Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Fiber laser fusion welding of two applicable alloys including 308 stainless steel and low carbon steel (St 37) was
Fiber laser performed to assess the formation mechanism of the weld bead and temperature field near the fusion zone. In this
Molten pool research, some parameters including welding speed, laser power, nozzle distance, and beam deviation of the
Fusion zone
laser beam were determined as the main parameters. The results showed that the effect of the nozzle distance on
Temperature field
Weld bead
the temperature field was higher than that of the welding speed and laser power. It was also observed that
increasing the nozzle distance caused more absorption of the beam in the parts and there was an almost two-fold
increase in the dimensions and volume of the weld bead. The measured temperature near melt pool was
decreased about 120 ◦ C for st37 while a reduction about 30 ◦ C for stainless steel according to increasing nozzle
distance from 3 to 7 mm. Unlike carbon steel, the temperature of the stainless steel was clearly decreased at the
nozzle distance to the highest point. By increasing the welding speed, the temperature around the molten area
was decreased. The beam deflection parameter showed the effect of the temperature gradient index on changes
and a temperature decrease was observed by creating a distance from the location of thermocouples. Increasing
laser power from 300 to 400 W created wider weld bead about 40% and higher temperature about 40 ◦ C for
stainless steel in comparison to st37.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: hwszzu@126.com (G. Wang).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infrared.2021.103774
Received 21 March 2021; Received in revised form 1 May 2021; Accepted 4 May 2021
Available online 7 May 2021
1350-4495/© 2021 Published by Elsevier B.V.
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
sheets using heat treatment and optimal parameters. Their results 2. Experimental procedure
showed that some optimal parameters such as the effect of shielding gas
could greatly affect the geometry of the molten area and the weld In this experiment, a fiber laser with a maximum power equal to 500
appearance. Kumar and Sinha [13] also performed butt laser welding of W was used to join two dissimilar metals. The dimensions of the work
St 37 carbon steel at a specified speed. The welding results and the pieces used were 50 × 20 × 1.5 mm. As shown in Fig. 1, to achieve the
selected parameters of the laser could create the maximum tensile temperature gradient during the welding process, all thermocouples (K
strength with the base metal. Yazdian et al. [14] welded stainless steel type) whose measurement accuracy was ± 1 were placed at a distance of
304L using a combined welding operation (electric arc and disc laser). 2 mm from the center of the melt pool. An Advantech USB 4780 module
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of speed and power card was then utilized to save and process the temperature data. The
of laser on the welding area and reduction of pores. Their results showed chemical composition of the materials in weight percentages can be seen
that the welding speed in arc welding, as compared to the disk laser, in Table 1.
significantly reduced the pores caused by the gas, forming a smooth The laser welding process was performed by placing the parts on a
weld with a good appearance. Further, Sinha and Kumar [15] investi fixture. During welding, the effects of changing the parameters affecting
gated the effect of pulse width on dissimilar laser welding of S.S 304 L the quality of welding were investigated. These parameters were weld
and St 37 carbon steel. Their results showed that with changing the pulse ing speed, nozzle distance and beam deviation.
width, the welding profile was changed; so, with increasing the pulse
width up to 5 ms, a good penetration and quality connection were ob 3. Experimental design
tained. Moradi et al. [16] welded AISI 410 martensitic stainless steel to
achieve a corrosion resistant surface. Their results showed that by The trend of changes in laser welding parameters is illustrated in
increasing the focal position, penetration depth and hardness were Table 2. Investigation and optimization of these parameters during
decreased and with the lowest pulse energy, the highest corrosion welding were done based on the appearance of the welding bead, and
resistance was obtained. Akhiri Ardakani and Naffakh-Moosavy [17] thermophysical and metallurgical properties. The main objective of the
investigated the effects of pulsed Nd:Yag laser welding on Kovar and designed experiment was to analyze the effect of process parametes on
AISI 304L alloys. Their results showed that raising the inlet heat led to the temperature field and weld bead dimension simultaneously at low
an increase in thermal stress and cracking in the weld profile. Saravanan cost and time. The most effective parameters can be distinguished as
et al. [18] also conducted pulsed laser welding of stainless steel and well.
investigated the effect of heat input on the microstructures and me An experimental design for this process was considered to investigate
chanical properties. Their results indicated that raising the inlet heat led the trend of changes in the weld bead dimentions and appearance. The
to the formation of full penetration and increased the width of the joint most important factor affecting the changes in weld bead dimentions
area; meanwhile, with moderate inlet heat, the maximum hardness and and mechanical properties consisted of temperature variations. The
weld penetration were decreased significantly. Khorram et al. [19] also variation of the working parameters during experiments is illustrated in
investigated the effect of laser parameters on the geometric dimensions Table 3.
