Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In 1954, he was appointed as governor of his home province of East Bengal by prime
minister Mohammad Ali of Bogra to control the law and order sparked as a result of the
popular language movement in 1952, but later elevated as interior minister in Bogra
administration in 1955.
Playing a crucial role in ousting of governor-general Sir Malik Ghulam, Mirza assumed his
position in 1955 and was elected as the first president of Pakistan when the first
set of Constitution was promulgated in 1956.[
Playing a crucial role in ousting of governor-general Sir Malik Ghulam, Mirza assumed his
position in 1955 and was elected as the first president of Pakistan when the first
set of Constitution was promulgated in 1956
.[5] His presidency, however, marked with political instability which saw his unconstitutional
interferences in the civilian administration that led to the dismissal of four prime ministers in a
mere two years.
Facing challenges in getting the political endorsements and reelection for the presidency, Mirza
surprisingly suspended the writ of the Constitution by having imposed martial law against his
own party's administration governed by Prime Minister Feroze Khan on 8 October 1958,
enforcing it through his army commander General Ayub Khan who dismissed him when the
situation between them escalated, also in 1958.
Mirza lived in the United Kingdom for the remainder of his life and was buried in Iran in 1969.[3]
His legacy and image is viewed negatively by some Pakistani historians who believe that Mirza
was responsible for weakening of democracy and political instability in the country.[3]
o 2Political career in Pakistan
o 3Presidency (1956–58)
3.1Martial law
Mirza was the first Indian graduate of the military college, and gained his commission in
the British Indian Army as 2nd Lt. on 16 July 1920.[12][3][13] As was customary for newly
commissioned British Indian Army officers, he was initially attached for a year to the second
battalion of the Cameronians (Scottish Rifles).[3] On 16 July 1921, he was promoted to lieutenant
and was assigned to command a platoon on 30 December 1921.[14
11-08-1955 To 12-09-1956
Ch. Mohammed Ali
12-09-1956 To 18-10-
5 Mr. Hussain Shaheed Suharwardi
1957
18-10-1957 To 16-12-
6 Mr. Ibrahim Ismail Chaundrigar
1957
16-12-1957 To 07-10-
7 Malik Feroz Khan Noon
1958
Presidency (1956–58)
The newly constituted Electoral College unanimously elected Mirza as the first president upon
the promulgation of the first set of the Constitution on 23 March 1956.[36] The coalition of
the Awami League, the Muslim League, and the Republic Party endorsed his presidency.[36]
Threatened by President Mirza's dismissal, Prime Minister Suhrawardy tendered his resignation
on 17 October 1957 and was succeeded by I. I. Chundrigar but he too was forced to resigned in
mere two months.[39]
President Mirza had widely lacked the parliamentary spirit, distrusting the civilians to ensure the
integrity and sovereignty of country.[36] His unconstitutional interference in the civil administration
made the elected prime ministers effectively
unable to function the government, as he had dismissed four elected prime ministers in matter of
two years
.[36] On his last nomination, he appointed Feroz Khan as the seventh Prime Minister of the
country, who had been supported by the Awami League and the Muslim League.[3]
Basic principles
The Constitution drives the country's system of government toward parliamentarianism,
with executive powers vested under the elected prime minister while the president serving as
a ceremonial head of state.[36]
On 12 September 1956, he established and became vice-president of the Republican Party that
was in direct conflict with Muslim League, mainly due to disagreement on the idea of
republicanism and conservatism.[30] Unable to keep the substantial pressure on Mirza's Republic
Party eventually led the Muslim League's successful demand for the resignation of Prime
Minister Muhammad Ali on 12 September 1956.[37]
Upon these development, President Mirza invited Awami League to form the central government
that appointed Huseyn Suhrawardy as the Prime Minister, who made an alliance with the
Republican Party, to take over the charge of the government.[38]
1. Objectives Resolution’s Place in the Constitution: the interim report suggested that the Objectives
Resolution was to be included in the constitution of Pakistan as the directive principles of policy as
guideline of policy making.
2. Federal from of Constitution: this was evident from the geographical split and the ethnic and linguistic
diversity of Pakistan. Each part of the federation was to be known as a federating unit. The provinces
of Pakistan, along with the federal capital, tribal areas and princely states that had not formally
acceded to Pakistan till then were all the federating units of Pakistan. A total of 9 federating units (4
provinces + 5 other federating units) comprised the western wing of the country called West Pakistan
while 1 federating unit (1 province) comprised the eastern wing of the country called East Pakistan.
3. Parliamentary Form of Government: there was to be a bicameral central/federal legislature which
would jointly elect the Prime Minster, on whose advice the Head of State was to appoint Ministers.
4. Bicameral Central Legislature: the interim report suggested a bicameral federal legislature with both
houses having equal power. Details of both houses are as follows:
1. Upper House: this was to be called the House of Units. All federating units were to have an
equal number of seats in the proposed Upper House.
2. Lower House: this was to be called the House of People. All federating units were to have a
number of seats in proportion to their population in the proposed Lower House. The Prime
Minister was to be appointed by the Head of State from amongst the members of the Lower
House.
