You are on page 1of 8

Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488

DOI 10.1007/s00256-010-0907-3

TECHNICAL REPORT

MR arthrographic assessment of suspected posteroinferior


labral lesions using flexion, adduction, and internal rotation
positioning of the arm: preliminary experience
Mary M. Chiavaras & Srinivasan Harish & Janet Burr

Received: 5 December 2009 / Revised: 31 January 2010 / Accepted: 4 February 2010 / Published online: 26 February 2010
# ISS 2010

Abstract Keywords MRI . Shoulder . Posterior labrum .


Objective Imaging the shoulder in the position of flexion, Arthrography . Instability
adduction, and internal rotation (FADIR) may be useful in
characterizing lesions of the posteroinferior labrum. The
purpose of this preliminary study is to illustrate the Introduction
diagnostic utility of FADIR positioning in the assessment
and characterization of posteroinferior labral tears. Posteroinferior labral tears can result in significant morbidity,
Materials and Methods In the FADIR position, the arm is particularly in athletes engaging in overhead or contact sports,
placed across the chest, with the hand on the contralateral but may go clinically unrecognized because of their relative
shoulder and palm facing outwards. FADIR positioning infrequency. Compared with anteroinferior labral pathology,
was performed if there was a subtle or equivocal the posterior counterparts are much less common with
abnormality of the posteroinferior labrum on conventional posterior shoulder instability (PSI) comprising only 5% of
MR arthrography sequences. A retrospective review of the all cases of instability [1, 2]. PSI often presents with non-
charts of 9 people who were imaged using FADIR specific symptoms of poorly localized shoulder pain or
positioning in addition to routine MR arthrographic fatigue with activity rather than actual symptoms of
sequences of the shoulder was performed. The review instability [1]. The majority of cases of PSI are initially
included the indication for the study, documentation of treated with physiotherapy and rehabilitation and, only with
presence of clinical posterior instability, and surgical failure to respond to conservative therapy, is surgical
correlation, where available. intervention considered [2–6]. Surgical management has a
Results In all 9 patients, FADIR positioning helped better outcome if a lesion is identified at the level of the
confirm, exclude, or better characterize a posteroinferior posteroinferior labrum [7, 8]. Hence, optimal radiological
labral abnormality by increasing the diagnostic confidence. assessment is helpful to diagnose these lesions for adequate
Conclusion Flexion, adduction, and internal rotation posi- pre-surgical planning.
tioning appears to be a useful adjunct in evaluating patients Magnetic resonance arthrography is the imaging modality
with equivocal or subtle posteroinferior labral abnormalities of choice in assessing abnormalities of the glenoid labrum
on conventional MR arthrography sequences. [9–14]. Anteroinferior labral lesions that are occult on
conventional MR arthrographic sequences are often better
visualized when positioning the arm in abduction and
M. M. Chiavaras : S. Harish
external rotation (ABER), the position of provocation for
Department of Radiology, McMaster University, anterior instability [15]. MR arthrography in the adducted,
Hamilton, ON, Canada internally rotated position has been noted to be highly
accurate in diagnosing anterior labral periosteal sleeve
S. Harish (*) : J. Burr
avulsion (ALPSA) lesions of the anteroinferior labrum
Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph’s Healthcare,
Hamilton, ON L8N 2A6, Canada [16]. We hypothesized that, in cases of suspected poster-
e-mail: sriniharish@gmail.com oinferior labral tears, imaging the shoulder in the provocative
482 Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488

18]. In this preliminary report, we present our experience


with 9 cases and illustrate the potential impact of FADIR
positioning in patients with posterior instability and poster-
oinferior labral tears in which the conventional MR
sequences are equivocal.

Materials and methods

Research Ethics Board approval was obtained for this study.


