Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Promotion Planning: Training FOR Information Processing Notes
Promotion Planning: Training FOR Information Processing Notes
CNX00L07A
Promotion Planning
Promotion Planning
TRAINING FOR
INFORMATION PROCESSING
NOTES
All products, names and services used in this book may be trademarks or registered
trademarks of their respective owners.
No part of this text book may be copied or reproduced in any way and by any means
without the permission of the copyright holder .
Contents
Objectives ........................................................................................................... 2
Contents ............................................................................................................... 3
Promotion Planning 1
Promotion Planning 2
Promotion Planning 3
1-1
1-2
“Enlightening promotion” means disseminating new knowledge and technology widely among
many people. “Enlightening promotion activity” refers to an activity for this enlightening
promotion. The term “Enlightenment” refers to an idea held by many writers and scientists in the
eighteenth century, who believed that science and knowledge could improve people's lives.
1-3
The purpose of enlightening activity is to improve people’s lives. Improving people’s lives
means constructing a better life using new technology and knowledge. Activities for improving
people’s lives include, for example, health promotion, productivity improvement, economic
growth and encouragement to participate in society. "Enlightening promotion activity" means
disseminating new technology and knowledge among people so as to further these activities. In
the enlightening promotion activity, people should be able to learn new technology and
knowledge easily. Thus, the method of the technology and knowledge dissemination to people is
extremely important.
1-4
1-5
There are many fields of enlightening promotion, such as public health, rural development and environmental
issues. However, this text covers enlightening activities for ICT.
The important points of ICT dissemination are to formulate the ICT policy, to build information infrastructure
and to develop ICT-related human resources.
1-6
Indirect approach
1.2.1 Introduction of laws and guidelines
1.2.2 Easing some regulations
1.2.3 Business-academia collaboration
Direct approach = Education, Training
1.2.4 Job training program
1.2.5 Assignment of technical instructors
1.2.6 Short courses for general public
Reference: Publicity strategy
Section 1 has described the important points of ICT dissemination. Section 2 discusses the
concrete examples of the enlightening promotion activity.
Items 1 to 3 are indirect approach to disseminate some system, knowledge and skills. Items 4 to
6 are direct approach to disseminate those.
Items 1 (Introduction of laws and guidelines) and 2 (Easing some regulations) are the concrete
examples of policy formulation.
Items 4 (Job training program), 5 (Assignment of technical instructors) and 6 (Short courses for
general public) are the concrete examples of human resource development.
1-7
2) ISO 9000
• Meets the globalization and borderless age needs.
• Secures transparency and reliability by the system of audit
and registration by the third party.
Laws are enacted when legal force is required for the dissemination and/or when a public organization is
the entity for implementation and needs a basis for its activities. Also, guidelines set by some organizations
are disseminated when the system is inappropriate for regulation by law such as the quality service standard
provided by private enterprises or the system used by some company customarily.
1-8
Old fashioned regulation prohibits us from economic growing, but sudden deregulation may
cause social confusion. Therefore easing regulation regionally on trial basis is practical
solution. In those specific area, industries are developed and created professional people.
Examples of special deregulation zones for the ICT industry include the following:
•Deregulation of communication infrastructure and support to infrastructure building
•Tax breaks for ICT investment and IT business
•Various deregulation measures for Internet trade
•Establishment operation of organizations for local industry development
In Japan, local governments are requested to offer proposals for special deregulation zones for
structural reform, and have created a variety of special deregulation zones.
1-9
Enterprises have to apply their in-house resources to their existing business as a result of
globalization and intensified competition in recent years. Because of this, more and more
enterprises are trying to adopt business-academia collaboration for new researches and
developments regarding mid- and long-term R&D.
1-10
Concrete example
• In the U.S., each state formulates a job
training policy under the Workforce
Investment Act (WIA).
Job training programs provide people with occupational ability, productivity, moral discipline,
working attitude and professional ethics and improve ability to a professional level.
The systematic provision of training programs leads to the standardization and dissemination
of the human resource development level.
Concrete example:
• In the U.S., each state formulates its own job training policy and carries out a job training
program under the Workforce Investment Act established by the Federal Government.
