Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mergers and Acquisitions Project
Mergers and Acquisitions Project
The following project is prepared for the course of ‘Mergers and Acquisitions’ in the
Accounting & Finance Specialization. The report aims to analyse 4 strategic
acquisitions made by Verizon Communications, Inc. between 2015 to 2020 in
different areas. Verizon is one of the largest communication technology companies
in the world. Founded in 2000, the company operates America’s most reliable
wireless network and the nation’s premier all-fiber network, and delivers
integrated solutions to businesses worldwide.In 2019, it generated a revenue of
$131.9 billion. In total, Verizon has made 22 acquisitions since its inception. The
acquisitions are categorised into 4 types of integrations - Horizontal Integration,
Vertical Integration, Conglomerate Acquisition and Concentric Acquisition. A brief
introduction to the company, details of the acquisition along with extracts of legal
contracts detailing the same are included. The acquisitions are analysed on the
basis of SWOT, pre-transaction and post-transaction performance and key changes
based on financial statements, with suitable graphs and tables. Each category is
concluded with the actions taken by Verizon with the companies acquired. Finally,
the report concludes with some of the main learnings gained while doing the
project along with the sources of information and bibliography.
2
Table of Contents
SWOT Analysis 8
SWOT Analysis 20
SWOT Analysis 32
SWOT Analysis 42
Conclusion 50
Bibliography 51
3
Verizon Communications, Inc.
K
ey Financials (2019)
4
Chapter 1 : Horizontal Integration
T
he Acquisition of Verizon Wireless from Vodafone Plc
5
Execution of the Buy-out
6
Reasons for the Buy-out
(Source : https://www.lawinsider.com/contracts/7T4mOxcQ8WZ)
7
SWOT Analysis of Verizon-Verizon Wireless Buy-out
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
8
Pre-Acquisition Consolidated Financials : Verizon
9
A. General Analysis
Motive behind the Acquisition: Since Wireless was held as a Joint Venture
between Vodafone and Verizon, the full buy-out of Verizon Wireless from Vodafone
by Verizon, was in part to help Vodafone avoid a massive capital gains tax bill.
The possibility of a huge tax bill is regarded by analysts as a big hurdle to any
such deal. Verizon had hoped prior to making the deal that easing most of the tax
bill for Vodafone, so that it can buy the indirect 45% stake of the British company.
The deal was structured in two parts to avoid any tax hit -- firstly, Verizon
Communications bought the Delaware-based Vodafone Americas, which is the U.S.
based holding company of Vodafone that owns the interest in Verizon Wireless.The
second part of the transaction, however, attracted capital gains tax, because of
the sale of assets by Verizon, which is a U.S. based entity.
B. Comparative Analysis:
10
(ii) Cost of services and sales:
Cost of services and sales decreased
during 2013 compared to 2012
primarily due to a decrease in cost of
equipment sales, decreased data
roaming, a decline in cost of data
services and a decrease in network
connection costs, as well as a
decrease in costs related to customer
premise equipment, a decline in
access costs and the net effect of
storm-related insurance recoveries at the Wireline segment.
(v)Dividend payout: During the third quarter of 2013, the Board increased the
quarterly dividend payment 2.9% to $.53 per share from $.515 per share in the
same period of 2012. The cash flows were used to maintain and grow the dividend
payout to shareowners. Verizon’s Board of Directors increased the Company’s
quarterly dividend by 2.9% during 2013.
11
significant increase in the eps might be due to the future acquisition which was
clearly an accretive acquisition for Verizon.
12
(ii) Retail Postpaid Connections :
During 2014, retail postpaid
connections increased 5.5%
compared to 2013, with smartphones
representing 79% of retail postpaid
phone base in 2014 compared to 70%
in 2013. Retail postpaid connections
per account, which is calculated by
dividing the total number of retail
postpaid connections by the number of
retail postpaid accounts as of the end of
the period, increased 4.0% as of December 31, 2014 compared to 2013 primarily
due to the increased penetration of tablets.
