Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROJECT REPORT ON
“A STUDY ON IMPACT OF
IMPLEMENTATION OF GOODS AND
SERVICE TAX AMONG RETAILERS IN
WARORA CITY”
SUBMITTED TO
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Date:
( Principal )
DR. AMBEDKAR COLLEGE OF
ARTS, COMMERCE AND SCIENCE
CHANDRAPUR
DR. AMBEDKAR COLLEGE OF ARTS, COMMERCE AND
SCIENCE, CHANDRAPUR
CERTIFICATE
Date:
( Head of department )
DR. AMBEDKAR COLLEGE OF
ARTS, COMMERCE AND SCIENCE
CHANDRAPUR
DR. AMBEDKAR COLLEGE OF ARTS, COMMERCE AND
SCIENCE, CHANDRAPUR
CERTIFICATE
Date:
( Project guide )
DR. AMBEDKAR COLLEGE OF
ARTS, COMMERCE AND
SCIENCE CHANDRAPUR
DECLARATION
Place: Chandrapur
Date:
Projectees
M. Com. (Final Year)
2021-2022
INDEX
Sr.
No CHAPTERS Page No.
1 Introduction
5 Review of literature
6 Conception Framework
* Bibliography
* Questionnaire
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
GST stands for Goods and Service Tax. Vishwanath Pratap
Singh who was the 7th Prime Minister of India first initiated GST act in 1986.
After that in 2007, the prevailing government suggested to deploy GST Act and
the proposal has been presented in Lok Sabha in 2011 and again the same
proposal was presented in Lok Sabha in Dec 2014. GST Act was passed in 2015
and again Act was passed in the Lok Sabha on 29th March 2017 After the
approval of Rajya Sabha GST act was launched from 1st July 2017 and it was
referred as 101 Amendment of Constitution. GST has become a revolutionary
change in indirect taxes after rossing 25 years of economic amelioration.
Items not covered under (as in Proposed Draft) GST: Alcohol, tobacco, petroleum
product, electricity etc. are not covered under GST.
The retailers can file GST in two ways i.e.; regular and
composite. In the case of regular dealers, they have to file GST monthly returns
(GSTR 3B, GSTR 1,2, 3) + Annual returns), whereas in the case of composite
dealers, they file quarterly returns (GSTR 4) + Annual returns. And also, regular
dealers can make interstate sales as well as local sales and higher sale of tax is
applicable for them. (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%). It is applicable for large assesses
having turnover more than 1.5 crores. If the turnover is less than 1.5 crores, still
normal scheme can be chosen. While, the composite dealers cannot make interstate
sales and they can only sell within the state and their rates of tax are lower ie; 1%
for traders, 1% & 2% for manufactures and 5% for restaurants. It is applicable for
small assesses having turnover up to 1.5 crores in previous year.
The impact of GST on retail sector is going to be positive as it will
bring down total indirect taxes, increase supply chain efficiency and facilitate
seamless input tax credit. After the implementation of GST, state boundaries will
be irrelevant from taxation and documentation point of view. Vanishing state
boundaries will reduce the complexity for retailers and increase the distribution
reach as well as efficiency.
Retail is the process of selling consumer goods or services to
customers through multiple channels of distribution to earn profit. Retailers satisfy
demand identified through a supply chain. Retailing can be defined as the buying
and selling of goods and services. It can also be defined as the timely delivery of
goods and services demanded by consumers at prices that are competitive and
affordable.
TYPES OF GST
GST has four different kind of taxes namely CGST,SGST, IGST and UGST.
CGST
stands for CENTRAL GOODS AND SERVICE TAX, the tax is levied based on
intrastate supply of goods and services. The share of GST tax is redirected to the
revenue department of central government. CGST replaces all the current Central
taxes like Central Excise Duty, Service Tax, Custom Duty, SAD, etc. the share of
this tax compensates all loss of current service tax and excise duty of the central
government. In case of local sales, Under GST 50% quantum tax is transferred to
SGST.
