This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been

fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal

 
















.F.A5?6
!.4.@B/?.:.;6.;
$.82@5
B:.?
%.8A56C29
$6GD.;
#.A.;
'/$'4

BA5B?.:.96;4.:
%.;8.FF.

.5:<B1
.;2@5:.;1
'0+14
+('
'/$'4

:6?

.;1<:6
'0+14
'/$'4



) $"$

$#
 

$
"%$%"

"&#

" #"$
$
#"

%$$
"
#%$#
%"

#
$'"
&"

 $#


$
$

#"&
$
"
"$
$#
$
"$
$#

$

$"
$"%

 $#
#%
#
##"#

"#



%#
$

 %$
"

$$"
"
"$
#

"##
#
'"
" ##

#(#$
$$
#"&#
$
" #*

-
.;1

"'$


###
$%%#(
"
&#
""#




"&
($
#$$#$#

$
"'$

##
$$"#

$
" #
"'"
%##

"
$!%#
#%
#

-
.;.9FG21
A52
4?22;
A205;<9<462@
.==960.A6<;@
6;
A52
.4?60B9AB?2

#% "$
&$"


&%$
%"
$'"
#

"'"
"%#
$
"
$
$$#
$
$"

#$
3<0B@2@
<;
A52
12C29<=:2;A
<3
@=<;A.;2<B@
?20<4;6A6<;

.;1
09.@@6360.A6<;
<3
A52
0?<=
16@2.@2@
3?<:
A52
4.A52?21
5645
?2@<9BA6<;
:B9A6@=20A?.9
6:.42@
5F=2?@=20A?.9
6:.42@
.;1

@A2?2<AF=2
6:.42@
<?
2E.:=92
@B4.?
/22A
92.C2@
.?2
B@B.99F

6;320A21
/F
A52
16@2.@2@
9682
<D;F
:6912D
?B@A
2?0<@=<?.
92.3

@=<A
.;1
=5<:.
92.3
@=<A
;
A56@
?24.?1
$.<
2A
.9
,
%?228.;A5.
2A
.9
,-
.;.9FG21
A52
6;A299642;A
0?<=
:<;6A<?6;4
.;1

6??64.A6<;
@F@A2:
A<
529=
6;
A52
4?<DA5
<3
A52
=9.;A@
%5.685
2A
.9

,
36291@


 $#
'
"
###$

""$
%$"$

$.F
'6
#.
,-
.;1
&G<B;6@
'6
#.
,-
2E=9.6;21
A52
<&
3BAB?2
A?2;1@


&"$
 
"$
$
$
"
#

$#
.;1
.?056A20AB?2@
?2@=20A6C29F
<&
12C602@
6;09B12
5645?2@<9BA6<;

""
$#
'"
" ##
#
##$


$$"
@=20A?.9
0.:2?.@
.4?60B9AB?2
@2;@<?@
.;1
.
$.@=/2??F
#6
0<;A?<992?

$
"
"
$"
(#$


$
$(
$
D5605
5.@
/22;
:.;6=B9.A6;4
A52
=9.;A
6:.42@
B@6;4
:.056;2

###
$
$
"(
#$#


" #


%##
#
92.?;6;4
.94<?6A5:@
&52
6:.42@
A.82;
/F
A52
0.:2?.@
.?2

"
% "$
$"


"
$$


=?<02@@21
/F
2EA?.0A6;4
A52
92.3
=<?A6<;@
<3
A52
6:.42@


"
###

$
$#
'"
""#
 "$&
(##
&52;
A52
2EA?.0A21
92.3
?246<;@
.?2
@24:2;A21
B@6;4
"A@BM@
:2A5<1

$'
&"%#


$!%#
#%
#
-(('*,
,'*
!"&
";02
A52
92.3
?246<;@
.?2
@24:2;A21
A52
16@2.@2
=<?A6<;@
6@



'&.'$-,"'&$
-*$
,/'*#


&2.
1+
612;A63621
/F
B@6;4
A52
@</29
2142
12A20A6<;
.==?<.05
3<?
=<6;A6;4

&
&*+,
&" !'*+
&
,!"+
0(*"%&,$
+,"'&
,!
16@2.@2
6;320A21
=<6;A@
6;
A52
92.C2@
&52@2
6:.42
=?<02@@6;4

"#%$#
#'
$$
$
" #


#(#$
'"#
 $(

A205;6>B2@
.?2
B@21
A<
@=<A
A52
16@2.@2
6;
A52
=9.;A
92.C2@
/BA
;<A
A<

 "
$
$
$"
#(#$#


09.@@63F
A52:
2336062;A9F
;
<?12?
A<
.0562C2
16@2.@2
=.AA2?;D6@2



 
 

)
Ensemble SVM, IoT, Agriculture, Crop and Leaf
09.@@6360.A6<;@
.;1
?20<4;6A6<;
<3
16@2.@2@
:.;F
:.056;2
92.?;6;4

diseases

.==?<.052@
.?2
A.82;
/F
A52
?2@2.?052?@


<?
2E.:=92
.4?60B9AB?.9
?2@2.?052?@
.?7.;6;
'6
#.
,
-
3<0B@21


%+)&,+ &%
<;
A52
=?</92:@
.;1
@<9BA6<;@
<3
.4?60B9AB?2
12C29<=:2;A
B?A52?

#$
%F@A2:
3<?
=9.;A
16@2.@2
?20<4;6A6<;
@B==<?A@
A52
3.?:2?
A52
<A52?
?2@2.?052?@
12C29<=21
A52
A205;6>B2@
@B05
.@
%( 
#

A<
A.82
=?<.0A6C2
1206@6<;@
.A
A52
/246;;6;4
=<6;A
<3
A52
16@2.@2
!2AD<?8
!!
,

-,
-,
-
1206@6<;
A?22@
/.08=?<=.4.A6<;

4?<DA5
.;B.9
<?
C6@B.9
?20<4;6A6<;
<3
A52@2
16@2.@2@
3?<:
A52
;2B?.9
;2AD<?8@
.;1
;2.?2@A
;2645/<?@M
09.@@6360.A6<;
3<?
A52

</@2?C21
=9.;A
=<?A6<;@
=.AA2?;@
6@
6;.00B?.A2
.;1
6;2336062;A
16@2.@2
09.@@6360.A6<;
";
A52
D.F
22
'6
#.
,-
=<6;A21
<BA

<?2<C2?
A52
D.F
<3
?20<4;6A6<;
?2>B6?2@
.
D299A.92;A21
/<A.;6@A
=5FA<=5A5<?.
6;32@A
16@2.@2@
<;
A52
A<:.A<2@
&52F
B@21
C.?6<B@

<&
0<:=<;2;A@
A<
/B691
A52
@F@A2:
682D6@2
*B
'6
#.
,-
.==9621

&52
6@@B2@
A5.A
<00B?
1B?6;4
0<;C2;A6<;.9
.==?<.052@
0.;
/2

%(
0<AA<;
:<B91
16@2.@2@
/.@21
<;
A526?
C6@B.9
:.?8@
&52
:.6;

?20A63621
B@6;4
#$
.BA<:.A60.99F


@0<=2
<3
A56@
=?<=<@21
#$
@052:2
6@
A<
12C29<=
.
C2?@.A692

#064%3+25
3'%'+7'&
""

3'7+4'&
""

#%%'25'&
""
#5'
1(
26$.+%#5+10
""

0?<=
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
.;1
<&/.@21
.BA<:.A60
1206@6<;
&#5'
1(
%633'05
7'34+10
""







 

:.86;4
@F@A2:


E6@A6;4
D<?8@
:.6;9F
3<0B@
<;
<3396;2
<?
<BA1.A21
1.A.
6A2:@
3<?

#9#5*3+

#0&
#-'4*
6/#3

#3'
8+5*
5*'
%*11.
1(
1/265+0)
%+'0%'
92.3
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
&56@
6@
A.82;
.@
.
@2?6<B@
=?</92:
D5605
6@


0)+0''3+0)
#.)15+#4
0+7'34+59
3'#5'3
1+&#
55#3
3#&'4*
0&+#
'
A52
@0<=2
<3
A52
=?<=<@21
D<?8
A5.A
.6:@
A<
=?<C612
?2.9A6:2
<&

/#+.4
)#9#5*3+'3/')/#+.%1/
3#-'4*'3/')/#+.%1/



#5#0
+4
8+5*
5*'
'2#35/'05
1(
1/265+0)
%+'0%'

0)+0''3+0)
1.A.
.;.9F@6@
&52
<A52?
0<;A?6/BA6<;
<3
A56@
D<?8
6@
A<
12C29<=


!'.#)#26&+
#/#-3+4*0#
+&&*#35*#
0)+0''3+0)
1..')'
!+,#9#8#&#
0&+#
.;1
/.@21
:B9A609.@@6360.A6<;
:<129@
3<?
12A20A6;4
A52
?2.9
'/#+.
23+:8#0
)/#+.%1/
A6:2
<&
@2;@<?@
6;=BA@
4.A52?21
3?<:
C.?6<B@
92.C2@
;
.116A6<;

65*63#/#.+0)#/

+4
8+5*
5*'
'2#35/'05
1(
0(13/#5+10
'%*01.1)9
A56@
D<?8
:.6;9F
0<;02;A?.A2@
<;
A52
2336062;A
.==960.A6<;
<3

*+#)#3#,#3
1..')'
1(
0)+0''3+0)
#&63#+
0&+#
'/#+.
4/3+55%''&6



#0'4*/#0&
+4
8+5*
5*'
%*11.
1(
64+0'44
5'7'04
045+565'
1(
!%( 
;2.?2@A
.;1
!!
6;
92.3
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
&52

