Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Malnutrition affects 42 million people in the United States. (Hunger Fight, n.d.) It costs
the country $15.5 billion in healthcare costs and accounts for one-third of all hospitalizations
which makes malnutrition a major public health concern. (Castellucci, 2016) Food insecurity is
the reason that malnutrition is such a widespread yet silent problem. (World Food Programme,
n.d.) The diseases caused by malnourishment can be subdivided into micronutrient deficiencies
and protein-energy deficiencies (Muller,O. & Krawinkel, M., 2005) To test the effects of a
healthy plant-based diet on malnutrition, one nutritious meal a day, three times a week, for six
months, was provided for a group of 215 participants (ages 18-72). Health and wellness tests
were performed monthly to record changes in overall state of health, specifically focusing on
micronutrient levels and waist circumference. Results demonstrated a consistent, steady increase
in micronutrient levels in all participants with ranges below normal at the beginning of the study
and concluding well within normal levels. Waist circumference showed a gradual decrease over
the six months in all participants who were overweight. The sweeping decrease in malnutrition
seen throughout the six-month longitudinal study confirms that the implementation of a
nutritious, plant-based diet improves public health. In order to address the issue of food
insecurity that leads to malnutrition, legislative changes were proposed to ban food waste in the
United States and to provide more government subsidies for specialty crop farmers.
Hidden Hunger 2
When speaking of malnutrition, the image of a skeletal child in a third world country is
recalled for most. In reality, that is not always the case. This vast misconception allows the
problem to be ubiquitous yet remain unknown, even in the United States. The real definition of
Food insecurity is not being able to access enough food or nutritious enough food to
maintain health. (World Food Programme, n.d.) Food security is measured by three values: food
availability, access to food, and food utilization. In 2015, almost 16 million homes in the United
States were considered food insecure. (“Definitions of Food Security” n.d.) To put it in
perspective, that is equal to 59.5 million people living with hunger or about 19% of the United
States’ population. (“Definitions of Food Security” n.d.) Because of this, a variety of nutritional
imbalances and conditions develop every day in the population of the United States. The
In some rural towns like Jonestown in Mississippi, families sometimes go weeks without
eating a fresh fruit or vegetable because there are none available. (A Place at the Table, 2012) In
Jonestown, only one supermarket has a small selection of fresh fruits and vegetables at high
prices which most people cannot afford on their meager budgets. Any fruits or vegetables that
are available come in cans and the nearest supermarket that does offer a large, varied selection of
fresh fruits, vegetables, and healthy products is thirty-three miles away. (A Place at the Table,
2012) The lack of food availability and difficulty of accessing the necessary healthy foods make
At first glance however, Mississippi may not appear to have a problem with food
availability as they also have the highest rate of obesity in the country. (A Place at the Table,
Hidden Hunger 3
2012) This can be attributed to the fact that people are basically forced to eat empty calories.
They do not have access to affordable, nutritious foods. While they may be eating a lot calorie-
wise, they may not be eating enough of the foods that they need, resulting in obesity along with
The type of malnutrition each person suffers from is based on which nutrient or mineral
their diet is missing. The diseases caused by malnourishment can be divided into two types –
(Muller, O., & Krawinkel, M. 2005) Marasmus and kwashiorkor are diseases caused by protein-
energy deficiencies in the diet. Anemia, goiter, pellagra, scurvy, rickets, and beriberi are diseases
caused by the lack of micronutrients being consumed. (Muller, O., Krawinkel, M. 2005)
Marasmus occurs when not enough protein and calories are consumed. The signs of
marasmus include being severely underweight, lethargic, dry skin, saggy skin around the
buttocks and thighs, and brittle hair. Having this disease puts the person at a higher risk for other
conditions such as infections, hypoglycemia, diarrhea, cognitive deficiencies (in children), and
stunted growth. (“Marasmus Treatment & Management” 2017) Blood and fecal tests can be
performed to determine if there is any additional infection or parasites. Usually, the clinical
observation is enough to diagnose the condition. (“Marasmus Treatment & Management” 2017)
Kwashiorkor is a severe protein deficiency. It differs from marasmus in that there may be
an adequate intake of calories but not enough protein. (“Kwashiorkor” 2017) Signs of
kwashiorkor include a skeletal appearance with areas of edema such as the ankles, belly, and
feet, dry hair, brittle hair, loss of hair, diarrhea, lethargy, rash, fatigue, irritability, increased
Anemia is a micronutrient deficiency of iron, folate, or vitamin B12. Signs and symptoms
of this disorder may be fatigue, weakness, pale or yellow skin, arrhythmias, headaches, dyspnea,
and dizziness. Iron, folate, and vitamin B12 is required by the body to make hemoglobin and
healthy red blood cells. When these nutrients are missing in the diet, the body may not be able to
make enough red blood cells which results in all the signs and symptoms associated with the
disease. (“Symptoms and Causes” n.d.) An effective method of prevention for both protein-
energy deficiencies and anemia include having a protein rich diet including beans, lentils,
A goiter is caused by an iodine deficiency. Iodine is used by the thyroid gland to make
thyroid hormones: thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). (“Goiter” n.d.) Therefore, with an
iodine deficiency the thyroid cannot make enough thyroid hormones resulting in hypothyroidism.
