Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Americans Act, which provides every older person, regardless of income, with
sociocultural perspective a variety of health benefits-from subsidized meals to counseling and other
theoretical perspective that
focuses on how social and services provided by over 20,000 community agencies. As a result, older Amer
hteto
cultural factors contribute to icans have more opportunities today to remain in better health than their
health and disease
counterpart ohorts who reached late adulthood earlier in our nation's history.
gender perspective theoret
cal perspective that focuses
on gender-specific health
problems and gender barriers Sociocultural Perspective
to health care
How social and cultural factors contribute to health and disease is the focus of
the sociocultural perspective. When psychologists use the term culture, they
refer to the enduring behaviors, values, and customs that a group of people
have developed over the years and transmitted from one generation to the
next. Within a culture, there may be one, two, or more ethnic
groups, large
groups of people who tend to have similar values and experiences because they
share certain characteristics.
In multiethnic cultures such as those of the United States and most
large
nations today, wide disparities exist in the life expectancy and health status of
ethnic minority groups and the majority population. Some of these differences
undoubtedly reflect variation in socioeconomic status (SES), a measure of sev-
eral variables, including income, education, and
occupation. For example,
the
highest rates of chronic disease occur among people who are at the lowest SES
levels (Flack et al., 1995).
Sociocultural variation is also apparent in health-related beliefs and
iors. For example, traditional Native American health behav
care practices are holistic
and do not distinguish
separate models for mental and physical illnesses
(Johnson et al, 1995). As another example, Christian Scientists
reject the use of medicine in their belief that sick people can betraditionally
cured
through prayer. And Judaic law prescribes that God gives health, and it isonly the
responsibility of each individual to protect it.
In general, health psychologists working from this perspective have found
wide discrepancies only among
not ethnic groups but also within these
groups. Latinos, forexample, are far from homogenous. The three major na-
tionality groups-Mexican-Americans, Puerto Ricans, and Cubans-differ in
education, income, overall health, and risk of disease and death
Dilworth-Anderson, Liu, & Schinke, 1995). (Bagley, Angel,
Gender Perspective
The gender perspective in health psychology focuses on the
specific health problems and gender barriers to health care. Menstudy of gender
and women
differ in their risk of a variety of disorders.
Throughout childhood, for exam
ple, boys outnumber girls in a range of behavioral and
psychological disorders.
IntroducingHealth Psychology CHAPTER 1| 29
Sociocultural Bias in
Diagnosis
including sleep and eating problems, hyperactivity, autism, and antisocial be
Physicians were told that these
havior. Conversely, from age 8 through adulthood, girls and women outnum-
supposed "heart patients" were
ber boys and men in the diagnosis of depression, anxiety, and eating disorders identical in occupation, symp
toms, and every other respect ex
(Ussher, 1997). In addition, women tend to respond more actively than men to cept age, race, and gender. Al
illness symptoms and to seek treatment earlier.
The medical profession has a long history of treating men and women dif- though catheterization was the
appropriate treatment for the de-
ferently. For example, research studies have shown that women treated for scribed symptoms, the physicians
heart disease are given more prescriptions, are more likely to be put through were much more likely to recom-
unnecessary diagnostic procedures, and are not likely to receive the same qual mend it for the younger, white,
ity of medical care as men (Ayanian & Epstein, 1991). In one study, 700 physi- male patients than for the older,
female, or black patients.
cians were asked to prescribe treatment for eight heart patients with identical
Source: "The Effect of Race and Sex on
were actors who dif-
symptoms (Schulman et al., 1999). In fact, the "patients" Physician's Recommendations for Cardiac
fered only in gender, race, and reported age (55 or 70). Although diagnosis is a Catherization," by K. A. Schulman, J.
Berlin, W. Harless, J. F. Kerner, S. Sistrunk,
judgment call, most cardiac specialists would agree that diagnostic catheteriza- B. J. Gersh, R. Dubé, C. K. Taleghani, J. E
tion is the appropriate treatment for the symptoms described by each hypo- Burke,S. Williams, J. M. Eisenberg, andJ.
Escarce, 1999, New England Journal of
thetical patient. However, the actual recommendations revealed a small, but Medicine, 340, pp. 618-625.
nevertheless significant, antifemale and antiblack bias. For the younger, white,
and male patients, catheterization was recommended 90, 91, and 91 percent of
the time, respectively; for the older, female, and black patients, 86, 85, and 85
percent of the time, respectively.
Problems such as these, and the underrepresentation of women as partici-
pants in medical research trials, have led to the criticisnm of gender bias in
health research and care. In response, the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
has issued detailed guidelines on the inclusion of women and minority groups
in medical research (Burd, 1994). In addition, the NIH recently launched the
Women's Health Initiative, a l5-year study of 160,000 postmenopausal women
focusing on the determinants, and prevention, of disability and death in older
30 PART 1Foundations of Health Psychology
biopsychosocial (mind-body)
perspective the viewpoint women. Among the targets of investigation in this eping study are
sweeping are e
that health and other porosis, breast cancer, and coronary heart disease.
osteo.
iors are determined behav By now,it's probablyclear to you that these perspectives overlap, that
teraction of biologicalby mecha-
the in-
view health and illness as the product of interacting actors. they all
They differ only in
nisms, psychological processes, the factors they emphasize. Although these perspectives answer
and social influences
tions about health, they complement, rather than contradict, one
different ques
another. T
gether, they help explain human health and illness. In a sense, the sociocultural
life-course, and gender perspectives are subsumed under the
biopsychosocial
perspective because that model, whether directuy or indirectiy, deals with
issues covered by the other allthe
will be on the
perspectives. For that reason, our focus in this tet
biopsychosocial perspective, to which we now turn.
abnormal.
predispose our behav-
dency to abuse alcohol has For example, the ten-
long been known to run in some
families (see
igure 14
Biologica
mechanisms The Biopsychosocial Model
According to the biopsychosocial
health behaviors are perspective, all
best explained in terms of
three contexts:
Psychological biological processes, psychologica
processes
BEHAVIOR processes, and social influences.
Source:
Psychology: A Biopsychosocial Approach, by C. Peter
son, 1997, New York:
Addison-Wesley Longman.
Socaln f u e n c e
TntroducingHeath Psychology cHAPtER 31
Chapter 8). One reason is that alcohol dependency is at least partly genetic, al
though it does not seem to be linked to a single. specihc gene. Instead. some
people may inherit a greater sensitivity to akcohol's physical effects, experien-
ing intonication as pleasurable and the aftermath of a hangover as minor. Such
people may be more likely to drink, especially in certain psychological and so-
aal contexts.
A key element of the biological context is our species' evolutionary history
Our characteristic human traits and behaviors exist as they do because they
helped our distant ancestors to survive long enough to reproduce and send
their genes into the future. For example. natural selection has favored the ten-
dency of people to become hungry in the presence of a mouth-watering aroma
see Chapter 7). This sensitivity to food-related cues makes evolutionary sense
in that eating is necessary for survival--particularly in the distant past when
food supplies were unpredictable and it was advantageous to have a healthy
appetite when food was available.
At the same time, biology and behavior constantty interact. For example,
some individuals are more vulnerable to stress-related ilnesses because they
angrily react to daily hassles and other environmental "triggers (see Chapter
4). Among men, increased amounts of the hormone testosterone are positively
correlated with this type of aggressive reaction. This relationship, however, is
recaproca: Angry outbursts can also lead to elevated testosterone levels. One of
the tasks of health psychology is to explain how (and why) this mutual influ-
ence between biology and behavior ocurs.
ABiopsychosocial Model of
Genetic Depression
predispositions Depression is best understood as
Insuficient
occuring in thre contexts: biolog
norepinephrine ical (genetic predispositions and
and serotonin neurotransmitter imbalances), psy.
Stressful activity Depressive chological (negative thinking and
events disorders self-defeating beliefs), and social
(stressful events, conditioned help
Negative lessness, and an individualistic
thinkng
culture that encourages self-blame
Culture for personal failure).
Source: Psychology: A Biopsychosocial Ap-
proach, by C. Peterson, 1997, New York:
Addison-Wesley Longman.
Depressed people tend to think about themselves, their world, and the future
grim ways (see Chapter 5). When unavoidable or uncontrollable painful
events occur, people who are vulnerable to depression tend to explain the
events as due to causes that are internal ("It's all my fault"), global ("It's going
to affect everything I do"), and stable (Tl never get over this"). In
cognitive
therapy, psychologists work with depressed clients to challenge and redirect
these negative beliefs.
On the social side, depression is often brought on by stressful experi-
ences-losing a job or a loved one, getting divorced, anything that challenges
a
person's sense of identity and self-esteem (Kendler, Neale, Kessler, Heath,&
Eaves, 1993). Martin Seligman (1991) has proposed that
and depression may be socially conditioned in
self-defeating beliefs
not influence
people who learn that they can-
important events in their lives. Just as laboratory animals who
receive unavoidable electric shocks become
passive and withdrawn, so too do
people who experience uncontrollable painful events.
As is true of other
psychological disorders, culture exerts an important in-
fluence on a
person's vulnerability to depression. Major depressive disorder is
much more common among
of individualism, which
young Westerners-perhaps
because of the rise
encourages the self-focused individual to accept per
sonal responsibility for all
problems. In contrast, in more close-knit, coopera-
tive non-Western cultures such as
Japan, depression is much rarer-perhaps
because problems are less
likely be tied to self-blame for personal taulure
to
(Seligman, I1995). Moreover, there is a birth cohort effect on
depression: Young8
North American adults are three times as
likely to report suffering
today as were their grandparents at any time during their lives depression
Canada, 1999). (Statistics,
Introducing Health Psychology | CHAPTER 1 | 35
ripe old age-shows dearly that the biopsychosocial model guides much of it.
in-
Applied health psychologists, who generally focus on health-promoting
terventions, are licensed for independent practice in areas such as clinical and
counseling psychology. As clinicians, they use the full range of diagnostic as
sessment and therapeutic techniques in psychology to promote health and as-
sist the physically ill. Assessment approaches frequently include measures of
cognitive functioning, psychophysiological assessment, demographic surveys,
and lifestyle or personality assessment. Interventions may include stress man-
agement, relaxation therapies, biofeedback, education about the role of psy
chological processes in disease, and cognitive-behavioral interventions.
Both individual and group interventions are commonly used. Further
more, interventions can be either direct or indirect. Direct intervention
would involve, for example, designing and implementing a program of re.
laxation training to help a patient cope with chronic pan. An indirect inter.
vention would be consulting with a patients physician to determine
whether the patient's psychological traits are intluencing his or her medical
treatment.
Interventions are not limited to those who are already suffering from a
health problem. Healthy or at-risk individuals may be taught preventive
healthy behaviors. Often health psychology interventions of this type focus on
buffering the negative impact of stress by promoting enhanced coping mecha
nisms or improved use of social support networks.
As the Human Genome Project moves toward pinpointing the precise role
every human gene, society will confront an explosion ot intormation, which
promises wondrous advances in disease diagnosis, treatment, and prevention
while raising challenging ethical and legal questions. Health psychologists are
expected to play essential roles in providing the research and clinical support
needed to grapple with this information. For example, in the research arena,
health psychologists are likely to be called on to explore issues such as the age
at which children should be permited to give informed consent for medical
treatment, the impact on the developing person of knowing that one is geneti-
callyvulnerable to a later chronic disease, and the impact of individual DNA
profiles on interpersonal relationships.