Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ENGINEERING CHAPTER 10
ROCK UNDERGROUND
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
MECHANICS
DR MUHAMMAD IRFAN BIN SHAHRIN
UNDERGROUND EXCAVATION
IN ROCK
Underground excavation in rock include
cavern, tunnel, shaft & drift.
3
Underground cavern,
large excavation in rock
for powerhouse in HEP
project
Tunnel as underground
access & transportation,
The prevailing stresses (‘virgin’ & residual stresses) that are induced by geological processes.
They can be regional or localised & can affect the structures – Structural Geology
Excavation will disturb the rock, stresses in the rock & close to the excavation will change
(directions & values) creating new stresses, called ‘construction induced stresses’ – Rock
Mechanics
• Faults
• Folds
• Regional surface landforms & features of the site (e.g. presence of major
mountain range)
9
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Rock close to the fault may store
residual strain in the form of shear
stress. Fault is large fracture or
discontinuity in rock. Its presence
may form a boundary/limit for
transmission of stresses, creating
uneven stress distribution in a
relatively uniform & homogeneous
rock body.
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
13
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
sv = rgH sv
sv ¹ sh
sh1 = sh2
sh2 sh1
18
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
If the ground surface exhibits a massive mountain range at one side, sh
on either side of the tunnel is unlikely to be equal.
Ground surface
sv ¹ sh sv
sh1 > sh2, due to higher overburden
created by the mountain
sh2 sh1
19
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
If the ground surface exhibits massive mountain range at one side & there is
a major fault in between the tunnel & the mountain.
Ground surface
sh1 ¹ sh2 sv
In fact sh1 can be smaller than sh2
sh2 sh1
20
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Fault is a discontinuity (fracture) thus, high overburden stress created by
the mountain, cannot be transmitted through the major fault. It is often
observed that sh1 < sh2
Ground surface
sv
sh2 sh1
21
Circular tunnel in an ideal
rock is subjected to 3-D
stresses (x y z direction).
This can be simplified to
be 2-D, as sy along the
axis of the excavated
tunnel can be taken as
zero, as discussed in the
following topic
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
1-D linear elasticity can be generalised to 3-D as indicated by the direction 1, 2
& 3, and with the following assumptions (Jaeger & Cook,1979):
For principal stresses & strains proportionality of s & e can be expressed by:
23
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
l & G are Lame’s constants. Equation (1), (2) & (3) shows that one constant (i.e.
(l + 2G)) relates the stress & strain in the same direction, while relates the
stresses & strains in the other 2 perpendicular directions which must be on the
same footings.
24
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Besides l and G, other important constant in 1-D elasticity is
Young’s modulus, E. E = Ds/De, is a constant that relates stress
& strain under uniaxial compression (UCT).
For uniaxial stress, s2 = s3 = 0 & in this case equation (1) to (3) become:
s1 = (l + 2G)e1 + le2 + le3 (6)
0 = le1 + (l + 2G)e2 + le3 (7)
0 = le1 + le2 + (l + 2G)e3 (8)
It follows that:
e2 = e3 = - [l/[2(l + 2G)]e1 (9)
And,
E = s1/e1 = G(3l + 2G)/(l + G) (10)
25
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
In this case s1 is +ve (compression), e1 is +ve (contraction), and e2
& e3, are -ve (expansion).
3p = (3l + 2G)D
K = p/D = l + 2/3G (12)
26
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Relationships between K, G, E, l & n exist, the most important are:
27
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
There are certain restrictions on value of n by the above equations, e.g.
from (15), n < 1/2 & from (13) n > -1. This is known as two constants theory,
i.e. for complete specification of a material, two values of K, G, E, l & n
are needed.
28
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
In practice there are cases where linear elasticity is applicable and this
include the following cases:
CASE 1:
Uniaxial stress, s1 ¹ 0, s2 = s3 = 0:
The case where rock specimen is axially loaded in one direction & free of
loading in the other two directions (eqn. (6) to (10)). It is contraction
Since n < 1/2, there is a decrease in volume if s1>0 and increase if s1<0.