(vi) Dividend Payout : During the third quarter of 2014, the Board increased
quarterly dividend payment 3.8% to $.55 per share from $.53 per share in the
same period of 2013. During 2014, $7.8 billion in dividends were paid, compared
to $5.9 billion in 2013. The increase is primarily due to the issuance of
approximately 1.27 billion additional shares of common stock as a result of the
Wireless Transaction. There were no repurchases of common stock in 2014.
Date Open High Low Close Adj Close Volume
Dec 01, 2014 50.68 50.84 45.09 46.78 36.5 419,728,200
Oct 08, 2014 0.55 Dividend
Oct 01, 2014 49.73 50.5 46.89 50.25 38.78 369,933,200
Jul 08, 2014 0.53 Dividend
Jul 01, 2014 48.88 53.66 48.54 50.42 38.49 316,714,100
Apr 08, 2014 0.53 Dividend
(Source : Yahoo Finance - Verizon Communications Historical Stock Prices)
13
(ix) Earnings per Share (EPS): This
acquisition was clearly an accretive
acquisition also for Verizon because it
increased the EPS significantly from $0.31
to $4.01 in 2013 after the transaction. In
2014, it decreased to $2.42, due to the
introduction of 1.27 billion additional
shares of common stock as a result of the
Wireless Transaction.
14
Changes in the Company Pre and Post-Acquisition
Pre-Buyout Post-Buyout
Product Line
Geographical
presence
Management
15
Financial Ratios
Conclusion
Moody’s Investors Services downgraded its rating on Verizon after the news of the
acquisition, to reflect an increase in debt leverage from the addition of about $67
billion of new debt which the credit ratings agency said will more than double
Verizon’s debt load to $116 billion.An article in The New York Times estimated
Verizon Wireless' valuation at about $290 billion. In 2019, Verizon Wireless
services were split between two new divisions: Verizon Consumer and Verizon
Business.
16
Chapter 2 : Vertical Integration - Market Expansion
The Acquisition of Terremark Worldwide Inc.
Transaction Value : $1.4 billion. Closing and other direct acquisition-related costs
totaled approximately $13 million after-tax.
Type of Acquisition : S
tock Purchase
17
Execution of the Acquisition
18
Extract of the Acquisition Agreement
Exhibit 2.1
EXECUTION COPY
(Source : https://www.lawinsider.com/contracts/7T4mOxcQ8WZ)
19
SWOT Analysis of Verizon-Terremark Acquisition
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
20
Pre-Acquisition Consolidated Financials : Verizon
21
Selected Notes to Accounts (Note no.2 - Acquisitions and Divestitures) :
The following table summarizes the allocation of the acquisition cost to the assets
acquired, including cash acquired of $0.1 billion, and liabilities acquired as of the
acquisition date:
22
Analysis
During the year, 2011, Verizon continued to execute its global cloud strategy,
rolling out an expanded portfolio of secure IT solutions and an operational model
for its Terremark subsidiary. Verizon also continued to deploy integrated IT and
communications solutions for multinational enterprise, medium-sized and
government customers. These solutions included expansion of the company's
managed mobility services for tablets, mobile access to cloud-based SAP
applications and enhanced security management programs for health care
providers.
23
can be recorded. As per the general there is a temporary slump till May 30, 2011,
when the share closed at $36.93.
The table also validates the general rule of acquisitions, i.e. the acquiring firm
experiences a slowdown in share price from March 28, 2011 when it was trading at
$38.47, after the acquisition on April 11, 2011 when it was trading at $37.85 and
reduced to $36.91 on April 18, 2011. The slump continued till May 30, 2011.
As per the view of analysts, Verizon had executed this merger mainly to have
leverage with the federal government since Terremark had several data
centres in the Capitol region of the USA, and to mainly expand into the cloud
business, to compete with Microsoft, Google and Amazon, which were already
pioneering to provide cloud management services.The federal government, in
2011, had adopted a “cloud-first” policy that makes cloud, or Web-based
computing, the default choice and has required agencies to move at least three
services to the cloud within an 18-month period. The policy announcements have
stoked a growing industry of companies — both those better known for
commercial work and traditional contractors — hoping to play a part in the shifts.