'%*01.1)9
1$1-'0

 

#0&
*'
+4
5''3+0)
1//+55''
*#+3
0<:=.?.A6C2
2E=2?6:2;A.9
.;.9F@6@
529=@
A<
.;.9F@2
A52
92.3

1(

1
'/#+.
#*/16&#0'4*/#0&45'7'04'&6
=.AA2?;@
.;1
16@2.@2
=.?A6092@
3?<:
16332?2;A
=2?@=20A6C2@



#0&1/+
+4
8+5*
5*'
#%6.59
1(
0)+0''3+0)


0+7'34+59
1(
&52
<C2?.99
=.=2?
6@
<?4.;6G21
.@
3<99<D@
%20A6<;

46C2@
A52

'%*01.1)9
9&0'9
6453#.+#
'/#+.
#0&1/+654'&6#6
96A2?.AB?2
?2C62D
%20A6<;

=?<C612@
A52
=?<=<@21
D<?8
@20A6<;


(
=?<C612@
A52
?2@B9A@
.;1
36;.99F
@20A6<;
(
2;1@
D6A5
A52


0<;09B@6<;



2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal


&$&'$
$()
0<;A?6/BA6<;@
6;
A52
36291
<3
A52
0?<=
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
&52

=?<=<@21
#$
0<;02;A?.A2@
<;
A52
@B4.?
/22A@
16@2.@2@
D5605

&52
.4?60B9AB?2
36291
?2>B6?2@
:<?2
.AA2;A6<;
A<
/2
12C29<=21
D6A5

6@
0<::<;
6;
;16.

;
A56@
D<?8
;@2:/92
!<;96;2.?
%B==<?A

6;A299642;A
:<;6A<?6;4
.;1
1206@6<;:.86;4
@F@A2:@
6332?2;A

(20A<?
.056;2
C6A.9
6@
.==9621
3<?
A52
09.@@6360.A6<;
<3
A52

AF=2@
<3
?2@2.?05
D2?2
0.??621
<BA
A<
612;A63F
C.?6<B@
0?<=

16@2.@2@
&52
0<;C2;A6<;.9
%(
5.@
/.@60
09.@@6360.A6<;
?B92@

16@2.@2@

$.<
'6
#.
,
-
B@21
@2C2?.9
@A?.A2462@
A<
=?206@2
A52

D5605
.?2
;<A
23320A6C29F
.1.=A./92
3<?
:B9A6=92
16@2.@2

0.=AB?21
6;160.A6<;@
6;
A52
0<AA<;
92.C2@
&52
6:.42@
B@21
6;
A56@

09.@@6360.A6<;
<D2C2?
!%(
5.@
:B9A6=92
@B/
09.@@6362?@

D<?8
D2?2
:.6;A.6;21
.A
;<:6;.9
?2@<9BA6<;@

&52@2
6:.42@
D2?2

0<:=.?21
A<
A52
<A52?
A205;6>B2@


=?2=?<02@@21
.;1
9<0.A21
6;
.
@2=.?.A2
6:.42
1.A./.@2
&52

0<;C2;A6<;.9
2142
12A20A6<;
.;1
09.@@6360.A6<;
A205;6>B2@
D2?2
.056;2
2.?;6;4
 
6@
.
A205;<9<4F
B@21
A<
A?.6;
A52
0<:=BA2?

B@21
/F
A52
.BA5<?@
A<
612;A63F
A52
0<AA<;
92.3
16@2.@2@

;
.116A6<;
@F@A2:
3<?
:.86;4
1206@6<;@
/.@21
<;
A52
92.?;6;4
A205;6>B2@


A<
A5.A
8;2.?2@A
09.@@6360.A6<;
D.@
B@21
A<
2EA?.0A
A52
0<9<?
A205;6>B2@
.?2
42;2?.99F
B@21
A<
46C2
92.?;6;4
0.=./696AF
A<
A52

32.AB?2@
<3
16332?2;A
92.C2@
.;1
%(
D.@
.==9621
A<
612;A63F
A52
0<:=BA2?
@F@A2:@
&56@
6@
0.9921
.@
@8699
A<
92.?;
&52?2
.?2
C.?6<B@

16@2.@2@
6;
=9.;A
92.C2@
2336062;A9F



A205;6>B2@
.C.69./92
&52F
.?2


%?228.;A5.
'6
#.
,-
=?<720A21
.
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
3<?
•
%B=2?C6@21
2.?;6;4


0<AA<;
=9.;A
16@2.@2@
&52
16@2.@2@
D2?2
?20<4;6G21
/F
A52:
B@6;4
•
';@B=2?C6@21
2.?;6;4

A52
6:.42@
A5.A
?23920A
A52
16@2.@2
@=<A
:.?8@
<;
A52
0<AA<;
92.C2@

&52
.BA5<?@
=?<02@@21
A52
6:.42@
B;12?
0<::2?06.9
:</692
•
9B@A2?6;4
.;1
9.@@6360.A6<;

0.:2?.@
6;
.;
B;0<;A?<9921
@6AB.A6<;
<3
A52
3.?:9.;1
&56@
AF=2
<3
•
.A.
=?2=?<02@@6;4

6:.42
=?<02@@6;4
:.82@
A52
92.3
@24:2;A.A6<;
0?6A60.9
&56@
D<?8
•
6:2;@6<;.96AF
$21B0A6<;

B@21
AD<
16332?2;A
AF=2@
<3
@2>B2;021
09.@@6362?@


•
B9A6.F2?
=2?02=A?<;


A
A52
36?@A
@A.42
A52
09.@@6362?
6@<9.A2@
A52
92.3
3?<:
A52
6:.42

•
!<;#.?.:2A?60
2A5<1@


/.084?<B;1
B@6;4
9<0.9
6:.42
32.AB?2@
3A2?
A5.A
A52
09.@@6362?

@=<A@
<BA
A52
16@2.@2@
B@6;4
5B2
.;1
9B:6;.;02
<3
A52
6:.42
•
6112;
.?8<C
<129

&56@
86;1
<3
?2@2.?05
@64;@
6@
4<<1
A<
.==9F
:.056;2
92.?;6;4

A205;6>B2@
3<?
A52
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
6;
<&/.@21
3.?:6;4

36291@
";
A56@
?2@2.?05
=.A5
.?7.;6
'6
#.
,
-
1296C2?21
.
4?.F ';9682
%(
96;2.?
2;@2:/92
;<;96;2.?
09.@@6360.A6<;
B@2@

@0.92
:<?=5<9<4F/.@21
92.3
;2?C2
2EA?.0A6<;
@F@A2:
&<
2EA?.0A

A52
92.3
32.AB?2@
A52
0<9<?
6:.42@
<3
A52
92.C2@
D2?2
0<;C2?A21

6;A<
4?.F@0.92
6:.42@
/.@21
<;
A52
6;A2;@6AF
.;1
5B2
0<;A2;A@
<3

A52
6:.42
&52;
4?.F@0.92
:<?=5<9<4F
A205;6>B2
D.@
A.82;
A<

?2:<C2
.
0<9<?
0<;3B@6;4
@20A6<;
<3
A52
6:.42
&52
;2EA
@A2=
6@

B@21
A<
612;A63F
A52
4?.F@0.92
C.?6.A6<;@
3<?
A52
92.3
=.?A
.;1
;2?C2

*
:<;4
A52@2
A205;6>B2@
A56@
=?<=<@21
D<?8
B@2@
.
%B==<?A

(20A<?
.056;2
%( 
D6A5
2;@2:/92
;<;96;2.?
09.@@6360.A6<;

:B9A69.F2?
09.@@6362?@
D5605
@B==<?A
B;02?A.6;
0<;16A6<;@
<3
92.3

=.AA2?;
12A20A6<;@
&56@
529=@
A<
=?<720A
:<?2
2336062;A
09.@@63621

?2@B9A@
<;
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
%6:69.?9F
!!
6@
.==9621
3<?

12A20A6;4
92.3
16@2.@2@
!!
6@
.
AF=2
<3
B9A6.F2?
=2?02=A?<;

:<129
.6;9F
6A
6@
.==9621
D6A5
:.;F
9.F2?@
<3
369A2?@
&52
369A2?

AF=2@
:.F
/2
6:=92:2;A21
.@
*
*
J
!!
1<2@

=.?A
;
A52
2;1
.;
<=A6:.9
A5?2@5<91
C.9B2
6@
12A2?:6;21
A<
6@<9.A2

A52
;2?C2
=.?A
<3
A52
92.3
3?<:
<A52?@
&52@2
D<?8@
D2?2
:.6;9F

B@21
A<
?20<4;6G2
A52
92.3
32.AB?2@
D5605
.?2
529=3B9
A<
612;A63F
A52

16@2.@2
=<?A6<;@
.A
16332?2;A
=<6;A@
<3
.;F
92.3

B?A52?
$.72@D.?6
'6
#.
,
612;A63621
A52
.==960.A6<;@
<3
*?.F

6:.42
=?<02@@6;4
A<
@=<A
A52
=9.;A
16@2.@2@
;
A56@
D<?8
A52
92.3M@


6:.42@
D2?2
B@21
3<?
2EA?.0A6;4
A52
42<:2A?60.9
32.AB?2@
.;1

1646A.9
:<?=5<9<460.9
32.AB?2@
&52
4<.9
<3
A56@
?2@2.?05
D<?8
D.@

A<
3.:696.?6G2
A52
.==?<=?6.A2
32.AB?2@
3?<:
A52
92.3
=.AA2?;@
3<?