of the AISI 431 stainless steel hardened layer. Their results showed that
the optimal parameters of laser welding were the frequency of 17 Hz, the 4. Results and discussion
pulse width of 18 ms, the welding speed of 20 mm/min, the focal po
sition of 7.5 mm and the calculated microhardness of 650 HV. Further, Due to the unique physical and chemical properties of the materials
Yang et al. [20] investigated the microstructures and mechanical during welding, good progress could be achieved in this field. By
properties in the laser welding operation of SU 304 steel plates with a creating a proper weld between two metals, the challenges involved in
thickness of 100 mm. They performed the welding operation success using these metals in different industries could be addressed. Also, by
fully by changing the deflection angle of the laser beam to less than 1◦ . examining the appearance of the weld bead, the quality of the connec
Their results showed a suitable connection with the appearance of a tion between the two metals could be partly analyzed. Also, by exam
smooth surface without any pores and cracks. Using the Nd: Yag laser ining the appearance of the welding bead, an optimal speed for welding
welding operation, Li et al. [21] investigated the porosity and cracking could be achieved. In the following, the parameters and their effects on
of the heat-affected zone (HAZ) in the joint welding between SUS 304 the weld bead appearance were investigated.
stainless steel and copper. Their results showed that the only factor in
the loss of polygonal porosity was the regulation of the laser deflection 4.1. Effects of laser parameters on the weld bead shape
angle; by controlling the inlet temperature, the sensitivity to the HAZ
cracking could be greatly reduced. Ramesh et al. [22] also investigated Changes in process parameters during laser welding could greatly
the microstructural properties and tensile behavior of A 558 low affect the appearance of the weld bead. It is also very important to note
strength alloy steel sheets under Nd: Yag laser welding. They increased the laser beam interaction during laser welding. As mentioned, the
the welding speed from 70 mm/s to 120 mm/s and kept the other thermophysical properties of the two metals were different.
welding parameters constant. Their results also showed that increasing
the welding speed led to the formation of ferrite in the fusion zone and 4.1.1. Welding speed effect
reduced the austenite size and dimensions of the molten zone. Fig. 2 shows the effect of the laser welding speed on the appearance
In this study, dissimilar laser welding of stainless steel 308 and St 37 of a dissimilar weld bead composed of two metals. As could be observed
was performed. Joining dissimilar materials has been remarkably in Fig. 2b, as the laser welding speed was decreased from 500 to 300
growing in different industries. Hence, this experimental study was mm/min, the width of the weld was increased and the overlap on the
carried out to investigate the effects of different process parameters on surface of the weld bead was clearly increased as well. Also, the shape of
the weld bead shape and temperature field. Analyzing the temperature the weld bead was regular and convex, thus indicating the stable melting
variation during the laser welding process could adequately control the condition of the two materials in acceptable conditions. No spattering or
effects of the process parameters on the quality of the joint; this included defects, such as exccesive undercut or porosities, could be seen, ac
mechanical properties or surface appearance of the joint for industrial cording to the combination of different alloys elements such as carbon
applications. and chorome.
2
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
Table 1
Materials chemical composition used for experiments.
C Cr S Ni Mo Mn Si P Fe
3
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
Fig. 2. Effect of welding speed on weld bead formation and shape at laser power of 400 W, nozzle distance of 2 mm, and welding speed of (a) 500 mm/s, (b) 300
mm/s.
Fig. 3. Effect of laser power on weld bead formation and shape at welding speed of 500 mm/s, nozzle distance of 2 mm, and laser power of (a) 300 W, (b) 400 W.
speed of 200 mm/min; for carbon steel, it was about 190 ◦ C. changes in the absorption coefficient of the laser beam at the lower
It could also be seen that with increasing the welding speed to 300 power and its lower absorption at a power lower than that of carbon
mm/min, the temperature decrease rate was about 10 ◦ C due to the steel. The temperature changes for stainless steel at 300 W, as compared
higher thermal conductivity coefficient for carbon steel; this was about to 400, was about 60 ◦ C; meanwhile, temperature changes for carbon
40 ◦ C for stainless steel owing to the lower thermal conductivity coef steel were about 20 ◦ C. On the other hand, it could be said that with
ficient. On the other hand, by increasing the welding speed to 500 mm/ increasing the temperature, high thermal accumulation occurred in
min, the temperature of both metals was almost the same, thus indi stainless steel, as compared to carbon steel.