1-11
Concrete examples
• Forestry instructors
• Agricultural instructors
• Fishery instructors
One of the methods for enlightening promotion activity is to efficiently assign human resources
having a high level of techniques with qualification to the workplace to disseminate and give
guidance on techniques and knowledge to employees of various job types.
This is an effective method for small or medium enterprises that have no sufficient human
resources having a high level of techniques.
1-12
Concrete examples
• PC operation classes organized by the local
government or individual instructors
• Guidance on Internet skills on the web
This is an effective method when there are needs for relatively simple skills by many people.
The local government may operate courses itself, or may provide support to the individuals or
enterprises that run class.
Concrete examples:
• PC operation classes organized by the local government or individuals or enterprises
• Guidance on Internet skills on the web
1-13
(Concrete example )
Project for disseminating "eCitizen," an e-governmental service, in
Singapore
It is very important to examine a publicity strategy for dissemination. The AIDMA law says
there are five steps when people buy something.
• Attention
• Interest
• Desire
• Memory
• Action
The same process is followed when a certain technique or system is disseminated. Thus, to
encourage people to use the target technique or system there is a need to concretely consider
how to execute each process.
Concrete example
The Singaporean government offers its citizens administrative services on the portal site
named "eCitizen" on a one stop basis. It takes the following measures for enlightening
promotion purposes:
1-14
There are main styles of the enlightening promotion activity as shown above. It will lead to an
effective dissemination activity to select the best style according to the purpose of the activity
and the target individuals. The following pages explain the style of implementation as well as the
advantages and disadvantages for each type of enlightening promotion activities.
1-15
Disadvantages:
- This style is unsuitable for large-scale education.
- It is difficult to secure training time.
- Transfer costs are needed.
- It is difficult to secure the place for instruction.
1.3.1 Classroom type 1-16
"Classroom type" is the learning style in which several trainees are given explanations of the
knowledge and guidance on the technique directly from the instructor at a particular place. One
or more instructors give guidance to a relatively small number of trainees.
In this style, the instructors can adapt their explanations to the level of the learners, attracting
their interest or concern and increasing their understanding. Thus the learners' satisfaction with
this style is high. The instructors can explain not only the knowledge and technique but can also
give guidance on practical training, making this style suitable for guidance on an introductory to
advanced level. The learners can ask questions then and there and can understand the contents
steadily. During the lecture, practice and discussion, the learners can exchange their opinions
with each other and gain the secondary effects that they could not have in individual learning.
While the classroom type is now adopted and achieves good effects for many activities, it is
not almighty. Some learners may be discontent with this style because of, for example, the
instructor's quality, difference in the trainees' level and impractical teaching materials and
workshops. This type has problems about time and costs, too. When you want to provide
education to many people, the classroom type requires too much time and too high costs.
Because the learners have classes on a given date and time and at one place, they find difficulty
securing time enough to attend and, if they live far from the place for instruction, need costs for
traveling to the place. The organizer also has difficulty securing the place and instructors and
faces the problem of developing high-quality instructors.
1-16
Disadvantages:
- Priority tends to be given to the daily operation, resulting in the
postponement of training.
- Systematic and theoretical aspects are apt to be neglected.
- The results differ depending on the instructor's motivation and ability.
"Workplace type" is the style aiming to improve the knowledge, skills, techniques and attitude
that employees need for their work while they are performing their daily duties. It is also known
as on the job training (OJT) or learning by doing. In most cases, the seniors or bosses serve as
instructors and give guidance to new employees and beginners. This type of guidance is usually
given on a one-to-one basis but is given on a one-to-group basis in some cases through the
division of roles among the instructors.
An effective way to improve the employees' ability to perform their duties is to encourage
them to accumulate experiences for the duties in the workplace. In the workplace type, the target
of human resource development is clearly defined, the development plan is drafted and
instruction is given step by step, starting from simple things and then proceeding to more
difficult ones. An everyday and realistic target is established for human resource development
after the duties of employees have been analyzed. Because the boss experienced in the duties
gives instruction to their subordinates on a one-to-one basis, they can provide them with
practical and careful guidance. The instructor can adapt the contents and level of guidance to the
individual skill level and to the situation concerned, and the trainees can take their time to learn
what they cannot understand well. Because this training style is carried out during daily
operation, it does not entail extremely high costs. However, there are some cases where too high
priority is given to daily operation and it becomes as much as you can to perform your duties,
resulting in the loss of the systematic aspects of training. There are also the cases where too
much emphasis is given to practical guidance and theoretical aspects are dismissed. The results
of development may differ according to the instructor's motivation and ability. It is important to
carry it out according to the plan to avoid these problems. It is advisable to conduct interviews
with the trainees and to review the plan regularly or whenever the target is changed midway.