3BAB?2
.4?60B9AB?.9
?2@2.?05
5:.16;27.1
'6
#.
,-
=?<=<@21
A52

!!/.@21
=9.;A
AF=2
612;A6360.A6<;
@F@A2:
3?<:
A52
46C2;
92.3

6:.42@
;
.116A6<;
A<
A52
6:.42
=?<02@@6;4
A205;6>B2@
A52

.BA5<?@
B@21
A52
=?<=2?A62@
<3
A52
46C2;
92.3
6:.42
92.3
.@=20A

?.A6<
.=2E
.AA?6/BA2@
12C6.A6<;
?.A6<
.;1
92.3
.;492
&52@2
92.3

=?<=2?A62@
D2?2
46C2;
A<
!!
.@
.
@2A
<3
6;=BA
&52
.BA5<?@

0<9920A21
.?<B;1

92.3
=.AA2?;@
3<?
C.?6<B@
=9.;A@
00<?16;4
A<

A5.A
A52F
A?.6;21
:<?2
A5.;

0<;C<9BA6<;
.A
A52
/246;;6;4
<3
369A2?
@20A6<;@
A<
@=96A
A52
6:.42

=.AA2?;@
6;.99F
6A
1<2@
120<;C<9BA6<;
3<?
42AA6;4
A52
6;A24?.A21

?2@B9A@

&52
:B9A69.F2?
=2?02=A?<;
6@
?232??21
A<
A52
3B99F
0<;;20A21
;2B?.9

;2AD<?8@
&56@
:2.;@
2.05
;2B?<;
<3
.
=.?A60B9.?
9.F2?
6@

0<;;20A21
A<
.99
;2B?<;@
6;
A52
@B002216;4
9.F2?
<D2C2?
!!@

A.82
A52
/2;236A@
<3
A52
562?.?0560.9
=.AA2?;
6;
A52
92.3
1.A.
.;1

0?2.A2
:<?2
0<:=92E
92.3
=.AA2?;@
3<?
42;2?.A6;4
:2.;6;43B9

0<:=92E
1.A.
&56@
46C2@
:<?2
.00B?.A2
?2@B9A@
6;
16@2.@2

12A20A6<;
6;.99F
A56@
=?<=<@21
D<?8
B@2@
 2.;@
09B@A2?6;4

A205;6>B2
3<?
36;16;4
A52
09.@@2@
<3
C.?6<B@
16@2.@2
=.AA2?;@
6;
.

92.3

:2.;@
09B@A2?6;4
6@
.
A205;6>B2
D5605
B@2@
C20A<?

>B.;A6G.A6<;
.==?<.05
&56@
6@
:.6;9F
12?6C21
3?<:
@64;.9

=?<02@@6;4
A205;6>B2
&52
A205;6>B2
6@
12C29<=21
3?<:
A52
@A2=@

<3
09B@A2?
.;.9F@6@
6;
A52
1.A.
:6;6;4
1<:.6;


:2.;@
09B@A2?6;4
A205;6>B2
D.@
12C29<=21
<3
A52


92.C2@
.;1
.0>B6?21

.00B?.0F
09.@@6360.A6<;
=.?A6A6<;@
D6A5
L;M
;B:/2?
<3
0<;A6;B<B@

6;
A52
=9.;A
612;A6360.A6<;

</@2?C.A6<;@
6;A<
L8M
A6:2
<3
09B@A2?
B;6A@
.05
</@2?C.A6<;

%?6;6C.@.9B
'6
#.
,
-
B@21
%(
3<?
?20<4;6G6;4
A52
0<AA<;
=9.;A

16@2.@2@
@B05
.@
/.0A2?6.9
6;320A6<;@
02?<@=?.
.;1
.9A2?;6.
&56@

D<?8
D.@
2EA2;121
6;
D5605A52
?2@B9A@
=?<1B021
/F
%(
D.@

46C2;
A<
A52
;1?<61
=9.A3<?:
3<?
/2AA2?
=?<720A6<;
&56@
@F@A2:

:.82@
A52
<&
=9.A3<?:
D<?8
D6A5
:.056;2
92.?;6;4
A205;6>B2@

&52?2
.?2
:.;F
?2@2.?05
D<?8@
D5605
5.C2
:.12
A526?

4.A52?21
.A
16332?2;A
A6:2
6;A2?C.9@
/29<;4@
A<
.;F
<;2
<3
A52

09B@A2?@
&52
09B@A2?21
</@2?C.A6<;@
:.6;A.6;
A52
:2.;
C.9B2
&56@

6@
!<;#<9F;<:6.9
!#
5.?1
6;
A52
0<:=BA.A6<;.9
.@=20A
&56@

5.@
.
16?20A
0<;02=AB.9
?29.A6<;@56=
D6A5
A52
!2.?2@A
;2645/<?

09.@@6360.A6<;
&52
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:
B@2@
A56@
A205;6>B2
3<?
92.3

16@2.@2
09.@@6360.A6<;

2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal


#$"#"%
##$"

 ) &%
" %

;
A56@
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:
A2:=2?.AB?2
@2;@<?@
@<69
:<6@AB?2
@2;@<?@
(-(
&+#

%#.) )
&+#
&+#

&%*(&##(

.;1
9645A
@2;@<?@
.?2
B@21
A<
A52
:2.@B?2
A52
A2:=2?.AB?2
C.9B2
%)&()
%

#&( *$)
)))

%*  * &%

:<6@AB?2
92C29
.;1
9645A
6;A2;@6AF
92C29
<3
A52
=9.;A@
?2@=20A6C29F
$(

&52
1.A.
4.A52?21
3?<:
A52@2
@2;@<?@
.?2
:.;6=B9.A21
/F
?1B6;<

'!"
:60?<=?<02@@<?
B;6A
64


=?<C612@
A52
<C2?.99
@F@A2:

.?056A20AB?2
3<?
A52
=?<02@@
<3
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;

*
&##* &%
*)

% *


%)&()
%


$()
(+ %&
% *
*)



<:


')
$B7H?8F
8F6E<CG<BA





 %
(% %
+#



&&#)
&+
&$'&%%+*

* %&
B@CBA8AGF B+
$B78?





+8@C8E4GHE8
F8AFBE
#$

+&


<:

4F<6
*LFG8@
4E6;<G86GHE8



*B<?
@B<FGHE8
F8AFBE
#$



&52;
A52
C.9B2@
.?2
B@21
/F
!%(
.;1
!!
A<
612;A63F
A52

H@<7<GL
F8AFBE
+

=9.;A
16@2.@2
&<
.0562C2
A56@
16@2.@2
.;.9F@6@
!%(
.;1
!! 
#<:;G
<AG8AF<GL
F8AFBE


/.@21
.94<?6A5:@
.?2
B@21
A<
:.82
.
A?.6;6;4
@.:=92
<3
92.3
6:.42@

LC8E
FC86GE4?
64@8E4F
L*C8K

.;1
<=A6:.9
A5?2@5<91
C.9B2@
3<?
A52
92.3
32.AB?2@
&52?2
.?2
A5?22


.4G8E
9?BJ
F8AFBEF
0*


:<1B92@
6;
A56@
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:
&52F
.?2

•
.?1D.?2
:<1B92

•
;.9F@6@
:<1B92


•
206@6<;:.86;4
:<1B92

.?1D.?2
:<1B92
0<;A.6;@
?1B6;<
0<;A?<992?
B;6A
@2;@<?@
.;1

0.:2?.@
.;1
.;.9F@6@
:<1B92
:.6;A.6;@
:.056;2
92.?;6;4

A205;6>B2@
.0A6C.A6<;
&56@
:<1B92
0<C2?21
A?.6;6;4
.;1
A2@A6;4

6;3<?:.A6<;
./<BA
A52
92.C2@
.;1
92.3
=.AA2?;@
;
A52
@2;@6;4

:<1B92
A52
3<99<D6;4
@2;@<?@
.?2
B@21
6;
A52
3.?:6;4
36291
&52F

.?2
B@21
A<
:<;6A<?
2.05
.;1
2C2?F
=<6;A
6;
A52
=9.;A
;
.116A6<;

A<
A5.A
:B9A6=92
@2;@<?@
.?2
12=9<F21
A<
:2.@B?2
2;C6?<;:2;A.9

0<;16A6<;@
&52@2
0<:=<;2;A@
.?2
0<;;20A21
C6.
?29.F@
A<
A52

-

?2@=20A6C2
A2?:6;.9
12C602@
@B05
.@
D.A2?
:<A<?
.;1
<A52?

0<:=BA2?
@F@A2:@
&52
12@64;
<3
A52
<&
.?056A20AB?2
12=2;1@

B=<;
A52
0<:=<;2;A@
?2>B6?21
A<
.0562C2
A52
4<.9

$.F
'6
#.
,
-
.;.9FG21
16332?2;A
AF=2@
<3
<&
.?056A20AB?2@
6;

12A.69
&52
0<:=<;2;A@
6;C<9C21
6;
A52
<&
@F@A2:
6;09B12@
.;F

0<::B;60.A6;4
12C602
A2?:6;.9
12C602
D6?292@@
@2;@<?
;<12@

.;1
;2AD<?8@
"75.
'6
#.
,
-
16@0B@@21
A52
.1.=A.A6<;
<3
A52

D6?292@@
@2;@<?
;2AD<?8
6;
A52
<&
12@64;
&52
?2=?2@2;A21

0<:=<;2;A@
0.;
0<::B;60.A2
D6A5
A52
:</692
=5<;2@
A<
46C2
A52

:.;6=B9.A21
?2@B9A@
?24.?16;4
A52
16@2.@2
09.@@6360.A6<;
@2;@21

2;C6?<;:2;A.9
</720A@
.;1
3.?:2?
@B442@A6<;@
&56@
86;1
<3


A<
;
#+
:2.;@

3.?:6;4
@B442@A6<;@
6@
46C2;
/F
A52
:.056;2
92.?;6;4
.94<?6A5:@

%(
.;1
!!
=.?A
3?<:
A52@2
A205;6>B2@
A52
0<:=<;2;A

@2920A6<;
=?<02@@
6@
6;2C6A./92
&./92


699B@A?.A2@
A52
12A.69@
<3
A52


0<:=<;2;A@
B@21
6;
A56@
=?<=<@21
D<?864

46C2@
A52
@=206360

=.AA2?;
3?<:
A52
42;2?.9
@A?B0AB?2
6;
364


A<
612;A63F
A52
=9.;A
!%(
@B==<?A@
:B9A6=92
09.@@6362?
B;6A@
.00<?16;4
A<
C.?6<B@

16@2.@2


#$JJJ#$!