Over an 18-month period, we identified 9 patients out of 420
MR arthrogram examinations of the shoulder that had
imaging using FADIR positioning. We analyzed the clinical
charts and MR arthrograms of these 9 patients. The review
included the indication for the study as well as the
documentation of presence of clinical PSI and surgical
correlation, where available. In the FADIR position, the arm
is placed across the chest, with the hand on the contralateral
shoulder and palm facing outwards (Fig. 1). This provocative
position places traction on the posteroinferior labrum,
causing displacement, and increasing the conspicuity of a
labral tear, if present (Fig. 2). FADIR positioning was
performed if there was a subtle or equivocal abnormality of
the posteroinferior labrum on conventional MR arthrography
Fig. 1 Flexion, adduction, and internal rotation (FADIR) position a sequences.
without and b with coil placement. In this position, the shoulder is
forward flexed/adducted and the elbow flexed with hand on the
contralateral shoulder and the palm facing outward to achieve internal MR technique
rotation
All patients underwent intra-articular injection, using an
position of flexion, adduction, and internal rotation (FADIR) anterior approach, of 10 cc of a 0.1% gadolinium solution
may be useful in uncovering and characterizing lesions. followed by conventional imaging on either a GE Signa HDx
There are a couple of reports in the literature that 1.5 T MRI (n=7) or a Philips Achieva 3 T TX MRI (n=2).
mention imaging the shoulder in the FADIR position [17, On the GE scanner, the US Shoulder PA coil was used for

Fig. 2 Schematic diagram of


the arm in both a the neutral
and b the FADIR positions. a
The neutral position demon-
strates an equivocal tear of the
posteroinferior labrum (dashed
black arrow). b The chondrola-
bral separation is clearly evident
when the arm is placed in
flexion, adduction, and internal
rotation (black arrow). White
asterisk=bicipital groove
Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488 483

Fig. 3 Localizer sequences in the FADIR position showing the planning of the axial sequence, which was carried out on the coronal localizer

Table 1 Summary of 9 patients

Patient Age/sex Clinical/surgical correlation Conventional sequences FADIR positioning Impact of FADIR

1 23/male “Anterior instability” on the No anteroinferior labral tear. More clearly demonstrates Increases diagnostic certainty
MR request. PSI and a Subtle posteroinferior unsuspected posteroinferior
posteroinferior labral tear labral tear labral tear
proven arthroscopically
2 37/male PSI Hyperintense fluid (not as Demonstrates unequivocal Increases diagnostic certainty
bright as gadolinium) gadolinium signal and labral
tracking between detachment confirming
posteroinferior glenoid unstable labral tear
and labrum
3 24/male PSI professional elite Subtle undercutting of Reveals chondrolabral Increases diagnostic certainty
football player gadolinium at posterior separation to better
chondrolabral junction advantage
4 23/male PSI Posterior cystic intralabral Fails to reveal chondro-labral Further characterizes
focus, raises possibility of a separation confirming posteroinferior labral
Kim’s lesion diagnosis of Kim’s lesion abnormality
5 47/male Suspected SLAP Small cystic lesion within Demonstrates both the Detects clinically
No PSI posteroinferior labrum, but chondrolabral detachment unsuspected posteroinferior
Posterior shoulder pain with no definite chondrolabral and paralabral cyst filling labral tear equivocal on
throwing separation with gadolinium routine sequences
6 49/male Suspected SLAP SLAP lesion, but also Reveals chondrolabral Detects clinically
No PSI questionable posteroinferior separation confirming unsuspected posteroinferior
Shoulder pain post-MVA labral tear posteroinferior labral tear labral tear equivocal on
routine sequences
7 40/male Suspected SLAP Questionable irregularity Demonstrates high signal Fails to reveal posteroinferior
No PSI Posteroinferior labrum (not as bright as labral tear suspected on
Shoulder pain post-MVA Suspected tear, with small gadolinium) in keeping with routine sequences
paralabral cyst granulation tissue/healed
tear
8 20/male Previous anterior dislocation Bankart lesion, but also No evidence of displacement Fails to reveal clear
No PSI irregular posteroinferior or contrast extension posteroinferior labral tear
Conservative treatment labrum with suspected tear
9 36/male PSI, but no labral tear on Subtle high signal at No evidence of displacement Further characterizes
arthroscopy 8’o clock position or contrast extension apparent posteroinferior
labral abnormality

