Address: 501, Pujit Plaza, Palm Beach Road, Date

Sector-11, Near CBD Station, Opp K-Star Hotel, 7/19/2022

CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra By
400614 MS
Name of Project-Rehabilitation and upgradation of existing road to two lane with paved shoulder configuration from Design chainage Km. 36/400 to
Km. 107/224 of NH-167BG from Duttaluru (at NH-565 junction) to Kavali (joining on NH-16) in the state of Andhra Pradesh on EPC mode.
two lane with paved shoulder in the State of Andhra Pradesh on EPC mode
Comments on Box Culvert_CH 50+454

Sr.
Comments from DCSL Compliance from Design Director Remarks
No.

1 Kindly add the calculation for braking force as per IRC 6:2017 Cl. Design note
211.2 MNB(1x10x2m)
Kindly apply the impact factor for Vehicular loading as per IRC Design note
2 6:2017 Cl. 208 MNB(1x10x2m)
In design, Maximum crack width at Midspan of Bottom Slab is Pg no-28,Design note
0.388mm which is exceeding permissible crack width as 0.3mm MNB(1x10x2m)
3 for severe condition as per IRC 112, Table12.1. Kindly redesign
and resubmit.
4 In design, Maximum stresses in steel at Bottom of Side wall is Pg no- 40, Design note
467.88Mpa which is exceeding permissible stresses as 300Mpa MNB(1x10x2m)
(taken to avoid fatigue check for rare combination as per IRC 112-
2011 Ammendment Oct13,A-8). Kindly redesign and resubmit.

In design, Maximum crack width at Bottom of Side wall is Pg no- 41, Design note
0.739mm which is exceeding permissible crack width as 0.3mm MNB(1x10x2m)
5 for severe condition as per IRC 112, Table12.1. Kindly redesign
and resubmit.

Slope of stone pitching shall be 2:1 in width direction as per SP GAD, DRG No. HELP-
13:2004 according to Plate 18. STR-MNB-GAD-06 (SH
6 01 OF 02)

7 Design note
Please provide Hydrology report MNB(1x10x2m)
8 GAD, DRG No. HELP-
Mention the name of Design consultant and Authority engineer in STR-MNB-GAD-06 (SH
Drawings. 01 OF 02)

9 Please provide Geotech report

 Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Moment
Node L/C Fx Mton Fy Mton Fz Mton Mx kN-m My kN-m Mz kN-m
201 101 -5.696 105.808 3.514 298.852 -0.119 502.131
102 -5.902 105.628 3.806 322.559 -0.119 519.122
103 -18.398 48.361 8.052 687.720 -0.357 1612.228
104 -9.851 97.242 21.751 1766.704 -0.392 851.109
105 -30.339 -27.689 7.300 590.522 -0.827 2588.419
202 101 -6.037 143.582 3.509 299.436 -0.084 522.256
102 -6.244 144.549 3.801 323.144 -0.084 539.287
103 -18.584 209.200 8.003 687.990 -0.276 1629.906
104 -10.180 184.382 21.654 1765.774 -0.104 871.830
105 -30.106 242.745 7.218 590.778 -0.728 2597.602
203 101 -5.761 111.136 3.466 296.096 -0.011 506.159
102 -5.967 110.582 3.762 320.033 -0.011 523.167
103 -18.496 40.700 8.143 692.620 -0.033 1617.535
104 -9.956 60.210 22.208 1790.031 -0.051 856.109
105 -30.452 -34.850 7.392 595.541 -0.310 2594.158
204 101 -6.017 149.265 3.477 297.572 -0.010 521.527
102 -6.224 149.859 3.773 321.508 -0.010 538.553
103 -18.584 202.332 8.105 693.420 -0.032 1629.756
104 -10.161 147.641 22.109 1788.972 -0.145 869.851
105 -30.135 236.549 7.298 594.988 -0.337 2598.711
205 101 -5.767 104.059 3.360 290.017 0.011 506.682
102 -5.974 103.465 3.656 313.954 0.011 523.709
103 -18.512 32.227 8.046 687.071 0.034 1618.491
104 -9.997 55.197 22.197 1789.184 0.146 858.313
105 -30.466 -36.447 7.373 594.649 0.339 2594.812
206 101 -5.996 145.264 3.378 291.852 0.009 520.608
102 -6.203 145.818 3.674 315.789 0.009 537.616
103 -18.554 196.935 8.010 687.935 0.031 1628.162
104 -10.124 143.089 22.094 1787.770 0.052 867.639
105 -30.124 235.525 7.264 592.786 0.309 2597.951
207 101 -5.740 67.529 3.140 277.308 0.085 504.842
102 -5.947 66.562 3.432 301.016 0.085 521.874
103 -18.494 -14.477 7.718 668.129 0.280 1616.471
104 -9.996 0.315 21.668 1757.097 0.101 856.933
105 -30.414 -61.480 7.128 580.726 0.735 2590.339
208 101 -5.988 113.767 3.156 279.045 0.117 519.944
102 -6.195 113.947 3.448 302.751 0.117 536.935
103 -18.533 154.832 7.676 668.519 0.353 1626.083
104 -10.128 89.838 21.579 1756.431 0.393 866.604
105 -30.126 210.864 7.011 578.127 0.819 2596.490

Maximum Axial Load -5.696 242.745 22.208 1790.031 0.819 2598.711

Minimum Axial Load -30.466 -61.480 3.140 277.308 -0.827 502.131