Thyroid hormones are responsible for regulating the body’s metabolism. The pituitary gland acts
as a feedback mechanism for the thyroid. When the levels of thyroid hormone are too low, the
pituitary releases thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) to stimulate the thyroid to convert more
iodine into thyroid hormones. TSH also stimulates the thyroid to grow. Once adequate levels of
the hormones are reached, the pituitary stops the release of TSH and the thyroid remains
resulting in the enlarged appearance of the thyroid gland in the neck. Signs and symptoms of a
goiter are a feeling of pressure in the throat, coughing, and hoarse voice. (thyroid.org) Iodine can
make niacin and serotonin. Niacin in turn is responsible for helping to convert food to glucose,
helps to synthesize sex hormones and stress hormones in the adrenal glands, helps improve
Hidden Hunger 5
circulation and suppress inflammation. (“Vitamin B3” n.d.) Signs and symptoms of pellagra are
indigestion, fatigue, vomiting, poor circulation, cracked, dry skin, dementia, and diarrhea.
(Vitamin B3 n.d.) Some sources of niacin in the diet are mushrooms, green peas, turkey, fish,
Scurvy is a severe vitamin C deficiency. It causes fatigue, anemia, gum disease, purpura,
skin ulcers, nose bleeds, decreased ability to fight off infection, and broken bones. (A Nightmare
Disease Haunted Ships During Age of Discovery 2017) Vitamin C is essential for the body’s
tissues to grow and repair themselves. It helps the body produce collagen which is a building
block of skin, cartilage, tendons, ligaments, and blood vessels. Without it, the impact on the body
is profound. (“Vitamin C” n.d.) Testing the plasma ascorbic acid level may be helpful in
establishing a scurvy diagnosis. (“Scurvy Workup” 2017) Vitamin C is exclusively from plant
sources - mainly citrus fruits, bell peppers, dark, leafy greens, kiwi, broccoli, tomatoes, and
papaya.
Rickets is a severe vitamin D deficiency which results in the softening and weakening of
bones. Other signs and symptoms of rickets may be muscle weakness, pain in the back or legs,
and stunted growth. Vitamin D is essential in helping the body absorb calcium and phosphorus.
The lack of vitamin D results in the body not being able to maintain healthy bone composition.
Bone x-rays can confirm if any bone deformities are present. (“Overview” n.d.) The body makes
vitamin D when exposed to sun but can also be found naturally in salmon, tuna, or enriched
foods such as milk, some cereals, yogurts, orange juice, and mushrooms that have been exposed
to UV light.
carbohydrates into energy for the brain and nervous system. It also functions to conduct nerve
Hidden Hunger 6
signals, help with muscle contraction, and in pyruvate metabolism. A person suffering from this
disease may have trouble in many motor functions such as walking, feeling numbness, tingling,
vomiting, nystagmus, speech difficulties, paralysis of the lower legs, increased heart rate and
swelling of the lower legs. The signs and symptoms depend on which form of beriberi the person
is afflicted with. The two types of beriberi are wet or dry. The wet beriberi affects the
cardiovascular system while the dry beriberi affects the nervous system. (“Beriberi” n.d.) Blood
and urine tests may be done to check for thiamine levels. Thiamine can be found in rice, oranges,
For several of these conditions, the examinations are similar. A physical exam may be
done to detect hepatomegaly which is indicative of the metabolic disorder. Arterial blood gas test
may be ordered to measure lung function, kidney function, and to detect the presence of any
metabolic disorders. A blood, urea, nitrogen (BUN) test helps to check kidney function. A
complete blood count helps to monitor and check for numerous conditions and complications
that may accompany or arise from kwashiorkor such as anemia, infections, kidney failure, etc.
