when the force on
the rod changes from tension to compression, or vice versa. It is a critical lubrica-
tion factor for the crosshead pin and bushing. If there is no reversal, the pin and
bushing surfaces do not separate; hence, oil is prevented from lubricating these
surfaces. This can result in catastrophic damage to the crosshead, connecting rod,
bushing, and crosshead pin.
Frame loading is the result of reaction forces from the gas-pressure resultant
forces. Frame loading stresses static items such as crosshead guides, distance
pieces, the frame itself, and the bolting between these items.
Rod loading is somewhat of a misnomer in some cases. A manufacturer's adver-
tised maximum allowable continuous rod load (MACRL) rating is based on the
weakest link in the running gear/frame system. The piston rod is not always the
weakest link. It may be the crosshead pin or bushing, for example.
Years ago, quite often only gas loads were considered in evaluating proposed
compressors. In most cases, a quick comparison of gas loading with the MACRL
was adequate. But occasionally, inertia forces augmented the gas loading at certain
crank angles so that the MACRL was exceeded.
Rod reversal becomes a problem at low pressure ratios. It can also be a problem at
high-pressure ratios for single-acting cylinders, half loaded cylinders, or when the
bore of double-acting cylinders is not much larger than the piston rod. Tail rods can
be used to alleviate the latter situation.
Figure 300-43 shows gas, inertia, and combined loading for pressure ratios of 4.00
and 1.05. The 4.00 ratio examples show the maximum combined loading is less
than the gas loading (the inertia force helped the situation). Such is not always the
case, however. It depends on the differential pressures throughout the stroke, and
the weights of the reciprocating parts. It is impossible to provide a “rule of thumb”
for this phenomenon.
Figure 300-43 also illustrates a cylinder with a very low pressure ratio (1.05). In
this case, the maximum combined load is greater (negative) than either the gas or
inertia loads. Also the combined load only reversed for 15-20 degrees of crankshaft
rotation. (Note that API 618 suggests a minimum of 15 degrees of reversal).
Figure 300-44 shows the ideal reversal (see dark areas labeled “A”) at the crosshead
pin.
A subtlety often overlooked is that the actual differential pressure that exists at a
certain crank angle inside the cylinder is higher than the theoretical differential
pressure. Refer to Figure 300-15 and note that the vertical distance between points
C and F is significantly greater than discharge minus suction pressure. Pressure
pulsations can make matters worse. It should be noted that, at any one instant, the
upper part of the diagram in Figure 300-15 would correspond to the head end,
while the lower part would correspond to the crank end.
When purchasing new compressors, you should insist that the vendor make a study
of combined rod loading versus crank angle using internal cylinder pressures with:
(1) normal operating conditions, and (2) with any broken valve, with relief valve
setting as discharge pressure. Refer to CMP-MS-1626 and CMP-MS-4735.
Calculated gas loads can be very misleading, but sometimes they can be used as a
preliminary index to estimate the frame size or number of cylinders per stage.
These calculations can be made using pressures at the cylinder flanges and the full
area of the piston on the head end and the net area (piston area minus rod area) for
the crank end. Loading should be calculated for tension and compression. When
one end of a cylinder is unloaded, that end will have suction pressure in it at any
crank angle.
See Equations A-6, and A-7 (Appendix A) for calculating gas loads.
Piston Speed
Average piston speed is an index of the rubbing speed and wear of the piston and its
rings. Average piston speed, in feet per minute (FPM), may be calculated with the
following formula:
A.P.S. = SN/6
(Eq. 300-30)
where:
S = stroke in inches
N = RPM
For critical service heavy-duty Class A compressors, a speed limit of 360 RPM is
recommended. The average piston speed should be limited to about 860 FPM for
lubricated machines, and 700 FPM for non-lubricated machines.
Class B, high-speed machines used in medium- to light-duty applications in the oil
field typically have upper limits of 1000 RPM. Machines will work at these levels,
but significant improvement in reliability can be achieved by running these units at
900 RPM or slower. Although the slower speeds result in larger cylinder sizes and
increased rod loading, this disadvantage is usually overbalanced by the reduced
wear.
Plate Valves
Figure 300-45 shows a typical plate valve. This type of valve is actuated by unbal-
anced pressures on either side of the valve. The valve plates or elements are held
against the ports in the valve seat by spring force. The gas pressure overcomes the
spring force, the elements lift away from their seats and stop against the guard,
opening the valve.
Concentric Ring Valves. The plate valve shown in Figure 300-45 is a concentric
ring valve. This type of valve can be fitted with plastic elements, which is an advan-
tage in corrosive services. The concentric ring valve can be used over the widest
range of compressor applications and can withstand the most extreme operating
conditions. Concentric ring valves have been used for pressures as high as 60,000
psi with differential pressures greater than 10,000 psi and temperatures in excess of
500°F.
Ported Plate Valves. Ported plate valves are very similar to concentric ring valves
except that the individual rings are joined to form one or two larger plates. Their
chief advantages are ease of manufacture and simpler assembly. Ported plate valves
are used primarily for high speed gas field compressors. Ported plate valves are
shown in Figure 300-46.
Strip Valves. Strip valves include channel and flexible element valves. They are
used primarily for air service, either lube or nonlube. A disadvantage is that they
cannot be used with plastic elements and are therefore not very tolerant of dirt or
liquids in the gas stream. They have good flow areas and are relatively inexpensive.
The maximum discharge pressure for these valves is about 1,500 psi. The highest
recommended operating temperature is 350°F and the maximum pressure differen-
tial is approximately 500 psi. Strip valves may be used in compressors with rotating
speeds up to 1,800 rpm.
One type of strip valve, called a “feather” by the original manufacturer, employs a
single component to serve as the sealing element and the return spring. Application
of the feather valve is generally limited to operating pressures less than 1000 psi,
differential pressures no greater than 400 psi, and maximum temperatures of 350°F.
A feather valve is shown in Figure 300-47.
Fig. 300-46 Ported Plate Valves (Courtesy of Dresser- Fig. 300-47 Feather Valves (From Compressed Air &
Rand) Gas Data ed. by A.W. Loomis 1982 by
Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Another type of strip valve, called a channel valve, is shown in Figure 300-48.
Poppet Valves. Poppet valves have an effective lift area approximately 50% greater
than that provided by the same size concentric ring valve. Poppet valves can operate
with lifts as great as 1/4 inch and are used extensively in the natural gas transmis-
sion industry. They have recently been applied in other process applications such as
carbon dioxide injection for tertiary oil recovery. By design, they add built-in clear-
ance, which causes a capacity penalty, especially with high specific heat gases.
The poppet valve utilizes a mushroom-shaped element made from a variety of mate-
rials. The sealing element material determines the range of application. Valves with
metallic poppets can withstand pressures up to 3000 psi and temperatures to 500°F.
However, metallic poppets are seldom used due to inertial effects.
Fig. 300-48 Channel Valve (From Compressed Air & Fig. 300-49 Poppet Valve
Gas Data ed. by A.W. Loomis 1982 by
Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand)
Nonmetallic poppets are limited to 450°F and 800 psi, with compressor speeds up
to 1,800 rpm. Typically NYLON, TORLON, and now PEEK are used for the
poppet material because of their light weight and conformability to the valve seat.
Several OPCOs are using poppet valves with good success. Figure 300-49 shows a
poppet valve.
Valve Motion
The motion of valve elements during the compressor cycle are affected by two
forces, as shown in Figure 300-50. The first is an aerodynamic force due to flow of
gas around the element. The second is the spring force resisting this aerodynamic
force.
Plate or strip motion affects compressor performance and reliability. Not only must
the valve open and close at the correct time, but it must open completely and seal
tightly upon closing. In addition to being able to open fully and close completely,
the valve element must not strike the seat or guard with excessive force, or short
valve life will result.
Each valve is a damped spring/mass system with natural frequency. If the natural or
resonant frequency is forced by some driving frequency, such as the pulsations from
the compressor pistons, rapid cycling of the valve element will occur. The element
generally bounces between the guard and the seat. This is commonly called
“flutter”. Flutter can greatly reduce the life of springs and valve elements.
The manufacturer modifies the valve lift to suit the gas specified. For example, an
air compressor might be furnished with a lift of .100 inches. The same compressor
valve applied in a low mole weight service such as hydrogen, might use a lift of
.032 inches.
The problem with a higher lift valve in the hydrogen service is that hydrogen lacks
the damping properties of air. As a result, the valve elements would experience high
impact forces and might bounce. Broken valve elements might result.
Fig. 300-50 Forces Acting on a Valve Plate Fig. 300-51 Gas Damped Valve Plate
Another type of damping, mass damping, is used in the “damped plate” design. A
disk ported the same as the valve element is attached to the valve element, usually
at its center. This damping plate adds inertia to the valve element and therefore
retards the impact velocities of the valve element against the guard and seat. This
type of damping is useful for high speed compressors where valve velocities are
high. It is also more desirable than gas damping, where the gas stream is dirty or
heavily lubricated. A damped plate valve is shown in Figure 300-52.
Most vendors have computer programs that mathematically model valve element
motion, aerodynamic drag coefficients, and flow through the valves during the
compression cycle. These programs assess the valve dynamics and optimize the
design in terms of lift, spring stiffness, and the damping for a specific application.
The programs have a fairly good record of success, and continue to be improved
with time. Figure 300-54 shows the results of a typical computer analysis (note the
greatly reduced valve flutter).
If practical, before purchasing, have the vendor run a computer study for new
machines, or for any valve upgrades planned for existing machines. It is highly
recommended to discuss actual field experience with users of any particular type of
valve proposed. Avoid valves which are not being used in similar services.
355 Drivers
Figure 300-55 presents a generalized curve of speed versus horsepower for Class A
machines based on one vendor's experience. Figure 300-56 shows the distribution
of driver types for Class A compressors, again based on one vendor's experience.
Refer to the Driver Manual for detailed application information, and use the
following general comments for any preliminary work:
1. Synchronous motors are 3-4% more efficient than induction motors of the
same speed, and usually offer power factor improvement for the electrical
system. High-efficiency induction motors should not be used with recipro-
cating compressors, because the oscillating torque causes excessive heat.
Rather, use standard induction motors.
2. Steam and combustion gas turbines can be applied to reciprocating compres-
sors, although it is not a frequent practice (see Figure 300-57). A torsional anal-
ysis is essential to be certain the train will not operate close to a torsional
critical speed.
3. Spark-ignited gas engines are available to drive Class B machines up to about
2000 HP at 900-1000 RPM.
4. Belt-drive systems can be used up to about 200 HP.
357 Noise
Noise data must be obtained from the vendor. Compressor vendors generally cannot
meet the 85 dbA noise limit recommended in many Company specifications. They
usually guarantee 90 dbA. Acoustic treatment may be required if it is necessary to
meet 85 dBA.
Fig. 300-57 Typical Turbine Drive (Courtesy of Dresser- Fig. 300-58 Typical Efficiency Reciprocating Process
Rand) Compressors—Hydrogen (Courtesy of
Dresser-Rand)
Fig. 300-59 Gas Temperature Rise Characteristics for Operation with Thermally Circulated Coolant and Dry Jackets
(From Compressed Air & Gas Data ed. by A. W. Loomis 1982 by Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-
Rand)
The coolant inlet temperature should be at least 10°F above the suction temperature
to prevent condensation. The coolant temperature-rise across each cylinder should
be at least 10°F, but no more than 20°F.
The following relationships should be treated as guidelines. They will not provide
exact answers for all applications. Consult the vendor if it is necessary to know the
discharge temperature more accurately.
The average gas and coolant temperatures affect the actual discharge temperature of
cylinders with forced cooling. If the average gas temperature less the average
coolant temperature is between 50°F - 60°F, the discharge temperature should be
close to that predicted by Equation 300-25. For other temperature differentials,
refer to Figure 300-60 to determine an estimate of the deviation from adiabatic
discharge temperature.
Two other types of cooling systems are applied to cylinders: thermosyphon and no
coolant circulation (static filled jackets). Refer to API 618 for criteria to apply
these systems. Figure 300-61 gives temperature relationships for these systems.
Fig. 300-60 Gas Temperature Rise Characteristics with Forced Coolant Circulation
Fig. 300-61 Gas Temperature Rise Characteristics for Operation with Thermally Circulated Coolant and Dry Jackets
Fig. 300-62 Crosshead Pedestal Sole Plate (Courtesy of the Cooper Cameron Corporation)
Many Class B units are typically skid-mounted. In this case, the frame is mounted
on a base plate, and the base plate is grouted to the foundation. When the base plate
becomes quite large, sole plates are sometimes used under the base plate.
Except for very small units, epoxy grout is recommended for reciprocating
machines. Although more expensive than cementatious grout, epoxy grout has
superior strength, is oil-resistant, and has negligible shrinkage. Some cementatious
grouts include an additive that expands during the curing process to reduce
shrinkage. However, this process has been unreliable in many cases, and the grout
deteriorates with constant exposure to lube-oil. One recommended rule-of-thumb is
to use epoxy grout on all reciprocating machines rated at 500 HP or more, or that
weigh 5000 pounds or more.
Where there is any possibility of liquid condensation, the suction lines should be
heat-traced. A second line of defense is to include a liquid separation chamber in
the pulsation damper (see API 618). Pulsation dampers can be heat-traced with a
“plate coil” for steam, or with electrical heaters. Bayonet heaters can also be
supplied.
The distance between the pulsation damper and the compressor cylinder should be
held to a minimum.
It used to be common practice to install intercoolers on top of the compressor cylin-
ders. Each cooler would span across two cylinders, with pulsation-damping volume
built into the coolers. This arrangement made a compact installation, but provided
little defense against liquids, and compromised maintenance access. It also required
that the suction valves of one of the two cylinders be placed in the undesirable loca-
tion on the bottom of the cylinder. Currently, on-compressor mounting of coolers is
no longer used, except perhaps for bone-dry gases.
Piping design should be analyzed to assure that forces and moments exerted on the
cylinder flanges are within the vendor's tolerances. Cold springing should not be
allowed. (Cold springing is forcing pipe to the machine in a cold condition in order
to afford relieved stresses as the pipe heats to operating temperature.)
When the pressure ratio is quite low (less than approximately 1.7) the volume of the
clearance pocket becomes very large. The actual volume is dependent on the piston
displacement and “k” value of the gas. Refer to the formula for volumetric effi-
ciency. Also, API 618 recommends that volumetric efficiency remain above 40%
since performance prediction is generally unreliable below that value. (However,
values as low as 25% have been used when less precise capacity control is accept-
able.)
Note also that when the cylinder bore is not much larger than the piston rod,
unloading the crank end of the cylinder results in a capacity reduction much less
than 50%.
Three-step (100%, 50%, 0%) capacity control is used on some general purpose
machines such as air compressors. Three-step control requires more cyclic actua-
tion of the unloaders than five-step control. Therefore, three-step control is more
detrimental to machine components (particularly valves).
When precise capacity turndown is required, a bypass with a control valve is neces-
sary. Depending on the system requirements, the bypass may only be across the
first stage. But, more often the bypass spills back across all stages unless the differ-
ential pressure is too high to be handled by a single control valve. The take-off
point for the bypass must be downstream of a heat exchanger so that cooled gas
will be spilled back to the suction. If there is no exchanger in the discharge, the
bypass must branch into the suction line upstream of an exchanger. Alternatively, a
cooler may be placed in the bypass line. In any case, the bypass should tie-in
upstream of a suction knockout drum so that any condensate resulting from the
expansion cannot enter the compressor.
When a bypass is used in combination with step control, five-step operation is more
efficient than three-step operation.