FADIR: flexion, adduction, and internal rotation; PSI: posterior shoulder instability; MVA: motor vehicle accident; SLAP: superior labral anterior
posterior
484 Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488

Fig. 4 Posteroinferior labral tear. A 23-year-old man, whose history at arrow) raising the possibility of a tear. b FADIR axial T1-weighted
the time of the arthrogram was anterior instability. a Double oblique fat-saturated sequence reveals a convincing posteroinferior labral tear
axial T1-weighted fat-saturated image demonstrates a subtle, thin (white arrow) and a loose fragment (black arrow). This was
streak of contrast at the posteroinferior chondrolabral junction (white arthroscopically proven

all routine sequences and the cardiac coil for FADIR one of our initial cases, an axial PD fat-saturated FADIR
sequences. On the Philips scanner, the Philips Sense sequence was performed instead of a T1-weighted fat-
Shoulder 4 coil was used for both the routine and FADIR saturated sequence. The acquisition time for the FADIR
sequences. Standard MR sequences were all performed sequence including the localizer sequence was approxi-
with fat saturation and included sagittal T1-, axial proton mately 9 min. The acquisition time to perform the entire
density-, double oblique axial T1- and coronal T1-, and study including the conventional sequences and the FADIR
coronal T2-weighted sequences. The following MR param- was between 35 and 40 min. For the FADIR sequence, no
eters were used: FOV 14 cm (all sequences), matrix 256× saturation bands were used. Sponges were used to maintain
256–512×512, slice thickness 3.0 mm, and gap of 0.3 mm. rotation, provide support, and the arm was secured by
In our department, the MR arthrogram images are strapping to ensure immobility and patient comfort. No
routinely checked for adequacy, completion, and need for significant respiratory or motion-related artifact was seen in
extra sequences by a musculoskeletal radiologist and/or any of the cases. Graphic saturation bands were applied to
fellow. If, at that time, the radiologist notes equivocal or reduce breathing artifacts for the conventional sequences.
subtle abnormalities of the posteroinferior labrum, the
patients are repositioned with their arm in the FADIR Evaluation
position (Fig. 2). In 8 patients, T1-weighted fat-saturated
sequences in the FADIR position were obtained in the axial The 9 cases were reviewed by a musculoskeletal radiologist
plane planned primarily on the coronal localizer (Fig. 3). In and a musculoskeletal imaging fellow in consensus.

Fig. 5 Posterior glenoid labral articular disruption. A 49-year-old man double oblique axial T1-weighted fat-saturated image. b FADIR axial
with shoulder pain after a motor vehicle accident and clinically T1–weighted fat-saturated sequence shows an unequivocal labral
suspected superior labral anterior posterior (SLAP) tear. a The patient detachment (white arrow) with posterior displacement of the labral
had a SLAP tear (not shown) with an additional thin streak of high fragment and accompanying chondral flap
signal at the posteroinferior chondrolabral junction (white arrow) on a
Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488 485

Fig. 6 Posteroinferior labral


tear. A 37-year-old man with
clinical posterior shoulder insta-
bility (PSI). a Double oblique
axial T1-weighted fat-saturated
image demonstrates mild hyper-
intense signal tracking between
the glenoid and the posteroinfe-
rior labrum (white arrow), but
not as bright as gadolinium. b
The chondrolabral detachment is
more definitively demonstrated
on the FADIR axial T1-
weighted fat-saturated sequence
(white arrow)

Evaluation was subjective and included comparison of the convincing chondrolabral detachment. In 1 patient with
conventional sequences and FADIR sequence on a PACS posterior shoulder pain, but with no clinical suspicion of
workstation. The evaluation was primarily to determine if PSI documented, the FADIR sequence increased diagnostic
the FADIR sequence added value to the conventional certainty by revealing chondrolabral separation to better
images. Surgical correlation was made, where available. advantage than the conventional images (Fig. 10).