SGST
SGST stands for STATE GOODS AND SERVICE TAX , this tax is similar to
CGST ,as part of tax which is diverted to the state government has been credited to
revenue department of state government. In SGST ,tax are exacted by within one
state where transaction of goods and services take place. SGST compensate the
loss of other existing tax like sales tax and value added tax(VAT) which was
replaced all these taxes and has been a sole claimer of the revenue to the state
government. In case of local sales , 50% of quantum tax which was under GST has
been redirected to SGST tax.
IGST
IGST stands for INTEGRATED GOODS AND SERVICES TAX . This tax is
applicable when transactions take place on interstate or when two states involved
in purchases of goods and services. This tax is collected by central government.
One part of tax is transferred to central government and rest is transferred to the
state government.
UTGST /UGST
UTGST stands for Union Territory Goods and Services Tax. UTGST provide the
same benefits as SGST. The main purpose of UTGST bill is to levied tax on every
purchase of goods and services which take place within intrastate. This tax is only
applicable to union territories of India namely Andaman and Nicobar Islands,
Chandigarh, Daman, Diu, Dadra, Lakshadweep and Nagar Haveli.
IMPACT OF GST SYSTEM TO RETAILERS
Retail sector is one of the key pillars for Indian economy and it
accounts for around 10% of Gross Domestic Price (GDP). GST will usher in wide
changes in various industries and sectors and Retail industry is not an exception.
While GST implementation is now just few days away, let’s see what will be the
impact of GST on Indian Retail Industry and which changes will this industry need
to imbibe to become GST ready
.
Less Taxes
As per current tax scenario, retailers are indulged to about 30% indirect taxes
such as CST, VAT, service tax on warehousing, octroi, excise duty and many more.
Retailer tax burden shall be lessen by GST system as it will assign everything into
a single tax .So, simplified tax structure will come into existence by eradicating
cascading of taxes.
Geography
Demography
Industrial Status :
The story of Tata Steel is a century old and Sir Jamsetji Tata had idea of
starting a steel plant near Warora region. At the age of forty-three in 1882,
Jamsetji read a report by a German geologist, Ritter von Schwartz, that the
best situated deposits of iron ore were in Chandrapur district in the Central
provinces, not far from Nagpur where he worked. They area named was
Lohara, after the iron ore deposits nearby. In the vicinity, Warora had
deposits of coal. Jamsetji is believed to have visited Lohara himself and
obtained specimens of Warora coal for testing. He took a consignment of
coal with him and had it tested in Germany. The coal was found unsuitable.
The mining terms offered by the government were too restrictive, and
Jamsetji gave up the project. But the idea of giving India a steel plant
abided with him
GMR
GMR Warora Energy Limited is a 600 megawatt (MW) coal plant in
Maharashtra, India. The power station is close to Warora in Maharashtra. It
was initially functioned by EMCO Energy, an auxiliary of the GMR Group.
The two 300 Megawatt units were commissioned in 2013 itself.
GMR Warora Energy Limited is commissioned in March 2013. The approved
capacity of the thermal power plant is 600 Megawatt. The installed capacity
of the thermal power plant is also 600 Megawatt. The status of the Thermal
Power Plant is Operational. The source of coal for the generation of power
is from South Eastern Coal Fields Limited (SECL) coal mines, which is a part
of Coal India Limited (CIL).
The primary fuel used is Coal. The GMR Warora Energy Limited is owned
and operated by the GMR Group. The Boiler, Turbine and Generator of the
plant are manufactured by the Shanghai Electric Company, China. Also the
Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) contract was given to
Shanghai Electric Company, China. The beneficiary states of the thermal
power plant are Maharashtra and its neighboring states.
The unit sizes of the thermal power plant are 600 Megawatt (300 Megawatt
x 2 units). There are two units in operation and they are Unit 1 and Unit 2.
