Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/316968651
CITATIONS READS
13 61,809
3 authors:
Purna Saha
KIIT University
73 PUBLICATIONS 671 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sajal Verma on 16 May 2017.
ABSTRACT: Earthquake is one of the most devastating natural calamities which causes sudden shaking of the earth surface.
It not only causes damage to buildings and other structures but also affects the surrounding environment and our lifestyle
significantly. An earthquake can trigger many sudden changes in the environment which can be classified as primary (e.g.
subsidence, surface faulting) and secondary effects (displaced rocks, tsunami, ground cracks, liquefactions, landslides). These
effects are known as earthquake environmental effects (EEE). The scales which use these effects of an earthquake as a
parameter for assessment are known as Earthquake Intensity Scales. These scales quantify an earthquake based on the
observed effects on the surroundings. All such scales come along with different guidelines and parameters. In this paper, a
review has been made on the different parameters of EEE like ground cracking, liquefaction, landslides etc. and use of three
different XII degree intensity scales (ESI 2007, EMS-98 and MM) for the assessment of an earthquake. A comparison of the
use of these scales in different earthquakes has also been made. The ESI 2007 focusses more extensively on ground damages
than EMS-98 and MM but it is only effective for sparsely populated areas. In case of areas having considerable human
population and manmade structures, use of EMS-98 and MM can be preferred over ESI 2007.
Keywords: Earthquake Environmental Effects (EEE), Environmental Seismic Intensity (ESI), International Union for
Quaternary Research (INQUA), European macroseismic scale (EMS), Modified Mercalli scale (MM) Primary and
Secondary Effects of earthquake, seismic hazard.
(2)
Where,
= effective cohesion
= effective friction angle
Fig. 1 Houses of residents at Hambantota, located about 100 = material unit weight
meters from the coast destroyed due to a Tsunami generated = unit weight of water
due to the 2004 Sumatra-Andaman earthquake [32]. m = represents the fractional depth of the water table with
respect to the total slide depth
For the purpose of obtaining data for height of Tsunami z = stands for the slope-normal thickness of the failure slab
waves and assess the damage caused by tsunami, field visits
= slope angle
can be conducted. A team of investigators can visit the
tsunami affected areas and collect data relating to the time of
occurrence, total area affected degree of damage, wave height 3 EARTHQUAKE INTENSITY SCALES
etc. [34]. The effects of tsunami can be diverse at different
places. During the 2011 Tohoku earthquake a devastating The intensity scales used for evaluation of an earthquake do
Tsunami had hit Miyagi Prefecture. Along the coast the not take into account the amount of energy released rather
drainage channels were more affected due to the structure they consider observed effects on the environment.
formed by the flow of water from land to the sea. It was also
observed that noncontinuous coast protection structures were
subjected to severe damage [35]. In areas where the coast is
surrounded by forest or vegetation, it can be observed that the
Mainak Choudhury / Sajal Verma & Purnachandra Saha
3.1 Environmental Seismic Intensity Scale 4 COMPARISON BETWEEN ESI 2007, EMS 98
The Environmental Seismic Intensity scale (ESI 2007) is a AND MM SCALES
twelve degree macroseismic intensity scale used for assessing
seismic events based on the effects of earthquake on the 4.1 1999 Athens Earthquake
natural environment or EEEs. INQUA EEE scale is an earlier EEEs like landslides, surface faulting, hydrological
version of ESI 2007. It is developed by International Union anomalies and other factors like human casualties, structural
for Quaternary Research (INQUA). Intensity of an damage were considered for intensity assessment. The
earthquake can be found out using this method after a post- earthquake was of magnitude 5.9 in surface wave magnitude
earthquake survey. scale (Ms). The cycle of seismic events in the area sustained
The area affected by EEEs and the magnitude of the for two months.
environmental effects affect the intensity degrees. However The intensity value assigned by INQUA scale were lower
this method is found to be more suitable for areas having low than that assessed by MM scale. The probable reason for this
human population or abandoned areas. The basic framework underestimation could be that very few ground damages
of ESI 2007 is similar to other XII degree scales like MCS, occurred during the earthquake, which are extensively
MSK etc. [9]. Ahmad et al. (2007) assessed 2007 Baramulla, considered in INQUA scale [49, 50, 51, 52].
Kashmir earthquake and assigned a variable intensity of VI to
X in ESI 2007 scale. EEEs like surface faulting, landslides, Table 1. Comparison of intensity values assigned by INQUA
liquefactions and ground cracks were considered in the scale and MM scale for the Athens Earthquake [49, 53].
assessment [42]. The estimates based on INQUA EEE scale Location Intensity ( in Intensity ( in
are found to be agreeable when compared with other XII
degree scales like Mercalli scale [43]. Tatevossian (2007) INQUA scale) MM scale)
assessed epicentral intensity using INQUA scale of 1887 Fili V VIII
Verny earthquake by studying the secondary EEEs, materials
were obtained from the earthquake site for this purpose. This
method was found to be effective in determining epicentral It can be observed that for Fili region higher intensity value
intensity [44]. has been given by MM scale.