Results Discussion

A summary of the results is provided in Table 1. In 2 cases, Posterior shoulder instability is a potentially debilitating
FADIR positioning increased conspicuity of posteroinferior condition, which is generally seen in young adults in three
labral tears, which were clinically unsuspected (Figs. 4 and 5); clinical settings: following posterior dislocation, after direct
one of these was arthroscopically proven. In 2 patients with impact to the shoulder without frank dislocation, and, most
posterior instability, the FADIR sequence increased diagnostic commonly, as the sequela of repetitive microtrauma associated
certainty by revealing chondrolabral separation to better with various sports [1, 2, 11, 12]. These include American
advantage (Figs. 6 and 7). In 2 patients with posterior football, which employs defensive blocking techniques with
instability, the FADIR sequence increased diagnostic certainty arms in flexed and adducted positions, weightlifting with
in characterizing the posteroinferior labral abnormality (Figs. 8 strenuous axial and posterior loading, and overhead sports,
and 9); one of these was arthroscopically proven. In 2 cases such as swimming and baseball [1, 2, 12, 19].
without documented posterior instability, where a poster- The clinical presentation of posterior instability is
oinferior labral abnormality was suspected on the conven- variable with some patients describing a sense of joint
tional sequences, the FADIR sequence failed to reveal a instability or looseness while the majority report poorly

Fig. 7 Posteroinferior labral tear. A 24-year-old male professional 8 o’clock position (black arrow), although here there is some high
elite football player with clinical PSI. a Double axial oblique T1- signal medial to the labrum (black arrowhead). b FADIR axial T1–
weighted fat-saturated image demonstrates no convincing gadolinium weighted fat-saturated sequence more clearly demonstrates the
at interface between labrum and posteroinferior glenoid at the chondrolabral separation (white arrows)
486 Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488

Fig. 8 Concealed posteroinferior labral tear and noncommunicating with the deep aspect of the labrum (white arrow). b FADIR axial T1–
sub-labral cyst consistent with Kim’s lesion. A 23-year-old man with weighted fat-saturated sequence fails to reveal a chondrolabral
clinical PSI. a Axial proton density (PD)-weighted fat-saturated MR separation (white arrow)
arthrographic image demonstrates a cystic lesion in intimate contact

localized posterior shoulder pain [1, 2]. In both instances, on the posteroinferior chondrolabral junction, better delin-
the symptoms are exacerbated with the arm in the flexed, eating chondrolabral separation. In addition, lack of
adducted, and internally rotated position [1, 2, 7]. displacement may serve to confirm the absence of a definite
Posterior instability is associated with multiple structural posteroinferior labral tear or the presence of an incomplete
abnormalities of the glenohumeral joint, including osseous, or concealed tear of the posteroinferior labrum. Finally, it
muscular, and labroligamentous pathologies [17, 20, 21]. may assist in distinguishing a displaceable tear from a
Although less common than anteroinferior labral pathology, healed tear filled with granulation tissue. Recently, a
tears of the posteroinferior labrum are not an infrequent posterior labral cleft has been described as a normal variant
cause of posterior shoulder pain and instability and are in the posteroinferior labrum at the 8’o clock position,
often seen following traumatic posterior dislocation [22]. which was proven to be a normal finding at arthroscopy
Many variants have been described such as the reverse [26]. FADIR positioning may potentially help in differen-
Bankart, the posterior labrocapsular periosteal sleeve tiation of a true tear from this cleft. Another feature we
avulsion (POLPSA), Kim’s lesion, and posterior glenola- noted whilst reviewing the images was that the contrast
bral articular disruption (GLAD) [17, 18, 23–25]. Famil- medium appeared to move preferentially into the anterior
iarity with these lesions and optimal imaging techniques are recess on the FADIR images compared with the standard
necessary for their identification and to guide timely, axial images. Therefore, the technique might be potentially
lesion-specific intervention. useful to assess the undersurface of the subscapularis
In this preliminary study, we have demonstrated the tendon and the contents of the biceps tendon sheath
utility of the FADIR position in addition to conventional including loose bodies and synovial fold thickening/
MR sequences in evaluating patients with equivocal or septations. Song et al. [16] described an adducted,
subtle posteroinferior labral abnormalities on standard MR internally rotated sequence for demonstrating ALPSA
arthrography. In this provocative position, the posterior lesions. However, the shoulder was extended in the patients
band of the inferior glenohumeral ligament creates tension in that study [16].