2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

$<6EB6BAGEB??8E
E7H<AB
,%&


B@@HA<64G<BA
G86;AB?B:<8F
*$
@B7H?8
4A7
. 




!#5'&
+5'#5'
&'06+(+%#6+10

%B==<?A
(20A<?
.056;2
%( 
6@
.
:.056;2
92.?;6;4
A205;6>B2

D5605
6@
B@21
A<
.;.9FG2
.;1
09.@@63F
A52
46C2;
=?</92:
6;
.

@B=2?C6@21
:.;;2?
&52
@B=2?C6@21
09.@@6360.A6<;
B@6;4
%(
B@2@

16332?2;A
09.@@2@
<3
16@2.@2
=.AA2?;@
.;1
92.3
=.AA2?;@
A<
09.@@63F
A52

</@2?C21
=9.;A
16@2.@2@
&56@
=?<=<@21
#$
B@2@
!%( 
&52

!%(
:.;.42@
A52
1.A.
09.@@6360.A6<;
/F
16C616;4
A52
09.@@6362?@

6;A<
@2C2?.9
@B/3B;0A6<;@
A<
@=<A
<BA
A52
16@2.@2
C.?6.A6<;@
&56@

6@
A52
.1C.;A.42
<3
12A20A6;4
C.?6<B@
92.3
16@2.@2@
+5.;4
'6
#.,
B@21
2;@2:/92
%(
!%( 
3<?
=.AA2?;
612;A6360.A6<;
3<?

0<4;6A6C2
A.@8@
612;A6360.A6<;
@
@.:2
.@
A56@
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:

B@2@
!%(
3<?
92.3
16@2.@2
=.AA2?;
612;A6360.A6<;
&52
!%(

09.@@6362@
A52
6;=BA
6:.42
=.AA2?;@
6;A<
@2C2?.9
09.@@2@
0
.;1

@B/09.@@2@
D6A5
L;M
@.:=92@
.;1
L8M
=.AA2?;@



%
=?0
0>
9+6*
4'52'%6
61
%

5+)0(-





 
38
6@
.
;<;96;2.?
4?<B=6;4
<3
82?;29@
:
86
8
0.90B9.A6;4
A52

?2@2:/9.;02@
/2AD22;
A52
A?.6;6;4
C20A<?
.
.;1
A52
46C2;
=.AA2?;

C20A<?
8
.;1
86
2?2
%+
?2=?2@2;A@
A52
6;16C61B.9
09.@@6362?
B;6A

6;
A52
:B9A6
09.@@6362?
:<1B92
D52?2
+
C.?62@
3?<:

A52
6;=BA@
<3
A52
6;16C61B.9
09.@@6362?
B;6A
%+




'( " %
  ' ( 
92.3
=.AA2?;@
&52
09.@@6362?@
%J%!
B@2@
A52
=?<1B0A6<;
?B92@




'( " %  







This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal

16@2.@2@
/.@21
<;
369A2?6;4
.==9621
<C2?
@=20A?.9
32.AB?2@
<3
A52
92.3

$ '*",!%

!%(
/.@21
6@2.@2
2A20A6<;
6:.42@
&56@
D<?8@
/2AA2?
A5.;
!%( M@
@B/09.@@6362?@

&(-,

.A.@2A 
9.@@6362?
%=96A@
%.:=92@
:


-,(-,

9.@@63621
1.A.
6;@A.;02@
 



 *(
#&-
%)&(
$'(*+(
%)&(

+$  *.
%)&(
 *
%*%) *.
%)&(




2.+6
6*'
+/#)'
&#6#
+061
57$5'65)
*
%
& #
& )*+(
%)&(






+0&
5#/2.'
&+5'#5'
+056#0%'5





%37+4'
!


(41/
'#%*
57$5'6







4'24'5'06#6+10
1(
5#/2.'
'56+/#6+10


 " 
'  (




'#40
6*'
!
5#/2.'5





'6740
6*'
5#/2.'5

 (&&%*(&##(




:'%76'
/116*'0+0)
(70%6+10
!




' ( "  ! &



 
.1)
&+564+$76+10
, )

   *(




'&1
(14
#..
1$5'48'&
.'#8'5

&*&(

 *)

&-(

64B?2

699B@A?.A2@
A52
42;2?.9
=?<02@@
<3
!%(
.;1
A52
<A52?
% *

)'#.

9.@@6362?@
6;
A52
#$
3?.:2D<?8
;
A56@
364B?2
@2;@<?@
.;1

?29.F@
.?2
@5<D;
6;
A52
5.?1D.?2
=.?A
&52
#$
2;46;2
529=@

A<
.0A6C.A2
26A52?
!%(
<?
!!
.0A6C6A62@
<;02
A52
1.A.
.?2

#))  (
% *)

?2026C21
3?<:
A52
@2;@<?@
;
.116A6<;
A52
<C2?.99
B;6A@
.?2
/

( % %

*)*

0<;A?<9921
/F
A52
?1B6;<
'!"
:<1B92
&52
=?<02@@21
1.A.
0.;

/2
@A<?21
.;FD52?2
.@
6;
09<B1
@A<?.42
9<0.9
@A<?.42
.?2.
<?


?2:<A2
1.A./.@2
&56@
1.A.
6@
.002@@6/92
3?<:
.;F
=9.02
D52;
6A
6@
<:

')
CEB68FF
9BE
6EBC
7<F84F8
@BA<GBE<A:

5<@A21
6;
A52
6;A2?;2A
1<:.6;
#?232?./9F
A52F
0.;
/2
@A<?21
6;

=<?A./92
09<B1
@A<?.42
3<?
=?<C616;4
@20B?6AF
.002@@6/696AF
$ '*",!%



+
"++
,,"'&

.C.69./696AF
.;1
2.@F
5.;196;4
A.@8@
&52
!%(
09.@@6362?
&(-,

:.42
1.A.@2A
%.:=92@

5.;192@
A52
46C2;
A2@A6;4
1.A.
B@6;4
A52
A?.6;6;4
1.A.@2A
&52
-,(-,

6@2.@2
2A20A6<;@


A?.6;6;4
1.A.@2A
0<;A.6;@
.?<B;1

92.3
=.AA2?;@
.;1

16@2.@2



0276
+/#)'

4#9
+/#)'
*#5

"
"
5+<'
9+6*


=.AA2?;@
$#0&
52'%64#.
$#0&5






#%*
+/#)'
5')/'065
#4'
9'+)*6'&
$;
%1081.76+10#.
.#;'4

&52
16@2.@2
=.AA2?;@
:.F
/29<;4
A<
@2C2?.9
16@2.@2
09.@@2@
&52
(70%6+10
#0&
(14/
6*'
0'74105

!%(
6@
.9@<
B@21
A<
612;A63F
A52
;BA?62;A@
6;
2.05
92.3



/#)'
(+.6'45
#4'
#22.+'&

+.6'45

<D2C2?
A56@
0.;
/2
.;.9FG21
/F
!!
D52;
0<:=.?21
A<



'.7
#%6+8#6+10
(70%6+10
+5
#22.+'&
10
.'#(
'.'/'065
9+6*

!%( 
=.?A
3?<:
16@2.@2
612;A6360.A6<;
!%(
529=@
A<
46C2
4'52'%6
61
#
%1/276'&
6*4'5*1.&
8#.7'


.00B?.A2
059<?<=5F99
=<A.@@6B:
.;1
;6A?<42;
92C29@
6;
=9.;A@

@



*'
&190
5#/2.+0)
12'4#6+105
*#8'
$''0
#%6+8#6'&
75+0)

@.:2
.@
22
'6
#.
,
-
B@21
C.?6<B@
AF=2@
<3
=?2160A6<;
@F@A2:@
6*'
211.+0)
241%'&74'
75+0)
52#6+#.
&'6#+.5








1/276'
%.#55'5
#0&
5%14'5
(14
&+(('4'06
.'#8'5
#0&
%4'#6'

3<?
/64
1.A.
@F@A2:@

 
5'6


#5'&
+5'#5'
'6'%6+10



4'#6'
5%14'$#5'&
&+5'#5'
5;/261/5
+0
'#%*
.'#(

!!
5.@
A5?22
16332?2;A
9.F2?@
@B05
.@
6;=BA
9.F2?
<BA=BA
9.F2?