5. Joint Session of the Central Legislature: the Head of State was to have the authority to call in a joint
session for various purposes including election of the Head of State, removal of the Head of State,
resolution of a conflict between the two houses, consideration of budget and money bills etc.
6. Unicameral Legislatures for the Units: federating units of Pakistan were to have a unicameral
legislature. The Chief Minister was to be appointed from amongst the members of the legislature by
the Head of Province who was to be appointed by the Head of State.
7. Powers of the Head of State: the Head of State was to be elected jointly by the two houses at the
center. He was to enjoy vast powers according to the interim report of the BPC though he was to
exercise most of his powers on the advice of the Prime Minster. He was not necessarily to be a
Muslim. The Head of State was to appoint the Prime Minister, the heads of provinces i.e. Governors,
and the Commanders in Chief of the military forces. The also had the power to dissolve the House of
People on the advice of the Prime Minister. Finally, the Central Legislature had the power to remove
the Head of State in a joint session.
8. Immunity for the Executive and Legislature: the Head of State, the Prime Minister and the legislators
were all indemnified from appearing in the courts for all acts taken in their official capacity.
9. National Language: Urdu was to be the national language of Pakistan.
bOGRA FORUMELA
Suhrawardy's popularity with his East Pakistan constituency further dipped when he backed down over the
Awami League's call for land reforms because of the resistance of the West Punjab rural elite. He was now in
the dangerous business of disappointing friends and creating enemies. He evoked the ire of the western
province's business class, l'or example, by having the temerity to tinker with the longstanding regional economic
imbalances in distributing the lion's share of American uid to East Pakistani industrialists.66 The West Pakistanis
now decided that it was time to pull the carpet from under his feet. The withdrawal of Republican support from
the coalition sealed Suhrawardy's fate67 and ushered in the farce of Chundrigar's two month ministry. Brief
though it was, Chundrigar stayed sufficiently long enough to further widen the gulf between the eastern and
western wings by reversing Suhrawardy's decision on the allocation of the US $10 million aid package.
BOGRA FORMULA
Bogra Formula[edit]
The Bogra Formula was a political compromise presented and proposed by Prime Minister
Bogra on 7 October 1953 before the Constituent Assembly.[43]
Upon taking the control of the Prime Minister's Secretariat, Bogra announced that drafting of the
codified Constitution was his primary target, and within six months, he announced a proposal that
leads to the drafting of the constitution writ.[43]
300 seats
The framework proposed the establishment of more effective bicameral parliament that would be
composed of National Assembly and the Senate with equal representation from then-five
provinces: Punjab, Khyber–Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan, Sindh, and Bengal.[43] A total of 300 seats
were to be reserved for the National Assembly on the basis of proportionate representation and
50 for the Senate that would be equal representation for all the five provinces of the country.[43]
Under this framework, the larger number of constituencies were given to Bengal which had 165
reserved seats in contrast to Punjab which had 75, Khyber–Pakhtunkhwa, which had 24, Sindh
which had 19, and Balochistan which had 17 reserved seats.[43] Tribal areas, Karachi metropolitan
area, Bahawalpur, Khairpur, Baluchistan States Union, were combined as 24 reserved seats.[43]
In this framework, Bengal had given more seats due to its social homogeneity in the National
Assembly than the combined reserved seats for the four provinces and the federal capital which,
all were socially heterogeneous and ethically diverse.[43]
But combined the reserved seats in the four provinces were in balance with Bengal in
the bicameral parliament.[43] Both the houses were given equal power, and in case of a conflict
between the two houses, the issue was to be presented before a joint session.[43]
The Bogra framework also addresses the check and balance to avoid the permanent domination
by any five provinces where a provision was made that if the President was elected from the four
provinces then the Prime Minister was to be elected from East Bengal, and vice versa.[43]
The President was to be elected for a term of 5 years from the indirect elections by the Electoral
College formed by both houses: National Assembly and the Senate.[43]
The Supreme Court of Pakistan was to be given more power and institutional judicial
independence that would permanently replace the Islamic clergy to decide if a law was in
accordance with the basic teachings of the Koran or not.[43]
The Bogra formulae was highly popular and widely welcomed by the people as opposed to
the Basic Principles Committee led by Prime Minister Nazimuddin as it was seen as great
enthusiasm amongst the masses as they considered it as a plan that could bridge the gulf
between the two wings of Pakistan and would act as a source of unity for the country.[43]
In 1955, the One Unit Scheme integrated the four provinces of the western wing of Pakistan into a single
province, West Pakistan.[43][44][45]
The compromise did not settled to its ground when Governor-General Ghulam Muhammad,
threatened by curbing of his powers, dissolved the Constituent Assembly in 1954 with the
support of Pakistan military and civil bureaucracy.[46][47]
One Unit[edit]
Main article: One Unit
Following the failure of reaching concession on Bogra Formula, he began working towards the
controversial One Unit program that integrated the Four Provinces into a single nation-state and
began advocating for such idea when he quoted:
There will be no Bengalis, no Punjabis, no Sindhis, no Pathans, no Balochis, no Bahawalpuris,
no Khairpuris. The disappearance of these groups will strengthen the integrity of Pakistan...
