Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE PROBLEM: Welding their the areas being welded were not flat, open surfaces.
parts required that the operators’ And then it was pointed out that the ring guard did
fingers had to be close to the not protect the operator when electrodes were being
moving electrodes. Because of dressed or replaced. Therefore this idea was rejected.
the part design and large number
THE SOLUTION: With less than 20 days left before
of different models being welded,
shut-down, the company contacted UNITROL to find a
there was no way they could use
solution and keep their company operating. UNITROL
drop-in fixtures and anti-tiedown
took up the challenge and developed SOFT TOUCH,
hand buttons.
a fully passive system that would not interfere with their
FIRST IDEA: The first attempt at finding a solution was production process.
to use a light curtain to protect the area between the
The SOFT TOUCH system closed the electrodes under
electrodes. However this idea was quickly abandoned
low force and only increased to full welding force after
when they realized that the operator had to hold and
contacting the metal part being welded. The sensing
position parts near the electrode and would be working
system was fully electronic, could not be bypassed, and
in the light curtain sensing zone. Also fine tuning of the
did not depend on an adjustable mechanical probe.
light curtain safety zone would be required when new
parts were welded. SOFT TOUCH therefore satisfied the passive test
required by OSHA.
SECOND IDEA: They then found a ring guard system
that mounted on the spot welder. With this type of As a plus, a TIP DRESS switch
guard, the moving electrode goes through the center was included in the system to
of a wire loop. The loop is connected to a rod that trips bring the electrodes together
a limit switch when it moves under low force during electrode
downward a certain distance. At dressing, replacement, or
the start of each weld, the loop is alignment procedures. This solved
sent downward before movement the problem of operator protection
of the upper electrode. If the ring during electrode maintenance.
is stopped by a finger or other
object before reaching the top THE RESULT: The company installed SOFT TOUCH
of the part being welded, the on one welder and it cleared the OSHA compliance
limit switch does not trip and the officer’s inspection. They installed SOFT TOUCH on
Ring
Guard electrode won’t close. the remaining 22 welders to bring their company back
to operating on a 3-shift schedule.
On presentation to the OSHA compliance officer,
he pointed out that the “safety” of this ring guard Since that time, thousands of SOFT TOUCH
system could easily be bypassed by just loosening systems have been installed around the world
the adjustment screw and raising the loop upward. It with a 100% safety record. In the United States,
was therefore not passive. Mechanically there was all installations presented to OSHA compliance
no way to have the ring clear most of their parts since officers have been accepted.
OSHA RESEARCH FOR SOFT TOUCH CONCEPT
UNITROL contacted an OSHA 1910.255(b)(4) 1910.217(c)(3)(iii)(b)
representative and discussed the (resistance welding machines) The device may not be used as a tripping
requirements for pinch point guarding
Guarding. All press welding machine means to initiate slide motion.
of resistance welders. The operation
operations, where there is a possibility of
of the SOFT TOUCH system was also
discussed. The OSHA representative UNITROL note: This SOFT TOUCH circuitry
of operation, shall be effectively guarded by does not initiate any valves. It is only an
recommended the following
the use of a device such as an electronic input into the weld control to indicate part
regulations to cover requirements
eye safety circuit, two hand controls or
for this device:
protection similar to that prescribed for
punch press operation, 1910.217. 1910.217(c)(3)(iii)(c)
1910.212(a)
(general machinery) The device shall be constructed so that a
UNITROL note: The following sections
Machine guarding failure within the system does not prevent
are all that were recommended for this
the normal stopping action from being
1910.212(a)(1) application:
applied to the press when required, but does
Types of guarding. One or more methods prevent the initiation of a successive stroke
1910.217(c)(3)(iii)
of machine guarding shall be provided to until the failure is corrected. The failure shall
protect the operator and other employees A presence sensing point of operation be indicated by the system.
in the machine area from hazards such device shall protect the operator as provided
as those created by point of operation, in paragraph (c)(3)(i)(a) of this section, and UNITROL note: At the start of each stroke,
shall be interlocked into the control circuit to we check to see if the sensing system is
chips and sparks. Examples of guarding prevent or stop slide motion if the operator’s closed. If it is, the sensor stroke is never
methods are barrier guards, two-hand hand or other part of his body is within started, and the control’s display shows the
tripping devices, electronic safety fault. The sensor must be opened before
devices, etc. downstroke of the press slide. any other action is possible on the welder.
UNITROL note: The SOFT TOUCH sensor UNITROL note: The electrode on the
board is an “electronic safety device” in that low-force ram becomes the “sensor” in this
it closes an electro-mechanical relay when it system. The “downstroke” of the welder,
electronically senses that the electrodes are with the SOFT TOUCH system installed,
closed on the metal part in the work area starts when high pressure is applied to
prior to application of high force. the welder ram.
Distributed by:
UNITROL
PRODUCTION ENGINEERING
1344 Woodman Drive
Dayton, Ohio 45432
888-654-WELD (9353)
sales@productionengineering.com
www.resistanceweldsupplies.com