1-17
Disadvantages:
- No direct guidance can be given.
- No direct questions can be asked.
- Training depends on the quality of the teaching materials (contents).
- There are some cases where the trainees learn knowledge only and can have no
practical training.
1.3.3 Correspondence course type 1-18
"Correspondence course" is the training style in which training is given by the correspondence
between the instructor and the trainee. The instructor provides the trainee with teaching materials
and makes corrections on the answers by mail. The trainee uses the teaching materials mailed to
them and has training indirectly at home by self-learning. This training style needs no advanced
information communication structure like the e-learning type; it only needs the communication
infrastructure of the mail service. The trainee can learn at their own pace with no restrictions as
to place and time as far as they have the teaching materials. The organizer does not have to
secure instructors and a training place. Thus this style is suitable for large-scale training as well.
However, the trainee can ask no direct questions and has to wait for a certain amount of time
before receiving answers by mail or other means of communication. The learner’s understanding
is considerably affected by the quality of the teaching materials. Depending on the quality of the
teaching materials, the training gives the trainee knowledge only and no practical guidance.
While this style requires no direct instructor, it needs the development of teaching materials and
their update based on the latest information so as to increase the understanding of the trainee.
1-18
Web-based training (WBT): the style in which the trainees receive education through
the network using the Web browser.
Learning management system (LMS): the training system having the function for managing the
progress and result of learning in addition to the WBT
function.
Advantages: Disadvantages:
-There are only a few time constraints. -This training style requires the provision of
information communication infrastructure (PCs,
-Trainees do not have to travel to a
networks).
particular place.
-Human relations are apt to become less close.
-It is easy to update and distribute the
teaching materials. -No direct guidance can be given.
-This training style can be used for large- -No direct questions can be asked.
scale training.
-Training depends on the quality of the teaching
materials (contents).
1.3.4e-Learning type 1-19
“e-learning type” is the style in which the trainees learn by using CD-ROMs or DVDs via the computer or
by accessing contents via the Internet or intranet.
Compared with the classroom type, this style has less time constraints and so the learner can learn at their
own pace. The organizer can also save costs because they can use digital contents and so it is easier to
update and distribute the teaching materials; they also do not have to secure instructors and the place for
training. Therefore, this training style is used as a means to train a large number of learners, too, and can
provide guidance effectively in a short time.
Main types of e-learning include the following:
Computer-based training (CBT): This is the training style in which the learner does self-learning using a
computer by installing the teaching materials in a PC or by operating the CD-ROM or DVD distributed on
a PC. The learner can study and review the materials at their own pace without having any constraints of
time and place. In this training style, information is given via a computer on a one-way basis.
Web-based training (WBT): This is the learning style in which the learner receives the teaching materials
on an on-line basis from the server via the Internet or intranet using the Web browser. All that the trainee
needs is to have the environment for using a PC and the network. The organizer can always provide the
latest information by updating the contents on the server. Recently, there are interactive systems, too, by
which the trainee can learn while exchanging communications with the instructor or other trainees.
Learning management system (LMS): This training system has the function for managing the progress,
result and history of learning in addition to the WBT function. The trainee receives the teaching materials
by the LMS, learns the materials and takes tests. The progress of learning, the history of the classes
attended and test results are all recorded on the LMS server. The organizer can check when the trainees
receive learning, who does learning, what teaching materials they use and to what extent they learn. It can
also analyze the strong and weak fields of the trainee and their ability from the results of tests and
exercises. This is an interactive learning system by which the organizer can give the trainee effective
guidance by providing them with this information.
The e-learning type described above needs ICT infrastructure, such as PCs and servers as well as
networks for linking them together. Care should be taken even when this environment is available
because there may be the need for higher-performance PCs and speedier networks.