Creatinine clearance test and creatinine blood test may help to check kidney function. A
potassium test may be ordered to check kidney function and metabolic efficiency. A total protein
test checks for normal levels of protein in the blood. Low levels are indicative or malnutrition. A
urinalysis can also check for hyperglycemia, kidney function, infections, etc.
Treatment depends on the severity of the condition but is similar for both protein-energy
deficiencies and anemia. It must be gradual to prevent complications. (Hearing, S.D., 2017,
p.908-909) In any case where starvation is present, the body begins to catabolize fat reserves for
energy instead of catabolizing carbohydrates as usual which signals the body to slow the
metabolism including the production of insulin. While the body is under stress, aldosterone, a
Hidden Hunger 7
hormone, is released which promotes the retention of sodium and water, while potassium and
phosphate are lost. Phosphate is essential in the production of ATP at the cellular level and for
smooth and skeletal muscle contraction (Duggan, C., Watkins, J. B., & Walker, W. A., 2009,
p.129)
If a person with severe malnutrition under these conditions is fed very rich and high
calorie foods all at once, the body faces complications in switching from fat metabolism to
carbohydrate metabolism. The rapid ingestion of food would promote insulin secretion and
cellular uptake of already low levels of phosphate for use in digestion. Hypokalemia can result in
respiratory failure, cardiac failure, arrhythmias, seizures, and sudden death. This fatal
phenomenon is known as refeeding syndrome. It was first described in the cases of severe
malnutrition seen in the war prisoners of World War II after they were fed large amounts of food
To avoid refeeding syndrome, restoring these electrolyte balances and rehydration are
often the first step of treatment through oral rehydration solutions (ORSs). If there is any
simultaneously. Electrolyte levels are monitored constantly for the first four days after refeeding
has commenced. Intravenous phosphate is administered and feedings are small and often, every
few hours until caloric needs are met. (Hearing, S.D., 2017, p.908-909)
Treatment for micronutrient deficiencies is not so rigorous and mostly involves just
reintroducing the missing vitamin or nutrient into the diet. Prevention of the micronutrient
deficiencies includes maintaining a healthy, balanced diet with generous fresh fruits, vegetables,
Of these conditions, anemia and micronutrient deficiencies are most common in the
United States because of food insecurity. (“Parentingliteracy.com” n.d.) Populations that are at
an elevated risk are those who live in food insecure areas. (“Definitions of Food Security” n.d.)
Other conditions such as cancer, burn victims, and people that have existing metabolic diseases
are at risk for developing some form of malnutrition. Cancer and burn victims are at risk because
as bodies repair themselves they require a higher than normal caloric and micronutrient intake.
The highest rate of food insecurity in the entire United States can be found in Apache
County, Arizona, where the population is predominantly Native American. Almost 42% of
Apache County is considered food insecure. (Scalise, 2016) This is a common trend among
Native American reservations nationwide. (Lee, 2016) Many of the residents in the reservation
suffer from obesity, diabetes, heart disease, and other nutritional deficiencies because of
consuming mainly processed, unhealthy food. (Apache County Public Health Services District
2015) These factors make Apache county a perfect location to perform a longitudinal study on
In order to demonstrate the significant impact a nutritious diet can have on health,
nutrient-dense meals were provided once a day, three times a week over the course of six months
for the 215 willing participants of the most food insecure population in the country. The
participants received a full physical examination with laboratory work to evaluate and record
their initial health. Changes in the participants’ overall health were then measured and evaluated
For this experiment, the independent variable was the adjusted diet (the provided meals).
