Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Signalling to
Digital Automation
EDITORIAL
Farewell, signals.
Here comes digital automation.
Stephen Shirlaw
Market & Portfolio Manager,
Alstom Digital Mobility
Jean Koulischer
Business Development Director,
Alstom Digital Mobility Mainlines
I
t is no surprise that industrial production sites are
becoming more and more automated. With automation
and d igitalisation, the industry has, since the 1970s,
been optimising its investments and operating costs, better
controlling the flow of materials, energy and people.
Editorial 02
Interview
The time has come to run digital signalling
at full speed 04
Data
Digital signalling: a strong lever for network
optimisation in more than 30 countries 06
Interview
Onboard intelligence for high-
and low-density networks 07
Analysis
A solid future for digital automation 08
Demo
Making the grade in mainline
with Automatic Train Operation 10
Interview
An enabler for business transformation 11
GLOSSARY
By 2030, mainline trains could spend the majority of their and we are aiming for automatic driving with no agent on
trips running on autopilot, just like airplanes do so today. board for particular applications like freight in a specific
This feat will be made possible by technologies that are environment. Then, on the 2025-2030 horizon, we will see
already available, which constitutes a considerable asset the automation of driving become widespread on the
for infrastructure managers and network operators, in mainlines.
particular. Vincent Passau, Solution Director of Atlas
(European Train Control System) at Alstom. The technological building blocks are there, proven on urban
metro lines that already operate without a driver.
WHAT IS THE CHALLENGE OF DIGITALISATION Then, for mainlines in
FOR INFRASTRUCTURE MANAGERS AND RAIL particular, it must be taken
NETWORK OPERATORS?
Both passengers and freight operators are hoping for better
into account that the tracks
are in an open environment, “The more we digitise,
quality of service: higher capacity, better punctuality and
predictability, improved comfort, reduced trip time, easier
where the unexpected is
much more relevant. It is the more attractive
connections, etc. This is the goal of our customers. But they
also face the challenge of minimizing their initial investments
thus necessary to include
intrusion detection equip- the railway is for
(CAPEX) and their operating costs (OPEX).
Digitalisation represents the opportunity to optimise traffic,
ment. This, we also know
how to do, especially on passengers, the more
ensuring the network stability and gradually automating
operations. The more we digitise, the more attractive the
street-type urban equipment.
Some trams can brake viable the economic
railway is for passengers, the more viable the economic
models for operators and infrastructure managers, the more
automatically if they detect
an intrusion on their route. models for operators
it is possible to invest – it’s a virtuous cycle. But it’s also a
challenge, all the more important for mainlines,
Lastly, there is the regulatory
aspect, for which progress is and infrastructure
characterised by their complex interoperability, compared
to urban lines, where municipalities are less constrained to
constant but requires time,
like for autonomous driving managers, the more
innovate. in the automotive sector.
it is possible to invest
ARE SOME MARKETS MORE MATURE?
The transition to digital is easier in freight, for certain
IS THE DIGITALISATION OF
INFRA AND TRAINS ALSO – it’s a virtuous cycle.”
applications. In Australia, or in some Gulf countries, there A PLUS FOR MAINTENANCE?
is a big demand for full automation. With mining operations, Rails will always be neces-
for example, it is much more cost-efficient to use automation sary, as well as switch machines – but this is the minimum
than have drivers take shifts in very isolated areas, 24/7. In in terms of remaining conventional equipment. With the
Europe, there is no corridor that is 100% dedicated to freight. IoT and analysis of the data from the tracks and trains, one
The constraints are thus those related to passenger traffic, can effectively optimize maintenance, because the
the most demanding for automation. information available on the railway equipment is multiplied,
more precise and often in real-time. Maintenance has
ARE DRIVERLESS TRAINS READY FOR TOMORROW? always been preventive, but is becoming predictive: it is
The timeline is double. In rail, short-term means 3 to 5 years. targeted and aims to implement only what is necessary. The
We already have cases of automatic driving with drivers automobile has followed the same path: it is the engines
4
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
5
DIGITAL SIGNALLING
a strong lever for network optimisation in more than 30 countries
Projects
In service
Trainborne
Trackside
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
Onboard intelligence
for high- and low-density
networks
Int e r v i e w:
S t e p h e n Sh i r l aw,
M a r k e t & P or t fo l io M a na g er,
A l s t om D i g i t a l M o b ility
Trains are becoming more intelligent thanks to digital be facing competition from things like car-sharing and regional
technology, which is enabling trains themselves to carry out buses, which have more flexibility in where they can go in
new functions, or ones that currently require significant low-density areas. Regional lines will simply close if they can’t
infrastructure, such as signalling and safety management, as compete with coaches. But also, governments are trying to en-
Stephen Shirlaw, Market & Portfolio Manager of Digital courage people on to trains
Mobility at Alstom, explains. for environmental reasons.