No direct guidance is provided in the e-learning type. Therefore, the learner may be unable to ask
questions or to dissolve doubts because it is too complicated to ask questions using an e-mail or other
means. The e-learning type has less secondary effects (e.g. the trainee can listen to the opinions of other
trainees) than the classroom type. Thus some steps should be taken to avoid inappropriate self-solution
and complacence. Because the quality of the teaching materials directly affects the learner's
understanding, it is advisable to take some measures to reflect their opinions and needs on the materials,
such as questionnaires to them.
1-19
Advantages:
- It is possible to give training to a large number of learners at a time.
- The latest information can be provided.
Disadvantages:
- Information is provided to the learner only on a one-way basis.
- It is difficult to check the effects of learning.
- This style is unsuitable for practical and advanced-level training.
“Media use type” is the training style in which training is provided to a wide range of people by
distributing video clips, voices and pictures to them via television, radio, newspapers, the
Internet and other means. These media have a high communication efficiency, and this training
type thus aims at raising a question before or offering knowledge or information to the general
public. This training style is characterized by promptness, too. On the other hand, however,
information is provided to the trainee only on a one-way basis in most cases and it is difficult to
establish knowledge in the learner or to keep their motivation for activities. There is no definite
means to quantitatively measure the effects of the training provided. Because it can define the
scope of trainees only roughly, this training style is suited for the teaching of general and basic
knowledge and techniques more than for that of specialized ones.
1-20
introductory
Size
The above is the chart drawn up by plotting the styles of enlightening promotion activity on the
graph showing the size and level of trainees.
The classroom type is suitable when good results should be achieved steadily for a small
number of trainees. It can meet the needs of different levels of trainees, ranging from the level of
introductory training for new employees to the advanced level of technical or practical contents.
Because the instructor can adjust the contents of their lecture during the class hours, they can
flexibly change the guidance to the same level of trainees into the most needed one at the time.
The workplace type is basically one-to-one training and thus is targeted at a small number of
trainees. Its objective is to improve the ability of employees on an introductory level to the level
on which they can perform their duties themselves.
In the e-learning type and the correspondence course type, individuals can select the place and
time for learning. Therefore, these training types can provide training both to a small number of
trainees and to a large number of trainees. The e-learning type can teach technical or practical
contents using the teaching materials containing animations and sounds and can thus provide
training to the learners on an applied level, too.
In the media use type, information is distributed to the general public. This training type needs
general and simple contents because it is targeted at a large number of people. Thus it is suited
for the introductory and basic level of trainees.
1-21
Workplace type
Classroom Type
One way
The above is the chart drawn up by plotting the styles of enlightening promotion activity on the
graph showing the type of communication and the need to fix a particular time.
The classroom type is an interactive training style in which training is given at the predetermined
date and time and the instructor and the trainees meet face to face.
The workplace type training is more interactive than the classroom type one because it is
provided during the daily operation and on a one-to-one basis.
The typical examples of the e-learning type are CBT, WBT and LMS. CBT is mostly
individual learning and tends to be one-way communication. WBT has some interactive
elements because it includes the recently introduced system by which the trainees and the
instructor are linked together online. LMS can be regarded as an interactive system because it
can follow up the post-training situation of individual trainees by managing the progress of their
learning.
The correspondence course type is based on the correspondence between the instructor and
the trainee but is mostly composed of individual learning of the teaching materials mailed to the
trainee. Therefore, this training type has much the nature of one-way communication.
The media use type training may have to depend on the time slot for the training course
concerned. It is a one-way training type because it is based on the distribution of information to
the trainee.
These training styles do not always need to be used separately. Synergy may be achieved by
combining them. For example, it is possible to strengthen the practical skills of new employees
by the workplace type and to teach them the theoretical aspects, which are apt to be neglected in
the workplace type training, by the e-learning type training at the same time. It is important to
select and apply the styles most suited for the business organization.
1-22
In this chapter training implementation procedure which is one means of enlightening promotion
activity will be explained. When you offer a training, you have to plan logically and execute
according to the plan. This textbook explains “Instructional Design” which is one of training
implementation methods.
2-1
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.1 Procedure of Training Implementation(1/2)
“A method
for planning and executing training
efficiently and effectively
in a short term”
Instructional Design (ID) is a training design method adopting a systematic approach. In ID,
things are logically systematized, the programs to be implemented in each phase are
standardized and checked, and the output is documented.