This may have resulted in Verizon seeking out the opportunity to acquire a small,
niche but rapidly growing company, like Terremark, with connections to the
24
federal government and more than 13 data centres all over the USA. This was also
executed to partially throw off one of Verizon’s major rivals, AT&T, which had
already been providing cloud solutions for companies to scale.
3. Financial Performance
Post-Transaction (2011-12)
Pre-Transaction
Ratio (2010-11) 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
QoQ
Revenue
Growth 2.25% 2.02% 1.36% 1.87% -0.83% 1.09% 1.60% 3.57%
Comments :
25
second-quarter 2010 and now represent approximately 48 percent of global
enterprise revenues.
26
Comments :
(i) Debt and Goodwill : As per its annual reports, Verizon added $2 billion
worth of debt to finance the acquisition of Terremark, which showed the
usage of leverage by the company rather than equity. Verizon also paid off
all outstanding debts of Terremark by May, 2011, which balanced the total
debt in 2011, leading to a net increase of 4.5%. This also could lead to an
increase in confidence for the company and hence an increase in goodwill by
6.2% in 2011.
(ii) Basic EPS : The reason for the downfall in EPS was due to an apparent
increase in the number of stocks due to the acquisition which led the Basic
EPS per Common Share to drop while the company recorded higher
consolidated revenues post-acquisition.
(iii) Dividends :
Dividends paid by Verizon before the acquisition on April 6 and July 6, 2011 were
lower than the standard dividends of $0.5/share. This could be due to funds being
retained to finance the acquisition and paying off debts and other integration costs
after the acquisition. The dividends paid during 2011 were overall higher than
2010, which led to more shares being acquired in 2012.
(iv) Equity : Total Equity is a slightly different scenario, because we see a drop in
equity from 2010 to 2011, which was the year of acquisition. Shareholders may
not be too happy with the acquisition because of the weak performance of telecom
firms in cloud services, as compared to bigger giants like Amazon Web Services,
Microsoft, etc.
27
Changes in the Company pre and post acquisition
Pre-Buyout Post-Buyout
Product Line
Geographical presence
Management
28
Fate of the Acquisition :
In May 2016, Reuters published an article saying that Verizon was set to sell its 29
data centre assets to Equinix for $3.6 billion, the world’s biggest provider of data
centres. This piece of news, however, did not include the sale of Terremark. It was
reported that Verizon wanted to focus on its core business and was already in talks
to acquire Yahoo. On May 2, 2017, Verizon entered into an agreement with IBM to
sell its cloud hosting arm, including Terremark. The transaction value was
undisclosed. Verizon had acquired Terremark for $1.4 billion in April, 2011 and in
2012 began aggressively expanding Terremark’s capabilities but shut down the
cloud business in 2016. The company was facing stiff competition from Microsoft
and Google in the cloud business arena and did not manage to achieve the levels
of profitability and scale needed to compete in the cloud market.
29
Chapter 3 : Subsidiary Merger - Forward Triangular
The Acquisition of AOL Inc.
30
Execution of the Acquisition
31
Extract of the Acquisition Contract
(Source : https://www.lawinsider.com/contracts/7T4mOxcQ8WZ)
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
32
Pre-Acquisition Consolidated Financials : Verizon
33
Selected Notes to Accounts : Note 2 - Acquisitions and Divestitures
Analysis
Taking another significant step in building digital and video platforms to drive
future growth, Verizon Communications Inc., in 2015 had announced the signing
of an agreement to purchase AOL Inc. for $50 per share — an estimated total
value of approximately $4.4 billion.