Without this new functional-
WHAT ARE THE KEY TRENDS THAT ARE MAKING ity that allows for more ser-
ONBOARD SYSTEMS MORE INTELLIGENT? vices to run, however, trains
The first trend, which started 20-30 years ago, was the need for will just become overcrowd-
full safety control over driver actions. Initially, systems would just ed on busy lines. The default
check if the train was going past a red light. Now they check speeds position used to be that the
on curves, whether they slow down correctly on the approach to network could only take a
signals, if they slow down when the track is not in a good state certain amount of people.
and whether they have the right stopping distances. But now many operators are
The second recent big development is the advent of interoperability. trying to increase capacity.
This is important so that trains can travel from one country to Increased operability allows
another, and to improve the efficiency of the high-speed network the train to switch from high-density to low-density operating
and freight networks – rail freight is more efficient over longer modes along its route, as well as travel across borders.
distances because of the need to load and unload cargoes. In
Europe, that means crossing borders, unlike in Russia, China or WHAT DO MORE INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS
the US. But interoperability means more complexity. MEAN FOR TODAY’S RAILWAYS?
The next factor is an increase in automation. Operators are We’re getting to an inflection point with these converging trends.
looking for energy savings and being able to run trains closer Mobility in a complex world implies a concentration of intensity – as
together at a safe braking curve. At the moment, most operators railway systems become more intelligent, all the functionality is
are not looking to take drivers out of trains, but you can do things focused on the train, as opposed to the trackside. Systems are
like connect safety systems to traction equipment, check if doors becoming more complex and we’re moving towards a
are closed, connect cameras up to see if, for example, there is an software-based system that requires regular upgrades on a
object on a level crossing. high-technology platform on the train.
The final trend is digitalisation. Traditional signalling systems
are electrical, not digital. They use circuits along the track to IS THE INDUSTRY PREPARED FOR THE CHANGES
detect train positions within “blocks” of a couple of kilometres THAT ARE COMING?
in length. With digital signals, there is less hardware along the It has taken the industry a bit by surprise. Getting rid of trackside
track – everything is calculated by computer. Because the train equipment was not envisaged 20 years ago when these new
measures its exact position, on very busy lines, instead of having systems were first envisaged. But the world is changing fast and
block distances, you can have the exact position of moving we must adapt. We are basically half way there. At the highest
trains (called moving blocks). And if you have low-density lines, levels, rail chiefs recognise that they have to digitalise and automate.
you don’t want to have all that equipment every 2 km – you To move forward, the industry must focus more on the onboard
can safely use a GPS-type device. systems and start thinking about simpler driving rules for lines that
no longer have traditional signals and avoid the multiplication of
WHY IS THE CHANGE NECESSARY? national versions to allow for trains that are fully automated.
We must think about efficiency because there is competition from
other forms of transport. Operators did not realise that they would
7
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
A solid future
for digital
automation
Int e r v i e w:
M a rco N a n n i , TM S M a i nline So l uti o n Director, Alstom
& Pi e r re - D a m i en J o urda i n, Ro ute Co n trol Solutions Director, Alst om
The railway is changing. Europe’s ageing rail infrastructure signalling system reaches obsolescence, all the work must be
needs to evolve to meet increased demand and reduce the redone. Finally, having both a new train control system and
environmental impacts of transportation. New digital existing signals leads to complexity of operations and ties the
technology will be one of the key enablers in the development rules to the constraints of old technology.
of an automated future. “Digital technology is the enabler,” says Pierre-Damien Jourdain,
Route Control Solutions Director at Alstom Transport.
The move to digital automation comes as more and more “Digitalisation allows you to have automation. The industry has
customers have started to ask for increased functionality, says to replace traditional cable connections with a new digital railway
Marco Nanni, Traffic Management System (TMS) Mainline that has a comprehensive network of computers talking to each
Solution Director at Alstom. Operators want to improve the other. We’re are also adding a second level, moving from fibre-
efficiency of the existing network because upgrading tracks and optic cable to a radio communication system when this can
other infrastructure requires a lot of time and money – and in enable cost savings.” Replacing obsolescent signalling systems
some cases is just not possible due to physical, economic or with digital rather than traditional technology reduces the project
political constraints. cost. In addition, if new train control systems are introduced at
However, adding new train control and automated functions the same time, there is no need for signals, further reducing costs.
to the existing (electrical) signalling system faces several The current standard rail communications system is GSM-R
problems which, over the past 10 years, have slowed the (Global System for Mobile Communications – Railways), based
introduction of new technology. Firstly, the new train control on the 2G GSM technology and dedicated to the rail system. But
system needs to be connected to the old system, increasing the in a world of 5G telecommunications, GSM-R is no longer
cost and complexity of the work. Secondly, when the old enough, according to Jourdain. Both for radio and fixed
8
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
9
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
RER A + Betuweroute:
Making the grade
in mainline with
Automatic Train Operation
Automatic Train Operation (ATO) has been successfully up to three minutes per journey and an improvement in the
running in metro systems around the world since the late regularity of trips for millions of passengers on a line well-known
‘60s. But automation has not been making any headway in for its overcrowding and risk of disruption. This new development
mainline networks since then – at least not until this last year. represents real progress in the drive to improve mobility, a vital
priority for cities today. It is a first step towards achieving greater
Alstom has taken automation to the next grade in 2018 by automation of mainline railways for improved, more sustainable
showing, through two projects, that existing mainline signalling mobility solutions.
systems can be upgraded with ATO. The first project is the
implementation of ATO across the central section of the A line SAFER, MORE EFFICIENT RAIL FREIGHT:
of the Paris RER interurban/commuter rail system, one of the ON THE RIGHT TRACK
busiest lines in the world. The second involves the testing of ATO In November, Alstom will start live testing of an ATO enabled
technology on the Betuweroute, a 150-km double track freight freight train along the Betuweroute, a dedicated freight line with-
line in the Netherlands connecting Rotterdam to Germany. The out passenger trains
Betuweroute is equipped with the latest generation standardised or level crossings,
signalling system – the interoperable and radio-based ERTMS part of the European
Level 2. These two projects represent the first time that ATO has freight Corridor A.
been successfully added to the signalling of a mainline rail Tests will be carried
system. out with a GoA 2
level of automation.
IMPROVING MOBILITY FOR MILLIONS By allowing the
OF PARIS COMMUTERS driver to focus on
In 2015, Alstom won a 20 million euro contract with the RATP supervision, ATO is
or Paris Transport Authority, to develop and implement an ATO expected to improve
system for line A of the RER, one of the most highly travelled the safety and
commuter rail lines in the world serving up to 70,000 passengers efficiency of freight
per hour per direction (totalling 109 km in length) and some transport, while
1.2 million passengers per day. Today, 80% of the A line fleet of reducing energy
183 double-deck MI2N and MI09 trains have already been consumption.
equipped and running in ATO mode. The project is on schedule
to be completed by November 2018. The ATO solution was The test, the result of an agreement between Alstom, the Dutch
integrated with the existing SACEM (Driver Assistance, railway infrastructure operator Prorail and train operator RRF
Operation and Maintenance System) signalling installed in 1989 (Rotterdam Rail Feeding), which is providing the locomotive,
with the participation of Alstom. It is Grade of Automation 2 or will demonstrate that an existing ERTMS (European Railway
semi-automatic train operation. At GoA 2, the automated Traffic Management System) enabled line (levels 1 and 2) can
system controls acceleration and braking, safe speed and be successfully upgraded with the ATO system. Above all, the
starting and stopping, while the driver operates the doors, demo is expected to send a clear message to freight operators
monitors trackside conditions for obstacles and handles any that it is time to start thinking seriously about moving to more
emergencies. The new Alstom ATO system delivers substantial automated operations on lines that don’t involve any major
benefits such as enhanced performance regularity and optimised hazards.
speed profiles with increased commercial speeds by 5 km per
hour. The result is extremely promising: shorter travel times by
10
From Mainline Signalling to Digital Automation
An enabler
for business
transformation
Int e r v i e w:
Je a n - Ma rc N i z et ,
“Without any
Vi ce P re s i d e n t , compromise of safety,
M a i n l i n e Si g n a l ling , Als to m
which is at the heart of
our DNA, this will allow a
The advent of the digital railway will change the way that nutshell, it is a move from a
reduction of the costs of
providers of railway infrastructure and equipment do
business. Jean-Marc Nizet, Vice President of Mainline
hardware and products delivery
model to a System and
investment and operation
Signalling at Alstom, explains. Software as-a-service model.
However, there are big
for our customers and
WHAT EFFECT IS DIGITALISATION HAVING
ON THE INDUSTRY FROM A BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE?
variations in business models
from country to country – in
implies an evolution of
The digital revolution is already on its way in the railway sector
and, in particular, within Alstom. More and more, we are in the
some markets the trend is not
so apparent. So, we will
the business model.”
software business and less in the hardware or product business. continue, as we do now, to
This transformation to software with enhanced functionality remain close to our customers and follow their evolving needs.
allows for many opportunities for the sector and our customers. But it is important for Alstom to show to its customers that it is
As explained by my colleagues in the previous sections of this taking the lead in embracing this future.
paper, this transformation includes simplified trackside
architecture, more intelligence onboard, increased automation DOES THE FOCUS ON SOFTWARE MEAN
and new remote maintenance systems. THAT YOU WILL SEE NEW COMPETITION
A key consequence of this increase in software is the need to FROM OUTSIDE THE INDUSTRY, AS HAS HAPPENED IN,
deal with evolutions along the whole lifecycle of the system (as FOR EXAMPLE, THE AUTOMOTIVE SECTOR?
for apps on mobile phones). We’ve been doing software for Alstom firmly believes that the progress on automated mobility
about 30 years, but in the past, the software functionality was will bring significant benefits to the rail industry. However, the
interlinked with hardware and trackside products and railways, especially mainlines, represent a very particular
procurement was done according to the procurement rules for environment due to the rail technology and the high speeds.
hardware. The industry is starting to recognise that today, the Therefore, safety is the number one priority requirement. New
value is more in the software than the hardware. This recognition entrants in the automotive sector are using this window of
is relatively new, both for us and for our customers. It makes a opportunity in that industry to extensively test their autonomous
real difference when considering the requirements of delivery solutions to get safety approval. Most of our business is still
in terms of the performance and reliability of the system. about providing safety for our customers, and it will remain so
for the coming century. This responsibility puts us in a specific
HOW DOES THE INCREASING FOCUS ON SOFTWARE technology and specialised role. The automotive sector uses
CHANGE HOW YOU DO BUSINESS? “line-of-sight” cameras and radars that can’t be used in railways.
Without any compromise of safety, which is at the heart of our In addition, the safety level required on a single car is much lower
DNA, this will allow a reduction of the costs of investment and than that which is necessary for a heavy train with over a
operation for our customers and implies an evolution of the thousand passengers. There may be extra competition in traffic
business model. management systems, but it will be limited to certain areas. As
The Alstom business model is changing in three aspects. The long as the rail industry goes along with the new customer
first is the effort towards long-term partnerships with customers. requirements, and this is clearly the case for Alstom, we do not
The second is a better plan for system enhancements along the expect to create a window of opportunity for other industries.
whole lifecycle of the system whether it is for upgrades, new
features, or accounting for new cybersecurity threats. Finally,
there is the need to take into account performance-based
contracts that are adapted to software-intensive systems. In a
11
Alstom – White paper 2018/2019 is published by the security and city mobility department of Alstom. © ALSTOM, 2018. All rights reserved. ALSTOM, the ALSTOM logo, all alternative versions and all mentioned trademarks of Alstom’s transport activities, are the brands
and trademarks of ALSTOM SA or ALSTOM Transport Technologies. The other names mentioned registered or not, belong to their respective owners. Technical and other forms of data contained in the present document are given for the purposes of information only.
ALSTOM reserves the right to reconsider or change this data at any time and without warning. Editorial Director: Stephen Shirlaw. The articles and illustrations published in this issue may not be reproduced without prior written authorisation. Design-Production:
Photo credits: ALSTOM Transport, TOMA – Julien Goldstein, TOMA – C. Sasso, Alstom, A. Février
Alstom
Alstom
Alstom
Alstom
Asia Pacific
Água Branca
Latin America
North America
Karnataka - India
B Wing 3rd Floor,
www.alstom.com
C V Raman Nagar,
Bangalore - 560 093