29
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
CASE 2:
Uniaxial strain: e1 ¹ 0, e2 = e3 = 0:
From (1) to (3) & using (15),
30
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
CASE 3:
The case where: e1 ¹ 0, e2 = 0, e3 = 0, this is not equal to e2 = e3 = 0
as in Case 2:
31
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
CASE 4:
It is termed biaxial stress or plane strain plane
strain stress, s1 ¹ 0 and s2 = s3 ¹ 0:
Ee1 = s1 - ns2; Ee2 = s2 - ns1; Ee3 = - n/(s1+s2) (21)
32
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
To calculate the stresses close to an excavation face, it is necessary
to know the in situ state of stress in an undisturbed rock. All methods
of stress measurement in underground (e.g. Talbot cell &
instrumented bolt) unfortunately, are methods conducted from
excavation faces (disturbed rock conditions) thus, accuracy of data is
questionable
s = rgz (22)
r is density of overlaying rocks, g is gravity & z is depth
33
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Field stresses - for any part of an excavation (stresses which would exist in
the neighborhood of this part of excavation before it was made).
The field stresses are determined from the virgin stresses and the
remainder of the excavation stresses.
34
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
35
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
It follows that:
sx = sy = [l/(l + 2G)]sz = [n /(1 –n )]sz = n /(1 –n ) rgz (25)
sx = sy = [n/(1 –n)]sz
36
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Rock type Elastic modulus, E Poisson’s ratio,
(GPa) n
Andesite, Basalt 60 0.20
Gabbro, Dolerite 90 0.20
Coal 3 0.42
Dolomite 70 0.15
Gneiss 60 0.24
Granite 60 0.22
Limestone 70 0.30
Quartzite 80 0.17
Sandstone 20 0.15
Shale 12 0.10
Typical values of Poisson’s ratio for various types of fresh rock [Stacey & Page, 1986]
37
Circular opening in solid,
homogeneous & isotropic rock
38
Circular opening in solid,
homogeneous & isotropic rock
A rock mass is in a state of ‘equilibrium’. Any excavation & construction
will disturb the existing state of equilibrium in the rock.
New sets of stresses will occur in this zone, which are different from the
field stresses. They must be controlled & monitored so to help the rock
mass reaching its 2nd state equilibrium sooner (e.g. by installing
stabilisation methods).
39
YIELD ZONE As soon as tunnel is excavated,
(ZON ALAH) surrounding rock mass will be
disturbed, forming a layer of
CIRCULAR disturbed rock - yield zone. This
TUNNEL the volume of rock need to
monitored & controlled during
construction.
SURROUNDING
ROCK MASS
40
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
41
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
Initial state of stresses (before excavation) that exists in rock at depth, is influenced by:
- Strength of rock material (e.g. intact small rock sample tested in lab) & rock mass
(e.g. in situ properties, intact + discontinuities + weathering).
42
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
In practice approximation of the initial earth stresses is essential in underground
construction:
The 3 states are insufficient to embrace all the possible state of initial stresses (e.g.
over-bridging beds & lateral transmission of stress which partly affect the vertical
stress (rgz)).
In other case, erosion releases part of vertical stress while lateral stress remains
unchanged, or presence of fault zone may result in significant difference between
lateral stresses.
43
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
44
Circular opening in solid,
homogeneous & isotropic rock
Panek (1942) refined the theory & stated that the zone of stress caused by
introduction of opening is confined to a small area around the opening.
The maximum tensile & compressive stresses occur at the boundary of the
opening, the roof & floor are in tension & the walls are in compression
45
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
The theory uses simple geometrical shapes in an ideal rock mass. The
result is then used for actual design with appropriate approximations
& assumptions to suit practical conditions.
Any significant deviation from the data used in the design (e.g. stress
& strain) may require changes in the design or other contingency
plans.