Fig. 9 No posteroinferior labral


tear on arthroscopy. A 36-year-
old man with posterior instabil-
ity. a Axial T1-weighted
fat-saturated image demonstrates
a small amount of subtle in-
creased signal (white arrow) at
the posteroinferior labrum. b
FADIR axial T1-weighted fat-
saturated image reveals no
change with the absence of a
clear chondrolabral detachment
(white arrowhead). Patient had
posterior capsular laxity, which
was corrected arthroscopically
Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488 487

Fig. 10 Posteroinferior labral tear and communicating paralabral cyst. no definite chondrolabral separation or paralabral cyst filling with
A 47-year-old-man with posterior shoulder pain. a Axial PD-weighted gadolinium (white arrow). c FADIR axial T1–weighted fat-saturated
fat-saturated MR arthrographic image demonstrates a small cystic sequence, however, clearly demonstrates both the chondrolabral
lesion at the deep aspect of the posteroinferior labrum (white arrow). b detachment and communication with the paralabral cyst (white
Double oblique axial T1-weighted fat-saturated image demonstrates arrows)

There are limitations to this study. There were only 9 Acknowledgements We extend thanks to all MR technologists at
cases; hence, this is a preliminary study. Surgical correla- St. Joseph’s Healthcare for their help with this study. We would also like
to thank Glen Oomen for preparation of the illustrations, Dr. Nick Plaskos
tion was present in only 2 patients. Many patients with
for his help.
posterior instability are treated conservatively, presenting an
impediment to more comprehensive surgical correlation.
Other limitations include the lack of objective selection
criteria, given that the decision to perform FADIR was References
based on finding the abnormality at the time of the scan.
The lack of FADIR sequences in patients without any clinical 1. Bradley JP, Forsythe B, Mascarenhas R. Arthroscopic manage-
ment of posterior shoulder instability: diagnosis, indications, and
posterior instability or posteroinferior labral abnormality on
technique. Clin Sports Med. 2008;27:649–70.
conventional sequences leaves a lack of a standard for this 2. Robinson CM, Aderinto J. Recurrent posterior shoulder instabil-
sequence with which to make comparisons. However, we ity. J Bone Jt Surg Am. 2005;87:883–92.
only perform FADIR if there is any suspicion of an 3. Millett PJ, Clavert P, Hatch III GFR, Warner JJP. Recurrent
posterior shoulder instability. J Am Acad Orthop Surg.
abnormality on the conventional sequences and to do so
2006;8:464–76.
with a completely normal posteroinferior labrum on the 4. Tibone JE, Bradley JP. The treatment of posterior subluxation in
conventional sequences might be unethical. Finally, as with athletes. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993;(291):124–37.
ABER, patients may have difficulty performing FADIR as 5. Lamar DS, Williams GR, Iannotti JP, Ramsey ML. Posterior
instability of the glenohumeral joint: diagnosis and management.
this is the provocative position for their symptoms.
Univ Pa Orthop J. 2001;14:5–14.
In conclusion, we have shown that FADIR positioning is 6. Antoniou J, Harryman II DT. Posterior instability. Orthop Clin
a useful adjunct in the evaluation of suspected poster- North Am. 2001;32:463–73.
oinferior labral pathology. A prospective study with a larger 7. Vidal LB, Bradley JP. Management of posterior shoulder
instability in the athlete. Curr Opin Orthop. 2006;17:164–71.
number of patients and utilizing well-defined selection
8. Papendick LW, Savoie III FH. Anatomy-specific repair techniques
criteria and surgical correlation is necessary to fully for posterior shoulder instability. J South Orthop Assoc.
evaluate the utility of this technique. 1995;4:169–76.
488 Skeletal Radiol (2010) 39:481–488