cating the low rate of input energy given to the workpiece and different
thermal conductivity coefficients. Due to the lower thermal conductivity 4.2.3. Effect of nozzle distance on the temperature distribution
coefficient, stainless steel was more sensitive to the changes in the Fig. 7a shows that by reducing the nozzle distance, the temperature
welding speed, as compared to carbon steel, in terms of the temperature for carbon steel was increased significantly. As a result, the temperature
gradient. around the molten pool reached its highest value (approx. 300 ◦ C); also,
with incrasing the nozzle distance from the surface of the workpiece, the
4.2.2. Effect of laser power on the temperature distribution temperature was decreased, approaching 200 ◦ C. By moving the nozzle
Fig. 6a shows that the temperature changes in low carbon steel were distance to the higher distance from the workpiece surface, the tem
20 ◦ C higher than those in stainless steel at 400 W due to the higher perature was raised again, by about 30 ◦ C, which could be due to the
thermal conductivity coefficient and the greater absorption of the laser changes occurring in the size of the laser beam diameter and its prox
beam by carbon steel. On the other hand, Fig. 6b shows that the imity to the thermocouple; the laser beam did not enter the molten pool.
reduction of the laser power significantly reduced the temperature In this case, the energy density in the center of the pool was lower and
generated in stainless steel, which could be due to the significant the amount of the melt was less and more energy was spent on heating
4
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
Fig. 4. Effect of nozzle distance on the weld bead shape at laser welding speed 300 mm/min, laser power of 300 W, and nozzle distance of (a) +5 mm, (b) +7 mm.
Fig. 5. Effect of welding speed on the temperature near the melt pool at laser power of 300 W, nozzle distance of 2 mm and beam deviation of 0 mm for (a) St 37, (b)
stainless steel 308.
Fig. 6. Effect of laser power on the temperature near the melt pool at welding speed of 300 mm/min, nozzle distance of 2 mm and beam deviation of 0 mm for (a) St
37, (b) stainless steel 308.
5
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
Fig. 7. Effect of nozzle distance on the temperature near the melt pool at laser power of 400 W, welding speed of 300 mm/min and beam deviation of 0 mm for (a) St
37, (b) stainless steel 308.
the areas around the melt pool. 100 ◦ C, which was almost the same as that of stainless steel in the pre
Fig. 7b shows the temperature graph for stainless steel with respect vious experiment (deviation towards carbon steel).
to nozzle distance changes. The highest temperature was seen in the area Since different thermal conductivity coefficients of about 16 W/m.K
around the molten pool, which was about 230 ◦ C. By further decreasing for stainless steel and 48 W/m.K were obtained for carbon steel, the
the distance of the nozzle from the surface, the workpiece temperature temperature created by the deflection of the beam towards carbon steel
was dropped about 20 ◦ C, which was due to the relative evaporation and was higher. On the other hand, increasing the distance from the contact
absorption of more laser beam in the molten material. Unlike carbon point of the two metals caused the measurement of temperature to be
steel, the temperature was clearly decreased at the nozzle distance to the almost similar for the other metal. Therefore, it could be said that
highest point. changing the location of the laser beam caused a sharp decrease in the
thermal gradient at the temperature measuring point in the metal, which
4.2.4. Effect of beam deviation on the temperature distribution was farther away from the laser beam. In addition, due to the difference
In general, in order to investigate the effect of beam deviation on the in thermal conductivity coefficients between carbon steel and stainless,
thermal gradient created around the molten pool, the laser beam was steel and the same distance of about 2.3 mm from the laser beam, the
diverted to stainless steel or carbon steel by 0.3 mm, respectively. The temperature measured at this point on carbon steel and stainless steel
temperature obtained by the thermocouples in both metals was was almost the same, mostly due to thermal conductivity.
measured at the previously specified position. As can be seen in Fig. 8,
the deviation of the laser beam towards the low carbon steel indicated
4.3. Melt pool dimensions and microstructure
that the temperature around the molten pool had been increased to
about 210 ◦ C for the low carbon steel. This was as if the temperature had
The microstructure of two dissimilar metals and their molten pool is
risen only to 100 ◦ C for stainless steel. Therefore, displacement of laser
of particular importance. To perform this process, it is first necessary to
beam radiation could have a significant effect on the temperature
accurately determine the microstructure of each material and then using
gradient. On the other hand, as shown in Fig. 8b, the deviation of the
metallographic methods, especially the general and partial microstruc
laser beam towards stainless steel increased the temperature to about
ture of the molten pool in different areas, investigate the participation of
170 ◦ C, which was decreased by 40 ◦ C, as compared to the low carbon
each of the specified metals in the molten pool. The microstructure of
steel. The temperature of carbon steel in this experiment was about
the base metal of St 37, as shown in Fig. 9a, included the ferrite structure
Fig. 8. Effect of beam deviation on the temperature near the melt pool at laser power of 400 W, welding speed of 500 mm/min and nozzle distance of 2 mm for (a) St
37, (b) stainless steel 308.