34
Net Profit 7.57% 13.58% 10.42% 27.35%
Margin
(ii) Revenue : The increase in consolidated revenues during 2015 was primarily
due to higher equipment revenues in the Wireless segment, higher revenues as a
result of the acquisition of AOL and higher Mass Markets revenues driven by Fios
services at the Wireline segment. AOL pulled in $669 million in the first quarter of
2016 — its highest revenue in 5 years which pushed its parent company Verizon's
first quarter revenue to $31.2 billion. Without AOL, Verizon's total revenue would
have declined 1.5% in the quarter. Even though AOL represents a small portion of
Verizon's total revenue, the results demonstrate the impact AOL is having on
Verizon's growth. Verizon was looking to branch out beyond its broadband and
telecommunications capacity by growing its digital media and ad business. The
$4.4 billion acquisition of AOL was a crucial step in Verizon's ability to achieve this.
(in millions)
35
(iii) Operating Expenses :
Consolidated operating expenses
decreased during 2015 primarily
due to non- operational credits
recorded in 2015 as compared to
non- operational charges recorded
in 2014. Cost of services increased
during 2015 primarily due to an
increase in costs as a result of the
acquisition of AOL, higher rent
expense as a result of an increase
in wireless macro and small cell
sites, higher wireless network costs
from an increase in fiber facilities supporting network capacity expansion and
densification. Since AOL’s acquisition there have been a mix of devices sold thus
increasing the Wireless cost of equipment per unit sold, partially offset by a
decline in the number of units sold.Selling, general and administrative expenses
decreased during 2015 primarily due to non- operational credits, primarily
severance, pension and benefit credits, recorded in 2015 as compared to non-
operational charges, primarily severance, pension and benefit charges, recorded in
2014.
36
(v) Assets : The table shows that
there is a significant increase in
Verizon’s asset base after its
acquisition of AOL in 2015. The
acquisition helped Verizon, the
largest mobile phone operator in
US, to drive its growth and
strengthen its presence by entering
into the increasingly competitive
online video space wherein it used
AOL's advanced technology
developed for selling ads and
delivering high-quality web video. AOL also owned online news websites such as
The Huffington Post and TechCrunch, which became part of Verizon once the
acquisition was completed, along with its video and online advertising technology.
The key assets of the company, apart from The Huffington Post and TechCrunch,
include Engadget, MAKERS and AOL.com, as well as its millennial-focused OTT,
Emmy-nominated original video content, and its programmatic advertising
platforms. All these factors led to a major increase in the assets.
(vii) Stock Performance Post Acquisition : Aol shares shot up 19%, after the
Internet content company agreed to be acquired by Verizon Communications Inc.
in a deal valued at $4.4 billion. The company posted credible growth for its
Advertising business in 2013 and 2014.
The recent surge in the AOL stock
price, after the acquisition
announcement, has yielded a return of
over 235% for AOL shareholders.
Verizon paid $50 for each AOL share,
which represented a 17% markup to
the previous closing price. However,
shares of Verizon fell 1.6% after the
deal was announced, meaning
stockholders weren’t too keen on the
success of the deal. There was a drop in closing prices for Verizon in the
beginning of the month of June, just before the announcement of the deal.
(Note : The source of information in the graph is Yahoo Finance - Verizon Monthly
Historical Stock Prices. The time period taken is mentioned in the graph.
37
Changes in the Company Pre and Post-Acquisition
Product Line
Geographical
presence
Management
38
Chapter 4 : Concentric Acquisition
The Acquisition of Yahoo! Inc.
39
Execution of the Acquisition
● On July 23, 2016, Verizon entered into a stock purchase agreement (the
Purchase Agreement) with Yahoo! Inc. (Yahoo). Pursuant to the Purchase
Agreement, upon the terms and subject to the conditions thereof, Verizon
agreed to acquire the stock of one or more subsidiaries of Yahoo holding all
of Yahoo's operating business, for approximately $4.83 billion in cash,
subject to certain adjustments.
● On February 20, 2017, Verizon and Yahoo entered into an amendment to the
Purchase Agreement, pursuant to which the transaction purchase price will
be reduced by $350 million to approximately $4.48 billion in cash, subject to
certain adjustments.