The first unit is commissioned in March 2013 with an installed capacity of
300 Megawatt.
Similarly the second unit is commissioned in September 2013 with also an
installed capacity of 300 Megawatt. GMR Warora Energy Limited is
completely tied up below long term Power Purchase Agreement for 200
Megawatt each with Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company
Ltd, Dadar and Nagar Haveli Power Distribution Corp Ltd, and Tamil Nadu
Generation and Distribution Corporation. The Commercial Operation Date
of first unit in the power station is March 2013 and the Commercial
Operation Date of second unit was in September 2013. The plant got
certifications like ISO 9001 and ISO 14001
SAI
Sai Wardha Power Plant is a coal-based thermal power plant located
near Warora city in Chandrapur district in the Indian state of Maharashtra.
The power plant is operated by the KSK Energy Ventures.
The coal for the plant is sourced from Western Coalfields Limited (WCL).
The Engineering, procurement and construction contract (EPCC) is given to
Sichuan Electric Design Company of People's Republic of China.
CHAPTER 3
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH DESIGN
DESCRIPTIVE RESEARCH
CONVENIENCE SAMPLING
POPULATION
SAMPLE SIZE
Source of data means the origin from where we collect the data. Generally, the
source of data collection is two types (1) primary source of data (2) secondary
source of data. Primary and secondary have been used in this study and they were
collected accordingly.
PRIMARY DATA
Primary data are those data which are directly collected by the researcher or
through investigator or enumerator for his purpose in first time. The primary data
are original in character.
Here, primary data is collected from the retailers in warora taluk by using
questionnaire.
SECONDARY DATA
The secondary data are those data, which have already been collected and
published or compiled for another purpose of the study. It includes not only
published records and reports but also unpublished records. Secondary data require
for the study have been gathered from internet, newspaper, articles, magazines
etc…
TOOLS FOR ANALYSIS
Under this study in order to analyze and interpret the collected data the following
statistical tools are used.
Charts, diagrams and tables are used for presentation of the data. It is more useful
to present the results in a simplified manner.
Due to lack of time, money and resources, the sample size limited to 50
respondents.
The sample size may not be represented the target population of the study
HYPOTHESIS
So that it will ensure that GST have positive impact in the retail sector. Because of
GST will avoids the cascading effect as the tax is calculated only on the value add
at each stage of transfer of ownership. GST is one indirect tax for the entire
country.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Studied, “Goods and Service Tax – Panacea for Indirect Tax System in India “and
concluded that the new NDA government in India is positive to ward simple
mentation of GST and it is beneficial for central government, state government and
as well as for consumers in long run if its implementation is backed by strong IT
infrastructure.
AGOGOMAWULI
Studied, “Goods and Service Tax- An Appraisal” and found that GST is not good
for low- income countries and does not provide broad based growth to poor
countries. If still thee countries want to implement GST, then the rate of GST
should be less than 10%forgrowth.
NITIN KUMAR
Studied, “Goods and Service Tax – A Way Forward” and concluded that
implementation of GST in India help in removing economic distortion by current
indirect tax system and expected to encourage unbiased tax structure which is in
different to geographical locations.
NISHITHA GUPTHA
In her study stated that implementation of GST in the Indian framework will lead
to commercial benefit which were untouched by the VAT system and would
essentially lead to economic development. Hence GST may us her in the
possibility of a collective gain for industry, trade, agriculture and common
consumers a well as for the Central and State government.
JAIPRAKASH
In his research study mentioned that the GST at the Central and the State level are
expected to give more relief to industry, trade, agriculture and consumers through a
more comprehensive and wider coverage of input tax set-off and service tax set-
off, subsuming of several taxes in the GST and phasing out of GST. Responses of
industry and also of trade have been indeed encouraging. Thus GST offers us the
best opinion to broaden our tax base and we should not miss this opportunity to
introduce it when the circumstances are quite favorable and economy is enjoying
steady growth with only mid inflation.
