You are on page 1of 25

Characteristics o f t h e

Workplace
We have described some of the effects of the social and psychological climate
in which work takes place. The structure of the organization, its style of leader-
ship, and the motivations of employees all influence productivity and job
satisfaction. But the more tangible aspects of the workplace-physical fea-
tures, working hours, safety issues, and concerns about physical and emo-
tional health-also are influential.
Chapter 10 deals with physical conditions of work, including lighting,
noise, temperature, color, and music. Work hours and work schedules are dis-
cussed, along with factors such as fatigue, monotony, and sexual harassment.
Accidents, violence, alcoholism, and drug abuse are covered in chapter 11.
Psychologists help to determine the causes of workplace accidents and
violence and ways to prevent them. Dependence on alcohol or illicit drugs is
both a personal tragedy and a personnel problem. Psychologists design
employee assistance programs for troubled workers at all occupational levels.
Chapter 12 considers the stresses that result from various physical and psy-
chological conditions of work, including conflicts between the demands of the
job and those of home and family. Psychologists have developed ways of pre-
venting such stress and of treating it on and off the job.
C H A P T E R 1 0

I CHAPTER OUTLINE
PHYSICAL WORKING CONOXTIONS The Four-Day Workweek
Navsbreak: Complaints About Your Job? Maybe Flexible Work Schedules
You're Experiencing Bad Workplace Design Rest Breaks
Work Sites Newsbreak: The Modern Flextime Virtual Mom
Office and Workplace Design Shift Work
Environmental Psychology: Landscaped Offices Newsbreak: Asleep on the Job? Good for You!
and Cubicles
PSYCHOLOGICAL AND SOCIAL ISSUES
Newsbreak: Does Anyone Get Work Done in
Those Dilbert- Style Cubicles? Job Simplification
Lighting Boredom and Monotony
Noise Physical Fatigue
Ethnic and Gender Harassment
Color
Music
Navsbreak: Put a Little Red in Your Life
Telecommuting: The Virtual Workplace at Home
SUMMARY
i
Temperature and Humidity KEY TERMS
WORK SCHEDULES REVIEW QUESTIONS
Working Hours
Permanent Part-Time Employment ADDITIONAL READING
Chapter 10: Working Conditions

PHYSICAL WORKING tivity? Was it physical changes such as a new


climate-control system, brighter lighting, or better
CONDITIONS soundproofing? Or was it a more subtle psycholog-
Look around. Are you in the dorm? An Internet [cal factor such as employees' more positive atti-
cafk? The library? An office? What is it like? tude toward management for instituting the
Comfortable and quiet? Noisy and distracting? changes?
Bright and attractive? Cold and drab? These are Although the results may be beneficial for the
just some of the physical characteristics of a work company, whatever the cause, management needs
environment that can determine how well employees to be able to explain the reasons for any improve-
are able to do their jobs. Whatever the task- ments in productivity or satisfaction. Suppose the
studying, repairing an engine, designing software- improvements occurred because employees are
our surroundings can affect our skill, motivation, pleased that their company is treating them as
and satisfaction. human beings rather than cogs in a machine. If so,
An organization can recruit and select the best the company will want to know whether there are
employees, train them thoroughly, provide out- other ways to improve satisfaction and productivity
standing leaders and a n optimal organizational that do not involve expensive alterations to the
climate to maximize job performance, but if the physical workplace.
physical working conditions are uncomfortable, In many industries people work at peak
productivity will suffer. Uncongenial work settings efficiency under what appear to be intolerable con-
can lead to decreased productivity, lower job ditions. And there are many instances of poor per-
satisfaction, more mistakes and accidents, and formance and low morale in well-equipped, lavishly
increased absenteeism and turnover. decorated surroundings. The effects of changes in
When a workplace is made more comfortable physical working conditions may be influenced or
or working hours are made more flexible, produc- modified by how employees perceive, accept, and
tivity usually increases, at least temporarily. But be adapt to these changes. Therefore, the physical fea-
careful in interpreting such changes in perform- tures of the workplace must be considered in light
ance. What, precisely, caused the greater produc- of complex psychological factors.

Complaints About Your Job? Maybe You're


Experiencing Bad Workplace Design
What do you think is the number one complaint Not enough storage or filing space at the
of people who work in offices? What is it about workstation
their workplace that bothers them more than
anything else? Take a guess. According to the
International Facility Management Association,
. Poor quality of indoor air
Lack of privacy at the workstation

1
the number one office complaint relates to
temperature-the workplace is too cold. And the
number two complaint? The office is too hot!
. Inadequate parking
problems
Too much noise in the workplace
Here are the rest of the top 10 complaints Do any of these apply to your work or study
reported by office workers: area?

I Poor janitorial service


Not enough conference space
Part Four: Characterisiics of the Workplace
...
Work Sites
The physical work environment includes many fac-
tors, from the size of the parking lot and location of
the building to the amount of natural light and
noise in the work area. Inadequate parking spaces
or a parking lot located too far from the building
can so irritate employees that their attitude toward
the organization is negative before they reach their
workstation.
The location of the work site, whether in the
downtown of a large city or in a more remote sub-
urban area, can also affect employees' satisfaction
with their jobs. For example, suburban office parks
are often isolated from the shops, restaurants, and
other services found in cities. Surveys show that
young, single employees typically prefer living and
working in cities, whereas married people tend to
prefer the quieter suburbs as better places to work can be noisy and distracting.
and rear children.
Organizations offer various amenities to attract
and retain dedicated employees. Some companies
the quality of the food in the company cafeteria,
have turned themselves into vacation resorts with
and inconvenient or poorly maintained restrooms.
on-site spas, gyms, nurseries, shops, banks, medical
Office size and design can be related to
clinics, and upscale dining rooms. For example,
employee satisfaction and productivity. The layout
Google provides gourmet meals for employees-
of a set of offices will affect the behavior of man-
without charge. The Nielsen Company's facility in
agers who rely on spontaneous encounters as a way
Florida features a five-star cafeteria with a glass wall
of obtaining and exchanging information. The
overlooking a nature preserve where a resident alli-
closer their offices, the more likely they are to meet
gator delights visitors from northern states. On "fam-
throughout the workday. Physical separation, such
ily friendly" days each month, pizza and hot dogs are
as placing suites of management offices on differ-
served to employees' children (Rexrode,2007).
ent floors of a building, decreases the amount of
Why would organizations spend money on
contact.
what used to be considered frills? At the luxury-
In studies of office workers in South Korea,
laden Citicorp office complex in Tampa, Florida, an
researchers found that the more personal control
employee said, "You spend so much of your life at
workers had over their desk and office space, and
work; it's nice that you can have things like a fit-
the easier the access to meeting rooms, the higher
ness center or child-care facility. For me, it builds
was workers' job satisfaction and group cohesive-
loyalty." And loyal employees are less likely to quit,
take time off, or be sloppy about their work.
ness (Lee &- Brand, 2005). Research on office workers
in the United States showed that greater satisfac-
~
tion with the layout of their workstations was
related to higher job performance and increased
Office and Workplace Design collaboration with co-workers (Robertson 6
Once inside their place of employment, workers Huang, 2006).
may find physical features that create dissatisfac- The size of an office building can influence
tion or frustration. One source of complaints is the working relationships. The smaller the building,
ventilating, heating, and air conditioning systems in the closer the relationships among employees tend
glass-wall, fixed-window buildings. Temperatures to be. In very large buildings, where employees
are often uncomfortably hot on the sunny side of have fewer interactions, relationships tend to be
the building and too cool on the shady side. Other more formal and impersonal. All these factors,
irritants are slow elevators in high-rise buildings, none of which involves actual job tasks, can impair
l&Vhmmalrtal psy~hology The study of
, the effect of workplace design on behavior
and attitudes.

productive efficiency. An unpopular location, poor grouped into cubicles, functional work units that
design, or inconvenient layout can reduce morale are set off from others only by planters, screens or
and foster negative attitudes. partitions, or cabinets and bookcases.
Workplace design and location are especially Inexpensive to construct and maintain, land-
critical for disabled employees who may be barred scaped offices are believed to facilitate communica-
from certain jobs not because of lack of ability but tion and work flow. The openness is supposed to
, because they do not have access to the work area. enhance group cohesiveness and cooperation and
'
Steep flights of stairs, narrow doorways, and inade- reduce psychological barriers between employees
I quate restrooms may prevent them from being and managers. Research on employee reactions has
employed. The 1973 Rehabilitation Act and the 1990 revealed both advantages and disadvantages.
: Americans with Disabilities Act require the removal Employees report that landscaped offices are pleas-
. of architectural barriers. All parts of a building must ant and conducive to socializing. Managers report
be accessible to persons in wheelchairs. improved communication. Complaints relate to
Compliance with the laws has meant modifica- lack of privacy, noise, and difficulty in concentrat-
tions to elements of the physical plant, such as ing. Because cubicles are typically separated only
automatic doors, ramps and elevators, handholds, by low dividers, work areas tend to lack the per-
wider doorways and corridors, and lower wall tele- sonal touches-such as photos, plants, posters, or
phones and speakerphones. Surveys show that 60% souvenirs-that contribute to feelings of individu-
of these required changes cost less than $100 and ality and comfort.
90% cost less than $1,000. Many disabled employ- In studies of 779 cubicle workers in the United
ees do not need any physical modifications of an States and in Canada, investigators found that
office workspace. IBM, which has hired disabled those who were more satisfied with their work
workers for more than 40 years, took the lead in environment were also more likely to be satisfied
redesigning workstations to provide job opportuni- with their jobs as a whole. This finding reinforces
ties for these employees. the importance of the physical environment to
employees' well-being and effectiveness (Veitch,
Charles, Farley, Er Newsham, 2007). A study of
Environmental Psychology: Landscaped employees in Turkey who worked in cubicles found
Offices and Cubicles that those who had access to a window that pro-
The field of environmental psychology studies vided natural light and an outdoor view were sig-
the relationships between people and their physical nificantly more satisfied with their workspace than
environment. Combining architecture and psychol- those who had no window. In addition, workers in
ogy, environmental psychologists are concerned cubicles with partitions 1.4 meters ( 4feet, 7 inches)
with natural and built environments and their in height expressed greater satisfaction with their
impact on behavior. For example, research on office space than those with lower walls. Men in the
design and layout has focused on communications Turkish study were more satisfied working in cubi-
between and within departments, flow of job tasks cles than were women (Yildirim, Akalin-Baskaya,
among groups, relationships between managers 6 Celebi, 2007).
and subordinates, and work group cohesiveness. Despite the problems with landscaped offices,
One early result of environmental psychology many organizations have invested considerable
research was the landscaped office. In contrast to money in them and are reluctant to bear the addi-
private, separated offices, the landscaped office tional expense of reconverting to more private
consists of a huge open space with no floor-to-cehg offices. For companies with large numbers of
walls to divide the area into separate rooms. All employees at computerized workstations, the land-
employees, from clerks to corporate officers, are scaped office has become standard.
Part Four: Characteristics of the Workplace