9. Jbara M, Chen Q, Marten P, Morcos M, Beltran J. Shoulder MR 18. Resnick D, Kang HS, Pretterklieber ML. Shoulder. In: Resnick D,
arthrography: how, why, when. Radiol Clin North Am. Kang HS, Pretterklieber ML, editors. Internal derangement of
2005;43:683–92. joints, vol 1. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2007. p. 713–1122.
10. Hottya GA, Tirman PFJ, Bost FW, et al. Tear of the posterior 19. Kaplan LD, Flanigan DC, Norwig, et al. Prevalence and variance
stabilizers after posterior dislocation: MR imaging and MR of shoulder injuries in elite collegiate football players. Am J
arthrographic findings with arthroscopic correlation. AJR Am J Sports Med. 2005;33:1142–6.
Roentgenol. 1998;171:763–8. 20. Shah N, Tung GA. Imaging signs of posterior glenohumeral
11. Beltran J, Rosenberg ZS, Chandnani VP, et al. Glenohumeral instability. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2009;192:730–5.
instability: evaluation with MR arthrography. Radiographics. 21. Tung GA, Hou DD. MR arthrography of the posterior labrocap-
1997;17:657–73. sular complex: relationship with glenohumeral joint alignment and
12. Beltran J, Kim DH-M. MR imaging of shoulder instability injuries clinicalposteriorinstability.AJRAmJRoentgenol.2003;180:369–75.
in the athlete. Mag Reson Imaging Clin N Am. 2003;11:221–38. 22. Saupe N, White LM, Bleakney R, et al. Acute traumatic posterior
13. Tirman PF, Palmer WE, Feller JF. MR arthrography of the shoulder dislocation: MR findings. Radiology. 2008;248:185–93.
shoulder. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am. 1997;5:811–39. 23. Simons P, Joekes E, Nelissen RG, Bloem JL. Posterior labrocap-
14. Chandnani VP, Yeager TD, DeBerardino T, et al. Glenoid labral sular periosteal sleeve avulsion complicating locked posterior
tears: prospective evaluation with MRI imaging, MR arthography, shoulder dislocation. Skeletal Radiol. 1998;27:588–90.
and CT arthrography. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1993;161:1229–35. 24. Yu JS, Ashman CJ, Jones G. The POLPSA lesion: MR imaging
15. Cvitanic O, Tirman PF, Feller JF, et al. Using abduction and findings with arthroscopic correlation in patients with posterior
external rotation of the shoulder to increase the sensitivity of MR instability. Skeletal Radiol. 2002;31:396–9.
arthrography in revealing tears of the anterior glenoid labrum. 25. Kim SH, Ha KI, Yoo JC, Noh KC. Kim’s lesion: an incomplete
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1997;167:837–44. and concealed avulsion of the posteroinferior labrum in posterior
16. Song HT, Huh YM, Kim S, et al. Anterior-inferior labral lesions or multidirectional posteroinferior instability of the shoulder.
of recurrent shoulder dislocation evaluated by MR arthrography in Arthroscopy. 2004;20:712–20.
an adduction internal rotation (ADIR) position. J Magn Reson 26. Lee GY, Choi JA, Oh JH, Choi JY, Hong SH, Kang HS.
Imaging. 2006;23:29–35. Posteroinferior labral cleft at direct CT arthrography of the
17. Harish S, Nagar A, Moro J, et al. Imaging findings in posterior shoulder by using multidetector CT: is this a normal variant?
instability of the shoulder. Skeletal Radiol. 2008;37:693–707. Radiology. 2009;253(3):765–70.

You might also like