'&1
6*'
12'4#6+105


.;1
56112;
9.F2?
.@
@.:2
.99
A52
;2B?.9
;2AD<?8@
!!
5<91

:B9A6=92
@A.42@
<3
3B;0A6<;@
.@
3<99<D

•
;=BA
#5.@2

•
<;C<9BA6<;
#5.@2

•
2A20A<?
#5.@2


•
#<<96;4
#5.@2
64 !!
%A?B0AB?2

•
!<?:.96G.A6<;
#5.@2

•
"BA=BA
#5.@2
&52
:.6;
.6:
6@
A<
BA696G2
A52
:2A.09.@@6362?
.0A6C6A62@
<3
!%(

!!
?21B02@
A52
;2B?.9
0<;;20A6<;@
.;1
0<:=92E6AF
<3
A52
.;1
!!
3<?
12A20A6;4
:B9A6=92
92.3
16@2.@2@
&52
:<A6C.A6<;
<3

;2AD<?8
3B;0A6<;@
A<
6;0?2.@2
=2?3<?:.;02
2E20BA6<;
94<?6A5:
A56@
D<?8
962@
6;
A52
B@.42
<3
/.@21
A?.6;21
09.@@6362?@
B;6A@
<3


12@0?6/2@
!!/.@21
0?<=
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
.568.?
'6
#.
,
-
/<A5
!%(
.;1
!!

<;
1<A
@=<A@
612;A6360.A6<;@
&52@2

B@21
!!
3<?
=?2160A6;4
.;1
?20<4;6G6;4
A52
0?<=
F6291
6;
A52
09.@@6362?@
529=
A<
0.A24<?6G2
:B9A6=92
1<A
@=<A@
B;12?
:B9A6=92

.4?60B9AB?2
9.;1@
&56@
:<A6C.A2@
A52
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:
A<
B@2
!!
09.@@2@
D5605
6@
.;
2336062;A
D.F
<3
12A20A6;4
A52
16@2.@2

3<?
16@2.@2
=?2160A6<;
6;
A52
92.C2@
<:=.?21
A<
%(
.;1
09.@@6360.A6<;
&52
:.6;
.1C.;A.42
<3
B@6;4
!%(
6@
=?<C616;4

!%( 
!!
B@2@
A?.6;21
;2B?<;
3B;0A6<;@
.;1
9.F2?@
<3
369A2?@
@B/
09.@@6362?@
3<?
C.?6<B@
292:2;A
=?<=2?A62@
BA
A56@
6@
96:6A21
6;

3<?
6@<9.A6;4
16332?2;A
16@2.@2
@20A<?@
D6A5
5645>B.96AF
?.A2
&52

.@=20A@
;
.1C.;02
!!
6@
B@21
D6A5
:B9A6
369A2?6;4

3<99<D6;4
.94<?6A5:
6@
=?<=<@21
B@6;4
!!
D5605
12A20A@
A52
0<:=<;2;A@


2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
&52
6:.42
@24:2;A.A6<;
2142
12A20A6<;
.;1
12;<6@6;4
=?<02@@2@

<3
A52
0?<=
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
@F@A2:
.?2
6:=92:2;A21
B@6;4

&
A<<9
&52
.;1?<61
@AB16<
6@
B@21
A<
12C29<=
.;

.==960.A6<;
6;
:</692
=5<;2
3<?
@B002@@3B9
:<;6A<?6;4
<3
16@2.@2@

.;1
1206@6<;:.86;4
=?<02@@2@
;
.116A6<;
A<
A52@2
A<<9@
A52

:60?<=?<02@@<?
B@2@
.;
6;/B69A
<=2?.A6;4
@F@A2:
A5.A
4<C2?;@
A52

1.A.
4.A52?21
3?<:
16332?2;A
@2;@<?@
;
!!
:P:
;2B?.9

;2AD<?8
9.F2?@
.?2
3<99<D21
/F
.
0<;C<9BA6<;.9
9.F2?
<?
369A2?
@

D6A5
3P3
16:2;@6<;
A52
<BA=BA
<3
A52
0<;C<9BA6<;.9
9.F2?
6@

:O3

P
:O3

2?2
A52
=?2;<;96;2.?6AF
6@
12;<A21
.@
=078

&52
D2645A21
369A2?
0<:=<;2;A@
.?2
0<:=BA21
3<?
=?20216;4
;2B?.9

9.F2?@
.@


 "

 & #$
 
' ! (' ! (




Things Journal
;
.116A6<;
364B?2

/
46C2@
.;<A52?
<BA0<:2
D5605
369A2?21
A52

92.3
6:.42@
&56@
369A2?@
A52
;<6@2
1.A.
F
0<:=.?6;4
A52
A?.6;6;4

@2A@
<3
A52@2
86;1@
<3
92.C2@
!%(
.;1
!!
612;A63F
A52

16@2.@2
AF=2
64B?2
.
=?<C612@
.
/6;.?F
6:.42
A<
612;A63F
A52

2E.0A
92.C2@
=<?A6<;
6;
A52
6:.42
&52;
A52
0<9<?
2;5.;02:2;A

529=@
A<
6:=?<C2
A52
0<;A?.@A
<3
A52
6:.42
A<
6;0?2.@2
A52
C6@B.9

6;A2?=?2A.A6<;
<3
A52
6:.42
64B?2

/
&52
?1B6;<
'!"

0<;A?<992?
.;1
A52
@2;@<?
B;6A@
.?2
699B@A?.A21
D6A5
A52
16@=9.F

:<1B92@
64B?2

46C2@
A52
?2.16;4
<3
A52
A2:=2?.AB?2
@2;@<?

29@6B@
.;1
A52
5B:616AF
@2;@<?

B;6A@
D6A5
?2@=20A
A<
A52

16332?2;A
0?<=9.;1@
&52
?2.16;4@
<3
A52
@2;@<?
C.?F
3?<:
36291A<
36291
&56@
86;1
<3
.@@6@A.;A@56=
529=@
A<
09.?63F
A52
2;C6?<;:2;A.9

6@@B2@
<3
A52
0?<=
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:



+#



%%
'**

&!"
$# 
#!
'"
"
#!"


BAIB?HG<BA
K



'BB?<A:
K


BAIB?HG<BA
K



'BB?<A:
K


BAIB?HG<BA
K




BAIB?HG<BA
K






BAIB?HG<BA
K


4




















































5


<:

@4:8
E86E84G<BA
4
%B<F8
6B899<6<8AGF
5
<?G8E87
&HGCHG

&52;
!!
B@2@
.
;<;96;2.?
3B;0A6<;

: ,-@: ,-











2
@B?2
A5.A
A52
@F:/<9@
6;
F<B?
2>B.A6<;
5.C2
/22;
1236;21

2?2
Q
K;<;96;2.?
3B;0A6<;
E078369A2?@
.==9621
3<?
6;=BA
92.3

@2>B2;02@
&52
0<;C<9BA6<;
.;1
=<<96;4
=5.@2@
.?2
12@64;21
B@6;4


369A2?@
:.E6:B:
.@
46C2;
6;
A./92

B?A52?
&./92


699B@A?.A2@
A52
12A.69@
<3
A52
;2B?.9
9.F2?@
369A2?
@6G2@
.;1
05.;;29@

B@21
A<
?20<;@A?B0A
A52
@=20A?.9
6:.42@
<3
A52
92.C2@
.A
5645
6;A2;@6AF
92C29@

(
$%'&%

&52
6;=BA
6:.42
<3
.
92.3
6@
46C2;
D6A5
$
@=20A?.9
6;3<?:.A6<;

&52
5645@=20A?.9
6:.42
A.82;
/F
F%=2E
0.:2?.
6@
0<;C2?A21


6;A<
6A@
2>B6C.92;A
4?.F@0.92
6:.42

<3
A52
1.A.
3?<:
A52
4






















































5


1.A.@2A
6@
B@21
3<?
A?.6;6;4
=B?=<@2
.;1
A52
?2:.6;6;4

6@
B@21
<:

@4:8
8A;4A68@8AG
4
<A4EL
@4:8
5
B?BE8A;4A687
<@4:8

3<?
A2@A6;4
=B?=<@2

64B?2

?2=?2@2;A@
A52
92C29
<3
A2:=2?.AB?2
5B:616AF
6;
16332?2;A

.4?60B9AB?2
36291@
&52
A2:=2?.AB?2
.;1
A52
5B:616AF
<3
A52
36291
6@
96;2.?
A<
2.05
<A52?
64B?2

699B@A?.A2@
A52
12320A@
6;
=9.;A
92.C2@

1.?8
@5.12@
.;1
1<A
@=<A@



+&

*&
"!
%$"

)&
4
































































5

<:
 ACHG
<@4:8
C4GG8EAF 4
<I8A
)
<@4:8
5E4L*64?8
<@4:8

(&
  


"#
64B?2
.
699B@A?.A2@
.;
$
@=20A?.9
6:.42
<3
A52
92.C2@
.;1

'& 


"2#
364B?2
/
12=60A@
.
4?.F@0.92
6:.42
<3
A52
92.C2@
;
A52
4?.F
@0.92
6:.42
A52
1<A@
6;
92.C2@
.?2
@=<AA21
092.?9F
A5.;
A52
/.@60

&
@=20A?.9
C62D
64B?2

.
@5<D@
A52
;<6@2
0<2336062;A@
<3
.
46C2;






6:.42
D5605
46C2@
B;D.;A21
12=60A6<;
6;
.;
6:.42
&56@
=5.@2

!$#$!
"
529=@
A<
612;A63F
A52
92.C2@
.9<;2
6;
A52
6:.42
B?A52?
A52@2
;<6@2

<:

*4@C?8
F8AFBE
E847<A:F

0<2336062;A@
.?2
B@21
3<?
12;<6@6;4
A52
6:.42

2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal


   
 

'.&&
$!

""
"#"

',&&
'*&&
'(&&
'&&&
.&&
,&&
*&&
(&&
&


+& '&& '+& (&& (+& )&& <:

BAA86G<BA
B9
@BA<GBE<A:
FLFG8@

$!