46
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
sv
Tunnel
A tunnel subjected
to field stress sv &
sh. In the yield
zone new stresses
occur, their values
sh
& directions is not
equal to sv & sh
Yield
zone
47
Circular tunnel
subjected to 3-D
stresses sz, sx, sy.
sx & sy are
horizontal stress
(sh) & sz is vertical
stress (sv). Ideal
rock therefore sx =
sy = sh.
48
For a circular tunnel in an ideal rock & geologically undisturbed, it will be being
subjected to in situ or field stress only (eqn (20)):
sh = 1/3sv
True only if there is no lateral strain (note that the tunnel wall is free to deform
after excavation).
Poisson’s ratio of rock creates a horizontal stress sh which is 3 times smaller than
vertical stress sv.
49
When tunnel is excavated, field stress will redistribute (change in value & direction) in
an attempt to achieve another state of equilibrium. This gives rise to a new set of
stresses in the yield zone, & termed as sq & sr :
sq : tangential stress acting around the tunnel & tangential to its surface.
sr : radial stress acting around the tunnel & towards its centre.
The value sq & sr within the yield zone varies, depending on their locations around &
within the yield zone as
50
Excavation of
circular tunnel
subjected to sv =
rgz only, will
induce new set
of stresses, sq &
sr in the yield
zone around the
tunnel
51
The following curves show distribution of sq & sr around a circular tunnel, when
subjected to sv only. However in actual case, the tunnel is subjected to both sv & sh
(hydrostatic state of stress). The effect of sh will be considered later
sq & sr are all expressed in terms of sv (as unit stress), the tunnel is being subjected
to vertical stress only.
sv is compression (+ve).
52
sv
Tunnel
Yield
zone
53
sq & sr around circular 5
tunnel, subjected to
VERTICAL STRESS sv 4
only. r/a s r
o
From point B and at
q
2
1
r/a into the wall. +1 0 -1
o
o v o v
q
a is radius of tunnel A
1
54
sv
Along Point A,
distribution of sq &
sr vertically 4
A
upwards into the
s
tunnel roof, and at r/a r
o q
2
1
+1 0 -1
o o q
v o v 55
A
3
2
o q
2
sv
1
Along Point
+1 B, 0 -1
o
distribution ofosv q
q
o v
& sr horizontallyA 1
into the tunnel o r
wall, and
r at
various depths a 0
1 2 4 B
B 3
(r/a ratio) into
the rock. r/a
56
5
r/a s r
Value of sq & sr
around circular 2
3
tunnel subjected to o q
sv only. 1
2
+1 0 -1
o o q
v o v
A
1
o r
r
a 0
B 1 2 3 4
r/a
57
At tunnel surface or at r/a = 1.0:
at Point A: sr = 0 & sq = - sv (-ve tensile)
at Point B: sr = 0 & sq = 3sv (+ve compression)
At depth r/a > 1, values of sr & sq change
accordingly as shown in the figure.
58
At point A : when r/a > 4, sr ® sv & sq ® 0 (sq does not exist
anymore & value of sr is approaching the value of field
stress sv).
Tunnel
Undisturbed rock
lies outside the
yield zone.
In this zone along
vertical axis sr ®
sv & sq ® 0.
Along horizontal
axis sr ® 0 & sq ®
sv
Yield
zone
60
When a circular opening is excavated in an ideal rock, and is
subjected to a stress in one axis only (sv (= rgz)), at r/a = 1 (exactly
at the roof & wall of the tunnel, point A & B) this will induce:
acting at point lies perpendicular to the first axis (i.e. point B).
…this is CASE I
sv
Case I: -sv
when sv ¹ 0 & sh = 0, only sv
is acting on the tunnel
3sv
62
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
63
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
3sh
Case II:
when sv = 0 and sh ¹ 0, only
sh is acting on the tunnel sh
-sh
64
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
sv
Tunnel
As the tunnel is
subjected to both sv
& sh, by Law of
Superposition of
Case I & II, gives the
sh following stresses at
Point A & B.