6
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
with the distribution of semantite particles. The microstructure of distance and beam deviation were each examined separately in several
stainless steel as a second base metal is ALSO shown in Fig. 9b. As different amplitudes:
shown, the stainless steel 308 consisted of austenitic microstructure with The results of the experiment showed that the thermal conductivity
twin zones and ferrite filaments. of the applied alloys played an effective role among all determined pa
The microstructure was obtained by the laser welding process on rameters, causing the absorption of laser energy and heat retention in
carbon steel and stainless steel included different areas. In the molten the parts.
pool area, the dominant structure consisted of tempered martensite. In welding speed which controls the heat input rate per unit time had a
Fig. 10, due to the high thermal gradient in the molten pool and crucial role on the temperature field.
receiving the highest energy density in this area, the workpiece received The laser power had a significant effect on both the temperature
the highest heating and cooling rates, which leads to the formation of field, and dimensions and volume of the melt area. By changing the
tempered martensite microstructure in this area. In the area of contact of input power density, the amount of the heat applied to the alloys used
the molten pool with the stainless steel region, the dominant micro was different, which could be attributed to the heat received by each of
structure included the austenitic structure, along with the twin regions the alloys.
and delta ferrite filaments. Therefore, it can be said that there are no Nozzle distance was another parameter thus decreasing the distance
significant microstructural changes in stainless steel during the laser and increasing the temperature around the molten area; so, nozzle dis
welding process. It can also be concluded that in the welding process of tance caused more absorption of the beam in the parts. For this study
these two metals, the microstructural changes in carbon steel are much experiments, there was an almost two-fold increase in the dimensions
greater than in stainless steel and therefore the rate of temperature and volume of the weld bead. The temperature near melt pool was
changes can be higher. decreased about 120 ◦ C for st37 while a reduction about 30 ◦ C for
stainless steel.
5. Conclusion Furthermore, there was no significant microstructural changes in
stainless steel during the laser welding process and in the welding pro
In this paper, the effects of laser parameters determined for welding cess of these two metals, the microstructural changes in carbon steel
operations were investigated. Welding speed, laser power, nozzle were much greater than in stainless steel and therefore the rate of
Fig. 10. The microstructure of the molten pool in two magnifications: (a) 100× magnification, (b) 500× magnification.
7
X. Dong et al. Infrared Physics and Technology 116 (2021) 103774
temperature changes can be higher. [9] M. Moradi, M. Ghoreishi, M.J. Torkamany, J. Sabbaghzadeh, M.J. Hamedi, An
Investigation on the Effect of Pulsed Nd: YAG Laser Welding Parameters of
Stainless Steel 1.4418, Adv. Mater. Res. 383 (2012) 6247–6251.
Declaration of Competing Interest [10] M. Keskitalo, K. Mäntyjärvi, J. Sundqvist, J. Powell, A.F.H. Kaplan, Laser welding
of duplex stainless steel with nitrogen as shielding gas, J. Mater. Process. Technol.
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial 216 (2015) 381–384.
[11] H.-C. Chen, G. Bi, B.Y. Lee, C.K. Cheng, Laser welding of CP Ti to stainless steel
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence with different temporal pulse shapes, J. Mater. Process. Technol. 231 (2016)
the work reported in this paper. 58–65.
[12] F.A.O. Fernandes, D.F. Oliveira, A.B. Pereira, Optimal parameters for laser welding
of advanced high-strength steels used in the automotive industry, Procedia Manuf.
Acknowledgement 13 (2017) 219–226.
[13] P. Kumar, A.N. Sinha, Microstructure and mechanical properties of pulsed Nd:YAG
This work was sponsored in part by Key Research and Development laser welding of st37 carbon steel, Procedia Comput. Sci. 133 (2018) 733–739.