● The deal ends Yahoo as an operating company and leaves it with its stake in
Chinese e-commerce company Alibaba and Yahoo Japan, its cash,
convertible notes, certain minority investments, and a non core portfolio of
patents called Excalibur. These assets will be renamed Altaba.
● Subsequently, Yahoo sold the stock in the single subsidiary to Verizon. Since
it is a sale of a subsidiary, the $4.8 billion was paid to Yahoo. In accordance
with the original Transaction agreements, Yahoo will continue to retain
100% of any liabilities arising out of any shareholder lawsuits (including
derivative claims) and investigations and actions by the Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC).
40
Reasons for the Acquisition
41
SWOT Analysis of Verizon-Yahoo Acquisition
Strengths Weaknesses
1. Verizon has the ability to track users’ 1. Verizon executives reportedly feel
online behavior perhaps even more that Yahoo’s value has been
broadly than Google and Facebook diminished by the hacks, which
do—including their location. could adversely impact future
2. Verizon is in a process of building a growth in user accounts.
portfolio of online content, with their 2. With Yahoo they have a litany of
successful acquisition of Yahoo. failed acquisitions: Broadcast.com
3. For Verizon, the deal paves the way for $5.7 billion, GeoCities for $3.6
to assembling a new media empire billion, Tumblr for $1.1 billion.
capable of delivering potentially 3. In its quest to avoid a Yahoo-like
billions in advertising revenue and decline, Verizon risks repeating
offsetting slowing growth in its one of its key mistakes.
wireless and wireline business units. 4. Yahoo, too, sought to fight
4. Yahoo’s widely distributed content irrelevance through diversification.
capabilities will provide Verizon with But in the process of tacking on
the ability to both expand their digital acquisitions, it lost sight of its
advertising endeavours and continue identity.
to reach wider (and younger)
audiences.
Opportunities Threats
42
Pre-Acquisition Consolidated Financials : Verizon
43
Analysis
In order to extend its reach to more customers and boost its presence in the
mobile and online video space against the likes of Google and Facebook,
Verizon-owned AOL acquired the internet’s oldest business Yahoo. In June 2017,
the transaction was completed. The aggregate purchase consideration of the
transaction was approximately $4.7 billion, including cash acquired of $0.2 billion.
44
(i) Revenue – The revenue of
Verizon for the year 2018,
which is after the transaction of
the acquisition of Yahoo
increased by almost 4%. The
acquisition of Yahoo has been
accounted as a business
combination to diversify and
strengthen its base in the
internet market. The
combination of the three
Verizon AOL and Yahoo is known as ‘OATH’. Oath has generated revenue of almost
7.7 billion at the end of the year 2018, and proved the fact that this acquisition is
profitable in terms of revenue to Verizon.Oath, had an increase in operating
revenues of 89.7% to $6.0 billion during the year ended December 31, 2017
primarily due to the acquisition of Yahoo! Inc.’s (Yahoo) operating business in June
of 2017
Depreciation and
amortization expenses
16,954 17,403
45
The table above shows the
changes in the two years for
operating expenses. The main
reason for the increase in
expenses of Verizon for the
year 2018 is expansion. By
acquiring Yahoo the firm
made entry in the search
engine and native ad-market
which increased their selling,
general and admin expenses.
After the acquisition of Yahoo, Verizon had to incur Goodwill impairment, which
actually is the reason for around 1/3rd increase in expenses, Goodwill impairment
is an accounting charge that companies record when goodwill's carrying value on
financial statements exceeds its fair value. These are the main factors which
affected the operating expenses of Verizon. The below graph shows the difference
of the expenses before and after acquisition.
(iv) Earnings per share - Earnings per share can be defined as a company's net
earnings or losses attributable to
common shareholders per diluted
share base, which includes all
convertible securities and debt,
options and warrants. During the
transactional year i.e. 2017 an
unnatural rise in earnings per share
was observed. The increase was
about 130%, it may have been the
effect of the acquisition of Yahoo. In
2018 the company’s earnings per
share came back to its original and natural trend of 3.76, here below is the table
depicting the same.