SARAVANAN VENKADASALAM
Has analyzed the post effect of the goods and service tax (GST) on the national
growth on ASEAN states using Least Squares Dummy Variable Model(LSDVM)
in his research paper. He stated that seven of ten ASEAN nations are already
implementing the GST. Heal so suggested that the household final consumption
expenditure and general government consumption expenditure are positively
significantly related to the gross domestic product as require and support the
economic theories. But the effect of the post GST differs in countries. Philippines
and Thailand show significant negative relationship with their nation’s
development. Meanwhile, Singapore shows a significant positive relationship. It is
undeniable that those countries whom implementing GST always encounter grows.
Nevertheless, the extent of the impact varies depending on the governance,
compliance cost and economic distortion. A positive impact of GST depends on a
neutral and rational design of the GST such a way it I simple, transparent and
significantly enhances involuntary compliance. It must be actual, not presumptive,
prices and compliance control would be exercised through an auditing system.
HUANG
The author examines the relation between the newly introduced GST in Australia
in 2000 and the mortgage costs between 1999 and 2001. The study concludes that
given that in Australia financial services industry is taxed on input taxation basis
i.e. the output mortgage service not liable to GST and GST paid on input services
to provide these mortgage services are also not allowed. This extra cost of sunk in
put taxis passed in the form of increased mortgage costs to customers making
housing costly post introduction of GST in Australia.
The author has traced the GST and import duties applicable on the various imports
into New Zealand. The paper discusses not only the goods on which duty is
payable but also whether further GST is payable on the same goods. The paper
also discusses the applicability of the taxes on the goods ordered and delivered
through internet. The paper also discusses various exemption available like
personal effects to the import taxation.
DR. R. VASANTHAGOPAL
Studied, “GST in India: A Big Leap in the Indirect Taxation System” and
concluded that switching to seamless GST from current complicated indirect tax
system in
India will be a positive step in booming Indian economy. Success of GST will lead
to its acceptance by more than 130 countries in world and a new preferred form of
indirect tax system in Asia also.
Studied “Goods and Service Tax Reforms and Inter governmental Consideration in
India” and found that GST introduction will provide simpler and transparent tax
system with increase in output and productivity of economy in India. But the
benefits of GST are critically dependent on rational design of GST.
CHAPTER-6
CHAPTER-6
CONCEPTION FRAMEWORK
VALUE-ADDEDTAX(VAT)
RETAILING
Retail refers to the activity of re selling. A retailer is any person or organisation is
are seller who sells good or services directly to consumers or end-users. Some
retailers may sell to business customers, and such sales are termed non-retail
activity. In some jurisdiction or regions, legal definitions of retail specify that at
least 80% of sales activity must be to end-users.
TYPES;
Fast moving consumer goods are products that sell quickly at relatively
low cost – items such as milk, gum, fruit and vegetables, toilet papers,
soda, beer and over- the-counterdrugs like aspirin. The fast moving
consumer goods industry covers the households’ items that you buy
when shopping in the supermarket or pharmacy. ‘Fast moving’ implies
that the items are quick to leave the shelves and also tend to be high in
volume but low in cost items.
The products are ones that are essential items that we use day in and day
out. This multi-million-dollar sector holds some of the most famous
brand names that we
come across every single day.
TEXTILES
HOTEL
MEDICAL SHOP
A store that sells health care products and medicines. Customer can buy
both over- the-counter and prescription medication at a drugstore. It is
not uncommon for drug store to carry other frequently used household
products and pp merchandise.
It is a retail shop which provides prescription drugs, among other products. At the
pharmacy, a pharmacist oversees the fulfilment of medical prescription and is
available to give advice on their offering of over-the-counterdrugs. Atypical
pharmacy would be in the commercial area of a community.
JEWELLERY
Variables Number
Age Below30 12
30–40 10
40-50 20
Above50 8
Gender Male 40
Female 10
Educational Qualification School Level 21
UG 24
PG 1
Others 4
Income BelowRs.20,000 18
20,001 - 40,000 25
AboveRs.40,000 7
Working Experience Below1year 3
1-3years 7
3-6 years 10
6-10years 15
Above10years 15
Nature of Shop Own 25
Lease 10
Rent 15
Total 50
Source: Primary Data
From the table it is clear that the age of the respondents below 30 years are 12,
between 30 to 40 years are 10, 40 to 50years are 20 and above 50 years are 8. From the
respondents the maximum retailers are male and the educational qualification of
maximum respondents is Undergraduate and School education followed by Post
graduate and some have done other courses such as D.Ed. Maximum respondents i.e.,
30 are doing the business since from 10 years and above and the shop they run are
owned by maximum respondents while few have taken it on rent or lease.