— Prime Minister M. A. Bogra, presenting the One Unit on 22 November 1954 [48]
Huseyn Shaheed
Suhrawardy(1892–1963)
n Dhaka, Suhrawardy
emerged as the leader of
the Bengali-dominated A
wami League which
became the principal
opposition party to
the Pakistan Muslim
League. In 1956, the
centre-left Awami
League formed
a coalition
government with the
military-backed Republic
an Party to unseat the
Muslim League.
Suhrawardy became
Prime Minister in the 12 17
Awami
5 coalition government. He Septembe October —
League
forged stronger ties with r 1956 1957
the United States by
leading Pakistan's
diplomacy
in SEATO and CENTO.
He also became the first
Pakistani premier to
travel to Communist
China. His pro-US
foreign policy caused a
split in the Awami
League in East Pakistan,
with Maulana
Bhashani forming the
break-away pro-
Maoist National Awami
Party. Suhrawardy's
premiership lasted for a
year. His central cabinet
included figures like
Sir Feroz Khan Noon as
Foreign Minister
and Abul Mansur
Ahmad as Trade
Minister. Sheikh Mujibur
Rahman was considered
Suhrawardy's chief
political protégé.[8]
Ibrahim Ismail
Chundrigar(1898–1968
Ibrahim Ismail
Chundrigar[3] (Urdu: ابراہیم
;اسماعیل چندریگر15
September 1897[1] – 26
September 1960), best
known as I. I.
Chundrigar, was the
sixth prime minister of
Pakistan, appointed in
this capacity on 17
October 1957 until being
removed due to a vote of
no confidence on 11
December 1957.
Trained in constitutional
law at the University of
Bombay and one of
17 16
the Founding Fathers of Muslim
6 October December —
the Dominion of League
1957 1957
Pakistan, Chundrigar's
tenure is the second
shortest served in
the parliamentary
history of Pakistan just
after that of Nurul
Amin who served as
prime minister for 13
days. Chundrigar served
for just 55 days.[4][5]
16
Sir Feroze Khan 7 October Republica
7 December —
Noon(1893–1970) 1958 n Party
1957
In his memoirs, "From Memory", Noon writes, "With Gwadar in foreign hands, I had felt we were
living in a house in which the back room with another door, was occupied by a stranger who
could, at any time, sell us out to a power inimical to Pakistan…".[38][39]
The wife of Feroz Khan Noon, Viqar-un-Nisa Noon, also played a large role in the accession of
Gwadar to Pakistan. She visited London in 1956 to see the British Prime Minister Winston
Churchill, and to lobby the British Parliament for their protectorate of Muscat and Oman to give
custody of 'Gwadar Port' to Pakistan,[40] and get approval from the House of Lords.[41][42][43][44][45][39]
Noon had not endorsed the presidential re-election of Mirza as the three-party coalition had been
negotiating their own president to replace Mirza in 1958.[46] At midnight on 7/8 October 1958,
Mirza imposed martial law in a coup d'état against his own party's government, effectively
dismissing his own appointed Prime Minister to usurp all political power into his own hands.[31]
Ruling
legitimized
Court membership
Muhammad Munir
Muhammad Shahabuddin
Amiruddin Ahmad
Laws applied
Dosso v. Federation of Pakistan was the first constitutional case after the promulgation
of Constitution of Pakistan of 1956 and an important case in Pakistan's political history. The case
got prominence as it indirectly questioned the first martial law imposed by President Iskander
Mirza in 1958.[1]
First pm
Chaudhry Muhammad Ali
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Chaudhry Mohammad Ali)
Jump to navigationJump to search
This article is about the fourth prime minister of Pakistan. For the third prime minister
of Pakistan, see Mohammad Ali Bogra.
For other people named Muhammad Ali, see Muhammad Ali (disambiguation).
Chaudhry
Mohammad Ali
In office
Monarch Elizabeth II
Minister of Defence
In office
(Defence Secretary)
Succeeded by H. S. Suhrawardy
2nd Minister of Finance
In office
(Finance Secretary)
Federal Secretary
In office
In office
Finance Secretary
In office
(as Finance Secretary)
In office
Succeeded by I. I. Chundrigar
Personal details
15 July 1905
Jalandhar, Punjab, British India
(Present-day, Jalandhar, Punjab, India)
Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan
Pakistani (1947–82)
(BSc and MSc in Chem.)
Official website
Chaudhry Muhammad Ali (Urdu: چ وہ دری دمحم علی 15 July 1905 – 2 December 1982),
best known as Muhammad Ali, was the fourth prime minister of Pakistan, appointed
on 12 August 1955 until being removed through successful passage of vote of no
confidence motion in the National Assembly on 12 September 1956.[citation needed]
His credibility is noted for promulgating the first set of the Constitution of
Pakistan lost