Area of the structure 69* 25 m with 6 M Clear height.

( floor to floor)
G+2 considered for frame anaylisis and
Structural configeration foundation
At this stagedesign
G+1 considered for
construction

Option 1 Option 2
Conventional RCC framed structure with
beams and slab Flat slab Design
Breif

30 Days .Generally venders will take 15 20 days.Due to the flat shuttering only for the slab
Time frame for each floor readiness with +15 days ( if total area concrete pour soffit and column cap the repetition and better
1 shuttering planned in two segments) speed can be achived
Posibility of increase column free Area in
2 internal Layout . Moderate High
3 Grade of concrete M 20 /M 25 M25 /M 30 . Crn to comment

4 Cost Moderate same as in option 1

cost per Sqm CRN to give input CRN to give input
5 Technology availability locally Generally available Generally available

6 Venders capacity / knowledge Normally all venders used to do it Normally all venders used to do it
Fully in situ shuttering beam shuttering
7 Quandum in situ shuttering work takes the time comparitvely lesser and relatively faster

Suitability of the option for connection bet

8 existing rcc framed building suitable suitable

Due to elimination of beam, effective floor height

9 Any other parameter needs to be covered CRN to comment if any can be reduced

Recommendations

Cost Least Cost Heavier slab and reinforcement will be required.

Hence increase in cost of buildings and

foundations. Self weight of future flat slab, will be
much more then live load.

Hence, when upper floor is cast, lower floor to be

repropped. Not possible while lower floor is under
occupation. Hence constrcutabiity will be A
PROBLEM

Maintenance Least maintenance Least maintenance

Fire protection Good fire resistance capacity Good fire resistance capacity

Ease of future vertical extension and Ease of future vertical extension and connection to
Vertical extension connection to existing buildings. existing buildings.

Vendors Available Large panel of builders available Many builders available

Ranking I IV
 Option 3 0ption 4 Option 5

Flat slab with Post tentioning Rcc column with steel joist and rcc slab with shuttering RCC column with steel joist and Deck sheeting
similer to Asian Paint sriperumpudur
steel joist can be Solid web or open web

From the date of panel column readiness the slab concrete

30 Days .CRN to review and comment can be completed in 7 Days 7 Days

Very High Same in Option 1 High

M 35. crn to review and comment M25 M20

Relatively high due to the scale of work crn to give input Crn to give input
CRN to give input CRN to give input CRN to give input
Available Available Available

Steel fabrcation and erection is required.previous experience

Previous experience is required is required
Very Minimum shuttering .Relatively faster and
same as in option 2. comparitvely lesser and involves erection activity skilled labour intensivesity is low

suitable suitable suitable

As steel fabrication and erection is required along

Due to elimination of Rcc beam, As steel fabrication and erection is required along with rcc with rcc works.better effective syncronised planning
effective floor height can be reduced works.better effective syncronised planning is required is required

Small value of works, is not likely to To enable future extension of column to upper floors, the To enable future extension of column to upper
attract, required attention or response. steel beam have been seated on RC bracket from RC column. floors, the steel beam have been seated on RC
In situ welding of steel beam to insert plates on column face bracket from RC column. In situ welding of steel
With only two upper floors, reduction not recommended. beam to insert plates on column face not
load compared to Optoin -2 will be less. recommended.
Therefore column and foundation will be subjected to
Costlier then - Option - 2 excessive bending moment. Therefore column and foundation will be subjected
to excessive bending moment.

To overcome point 2, above, we may go for steel

stanchion, which needs to be encased for
appearance and integration with block wall on the
periphery. Hence this will be further costlier.

Least maintenance Slightly higher maintenance Slightly higher maintenance

Good fire resistance capacity Acceptable fire resistance behaviour Acceptable fire resistance behaviour

Vertical extension more difficult Vertical extension more difficult Vertical extension more difficult

Only limited number of builders Many builders available Many builders available
available

V II III