Also known as SATE (systems approach to education) or ISD (instructional systems
development), this method has its origin in the training at the US Army in the late 1950s and was
improved into Computer Aided Instruction (CAI) and other methods in the 1960s, which have
since been used up to now.
If you promote enlightening promotion activity using ID, training will be effective and
efficient.
Next, you learn each phase of ID.
2-2
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.1 Procedure of Training Implementation(2/2)
ID process
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
ID consists of five phases which are Course Plan/Analyze, Design, Develop, Implement and
Evaluate.
1) Course Plan/Analyze
In the course planning/analysis phase, the issues/challenges are checked and the human resource
development needs and training objectives (course objectives) are defined. In other words, this
phase specifies the target trainees (“who”) and the objective (“What is the desirable goal that the
trainees achieve?”).
2)Design
Based on the Course Plan/Analyze result, in the design phase, it is designed that the training
contents for helping the trainees attain the training objective. It decides what should be taught,
and how they should be taught.
3)Develop
This phase prepares the course materials designed in the design phase and makes a format for
evaluation.
4)Implement
In this phase, the training contents are provided to the trainees in a simple and proper way for
them to learn the training contents.
5)Evaluate
This phase checks whether or not the training given has achieved the course objectives.
2-3
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2 Phases of Instructional Design
2.2.1 Course Plan/Analyze
2.2.2 Design
2.2.3 Develop
2.2.4 Implement
2.2.5 Evaluate
2.2 Phases of Instructional Design 2-4
In this section, Task item, Output and Review points of each phase will be explained.
2-4
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.1 Course Plan/Analyze (1/3)
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
When you promote “Enlightening promotion activity”, you will face various “issues and
challenges”. Training is one of solutions to “issues and challenges”. In this phase, you will
clarify issues and challenges human development needs which should be solved by training and
make a training strategy as a first step. In the second step, you will specify "whom" you want to
"become what type of human resources" and "what you should teach them" to make the training
one that meets the "human resource needs."
1) Task
i) Identify personnel needs
•For this item, you will identify the issues/challenges to be solved and will specify personnel
needs to be satisfied by the training. You will prepare documents of them as an output.
iii) Specifying the training objectives and analyzing knowledge, skills and attributes as needed
•First, you will list the specific objectives to be attained by the training. Next, you will identify
objectives attained and the current situation.
•Second, you will clarify the knowledge, skills and attributes needed to attain the objectives.
iv) Establishing the level of the trainees before and after the training
•To analyze professional qualities of trainees who have attained the objectives, you will
establish the level of trainees before and after the training.
2-5
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.1 Course Plan/Analyze(2/3)
(Continued)
2)Output
The key documents you will prepare in this phase are as follows:
i) Personnel needs
•This document should describe the current situation, technology trends, issues/challenges,
selected trainees, number of trainees, training term and the methods for settling non-training
issues.
ii) Chart of the course system and the outline of the course
•This document should state the course name, level of instruction, objectives, features,
qualifications of selected trainees, training types and training days.
2-6
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.1 Course Plan/Analyze(3/3)
(Continued)
3)Review points
Review points in this phase are stated below.
i) Is the training an appropriate solution to the issues/challenges?
•Are the issues/challenges behind the personnel needs critical issues?
•Is specialized training indispensable for a solution to issues/challenges?
•Is there any other method than training for resolving issues/challenges?
•Is it possible to combine training with other methods?
2-7
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.2 Design(1/4)
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
In this phase, you will design "what" should be taught and "how" they should be taught, as well
as "how the effect is measured" on the basis of the result of the Course Plan/Analyze .
1) Task
i) You make a module accompanied with objectives and check if the objectives are consistent
with the course objectives.
•Enumerate the learning items based on the knowledge, skills and attributes, which are the
output of the previous phase.
•Divide the learning items into several groups.
•Name the module (ex.---subject name, chapter name) and module objectives (ex.---subject
objectives).
•Check the module objectives and course objectives consistency.
•Determine the learning order of each module and make a teaching schedule.
•Determine the instruction method of the training contents.
ii) You plan the training subjects and make a teaching schedule. Design a lesson plan.
•Make a "lesson plan" based on the design results of the training contents, learning order,
teaching method and estimated class hours.