373 Instruments
Loadless Starting
Most motor-driven compressors are equipped with suction valve or plug-type
unloaders on both ends of all cylinders on the frame to permit loadless starting.
Loadless starting is not mandatory, but facilitates startup, and reduces disturbance
in the electrical system. It is also a convenient and less punishing feature for all
types of drivers.
Refer to the Driver Manual for recommended alarm and shutdown parameters for
drivers.
If a vibration detection device is used on the frame, an accelerometer type detector
is recommended to provide continuous measurement. Ball-and-seat or magnetic-
type switches are unreliable. Consult the vendor regarding the best location for the
device. Sometimes it is necessary to install two devices (one for transverse vibra-
tion, and one for axial vibration).
Note that whatever alarms and shutdowns are chosen, it is important to make sure
they are installed with facilities to allow testing.
Gages
Location of the gages is generally a matter of plant preference. They can be
mounted locally on the compressor or piping, or mounted in a local panel. Gages
mounted on the compressor or attached piping may be subject to vibration. Check
with plant operating and maintenance personnel regarding the best location for
these gages. (Figure 300-64 is a typical list of gages.)
Monitoring
Monitoring systems of the continuous type are not widely used on reciprocating
compressors. However:
Eutectic bearing temperature safety devices are available for main and connecting
rod bearings. These devices are spring-loaded and they vent control air to alarm or
shut down the unit when high temperature melts the eutectic material. At one large
Company installation, such devices prevented a major failure. Main bearing thermo-
couples or RTD's are also available.
One device that is gaining more acceptance is a rod-drop monitor. This device can
be a eutectic sensor that melts when rubbed by the rod allowing a signal to be trans-
mitted for alarm or shutdown. This function can also be accomplished with a prox-
imity probe.
Various lubricator flow and drive failure sentries are also available for cylinder and
packing lubricator systems.
380 Foundations
This sub-section provides a basis for establishing the dynamic forces to be used by
civil engineers in foundation design calculations. Soil mechanics, natural frequency
calculations, bearing pressure, concrete strength, and other design factors are not
covered here. Refer to the Civil and Structural Manual for such information. Foun-
dations, anchor bolts, and grouting are discussed in the General Machinery
Manual, and Sub-section 366 of this manual.
In addition to knowing the dimensions and weights of the machinery to be
supported, engineers designing the foundation must know the magnitude, direction,
and frequency of the dynamic forces that the machinery will exert on the founda-
tion.
The importance of foundations to a compressor installation cannot be overem-
phasized. Foundations attenuate vibratory forces generated by the machinery, and
reduce transmission of these forces to the surrounding plant and equipment. Foun-
dations also keep the machinery in alignment.
To perform these essential functions throughout the life of the installation, the foun-
dation must be sized to support the weight of the machinery while imposing a toler-
able bearing pressure on the soil or structure. It must be properly designed so that
the system, consisting of the foundation, soil, machinery, and piping, is not at or
Other Considerations
Any natural frequency of the foundation should be at least 30% above or below the
primary and secondary frequencies. For instance, on a 450 RPM unit, ideally any
natural frequency should not be anywhere in the range of 315 to 1170 cycles per
minute (cpm). Sometimes it is impractical to keep natural frequencies out of a
range that wide. Accordingly, it may be possible to place a natural frequency
between the primary and secondary frequencies. A natural frequency in the range
of 585-630 cpm would satisfy the criterion of 30% separation margins in the above
example.
For reciprocating units, as a rule of thumb, the weight of the foundation should be a
minimum of five times the combined weight of the frame, cylinders, and driver.
Design Approaches
Numerous approaches are currently employed to avoid excessive vibrations that can
occur in the connected piping, instrumentation, etc. These include:
1. Relying on vendors to design and supply adequate suppression dampers along
with the compressor, without stating any specifications. Vendors may use
digital calculations or proprietary empirical correlations. This is normally 5-
7% of line pressure peak-to-peak pulsation at the bottle outlet unless otherwise
specified.
2. Relying on vendors to design and supply suppression dampers, based on a spec-
ified maximum pulsation amplitude at the outlet of the damper. The specified
pulsation may be 1-5% of line pressure and determined by estimating pulsation
affects on the piping system.
3. Specifying the size of pulsation dampers based on empirical correlations
within the Company.
4. Specifying that the vendor obtain an analog study of the pulsation dampers and
associated piping, for machines not specified by API 618.
5. Specifying one of the three design approaches as outlined in API 618, as
summarized below.
Most manufacturing and many producing locations employ analog studies (from
SWRI) when purchasing new equipment. These studies are expensive, however,
and may not always be appropriate. Analog studies have the disadvantage of not
being very flexible. If changes in piping, vessels, or operating conditions are made
after the analog study, the entire analog must be redone at additional cost. For
example, Warren Petroleum, which employs a large inventory of integral and high-
speed separable compressors used in varying applications, uses all of the previous
approaches, as they determine to be applicable.
API 618 thoroughly specifies the requirements for pulsation suppression devices in
terms of pressure drop, pulsation level, and mechanical design. Three design
approaches are listed in API 618:
Design Approach-1 does not include a simulation study. Empirical factors and
experience are applied, and everyone involved hopes for the best.
Design Approach-2 calls for a simulation study which reveals the pulsation ampli-
tudes and frequencies, but does not predict how much the piping is going to vibrate.
Design Approach-3 is an extension of Design Approach 2 where the structural
design of the piping is reviewed to determine its vibration tendency with respect to
excitation by the gas pulsations.
Some compressor and damper vendors have digital computer programs to simulate
compressor systems. They are faster, and may be less expensive than analog
studies, and have proven to be reliable. Digital programs also have the advantage of
saving a file which can be easily modified when changes are made.
The Company is a member of the SGA-SWRI program for analog simulation.
Many systems have been successfully analyzed for the Company using SWRI's
services. For large, critical projects, it is recommended that SWRI continue to do
this analytical work, because although digital programs have some advantages,
SWRI has the overwhelming amount of simulation experience.
Moisture Removal
In many reciprocating compressor installations the pulsation dampers have integral
moisture removal sections to provide a final line of defense against liquid carryover.
There are two schools of thought. Pulsation dampers can be designed with these
moisture removal sections, or they can be designed so that liquids positively cannot
collect. Most refinery pulsation dampers have moisture removal sections. Many oil
field dampers do not have moisture removal sections.
Designing pulsation dampers without moisture removal sections takes great care
when the damper includes internals for pulsation attenuation (choke tube and
baffle). The baffle needs to have a hole at the bottom to prevent liquid from accumu-
lating on either side. However, a hole in the baffle can make the damper less effec-
tive as an acoustic filter. The way around this is to design the damper with an
additional choke tube at the bottom of the damper and acoustically model the
damper in this configuration. Another problem is the lip created by the nozzle
projecting into the bottle. Figure 300-65 illustrates the design aspects.
Additional Notes
Some have questioned the bottle-sizing equation in API 618, and would prefer to
use other, less-expensive procedures. Nevertheless, the API equation is based on a
combination of theory and statistics, and is recommended as a conservative prac-
Note: The very nature of pulsations cause aerosols and particles to agglomerate within the bottle. A path
should be provided to keep the bottom of the bottle clean and dry.
tice. If an exact equation were available, acoustical simulation studies would not be
needed.
Note that for pulsation control, bigger is generally better. On the other hand, there
can be interference problems and access to cylinders can be limited. There is a
point of diminishing return where a bigger bottle does not gain that much on pulsa-
tion attenuation.
To guard against high late charges after the purchase order has been committed, it is
a good idea to ask the vendor to quote a “dollar-per-pound” price addition in his
proposal for pulsation damper changes. In this way, if the simulation study reveals
the necessity for changes to the dampers, there will be a firm-price basis for them.
In setting up the simulation study, be sure to consider all operating conditions.
Beware of variations in molecular weight. For example, some hydrogen compres-
sors handle nitrogen during regeneration. The acoustic velocities of these two
gasses differ by nearly a factor of four (4400 fps versus 1200 fps @ 100°F). If the
machine is an addition to a plant, the existing machines should be included if they
are in the same system. Evaluate combinations of unloading steps, speeds, and vari-
ation in gas composition. Sometimes only the extremes of the conditions need to be
simulated, but SWRI should be the judge of which conditions can be ignored.
The simulation is not a design tool. The piping design must be completed before
simulation can be started. It can, however, indicate trouble spots which can be
corrected, and the simulation is then re-run. In view of this procedure, it is advis-
able to have a Company piping designer or other representative present during the
simulation.
Check the vessel sizing and the damper boot sizing. Check for insulation and heat-
tracing if condensation is a possibility. Always keep the cylinder jacket water at
least 10 to 20°F above the inlet gas temperature. Most liquid slugging occurs at
startup when the compressor is cold. Make sure there are no dead legs where
liquids can accumulate. All of these problems should be corrected before making a
decision to upgrade the valves.
Valves do not pass liquids well. Liquid slugs have been known to cause broken
pistons and, in at least one case, actually separate the compressor cylinder from the
crankcase. The usual evidence of liquid slugging is severely damaged plates or no
plates at all; only pieces. Springs can also collapse, although this is sometimes diffi-
cult to detect, since by the time the cylinder is opened the water or hydrocarbon
liquid may have drained or evaporated.
Lube oil accumulation from over-lubrication can have similar effects. This is espe-
cially prevalent with some compressors equipped with plug type unloaders on the
suction or top side of the cylinder. In one case, a piston assembly and valves were
severely damaged when the compressor was loaded after being operated unloaded
for about 30 minutes. Oil had accumulated in the valve pocket due to the design of
the internal suction passages.
There are many new valve designs available from OEM and non-OEM sources.
Valve problems are often design related, and they can be solved by a change in
materials, or valve type. For example, one Company compressor experienced over
50 valve failures over a three-year period. Although the gas was wet, changing from
strip to peek plate valves dramatically reduced the failure rate.
Before recommending replacement of existing compressor valves, ask the vendor to
conduct a valve motion study on the existing application. Be sure the valve design
is such that neither the valve guard nor the assembly bolting can fall into the
cylinder, even if the valves assembly bolting breaks or comes loose.
Ask the prospective supplier how his valves and unloading system deviate from
API 618. Confirm that the existing valves are being built to specifications according
to dimensions, material hardness, etc. Whether valves are repaired by a
contractor, or in-house, established specifications and procedures are a prereq-
uisite to reliable performance.
Non-metallic valve plate materials have been developed for relatively high tempera-
tures. These materials are only about one-sixth the weight of steel. Also, non-
metallic materials can be contoured to reduce the drag coefficient for the flow
around the plate. These designs have shown a great deal of improvement in valve
life at some installations. However, existing valves should not be indiscriminately
replaced with these new designs.
It is important to determine whether the manufacturer designs and manufactures the
unloader system or only the valves. Be careful of a manufacturer who supplies only
valves but relies on others for the unloader mechanism. The unloader system is an
integral part of most compressors and must be designed in conjunction with the
valves.
Crankshafts
Crankshafts are most commonly one-piece forgings or castings. (One exception is
the Worthington “Cub” which has a two-piece, coupled crankshaft.) Forged steel is
used exclusively for Class A machines. Steel or nodular iron castings are some-
times used for other machines up to 1500 HP. The advantages of a casting is that
counterweights can be an integral part of the shaft. However, the Company prefers
forged steel for ratings of 200 HP and higher. A typical material designation is
ASTM A688 Class F.
Piston Rods
The most common material is heat-treated AISI 4140 steel with a maximum Rock-
well C hardness of 40 at the core and a minimum of 50 at the surface. If stress
corrosion is a design factor, this material is annealed to a hardness of 22C
maximum (core) and 50C minimum (surface). AISI 8620 with the same hardness
provides higher working stresses for stress corrosion applications.
Rods of 17-4 PH stainless steel are used for corrosive services. Core and surface
hardnesses are 40-50C for standard applications. When stress corrosion is present,
the through-hardness is limited to 33C.
Crossheads
Crossheads are available in cast gray iron, nodular iron, or steel. The Company
prefers cast steel for all high-horsepower applications, but has accepted nodular
iron as an alternate on a few applications. It is recommended that cast gray iron be
allowed only on smaller machines with ratings less than about 200 HP.
Connecting Rods
Connecting rods should be forged steel. A typical material designation is ASTM
A235.
Compressor Cylinders
Maximum allowable working pressures (MAWP) corresponding to materials are
typically limited to the values shown in Figure 300-66.
Note that nodular iron may be used for Class A machines above 1000 PSIG only in
special cases. Nodular iron is an excellent engineering material, but homogeneity of
the material throughout the casting can sometimes be a problem. Thus, the yield
strength may not be as high as anticipated. API 618 calls for specimen testing and
other NDE in an effort to ensure the quality of nodular iron castings.
Compressor Valves
Valve materials must be selected for both durable, long-term operation and compati-
bility with the gas being handled. Extensive research and field testing contribute to
the improvement of valve materials.
Figure 300-67 shows materials for valve guards and seats. Valve plates are available
in various types of stainless steels and thermoplastics, as shown in Figure 300-68.
Figure 300-69 shows the wide variety of spring materials available, from music
wire to Inconel. Other super alloys, such as Elgiloy and Haynes 25, are being used
to avoid hydrogen embrittlement for springs.
Fig. 300-67 Typical Guard and Seat Materials for Compressor Valves
Material Application
1141 Light Duty Non-Corrosive Service
Heat Treated 1141 Light to Medium Non-Corrosive Service
Ductile Iron Light to Medium Service - Resistance to some
Chemical Attack
4140 Medium to High Strength - Resistance to some
Chemical Attack
Heat Treated 4140 High Strength Service - Resistance to Some Chemical
Attack
400 Series Stainless Steel Corrosive Service
300 Series Stainless Steel Extreme Corrosive Service
17-4 PH Stainless Steel
Quality assurance and accurate dimensions are equally important. Surface finish
and parallel face surfaces are the most serious considerations for metallic plates.
Dimensional stability of thermoplastic plates in humid and high temperature envi-
ronments is essential.
One drawback to the use of thermoplastic plates is their affinity for moisture, called
hygroscopicity. Newer materials, such as PEEK and TORLON, have lower absorp-
tion rates (.06%) than nylon glass composites (1%). Also, some of these materials
have a lower coefficient of thermal expansion. For example, Dresser-Rand's
“HiTemp” valve material has a thermal expansion factor of 1.2x10-6 in/in-F, almost
half that of nylon glass composites. A low thermal expansion factor makes the plate
more resistant to deformation at higher temperatures and better able to hold dimen-
sional integrity.
Laser cutting, for example, causes a heat affected zone, which can be minimized if
the plate is cut at optimum speed. A recast layer will be found on the cut edge as it
comes from the laser; this must be removed. One manufacturer does this by
tumbling the plates in a stone media. This method satisfactorily removes the recast
layer and also forms a radius on the edge of the plate surface.
Metal valve disks or plates should be suitable for installation with either side
sealing and should be finished on both sides to 16 microinches RMS. Edges should
be suitably finished to remove stress risers. Valve seats and sealing surfaces should
also be finished to 16 microinches.
The ends of coil-type valve springs must be squared and ground to protect the plate
against damage from the spring ends.
Abstract
This section contains information on the purpose of and general principals for
inspecting and testing compressors. It covers several quality-control tests, giving
general guidance on when the respective tests may be cost-effective and appropriate.