#"

<:

8986GF
<78AG<9<64G<BA
64B?2


?2=?2@2;A@
A52
0<;;20A6<;@
<3
A52
.4?60B9AB?2
:<;6A<?6;4

@F@A2:
&2:=2?.AB?2
@2;@<?
@<69
:<6@AB?2
@2;@<?
.;1
9645A

&?B2
=<@6A6C2
.;1
3.9@2
;24.A6C2
.?2
.00B?.A2
1206@6<;@
&56@
6;A2;@6AF
@2;@<?
&52F
.?2
0<;;20A21
.;1
A52
@64;.9@
.?2
.:=963621

:2.;@
A?B2
=<@6A6C2
?232?@
A<
A52
12A20A6<;
<3
16@2.@2
.;1
3.9@2 .;1
@2;A
3<?
:.;6=B9.A2
A<
A52
?1B6;<
0<;A?<992?
B;6A

6@
B@21

;24.A6C2
@A.A2@
A52
@B002@@3B9
12A20A6<;
<3
.
16@2.@292@@
92.3
;
A<
16@=9.F
A52
C.9B2@
3?<:
A52
@2;@<?@
%
6@
B@21
A<
@2;1
A52

0<;A?.@A
A?B2
;24.A6C2
699B@A?.A2@
A52
16@2.@2
D52?2
A52
92.3
5.@
;<
.92?A
:2@@.42
A<
A52
3.?:2?


16@2.@2


@
@.:2
.@
3.9@2=<@6A6C2
46C2@
.
3.9@2
.9.?:
3<?
16@2.@2
12A20A6<;
 #& $!& !"
&52
C.?6.A6<;@
<3
!!
.;1
!%(
D6A5
?2@=20A
A<
A526?
.00B?.0F

!!
#!"


.;1
?20.99
?.A2
?2@=20A6C29F
&56@
@5<D@
A5.A
!!
46C2@
/2AA2?

?2@B9A@
A5.;
!%( 
&52
;2.?2@A
46C2@
.
:<12?.A2
!
09.@@6360.A6<;
?.A2
0<:=.?21
A<
A52
<A52?
AD<
=?<=<@21
A205;6>B2@

;
A56@
:.;;2?
A./92

=?<C612@
.
0<:=.?6@<;
/2AD22;
!!

!%( 
.;1
;2.?2@A
09.@@6360.A6<;
A205;6>B2@
&52
A205;6>B2@

@B05
.@
!.HC2
.F2@8;2.?2@A
.;1
<A52?
0<;C2;A6<;.9
.==?<.052@

.?2
0<:=.?21
A<
A52
!!
.;1
!%( 
D52?2
A52
9.A2?


.==?<.052@
B@2
:B9A6=92
@B/09.@@6360.A6<;
9.F2?@
.;1
@=20A?.9

32.AB?2@/.@21
369A2?@
<?2<C2?
A52@2
A205;6>B2@
.?2
;<A
:<?2

0<:=92E
A<
0?2.A2
<C2?52.1
6;
A6;F
<&
12C602@
A
6@
C2?F
 
"  &" %
6:=<?A.;A
A<
12A20A
16@2.@2@
3?<:
92.C2@
B@6;4
564592C29
@=20A?.9
 $"
&"
32.AB?2@
.;1
:<?2
@B/
09.@@6362?@
A5.;
:<?2
0<:=92E6AF



<:

(H4?<GL
$84FHE8@8AGF



+# 


(,# +0
$*,)$%+*
64B?2

=?<C612@
A52
C.?6<B@
>B.96AF
:2.@B?2:2;A@
6;
A2?:@
<3


*'*%&
,*"+

?20.99
@2;@6A6C6AF
@=2063606AF
.;1
=?206@6<;
3<?
C.?6<B@

!&")-+
$$
(""",1
-*1
(*"+"'&
A205;6>B2@
64B?2@


.;1


12@0?6/2
A52
=2?3<?:.;02
.;1
A52

!%(
 



0<:=.?.A6C2
.;.9F@6@
<3
C.?6<B@

A205;6>B2@
.;1
!%(

A205;6>B2
64B?2


699B@A?.A2@
A52
./@<9BA2
2??<?
?.A2
6;
92.3

!!


 

 

=.AA2?;
?20<4;6A6<;
64B?2


12=60A@
A52
0<:=BA.A6<;
<C2?52.1

8;2.?2@A
 

 


0?2.A21
/F
2.05

.;1

A205;6>B2
;
A56@
0<:=.?6@<;
!!



.;1
!%(
=2?3<?:
;<A./9F
#.?A60B9.?9F
!%(
23320A6C29F

&52
?2@B9A@
.?2
0<:=.?21
D6A5
A52
2E6@A6;4
A205;6>B2@
,
-
A<

12A20A@
A52
92.3
=.AA2?;@
A
A52
@.:2
A6:2
!!
12A20A@
A52
92.3

2C.9B.A2
A52
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:
=2?3<?:.;02
&52
2E6@A6;4
@F@A2:

=.AA2?;@
.;1
16@2.@2
@=<A@
D6A5
:6;6:.9
2??<?@
&52
?2.@<;
6@
A5.A

B@2@
!%(
.;1
.B@@6.;
:<129@
3<?
=.AA2?;
612;A6360.A6<;
D6A5

!!
6@
:.6;9F
6:=92:2;A21
3<?
6:.42
=.AA2?;
?20<4;6A6<;

A52
A.@8
2C.9B.A6<;
;
A526?
:<129@
A52F
B@21
.
96:6A21
@2A
<3

=B?=<@2


=.AA2?;@
.;1
.==9621

A205;6>B2@
<;9F
BA
A52
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:

12.9@
D6A5
/<A5

.;1

A205;6>B2@
;
.116A6<;
:<@A
<3
A52

A205;6>B2@
0<;@612?
<3396;2
1.A.@2A@
BA
A52
=?<=<@21
@F@A2:

A.82@
A52
?2.9A6:2
@2;@<?
1.A.
A<
4.6;
?2.9
2336062;0F

2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal

() D6A5
2.05
<A52?
3<?
2;@B?6;4
A52
?2.9A6:2
.==960.A6<;
<3
A52

(' 6;A299642;A
0?<=
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
;
A52
3BAB?2
A56@
D<?8

'/ 6@
A<
/2
2EA2;121
B@6;4
.
5B42
1.A.@2A
<3
:B9A6=92
=9.;A@
.;1
6A@

=.?A@
B@6;4
A52
122=
92.?;6;4
.==?<.052@




$

'-
'+
') $)%

'' 23
)4B
)
% 

*E<7;4E

 
!4AH4EL
B+
54F87
F@4EG
6EBC9<8?7

@BA<GBE<A:
4A7
4HGB@4G<BA
<EE<:4G<BA
FLFG8@
A

 

.$
.3%1.!3)/.!,

/ /.&%1%.#%
/.
.5%.3)5%
823%-2
!.$
/.31/,

CC



- 
*E88>4AG;4

" 
"4IL4

$
 
!4AH4EL
:E<6H?GHE4?
6EBC

+ @BA<GBE<A:
HF<A:
&+4
FGH7L
A

 
3(
.3%1.!3)/.!,
/.&%1%.#%
/.

.3%,,)'%.3
823%-2
!.$
/.31/,

CC



'&& (&& )&& *&& +&&

)4L
'
'
 
AG8EA8G
B9
G;<A:F
9BE
F@4EG
4:E<6H?GHE8
+86;AB?B:<8F




 CE46G<68F
4A7
9HGHE8
7<E86G<BA
/41.!,
/&
-")%.3
.3%,,)'%.#%
!.$
-!13

.5)1/.-%.32

 


  !  
$4E=4A<
$ 
%4F4EH77<A
 
4A<
 
"4E<@
 
4F;8@


+ 
*<77<D4

   
   
04DBB5

 
<:
B+
74G4
4A4?LG<6F
4E6;<G86GHE8
BCCBEGHA<G<8F


4A7
BC8A
E8F84E6;
6;4??8A:8F

##%22

  


)4=8FJ4E<
* 
*HG;8A7E4A
" 
)4=4>H@4E
"
 
!HA8

F@4EG

4:E<6H?GHE4?
@B78?
5L
<AG8:E4G<A:
B+
@B5<?8
4A7
6?BH754F87
5<:
74G4

64


??<?
$.A2
4A4?LG<6F
A

 
.3%1.!3)/.!,
/.&%1%.#%
/.
.3%,,)'%.3
/-043).'
!.$

/.31/,



CC



23
$4;74I<A8=47
$
* 
)8MI4A
$ 
4E8>4G4<A
$ 
7<5<
' 
4EA4:;<
' 

/
*;8G;

'
 
$46;<A8
?84EA<A:
9BE
AG8EA8G
B9
+;<A:F
74G4
4A4?LF<F

 



$

. 
FHEI8L
)')3!,
/--4.)#!3)/.2
!.$
%36/1+2



23
+MBHA<F
 
"4GFBH?4F
% 
4EGM4A4F
+ 
"<GG4F

 
AG8EA8G
B9

- +;<A:F
<A
4:E<6H?GHE8
E868AG
47I4A68F
4A7
9HGHE8
6;4??8A:8F
)/2823%-2

.').%%1).'



, 23
#88
$ 

J4A:
! 
0B8

 
868@58E
:E<6H?GHE4?
CEB7H6G<BA

FLFG8@
54F87
BA
B+
A

 

3(
.3%1.!3)/.!,
/.&%1%.#%
/.

+ /-043!3)/.!,
#)%.#%
!.$
.').%%1).'
CC



23
/H
! 
1;4A:
! 
1;8A:
/ 
.8<
/ 

4A
!
 