1. DISTRIBUTION ON THE BASIS OF AWARENESS LEVEL ABOUT GST
30
25
20
HIGHLY
AWARE
15
AWARE
NUETRAL
10 UNAWARE
HIGHLY UNAWARE
0
Tax rates Payment GST credit Composition GST online
mechanism scheme procedure
(SOURCE:PRIMARYDATA)
INTERPRETATION
From the above graph shows that awareness level about GST of 50 retailer i.e.,21 out
of 50 retailers are highly aware about GST tax rates , 7 retailer are highly aware of
payment mechanism of GST , 12 retailer are aware about composition scheme, 9
retailer are highly aware about the GST online procedure
2. DISTRIBUTION ON THEBASIS OF SOURCE OF GETTING KNOWLEDGE
ABOUT GST:
Sr. No SOURCES NO. OF
RETRAILERS
1 Trade unions 173
2 Professionals 178
3 Friends &relatives 215
4 Mass media 306
5 Online sources 304
6 Others 60
(SOURCE:PRIMARYDTA)
SCORE
350
300
250
200
150
SCORE
100
50
0
NS AL
S
TIV
E IA ES RS
NIO N A ED URC THE
L
U SIO RE SM O O
A DE FES & AS ES
TR O DS M IL N
PR IEN ON
FR
(SOURCE: PRIMARY DATA)
INTERPRETATION:
50
40 47
30
20 Registered underGST
10
0
3
Yes No
INTERPRETATION
From the above graph it is clear that 47 small Retailers i.e.
94% are register under GST and only 3 i.e. 6% did not register GST as they
are new in the market and they have changed the business.
4. DISTRIBUTION ON THE BASIS OF PROBLEMS RELATED TO GST
PROCEDURES
Percentage
38%
Yes No
62%
INTERPRETATION:
Percentage
40%
36%
35%
30%
25% 24%
Percentage
20% 18% 18%
15%
10%
5% 4%
0%
Excellent Good Moderate Bad very Bad
(SOURCE: PRIMARY DATA)
INTERPRETATION:
The above table shows that distribution on the basis of opinion
about implementing GST. It says that 33% of the respondents are says that
their opinion is neutral, and 24% of the respondent s are says that their
opinion is good. And 18% of the respondent are says that their opinion is
excellent and also bad, and 7% of the respondent are says that their opinion is
very bad. Majority of the respondents ‘opinion is neutral
6. DISTRIBUTION ON THE BASIS OFEFFECT OF GST ON SMALL
RETAILERS
INTERPRETATIO
OPINION GST IS GOOD TAX PAYMENT GST LOWER FILLING TAX GST LOWER
INITIATION IS EASY THE RATE OF RETURNS THE
GOODS AND EASY LOGISTIC
SERVICE OVERHEADS
AgreeCan’tSayDisagree
90%
70% 71%
66%
52%
22%26%
20% 17%
14% 15%15% 12%
8%
2%
INTERPRETATIO
From the above graph it is clear that GST has a significant impact on
Small Retailers as more than 90% of retailers are in opinion that GST is a good initiation,
66% are in opinion that the tax payment is easy, 70% are in, 52% say that filing of tax is
easy and 71% are in opinion that GST lowers the logistic overheads. So GST has impact
on Retailers towards progression of economy. So it is clear that the alternate hypothesis
is accepted i.e., GST has a significant impact on Small Retailers, but there are few
limitations like they are not so handy to technology so filing of tax returns is not easy as
there is requirement of clarity and simplification of procedure.