Contents Page
seal cannot have a leakage rate greater than 70% of the combined leakage of both
seals.
major influence on the operating stability of the machine, and on the design of the
anti-surge system. RTS tends to become a problem with gases that are heavier than
air and have relatively low acoustic velocities. Propane and propylene are examples
of gases that can have a very flat characteristic from the normal operating point to
the surge point. Accordingly, a small change in the system resistance would effect a
major change in capacity causing a potentially unstable situation. CMP-MS-1876
requires a guarantee on the RTS quoted by the vendor.
There are three classes of ASME loop tests as follows:
Class I Tests
The test gas used is the same as the actual gas specified. The pressures are essen-
tially the same as those specified. In general, this class of test can be applied only to
air compressors with an atmospheric suction for strict conformance to the ASME
code. The test piping would be an open loop with an atmospheric inlet and the
discharge vented to atmosphere downstream of a control valve. The test conditions
of Class I tests more closely duplicate actual operating conditions than do the test
conditions used in the other two classes of ASME tests. Modified open-loop Class I
tests that do not meet the Code are sometimes run to quickly approximate the
performance.
Class II Tests
The test gas is different than the specified gas, and in the reduction of test data it is
assumed that the test gas and the specified gas behave in accordance with perfect
gas laws. The test piping is a closed loop.
upset the gas composition. Therefore, flange tightness should be carefully checked
prior to test startup.
Figure 600-1 shows some typical test gases used for various specified gases in
Class III closed-loop tests. In general, the heavier test gases are used for heavy spec-
ified gases. Helium/nitrogen mixtures are used for hydrogen-rich gases such as
ammonia synthesis and refinery recycle gases.
Note that the equivalent speed, capacity-speed ratio, and volume ratio, at which a
Class III test is run, are generally compromises between the various departures
allowed by the PTC-10 code (see Figure 600-2). CMP-MS-1876 requires that the
test speed has a safe margin from the rotor's critical speed.
The subject of Reynold's Number corrections of the results usually comes up when
the performance test agenda is being developed by the vendor and purchaser. The
corrections suggested by ASME PTC-10 have been proven to be very misleading,
and are inclined to favor the vendor. Depending on conditions, the ASME correc-
tions could allow a specious improvement in efficiency of 6% or more. Most
purchasers have disallowed any correction, and some vendors voluntarily decline to
make corrections. In some special cases, 50% of the corrections would be allowed.
The effects of flow in different regimes of Reynolds Number is well known, and
some correction should logically be applied. The problem is in developing suitable
correlations of the complex flow path in the compressor.
In the early 1980's, a group of eight major compressor manufacturers in the United
States and Europe got together under the auspices of the International Compressor
and Allied Machinery Committee (ICAAMC) to develop a new correction method.
Test data were pooled, and good correlations between measurements and predic-
tions were established. The ICAAMC method includes the friction factor concept
that is used in the analysis of flow in piping. The method has been proposed to
ASME for possible adoption in the next revision of the PTC-10 Code. It has already
been used successfully on several compressors. The ICAAMC method should be
considered for cases where the ratio of Reynolds Numbers for test and specified
conditions are in the range of 0.01 to 100.
Modified closed-loop Class I tests have been run on high-pressure machines with
discharge pressures ranging from about 3000 to over 9000 psi. Such machines are
used for injection of natural gas into an oil field formation. For these tests, the test
gas is formulated by blending several hydrocarbon gases and other gases to closely
approximate the composition of the actual gas. The test is run at full pressure and
full load. Sometimes the main objective of such a test is to determine mechanical
behavior at high-pressure levels, and aerodynamic performance may be of
secondary importance. A Class III test is usually run in addition to the modified
Class I test. The full pressure test along with the Class III test will provide good
data for predicting gas properties.
Performance tests are ordinarily specified for all machines in critical service where
the process flow and pressure is crucial, or where the service is troublesome and
unpredictable such as gas injection. If some components of the machine are
Fig. 600-2 Allowable Departures From Specified Design Parameters ASME PTC-10 (1965) Test (From ASME PTC-10
(1965). Courtesy of the ASME)
unavoidably unproven, the machine should have a performance test. The perfor-
mance test will often shake out mechanical problems.
The performance test is generally good insurance for machines in tough duty, since
it is far less expensive and time consuming to modify a machine at the factory than
at the jobsite.
When it is decided that a performance test is required, merely specifying an ASME
test is seldom sufficient to obtain the desired results. The objective of the tests
should be stated in order that the vendor and purchaser can work out an appropriate
test procedure. In this regard, consultation with a mechanical specialist is strongly
recommended.
occurred on lower pressure machines when the rotor had an unusually long bearing
span.
This sub-synchronous phenomenon is known as aerodynamic whirl, and is too
complex to adequately cover in this manual. When high-pressure centrifugal
compressor applications arise, it is recommended that a mechanical specialist
become involved in the specifications for the machinery as well as for the testing.
tural integrity of the cylinder, to reveal leaks caused by material flaws that
extend through the cylinder wall, and to reveal leaks caused by machining
errors or damage to machined surfaces. The gas side of the cylinder and
cylinder heads are tested separately from the cooling water side to verify there
is no leakage from one side to the other.
4. Helium or Air Pressure Test. API 618 or the job specification may require
helium or air pressure tests in addition to the hydrostatic tests. Gas tests are
more likely to find small leaks than hydrostatic tests; gas tests are made with
the cylinder submerged in water (a helium probe is sometimes used for helium
tests instead of submergence). Since compressed gas has a great deal of stored
energy, high-pressure gas tests should always be preceded by a successful
hydrostatic test for safety. When a helium or air test is required, it should
always be witnessed.
5. Compressor Valve Leak Test. This test measures the amount of time for a
fixed volume of gas behind a valve to drop from one defined pressure to
another. Special fixtures are required for this test which is sometimes specified
for all of the compressor valves. If the test is required, it should be witnessed.
6. Alignment of Cylinders to Frame. Concentric and axial alignment of frame,
crosshead guide, distance piece, and cylinder are carefully measured.
Witnessing the alignment check should be considered for large machines;
consult a machinery engineer to determine if it is warranted. Note that if these
alignments are not done correctly in the shop, then field alignment will be
much more difficult. Although the vendor would still be liable, getting them to
take care of it could be very troublesome. Manufacturers will usually resist
fitting the distance pieces and cylinders on large units.
7. Piston Rod Runout and Piston/Head Clearance. These measurements on the
assembled compressor provide assurance that cylinder alignment is satisfac-
tory, machining/assembly of crosshead/piston rod/piston are correct, and that
the manufacturer's specified head clearance is in fact present. These measure-
ments should always be witnessed. Dimensional check of the compressor
against the outline drawing, and visual inspection for defects and damage are
done at this time. These steps would also be difficult in the field, as would
getting the vendor to correct any problems. The vendor might claim some
external factors.
8. Mechanical Run Test. This test is usually run without pressure-loading the
cylinders to verify that the compressor is mechanically sound. Cylinder heads
are removed after the test for inspection of the cylinder liners. This test (and
post-test inspection) should always be witnessed. For very large compressors,
manufacturers do not have the facilities to make mechanical run tests.
9. Final Inspection. This may not be required if the compressor is shipped disas-
sembled as many are. For compressors that ship assembled, final inspection is
similar to item 16, Sub-section 630.
The following are inspection points for auxiliary equipment and drivers.
Abstract
This section contains general guidelines and checklists for installation and precom-
missioning of new compressors and recommissioning of existing ones.
Contents Page
710 Introduction
These guidelines focus on new installations, although many aspects also apply to
existing installations where equipment has been repaired, rerated, retrofitted, etc.
Proper compressor installation and precommissioning helps ensure trouble-free
startup and long-term reliability. Thorough inspection and critical review during
each phase of the installation process eliminates “built-in” deficiencies or problems
which later result in equipment failures or poor performance. The checklists in this
section are intended to aid in this inspection/review process.
712 Summary
Successful startups depend on:
• Documented execution of maintenance/installation work during the turn-
around/construction phase.
• Startup procedures developed for each unique startup (with follow-up and
documentation support).
• Clearly defined startup tasks and responsibilities.
• Communicated tasks and responsibilities in a Pre-startup Meeting to review
timing, communications during startup, contingencies, startup sequencing, and
other pertinent items.
713 References
The following provide additional information:
Instructions are covered in detail in the CUSA Mfg., IMI Candidate Manual. This
standard startup information is used routinely and successfully in all CUSA refin-
eries.
Abstract
This section reviews reciprocating compressor/engine predictive maintenance, recip-
rocating piston rod reconditioning, and contains troubleshooting checklists for
centrifugal and reciprocating compressors. Maintenance checklists referred to in
this section are included in the Appendix. For information on predictive mainte-
nance of centrifugal compressors and vibration troubleshooting, see the CUSA, IMI
Candidate Manual.
Contents Page
837 Recommendations
838 Inspection and Specifications
840 Troubleshooting 800-50
841 Introduction
842 Troubleshooting Guidelines
843 Problem Solving Guides
811 Introduction
Performance analysis is employed in several Company locations as one of several
available methods of predictive maintenance.
Performance analysis is a program involving several elements, which can include:
• Analysis of power-cylinder pressure versus time,
• Analysis of compressor-cylinder pressure versus time, or volume,
• Analysis of vibration caused by mechanical events,
• Analysis of computed values, such as horsepower, and/or
• Analysis of power-cylinder ignition.
The concept of predictive maintenance is being successfully used throughout the
industry to reduce maintenance expense. The essential philosophy behind a predic-
tive maintenance program is a concentrated effort to gather pertinent data on a peri-
odic basis. Data acquisition is covered later on in this section.
The advantages of a predictive maintenance program include:
• Elimination of catastrophic damage, thereby avoiding very high expense.
• Avoiding equipment (and plant) downtime.
• Performing only necessary maintenance.
• Avoiding disassembly of healthy machinery (periodic “overhauls,” for
example) and exposing it to risks of maintenance errors.
• Allowing reliable machinery to continue operation.
• Optimizing fuel consumption.
The following is information summarized from two programs: one at a producing
facility, the other at a large refinery.
Compressor Cylinders
Figure 800-1 is a simplified summary of a typical Pressure-Volume display and
how it correlates to piston/valve actions. It gives the basic pattern and events rela-
tive to piston travel.
Figure 800-2 represents one format to display the compression cycle. Note that it is
similar to Figure 800-1, except for being reversed. Figure 800-2 also shows typical
problems that can be detected (with interpretation).
Figures 800-3 and 800-4 further illustrate methods for detecting impending
compressor valve problems.
Fig. 800-1 Typical Pressure Volume Display (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-2 Typical Compressor Cylinder Problems Identified with P-V Displays (1 of 5)
(Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-2 Typical Compressor Cylinder Problems Identified with P-V Displays (2 of 5)
(Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-2 Typical Compressor Cylinder Problems Identified with P-V Displays (3 of 5)
(Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-2 Typical Compressor Cylinder Problems Identified with P-V Displays (4 of 5)
(Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-2 Typical Compressor Cylinder Problems Identified with P-V Displays (5 of 5)
(Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-5 Typical Combustion Patterns (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
NOTE: Frames 1-6 are all cylinder pressure vs. crankangle displays.
Fig. 800-6 Details of Combustion Pattern (Primary) (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-7 Details of a Combustion Pattern (Inductive Secondary) (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Point B—Breaker points open/transistor turns off. This occurs at the same degree
each cycle if normal, and varies if the drive is worn or if the points stick or arc.
Point C—(line I) Peak ionization voltage. Voltage required to ionize the plug gap.
As this increases, the duration (line III) will decrease.
Things to Remember:
• Be sure to analyze the whole pattern.
• Watch for multiple fires. Voltage rises at wrong crankangles.
• Approach the ignition analysis systematically.
• Be sure all cylinders are firing at the correct crankangle. Variation is often
found between the cylinders.
• Know the characteristics of your ignition system.
Point A
Peak Pressure Vibration. The flame front is moving at maximum velocity at this
point and usually causes this normal vibration. If detonation occurs, this vibration
becomes a high-amplitude sharp spike. Piston slap also occurs at or near this point,
since the piston will rock in a worn cylinder under the maximum pressure.
Excessive wear in the wristpin or bushing is often seen at this point.
A badly worn rod bearing will knock at this point or slightly later, normally
detected at BDC long before it appears at this point. The same is true of a worn
wristpin. We normally look for the rod bearing, wristpin, or a piston loose on the
hanger at 10 degrees before and after BDC when it is in the early stages of wear.
Point B
Top Ring Enters the Exhaust Port. If the top ring is doing its job, the pressure
will be released when this event occurs. If this ring becomes worn, stuck, broken, or
the piston or cylinder port area wear, this vibration becomes a high-amplitude,
sharp spike. If something happens to the top ring, the second ring will hold most of
the pressure, resulting in a vibration spike when it enters the port. (This spike will
occur earlier, since the second ring enters the port at an earlier degree of crank rota-
tion.)
Evaluate the ring condition by watching this area. Also watch for carbon buildup in
the ports, which will cause the rings to clip. This can occur in the intake port as
well as the exhaust. Normally, a ring is not picked up as it enters the intake port
unless there is a problem. The same is true of the rings going back up through the
ports on the compression stroke. Since there is no pressure to hold the rings against
the cylinder walls, they do not clip in the ports on the compression stroke unless
there is a problem with the rings or the cylinder port.
If one of the lower rings is broken, it will cause a sharp spike in the exhaust port on
the power stroke, indicated by the degree at which it occurs.
Fig. 800-8 Typical Vibration Patterns with a 2 Stroke Power Cylinder. (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Fig. 800-9 Typical Vibration Patterns with Compression Cylinders (Courtesy of the American Gas Association)
Watch these ring vibrations, and they will increase in amplitude as the condition
gets worse. A new set of rings will clip in the ports until they wear in. Then the
vibration will drop down to a normal level until they begin to deteriorate.
Point C
Exhaust Blowdown—This is vibration of the gas as it leaves the cylinder. This
vibration will be present when the cylinder fires on a normal cycle and will disap-
pear when the cylinder has no combustion within the cycle. Use the exhaust blow-
down as a standard to compare all other vibrations within the pattern. If the
mounting or transducer changes, it will affect the whole pattern amplitude, which
the operator will note if he compares to a standard within the pattern.
The exhaust will elongate if the ports are restricted by carbon.
The operator may also note that on V-type units with a common exhaust manifold
between the V, the exhaust blowdown from the cylinder on the other bank may
carry over in the vibration trace. This blowdown (or ghost vibration) will always be
there and in the same place or crankangle. The operator can disregard it once he
identifies it.
Point D
Injection Valve Opens—This vibration is caused by the slack taken out when the
valve train activates the injection valve. The operator can get a fix on the CAM
timing and lobe condition from this vibration and the closure vibration. Some units
with hydraulic lifters will not have this vibration unless there is a problem with the
CAM or lifter. To pick up this vibration on such a unit, put the pick-up directly on
the rocker arm pin.
This vibration will be excessive if there is any wear in the valve actuation assembly.
Pressure applied to the rocker arm sometimes will eliminate much of the vibration
and allow the operator to make a true analysis of the rest to the pattern, possibly
distorted by this vibration.
Point E
Injection Valve Closes—The front (flat) side of this vibration is the degree at
which the valve hits the seat. The higher the amplitude, the harder the valve hits the
seat. The wider the vibration spike, the wider the mating surfaces. This is a good
indication of valve lash, CAM timing, injection valve, and seat condition.
If the vibration fades into the baseline, it is a good indication that the valve has
sealed. If it balloons out or continues to vibrate for too long, the valve is leaking.
Note the pattern in Figure 800-10.