Yield
zone
65
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
-sv + 3[n/(1-n)]sv
3sv - [n/(1-n)]sv
Law of superposition –
case I impose onto case II, &
substituting sh = [n/(1-n)]sv
66
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
67
EXCAVATION IN ROCK
68
Stress distribution around
circular-shaped tunnel
69
Stress distribution around
oblong-shaped tunnel
70
Stress distribution around
square-shaped tunnel
71
Design & construction of structure in rock must take into
consideration the factors listed in (a) to (f), so that:
• Any induced stresses due to excavation (sr & sq) must not
exceed the strength of the in situ rock.
72
If conditions (a – f) are not critical, shape & size of
underground excavation (tunnel & cavern) play an important
role for the stability of rock mass around excavation:
73
Shape of excavation affects stress distribution &
stability of the excavation.
74
• For tunnels of equal cross-section, narrower tunnel (smaller
width) is most stable.
75
Effect of size of
underground openings
with respect to fractures
(e.g. joint) spacing
76
Very often, theoretical prediction (computer simulation) of
the thickness of the yield zone & value of stresses within the
disturbed zone cannot be determined reliably.
77
Application Simple methods Complex method
Surface movements Optical surveys of Electrical tiltmeter.
monuments, settlement Electrical strain meter.
plates. Vertical extensometer.
Water level device.
Simple strain meter.
Wire extensometer.
Subsurface Settlement points. Inclinometer.
deformations Borros points. Deflectometer.
Rock bolt & rod type MPBX Wire type MPBX
extensometer. Shear- extensometer.
strip indicator. Acoustical emissions.
In situ pressures & Tell tales (pile load tests). Pneumatic & electrical
stresses Open-system piezometers.
piezometers. Strain gauges.
Pressure cells.
Vibrating-wire stress meter.
Residual rock Strain meter on rock Borehole devices.
stresses surfaces. Flat jacks.
78
Typical
instrumentation
for monitoring
stress/strain &
movement around
underground
excavations
79
Rod extensometer
to measure
movement in a
pre-drilled
borehole in rock.
80
Over-coring (trepanning) to
Talbot cell with embedded
relieve stresses around
strain gauges, to monitor
borehole where a Talbot cell
stress in rock
has been installed
81
Installation of pressure cells
in concrete to monitor stress Using pressure cells to
monitor loading on rock bolt
& pile performance
82
It has been shown that sr & sq occur at 2 along
perpendicular locations (point A and B). The fact that
these induced stresses occur all around the tunnel, 0 to
3600.
Consider a circular tunnel in an ideal rock material & at
depth z m from the surface:
Assume that the principal stresses are sv & sh, and Pi
(lining pressure) = 0.
If the depth (z) & density (r) of the overlaying rock are
known, sv can be calculated.
If n is known, the horizontal stress can be obtained using
sx = sy = [n/(1-n)]sz
83
e
e
Borehole
(depth, h)
C
B
r = R +h
A O
R
Tunnel Axis
O C
B
84
• As shown due to the excavation of the circular tunnel & presence
of sv, sh & n, in the tunnel walls (i.e. the yield zone), new sets of
stresses will occur namely sr & sq.
• The ‘actual stress’ in the tunnel walls can only bemeasured using
instrumentation (e.g. Talbot’s cells, instrumented bolt), however this
is only possible during tunneling work, i.e. availability of access to
install the instrumentation.
85
For the stresses sr (radial), sq (tangential) & trq (shear) at depth in the
tunnel walls, the following equations are applicable with assumptions:
Tangential stress:
sq = 1/2 (sv + sh) (1 + R2/r2) – 1/2 (sv - sh) (1 + 3R4/r4) cos2q
Radial stress:
sr = 1/2 (sv + sh) (1-R2/r2) + 1/2 (sv - sh) (1- 4R2/r2 + 3R4/r4) cos2q
86
sv
Circular tunnel
q sH with borehole
And subjected to
Pi R principle stress
87
sq
sr
sr e
e
sq sq sr
sq
sq r
sq
sr q sq
(90o -q)
sq sr
a
Cross-section A-A
(tunnel) Cross-section B-B (tunnel)
sq = sv
88
THANK YOU
89