CHAPTER-8
CHAPTER-8
SUMMARY, FINDINGS, SUGGESTIONS AND
CONCLUSION
SUMMARY
GST is one indirect tax for the entire country. In simple words, Goods
and Service Tax is an indirect tax levied on the supply of goods and services.
GST law has replaced many indirect tax laws that previously existed in India.
This study is reveals that 83% of the sample respondents are highly aware
about GST tax rates. And 63% of the respondents are aware about
composition scheme.
Under this study it found that, one of the most important source of getting
knowledge about GST is mass media and the second one is online sources.
83% of the respondents are registered under the composition scheme, and
17% of the respondents are not registered under the composition scheme.
This study is found that 55% of the respondents have said that GST is better
than VAT, and 45% of the respondents have said that VAT is better.
57% of the respondents have said that there is no problem related to GST
procedures, and 43% of the respondents have said that there are problems
related to GST procedures.
Most of the respondents [75%] are strongly agreed that GST ha increase the
cost of production, and 65% of respondents are agreed that GST is regulating
the unorganized sector.
Among the sample respondents 91% of the them are highly satisfied about 0%
tax rates, and 80% of the them are satisfied about 5% tax rates.
In my study is found that majority [32%] of the respondents are educated up
to SSLC. And 27% of the respondents are PLUSTWO.
Among the sample respondents 52% of them are says that GST in favor of
retailers.
Among the respondents 73% of them are sole traders and 27% of them doing
partnership.
Most of the respondents [75%] is strongly agreed that GST is helpful for overall
development of nation, and 73% of them agreed that GST is decrease the cost
of collection of tax revenues of the government.
SUGGESTIONS
This study is reveal that under the proposed GST regime, various
Indirect Taxes would be subsumed and hence it is expected that it would result
in a simpler tax regime, especially for industries like FMCG, Textiles, Hotel,
Medical shop, Jewellery etc…. Apart from simplification of tax compliances,
the rate of tax will also have a significant impact on the all the specified sectors.
In FMCG sector the VAT rate is amount to approximately 22-24%,under the
GST regime the rate would be in the range of 5% to 28%. Andin Textile
industry the VAT rate was 4-5%, under the GST regime the rate would be in the
range of 5% to 18%. Andin Hotel industry the VAT rate was 5-20%, under the
GST regime the rate would be in the range of 5% to 18%. And in Medical sector
the VAT rate was 4%, under the GST regime the rate would be in the range of
5% to 12%. And in jewellery industry the VAT rate was 1%,under the GST
regime the rate would be 5%. Thereby resulting in significant impact for these
sectors .i.e. the all these sectors have both positive and negative impact from
GST.
Dr. Mohan Kumar, CA Yogesh Kumar (2017). “GST & its portable
impact on the FMCG industry in India”, International Journal of Research
in Finance and Marketing(IJRFM),Vol.7Issue4,April– 2017,pp.66-76
Saurabh Suman (2017). “Study on New GST Era and its Impact on
Websites
https://cleartax
WWW.wekipidia.com
WWW.GST.com
Newspapers
Economics Time
Times OF India
Indian Express
The Hitwada
Hindustan Time
BOOKS REFERRED
A. Below SSC.
B. SSC.
C. Plus Two
D. Graduate.
E. Post Graduate.
F. Other
8. Business Nature ?
A. Sole Trader
B. Partnership
4 Composition scheme
5 GST online procedure
SOURCES RANK
Through trade unions
Professionals
Friend & relatives
Mass media
Online sources
others
12.Below are some of the statement regarding effect of GST on some factor is given?
Kindly tick the relevant option:
A. State Government
B. Centre Government
C. Consumers
D. Retailers
E. Not any
15.Do you face any problem related to GST like tax procedure, paper work, filing return
etc….....?
A. Yes
B. No
A. Excellent
B. Good
C. Moderate
D. Bad
E. Very bad
18.Do you face any problem related to GST like tax procedure, paper work, filing return
etc….....?
A. Yes
B. No
19.Opinion about GST structure ?