816 Hardware
A variety of electronic equipment is used to make the program analysis. This equip-
ment is continually being improved and perfected to obtain additional or more
precise information. The system components are as follows:
Analyzer—This unit is the control center for the analyst. Various signals are
selected, calibrated, and controlled for accuracy of display, and if applicable
computing the horsepower. There are two available types:
The above are the standard elements developed by the CUSA Manufacturing IMI
(Integrated Machinery Inspection) Program.
The essential philosophy behind a predictive maintenance program is a concen-
trated effort to gather pertinent data on a periodic basis. Data acquisition includes
the recording of visual inspections, temperature and pressure readings, along with
photographs of pressure, vibrations, and ultrasonic patterns. The conditions listed in
Figure 800-11 should be checked on a periodic basis: typically every 30 days on
critical machinery and 60 to 90 days on basic units.
Fig. 800-11 Summary of Typical Records Maintained: Reciprocating Compressor/Engine Predictive Maintenance
Program
General Operating
Power Cylinders Compressor Cylinders Conditions Scavenger Cylinders
Original specifications, or baseline data, plus recent trends as appropriate:
Horsepower per cylinder Horsepower per Oil temperature
head-end and crank-end
Followup Surveillance
During the time between periodic compression analysis, plant personnel may
perform followup surveillance of equipment highlighted by the analysis team. This
followup surveillance consists of the following:
• Visually inspect the compressor/engine;
• Record gage pressures and temperatures per individual equipment “road maps;”
• Monitor and record valve cover temperatures;
• Note oil levels; i.e., crankcase, McCord, Trabon, etc.;
• Use ultrasonic translator to help locate leaking and broken valves, valve
covers, rod packing, and auxiliary equipment leaks; and
• Monitor temperatures on fuel injection valves and starting air check valves.
Plant personnel should also review the surveillance schedule to determine which
compressors are due for analysis the next period. Notification should be given
responsible parties to make sure the equipment is online and available.
A periodic surveillance report should be prepared for each piece of equipment in
order to inform operations of any problems in their plant. Care should be taken to
ensure that all interested parties understand this information.
Through coordinated efforts between the surveillance team, operations, and mainte-
nance, the recommended repairs are scheduled, and when complete, are recorded
for review by interested personnel.
Design Review
Repetitive failures are almost always caused by design deficiencies. A design
review consists of first identifying repetitive problems, then reviewing and rede-
signing the system to eliminate them.
The following case history is one example of a persistent problem solved by an
analysis program, combined with a design review. The problem was excessive fail-
ures of inboard suction valves on a high-stage hydrogen-booster compressor in a
large refinery.
Compression analysis showed several instances of cylinder-pressure variations.
Normal compressor valves required an average differential pressure of 20 psig to
open suction valves. Prior to valve failure, however, the differential pressure
increased to as high as 220 psig. With this information, the surveillance crew began
to gather data on a twice-per-month basis to study valve life in relation to the pres-
sure differential. They concluded that after the differential exceeded 75 psig, less
than two weeks valve life could be expected.
A criterion was established for these valves to be considered in a “Phase II” condi-
tion when the pressure differential exceeded 50 psig. After this criterion for repair
was established, the breakage of inboard suction valves ceased.
Investigation also showed that the only time failures occurred were during, or after
the outboard end of the cylinder had been operated in the unloaded position.
Subsequent investigation of the valve repairs found that the plates and seats were
being honed to a mirror-like surface. With oil between the seat and plate, it was
impossible to lift the plate off the seat. This phenomenon was labeled “stiction.”
Valves were subsequently rebuilt with machined surfaces which alleviated a large
percentage of this “stiction”. Inboard valves were breaking because all the oil
supplied to the cylinder was dissipated during each stroke, except when the
outboard end was unloaded. This allowed oil to travel back through the outboard
suction valve and coat the inboard valve with excess oil. The following steps were
taken to eliminate the excessive failures of inboard suction valves:
• Valve surfaces were closely monitored to ensure proper finish.
• Lubrication rate to the cylinder was modified to the minimum required.
• Operations alternated outboard loads when notified of Phase I conditions by
the surveillance team.
Machinery Protection
Instrumentation for shutdowns and alarms are monitored, repaired, and upgraded as
necessary to prevent catastrophic failures of reciprocating equipment. The
following parameters are commonly considered critical for constant monitoring:
• Oil pressure,
• Discharge temperature,
• Jacket water temperature,
• Liquid knockout level,
• Vibration,
• Lubrication rate, and
• Amperage.
An important element of machinery protection is periodic testing of alarms and
shutdowns. In locations where there are regular, documented testing programs, tests
are conducted as often as weekly, but more commonly monthly. Longer intervals
are also used. One thing is clear: You cannot rely on shutdown protective
devices if they are not being tested and documented regularly.
Analysis worksheets used in the Warren Petroleum program are included in
Appendix M. They may be ordered from Warren or used as models to develop local
checklists.
Background
Typical maintenance programs consist of repairs only after failures, or doing peri-
odic overhauls. Needlessly, all power pistons and cylinders would be pulled and
inspected for damage, when only one or two pistons or cylinders on each engine
might need repair or replacement. A complete power cylinder overhaul of a Clark
RA-8 can cost a conservative $40,000 in parts, not including labor.
With a routine analyzer program, power piston rings that are worn, broken, or stuck
can usually be spotted and pulled for repair before the cylinder is damaged. A
costly overhaul, or worse, catastrophic damage, is thereby avoided.
Fuel Savings
When an engine is not balanced, some of the power cylinders carry more than their
share of the load. Consequently, the unbalanced engine will use more fuel to carry
the same load. This extra fuel varies depending on the severity of unbalance and the
type of engine. Besides the extra fuel, maintenance problems will arise from the
overloaded cylinders.
Balancing the horsepower between the power cylinders evenly distributes the load,
and wear is not excessive on any one cylinder. This is a basic preventive mainte-
nance procedure.
Ignition problems and poor ignition timing will cause the engine to use more fuel
than required. If there is no combustion in a power cylinder due to ignition difficul-
ties, then the fuel will be swept out the exhaust. If the spark is early or late by as
little as four degrees, it will cause the engine to consume more fuel than necessary.
Other problems that will cause excessive fuel consumption are improper fuel and
air quality, improper air/fuel ratios, engine load, and engine RPM. The result of
these problems can cause the engine to consume as much as 15 to 25% more fuel
than necessary.
Example: A Cooper Bessemer GMVA-8, rated at 1350 HP, consumes 250 MCFD
at an estimated price of $1.50/MCF. If it consumes 20% extra fuel, or 50 MCFD,
the annual cost of the extra fuel would exceed $27,000.
replaced, the costs are approximately $2500 to $4500 for a Clark RA and Clark
BA, respectively.
Ring Blow-by—This leads to oil contamination and also leads to piston slap if left
undetected and allowed to progress. If the repair is limited to piston ring changeout,
the cost is approximately $250 to $450 for a Clark RA and a Clark BA, respec-
tively. If the cylinder and piston require repair, the cost is about 10 times higher.
Detonation—This can be a very serious problem if allowed to continue for very
long. It breaks rings, cracks pistons, cracks heads, and wears piston bearings out
very quickly. The costs for replacing broken rings are noted under Ring Blow-by.
The reworking of the piston dome and cylinder costs approximately $700 each, and
the piston bearings cost $400 for a Clark RA. If the crankshaft is cracked or ruined,
a used RA-8 crankshaft costs $25,000, and a new one costs $65,000, with an
extended delivery time.
Cracked Head—This leads to detonation and visa versa. The costs for this are
detailed under Detonation.
Carbon in Ports—This only takes labor and gaskets to fix, but leads to a loss in
horsepower, which causes the other cylinders to overload, and high cylinder temper-
atures. This eventually leads to a major wear pattern detailed in Piston Slap. If the
carbon begins to get hot and cause premature ignition or detonation problems, then
more maintenance costs are incurred as a result of this relatively simple problem.
Note that excess carbon can also be caused by improper lubricating oils.
Knock in Wristpin/Bushing—This can be replaced for approximately $400. If the
condition is allowed to deteriorate, it creates excessive wear in the piston, cylinder,
and rings. These costs are noted in Piston Slap.
Bad Valves—If the intake and exhaust valves on a 4-stroke engine are leaking,
worn, or need adjustment, the cylinder loses horsepower, causing the other cylin-
ders to overload and have high cylinder temperatures. This can also lead to head
repair, which costs $600 to $1000, depending on the type of head.
Worn Rocker Arms Bushing—This is relatively simple to repair for $10 to $20. If
it is not repaired, it can cause a fuel valve, pushrod, and rocker arm to fail, costing
$200.
Problems and Cost: Compressor Cylinders
Leaking Valves—Repair this valve before it completely fails. Minor repair can cost
about $20; a new 7-1/4-inch valve costs $400. Replacing a cylinder destroyed by a
broken valve can easily exceed $10,000.
Ring Wear—One cause may be hot valves not changed before the rings were
damaged. If the rings fail, the compressor cylinder might be damaged. Relining a
compressor cylinder costs approximately $100 per diameter inch. Compressor rings
cost approximately $25 per diameter inch.
Multiplied by:
Additional conservative factor: .05
Estimated Value of operation and maintenance savings and added
protection
Per Year
Centrifugal Compressors
• IMI Guidelines for Completing the Overhaul Checklist for Centrifugal
Compressors
• Centrifugal Compressor Overhaul Checklist
• IMI Guideline for Inspection and Repair of Centrifugal Compressor Rotors
Reciprocating Compressors
• Compressor Lubricating Systems
• Compressor Piston and Piston Rod
• Compressor Packing Box and Packing
• Compressor Cylinder and Crosshead
• Compressor Valves and Unloaders
• Compressor Valve Gaskets and Cages
• Compressor Crankshaft and Bearings
• Repair Sheet for Clark Engines
• Compressor Cylinder Repair Report
• Compressor Crankcase Repair Report
• Engine Repair Sheet for Ingersoll-Rand XVG
• Ingersoll-Rand HHE Packer Rebuilding Procedure
• Ingersoll-Rand HHE Packer Rebuilding Check Sheet
• Ingersoll-Rand Packing Box and Packing Worklist
• Engine Driven Reciprocating Compressor Regrout
• Four and Eight Month Maintenance Checklist Prior Shutdown Information
• Ingersoll-Rand HHE Connecting Rod Rebuilding
• Aluminum Bronze Pin Bushing HHE Cylinder Connecting Rod
• Splitting HRA Engine CAM Lobes
• Clark HRA—Engine Power Cylinder Reconditioning
• Clark HRA—Power Cylinder Repair Flow Chart
• Clark HRA Main Crosshead Rebuilding
• Clark HRA Power Cylinder Head Rebuilding
• Clark HRA Gas Injection Valve Rebuilding
• Clark HRA Wesco Valve Lifters
• Clark HRA Power Piston and Connecting Rod Rebuilding
• Clark HRA Packer Rebuilding
• HRA Packer Rebuilding Check Sheet
• Clark Compressor Air Starting Check Valves
• Crankshaft Inspection and Reconditioning
• Crosshead Rebuilding
• Connecting Rod Reconditioning
• Connecting Rod Check Sheet
• Piston Reconditioning
• Piston/Rider Ring Clearance Tables
831 Introduction
This section summarizes field experience and provides guidance on reconditioning
reciprocating compressor piston rods. Sub-sections 832 through 836 contain back-
ground information; Sub-section 837 contains recommendations. (It may save you
time to refer directly to the Recommendations sub-section, 837.)
When equipment is not spared, any improvement in component service life can
have a significant effect on plant availability. Properly selected and applied hard
facings can improve reciprocating compressor reliability.
In many cases, worn or scored piston rods may be reconditioned at a fraction of the
cost of new rods.
This section is also applicable to reconditioning positive displacement pump
plungers. (In addition, certain processes used for rod and plunger reconditioning are
also applicable to reconditioning centrifugal compressor and turbine journals and
seal areas.)
flame hardening. Both processes involve heating the surface of rods above the
upper critical temperature followed by rapid quenching using water or other suit-
able coolants. Typical case thicknesses range from 1/16 to 1/8 inch, with surface
hardnesses in the range of Rockwell C50 to 60.
In certain cases, the hardness must be limited due to potential embrittlement prob-
lems. Sour hydrocracking services are one such service. For these applications, rods
are often fabricated from softer steels, then hardfaced for wear resistance in the
packing and oil wiper ring areas.
Figure 800-13 provides general guidance on appropriate hardness and surface
finishes for various applications. These hardnesses and finishes have normally
resulted in acceptable packer sealing and life.
As metal is removed from the surface of case hardened rods, hardness decreases.
Wear rates accelerate and susceptibility to galling and abrasion increases. The
acceptable degree of packer leakage depends to a large extent on the nature and
severity of the process application. In less severe applications such as lubricated,
low-pressure service, it is possible to accept much greater wear before replacing or
reconditioning a rod. In high-pressure hydrogen applications, however, leakage of
hydrogen results in further heating of packing, lubricant and the rod (due to Joule-
Thompson effect). An unacceptable operating condition quickly results.
Oversized Rods
When packing rings have a slightly smaller bore than the piston rod diameter, the
segments contact only at one end. The center portion of each ring segment provides
a direct gas passage along the rod surface. This condition is permissible if it is not
too severe. During the break-in process, packing will gradually wear to the point of
conformation with the general rod surface curvature.
The potential for overheating due to lack of proper lubrication exists for oversized
rods for the same reasons stated for undersized rods.
Tapered Rods
In lubricated services, a certain degree of rod taper can be tolerated. Lubricating
films tend to block small passages through which gas can escape. A tapered rod
combines both the effects of oversized and undersized rods in that packing rings
constantly try to adjust to the variations in surface profile. Excessive amounts of
taper, however, will rapidly destroy the packers' ability to seal.
Generally, the worst taper condition occurs at one end of the stroke. Reasonable
leakage rates and packer life can be expected if the degree of taper does not exceed
approximately 0.0005 inch per inch of stroke. For non-lubricated and high-pressure,
low molecular weight gas services, acceptable taper will be less than this value.
Misalignment
Misalignment of piston rod and packer rings cause another leak path. Rod-to-ring
surface contact area is reduced. In addition, edges of rings at the bore become worn.
This permits gas flow from one radial cut in the ring to another. In API 618, the
maximum allowable rod runout at operating temperature is 0.00015 inch per inch of
stroke. Alignment of cylinder, distance piece and crosshead guides should be
adjusted in order to meet this guideline. Runout should always be checked
following installation of piston rods, crossheads, wrist pins, etc. Noncontacting
probes can be used very effectively to measure and monitor rod runout.
Wear
Wear mechanisms include abrasion, adhesion, corrosion, fretting, erosion, surface
fatigue, etc. Adhesive and abrasive wear are the principal kinds encountered in the
sliding sites of a gas compressor or positive displacement pump packer.
Adhesive-type wear occurs when two parts make metal-to-metal contact and
adhere. Fragments are detached from one surface and welded to the other surface.
To minimize this type of wear, one surface must have films and coatings to mini-
mize the initial adhesion.
Abrasive wear is a cutting-type action where hard fragments embedded in the softer
component (packing) or trapped between relatively hard packing and rod material
act as a cutting tool.
Reconditioning Processes
In selecting a wear-resistant coating for rods, the following factors are important:
• Coating roughness and surface texture (smoothness, porosity),
• Coating hardness,
• Combination of sliding materials (rod coating and packer material),
• Corrosion resistance,
• Adhesion of coating to base metal (bond strength), and
• Previous coating/heat-treating history.