The dependent variables were the nutritional imbalances that were monitored which were
Hidden Hunger 9
anemia, scurvy, pellagra, and obesity. Because this study is done on an at-will basis for a group
of people that are in need, it was determined by the Institutional Review Board to be unethical to
provide nutritious foods to one group while depriving another group of the same opportunity at
the cost of their health. For this reason, the control group was the collective set of data consisting
of the participants’ initial health exam results. The experimental group was made up of the
participants – 215 in total, ages 18-72. There was no inclusion criteria, participants were allowed
The materials that were used for the experiment were the 215 participants who were fed
nutritious meals, a kitchen to heat up the meals, a cafeteria, the meals provided, a laboratory to
perform physical examinations and to analyze the blood work of participants. Plant- based meals
were chosen because they are rich in all essential vitamins and nutrients. (Russell, T., 2017)
Three meal options were provided: sweet potato chili, vegetarian ajiaco, and vegetarian refried
bean tacos. For the sweet potato chili the ingredients needed are: cooking oil, red bell peppers,
green peppers, onions, sweet potatoes, garlic cloves, salt, pepper, chili powder, cumin, red
pepper flakes, dried basil, bay leaves, tomatoes, vegetable stock, black beans, and jalapeno. For
the vegetarian ajiaco, the ingredients are: potatoes, carrots, peas, navy beans, corn, vegetable
stock, salt, pepper, and cilantro. For the vegetarian refried bean tacos, the ingredients used were:
black beans, garbanzo beans, water, olive oil, cumin, ground coriander, paprika, chili powder,
salt, garlic, sweet peppers, corn tortillas, onion, spinach, vegan cheese, lime juice, and cilantro.
For the physical examinations and blood tests for the participants, the following was
needed: tape measure to evaluate waist circumference, scale to weigh participant, height chart to
measure stature, blood tests for anemia– complete blood count (CBC) to measure hemoglobin,
Hidden Hunger 10
hematocrit, and ferritin, tests for scurvy– physical examination for usual signs and symptoms and
blood test for serum ascorbic acid levels, tests for pellagra- physical examination for
characteristic signs and symptoms and blood tests to measure serum levels of niacin and
tryptophan.
One dinner was provided a day, three times per week over the period of six months in a
the meals was crucial. The participants were accounted for by showing photo ID at the entrance
to keep track of attendance. To mark the beginning of the study, physical examinations and
blood work was done on all participants for reference. At the end of the study, the same
examinations were performed on all subjects and the results were compared to the initial results.
The most notable difference that was the decrease in waist circumference by the end of
the study. The above chart shows how the average waist circumference decreased over time. The
average waist circumference at the beginning of the study was 43 inches. At the end of the six
months, the average waist circumference amongst the participants went down to 35 inches.
The blood test results also showed a great improvement across all values.
Hidden Hunger 11
The preceding table lists all the tests, in the first column, that were performed on the test
subjects along with their corresponding normal ranges for reference. The tests with their normal
ranges, in order from top to bottom are: RBC– 4.2-6.2 mill/mm3, Hemoglobin- 12-17.5 g/dL,
Hematocrit- 35%-50%, Ferritin- 18-270 mcg/L, Ascorbic Acid- 0.6-2 mg/dL, and Niacin- 0.5-
8.45 ug/mL. (Pathophysiology 2013 p.256-260; Mayo Clinic 2016) The second column shows
the initial average amongst the 215 participants for each test from the beginning of the study.
The numbers that are written in red are considered low when compared to the normal range. The
initial average results are as follows, RBC- 4.1 mill/mm3, Hemoglobin- 10 g/dL, hematocrit-
33%, ferritin- 20 mcg/L, ascorbic acid- 0.7 mg/dL, niacin- 2 ug/mL. The last column shows the
average of all the results of the final blood work for each test. The results written in green are
indicative of normal levels according to the normal ranges. The results for the blood tests taken
at the end of the study are: RBC- 6.0 mill/mm3, hemoglobin- 17 g/dL, hematocrit- 49%, ferritin-
At the beginning of the longitudinal study, the population was averaging on the low end
of the normal ranges for almost all values. At the end of the six-month study however, all the
Throughout the six month long experimental study, health and wellness tests were
performed every month on all 215 participants. At the beginning of the longitudinal study, the
population was averaging on the low end of the normal ranges for all values. At every juncture,
the average results showed improvement from the previous tests for: red blood cell count,
hemoglobin, hematocrit levels, ferritin, ascorbic acid, niacin, and vitamin A. At the end of the
six-month study, all values were well within the normal range. This research data could also aid
colleagues who are working towards finding successful treatments for different types of
malnourishment or even for research on how a nutrient-dense, plant-based diet can reduce the
risk of many serious diseases such as heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and high blood pressure.