*8CG8@58E
.<E8?8FF

* F8AFBEF
<A
94E@?4A7
8AI<EBA@8AG4?
@BA<GBE<A:
A


.3%1.!3)/.!,

/.&%1%.#%
/.
8"%1.!",%$
)231)"43%$
/-043).'
!.$
./6,%$'%

) )2#/5%18
CC
 


23
)4L
'
'
 

FHEI8L
BA
AG8EA8G
B9
+;<A:F
4E6;<G86GHE8F
/41.!,
/&

( ).'
!4$
.)5%12)38/-043%1
!.$
.&/1-!3)/.
#)%.#%2



'&& (&& )&& *&& +&& 23
&=;4
+ 
$<FE4
* 
)4:;HJ4AF;<
%
*
 
.<E8?8FF
F8AFBE
A8GJBE>F

9BE
4:E<6H?GHE8
+;8
FG4G8B9G;84EG
<A
CE46G<68
4A7
9HGHE8




 6;4??8A:8F
/-043%12
!.$
,%#31/.)#2
).
'1)#4,341%




  !  2 3
#88
! 
#4C<E4
 
4:;8E<
 

"4B


 
)868AG
47I4A68F
4A7

GE8A7F
<A
CE87<6G<I8
@4AH946GHE<A:
FLFG8@F
<A
5<:
74G4

   
  8AI<EBA@8AG
!.4&!#341).'
,%33%12




23
*E<A<I4FH?H
' 
45H
$
* 
-8A>4G
) 

)4=8F;
"
 
CE<?
?BH7

F8EI<68BE<8AG87
4E6;<G86GHE8
*B
9BE
4:E<6H?GHE8
G;EBH:;
<AG8EA8G
B9

G;<A:F
 B+
4A7
5<:
74G4
A

 

.3%1.!3)/.!,
/.&%1%.#%
/.

64


<:=BA.A6<;
"C2?52.1
,%#31)#!,
.2314-%.3!3)/.
!.$
/--4.)#!3)/.
.').%%1).'
CC




64B?2


?2C2.9@
A52
0<:=BA.A6<;
<C2?52.1
<3
.99
A52
A205;6>B2@
23
4;<>4E
*
* 

)B78
*
-
 
:E<6H?GHE4?
6EBC
L<8?7
CE87<6G<BA

HF<A:
4EG<9<6<4?
A8HE4?
A8GJBE>
4CCEB46;
.3%1.!3)/.!,
*/41.!,
/&
)../5!3)5%

;
A56@
0<:=.?6@<;
!!
=?<1B02@
96AA92
:<?2
<C2?52.1
A5.;
1%2%!1#(
).
%,%#31)#!,
%,%#31/.)#2
).2314-%.3!3)/.
!.$
#/.31/,

!%(
.;1
<A52?
A205;6>B2@
@
!!
6@
.

;2AD<?8
6A
5.@
%.').%%1).'


 4;:4
 
$47<F8GG<
-
 
.3%1.%3
/&

:<?2
0<:=92E
369A2?
3B;0A6<;@
A5.;
<A52?
@F@A2:@
BA
A52
;221
3<?
().'2

(!.$2/.
!001/!#(
-CG

23
*;4<>;

" 
18474??L
* 
KCBF<GB

 
A45?<A:
G86;AB?B:<8F
9BE

2336062;0F
6@
6:=<?A.;A
6;
16@2.@2
612;A6360.A6<;
&5B@
A52
<C2?52.1
:E88A
<AG8EA8G
B9
G;<A:F

823%-2
/41.!,
 


0.;
/2
64;<?21
"A52?
A205;6>B2@
@B05
.@
;2.?2@A
%( 
23
1;4A:
! 
0<A
1 

.4A:
)
 
'4GG8EA
6?4FF<9<64G<BA
B9

.F2@6.;
;2AD<?8
.;1
!.HC2
.F2@
=?<1B02
96:6A21
<C2?52.1
<AFG4AG4A8BHF
6B:A<G<I8
G4F>?B47
G;EBH:;
$$
6?HFG8E<A:

<D2C2?
A52F
9.08
6;
.00B?.0F
?.A2

&52
2C.9B.A6<;
=?<02@@
6@
?4C?46<4A8<:8A@4C
4A7
8AF8@5?8
*-$F

31!.2!#3)/.2
/.

#/-043!3)/.!,
")/,/'8
!.$
")/).&/1-!3)#2



2E=2?6:2;A21
3<?
6;0?2.@6;4
A52
;B:/2?
<3
92.3
@.:=92@

23
*4@H8?
' 
*H554<L4A
* 
4?HF4@L

8G
4?

+86;A<64?
*HEI8L
BA

AG8??<:8AG
&CG<@<M4G<BA
EBHC<A:
?:BE<G;@F
9BE
<A<G8
*G4G8
HGB@4G4
<A

(
&%#,* &%
88C
'46>8G
AFC86G<BA
1#(
/-043!3
%3(/$2

.'


;GGCF

7B< BE:
 
F M

&52
#$
@F@A2:
D.@
6:=92:2;A21
A<
=?<C612
/<A5
23
+8?<>4A<
 
4A7B@<

 
*;4;54;E4@<
 
8;>BE7<
$
%
  

2;C6?<;:2;A.9
</@2?C.;02/.@21
0?<=
16@2.@2
:<;6A<?6;4
@F@A2:
'E<I46LCE8F8EI<A:
<A
4FFB6<4G<BA
EH?8
@<A<A:
HF<A:
4A
<@CEBI87
7<F6E8G8

5<A4EL
4EG<9<6<4?
588
6B?BAL
70%13
823%-2
6)3(
00,)#!3)/.2



;
A56@
D<?8
<&
6;3?.@A?B0AB?2@
D2?2
12=9<F21
A<
:<;6A<?
.;1
23
"4F<A4G;4A
 
!4L4>H@4E
* 
4A7B@<

 
)4@46;4A7E4A
$ 
BA:

0.=AB?2
A52
92.3
6:.42@
6;
5F=2?@=20A?.9
:<12@
&52
5F=2?@=20A?.9
*
! 
'4G4A
)
 
HGB@4G87

?HA:
GH@BE
78G86G<BA
4A7

6:.42@
<3
A52
92.C2@
D2?2
=?<02@@21
A<
A?.08
A52
16@2.@2
=<6;A@
6?4FF<9<64G<BA
5L
4A
46G<I8
6BAGBHE
@B78?
4A7
%%
6?4FF<9<8E
70%13

823%-2
6)3(
00,)#!3)/.2


 

&52@2
6:.42@
D2?2
@A<?21
6;
09<B1
@A<?.42
@F@A2:@
A<
/2
5.;1921


/F
!%(
.;1
!!
!!
.;1
!%(
D2?2
B@21
A<
A?.6;
A52
-,!'*+
"' *(!1

<&
6;3?.@A?B0AB?2@
A<
12A20A
A52
C.?6<B@
AF=2@
<3
92.3
16@2.@2@
;

.116A6<;
A52
<A52?

A205;6>B2@
@B05
.@
;2.?2@A
.F2@6.;

!.HC2
.F2@
.;1
0<;C2;A6<;.9
%(
A205;6>B2@
D2?2
0<:=.?21

2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/JIOT.2021.3072908, IEEE Internet of
Things Journal

&#!
E868<I87
;8E
$ 
78:E88
<A
B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
4A7
!


 
<F
4
'EB98FFBE
B9
4G4
*6<8A68
4A7
4A
)

A:<A88E<A:
*;8
<F
6HEE8AG?L
JBE><A:
4F
4A
FF<FG4AG
)
8??BJ
4G
G;8
46H?GL
B9
A:<A88E<A:

A9BE@4G<BA

'EB98FFBE
<A
*6;BB?
B9
B@CHG<A:
*6<8A68
4A7
A:<A88E<A:
+86;AB?B:L
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
+86;AB?B:L
*L7A8L
'E<BE
GB

4G
4?:BG<4F
,A<I8EF<GL
*;8
;4F
CH5?<F;87
E8CHG87


*
=B<A<A:
,+*
'EB9
4A7B@<
J4F
4A
FF<FG4AG
'EB98FFBE
4G
G;8

=BHEA4?F
*6BCHF
<A78K87
=BHEA4?F
4A7
4?FB
CE8F8AG87
*6;BB?
B9
HF<A8FF
*G8I8AF
AFG<GHG8
B9
+86;AB?B:L
,*
4A7

C4C8EF
<A
%4G<BA4?
AG8EA4G<BA4?
BA98E8A68F
CH5?<F;87
5BB>
4
7<FG<A:H<F;87
E8F84E6;
98??BJ
<A
&%
68AG8E
$<6;<:4A

6;4CG8EF
<A
)
'E8FF

:?B54?
*CE<A:8E

?F8I<8E
4A7
*G4G8
,A<I8EF<GL
,*
'EB9
4A7B@<
;4F
CH5?<F;87
BI8E
GJB

4?FB
;4I8
87<G87
5BB>F
<A
J<?8L
4A7
)
CE8FF
4L4G;E<
;4F
;HA7E87
=BHEA4?
C4C8EF
4A7
F8I8A
5BB>F
J;<6;
6B??86G<I8?L
;4I8
588A
6<G87


A7<4A
C4G8AGF

HFGE4?<4A
'4G8AG
*;8
<F
4
:H8FG
87<GBE
9BE
)868AG
'4G8AGF
BA


G<@8F
<A78K


8
;4F
588A
A4@87
4F
BA8
B9
G;8
@BFG
<A9?H8AG<4?