Numerous reconditioning processes are available today for restoring worn rods to
their original size and surface conditions. These processes may also be used to
provide extended life of rods in new equipment, especially in difficult services. In
general, only rods in sound condition should be considered as candidates for recon-
ditioning. Base metal surface condition must be carefully inspected prior to use of
any type of coating (discussed later).
Major hardfacing processes include the general categories of flame spraying (metal
spray and plasma spray), electroplating (chrome plating) and flame plating (detona-
tion gun). Figure 800-14 summarizes the relative characteristics of these processes
and the resultant coatings they produce. The acceptability of each process depends
on the service conditions, i.e., lubricated or non-lubricated, sour, corrosive or dirty
gas, etc. Only certain coatings applied by each major process are suitable for recon-
ditioning rods to resist adhesive and abrasive sliding-type wear. For the relatively
low-service temperatures of interest here (up to 400°F), changes in physical proper-
ties and strength of various coatings are of minimal concern.
Compressor Manual
Maximum Effect of
Coating Application Lubrication Surface
Corrosion Thickness Procedure on Holding Finishing
Process Porosity Hardness Resistance Bond Strength (Approx.) Rod Base Metal Characteristics Characteristics Comments
1. Metal Spray High Low-Moderate Poor-Sealer Poor-Fair 0.040 inch None Good Fair
Required
2. Metal Spray Low Mod-High Excellent Excellent 0.065 inch Significant Good Good Not permitted on
with fusion hard-enabled (SAE
(Wall 4041, etc.) rods.
Colmonoy Must consider
Spraywelding) effect of fusion
process on base
metal physical prop-
erties.
3. Plasma Spray Moderate Moderate Fair-Sealer Fair 0.006 inch None-Slight Good Good
Required
800-35
4. Flame Plate Low Very High Fair-Good Good-Excellent 0.010 inch None Good Good
(Linde D-Gun) Sealers occa-
sionally used
a. Porous Mod-High High Good-Excellent Good-Excellent 0.015 inch Causes H2 Good Depends
occlusion largely on base
metal surface
finish
b. Non-Porous Low High Excellent Good 0.015 inch Causes H2 Poor-Fair Ditto
December 1988
occlusion
800 Maintenance and Troubleshooting Compressor Manual
Disadvantages include:
• Bond strength is low. Coatings are mechanically bonded to the base metal.
• Fracture/peeling will occur unless the coating is continuously bonded to itself.
• Coatings are very porous. Must be impregnated with suitable sealers to mini-
mize porosity (and avoid base metal corrosion).
• Coatings have relatively low hardness (Rc 30-40).
• Surface preparation prior to coating is critical to adequacy of bond.
• Coating quality is likely to vary widely from shop to shop.
• Relatively slow powder/wire heating results in greater oxidation and some
change in coating chemical composition.
• Fair surface finishing characteristics.
• Finish machining is required.
An extension of the basic metal spray process is the post-application fusing of coat-
ings. Coatings are applied in the manner described above. Then one additional step
is taken. The deposited metal spray coating is fused with the base metal by use of
an oxyacetylene torch or controlled furnace atmosphere. The resulting bond is
molecular in nature and is claimed to be much stronger. Coatings up to 0.065 inch
can be applied. Hardness ranges from approximately Rc 55 to 63. Corrosion resis-
tance is excellent.
In order to utilize the metal spray and fusion process, the base metal must have a
melting point higher than 1950°F. High temperatures required to achieve fusing of
the coating may result in rod distortion. In addition, when the carbon content of
steel rods exceeds 0.25%, special precautions must be taken to avoid an annealed
metal. Any previous heat treatment applied to the rod to achieve improvement in
physical properties is lost. Annealed rods must be derated to maintain safe oper-
ating stress levels. Fusing followed by air cooling could result in the formation of
brittle martensite, depending on the hardenability of the base metal alloy.
secure bond has not been achieved. Peeling can result in considerable damage to
packing and perhaps cylinder components.
To obtain a reasonable degree of corrosion protection, plasma coatings must be
impregnated with suitable sealers to minimize porosity.
Undercoating
In some instances, a metallic undercoat such as nickel or nickel alumide is applied
between the base metal and the hardface coating. Metallic undercoats are applied to
increase the coating system's resistance to thermal shock and to improve bond
strength. Bonding of the metallic undercoat to the base metal is stronger than the
bond between coating and base metal. In addition, the as-sprayed undercoat
provides a good surface for the coating to mechanically bond. Undercoating is most
frequently used with the weaker bond strength metal and plasma spray processes.
836 Experience
Company Experience
Figures 800-16 and 800-17 summarize the results of a May, 1978 Company-wide
survey of experience with various hardface reconditioning processes. These summa-
ries reflect both refinery and producing field experience. Refinery experience
covers gas compressor applications in plants such as Catalytic Reformers, Isomax,
Isomerization, Ammonia, FCC, Naphtha Hydrotreater and Crude Units. Producing
experience generally covers the handling of sweet (wet and dry) natural gas in low-
and high-pressure separation and gas lift services.
Results show that for lubricated, low-pressure (less than approximately 1000 psi)
services, good service lift has been afforded by chroming, plasma spray, metal
spray and D-Gun coating processes. Average service life of reconditioned rods
when used with various grades of Teflon packing has been approximately four
years in sweet, noncorrosive gas services and approximately two years in sour,
corrosive gas environments.
For difficult, high-pressure (above 1000 psi) services, Linde D-Gun coatings have
proven superior. D-Gun coatings have performed consistently well (two to three
years and longer) in high-pressure (up to 5000 psi) lubricated, low- and high-molec-
ular weight gas services. Producing reports acceptable service from metal sprayed
and fused coatings at elevated pressures.
No Company experience was reported for coated rods in high-pressure, non-lubri-
cated service.
Other petrochemical company users report mixed success with metal spray and
plasma spray restoration of compressor rods. One user stated that Linde D-Gun
flame-plated rods were found to perform much better than new (bare) rods.
Electroplating (Chroming)
Two major compressor vendors indicate generally poor experience restoring piston
rods with various chroming processes. Vendor “A” recommends against recondi-
tioning by any electroplating procedure because of the high number of oilers
reported. In addition, there is also a concern that the electroplating process intro-
duces the risk of fatigue failure from hydrogen penetration into the rod. Vendor “B”
recommends against chrome plating due to the wide variation in the quality of the
plating operation from shop to shop.
If rods are reconditioned by the electroplating process, Vendor “B” strongly recom-
mends that: (1) plating be of the “porous” type; (2) plating thickness not exceed
0.005 to 0.006 inch; (3) rod surface finish prior to plating be 20 micro-inches RMS
or better; (4) rods be ground undersize along their full length, plate only on top of
the undersize area, allowing the plate to fade to the undersize diameter outside the
packing travel area; and (5) inspect the rod surface carefully prior to and after
plating.
Fig. 800-16 Rod Reconditioning Survey Summary (Sweet, Non-Corrosive Gas Services) (1 of 2)
Maximum
Operating Lubricated or
Pressure Non-lubricated Process Unit Experience
Below 500 psig Lubricated Ammonia 4+ yrs service life w/chromed rods. Tinized C.I.
packing. Low-pressure (165 psi), medium piston
speed (700 ft/min) compressor. Total of 12 D-Gun
coated rods in service w/carbon-filled Teflon
packing. 1-2 yr service without signs of wear.
Below 500 psig Lubricated Producing 10 yrs average life w/metal spray (Metco SS # 2) 4140
rods. Bronze packing. Low-pressure (vacuum to 150
psi) services. Wide range (low to high) piston speed
compressors.
Below 500 psig Non-lubricated Air 2-3 yrs service life w/chromed rods. Carbon-filled
Teflon w/bronze backup packing. Low-pressure, high-
temperature (320°F) air compressor.
500-1000 psig Lubricated HGO 2-1/2 yrs life w/plasma-coated (Metco # 450/451) on
X20CR13 rods. Carbon-filled Teflon packing higher
wear rate and cracking of coating noted. Bare
X20CR13 rods lasted 4-1/2 yrs.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Cat Ref New 4140 rods coated w/D-Gun (LW-1) installed
10/77. Teflon w/C.I. backup packing. Good service
experience. No problems reported to date.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Cat Ref 1-2 yrs life w/D-Gun coatings. One month life
w/chrome plating.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Cat Ref Varied experience w/chromed (non-porous) rods.
Teflon and tinized C.I. packing. Chromed rod lasted
4-7 months.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Naphtha Good (5-6 yrs) service on chromed 4140 rods. Glass-
HDTR filled Teflon packing. Low pressure ratio per stage,
760 ft/min piston speed.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Producing Good service experience metal spray (420SS) on 4140
rods. Bronze packing. 3-5 years life for gas lift service
(500-1000 psig).
500-1000 psig Non-lubricated Isomerization Chrome plating wears and peels within 6 months. 1+
year service w/spray-welded (Wall-Colmonoy Wallex
55) 4140 rods. Carbon packing. Low (490 ft/min) piston
speed.
1000-1500 psig Lubricated FCC Feed 3-4 yrs service life w/chromed 4140 rods. Carbon-
Hydrofiner filled Teflon w/C.I. backup ring packing. 1200 psi
maximum discharge pressure, 700 ft/min piston
speed.
1000-1500 psig Lubricated Isomax 3+ yrs service life w/plasma spray (Metco #439) on
4140 rods. Teflon packing. 760 ft/min piston speed.
Fig. 800-16 Rod Reconditioning Survey Summary (Sweet, Non-Corrosive Gas Services) (2 of 2)
Maximum
Operating Lubricated or
Pressure Non-lubricated Process Unit Experience
Above 1500 psig Lubricated Isomax 2 yrs life w/D-Gun (LW-1 w/nickel undercoat) over
4140 rods. Teflon with C.I. backup ring packing. High
(2870 psi) discharge pressure, moderately high (810
ft/min) piston speed.
Above 1500 psig Lubricated Ammonia 1+ year life w/D-Gun (LW-15) 4140 rods. Bronze
packing. 4780 psi discharge pressure. High (850
fit/min) piston speed. No wear after 1 yr.
Above 1500 psig Lubricated Producing Acceptable service life reported w/sprayed and
fused (Tuftin 500 Twin Arc Process) coating on 4140
rods. Bronze packing. Bond reportedly good up to
6000 psig. Metal or plasma sprayed steel rods failed
after 1 month at Swanson River.
Fig. 800-17 Rod Reconditioning Survey Summary (Sour, Corrosive Gas Services)
Maximum
Operating Lubricated or Process
Pressure non-lubricated Unit Experience
Below 500 psig Lubricated HDS Less than 1 yr service w/plasma spray (Comp. Products #3)
on steel rods. Steel/babbitt packing. 800 ft/min piston speed.
Below 500 psig Lubricated Isomax Good (6 yrs) service life w/chromed rods. Teflon w/tinized
C.I. backup ring packing. Low-pressure (195 psi) service.
Moderate (750 ft/min) piston speed. Total of 18 D-Gun
coated rods in service, carbon-filled Teflon packing life
exceeds 2-3 yrs.
Below 500 psig Lubricated Crude 2-3 yrs service w/plasma spray (Metco #2) on 18-8 SS rods.
Teflon packing. 150 psi max. discharge pressure, low (520
ft/min) piston speed.
Below 500 psig Lubricated Flare Gas 2+ yrs. service with D-Gun (LW-1N30) rods. Teflon packing.
Recovery
Below 500 psig Lubricated FCC 1-1/2 yr service w/chromed steel rods. Micarta packing.
Low (165 psi) discharge pressure, 660 ft/min piston speed.
500-1000 psig Lubricated HDS 10-18 months service w/plasma spray (Comp. Products #3)
on steel rods. Steel/babbitt packing. 800 ft/min piston speed.
500-1000 psig Lubricated Rhen. 1-2 yrs. service for plasma spray (Metco #2) on 4140 rods.
Carbon-filled Teflon packing. 750 ft/min piston speed.
Above 1000 psig Lubricated HDN 3+ yrs. service w/D-Gun (LW-1N30) 4140 rods. Carbon-filled
Teflon packing. High (1650 psi) discharge pressure, high
(890 ft/min) piston speed.
Vendor “C” recommends only porous type chrome platings. These platings are
normally provided as original manufacture on such service as high-pressure
hydrogen and sour gas (up to 2% H2S). These environments require moderate hard-
ness base materials with high hardness wear-resistant coatings.
Metal Spray
In general, metal spray coatings were not recommended by compressor vendors.
Vendor “A” does not consider the metal spray and fusing process to be a good
reconditioning procedure. Main problems reported are (1) distortion of rod's
finished surface, and (2) overlay of steel rod whose carbon content exceeds 0.25%
without special proper precaution. Vendor “B” similarly recommends against this
restoration method.
Vendor “C” cites mixed experience with this technique. In one case a 5-inch diam-
eter rod in hydrogen service was hardfaced to a 50-mil thickness by Spraywelding.
Shortly after startup, the rod cracked in half, causing significant damage to the
compressor. Later investigation showed base metal hardness in the range of 500
BHN (originally 240 BHN). Hydrogen embrittlement was thought to be the cause
of this failure.
Plasma Spray
Vendor “B” indicated that their experience shows “no acceptable or successful
process exists to restore rods reliably by plasma spray.” Vendor “D” cited peeling
problems with this reconditioning technique.
Experience Summary
Overall, consistently best service experience in low-pressure and even high-pres-
sure, difficult services has been afforded by the use of the Linde D-Gun coatings. In
addition to favorable Company and compressor vendor experience, Union Carbide
cites numerous applications throughout the domestic petrochemical industry where
D-Gun coatings have performed well. These coatings have been used in both lubri-
cated and non-lubricated services up to 6000 psi.
Experience with chrome plating and flame spray (metal and plasma) coatings varies
throughout the industry. Most diversity is noted in the chroming process. Quality
control varies enormously from shop to shop. Many chroming problems are likely
the result of changes in chrome shop personnel and the use of new shops seemingly
offering comparable quality at lower cost. Because commonly used non-porous
chrome has poor lubricant retention quality, special precaution must be taken to
insure adequate lubrication. Many times, these steps are not taken, resulting in short
packer and rod life.
Metal and plasma spray coating processes are generally less successful (especially
at higher pressures) due to low bonding strength and the need for strict quality
control during the preparation and coating processes. Where reliable shops have
been established, metal spray has proven an economical, reliable reconditioning
technique in lubricated low-pressure services. Metal spray and fused coatings are
good choices in very corrosive services as long as proper attention is given to the
metallurgical effects of the fusing operation. Little experience is available
supporting the general use of plasma spray.
837 Recommendations
Based on service experience available to date, the following procedure is recom-
mended when considering reconditioning used rods or coating new ones.
1. Confirm the technical adequacy and quality control procedures for every
coating shop to be used. Do this periodically for shops used repeatedly for
years.
2. Avoid reconditioning rods which are scored, galled or worn to a depth of more
than 20 to 30 mils; 5 to 10 mils is preferred.
3. Consider hardfacing new rods before putting in service.
4. Complete Figure 800-19 for each individual rod sent to a coating shop. Require
the vendor to complete and return Part II of this figure after all coating and
machining operations are complete. Retain this as a permanent record in the
file for that compressor.
5. For difficult and critical services, consider in-shop inspection prior to, during,
and following coating application.
6. Unless otherwise dictated by local service experience, the following restoration
processes are recommended in order of preference:
a. Union Carbide Linde D-Gun flame plating (most lubricated and non-lubri-
cated, high- and low-pressure services), and
b. Metal spray and fuse (extremely corrosive services only).
c. Porous chrome, Van der Horst Corp. “Vanderkrome” (lubricated services
up to moderate pressures)
d. Plasma spray (limited to low-moderate pressure, lubricated services)
e. Metal spray without fusing (limited to low-pressure, lubricated services)
f. Non-porous chrome (limited to low-pressure noncritical, lubricated
services)
7. Maintain a record of the service life of the coated rod (Part III of
Figure 800-18).