46
(v) Assets - The above chart shows that there is a significant increase in
Verizon’s asset base after its acquisition of Yahoo in 2017. Verizon has been
making a concerted push into the mobile advertising and content markets over the
last two years, investing in Internet TV providers (OnCue), content delivery
networks (Edgecast) and ad technology. By acquiring Yahoo, the firm is making
inroads into the search engine and native ad market. Yahoo’s key advertising
assets include Gemini – which combines search and native ads for superior results
– and BrightRoll, which offers programmatic buying and selling tools for video,
display and native advertising. This would give Verizon a wide spectrum of ad tech
assets, ranging from programmatic video and display to native advertising and
search, potentially allowing it to compete with digital ad titans such as Google.
These factors and the acquisition of Yahoo led to the major increase in assets for
Verizon.
(Note : The source of information for the graph is Yahoo Finance - Verizon Daily
Historical Prices. The time period in consideration is mentioned in the graph)
47
Changes in the Company Pre and Post acquisition
Pre-Buyout
Post-Buyout
Product line
Geographical
presence
Management
48
Fate of the Aol and Yahoo Acquisitions
49
Project Conclusion
Verizon is a conglomerate that is known for acquiring even the most weak
companies, such as Enron and WorldCom immediately after their scandal in 2003.
A total of 22 acquisitions and counting, the company has grown mainly through its
strategic integrations in different areas. Verizon Communications, Inc. implements
a generic strategy and intensive growth strategies. Michael Porter’s model states
that a firm uses its generic strategy to ensure competitive advantage. This
competitive advantage is essential in surviving the external forces that impact the
business, based on the condition of the competitive landscape. Verizon’s generic
competitive strategy represents business efforts to stand out in the
telecommunications industry. These efforts translate to competitiveness and brand
value. Recently, the company is under intense competition from its biggest rival
AT&T and the merger between T-Mobile and Sprint, with Sprint hiring the person
that created Verizon’s most famous slogan - “Can You Hear Me Now?”.
50
Bibliography
● https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20110127006903/en/ATLANTIC-ACM-A
nalysis-VerizonTerremark-Deal
● https://www.verizon.com/about/sites/default/files/annual_reports/2011/note02.ht
ml
● https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/verizon-buy-it-services-provider-terremark-14-bil
lion-vz-2011-01-28
● https://www.fool.com/investing/2019/12/27/better-buy-verizon-communications-vs
-att.aspx
● http://panmore.com/verizon-generic-strategy-intensive-growth-strategies
● https://www.verizon.com/about/news/verizon-completes-acquisition-vodafones-45-
percent-indirect-interest-verizon-wireless
● https://www.lawinsider.com/contracts/7T4mOxcQ8WZ
● https://www.reuters.com/article/us-verizon-vodafone-tax/analysis-tax-strategy-ma
y-be-key-to-verizon-wireless-deal-idUSBRE93S02O20130429
● https://www.reuters.com/article/us-verizon-vodafone-credit/verizon-seen-having-cl
ear-path-to-funds-for-vodafone-deal-idUSBRE93S07K20130429
● https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/VZ/history?period1=1388534400&period2=14199
84000&interval=1mo&filter=history&frequency=1mo
● https://www.nbcnews.com/news/all/verizon-takes-4-6-billion-hit-aol-yahoo-n94648
6
● https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Media
● https://www.verizon.com/about/sites/default/files/annual/verizon-annual-2015/do
wnloads/15
● https://in.reuters.com/finance/stocks/company-profile/VZ.N
● https://www.verizon.com/about/our-company/what-we-do
● https://fortune.com/company/verizon/
● https://money.cnn.com/2017/06/13/technology/business/yahoo-verizon-deal-close
s/index.html
● https://www.verizon.com/about/sites/default/files/annual_reports/2016/downloads.
html
● https://www.verizon.com/about/sites/default/files/annual/verizon-annual-2015/do
wnloads/15_vz_ar.pdf
● https://www.verizon.com/about/sites/default/files/vz_ar_final_2011.pdf
51