This research is already being used by colleagues to benefit the environment. One of the
public health educators from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is using this research
public health, mostly in places where there is food insecurity, while simultaneously benefitting
the environment. By incorporating fruit and vegetable gardens into the community where they
can be shared by everyone, nutritious produce would be more accessible for members of the
community and the environment would be positively impacted. (American Community Garden
Association, n.d.).
Although food insecurity and malnutrition in France is only seen in 5% of the population,
less than half the percentage of the United States’ rate, France makes food security a priority.
(Knoema, 2016) In 2016, France passed a law that would require supermarkets larger than 4000
square feet to donate all food that was still usable but would usually be disposed of. (Frej, 2016)
Instead, supermarkets must donate or compost their unsold, nearly-expired products or pay a
Hidden Hunger 13
hefty fine that ranges from about $4,200-$84,000 or two years in jail. (Gore-Langton, 2017)
Those who comply are compensated with a tax incentive of 60% of the eligible food value.
(Mourad, 2015) Carrefour, a large chain retailer in France, alone donates the equivalent of about
63 million tons of food are wasted every year in the United States. (ReFED, n.d.) Yet,
12.7% of the country’s population- that is 42 million people - are suffering from food insecurity.
(Hunger Fight, n.d.) Enforcing laws like France’s food waste law would make a tremendous
difference in lowering the United States’ food insecurity rate. The bill would require any
supermarket over 4,000 square feet to sign contracts with local charities to donate unsold food.
Donations could benefit soup kitchens, homeless shelters, or other hunger-fighting charities that
Reducing food waste would not only benefit the public but the environment as well. Food
a greenhouse gas that is about 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide in terms of retaining
heat in the atmosphere. (Jones, 2016) It is estimated that food waste contributes 1.5% of all
greenhouse gas emissions in the United States which is equal to 135 million tons of gases.
(Barclay, 2011) Therefore, reducing the amount of food waste would also benefit the
Another proposed legislation that would help to reduce malnutrition in food deserts is to
farmers who run the CSA farm. A Community Supported Agriculture farm is a type of farm that
allows local people to become a “member” of the farm by contributing money (amount is
determined by the farmer) in exchange for a “share” of the harvest from the farm. (Just Food,
Hidden Hunger 14
n.d.) The money collected from members is used to cover the costs of maintaining the farm,
buying equipment, buying seeds, making repairs if necessary, etc. (Just Food, n.d.) CSA farms
benefit communities and help to prevent malnutrition by making fresh, locally-grown produce
available to members of the community who choose to participate. Some CSA farms may even
offer eggs, meat, and flowers as part of each member’s share. (Just Food, n.d.) CSAs make
having a wholesome diet easier because fresh, nutritious food choices are readily available.
Current legislation provides many incentives for commodity crop farming, which is
harmful for the public and for the environment. (Food and Water Watch, 2015) Commodity
crops are corn, soy, and wheat, which are widely used for highly-processed, harmful foods.
(Food and Water Watch, 2015) Fruits, vegetables, nuts, dried fruits, culinary herbs and spices,
and more that are used for food, medicine, and even for aesthetic purposes are considered
specialty crops. (USDA, n.d.) Providing greater subsidies for small farmers such as those who
run CSA farms would be steering the agricultural policies of the country in a direction that favors
the production of specialty crops rather than commodity crops, thereby increasing the availability
Currently, malnutrition costs the healthcare industry about $15 billion a year and
accounts for one-third of all patients admitted to hospitals. (Castellucci, 2016) The goal of these
legislative changes is ultimately to improve public health and decrease the rate of malnutrition in
the United States. With these changes, obtaining one nutritious meal once a day, three times a
week would be more realistically obtainable even for those located in food deserts such as the
participants who were part of the longitudinal study, improving public health, reducing
References
American Community Gardens Association. (n.d.). Growing Community Across the U.S. and
A Nightmare Disease Haunted Ships During Age of Discovery. (2017, April 14). Retrieved from
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/01/scurvy-disease-discovery-jonathan-lamb/
http://www.co.apache.az.us/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/CHIP.pdf
Barclay, E. (2011, October 07). How That Food You Throw Out Is Linked To Global Warming.
food-you-throw-out-is-linked-to-global-warming
Bryant, E. (2016, April 19). France battles food waste by law | DW Environment | DW |
19148931
Castellucci, M. (2016, September 23). Malnutrition causes $15.5 billion in healthcare spending
http://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20160923/NEWS/160929940
Copstead, L. E., & Banasik, J. L. (2013). Pathophysiology. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier.
Duggan, C., Watkins, J. B., & Walker, W. A. (2009). Nutrition in pediatrics basic science,
Environmental Protection Agency. (2016, July 26). America's Food Waste Problem. Retrieved
from https://www.epa.gov/sciencematters/americas-food-waste-problem
Hidden Hunger 16
Food and Water Watch. (2015, October 21). Farm Bill 101. Retrieved from
https://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/insight/farm-bill-101
Frej, W. (2016, February 05). It's Now Illegal For Supermarkets To Waste Food In France.
waste_us_56b4ba4de4b04f9b57d93f53
Gore-Langton, L. (2017, March 24). France's food waste ban: One year on. Retrieved from
http://www.foodnavigator.com/Policy/France-s-food-waste-ban-One-year-on
http://hungerfight.org/about-us/about-hunger-fight?
gclid=EAIaIQobChMIy6aClZf90wIVUFt-
Jones, E. (2016, July 15). EPA Issues Final Actions to Cut Methane Emissions from Municipal
final-actions-cut-methane-emissions-municipal-solid-waste-
landfillsCh0aoQ9eEAAYAiAAEgIiHvD_BwE
Knoema. (2016, June 19). Global Food Security Index, 2016. Retrieved from
https://knoema.com/GFSIEIU2015R1/global-food-security-index-2016?
country=1000350-france
Lee, T.H. (2016, July 12). 7 Foods That Cost More on the Rez, and One Junk Food That Costs
https://indiancountrymedianetwork.com/culture/health-wellness/7-foods-that-cost-more-
on-the-rez-and-one-junk-food-that-costs-less/
Mayo Clinic (2016, October 18). Complete Blood Count (CBC). Retrieved from
http://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/complete-blood-count/details/results/rsc-
20257186
https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/001604.htm
Medscape (2017, April 04). Marasmus Treatment & Management. Retrieved from
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/984496-treatment?src=refgatesrc1
Mourad, M. (2015, September) France Moves Toward A National Policy Against Food Waste.
report.pdf
Müller, O., & Krawinkel, M. (2005, August 02). Malnutrition and health in developing countries.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/179316.php
https://nutritionfacts.org/topics/plant-based-diets/
http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/rickets/home/ovc-20200467
Russell, T. (2017, April 24). Plant-Based Nutrition: Everything You Need To Know To Thrive
https://www.incrediblesmoothies.com/plant-based-diet/nutrition/
Hidden Hunger 18
Scalise, S. (2016, October 05). Apache County had worst 'food insecurity' in U.S.; state also bad |
https://cronkitenews.azpbs.org/2016/09/16/apache-county-had-worst-food-insecurity-in-
u-s-state-among-worst/
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/125350-workup
Silverbush, L., & Jacobson, K.(2012). A Place at the Table. Participant Media. Retrieved from
https://youtu.be/KRK1c8GnYfY
http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/anemia/symptoms-causes/dxc-20183157
https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/food-security-in-the-us/
definitions-of-food-security/
https://www.ams.usda.gov/services/grants/scbgp/specialty-crop
http://www.umm.edu/health/medical/altmed/supplement/vitamin-b3-niacin
http://www.umm.edu/health/medical/altmed/supplement/vitamin-c-ascorbic-acid