Following initial grinding of a used rod, but prior to plating or coating, the rod must
be carefully inspected for cracks and grinding heat checks by magnaflux or equal
inspection techniques. In addition, base metal surfaces must be properly cleaned.
Certain coating processes demand much closer attention to surface cleanliness than
others. The importance of clean base metal is underscored by a recent two-year
survey by a major chrome plating company. Results showed 80% of the premature
plating failures were attributable to lack of cleanliness. Contamination can arise
from (1) nonmetallic, abrasive particles embedded in the surface or adhering elec-
trostatically from grinding, sandblasting, polishing, and honing operations, (2)
residual traces of metal working fluids, coolants, lubricants used during machining
operations, (3) dusty, moisture-laden coating environment, (4) insufficient interim
protection during various stages of coating, and (5) lack of caution by people
handling parts (dirty or perspiring bare hands).
Close review of a coating shop's quality control standards is essential. Microscopic
examination of rods before and after coating, intermittent inspection between
coating phases and strict adherence to proper handling procedures are mandatory
requirements for every coating process.
When a particular coating has not been previously applied by a coating shop, it is
recommended that the vendor be required to demonstrate the adequacy of his
proposal. One method is to require coating of a short rod of identical material and
similar heat treatment to the proposed rod. After coating, this specimen should be
bent repeatedly on a diameter equal to the diameter equal to the diameter of the rod,
until it fractures.
Acceptable coating adhesion will show no separation from the base metal.
In general, it should be noted that the quality of work by coating shops varies
widely, except for such proprietary processes as Linde D-Gun, which is closely
controlled by Union Carbide.
Figure 800-18 (Part I) includes basic operating, design, dimensional, and metallur-
gical information essential to the coating vendor. This section should be carefully
completed by the Purchaser and included with each piston rod sent to a recondi-
tioning shop. Purchase orders for coating work should require that Part II of
Figure 800-18 be completed by the coating vendor after coating work is complete.
The completed figure, specifying the as-finished coating condition, should then be
returned with the reconditioned rod and become part of the compressor mainte-
nance records. Any refinishing performed after the rod has been in service should
be noted in Part III of Figure 800-18. This information will assist in evaluating the
extension of service life afforded by the coating process.
840 Troubleshooting
841 Introduction
Machinery problems can be exceptionally complex; however, practical solutions
can, in many cases, be simple.
No machine operates perfectly, nor in a perfect environment. Numerous deviations
exist in every machine, yet do not normally surface as operational or maintenance
problems. For example, every machine operates with some imbalance, some
misalignment, some imperfections in installation, etc.
Therefore, when called upon to solve a problem that has surfaced, expect to find
several “deviations” during the investigation. The job is not to find a deviation (or
even several), but to find the deviation, or combination of deviations which are
causing the problem that needs to be corrected.
As in any problem-solving effort, one of the most important steps is to define the
problem. A problem given as “lube-oil pump will not put out—repair as neces-
sary” can result in considerable time and expense spent on overhauling the pump
when replacing a faulty pressure gage or adjusting a turbine governor may have
been all that was required. Look for the simple cause/solution first!
Many problems with compressors fall into one of the following categories:
1. Improper component assembly.
2. Component wear or failure.
3. Deposit-buildup imbalance or flow restriction.
4. Controls/instrumentation out of calibration or faulty.
5. Auxiliary system/driver malfunction.
6. Support system (seals, lubrication, alignment, piping strain, foundation
settling, baseplate warped or poorly grouted).
7. Off-design operating conditions.
Step 2
Analyze the cause of the deviation, based on a combination of practical and tech-
nical knowledge.
Use all available resources. Do not attempt to solve the problem single-handedly.
Input from both technical and non-technical personnel operators, maintenance
mechanics, process engineers, etc., can be invaluable. Obtain the manufacturer's
input as appropriate.
Accurate and current performance and maintenance records should be maintained
on all equipment. Use these records as a valuable source of data to identify changes
since the unit was last operating properly.
Keep an open mind. Avoid jumping to conclusions. Make every attempt to obtain
and analyze all relevant facts. Do not resist changing conclusions if warranted by
discovery of new information.
Step 3
Take corrective action to eliminate the cause.
Step 4
Monitor performance following corrective action.
Step 5
Document the important points and communicate to those who will benefit from
the knowledge gained.
4. Bent Rotor (caused by uneven heating or cooling) Turn rotor at low speed until vibration stops, then gradually increase
speed to operating speed.
If vibration continues, shut down, determine and correct the cause
17. Change in System Resistance due to Obstructions or Improper Check position of inlet/discharge valves
Inlet or Discharge Valve Positions Remove obstructions
22. Sympathetic Vibration Adjacent machinery can cause vibration even when the unit is shut
down, or at certain speeds due to foundation or piping resonance.
A detailed investigation is required in order to take corrective
measures.
25. Piping Strain Inspect piping arrangements and proper installation of pipe hangers,
springs, or expansion joints.
26. Warped Foundation or Bed plate Check for possible settling of the foundation support
Correct footing as required
Check for uneven temperatures surrounding the foundation casing
30. Clogged Oil Strainer/Filter Clean or replace oil strainer or filter cartridges
31. Relief Valve Improperly Set or Stuck Open Adjust relief valve
Recondition or replace
32. Incorrect Pressure Control Valve Setting on Operation Check control valve for correct setting and operation
34. Inadequate Cooling Water Supply Increase cooling water supply to lube-oil cooler
Check for above design cooling water inlet temperature
36. Operation at a very Low speed without the auxiliary oil Pump Increase speed or operate auxiliary lube-oil pump to increase oil
Running (if main L.O. pump is shaft driven) pressure
37. Bearing Lube-Oil Orifices Missing or Plugged Check to see that lube-oil orifices are installed and are not
obstructed
Refer to lube-oil system schematic diagram for orifice locations
40. Failure of Both Main and Auxiliary Oil Pumps Repair or replace pumps
42. Clogged or Restricted Oil Cooler Oil Side Clean or replace cooler
43. Inadequate Flow of Lube-Oil If pressure is satisfactory, check for restricted flow of lube-oil to the
affected bearings
44. Water in Lube-Oil Probably a steam leak condensing in bearings or lube-oil cooler leak.
45. Leak in Lube-Oil Cooler Tube(s) or Tube Sheet Hydrostatically test the tubes and repair as required
Replace zinc protector rods (if installed) more frequently if leaks are
due to electrolytic action of cooling water
46. Condensation in Oil Reservoir During operation maintain a minimum lube-oil reservoir temperature
of 120°F to permit separation of entrained water
When shutting down, stop cooling water flow to oil cooler
Commission lube-oil conditioning unit
Refer to lube-oil management guide
NOTE: Vibration may be transmitted from the coupled machine. To localize vibration, disconnect coupling and operate driver alone. This
should help to indicate whether driver or driven machine is causing vibration.
Abstract
This appendix gives instructions for using a program made available from Warren
Petroleum. This program will model reciprocating compressor performance as
described in Sub-section A1.0. It is only applicable for natural gas, and for known,
or assumed cylinder dimensions.
Contents Page
A1.0 Background
A computer program “GLTW7100" has been developed by Warren Petroleum to
make preliminary reciprocating compressor calculations for natural gas. Calcula-
tions are based on known, or assumed cylinder dimensions, and are only valid
for natural gas.
These calculations are:
• Flow rates (inlet and standard);
• Interstage and discharge temperatures;
• Horsepower;
• Rod loading (gas loads only);
• Surge drum volume estimates;
• Lead line diameter estimates; and
• Intermediate results, such as, volumetric efficiency, compression ratios, percent
clearance, displacement, and compressibility factors.
With predetermined cylinder geometry, these calculations can be used for:
1. Project scoping - Estimating horsepower prior to making a rigorous, detailed
study—estimates are often used as the basis for appropriation requests.
2. Verification of vendors' designs - Compressor vendors use their own propri-
etary computer programs to design compressors. Program GLTW7100 can be
used to check the vendors' design before awarding bids, or fabrication starts, or
to evaluate the effect of proposed changes during fabrication.
3. Rerates of existing equipment - Changing the service conditions of existing
compressors can be computer modeled to determine the effects.
4. Diagnose problems when compressors exhibit unusual behavior (low flow,
high temperatures, resonance problems, etc.).
GLTW7100 can handle up to four stages and up to four cylinders per stage. The
cylinders can be either double- or single-acting. It cannot accommodate side-
streams, refrigeration, or high molecular-weight applications.
A2.0 Procedures
To run this program, several steps must take place. In general you must:
• Install the program on a hard disk
• Gather the data
• Build an input data file
• Run the program
• Print the output
To enter data, press function key F2. This will add a new blank line between the top-
of-file and end-of-file lines and leave the cursor in the first column of the new line
as shown in Figure A-4. Now enter your first line of data and press F2 for another
blank line. Continue this procedure until you have entered all data.
Once you are sure the data is correct, do a save, and exit KEDIT. Press the HOME
key. This will move the cursor to the command line at the bottom of the screen. As
in Figure A-5, type “FILE” and press ENTER. This will save your file and return
you to DOS.
Fig. A-5 Screen Display, KEDIT, Ready for Saving the Data
Plant Name
Compressor Type-
Stages-
** -Enter a “1” if the cylinder clearance is to remain fixed. The program will calcu-
late clearance if left blank.
*** -Enter a “1” for refrigeration compressor. Leave blank for other applications.
† -Enter a “1” to calculate cylinder pulsation bottle and line sizes. Leave blank if
these calculations are not needed.
††-Enter a “1” for fixed volume and (enter volume in record number 500, ”Stan-
dard Volume MSCFD" column).
Mole Weight of Gas - Must be given in lieu of K Value and Z factors. This
program has minimal error for light gases (e.g., molecular weights less than 35);
heavier gases may cause errors in the flow rate.
PV = ZRT, so Z = PV/RT
(Eq. A-1)
If left blank, the program will calculate Z, based on the molecular weight inputted.
Percent Liquid Knockout - Enter the volume percent of liquid knockout after inter-
stage cooling. Note that assuming no knockout will result in a conservative design.
For examples, refer to Figures A-6 and A-7. These figures show the output for a
test case called “Sand Hill”, developed by Warren Petroleum. The Sand Hill file is
contained on the program disk and may be run as a tutorial, or it can be modified to
suit a particular application.
The main output from the program is:
• ACFM for each stage.
• Discharge temperature for each stage (the program includes heat from friction
and irreversibility effects).
• Brake horsepower (BHP) for each stage.
• Total BHP.
• Surge drum minimum diameter and volume estimates for each stage—note that
drum length must be calculated by hand. (Optional printout.)
• Inlet and discharge line size estimates. (Optional printout.)
EV = 93 – R – %cl ( R 1 / K – 1 )
EV Z = ( 1 + C ) – ( 1 + C – EV ⁄ 100 ) × Z s ⁄ Z d
(Eq. A-4)
Piston Displacement (CFD):
A HE ⋅ S ⋅ RPM ⋅ 1440 A CE ⋅ S ⋅ RPM ⋅ 1440
PD = -------------------------------------------------- + --------------------------------------------------
1728 1728
(Eq. A-5)
Gas Loads
Head End: Load = (Piston Area x PD) - (Piston Area - Rod Area) x (PS)
(Eq. A-6)
Crank End Load = (Piston Area - Rod Area) (PD) - (Piston Area x PS)
(Eq. A-7)
Inlet Volume:
TS
ACFD = MSCFD ⋅ 14.7
--------- ⋅ -------
-⋅Z
P 520 S
S
(Eq. A-8)
3
Surge Drum Volume (Ft ):
( PD ⁄ Stroke ) ⋅ ∆V PD
V = --------------------------------------------- and -----------------
( P′ ⁄ P ) 1 / K –1 Stroke
PD
= -------------------- for DA Cylinders
2 ( RPM )
∆V = Volume Rate of Change Factor
P′ ⁄ P = Allowable Pressure Fluctuation Ratio
(Eq. A-9)
Surge Drum Diameter (In) and Length = 2D
Minimum Diameter (D) = 10.32 ⋅ V1/3
Length determined manually from volume above
Contents Page
Contents Page
PQ = 10.73wT
----------------------
M
10.73wTZ
PQ = --------------------------
M
P
P r = -----
Pc
T
T r = ------
Tc
N N N
X 1 = -------1- , X 2 = -------2- , X 3 = -------3- , etc.
Nm Nm Nm
Wv 18 P v
S.H. = ---------- = ------------- ---------------
W da 28.96 P – P v
Pv
= 0.622 ---------------
P – Pv
14.7 T 1 Z 1
= ( SCFM ) ---------
P - --------
520 Z 0
- ------
1
P1 Q1 M
w = --------------------------
10.73T 1 Z 1
P1V1k = P2V2k = C
Z1 + Z2
k-----------
–1
- ------------------
-
r k – 1 2
H ad = RT 1 --------------------------
k–1
------------
k
T 2 = T 1 1 + --------
x
η ad
wH ad
Ghp = -------------------------
-
33 ,000η ad
n–1
H poly = RT 1 r n – 1
------------
Z1 + Z2
--------------------------
n–1 ------------------
2
-
------------
n
wH poly
Ghp = -----------------------
33 ,000η p
ηp
H poly = H ad --------
η ad
k–1
------------
r k –1
η ad = ----------------------
k-----------
– 1
-
kη p
r –1
1
---
r oa n
r = ------------------------
-
( 0.98 ) n – 1
2545
SR = --------------------------------
( h1 – h2 ) ( ηi )
U2
H = K -------
g
µU 2
H = ----------
g
H p 1---
N 2 = N 1 -------- 2
2
Hp
1
w 2 H p2
GHP 2 = GHP 1 -----------------
w 1 H p1
F = 4.3 × 10 –8 N 2 W R A v
14.7 T s Z rc
MMCFD = MMSCFD ---------- --------
14.4 520 Z
- --------
o
( SCFM )T Z rc
MMCFD = ----------------------------s -------
-
353 ,742 Z o
wT s Z rc
MMCFD = ------------------
932 M
14.4 Z s
Q = ( MMCFD ) ( 10 6 ) ---------- -------- --------------------------
day
P Z 1 ,440 min.