B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
8E
E8F84E6;
<AG8E8FGF
<A6?H78
<:74G4
A4?LG<6F
B+
4A7
F6<8AG<9<6
@<A7
4A7
<:;?L
<G87
)8F84E6;8E
GBC

CH5?<64G<BAF
4A7
 

A8GJBE>F
*;8
<F
4A
46G<I8
E8I<8J8E
<A
8AG;4@
*6<8A68
!BHEA4?
$B5<?8
%8GJBE>F
E8F84E6;8EF
9BE
9BHE
6BAF86HG<I8
L84EF


GB



8
4?FB
E4A>87
G;
<A
'

4A7
CC?<64G<BAF
KC8EG
FLFG8@F
J<G;
4CC?<64G<BAF
*HFG4<A45?8
B@CHG<A:


E8F84E6;8EF
8
;4F
F8EI87
4F
4FFB6<4G8

A9BE@4G<6F
4A7
*LFG8@F

AG8EA8G
B9
+;<A:F
KC8EG
FLFG8@F

"
$!
E868<I87
;<F

+86;
78:E88
<A
B@CHG8E

*6<8A68
4A7
A:<A88E<A:
9EB@
AA4
,A<I8EF<GL
;8AA4<
<A
G;8

L84E

5<5?<B:E4C;L
4@BA:
@BE8
G;4A

87<GBE
87<GBE
4A7
:H8FG
87<GBE
<A
F8I8E4?
CE8FG<:<BHF
=BHEA4?F
FH6;
4F

B9


+
4A7

B+!
'EB9
4A7B@<
<F
46G<I8
<A
78?<I8E<A:
>8LABG8F
4A7
<AI<G87

G4?>F
<F
E8F84E6;
<AG8E8FGF
4E8
:?B54?
BCG<@<F4G<BA
4A7
5<:
74G4
4A4?LG<6F
HF<A:

@46;<A8
?84EA<A:
4A7
8IB?HG<BA4EL
6B@CHG4G<BAF
<A
C4EG<6H?4E




8
E868<I87
;<F
$ 
78:E88
<A
B@CHG8E
*6<8A68

4A7
A:<A88E<A:
9EB@
AA4
,A<I8EF<GL
;8AA4<
<A
G;8
L84E



HEE8AG?L
;8
<F
JBE><A:
4F
4A
FF<FG4AG
'EB98FFBE
<A

*6;BB?
B9
B@CHG<A:
*6<8A68
4A7
A:<A88E<A:
4G
4?:BG<4F

,A<I8EF<GL
8
;4F
CH5?<F;87
E8CHG87


*
=BHEA4?F


*6BCHF
<A78K87
=BHEA4?F4A7
4?FB
CE8F8AG87
C4C8E
<A

%4G<BA4?
AG8EA4G<BA4?
BA98E8A68F
CH5?<F;87
5BB>
6;4CG8EF
<A
)
'E8FF


:?B54?
*CE<A:8E

?F8I<8E
4A7
4?FB
;4I8
87<G87
5BB>F
<A
J<?8L
4A7
)
CE8FF

)4>8F;
;4F
F<K
A7<4A
C4G8AGF
<F
E8F84E6;
<AG8E8FGF
<A6?H78
<:74G4
A4?LG<6F

B+
4A7
A8GJBE>F4A7
6?BH7
6B@CHG<A:

8
<F
4A
46G<I8
E8I<8J8E
<A
8AG;4@

*6<8A68
!BHEA4?
$B5<?8
%8GJBE>F
4A7
CC?<64G<BAF
KC8EG
FLFG8@F
J<G;

4CC?<64G<BAF
*HFG4<A45?8
B@CHG<A:
A9BE@4G<6F
4A7
*LFG8@F

AG8EA8G
B9

+;<A:F
KC8EG
FLFG8@F

'%#
<F
4A
FF<FG4AG
'EB98FFBE
<A
G;8
8C4EG@8AG
B9

B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
4A7
A:<A88E<A:
-8?4:4CH7<

)4@4>E<F;A4
*<77;4EG;4
A:<A88E<A:
B??8:8
-<=4L4J474

A7<4
F<A68


BE@8E
FF<FG4AG
'EB98FFBE
4G
F6;BB?
B9

6B@CHG<A:
F6<8A68
4A7
8A:<A88E<A:
4?:BG<4F
,A<I8EF<GL

%)
8?;<
A7<4A
9EB@


E
)<MJ4A
<F
6B@C?8G87

;<F
'; 
B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
4A7
A:<A88E<A:
<A


4G

F6;BB?
B9
6B@CHG8E
F6<8A68
4A7
8A:<A88E<A:
- +
,A<I8EF<GL

-8??BE8
+4@<?
%47H
A7<4A
4A7

+86;
4A7
$
+86;
6B@C?8G87
E8FC86G<I8?L




4A7


BA
!4J4;4E?4?
%8;EH
+86;AB?B:<64?
,A<I8EF<GL
A4AG4CHE
A7<4
E

)<MJ4A
;4F
CH5?<F;87
E8CHG87


*
=BHEA4?F
4A7

9E88
*6BCHF
<A78K87
=BHEA4?F

4A7
4?FB
CE8F8AG87
C4C8E
<A
%4G<BA4?
AG8EA4G<BA4?
BA98E8A68F
CH5?<F;87
5BB>

6;4CG8EF
<A
)
'E8FF

:?B54?
?F8I<8E
4A7
7<G87
4F
5BB>F
E
)<MJ4A
;4F

G8A
A7<4A
C4G8AGF
BA8
,*
C4G8AG

E
)<MJ4A
<F
4
:H8FG
87<GBE
9BE
AG8EA4G<BA4?

!BHEA4?
B9
E<7
4A7
,G<?<GL
B@CHG<A:
 A78EF6<8A68
)868AG
'4G8AGF
BA
B@CHG8E

*6<8A68
A9BE@4G<BA
$87<64?
,A?B6>
?F8I<8E
%8HE4?
B@CHG<A:
4A7

CC?<64G<BAF
*CE<A:8E
E
)<MJ4A
E868<I87
4J4E7
9EB@
JBE?7
E8F84E6;
6BHA6<?

4A7
@8E<64A
@87<64?
BHA6<?
<A
G;8
G<G?8
B9
<AABI4G<I8
E8F84E6;8E
BA
<:
4G4

4A7
B+
9BE
L84E





$#$!
6B@C?8G87
;<F
'; 
<A
A9BE@4G<BA
4A7

6B@@HA<64G<BA
A:<A88E<A:
<A
AA4
,A<I8EF<GL
;8AA4<
<A

G;8
L84E



8
6B@C?8G87
$4FG8E
B9
A:<A88E<A:
<A
G;8
9<8?7

B9
<:<G4?
6B@@HA<64G<BA
4A7
%8GJBE>
A:<A88E<A:
<A

"4@4E4=
,A<I8EF<GL



8
6B@C?8G87
;<F
46;8?BE
B9

A:<A88E<A:
HA78E
;4E4G;<74F4A
,A<I8EF<GL

*
8
<F

CE8F8AG?L
JBE><A:
4F
FFB6<4G8
'EB98FFBE
<A
8C4EG@8AG
B9

A9BE@4G<BA
+86;AB?B:L
4G
+;<4:4E4=4E
B??8:8
B9

A:<A88E<A:
$47HE4<
A7<4

8
;4F
CH5?<F;87
I4E<BHF
DH4?<GL
C4C8EF
<A
G;8

E8CHG87
=BHEA4?F
<F
@4<A
G;EHFG
E8F84E6;
4E84F
4E8
.<E8?8FF
%8GJBE>
$B5<?8

B@@HA<64G<BA
7;B6
%8GJBE>F



 $

"
$ON#$O
E868<I87
G;8
 *

4A7
$ *
78:E88F
<A
@4G;8@4G<6F
9EB@
G;8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9

+8;E4A
+8;E4A
E4A
4A7
G;8
$ *
4A7
'; 
78:E88F
<A

FG4G<FG<6F
9EB@
G;8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
4?<9BEA<4
4G
8E>8?8L

8E>8?8L

,*
8
<F
4
6B9BHA78E
4A7
4
'EB98FFBE
J<G;

G;8
8C4EG@8AG
B9
HF<A8FF
AG8??<:8A68
4A7
A4?LG<6F
4A7
4

'EB98FFBE
J<G;
G;8
8C4EG@8AG
B9
B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
*G8I8AF

AFG<GHG8
B9
+86;AB?B:L
B5B>8A
%!
,*
8
;4F
BI8E

L84EF
B9
<A7HFGEL
4A7

HA<I8EF<GL
8KC8E<8A68
4F
4
'EB98FFBE
4
)8F84E6;8E
4A
FF<FG4AG
;<89
*6<8AG<FG
4A

K86HG<I8
<E86GBE
4
<FG<A:H<F;87
$8@58E
B9
+86;A<64?
*G499
4
+86;AB?B:L

#8478E
4
;4<E@4A
B9
8C4EG@8AG
4A7
G;8
84A
B9
*6;BB?
J<G;
8??
#45BE4GBE<8F

$HEE4L
<??
%!
,*
++
*;4AABA
#45FN)8F84E6;
?BE;4@
'4E>
%!
,*

G;8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
4?<9BEA<4
4G
8E>8?8L
+;8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
+8K4F
4G
HFG<A
HFG<A

+/
,*
G;8
*;4E<9
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
+86;AB?B:L
+8;E4A
G;8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
+8;E4A

%8J
0BE>
,A<I8EF<GL
%8J
0BE>
%0
,*
4A7
G;8
*G8I8AF
AFG<GHG8
B9

+86;AB?B:L

2327-4662 (c) 2021 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Cape Town. Downloaded on May 18,2021 at 18:47:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.