Does Anyone Get Work Done i n Those


Dilbert-Style Cubicles?

1
Can you get any work done at work? Maybe not if workers who just wanted to have a conversation,
you work in a cubicle, as the comic strip Dilbert an average of 16 times a day. And none of these
reminds us daily. Cubicle designers and managers interruptions was related to work. Interruption
may insist that the open office plan, with its low that did relate to the job occurred an average of
walls surrounding individual workstations, times a day. Ms. Weidermann observed that afte
allows the free flow of ideas, but tell that to the an interruption, it took an employee 2.9 minute
employees who spend many hours each workday to settle down and return to work, which mean
in that setting. They'll likely tell you that they that approximately an hour of every workday wa
find it hard to concentrate on their job because of spent trying to refocus on the job tasks.
all the nonwork activities and conversations Kathi Heering used to work for a bank bu
going on around them. Cubicle dwellers will found that she couldn't concentrate in her cubicle
complain to anyone who will listen about being She pleaded with her boss to construct the cubic1
forced to hear of other workers' family- -problems, walls a few inches higher, so that co-worker:
medical problems, financial problems, or the cute couldn't lean over them so easily to chat, but the

I
thing their dog did yesterday. Some say it's easier boss refused. He claimed that the low walls "forti-
to work at home-the office is more suitable for fied communication." Unfortunately, the commu
socializing. nication was not about work. Now Icathi does he
Sue Weidermann, a management consultant job from home where she enjoys a luxury that sh
in Buffalo, New York, found that in one large law did not have at the office. It's called a door.
firm the employees who worked in cubicles were Whenever her family or her dogs intrude on he]
interrupted by noise, visual distractions, or co- work, she simply closes the door.

Source: Laboring to work at work (2004, May 8 ) .WallStreet J o u m l .

As real estate costs escalate, organizations are Otherwise they worked at home or while traveling.
trying to squeeze more employees into smaller Companies with similar programs include, among
facilities. The size of the typical office cubicle or others, IBM, American Express, Microsoft, and Sun
individual workstation is steadily shrinking. Some Microsystems.
employees who travel frequently no longer have a
permanently assigned work area but only a tempo-
rary space. For example, consultants who spend Lighting
much of their time on-site at a client's workplace In addition to studying general issues of work-
will phone ahead to reserve a cubicle for their next space design, 1-0 psychologists have conducted
visit to the home office. Because the practice is not extensive research on specific environmental fac-
unlike booking a hotel room, it has come to be tors such as lighting, noise, and temperature. These
known as "hoteling" or "free addressing." aspects of the work environment are analogous to
Capital One, a banking company headquar- the hygiene needs proposed by Herzberg. All of
tered in Richmond, Virginia, began a hoteling these environmental factors have been found to
program for its employees in 2005; it became so affect job satisfaction.
popular that within 2 years some 1:600 employees Continued exposure to inadequate illumina-
nationwide chose not to have desks of their own. tion while reading or performing detailed opera-
w h e n they did need office time, they simply tions can be harmful to a person's eyesight.
plugged in their laptops to empty docking stations. Research confirms that inadequate lighting is a
Chapter l o : Working Conditions

ource of distress. High glare, dim bulbs, and a lamp focused on your work. This arrangement will
f natural light have negative effects on job give a uniform distribution of light throughout the
mance. room. Similarly, it is less fatiguing to the eyes to
have addiiional lighting in the room where you are
Intensity. Intensity, or level of brightness, is the watching television or staring at your computer
most common factor associated with illumination. screen.
I The optimal level of intensity varies with the Uniform illumination throughout a work area
can be provided by indirect lighting in which all
i nature of the task and the age of the worker. Older
light is reflected. Thus, no light will strike the eyes
workers generally need brighter light than do
'
' younger workers for satisfactory performance
of the same task. A job involving the precise
manipulation of small parts, as in electronics
directly. In contrast, direct lighting, with bulbs
located at various points in the ceiling, tends to
focus or concentrate the light on specific areas,
assembly, requires brighter light than an assembly causing bright spots and glare.
line in a bottling plant. Lighting engineers have Glare. Glare reduces visual efficiency and con-
recommended minimum intensity levels for a
tributes to eyestrain. Glare is caused by light of a
variety of work areas, including office buildings brighter intensity than that to which the eye is
(see Table 10- 1 ). accustomed. This brightness may come from the
light source or from reflective surfaces. Glare can
. I stribution of light. Another important factor in lead to an increase in errors in detailed work in as
illumination is the distribution of light over the short a time as 20 minutes. It can obscure vision,
work area. Ideally, lighting should be distributed something you may have experienced when driving
uniformly throughout the visual field. Illuminating at night and confronting a n oncoming car that
a workstation at a much higher intensity than its has its high-beam headlights on. Glare is also a
surroundings leads to eyestrain because of the problem with the video display terminals for
natural tendency of the eyes to move. When a computers.
person looks from a brightly lit area to a dimly lit There are several ways to reduce or eliminate
area, the pupils of the eyes dilate. Returning the glare. Extremely bright light sources can be
gaze to the brighter area causes the pupils to shielded or kept out of the visual field. Workers can
contract. This constant reaction of the pupils leads be supplied with visors or eyeshades. Reflective or
to eyestrain. When you are sitting at your desk, you glossy surfaces can be painted with a dull, matte
should have overhead lighting as well as a desk finish.

TABLE 10-1 I

General Offices and Private Offices


Accounting, Bookkeeping, Drafting
. 2 . r - - . '(I
Conference Rooms . -..iF- i t ,..- , ,,-,
-*.1Lez: F
Corridors, Elevators, ~scdat&$; %mvays
Lobbies, Reception Areas
Part Four: Characteristics of the Workplace

Natural light. There is a definite psychological The National Institute for Occupational Safety
component with regard to the preference for and Health (NIOSH) reports that 30 million
natural (full-spectrum) light instead of artificial Americans are routinely exposed to noise levels
light. People who work in windowless offices and that eventually will affect their hearing. NIOSH
receive no natural light express a strong desire for also estimates that at least 20% of U.S. employees
windows, regardless of the adequacy of the work in environments that can endanger their
artificial illumination in their work area. Most hearing. For example, more than 90% of coal min-
workers want to see outside, and they believe that ers experience hearing loss by age 50. At least 75%
natural light is better for the eyes than is artificial of farmers suffer hearing impairment from contin-
light. People also may have a physiological need for ued exposure to noisy farm machinery. A past pres-
a certain amount of full-spectrum or natural light. ident of the National Hearing Conservation
Several European countries have laws requiring Association asserted that hearing loss was one of
employers to ensure that all employees can see the most common workplace conditions.
natural light from their work areas. The basic unit for measuring noise is the decibel
(db),which is a measure of the subjective or per-
Noise ceived intensity of a sound. Zero decibels is the
threshold of hearing, the faintest sound most of us
Noise is a common complaint in modern life. Noise
can hear. Table 10-2 shows decibel levels in familiar
makes us irritable and nervous, interferes with
situations. Some loudness levels are threats to hear-
sleep, and produces physiological effects such as
ing. A worker exposed regularly over a long period
hearing loss. Noise has been documented as a n
to decibel levels above 85 can expect to experience
occupational hazard for industrial employees such
some hearing loss. Exposure to levels over 120 db
as riveters, boilermakers, aircraft mechanics, and
can cause temporary deafness. Brief exposure to lev-
foundry and textile workers. Businesses have been
els in excess of 130 can cause permanent deafness.
faced with employee claims of hearing damage that
The U.S. government has established maximum per-
total millions of dollars each year.
missible sound levels for industrial workers: exposure

Whisper from 5 feet away

Conversation 3 feet away

Kitchen appliances

Power lawnrnowqs

Noisy restaurant-
Pneumatic hammers 3 feet away 120

The excexsive noise kwh in some industrial plants can cause


hearing loss.
Chnprcr 10: W o r k i n g Condiiions

to 90 db for a n 8-hour day, 100 db for a 2-hour one. Thus, the appropriate use of color can make a
period, and 110 db for a 30-minute period. worlcroom or office seem bright& or darker. Colors
When people are exposed to sounds in the 95 to also create different illusions of size. A room painted
110 db range, blood vessels constrict, heart rate a dhrker color seems smaller than it actually is. Light-
changes, and the pupils of the eyes dilate. The con- colored walls givc the feeling of space and openness.
striction of [he blood vessels conlinues for some timc On U.S. Navy submarines, the 24 Tridenl mis-
after the noise ceases, a condition that alters the sile tubes, which run through all four decks, are
blood supply throughout the body. Continuous expo- painted reddish-orange. The color is darker for
sure to loud noise is associated with stress, high tubes at one end of the ship than the other to create
blood pressure, and impaired emotional well-being. the illusion of depth. This lnakes the cramped quar-
In a study of 40 female clerical workers, 3 hours' ters appear more spacious than they are. The cap-
exposure to the noise of a typical open-office tain of the USS Tt.nt?c.ssee told an interviewer,
arrangement produced nlcasurablc physiological "That's the psychologists looking out for us."
signs of stress. The noise also reduced the cmploy- Interior decorators clainl that blues and greens
ees' motivation to work (Evans 6 Johnson, 2000). are cool colors and that reds and oranges are warm
Kesearchers studying the physiological effects of colors. Anecdotal evidence suggests that these col-
high noise levels tracked blood pressure changes in ors influence our perception of temperature. In one
worlcers in Israel over a 4-year period. They found example, a n office was repainted fro111 a drab
that workers who had more complex jobs showed brown to a bright blue. When winter approached,
greater increases in blood pressure than those with the enlployees complained that they wcre cold even
less complex jobs (Melamed, Fried, 6 Froom, 2001 ). though the indoor office tcnlperaturc was the same
Noise interferes with communication. If the as it had been during previous winters. The temper-
background noise in an office is low (between 50 ature was raised 5 degrees, but the complaints per-
and 60 db), thcn two people can conduct a conver- sisted. The office was repainted in warn1 colors, and
sation without raising their voices at a distance of he employees said they were too hot. The tempera-
up to 5 feet. As the baclcground noise level rises, ture kvas lowered 5 degrees to where it had been
workers nlilst talk louder or must leave their work- before, and complainls ceased.
stations and come closer logether to be heard. The If a work area is dingy, then repainiins it may
decibel level of the average factory forces workers improve employee morale. A fresh coat of paint in
and supervisors to shout; it is likely that important any color can make workers feel better about their
information is lost in transmission. environment. But there is litlle 1 - 0 psychologists
can conclude with assurance about the effects of
color on enlployce behavior.

Exaggerated claims have been made about the ben-


efits of color for homes, offices, and factories. Some
people have suggested that certain colors increase The use of music at work is as old as work itself.
productivity, reduce accidents, and raise employee Workers traditionally sang on the job, even in noisy
morale. These claims are not supported by empiri- factories at the timc of the Industrial Revolution.
cal evidence, and there is n o validity to any pur- During the late 1800s and early 1900s, quieter indus-
ported relationship between a specific color and tries, such as cigar making, encouraged singing on
productivity, fatigue, or job satisfaction. the job. Some companies hired musicians to play for
Nevertheless, there is a role for color in the work- the workers, and by the 1930s many organizations
place. Color can provide a more pleasant working supported their own bands and singing groups.
environment and can be an aid in safety practices. Many claims have been made aboi~tthe effects
Many manufacturing plants use color as a coding of music on productivity and morale. Employees
device. Fire equipment is red, danger areas yellolv, are supposed to be happier and more efficient
and first-aid stalions green. Color-coding allows when they listen to music at worlc. Studies con-
these areas to be identified quickly. Color can prevent ducted by firms thai supply recorded music support
eyestrain because colors differ in their reflective prop- these claims, but such research often lacks scien-
erties. A white wall reflects more light than a dark tific rigor and control. Early research on music
4 ! Part Four: Characteristics of t h e Workplace

Put a Little Red i n Your Life


If you start to feel a little drowsy or a little queasy Cool colors, like blue and green, cool and soothe
after dinner, maybe it's not what you ate or drank. your mind, body, and spirit. It's no wonder we
Maybe it's the color of your dining room. That's flock to the ocean and mountains to rejuvenate our
the suggestion of one painting contractor, who senses. These blue-based tones are best used in

I
wrote in the magazine Paint Dealer that beige walls rooms where you want peace and serenity to pre-
create gas and stagnation in the human digestive vail. Warm colors, like red, orange, and yellow, con-
tract. Should you paint your dining room walls vey an energy and passion unmatched by their
blue? No, that's not a good idea either. Decorators cooler counterparts. Use these high-power hues in
consider blue to be an appetite suppressant. You'll rooms where you anticipate activity and motiva-
lose weight if you have your meals in a blue room. tion, such as a kitchen, child's playroom, or exer- '
What about red? Yes! According to the same deco- cise space. You may find your life becomes more
rators, red increases your appetite, heart rate, pas- than just living. I t becomes a sensory experience
sion, and energy. full of color and feeling!
And so it goes-various and sometimes com- Do you believe that? Or do you think the
peting claims that the right color will improve in the business of selling
your life, or ruin it. Here's an ad from one manu-
facturer.

showed that most employees liked the idea of having Muzak-style sound is intended to humanize the
music during working hours and believed it would work environment by giving people an emotional
make them more productive. Research results lift. A different program is created for each type of
depend partly on the kind of work involved. Music business and each workday. The tempo corresponds
has been found to increase production slightly for to changes in mood and energy levels and is
assembly-line jobs that are reasonably simple and designed to be more stimulating at midmorning
repetitive. Workers regard this type of job as and midafternoon. Critics consider such music to
monotonous and not sufficiently demanding to be bland, even a form of noise pollution.
fully engage their attention. Thus, music can pro-
vide a focus for these workers, something to occupy
the mind and to help the workday pass more
Temperature and Humidity
quickly and enjoyably. For more demanding work, Most people have experienced the effects of tem-
there is no evidence that music increases produc- perature and humidity on morale, efficiency, and
tivity because the complexity of the work requires physical well-being. Some are happier and have
more concentrated attention. more vitality in cold weather, whereas others prefer
Most of the music piped into factories, offices, hot weather. Some people are depressed by rainy
corridors, elevators, and waiting rooms is supplied days, and others barely notice them. Most employ-
by Muzak, which has been in business since 1934. ees work in facilities where temperature and
The company estimates that its background music humidity are controlled. But workers in construc-
is played to 100 million people in more than tion, shipbuilding, and other industries are fre-
250,000 companies in a dozen countries. It has quently exposed to temperature extremes.
more than a million tunes in its database and pro- Recall that the number one complaint of office
vides customized pop-rock programs to companies workers was that the workplace was too cold, and the
such as .Gap, Old Navy, and Harry Winston. number two complaint was that it was too hot. But if
Another music provider, PlayNetwork, supplies the employees tried to raise or lower the temperature of
music you hear in Starbucks and TGI Fridays. their office area, they would probably find that the
Chapter 10: Working Conditions

1 thermostats are fakes-they are there only to provide Contrast that with the vacation policies of other
the illusion of control. Employees may believe that by nations: Italy, 42 days; France, 37 days; Germany,
changing the thermostat they have initiated some 35 days; England, 28 days; and Japan, 25 days.
action to correct the sensation of being too hot or too Vacations can be good for you. A study conducted
cold, and often that action satisfies them, even with 221 workers in Germany showed that their com-
though the actual temperature remains the same. plaints about health and exhaustion decreased signif-
Research shows that for people who work out- icantly during their vacation time. However, these
doors or in facilities that are not air-conditioned beneficial effects dissipated within 2 weeks after
(such as warehouses or automobile repair shops), returning to work (Fritz 6. Sonnentag, 2006).
unusually high temperatures seem to have no sig- In general, managers work longer hours than
nificant effect on mental work but do lead to lower employees at other levels, but they seem to be well
performance on strenuous physical tasks. Even if rewarded for their efforts. In a survey of 47 male
productivity holds steady, workers must expend managers, researchers found that they averaged a
more energy under difficult climate conditions to 56.4-hour workweek, and 28.6% of them worked
maintain the same output. Usually, they will need more than 6 1 hours per week. Those who put in the
more frequent rest breaks. Motivation is also a factor. greatest number of hours were paid significantly
Highly motivated workers are better able to main- more than those who worked less, receiving, on
tain production under temperature extremes than average, a $204,993 annual salary compared with
are poorly motivated workers. $162,285. Those who worked longer hours also
Automated office equipment has been found to reported significantly higher job satisfaction and job
interfere with climate-control systems. A single involvement. The negative side was a feeling of
computer terminal does not generate much heat, alienation from one's family and a high level of con-
but when dozens of terminals, printers, and fax flict between work and family (Brett 6 Stroh, 2003).
machines are operated in the same area, heat and Although Americans continue to work long
static electricity levels increase. The drier air also hours, they do so in ways that are different from
leads to complaints about eye irritation from previous generations of workers. The traditional
employees who wear contact lenses. 5-day, 40-hour week in which all employees of an
organization arrived and left at the same time is
WORK SCHEDULES being replaced by alternative work schedules such
as permanent part-time employment, the 4-day
A vita1 part of the overall work environment is the workweek, flexible hours, and shift work.
amount of time workers spend on the job. There is
no standard, universal work schedule. The 40-hour
workweek common in the United States is not the Working Hours
norm in every country. Americans spend more At one time in the United States, people routinely
hours on the job than do workers in other industri- worked 10 hours a day, 6 days a week. The 5-day,
alized nations. Employees in the United States work 40-hour week became the norm in 1938 with the
almost 2 weeks longer each year than employees in passage of the Fair Labor Standards Act. The
Japan, and 14 weeks longer each year than workers United States became the first country to formally
in Norway. Not only do Americans work more establish a 5-day, 40-hour workweek, but this is
hours, they also take fewer annual vacation days. A not necessarily the most efficient work schedule.
survey of 1,000 employees conducted by Expedia Workers have accepted it as normal, but in the past
found that 12% of them did not plan to take any they accepted 60 hours and then 48 hours as normal.
vacation days. On average, U.S. workers receive 16 There is a difference between nominal working
vacation days per year but take only 14 of them. hours (the prescribed number of hours employees
I Part Four: Characteristics of the Workplace

are supposed to spend on the job) and actual increased, will productivity rise if the workday is
working hours ( t h e amount of time employees shortened? Some research indicates that it will,
devote to job duties). The two rarely coincide. but other studies show that a decrease in nominal
Some research shows 'that employees spend no working hours has no effect on actual working
more than half the workweek actually performing hours. In a case of historical interest, during the
required job tasks. Some of the lost time is sched- Great Depression of the 1930s a U.S. manufactur-
uled by the company as rest pauses, but most of ing plant reduced nominal working hours by more
the lost time is unauthorized and beyond the than 9 hours a week, yet actual working hours fell
control of the organization. When employees only 5 hours a week. Another plant reduced the
arrive at the workplace, it may take them a long workweek by 10 112 hours, and hourly production
time to begin work. They may check their e-mails, rose 21%.
send text messages, surf the Web, or sharpen pen- In research conducted in Sweden with white-
cils (whether needed or not). Throughout the collar workers, investigators found that overtime
workday they visit with co-workers, take coffee resulted in fewer hours of sleep for these employees
breaks, and exceed the length of the lunch period. and greater self-reported feelings of exhaustion
Managers lose time waiting for meetings to begin (Dahlgren, Icecklund, 6 Akerstedt, 2006).
or calls to be completed, or spend time sending
personal e-mails.
An interesting relationship has been docu- Permanent Part-Time Employment
mented between nominal and actual working Part-time or half-time employment is the most
hours. When nominal (prescribed) working hours widespread form of alternative work schedule.
are increased, actual working hours decrease. In More than 25% of the U.S. workforce holds part-
other words, the longer the workday or work- time jobs. Part-time employment has grown faster
week, the lower is worker productivity. This find- than full-time employment, particularly in service
ing holds even for highly motivated workers. In and retail trades. By shifting to part-time employ-
the early days of World War I1 in England, patri- ment, organizations reduce the costs of keeping
otic fervor reached a peak. Dangerously low in full-time staffs (which require higher salary and
supplies and equipment, the nation was fighting benefit packages) and increase their scheduling
for survival. The government extended the work- flexibility.
week in defense plants from 56 to 69 1/2 hours. At
first, productivity increased lo%, but it soon fell
12% below the previous level. Other consequences
of increasing nominal working hours included
greater absenteeism and more frequent accidents.
In the 69 1/2-hour workweek, actual working
hours were only 51. With the shorter 56-hour
workweek, actual working hours had been 53. A
study conducted by the U.S. Bureau of Labor
Statistics during World War I1 showed that the 7-day
workweek that was adopted by many U.S. compa-
nies during the war resulted in no greater produc-
tion than the 6-day week. One day of the 7 days
was lost time.
This relationship between nominal and actual
working hours also applies to overtime when
employees are asked to work beyond the normal
workday fox a markedly higher rate of pay. Much
of the extra time is unproductive, because people
tend to adjust to the longer workday by per-
forming at a slower pace. If productivity drops Some jobs require workers to punch o time clock at the
when the number of required working hours is beginning and end of each lvwk shift.
Chapter 10: Working Conditions

*
beginning
~ ~ a
Qnd ISttw wwk&y.
t t h s

Management recognizes that full-time employ- but from management, for reasons such as these:
ment does not mean that the organization is actu- the possibility of increasing worker productivity
ally getting a full day's work from each employee. and efficiency, the use of the shorter workweek
Furthermore, much work, such as writing and as an incentive to recruit workers, and the hope
independent research, can be performed satisfacto- of reducing absenteeism, which in many organi-
rily part time. A lower-level assembly-line job or a zations is unusually high on Mondays and
clerical job can be performed by two persons, each Fridays.
working half time. Comments from managers and employees on
The U.S. Department of Health and Human the 4-day workweek have been positive. They cite
Services found that supervisors of part-time improved job satisfaction and productivity,
employees were strongly in favor of part-time reduced absenteeism, and easier work schedul-
employment. Welfare caseworkers in Massachusetts ing. A nationwide Gallup Poll supported the
who worked 20 hours a week had a lower turnover appeal of the 4-day week. Some 45% of the men
rate and higher caseload contact than did full-time surveyed indicated that they would like a 4-day
employees. State government agencies in Wisconsin schedule. Women who did not work outside the
found that actual working hours among perma- home opposed the 4-day workweek by a ratio of
nent, part-time social workers, attorneys, and two to one. Women who did work outside the
research analysts equaled or exceeded the actual home were far more favorable to the idea of a
working hours of full-time employees. 4-day workweek.
Part-time employment is attractive to people
with family responsibilities and to disabled per-
sons who have mobility problems. Most part-time Flexible Work Schedules
employees are women, and they tend to be con- Another type of alternative work schedule per-
centrated in lower level jobs and receive lower mits employees to decide for themselves when to
rates of pay than do full-time employees. In a begin and end the workday. In the 1960s, several
large-scale study including 794 employees of a companies in Germany tried a flexible working
grocery store chain, 200 hospital workers, and 243 hours ( f l e x t i m e ) schedule to deal with traffic
retail employees, researchers found that those congestion at rush hours. Under this plan, the
who had chosen part-time employment were far workday is divided into four segments, two of
more satisfied with their jobs, performed their which are mandatory and two optional (see
work better, and were more committed to their Figure 10-1 ) .
organization than were those who were assigned In this example, employees can report to work
to part-time work against their will (Holton, Lee, any time between 7:30 and 9:00 a.m. and leave any
6 Tidd, 2002). time between 4:00 and 5:30 p.m. The mandatory
work periods are the morning hours from 9:00 a.m.
until the lunch break and the afternoon hours from
The Four-Day Workweek lunch to 4:00 p.m. Thus, employees work a mini-
Another way to alter the workweek significantly is mum 6 1R-hour workday. The optional daily maxi-
to reduce it to 4 days. This usually involves 4 days mum is 9 112 hours. How long each employee
at 10 hours a day (a 40-hour week) or 4 days at 9 works is established individually as a function of
hours a day (a 36-hour week with no reduction in the company's needs.
pay). Union leaders, management consultants, and Flextime offers several advantages. Rush-hour
many companies that have tried the 4-day work- traffic congestion around plants and offices is
week are enthusiastic about it. Typically, initiatives reduced. Because employees spend-less time and
to shorten the workweek came not from employees energy commuting, they are often more relaxed at
Part Four: Characieristics of the Workpiace

Core Time

plus X hour lunch)

Flextime Flextime
7:30 9:OO 1O:OO 11:OO 12:OO 1:00 2:OO 3:OO 4:OO 5:30
am am pm pm
- -

FIGURE 10-1 A typical flexible work schedule.

work, more satisfied with their jobs, and more likely take breaks whether or not the company sanctions
to begin work promptly. Many workers make only them. If the time is going to be taken anyway, the
minor changes in their work habits under a flextime organization might as well appear benevolent and
schedule. The inflexible demands of car pools, com- offer the rest pauses as a fringe benefit.
muter timetables, and family life hold them to When authorized rest pauses are introduced,
schedules much like those they had before flextime. unauthorized breaks decline, though they do not
However, employees believe that having the choice disappear. Other benefits of rest periods include
of when to arrive and leave work enhances their increased morale and productivity and reduced
personal freedom. Studies have found that flextime fatigue and boredom. This is another instance of
schedules decreased absenteeism and improved how a decrease in nominal working hours can
workers' productivity and their satisfaction with the result in an increase in efficiency.
job and the work schedule. Workers who engage in heavy physical labor
Flexible working hours appear to be most need rest pauses because muscles in continuous
appropriate for jobs such as research and develop- use will tire and become less effective. Rest pauses
ment, clerical and data entry, and light and heavy also reduce repetitive motion injuries to hands and
manufacturing. For some assembly-line and shift- wrists. For sedentary and intellectual work, a rest
work operations, flextime is difficult to implement break provides a change of stimulation. It allows
because of the interdependence of the work teams. boredom to dissipate and provides the opportunity
Overall, flextime is a fair, sensible, and low-cost to think about something else or to socialize with
alternative work schedule that is popular with co-workers. Rest pauses may also result in more
employers and employees.
Surveys conducted by the Families and Work
Institute have consistently shown that employees
with flexible work plans were significantly less
likely to leave their companies and were more pro-
ductive than employees who had no flexible
options. The surveys also reported that 72% of low-
wage workers without flexible working hours call
in sick when they need time off to deal with child-
care problems or family crises. Under a plan of
flexible working hours, they might not have to use
illness as an excuse to tend to personal needs (see
www.familiesandwork.org).

Rest Breaks
Ever since the Hawthorne studies, management
has recognized the importance of authorized rest
breaks. Their beneficial effects have been amply Manyjobs are repetitive and physically demanding; workers
demonstrated, but there is a more insistent reason should be @venformal rest pen'ods to reduce boredom and
for granting them. Why? Because employees will fotigue.
Chapter 1 b: Working Conditions

M
1The Modern Flextime
I
1
h e y Stone is a financial writer for Business Week noon play date. But I also get to keep a full-time
Online and the mother of two small children. Her salary and the status and potential for advance-
schedule is hectic but she gets to choose when she ment that goes along with it."
works. "I manage my own time," she wrote, "and Nevertheless, sometimes her life presents
as long as I get my work done and my editors hard choices. "The downside is that I have to be a
know how to reach me, I don't think they really lot of things to a lot of people at the same time. Of
care where I am from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Most of the course, I can't be both Involved Mom and Devoted
time I assume they would rather not know why, Employee all day every day. The roles are in too
for example, I'm rushing out the door at 2 p.m. on great a conflict for me to manage them simultane-
a Wednesday or e-mailing after midnight on a ously for more than a few minutes at a time. Worst
Thursday." Most of the time she works from of all, some other roles I've signed on for-Loving
home, balancing the demands of her job and Wife, Loyal Best Friend, and Devoted Daughter-
those of her family, and her hours may seem odd sometimes get short shrift. But the truth is, if I
to those who are tied to their workplace from 9 to didn't work, I couldn't do it all anyway. So for me,
5, Monday through Friday. working full time flextime gives me the freedom,
"I get the flexibility to plan my workweek so financial security, and sense of accomplishment I
that I can attend my daughters' doctors' appoint- need to keep a lot of balls in the air."
ments, dance recitals, and the occasional after- It works for her. Would it work for you?

Source: Stone, A. (2005, May 4). One mom's solution: Flextime. Retrieved from Business Week Online.

positive attitudes toward management. When a In research conducted with 800 workers in the
rest program is implemented, workers tend to Netherlands and in Germany, investigators found
believe that it is a n expression of management's that the need for recovery from the demands of a
concern for them as individuals. job was highest for workers with low control over
Research on data entry clerks and computer hazardous jobs and little organizational support.
operators showed that those who reported higher This higher need for recovery time was linked to
levels of fatigue and boredom on the job tended to greater fatigue and lower psychological well-being
take longer rest breaks than did those who felt less ( Sonnentag 6 Zijlstra, 2006).
fatigued and bored. Also, psychologists have found A much longer rest break-the off hours
that computer workers who do stretching exercises between workdays-was the subject of another
during rest breaks, particularly for arms and shoul- research study. A survey of 147 workers in
ders, perform better after the breaks than do work- Germany showed that workers who believed they
ers who engage in no physical movement during had sufficiently recovered from the previous day's
their breaks (Jett 6. George, 2003). work were more involved in their work the next
In a study of data entry workers in Canada, day. Workers who felt greater stress on the job
researchers found that microbreaks lasting only 30 needed more time to recover from the workday
seconds, when taken regularly every 20 minutes, than did those who experienced less stress
reduced physical discomfort in back, shoulder, and ( Sonnentag, 2003).
forearm muscles to a greater extent than taking
microbreaks whenever the workers felt like it or
having no breaks at all. With regularly scheduled Shift Work
rest breaks, there was no decline in productivity Many industries operate around the clock: Workers
levels (McLean, Tingley, Scott, 6. Rickards, 2001 ). in electric and natural gas utilities, transportation,
Part Four: Charactrristics of t h e Workplace

steel, automotive assembly, hospital services, and nursing profession ( S m i t h , Icilby, Jorgensen, 6
teleconlmunications typically work one of three Douglas, 2007).
shifts: usually 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., 3:00 p.m. to Fewer problems are encountered with the
I1:OO p.m., or 11:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m. Some compa- fixed-shift system than with the rotating-shift sys-
nies assign workers to one shift permanently, tem, even w h e n the fixed shift occurs at night.
whereas others rotate assignments, switching Workers permanently assigned to one shift are
workers each week or month t o a different shift. more likely to adjust to a new diurnal rhythm. With
Employees working evening or all-night shifts usu- the rotating-shift system, workers r n u s ~readjust
ally receive extra pay to compensate for the incon- every week or so, whenever the shift schedule is
venience of the working hours. About 25% of the changed; this system does not give the body time to
blue-collar and white-collar workforces perform adjust to one schedule before being forced to begin
shift work. another.
How does shift work affect job performance? There are other ways to alleviate some of the
Research shows that workers are less productive problems associated with shift work. When the
on the all-night shift than o n the day shift. Night- rotating-shift system must be used, changes frorn
shift r,/orke~-sare also more prone to make errors one shift to another should be made as s e l d o ~ nas
and to have more serious accidents. Accidents in possible-for example, every month instead of
nuclear power plants in the United States and in every week. Another way lo case the change from
Russia occurred during t h e night shift. A nuclear one shift to another is lo lengthen the time off
power plant in Pennsylvania was closed by t h e between shift changes. A longer interim period
Nuclear Regulatory Commission when night-shift makes the change less abrupt and allows employ-
control roorn personnel were found to be asleep on ees to rest before starting a new schedule. Because
the job. the night shift is the most difficult for elnployees
In a study of 1,867 oil industry elnployees in and the least productive for employers, i t could be
Britain, shift workers reported greater levels of stress, shortened to make it less stressful.
increased exposure to adverse and risky working con- A potentially harlnful form of shift work that
ditions, lower feelings of job control, less social sup- affects many people is the erralic work schedule
port from supervisors, and higher levels of conflict at of commercial airline pilols. Commercial pilots
work than those who worked regular hours during often change from nigh1 flighls to day flights and
the standard workday (Parkes, 2003). back, sleeping a1 irrcg~ilarintervals and disrupting
Disruption of the normal sleep-wake cycle their bodily rhythms. Studies of civilian and mili-
has physiological and psychological conse- lary pilots and flight crews working unusually
quences. H u m a n s develop a diurnal rhythm, a long a n d erratic hours ( s u c h as 10 to 24 hours
regular daily cycle of bodily activities that is con- continuously) confirm the harmful effects of
sistent from one 24-hour pcriod t o t h e next. severe disturbances of diurnal rhylhms. Airline
When this rhythrn is disrupted, the body under- personnel reported considerable faligue, slept
goes clranlatic changes and sleep becomes diffi- poorly following their work periods, and took
cult. The effect o n sleep is the nlajor conlplaint of unauthorized naps in the cockpi1 for up to 2
employees w h o do night-shift work, that is, they hours. Exanlinations of aircraft f l i g h ~recorders
are unable to sleep during the day because of day- (so-called black boxes) revealed that deviations in
light and household routines. Fa~nilylife suffers, pilot performance correlated positively with sub-
and everyday activities such as shopping become jective feelings of faligue.
difficult to schedule. Night-shift workers a n d Psychologists conducting research for NASA's
those o n a rotaling-shift schedule reporl a high Fatigue Countermeasures Prograrll found that
incidence of stomach disorders, sleep disorders, allowing pilots 40-minute rest periods during low
cardiovascular complaints, marital problems, and worl<load portions of long flighls resulted in sip-
irritability. In a study of nurses in Australia, nificantly increased alertness. F l i g h ~crews that
researchers showed that a 30-minute nap break were not supposed to nap during the 5tudy period
during the night shift reduced sleepiness on t h e did so anyway, although most of the personnel
job a n d increased response speed a n d reaction w h o look unauthorized naps were not aware of
times, bolh of which are critical funclions in the having done so.
Chapter 10: ,Working Conditions B

Asleep on the Job? Good for You! -


There was a time when you could be fired for Worse, many of us don't get enough sleep at
falling asleep on the job. But now a growing night, so we begin the workday feeling sluggish.
number of companies are urging their employees A study by the National Sleep Foundation
to do just that. A national survey in 2008 found reported that 64% of U.S. workers fail to sleep the
that 34% of U.S. companies allowed their recommended 8 hours a night. And 32% of the
employees to nap during their authorized breaks people report sleeping fewer than 6 hours per
and 16% provided lounges and encouraged night. This widespread lack of sleep affects how
workers to "power nap" when they felt sleepy. well people perform their jobs.
Why are companies encouraging employees to go The same study found that 61% of the popu-
to sleep during working hours? The answer is lation said that a bad night's sleep impairs their
that employees will be more alert and efficient decision-making ability, and 37% felt that it pre-
when they wake up. vented them from doing their best work. The

I
I
Sleep researchers have demonstrated that no
matter how soundly we sleep at night, most of us
become drowsy in early afternoon, whether we've
obvious antidote is to make up the sleep at work,
to take brief power naps during the day to restore
alertness and efficiency.
eaten heavily at lunchtime or not. A sleepy worker The work of the National Sleep Foundation is
is not efficient or productive and is likely to make changing many corporate cultures. It has a slo-
mistakes or cause accidents. gan: Be productive. Take a nap!

Sources: Korkki, P. (2007, August 19).The yawn after lunch is perfectly normal. New York Times; Flora, C . (2008, February 4).Nap
your way to the top. Retrieved from Psychology Today Online.

For information, in English and Spanish, on Job Simplification


sleep and alertness problems (including jet lag,
Simplified, fragmented, and repetitive work
insomnia, shift work, and the effects of caffeine)
affects mental and physical health. For example,
see the Web site for the National Sleep
assembly-line workers complain more about their
Foundation at www.sleepfoundation.org You can
physical health and visit company medical facili-
also participate in a Sleep in America public opin-
ties more often than workers who do less repeti-
ion poll.
tive work. Psychologists suggest that people who
hold such jobs on a rigid work schedule are more
PSYCH'oLOGlCALAND SOCIAL ISSUES anxious, depressed, and irritable than workers
doing the same kinds of jobs on a more flexible
Other important factors in the work environment schedule. Simplified and repetitive work can lead
relate to the nature of the job and its impact on to the deterioration in cognitive functioning usu-
employees. Does your job provide you with a ally associated with old age. People who do this
sense of satisfaction and achievement, or does it type of work are prone to absentmindedness and
make you tired, bored, and ill? The design of a job disorientation.
can affect motivation and satisfaction. Some A meta-analysis of 259 research studies involving
quality-of-work-life programs have been success- 219,625 employees demonstrated that simplifying
ful in improving morale and motivation, but jobs jobs led to lower supervisor ratings of performance
designed to be so simple that they make no and lower job satisfaction. Providing more autonomy
demands on intelligence, need for achievement, in jobs led to better performance, higher job satisfac-
or attention will lead to boredom, fatigue, and tion, and lower levels of exhaustion (Humphrey,
inefficiency. Nahrgang, 6 Morgeson, 2007). .-
Part Four: Characteristics of the Workplace

The history of job simplification dates from ucts required additional businesses to advertise,
the beginnings of mass production systems in the sell, and service them. Such economic growth could
early twentieth century. If relatively expensive con- not have occurred if production methods had
sumer goods such as automobiles were to be pro- remained limited to the handcrafted approach.
duced cost-effectively in sufficient quantities to Assembly-line workers have paid a price for
meet consumer demand, then old-style production their role in this industrial development. The far-
methods, such as building each unit by hand, ther removed workers are from the finished prod-
would have to change. Mass production called for uct, the less meaning and value they attach to their
product consistency and standardization so that jobs. The carpenter who shaped a table from a piece
parts would be interchangeable. It also required of lumber knew the pride and fulfillment of
fractionation of job tasks. It was no longer econom- achievement and the challenge of using skill and
ically or technically feasible for one person to make imagination. There is little challenge and satisfac-
an entire product. The work had to be meticulously tion in operating a machine that attaches bumpers
divided so that each worker produced only a small to automobiles day after day, year after year. The
part of the finished product. The ideal was to worker is an adjunct to the machine, pressing a
reduce every manufacturing process to the simplest button or pushing a lever or watching in case some-
elements that could be mastered by an unskilled or thing goes wrong. The work has little meaning and
semiskilled employee. quickly becomes frustrating and monotonous.
Job simplification offered tremendous eco- Workers soon grow apathetic, morale declines, and
nomic advantages to industry and to consumers by the quantity and quality of production deteriorate.
permitting the lowest possible cost per unit pro- Job simplification also affects white-collar and
duced. When Henry Ford established his automo- managerial jobs because computers have turned
bile assembly line, he was able to sell cars at a price many offices into electronic assembly lines. In
within reach of people who previously could not white-collar jobs, work is increasingly fragmented
afford them. The same was true for other consumer and simplified. As a result, office workers are
goods. The factory-produced chair in which you are becoming cheaper to train and easier to replace.
sitting costs considerably less than a chair hand- Recall from chapter 9 how jobs can be enlarged,
made by a skilled furniture craftsperson. This was enriched, and expanded to provide employees with
a n additional advantage of job simplification: greater responsibility and challenge. The quality-
Industry no longer had to rely on the skilled trades, of-work-life programs discussed are real-world
the workers who required years of apprenticeship, examples of making jobs more complex rather than
expected high wages, and were apt to be independ- simpler. Expanding the job has clear benefits for
ent of mind. The typical assembly line could be both employees and employers.
staffed by workers who had little skill and could be
quickly trained to perform the job. The process
made workers more docile and easier to manage. Boredom and Monotony
Because they had few marketable skills, they knew Two inevitable consequences of job fractionation
they could easily be replaced. Workers were as and simplification-boredom and monotony-are
interchangeable as the parts they produced. important components of the psychological work
There is no denying that job simplification had environment. Boredom results from the continuous
a stimulating impact on the U.S. economy. More performance of a repetitive and uninteresting activ-
jobs became available, and people had more money ity and can lead to restlessness, discontent, and a
to buy the plentiful consumer goods. The more peo- draining of interest and energy. However, what is
ple bought, the more factories had to be built,
which, in turn, meant even more jobs. New prod-
Chapter 10: Working Conditions

be monotonous, for example, others do not. And


some workers in jobs that appear to be challenging
also report feelings of boredom. The relevant factor
is motivation. The data entry clerk who is highly
motivated to process entries without making errors
will be less bored than the worker who lacks this
motivation.
One obvious way to alleviate boredom is to
enlarge the scope of a job, to make it more complex,
stimulating, and challenging. Management can also
alter work schedules and the physical and social con-
ditions of the workplace to reduce boredom.
Attention to noise reduction, lighting, and pleasant
surroundings can help combat the negative effects of
repetitive and monotonous work. A congenial infor-
mal work group helps, as do rest pauses to provide a
change of activity. The greater the change in activity
during rest pauses or lunch breaks, the less disruptive
will be the effects of boredom ( M ~ M 2007).
,
An employee experiencing psychdogisol fatigue Jnds it
diflcult to concentrate, think coherently, und work
Physical Fatigue effectively.
Psychologists describe two types of fatigue: psycho-
logical fatigue, which is similar to boredom, and
physiological fatigue, which is caused by excessive Often a person leaves the job at the end of the shift
use of the muscles. Both types of fatigue can cause feeling exhausted but finds that the fatigue disap-
poor job performance and lead to errors, accidents, pears on arriving home and anticipating some
and absenteeism. Prolonged or heavy physical labor pleasurable activity.
produces measurable physiological changes. People A major survey of nearly 29,000 employees con-
whose jobs require heavy lifting and hauling con- firmed the strong relationship between physical
sistently show cardiovascular, metabolic, and muscle fatigue and productivity. Fully 38% of those surveyed
fatigue as well as a decline in the ability to main- said they had experienced fatigue, decreased energy,
tain their initial productivity level. and poor sleep during the 2 weeks prior to the survey.
Psychological or subjective fatigue is more diffi- The results also revealed that fatigue was higher
cult to assess but is no less disturbing to employees. among women than men, higher in workers younger
You are no doubt aware of experiencing strain, irri- than 50, and higher in Whites than in African
tability, and weakness when you are excessively Americans (Ricci Chee, Lorandeau, &- Berger, 2007).
tired, or of finding it difficult to concentrate, think In research conducted in the Netherlands with
coherently, and work effectively, 322 university employees and 555 nurses, researchers
On-the-job research has shown that productiv- found that as the demands of a job increased, greater
ity parallels reported feelings of fatigue. High feelings of job control reduced fatigue. Also, as the
reported fatigue is a reliable indicator that produc- demands of a job increased, reported feelings of
tion will shortly decline. With most physically fatigue led to a decrease in job satisfaction (Van
demanding work, employees say that they are most Yperen 6 Hagedoorn, 2003; Van Yperen &- Janssen,
tired at the beginning of the work period, just 2002).
before the lunch break, and again at the end of the Studies in Japan and in Australia showed that
workday. Thus, fatigue does not build up over the fatigue can be reduced if working hours are kept to
course of the work period but appears and disap- fewer than 260 per month and if workers perceive
pears throughout the working hours. This suggests that they have a high level of organizational support
that factors other than physical labor (motivation, (Nagashima et al., 2007; Samaha, Lai, Samaha, 6
for example) can influence feelings of fatigue. Wyndham, 2007).
Par1 Four: Characteristics oj'lhi. W o r k p l a c e

Research on physiological fatigue indicates that ination than those who speak English on the job
workers can undertake greater amounts of physical ( Bergman, Watrous-Rodriguez, & Chalkley, 2008).
labor when the work- pace is more gradual. Too
rapid a rate of heavy work dissipates the body's Sexual and Gender Harassment. Wonlen a t all
energy too quickly so that the worker lnust then levels in a n organization facc harassnlent on the
function at a slower pace for the remainder of the job ranging from suggestive remarks and obscene
work period. An analogy can be made with long- jokes to threats of job loss and physical assaults. A
distance runners who pace themselves so that they distinction can be inade between sexual harassment
do riot use all their energy before covering the and gender harassment. Sexual harassnlent
desired distance. involves unwanted sexual attention and coercion.
Rest periods are necessary for jobs that involve Gender harassment refers to behavior that reflects
heavy physical labor, and they should be taken a n insulting, hostile, and degrading attitude
before fatigue is complete. The greater the amount toward women. Thus, gender harassment does not
of fatigue at the time of the rest break, the longer necessarily involve sexual harassment. Gender
the recalvcry period must be. For some jobs, more harassment is directed toward all women, whereas
frequenr rest breaks are needed. Rest periods must sexual harassment is targeted toward a specific
provide total relaxation, not merely a stoppage of woman. To report incidents of sexual harassment
work. Tht, manual laborer, more than the office and to receive advice o n dealing with it, call the
worker, will benefit from pleasant cafeterias and toll-free Job Survival Hotline of 9 to 5, a working
cornfortable lounges in which to relax. women's advocacy group (1-800-522-0925).Their
Wcb site, www.9to5.org, focuses on issues of
economic fairness, harassment, and work-family
Ethnic and Gender Harassment policies.
Another social-psychological condition of the Gender and sexual harassnlent have occurred
workplace that affects productivity, job satisfaction, in many workplaces and have resulted in costly and
and emotional and physical health is on-the-job embarrassing lawsuits for prominent organizations.
harassment, whether based on race, cthnicity, gen- Chevron paid $2.2 million to four female employees
der, or other personal characteristics. Harassment who were further harassed following their initial fil-
may come from co-workers or supervisors, or it ing of sexual harassnlent charges. Mitsubishi was
may bc part of the corporate culture. ordered to pay $34 million to several hundred
women who charged that the company's Illinois
Ethnic Harassment. The population of a typical plant failed to respond to their sexual harassment
workplace, like the population of many countries, complaints.
has become increasingly diverse. As organizations A review of harassment claims filcd with the
employ more people of vdrious racial and ethnic Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
groups, harassment is on the rise. Ethnic harassment (EEOC) showed that several types of companies
is an obvious source of stress. It may be manifested at were likely to be the target of lawsuits because they
work as slurs or derogatory comments about a ignored reports of harassnlent. These include family-
person's racial or ethnic group and nlay result in the owned businesses, firins too small to maintain
exclusion of the person from work groups or social human resources or personnel departments, facto-
activities. ries located in rural areas, and so-called malc-
A study of 575 Hispanic nlen and women pro- dominated industries such as construction. Younger
vided evidence of harassment on the job. Verbal women in low-level jobs, single or divorced women,
slurs, derogatory comments, and offensive ethnic and women in predominantly malc environments
jokes were found to bc more cornnlon than bchav- report more harassment than do middle-age or
iors intended to exclude a person on cthnic grounds. older married women whose jobs are not in male-
People who wcre targets of verbal harassment dominated organizations.
reported a lowering of their sense of psychological S t ~ ~ d i have
e s shown that minority women are
well-being' (Schneider, Hitlan, & Radhakrishnan, far more likely than majority women to experience
2000). Hispanic workers who speak Spanish on the harassment on the job. Women of all races who are
job report more exclusion, harassment, and discrim- seen as violating female stereotypes (such as being
Chapter 10: Working Condiiiuns

assertive, aggressive, or behaving in other so-called Women perceived a rvider range of behaviors as
masculine ways) are more likely to be sexually potentially harassing than did men. For cxample,
harassed than are thosc who behave in tvays that 89% qf women perccived sexual touching as harass-
are tratlitionally considered feminine (Berdahl, ment; only 59 percent of rncn shared that vielv. Men
2007; Bcrdahl & Moore, 2006). Sexual harassment iverc significantly more likely to believe that physi-
on the job also occurs morc frequently in ivork- cal scxual contact initiated by a woman was a com-
places tvhere the male employees havc a habit of plimcnt; womcn were more likely to believe that
drinking heavily, cven off the job (Bacharach, physical sexual contact initiated by a m a n ivas a
Bambcrger, b McICinney, 2007). threal and a n instance of harassment (Rotundo,
The reported incidence of sexual harassment can Nguyen, b Sackett, 2001 ). Thus, there is disagree-
bc affected by [he wording of the survcy questions. A ment about the bchaviors that are considered
mela-analysis of 55 samples (consisting of 86,578 harassing. Another point to keep in mind is that not
respondents) found two distinct approachcs LO meas- all incidents of harassment on the job are reported.
uring the incidence of sexual harassment. The direct In a study of 3 15 male and 262 female police offi-
querysuwy allows respondents to define what behav- cers in New Zealand, researchers found that gendcr
iors constitule sexual harassment and to describe harassment lvas a significantly greater source of psy-
freely w h a t happencd to them. The behavioral chological distress for tvomcn than for men. The
experiences s ~ l w e yprovides respondents with a list of researchers suggested that harassment is more harm-
incidents defined by he researcher as constituting ful for ivomen who work in traditionally male occu-
sexual harassmcnt; respondents then select thc pations such as police dcpartments, because in those
experiences or behaviors t h a ~correspond to their pcr- situations such behaviors can make women fcel that
sonal situation. Thcse approaches reveal striking dif- "thcy need to over-perform to be acccpted and recog-
ferences in [he reported incidcnce of harassment. nized within the organization. High performance
Women ivho responded to surveys that used the demands are in turn associated tvith psychological
direct qucry approach reported the incidence of distress" (Parker b. Griffin, 2002, p. 13).
harassment at approximately 35%, ~vhereaswomen Like ethnic harassmcnt, gendcr harassment
who responded to surveys [hat used the behavioral can lead to physical ailments (gastrointestinal dis-
expcriences approach reported the incidence of orders, headaches, and weight loss) a:; wcll as psy-
harassment at approximately 620.6 (llies, Hauserman, chological problems (fear, depression, anxiety, and
Schwochau, b Stibal, 2003). These findings provide loss of self-esteem). It also has a negative effect on
another example of the importance of knotving how ,job satisfaction and productivity. Many studies link
a survcy was conducted and how the questions were harassment lo low job satisfaction and high stress
phrased before evaluating and applying the results. (Wiliness, Sleel, b Lee, 2007). A stucl)' of 11,52 1
The same meta-analysis compared the incidence women in the U.S. military showed that sexual
of sexual harassmen1 in four work environments: harassment led to a significant increase in
academic, the private sector, governmcnt, and the turnover. Those who had espericnced harassment
military. The reporled incidence of sesual harass- were far more likely to leave the service than those
ment was highest in the military setting; the results w h o had not been harassed (Sims, Drasgow, 6
were the same for both types of survey questions. Fitzgcrald, 2005).
More womcn in the military reporled being harassed Sexual harassment affects even those employ-
than womcn in any other work environment. Thc ees w h o are not being pcrsonally harassed. I n a
lowest reported incidence was in acadcmia. study of 1,702 male and female university cmploy-
Survey data from 22,372 tvomcn in all branches ees, investigators found that simply observing inci-
of he military services in the United States revealed dents of sexual harassment on the job led to lower
that 4% of them reported actual or attempted rape reported psychological tvell-being, lo~verorganiza-
by other military personnel. Thosc most likely to tional commitment and job satisfaction, and
report such physical assaults tvere lower in rank, increased intentions to.look for work elservhere
hencc in status and power (Harried, Ormerod, among both men and women (Miner-Rubino b
Palrnieri, Collinsworth, b Reed, 2002). Cortina, 2007).
A meta-analysis of gender diffrrences in defin- Research shows that most incidcnts of sexual
ing harassment involved 62 research studies. harassment on the job are not reported b u t of fear
Part Four: Characteristics of the Workplace

of retaliation, a fear that may be justified. A study well as actions being taken to combat on-the-job
of 6,417 men and women in the U.S. armed forces harassment. For the federal government's policy on
showed that those whqreported sexual harassment sexual harassment, and links to the proper way to
to their superiors faced retaliatory measures that file a charge of employment discrimination, see
led to greater psychological distress and lower job www.eeoc.gov/factslfs-sex.htm1
satisfaction. The higher the rank of the perpetrator
of the offense, the less likely that the organization
took punitive measures or corrective action against
Telecommuting: The Virtual
the harasser (Bergman, Langhout, Palrnieri, Cortina, Workplace at Home
& Fitzgerald, 2002). A study of 622 female nurses Many employees now work at home, thanks to
in Turkey revealed that 80% of those who had been advances in personal computers, telecommu-
sexually harassed on the job (almost always by nications, and fax machines. This move toward
male physicians) did not report the incidents to the telecommuting-the decentralizing of work-has
hospital administration for fear of retaliation (Celik affected hundreds of U.S. companies in life insur-
6 Celik, 2007). ance, data processing, financial services, airline
Another source of sexual harassment in the and hotel reservations, and mail-order merchan-
workplace comes not from co-workers or superiors dising. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management
but from the organization's customers and clients. estimates that 45 million workers in the United
A survey of 3,839 female employees found that States telecommute at least part time. Men in
such harassment led to decreases in job satisfaction their early 40s make up 65% of this workforce.
and organizational commitment, increases in Telecommuting is particularly attractive to employ-
stress, and a tendency to avoid the predatory client, ees with day-care or dependent-care problems and
which had negative repercussions for both the to disabled workers.
employee and the organization (Gettman 6 Companies that provide for telecommuting cite
Gelfand, 2007). gains in productivity, reduced costs for office over-
Gender and sexual harassment remain seri- head, and, obviously, a decline in absenteeism.
ous problems in the workplace, despite the People working at home may have fewer interrup-
ongoing publicity given to the issues. Training tions than people working in offices and may be
programs designed to make employees more
aware of and sensitive to the feelings of others
have had limited effects. A strong organizational
culture in which the consequences of sexual
harassment on the job are swift and severe can
reduce but not eliminate the problem. A com-
mitted organizational leadership is also impor-
tant. A study of 2,749 men and women in the
military showed that women who viewed their
leaders as making honest and sincere efforts to
stop harassment were significantly more willing
to report harassment than those whose leaders
were more tolerant of harassment. In addition,
women who viewed their leaders as sincere
about the issue were more satisfied with the pro-
cedure for filing complaints about harassment
and felt more committed to the organization
(Offermann & Malamut, 2002).
For current news about sexual harassment and
links to related sites see the Web site for the A growing number of employees work from a home ofice, an
National Organization for Women (NOW) at www. option that is particularly aftradfve to people with dq-tpre
now.org/issues/harass It describes current cases as concerns.
Ch~zpter10: Working Conditions

able to concentrate better. They can perform their 2008). In a meta-analysis of 46 studies of nearly
job in bad weather or when feeling poorly, whereas 13,000 workers, researchers found that telecom-
office-based employees in those situations might muting was related to increascd feelings of auton-
hesitate to come to worlt. Research at IBM coillparing omy, positive relationships with supervisors,
virtual-office telecommuters with in-house office higher performance ratings, greater job satisfac-
employees found that telecommuting was associ- tion, and reduced stress and turnover intentions.
ated with high productivity and job satisfaction as Nevertheless, telecolrlmuting also appeared t o
well as increascd psychological well-being. IBM's lead to poor relationships with co-workers; this is
flexible telework program has been so successful not surprising as t h e teleworkers spent so little
that 40% of its 330,000 employees havc chosen to time socializing in t h e office (Gajendran &
work away from the office, either at home or on the Harrison, 2007). A survey of information technol-
road (Cooney, 2007). ogy worlters in Egypt found that, in principle, far
In general, cvonlen in virtual offices are more more of then1 favored telecommuting than opposed
productive t h a n men in virtual offices, but both it (Abdcl-Wahab, 2007).
groups seem pleased that they don't have to spend Not everyone likes the idea of working at
time commuting. Thcy enjoy being able to sched- home. Not only do some people miss the social
ule their work outside traditional office hours, interaction, but they inay not he sufficien~lydisci-
and they report fewer distractions and a more plined to worlt steadily without supervision. Some
comfortable working environment. In a study of spouses object to having a partner work at home.
26 highly educated white-collar workers in Children may provide a n additional distraction.
Sweden, researchers found that the blood pres- Some managers believe they will lose their author-
sure levels of both men and women were signifi- ity over subordinates if the subordinates are not
cantly higher when they workcd at the office than physically prcsent. And labor unions are concerned
when they worked a t home. This finding sug- about the declining loyalty of members who do not
gested to the researchers that working a t home work together on t h r job.
was less stressful for these workers (Lundberg S To deal with potential feelings of isolation,
Lindfors, 2002). somc companies have established progranls to
Los Angeles County administrators estimated enable tcleworkers to develop and maintain rela-
that their telecomnluling program involving 2,600 tionships w i t h other telc-commuters a n d w i t h
workers saved $ 1 1 inillion a year in increased pro- office employees. IBM has set up so-called mobil-
ductivity, rcduccd absenteeism, decreased over- ity centers where telecommuters can havc office
time pay, and rcduccd office space. Thcy also time with other enlployees. IRM clubs also
claimed that the progranl cut commuting time by encourage telecommuting employecs to meet co-
1.4 million hours, thereby eliminating 7,500 tons workers through company-organized social out-
of carbon monoxide from car exhausts. An ATST ings in settings far removed from thc traditional
poll of 1,005 home-based worlters found that 80% worltplacc.
believed they were more producti\,e t h a n when Some tclecomnluters feel pressured to worlt
working in company offices. In addition, 61% said harder than they did in their traditional offices.
they got sick less oflen, and 79%)appreciated the Others say that by worlting at home, they are never
chance to wear casual clothes while rvorlcing. free of the job. When the phone or fax or e-mail
Surveys at other companies found increases of up summons t h e m after working hours, they feel
to 30% in productivity as well as a significant compelled to respond. For these reasons, nearly
reduction in the nonproductive work time spent 20% of telecommuting programs fail. Another rea-
socializing. 'Telecommuting does not appear to be son for unsuccessful programs is that some
related to any decrease in a n employee's opportu- telccomnluters d o not get the rechnical support
nity for promotion. they need from employers. Despite these difficul-
A survey of 10,000 U.S. workers found t h a l ties, many employees prefer working at home.
73% of the telecoinnluters were satisfied with Human resources managers view telecommuting
their employer, as compared to only 64% of those as one of the most important workplace trends of
who worked in the company offices (Coombes, the twenty-first century
Part Four: Characteristics of t h e Workplace

rrlysical working cvrlditions include factors such as 4-day workweek seems to result in Iower absen-
the location of the factory or office building, park- teeism and higher morale, but it has little effect on
ing facilities, heating and air-conditioning systems, productivity. Flextime is popular with employees
elevators, child-care facilities, cafeterias, and rest and increases productivity and job satisfaction. Rest
rooms. Environmental psychology is concerned pauses are taken whether or not they are officially
with the impact of these workplace features on sanctioned. In manual labor they are necessary to
employee behaviors and attitudes. In the land- rest the muscles. For sedentary workers, rest pauses
scaped office, employees are grouped in functional provide a change of pace and help alleviate bore-
units with no floor-to-ceiling barriers. dom. Shift work disrupts the body's diurnal rhythm
Light distribution and glare must be considered and can lead to social and psychological difficulties.
in designing illumination for work spaces. Noise in In general, productivity is lower on the night shift;
the work area can lead to deafness and to physiolog- serious accidents and errors are higher.
ical effects such as increased muscle tension and Social-psychological working conditions relate
high blood pressure. Color is a useful coding device to the design of the job and its effects on employ-
that can create differing illusions of size and tem- ees. Job simplification has made many jobs so
perature and improve the aesthetic appearance of unchallenging that they are boring and lead to psy-
the workplace. Some employees like music on the chological and physiological fatigue that reduces
job, but research shows that it does not influence productivity and job satisfaction. Repetitive, boring
productivity. Optimal temperature and humidity work is also tiring. Boredom can be relieved by
ranges have been established for different kinds of enlarging the job scope, improving working condi-
workplaces. The comfort level of a workspace also tions, and scheduling rest pauses. Ethnic and gen-
depends on humidity level and air circulation. der harassment occur frequently in the workplace.
Temporal working conditions include the num- Harassment causes harmful physical and emo-
ber of hours worked and how those hours are tional effects on employees as well as reducing
arranged. Much scheduled work time is lost to their job satisfaction and productivity.
unauthorized breaks. When nominal working Advances in computer and telecommunica-
hours are reduced, production tends to increase. tions technology have made working at home pos-
Part-time employment offers opportunities to com- sible for many types of employees. Telecommuting
bine career, family, educational, leisure, and other is associated with higher productivity, lower absen-
pursuits, and may result in greater productivity. The teeism, and corporate savings on office space.

environmental psychology job simplification


flextime nominal working hours

I Review Questions
1. Why is it difficult to interpret the effects of a affect productivity and the nature of the
change in the physical work environment that working relationships among co-workers?
has led to an increase in productivity? 4. Describe advantages and disadvantages of
2. What are the major complaints made by office landscaped offices.
workers about their work environment? 5. What is a foot-candle of light? Why is it a bad
3. In what ways can the size and design of idea to illuminate a workstation at a much
offices and the size of a n office building higher level of intensity than its surroundings?
Chapter 10: Working Conditions

6. How many decibels does it take to cause per- 14. When did job simplification begin? What did it
manent deafness? What other physiological involve? How did it benefit the U.S. economy?
changes occur as a result of exposure to high 15. Is there a relationship between job simplifica-
noise levels? tion and boredom or monotony on the job? If
7. In what ways can the use of different colors be so, explain it.
helpful in the workplace? 16. How would you reduce boredom and fatigue in
8. Describe the history of music provided for work- an automobile assembly plant? In an office
ers on the job. For what kinds of jobs does music where employees work at computer terminals?
lead to an increase in productivity? 17. Distinguish between ethnic harassment, sex-
9. What are the effects of exposure to very high ual harassment, and gender harassment.
temperatures on the job? Why do some organi- 18. What are the effects of sexual harassment on
zations put fake thermostats in their offices? female employees? On co-workers who observe
10. What is the difference between nominal work- the harassment?
ing hours and actual working hours? 19. In what type of work environment has sexual
11. What was the effect on actual working hours harassment been found to occur most fre-
when nominal working hours were increased quently?
in some companies during the years of World 20. Why are most incidents of sexual harassment
War II? not reported? What factors can reduce sexual
12. What are the advantages to employees and harassment at work?
employers of permanent part-time employ- 21. Why do some employees dislike telecommut-
ment, of a 4-day workweek, and of flexible ing?
working hours? 22. Would you rather telecommute for your job or
13. If you had a job that required shift work, which work in the office or factory? Why?
shift schedule would you choose? Explain the
reason for your choice.

Bell, l?, Green, T., Fisher, J., & Baum, A. (2001). Peirce, E., Smolinski, C. A., & Rosen, B. (1998).
Environmental psychology (5th ed.). Ft. Worth, Why sexual harassment complaints fall on deaf
TX: Harcourt College Publishers. A standard ears. Academy of Management Executive, 12 ( 3 ) ,
textbook on environmental psychology; covers 41-54. Discusses reasons why many organiza-
the influence of physical workplace features on tions are slow to respond to employees' com-
employee behaviors and attitudes. plaints of sexual harassment, forcing victims to
Hochschild, A. R. (1997). The time bind: When work seek help through the court system.
becomes home and home becomes work. New York: Rothausen, T. J., Gonzalez, J. A,, Clarke, N. E., 6
MetropolitardHolt. Describes an organization O'Dell, L. L. (1998). Family-friendly backlash.
in which employees routinely put in 10-hour Personnel Psychology, 51, 685-706. Discusses the
workdays and identify more with colleagues positive and negative effects on employees of
and subordinates than with family members, employer-provided on-site child care facilities.
deriving greater social support from office rela-
tionships than from relationships outside the
workplace.

You might also like