s rc
10 4 Z s
= ( MMCFD ) -------- --------
P Z
s rc
Bhp ( 10 4 )Z S
Q = V d E v = -------------------------------------------------------------
-
( Bhp ⁄ MMCFD )Z rc ( P s )
4 ,320 ( SG )
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ---------------------------
T s Z rc
3 ,624 ( SG ) + 696
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ------------------------------------------
T s Z rc
6 ,027 ( SG )
Bhp ⁄ MM ( SG ) = ---------------------------
T s Z rc
Ps
MF = ----------------
-
Ps – Pv
π D 2 SN D 2 SN
V d = --- --------------- = ---------------
4 1 ,728 2 ,200
( 2D 2 – d 2 )SN
V d = -----------------------------------
2 ,200
( D 2 – d 2 )SN
V d = --------------------------------
1 ,100
288V
V = ---------------d-
A
C2.0 Nomenclature
A Area
ACFM Compressor volume flow rate at any conditions specified
A.P.S. Average piston speed of reciprocating compressor pistons
Av Peak-peak vibration amplitude
a1 Speed of sound in gas at inlet conditions
H Compressor head
Had Adiabatic head
Hisot Isothermal head
Hpoly Polytropic head
H p , Hp Polytropic head at conditions specified
1 2
h1, h2 Enthalpy at conditions specified
h2(theo) Theoretical enthalpy at conditions specified
ICFM Compressor volume flow rate at inlet conditions
K Constant
k Ratio of specific heats
M Molecular weight
Mach No. Mach number in gas at inlet conditions
MCp Molal heat capacity of a gas
MCp(m) Molal heat capacity of gas mixture
M.F. Moisture factor in BHP/MM equation
Mm Molecular weight of a mixture
MMCFD Million cubic feet per day at 14.4 psia pressure and compressor
inlet temperature
MMSCFD Million cubic feet per day at standard conditions
MPH Moles per hour
N Rotating speed
n Polytropic exponent; or number of compression steps
N.C.L.F. Non-lube factor in BHP/MM equation
Nm Total moles in a gas mixture
Nmax Maximum impeller speed
N1, N2 Operating speed at conditions specified
N1,2,3...i Number of moles of a gas component in a gas mixture
p Pressure in pounds per square foot
P Pressure in pounds per square inch (gage or absolute)
Pc Critical pressure of a gas
Pc(m) Critical pressure of a gas (Mixture)
Pd Discharge pressure
Pr Reduced pressure
Ps Suction pressure
Psat Partial pressure of water vapor in air when fully saturated
Pv Partial pressure of water vapor in air
Pv(wb) Vapor pressure corresponding to wet bulb temperature
P1, P2 Pressure at conditions specified
T Absolute temperature
t Drybulb temperature
Tc Critical temperature of a gas
Tc(m) Critical temperature of a gas mixture
Td Absolute discharge temperature
td Fahrenheit discharge temperature
Tr Reduced temperature
Ts Absolute suction temperature
ts Fahrenheit suction temperature
twb Wetbulb temperature
T1, T2 Absolute temperature at conditions specified
T2(theo) Theoretical discharge temperature
V Volume, Velocity
Vc Reciprocating compressor cylinder clearance volume
Vcyl Reciprocating compressor cylinder displacement volume
Vd Reciprocating compressor displacement rate
Vrel Inlet gas velocity relative to an impeller blade
V1, V2 Volume at conditions specified
W Weight
w Weight flow rate
Wda Weight of dry air
Wv Weight of water vapor in air
w1, w2 Weight flow rate at conditions specified
X A factor
X1,2,3...i Mole fractions in a gas mixture
Z Gas compressibility
Zavg Gas compressibility at compressor average conditions
Zd Gas compressibility at discharge conditions
Zo Gas compressibility at standard conditions
Zrc Gas compressibility at 14.4 psia pressure and suction temperature
Zs Gas compressibility at suction conditions
Z1, Z2 Gas compressibility at conditions specified
Contents Page
Units of Specific Energy Multiply units in left column by proper factor below
absolute Joule/g int. Joule/g cal/g int. cal/g Btu/lb.
1 absolute Joule/gram 1 0.99984 0.23901 0.23885 0.42993
1 int. Joule/gram 1.000165 1 0.23904 0.23892 0.43000
1 calorie/gram 4.1840 4.1833 1 0.99935 1.7988
1 int. calorie/gram 4.1867 4.1860 1.00065 1 1.8000
1 Btu/lb 2.3260 2.3256 0.55592 0.55556 1
NOTE: The center column of numbers refers to the temperature in degrees, either Centigrade or Fahrenheit, which it is desired to convert into the other scale. If converting from Fahrenheit to
Centrigrade degrees, the equivalent temperature will be found in the left column, while if converting from degrees Centrigrade to degrees Fahrenheit, the answer will be found in the column
on the right.
Contents Page
Contents Page
Contents Page
Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Contents Page
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
From “Thermodynamic Properties of Steam” by Keenan and Keyes, 1936, Ingersoll-Rand. Courtesy of Dresser-Rand
Contents Page
Contents Page
J1.0 Overview
Appendix J consists of two parts, which collectively cover compressor cylinder and
packing lubrication. In summary:
• Part 1 - This is an overview of compressor cylinder and packing lubrication,
discussing the importance of cylinder and packing lubrication. It defines the
differences between distribution block and pump-to-point lubrication
schemes. Part 1 also provides oil feed rates, and outlines precautions necessary
for a trouble-free installation.
• Part 2 - This is a vendor discussion of the subject (Courtesy of Cooper
Cameron Corporation). It is primarily intended for field personnel, concen-
trating on the “nuts and bolts” of cylinder and packing lubrication. It provides
enlarged illustrations, and installation and maintenance procedures.
fresh oil continuously dilutes the old, maintaining the correct viscosity and benefi-
cial effects of the additives. If the crankcase oil is not compatible with cylinder oil,
distribution block systems then use separate reservoirs. Pump-to-point oilers have
self-contained reservoirs and do not use crankcase oil.
The quantity of cylinder and packing oil is critical. If too much oil is injected, it
may build up inside the cylinder or lead to valve deposits; it can flood the packing
and lead to a housekeeping mess; and it will increase operating costs. Too much oil
can also damage teflon parts. If too little oil is injected, metal-to-metal contact will
occur, leading to overheating problems, scored cylinders, worn rings, and other
repairs.
Figure J-1 is a chart listing typical oil requirements based on cylinder diameter and
piston speed.
One way to vary the lube-oil feed rate is to control the speed of the lubricator.
When several are connected together, the entire assembly must be driven at the
slowest speed that will satisfy all the points. This speed can drive some lubricators
in the train too fast, leading to over-lubrication. See Part 2, Page 5B-1 for additional
information on oilers.
Pump maintenance is described on Page 5B-3 of Part 2. In addition, it is important
to:
1. Keep oil reservoirs closed.
2. Regularly check inside reservoirs for accumulation of water and dirt, especially
after washing down the machinery.
When starting and priming the lubrication system, it is important to check ruptured
disks (if so equipped). Replace any broken ones. Also see Part 2, Page 5B-3.
Distribution block systems often incorporate their own specific reservoir. However,
where the crankcase oil is compatible with cylinder/packing oil, it is suggested that
the crankcase be the sole reservoir for both systems.
For example, oil from a drum (typically mounted on a stand above the crankcase
level) is metered and gravitates to the compressor crankcase. A level controller is
used to maintain the proper level.
A sidestream of low pressure crankcase oil is supplied by the crankcase pump to a
25 micron filter and pressure regulator. The filter should be mounted with the
connections on the top so that waste will be trapped inside the disposable housing.
Note that if oilers with dedicated cylinder/packing reservoirs are used, they must be
checked for the proper level periodically, as make-up oil is not available from the
crankcase.
J2.1 Precautions
Distributor block systems can be trouble free, providing they are properly installed
and maintained. Consider the following:
• Oil must be kept clean and dry.
• Replace filters regularly.
• Keep any disconnected lines closed. Also, block the connection on the machine.
• Replace damaged tubing with new stock—do not reuse old tubing. Blow
through tubing with air to remove any debris, before installation.
• Do not attempt to clean up the pistons or cylinders of the distributor blocks
with coarse abrasive paper. This will destroy the very close clearances (0.0005
inch) and unbalance oil distribution.
• Do not install a higher pressure than specified rupture disk or more than one
disk in a single fitting to prevent ruptures. Repetitive disk ruptures always indi-
cate trouble—either an oil outlet is restricted, the system is incorrectly
designed for existing conditions, the wrong viscosity oil or the wrong rupture
disks are in use.
• Paper oil filter elements are preferred over sintered metal ones because they are
disposable, and it is impossible to tell when a sintered element is clean
enough. Debris lodges inside where it is impossible to see.
Contents Page
K1.0 Introduction
Environmental protection and maintaining safety require close attention to contain-
ment of gas contaminated with hydrogen sulfide. Reciprocating compressors will
always have some gas leakage from the cylinders. The leakage occurs along the
piston rod and through the rod packer. This appendix outlines requirements for
preventing the escape of toxic, corrosive gas into the atmosphere or the compressor
crankcase. Leakage into the crankcase not only will result in atmospheric contami-
nation but, also, can result in crankcase explosions. The principles described herein
may also be applied to other compression services where controlled disposition of
leakage is required.
K1.1 Summary
Six designs for preventing the escape of gas from a compressor cylinder packer into
the atmosphere are discussed in Section I.
Designs 1 and 2 are conventional, non-purged arrangements which provide limited
protection. Designs 3 and 4 use purge gas to block the entry of gas into the distance
piece. Using a purge will prevent any leakage of H2S containing gas into the atmo-
sphere except when poor compressor rod or packer condition results in excessive
packer leakage. Designs 5 and 6, using expensive and space consuming double-
compartment distance pieces, will provide some additional protection in the event
of excessive packer leakage. However, the probability of needing this extra protec-
tion is low.
All designs require venting to a gas disposal system operating at a pressure less
than 10 psig and preferably, near atmospheric pressure.
Basic considerations and mechanical design features are discussed in Section II. It
must be emphasized that packer and wiper designs discussed in the following
require careful consideration of pressures to be encountered and of other applica-
tion details. Design must be a coordinated effort between the user, the compressor
manufacturer, and the packing manufacturer.
Fig. K-1 Guide to the Selection of Packer & Distance Piece Venting Systems for H2S Service (1 of 2)
Design No.
1 2 3 4 5 6
Governing Selection Factor
Allowable Atmospheric Contamination
(a) Continuous, Non-Toxic (odor ok) x
(b) None During Normal Operating x
(c) None, With Exceptions(1) x x
(d) None(2) x
B. Compressor Housing
(a) Open - 3 Side Minimum x x x x x x
(b) Closed (3) (3) x x
C. Environment
(a) Unpopulated Areas x
(b) In-Plant, Populated Areas x x x x x
Fig. K-1 Guide to the Selection of Packer & Distance Piece Venting Systems for H2S Service (2 of 2)
Design No.
1 2 3 4 5 6
Relative Ranking (A=Preferred, B=Acceptable, C=Undesirable)
D. Other Considerations
(a) Operator Safety C B A- A- A A
(b) Minimum Crankcase Contamination A B+ B+ B+ A- A
(c) Installed Cost A A- B B- C C
(d) Maintenance Effort A A- B B C C
(e) Equipment Space Required A A A A B B
(f) Purge Gas Use Rate - B- B C C C-
(g) Adaptability to Existing Compressors A B B B C C
(1) Some H2S escape permitted for short periods in the event of unforeseeable failures
(2) Least H2S escape possible under any circumstance
(3) Design not recommended unless safety devices recommended in Figure K-2 are used
Fig. K-2 Design Details, Packer & Distance Piece Venting Systems for H2S Service (1 of 2)
Design No.
1 2 3 4 5 6
(1) (1) (1) (2)
IB OB IB OB(1)
Distance Piece
No. of Compartments 1 1 1 1 2 2
Solid Access Covers R x x x x x x x
Cover Gaskets x x x x x x
Vent to Disposal System x x x
Vent to Atmosphere x x
Nitrogen Purge x x x
Rod Packer
Vent to Disposal System x x x x x x
Nitrogen Purge x x x
(2) (2)
Sweet Gas Purge
Preloaded Outer Rings R x x
Rod Wiper
Oil Control Rings x x x x x x
Preloaded Seal Rings x x x x
Code: x=required; R=recommended option. Superscripted numbers refer to footnotes.
Fig. K-2 Design Details, Packer & Distance Piece Venting Systems for H2S Service (2 of 2)
Design No.
1 2 3 4 5 6
(1) (1) (1) (2)
IB OB IB OB(1)
Rod-Diaphragm Packer x x
Safety Devices
Dist. Piece Safety Valve (4) x (4) x x (4)
Indicators
Purge Gas Flow Rate R R R R R
Distance Piece Pressure (5) R (5) (5)
The appendices in API 618 include figures that show the locations of vents and
purges for the designs discussed below.
are in good condition, providing the purge gas pressure is always greater than the
packer vent system pressure. However, poor mechanical condition will probably
result in gas blowing through the distance piece and into the atmosphere. Failure of
the purge gas system will have the same result. Therefore, Design 2 should not be
used for compressors handling highly toxic concentrations of H2S, particularly if
the compressor is housed. It should not be used for any H2S service when odor
from escaping gas is highly objectionable.
Fig. K-4 Two Cup Wiper Assembly with One Set of Seal Rings
Double-compartment distance pieces are generally used only for very hazardous
services, such as near 100% concentration of highly toxic or corrosive gases, or
oxygen. These distance pieces have a partition containing an auxiliary rod packer to
isolate the two compartments. Either or both compartments may have solid covers
and vent connections. Both compartments should have drain connections.
• Distance piece and packer vents may be piped separately to different gas
disposal systems. They also can be connected to a single disposal system
through common piping outside of the compressor. In either case, it is essential
that the piping does not restrict the flow of vented gas. Any unnecessary restric-
tion will increase the gas pressure in the packer vent cup or in the distance
piece. Increased pressure in either will increase the possibility of leaking unde-
sirable gas to the atmosphere.
Contents Page
P–F
Reliability ( % ) = ------------ ( 100 )
P
P–F–S
Availability ( % ) = ---------------------- ( 100 )
P
where:
P = hours in measurement period
F = hours of downtime caused by forced outages in period
S = hours of downtime in period caused by scheduled outages (main-
tenance)
The period P is often taken as the expected length of a continuous run of the plant
in which the compressor is installed. However, most published reliability and avail-
ability values are based on average annual downtimes. In the case of availability,
averaging is necessary because a particular machine probably does not have consis-
tent maintenance needs from year to year. For example, a hypothetical machine
may only require 100 hours of downtime annually for routine inspection and main-
tenance for the first four years. But in the fifth year, it might need fifteen days or
more of downtime for a major overhaul. The availability of the compressor system
should be compatible with the desired availability of the plant.
If possible, the cost of downtime in terms of lost production should be determined.
This will provide a better perspective of the requirements for reliability and avail-
ability.
In some process plants, a forced outage may pose a risk of losses in addition to
production losses. For example, an emergency trip of a recycle compressor could
cause a damaging high temperature excursion in the reactor if the backup quench
system failed to respond soon enough. This might be a rare double-jeopardy situa-
tion, and it would be difficult to do a numerical evaluation of the risk because there
would probably have to be a number of excursions before the reactor failed. Never-
theless, a qualitative consideration of the potential catastrophic loss might give reli-
ability the utmost priority among the major factors to be considered in selecting the
compressor. Such potential risks should be discussed in detail with the client.
In the case of two 100% machines, the system is treated as two fully parallel units
because only one machine has to be running at any given time to achieve 100%
capacity. Therefore, the individual or unit reliabilities are not multiplied by each
other. When two 100% machines are in series in a system, the overall system reli-
ability is the product of the individual reliabilities.
In the case of three 50% machines, two machines are treated as though they are in
series, despite the fact they are piped in parallel. Two machines must run simulta-
neously to achieve 100% capacity. Therefore, to make 100% capacity, they act as
though they are piped in series. The spare 50% machine is treated as a unit in
parallel with the other two.
Contents Page
Vendor Equipment
Type I - Maintenance Analyzers
Gas Equipment Testing GET 2000
Roanoke, Texas
(817) 431-3980
PMC/Beta Corporation Beta 350
Houston, Texas
(713) 820-2224
Cooper Energy Services EN-SPEC 2000
Mount Vernon, Ohio
(614) 397-0121
Beta Monitors and Controls Ltd.
300, 1615-10 Ave. S.W.