2-8
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.2 Design(2/4)
Levels of Evaluation
Level Name Contents How
learner If the learners are satisfied
Level1 questionnaire
reactions or not.
test
learning If the learners understand
Level2 exercise
achievement program contents.
workshop
transfer of If the learners use new
Level3 questionnaire
learning knowledge or skill on the job.
organizational If there is a improvement in Business
Level4
results organization performance. performance
(Continued)
iii) You design how to evaluate.
You evaluate effects of the implemented training. It is important for you to make an overall
judgment by rating the results of the training from several viewpoints. The evaluation is made
on the following four levels. On each level, you design "When," "What" and "How."
•Level1
Evaluation by trainee if he/she is satisfied or not.
•Level2
Evaluation by understanding of program contents. The methods for evaluating the
learning degree include evaluation of knowledge understanding by tests, and that of the
skill-learned degree by the result of exercises and workshops.
•Level3
Evaluation based on the action level of the trainee (e.g. Has the trainee been able to
apply to his/her job what he/she learned?). The evaluation on Level 3 is usually made
three to six months after the training.
•Level4(reflection on business results)
Was the trainee able to contribute to the business results by applying to his/her job what
he/she learned? For example, because a person takes “Project Management Basics“
class, so he/she proceed the project smoothly and made high quality system.
In general, no Level 4 evaluation is made as to the training whose objective is improving the
skill level or the knowledge level.
2-9
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.2 Design(3/4)
Sample items for Lesson Plan
subject name
subject objectives
purpose
background knowledge
training type
days of training
teaching equipment
time allocation
evaluation method
Evaluation points
instruction policy and so on.
2.2.2 Design 2-10
(Continued)
iv) Determine how to prepare course material.
You determine course materials type and course material preparation policy considering what
kind of materials will be effective for the trainees in attaining the objectives. You determine the
policy for the following three points:
•Policy for making textbooks for each subject.
•Type (e.g. PowerPoint files or Video etc.) of the audio-visual course materials for each object.
•How to prepare materials.
2)Output
i) Lesson plan
The contents of the lesson plan include the subject objectives, purpose, background
knowledge, training type (classroom training, e-learning, workshops, exercises), days of training,
teaching equipment, time allocation, evaluation points and instruction policy and so on.
2-10
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.2 Design(4/4)
(Continued)
3)Review points
i) Can the course objectives be attained by achieving the module objectives?
To check the validity of the designed lesson plan, you evaluate if the concrete objectives of the
entire training can be attained by achieving all of the module objectives. More specifically, you
prepare and check a matrix table of the course objectives and module objectives.
iii) Can evaluation exactly measure the degree of comprehension and the degree of attainment
of the objectives?
•Has the implementation method for Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 for evaluation been
designed?
•Can the list check the trainees’ satisfaction and the degree of learning and application to the
job of the knowledge, skills and attributes taught in the training?
•Can the developer prepare evaluation materials on the basis of this result?
2-11
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.3 Develop(1/3)
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
In this phase, you prepare course materials based on the result of the design phase. These course
materials are used to fully communicate the training contents to the trainees and to firmly plant
knowledge and skills in them.
1)Task
i) You prepare the textbook and audio-visual materials.
To prepare textbook, you first work on “format design”.
•In the format design stage, you determine "basic page format" and "style”.
•In the manuscript making stage, you determine a structure of textbook (arrangement of
chapters) and contents of each chapter.
Audio-visual materials should be consistent with textbook. You can prepare these
materials efficiently by using the figures and tables in textbook.
ii) You make evaluation material.
You make evaluation material based on the evaluation method devised in the design
phase.
Since Level 1 is the evaluation by the trainee, you use a questionnaire. You can collect
trainee responses using mark sensing cards, the Web or the LMS.
On Level 2, you check the trainee's understanding. You prepare a subject test and use it
to check the degree of understanding. You also check the skill level based on the
achievement indicators of the exercises and workshops.
On Levels 3 and 4, too, you basically use a questionnaire and collect responses to it.
iii) You review the prepared materials.
You review materials to guarantee the quality. You check "if course materials
are consistent with the design," "if contents have any mistake" and "if the contents help the
trainees’ understanding."
2-12
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.3 Develop(2/3)
(Continued)
The review should be done not only by the writer but also by all the other stakeholders as
well. The reviewer, writer and secretary should be assigned to the review work. This review
is an important item for guaranteeing the quality of the course materials.
2)Output
i) Textbook and audio-visual materials.
ii) Evaluation material
Examples )
Subject test
Questionnaire
2-13
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.3 Develop(3/3)
(Continued)
3)Review points
You check the validity of course materials from the following perspectives:
•Have course materials been prepared based on the lesson plan?
•Are course materials easily comprehensible ?
•Are there any literal error in materials?
•Are course materials respecting intellectual property rights?
•Are there any mistakes in the contents? It is especially important to check if any functional
mistake is contained (if command and other functions are valid) using the equipment
actually used.
2-14
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.4 Implement(1/2)
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
In this phase, you instruct training contents to trainee in a simple way so that they can learn
contents effectively. This section describes the implementation method of lectures in classroom
training.
1)Task
i) Preparation
Instructors make these preparations for lectures.
•Check and confirm the subject of the course.
•Examine the contents of subject.
•Make easy-to-understand stories of the lecture.
•Hold a rehearsal of the lecture.
•Be aware of the trainees’ situation.
•Check the course materials and tools necessary for the lecture.
2-15
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.4 Implement(2/2)
2)Output
i) Implementation result of Level1 evaluation
ii) Implementation result of Level2 evaluation
iii ) Training record (report)
3)Review points
You make evaluation in the next phase “Evaluate" but not in this phase.
2-16
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.5 Evaluate1/2)
Course
Plan Design Develop Implement Evaluate
/Analyze
In this phase, you check if the training you have provided would attain the course objectives.
You evaluate the training contents, and if no objectives have been achieved, you should analyze
the cause and take corrective measures.
1)Task
i) Implement of evaluation
You make Level 1 and 2 evaluations basically on completion of each subject. If a
course has two or more subjects, you also evaluate Level 1 and 2 of whole course.
The overall evaluation is made by the person in charge of the course, course planner,
course designer, instructor and people who analyze the result.
There are quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis. It is important to use both
analysis results effectively. Do not lean too much on quantitative analysis.
2-17
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
2.2.5 Evaluate(2/2)
2)Output
i) Totalized result of evaluation
ii) Evaluation report
iii) Action plan and implement result
3)Review points
•Is evaluation made to improve the training quality?
•Have all the totalized/analyzed results of the evaluation made been obtained?
•Can the proper action be provided to improve the training on the basis of the result at each
review meeting?
2-18
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
3. Instruction Technique
3-1
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
3.1 Effective Instruction Techniques
- Instruction
- Effective instruction
- Preparation
- Instruction techniques
- Closing
3-2
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction
Instruction means to communicate techniques and ideas
to the learner, who will then practice them.
Communication
Presentation
Instruction
Communication means a process to convey your thoughts and feelings to, and making yourself
understood by, other people.
Presentation is part of communication and means to present information to the particular learner
within a given time frame, which includes causing the learner to act in some way.
Instruction is a process to convey techniques and ideas to the learners through presentations,
causing them to use such techniques and ideas.
3-3
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Effective instruction
The learners spare time for, and have much interest in, your instruction. Effective instruction
further arouses their interest, causing them to agree and go into action.
3-4
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Reference: Learner’s response
Degree of agreement seen from the learner's response
Whether or not the learner agrees on the contents of the instruction and puts what they have
learned into practice can be known generally by their responses. In this sense, it is very
important for you to watch the learner's responses while you give instruction to them.
When the learner's responses are poor, you should take some measure during the instruction (e.g.
taking a break, changing the subject).
3-5
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Preparation
Preparation accounts for 70-80% of the factors affecting a
successful instruction.
Example of preparation
• Know the learner’s characteristics
• Prepare necessary equipment, samples, handouts, etc.
• Pick up most important points
• Decide how to conduct exercises
• Decide classroom layout
• Prepare for trouble
3-6
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(1/6)
3-7
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(2/6)
1. Greeting
"Good morning!"
You introduce yourself to the learner, telling them your name, career and other matters, and
introduce the cooperators, too. You show them your enthusiasm.
2. Breaking the ice
To relax the learner and give them a sense of unity, you talk about what you feel in your daily
life, the latest trend of the instruction contents and the like. You obtain the learners’ agreement.
3. Easing the learner's anxiety
You tell the learner that you will adjust the level of your instruction to their ability.
4. Telling instruction’s purpose, meaning and objectives
You tell the learner your instruction's purpose, meaning and objectives to motivate them to learn.
5. Telling rough schedule of lectures and exercises
You explain a rough schedule to the learners to prepare them for the instruction.
6. Inviting questions about an instruction format and contents
You have explained a whole picture of the instruction to the learner in the process of 1 to 5
above. At this point, you give them the opportunity to ask questions about the instruction.
7. Explaining the rules
You explain the rules to the learners (what they are expected to observe); you emphasize the
need for cooperation from all the learners and request their cooperation.
3-8
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(3/6)
b. How to give lectures
• Clearly show which part you are explaining.
• Observe learners and give acknowledgement.
• When there you do not have an answer, you study
and answer later.
• Make clear statement during class.
• Review the instruction on the previous day.
• Make material distribution plan.
• Be prepared for trouble.
When you give instruction, you should pay attention to several matters.
<Clearly show the part of the materials you are explaining>
When the contents you explain reach the lower part of the hierarchy, learners often cannot see where the
subject explained is situated and cannot understand the contents as a result. To avoid this; for example,
you can write the item numbers concerned (e.g. "1, 1-1, 1-2," "1, (1), A") on the blackboard.
<Observe learners and give acknowledgement>
You should not only give lecture but also motivate learners. Therefore carefully observe learners
expression or atmosphere of class and give feedback especially acknowledgement.
< When there you do not have an answer, you study and answer later. >
The learner understands tacitly that there are some problems that even the instructor does not know. You
should always try to answer the question from the learner.
< Make clear statement during class. >
Because a vague way of talking causes confusion among the learner, you should state everything clearly.
It is also advisable to ask the learner to talk about the problem.
< Review the instruction on the previous day. >
You can return the learner to the state at the closing of the previous instruction by reviewing the first day's
instruction.
<Make material distribution plan.>
You consider the timing when you distribute the teaching materials and show samples, photos and so on
to the learner, thereby preventing their concentration from being broken off.
<You show the learners as many samples, disassembled articles and photos as possible>
You can give the learner a clearer image of something by showing as many samples to the learner as
possible, rather than through explanations using imagination or verbal explanation.
< Be prepared for troubles. >
If you suppose troubles (e.g. "the learner who had been expected to attend class was absent," "the
projector's filament burned out") and decide how to cope with them in advance.
3-9
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(4/6)
c. Group work(1/2)
People learn best when they are actively involved in the
process and retain it longer.
Group work is a good way to involve learner into process.
When you carry out group work, you can clarify its theme, contents and tools by defining its
objectives.
<5W2H>
You discuss Why (purpose - objective), What (problem), Where (target scope), How (means to
realize), When (time for realization), Who (system for realization) and How much (necessary
costs).
3-10
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(5/6)
c. Group work(2/2)
Procedures for group work
1. Individual work
2. Group work --- Discuss and Summarize---
3. Prepare presentation materials.
4. Report the contents of discussion and the
conclusion.
5. Evaluate the report and give a feedback.
The procedures for group work are as shown above. Because some of the procedures can be
omitted according to the purpose, you should examine in advance which procedure you plan to
adopt.
There are a variety of tools for group discussion. If you use these tools in group discussion,
you can create, arrange and evaluate many ideas efficiently.
3-11
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Instruction techniques(6/6)
d. How to ask questions
• In an atmosphere where participants would not speak readily, you begin with an easy question.
• You avoid concentrating questions on a particular participant. If you randomly select a person
to ask a question, you can keep a feeling of tension among the participants.
• You call the name of the participant when you ask him or her a question.
• You should not interpret the answer to the question; you repeat the answer or write it on the
blackboard. If you interpret the answer as you understand it, you may distort what the
questioner intends to say.
3-12
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
Closing
3-13
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION
3.2 Points for instruction for each subject
Choose appropriate instruction methods by contents.
In training, you should select appropriate instruction methods. In almost every subject,
instructor communicate knowledge first. Next, instructor have to think if it is necessary for
trainee being able to utilize those knowledge as skill or attitude. If trainee have to use those
skill, instructor have to prepare exercise to display those skill, or prepare role-playing for
transferring those knowledge into attitude and/or behavior.
3-14
Copyright 2007 NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE EAST CORPORATION