[14] N. Yazdian, M. Mohammadpour, F. Kong, R. Kovacevic, Hybrid laser/arc girth
and Promotion Special Project of Henan Province (212102210351). welding of 304L stainless steel tubes, part 1 – Pore mitigation, thermal analysis and
mechanical properties, Int. J. Press. Vessels Pip. 163 (2018) 75–93.
References [15] A.N. Sinha, P. Kumar, Effect of Pulse Width in Pulsed Nd: Yag Dissimilar Laser
Welding of Austenitic Stainless Steel (304 L) and Carbon Steel (st37), Lasers Manuf.
Mater. Process. (2018).
[1] J. Long, L.J. Zhang, J. Ning, S.J. Na, Dynamic behavior of plasma and molten pool
[16] M. Moradi, D. Ghorbani, M.K. Moghadam, M. Kazazi, F. Rouzbahani, S. Karazi, Nd:
of pure titanium during hyperbaric laser welding, Infrared Phys. Technol. 115
YAG laser hardening of AISI 410 stainless steel: Microstructural evaluation,
(2021), 103686.
mechanical properties, and corrosion behavior, J. Alloys Compd. 795 (2019)
[2] J. Li, Y. Liu, Y. Tao, Q. Zhang, K. Kang, Q. Sun, Q. Sun, Analysis of vapor plume and
213–222.
keyhole dynamics in laser welding stainless steel with beam oscillation, Infrared
[17] H.A. Ardakani, H. Naffakh-Moosavy, The effect of pulsed Nd:YAG laser welding
Phys. Technol. 113 (2021), 103536.
parameters on defects of Kovar to AISI 304L dissimilar joint, Opt. Laser Technol.
[3] H. Heidari, M. Akbari, Investigating the effect of process parameters on the
118 (2019) 62–68.
temperature field and mechanical properties in pulsed laser welding of Ti6Al4V
[18] S. Saravanan, K. Raghukandan, N. Sivagurumanikandan, Pulsed Nd: YAG laser
alloy sheet using response surface methodology, Infrared Phys. Technol. 106
welding and subsequent post-weld heat treatment on super duplex stainless steel,
(2020), 103267.
J. Manuf. Processes 25 (2017) 284–289.
[4] C. Li, J. Huang, K. Wang, Z. Chen, Q. Liu, Optimization of processing parameters of
[19] A. Khorram, A. Davoodi Jamaloei, A. Jafari, M. Moradi, Nd: Yag laser surface
laser skin welding in vitro combining the response surface methodology with
hardening of AISI 43: stainless steel; mechanical and metallurgical investigation,
NSGA-II, Infrared Phys. Technol. 103 (2019), 103067.
Opt. Laser Technol. 119 (2019).
[5] G. Shanthos Kumar, K. Raghukandan, S. Saravanan, N. Sivagurumanikandan,
[20] W. Yang, J. Xin, C. Fang, W. Dai, J. Wei, J. Wu, Y. Song, Microstructure and
Optimization of parameters to attain higher tensile strength in pulsed Nd: YAG
mechanical properties of ultra-narrow gap laser weld joint of 100 mm-thick
laser welded Hastelloy C-276–Monel 400 sheets, Infrared Phys. Technol. 100
SUS304 steel plates, J. Mater. Process. Technol. 265 (2019) 130–137.
(2019) 1–10.
[21] J. Li, Y. Cai, F. Yan, C. Wang, Z. Zhu, C. Hu, Porosity and liquation cracking of
[6] Y. Yang, Z. Gao, L. Cao, Identifying optimal process parameters in deep penetration
dissimilar Nd:YAG laser welding of SUS304 stainless steel to T2 copper, Opt. Laser
laser welding by adopting Hierarchical-Kriging model, Infrared Phys. Technol. 92
Technol. 122 (2020).
(2018) 443–453.
[22] R. Ramesh, I. Dinaharan, R. Ravikumar, E.T. Akinlabi, Microstructural
[7] K.Y. Benyounis, A.G. Olabi, M.S.J. Hashmi, Effect of laser welding parameters on
characterization and tensile behavior of Nd:YAG laser beam welded thin high
the heat input and weld-bead profile, J. Mater. Process. Technol. 164-165 (2005)
strength low alloy steel sheets, Mater. Sci. Eng., A 780 (2020).
978–985.
[8] M.J. Torkamany, S. Tahamtan, J. Sabbaghzadeh, Dissimilar welding of carbon steel
to 5754 aluminum alloy by Nd:YAG pulsed laser, Mater. Des. 31 (1) (2010)
458–465.