Calgary, Alberta,
CANADA T3C0J7
(800) 661-9160
Type II - Performance Analyzers
Gas Equipment Testing PRM 2000
Roanoke, Texas
(817) 431-3980
PMC/Beta Corporation Beta 250
Houston, Texas
(713) 870-2224
Cooper Energy Services EN-SPEC 3000
Mount Vernon, Ohio
(614) 397-0121
Beta Monitors and Controls Ltd.
300, 1615-10 Ave. S.W.
Calgary, Alberta,
CANADA T3C0J7
(800) 661-9160
Contents Page
Abstract
This appendix gives instructions for using CENTCOMP a spreadsheet-based
centrifugal compressor performance program for IBM compatible personal
computers. The program allows the user to study performance of existing machines
with varying operating conditions and/or operating modes. The user may also
compare a single field operating test point to original design data provided by the
manufacturer.
Contents Page
O1.0 Introduction
O1.1 History
CENTCOMP is an updated and expanded version of COMPERF, a centrifugal
compressor performance program which resides in the mainframe VM system.
Based on a Company-wide survey of machinery computer program users in 1989, a
need for a personal computer based centrifugal performance program was identi-
fied. CENTCOMP was developed to fill this need.
CENTCOMP is a template type program which operates on Lotus 1-2-3, Version
2.01. Lotus was selected because it is flexible, “user friendly,” and available to
nearly everyone with an IBM compatible personal computer.
O1.2 Description
CENTCOMP is a spreadsheet-based program which analyzes a centrifugal
compressor's performance at conditions other than the for which it was originally
designed. It can also reduce actual field operating data and compare it to the
expected performance. The program presents results in both tables and graphs. All
operations use a simple custom menu.
Three other programs are provided with CENTCOMP. The first, CENTDATA,
allows the user to develop input files outside of CENTCOMP. It also operates on a
custom menu. Although data may be directly input into CENTCOMP itself, CENT-
DATA is a convenient vehicle for storing individual case files, requiring much less
memory. The second program, named README.DOC, is an ASCII version of this
written documentation. The third is CENT_GPH which is called automatically by
CENTCOMP during graph requests.
O1.3 Purpose
CENTCOMP was designed for engineering, maintenance, and operating manage-
ment people who want to evaluate their centrifugal compressors by:
• Studying “what if” scenarios with different gas, pressure, temperature, and
flow conditions.
• Looking at alternate operating modes by varying speed and/or by selecting
whether the suction pressure or discharge pressure remains fixed.
• Comparing a single field operating test point to the original design data. This
option also considers the influence data inaccuracies have on the solution. It
also may be used to trend a compressor's performance over time.
CENTCOMP analyzes only single section, sometimes called single stage, compres-
sors. A section is any number of compressor impellers which are connected in
series without any external heating or cooling.
For example, a four nozzle machine with intercooling between the second and third
nozzles is a two section compressor. Each section must be analyzed independently.
However, a train of two direct-coupled compressor casings, piped in series without
intercooling, could be evaluated as one section.
fore, it is recommended that the first time user initially call up CENTDATA to input
data.
Both CENTDATA and CENTCOMP contain custom macros which automatically
appear when they are initially loaded. The first screen contains basic operating
instructions. Whenever a macro is in control, a “CMD” will appear at the bottom of
the screen. This means that the program is:
1. Waiting for the user to select an option from the menu appearing at the top of
the screen.
2. Waiting for the user to press [Enter] after reading an information screen or
inputting certain data.
3. Taking an extended time to execute the last command.
The user may stop a macro's control or execution by pressing either [Esc] or [Ctrl]
[Break]. Press [Alt] [x] to return to the custom menu. This will be necessary after
typing data onto the Design or Field input screens.
Both programs are protected from inadvertent input which might change or damage
their function. Input is only permitted in the designated data cells. Attempts to input
elsewhere will generate a warning 'beep' and a “Protected Cell” note at the bottom
of the screen. If this occurs, press [Esc] to resume.
Users who are familiar with Lotus 1-2-3 may be concerned by a “CIRC” or
Circular Calculation message which appears at the bottom of the screen. This is
harmless and may be ignored.
If the gear option is not chosen, the program will assume there is no drive gear. The
“Design” and “New” speeds are also required.
CENTCOMP and CENTDATA will accept up to 9 performance curve data points.
The more points inputted, the better the curve resolution. The first point normally
represents surge, the left hand limit of the curve for a given speed. The last point
represents the “stonewall” or end-of-the-curve overload condition.
INPUT—FIELD must be completed when the user wishes to compare a field oper-
ating test point to the original design performance. Since accurate measurements
are difficult in the field, the program asks for estimated data “Tolerances.” It will
use the tolerances to calculate and show the test point's relative zone of possibility.
The “Flowmeter Element Design Basis” data is required gas condition and element
location information. It is used to calculate meter reading adjustments for differing
conditions.
INPUT—UNITS—DESIGN gives the user several units options for inputting the
“Design” data. The macro will automatically step through the options. The user
only has to enter each selection and press [Enter].
INPUT—UNITS—FIELD offers units options for inputting the “Field” data. Like
described above, the selection process is automated by a macro.
INPUT—UNITS—QUIT returns to the INPUT level of the menu.
INPUT—QUIT returns to the opening level of the menu.
FILE allows the user to save a CENTDATA file. When asked for a file name, the
user should input a unique subject name to avoid overwriting the master programs.
The FILE selection continues as a branch in the CENTCOMP menu tree.
FILE—SAVE stores the newly inputted or altered data from CENTCOMP.
FILE—RETRIEVE reads user data into CENTCOMP. These files were previ-
ously created either with the help of CENTDATA or directly from a CENTCOMP
FILE—SAVE command.
FILE—QUIT returns to the opening level of the CENTCOMP menu.
GRAPHS—VIEW—PRESSURE-FLOW displays a Pressure vs. Flow curve on
the screen for the “New” conditions. If field data was inputted, the graph will also
display a box which represents the calculated zone of possibility. Based on the
user's tolerances, the relative field operating point would lie somewhere inside the
box.
GRAPHS—VIEW—POWER-FLOW similarly displays the same information on
a Power vs. Flow curve.
GRAPHS—\VIEW—EFFIC.-FLOW similarly displays the same information for
a Polytropic Efficiency vs. Flow curve.
GRAPHS—VIEW—QUIT returns to the GRAPHS menu level.
facturer includes unspecified losses in the power values, the resulting efficien-
cies will be less precise than if they were directly inputted. When the user has
an option of inputting either power or polytropic efficiency “Design” curves,
the efficiency values should be used.
• Specific Heat Ratio Sensitivity. The gas specific heat ratio (K) is used as an
exponent in the program's calculations. The performance results are therefore
very sensitive to this value. The user must take care in assuring that it is accu-
rate, preferably to the third decimal place.
When the user elects the program's Field Test Data analysis, there are a few
concerns which will impact the resulting accuracy:
• Gas Analysis. Getting good field gas analyses frequently proves to be difficult.
The amount of every gas species must be accurately known to get accurate
molecular weights, specific heat ratios, and compressibilities. This is particu-
larly challenging in wet gas compressors which operate at or near the gas dew
points.
Another source of significant error is water (steam) in the gas which is not
measured by some chromatographs. One final problem is wet gas compressor
wash fluids. These confuse the gas analysis and the flow measurements and
should be temporarily turned off when running the test.
• Temperature Measurements. CENTCOMP calculates field polytropic effi-
ciencies from the inlet and discharge temperatures and pressures. A few
degrees error in temperature can often generate as much as 2% or 3% in effi-
ciency error. Therefore, it is best to use thermocouples in thermowells located
close to the compressor flanges. Reading line surface temperature with a
pyrometer several feet away may yield unacceptable data.
• Pressure Gages. The test gages should have the optimum range for the pres-
sure and be freshly calibrated before the test. Watch for velocity head errors if
the gage is measuring a low pressure in a high gas velocity location.
• Flowmeters. Each compressor section must have its own flowmeter. The flow
element should be checked to make sure its correct design data is inputted to
the program. Before a test, the flowmeter must also be zeroed and spanned for
accurate reading.
• Timing. Take the test data during a stable time in the process which represents
typical operation.
Abstract
This appendix gives guidelines for designing and selecting knockout pots and high
efficiency filters for compressor suction systems.
Contents Page
Surge Volume
Surge volume is defined as the liquid capacity below the maximum allowable liquid
level. The designer must factor into this vessel dimension any additional capacity
necessary to control potential liquid loading. Figure P-1 illustrates surge volume
and other design features of a basic vertical knockout drum.
For compressor suction knockout service, a minimum recommended fill time of
five minutes, based on maximum potential liquid loading, should be provided
between the high level alarm (LAH) and the automatic compressor shutdown
(LSH). This time period is based on the amount of time necessary for operating
personnel to respond to the high level, and should be adjusted to suit the operating
circumstances. Discussions with experienced operating personnel is recommended.
Liquid Drainage
Liquid drainage capacity must be addressed in a similar manner. Failure to
adequately size drain lines and level control valves for the above conditions can
result in uncontrollable high levels and consequential shutdowns. Part of this judg-
ment comes from understanding the location of the vessel and relative availability
of operating personnel during upset conditions. A two-inch outlet provision is
recommended as a minimum.
0.5
V = K [ ( ρL – ρG ) ⁄ ρ G ]
where:
V = Optimum gas velocity, ft./sec.
K = Factor used for optimum liquid/gas separation
ρG = Gas Density
ρL = Liquid Density
Empirical data suggests that when sizing the minimum inside diameter of a basic
vertical gravity separator (no impingement device), the following K values should
be used:
K = 0.11 or less Gas streams containing high liquid
loading with no impingement device
K = 0.15 - 0.17 Gas streams containing low liquid
loading with no impingement device
These values were largely determined through experiments with a perforated plate
column where tray spacing and liquid seal depths were varied to observe the effect
on K value. The K value was observed to level off between 0.17 to 0.19 at a disen-
gaging space of 28 inches, suggesting a reasonable value for simple gravity separa-
tion without the aid of impingement devices.
These values are consistent with the Scrubber Services Classes 'A', 'B', and 'C' as
described in API Specification 11P - Specification for Packaged Reciprocating
Compressors for Oil and Gas Production Services, however, slightly more conserva-
tive. In the interest of maximizing compressor reliability, it is preferred to design on
the conservative side to provide a degree of process capacity contingency.
For further guidance regarding allowable mass velocities for system pressures
above and below 800 psi at given vapor/liquid densities, refer to Chevron Research
chart RE 690433-1. Charts RD 663794-1, and RD 663795-1 are also reference tools
for required vessel diameter as a function of gas rate and system properties.
Note Inside diameter of the annular support ring is the dimension to use in the
vessel area calculation when the vessel is equipped with a demister pad or vane
mist eliminator. This represents the velocity for the inlet surface area of the impinge-
ment device.
Fig. P-2 Approximate removal efficiency of conventional mist elimination devices for given
particle sizes. Note that the effectiveness of vane mist eliminators is marginal at
the point where woven mesh efficiency is near its peak.
Fig. P-4 The approximate range of water aerosols entrained in air is plotted in this graph to illustrate the aerosol
concentration versus particle size and type of media effective to use for control. Note that as the aerosol
particle size declines, higher efficiency media is required to achieve efficient particle contact.
particle size cut-off point. The expected particle size cutoff (98% efficiency) is
about 15 micron, resulting in a considerable amount of aerosols carried through
with the gas.
The ability of the vane mist eliminator to handle large volumes of liquid at rela-
tively high vapor velocity is one of its key benefits. As long as the actual vapor
velocity is restricted to proper design K values, reasonable liquid scrubbing effi-
ciency is achieved with minimum pressure drop and fouling.
When determining a vessel diameter for vane mist eliminators, the actual velocity is
calculated using the same Souders Brown equation previously discussed in
Section P1.2, Determining Vessel Diameter. The recommended K values for vane
mist eliminators in vertical vessels are:
• Minimum K value = 0.12
• Maximum K value = 0.54
• K value 0.60 and above = Re-entrainment
A maximum K value of 0.54 is recommended for vertical vessels. This is approxi-
mately 120% of design rate to protect against carryover during upsets and unusual
operating conditions. A minimum K value of 0.12 is a turndown limitation to
prevent an insufficient velocity condition such that aerosols tend to flow around the
vanes in laminar gas flows, as opposed to impinging on the vane surfaces.
Another benefit of the vane mist eliminator is its stout physical structure. In corro-
sive services, a wire mesh pad can be relatively short lived compared to a vane mist
eliminator. In this circumstance, a combination of wire mesh and vanes can be of
further benefit. In either case, a conservative corrosion allowance is recommended
when separating corrosive liquid/gas vapors.
Combination Installations
Vane mist eliminators can be used in tandem with wire mesh pads to control the
amount of liquid pooling within the pad. Contacting the bulk of vapor entrained
liquids with vane mist eliminators prior to flowing to the wire mesh pad enhances
the pad's ability to quickly drain. This application also increases the effective oper-
ating range of the demister pad, particularly during unusual liquid loading
scenarios. Figure P-5 plots the liquid scrubbing performance of a vane mist elimi-
nator installed upstream of a woven wire mesh pad.
Fig. P-5 The point at which pressure drop indicates flooding is plotted for different rates of
liquid loading. The wide range of liquid handling capacity is attributed to the
installation of a vane mist eliminator in front of a demister pad to relieve the pad
of excessive liquid load.
In addition to the added removal capacity of vanes, another reason for enhanced
mesh pad performance in tandem configuration is the straightening of the gas flow
entering the pad. Swirling and lateral gas flow entry promotes pooling in the pad,
thus increasing the likelihood of pad flooding and re-entrainment.
Combination installations are well suited for minimizing mesh pad fouling and
corrosion. Fouling solids are effectively removed in the vane section and corrosive
liquids that pool in the mesh pad can be minimized.
The result of combination installations is reduced pad fouling and corrosion, as
well as enhanced removal efficiency over a wide range of loading. It is a good
retrofit alternative for systems that are operated beyond original design. Figure P-6
illustrates how a combination installation might look.
Fig. P-9 Minimum Recommended Clearance Between Outlet Nozzle and Top of Mist Elimi-
nation Device
Vh ⁄ Vs = ( L ⁄ t ) ( D ⁄ t ) = L ⁄ D
where:
Vh = horizontal gas velocity, ft/sec.
Vs = particle settling velocity, ft/sec.
t = time in seconds
L = length between inlet and outlet, ft
D = vessel diameter, ft
The equation is further modified to provide five feet for entrance and exit flow stabi-
lization. The allowable horizontal gas velocity is then expressed as:
V h = [ ( L – 5 ) ⁄ D ] [ K ] [ ( ρ L – ρ g ) ⁄ ρ g ] 0.5
Re-writing the equation into the form of the Souders Brown equation, it is
expressed as:
V h = K ( ( ρ L – ρ g ) ⁄ ρ g ) 0.5
h
where:
Kh = K ( L – 5 ) ⁄ D
SEPDES
When designing or modifying two- and three-phase separators, an easier alternative
to hand calculations would be to use SEPDES, a PC program for designing
liquid/gas separators for hydroprocessing units. Information for this program is
available through your local process engineer or through CRTC’s Process Engi-
neering Specialists.
The velocity limits described in Section P1.0 still apply, as they are meant to ensure
that the selected internals are operated within their efficiency range. As with all
other mist elimination applications, the inlet surface area of the mist elimination
device is used when determining the optimum velocity or K factor, not the cross-
sectional area of the vessel.
Figure P-11 illustrates an example of a horizontal vessel equipped with mesh pad
and liquid storage area. Figure P-12 illustrates several other alternative internal
configurations that, if designed within the criteria previously discussed, will
provide good protection from liquid carryover.
N O TES: