You are on page 1of 35

RUNNING HEAD: EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 1

EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING APPROACH ON JUNIOR

HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE

Miara Margarette Chin

Ma. Antonette Tabil

Christian Isaac De Joya

Research 1

Teacher Mirasol Ramos

April 8, 2022
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 2

CHAPTER 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction

COVID-19 had a profound impact on the majority of people's lives around the world.

Due to the sheer existence of the virus, particularly how it continues to spread from person to

person; social traits, interactions, and lifestyles have been drastically altered. Shops and stores,

as well as the tourism industry, were forced to close due to the disease's threat, and even a

lockdown was implemented. Moreover, schools were also closed, allowing students to take a

break from their studies.

As a result, the traditional learning method of school systems all over the world has

shifted into other modes of learning based on the availability of resources. While other schools

offer modular learning, most private schools shifted to Online Distance Learning. This is a

mode of learning that makes use of information and communication technologies.

One of the components of Online Distance learning is the physical separation of the

teacher and the learners. It takes place in the context of an institution of learning where

technical media are used; teachers and students interact online, and a model of an educational

platform is used. It is also being accomplished through the internet by the transmission of

lectures, presentations, and learning materials. Students work from home and are expected to

attend scheduled online classes and complete all learning materials. This mode of learning

allows students to learn independently, interactively, and collaboratively.


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 3

As physical contact with others is no longer permitted, online distance learning is

highly valued and essential. However, in terms of student engagement, satisfaction, and

interaction, the online distance learning environment differs significantly from the traditional

classroom setting, according to the learners' perspectives. The learning style, in particular,

varies according to the type of learning medium used. Traditional education is primarily

concerned with face-to-face classroom education that is led by a teacher who supervises the

learning activities. Meanwhile, online distance learning is more self-sufficient, as it is

dependent on the students' learning capabilities and flexibility. It has the potential to meet the

increasing demand for training and education by providing educational opportunities through

online classes (Zawacki-Richter & Naidu, 2016). Enrolled students in accessible virtual

classrooms will eventually work asynchronously, with all materials provided digitally.

Although there are deadlines for assignment submissions, students who work at their own pace

will have some flexibility in terms of when they complete their work (Campus Explorer,

2019).

With the given advantages of Online Distance Learning in the present state of education,

the researchers conducted this study to determine the effects of online distance learning among

Junior High School learners. In comparison to previous studies, this study aims to determine the

learners’ academic performance as well as to gather JHS students’ perspectives on participating

in ODL. In doing this research, the academic performance of learners during face-to-face and

online distance learning are being examined.

Statement of the Problem

The purpose of this research is to identify the effects of online distance learning on Junior

High School students’ academic performance.


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 4

Particularly, the researchers aim to answer the following questions:

1. What are the effects of online distance learning to the academic performance of the

Junior High School learners?

2. What are the difficulties encountered by Junior High School Learners during online

distance learning?

3. Is there a significant difference between the academic performance among JHS learners

during SY 2019-2020 and SY 2020-2021?

Objectives of the Study

The researchers intend to accomplish the following objectives:

● to identify the effects of online distance learning to the academic performance of the

Junior High School learners;

● to identify the difficulties encountered by Junior High School Learners during online

distance learning; and

● to determine whether there's a significant difference in the academic performance of

Junior High School learners in the school year 2019-2020 and 2020-2021.

Hypothesis

Alternative Hypothesis: There's a significant difference in the academic performance of

Junior High School learners in the School Year 2019-2020 and 2020-2021.

Null Hypothesis: There is no significant difference between the means of General Weighted

Average of the Junior High School learners in the SY 2019-2020 and SY 2020-2021.

Significance of the Study

The Students. Students will be able to recognize and share their experiences during online and
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 5

face-to-face learning. Moreover, it will help them to understand more about the Coronavirus

(COVID 19) epidemic.

Junior High School Learners. They will gain knowledge from this research by understanding

the similarities and differences between online distance learning and face- to-face learning.

They will realize that ODL makes them more independent and provides them at their own pace

while learning.

The Teachers. Through this research, teachers will see the difference between the academic

performance of the students between online distance learning and face-to-face learning. In this

manner, they will be able to create and plan more engaging activities that will help the students

understand the lessons and discussions online while also allowing the students to enjoy the

learning process that the teacher has prepared.

The School Administrations. The study will serve as an awareness in the future indicating

what had happened to learners' education during the time of the pandemic. This will help them

understand the problems and generate some ideas for schools to use in evaluating their systems.

Furthermore, it may contribute to the literature on online education in terms of quality

assurance. They will also identify where they lack and seek to strengthen their school systems

in which they will embrace new challenges for them to gain knowledge. It will help them build

a proper environment that would academically qualify students well.

The DepEd Authorities. They will be able to determine the needs to be improved in this type

of learning so that in the future the learners will be able to engage in online distance learning in

the most efficient way possible.

Scope and Delimitation

The primary goal of the study is to differentiate the learning process of the school year
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 6

2019-2020 and the year 2020-2021. Furthermore, the study aims to determine whether there's a

significant difference in the academic performance of Junior High School learners during face-

to- face and Online Distance Learning (ODL).

The collection of data in this study will be through online surveys via Google forms.

The questionnaires that will be administered are created by the researchers. Furthermore, the

respondents of this study are the selected Junior High School Learners from Philippine Yuh

Chiau School. The research will be conducted virtually with the permission of the advisory

class of each grade level and the school administration.

Definition of Terms

To gain a better understanding and knowledge of the study, the researchers developed

several thematically and well-defined terms that were used in the study.

Academic Performance- It is the evaluation of student achievement in a variety of academic

subjects. Teachers and education officials typically determine students’ academic performance

based on classroom performance, academic achievement, and test scores. In this study, the

researchers will be focusing on the General Weighted Average of the Junior High School

learners between the School Year 2020-2021 and the School Year 2019-2020 in order to see

the progress of the learners when it comes to the two different learning methods.

Coronavirus disease (Covid-19)- It is an infectious disease that generally began in the year

2019 and includes a variety of symptoms such as a dry cough, loss of smell and taste,

diarrhea, and others.

Face to Face Learning- Face-to-face learning is an educational setup in which students and

teachers meet in person at the same time. It enables direct interaction between a student and a

teacher. The students who study at a face-to-face learning institute attend classes daily.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 7

Online Distance Learning- It is a type of remote learning method wherein the student is not

physically present in a classroom. It requires the use of the internet as well as various types of

gadgets.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 8

Chapter II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter presents relevant works of literature and studies that provide information to

help the researcher analyze and formulate ideas about the study's data. 

Related Literature

Coronavirus Disease (Covid-19)

The recent outbreak of the novel coronavirus SARSCoV2, which began in the People's

Republic of China's Hubei Province, has spread to many other countries. Based on increasing

case alert rates in Chinese and international locations, the WHO Emergency Committee declared

a global health emergency in January 2020. The case detection rate changes on a daily basis and

can be tracked in near real-time on the Johns Hopkins University website and other forums.

The SARS-CoV-2 virus largely affects the respiratory system, though it also affects other

organ systems. The initial case series from Wuhan, China reported lower respiratory tract

infection-related symptoms such as fever, dry cough, and dyspnea. Headache, dizziness,

generalized weakness, vomiting, and diarrhea were also reported. It is now widely acknowledged

that COVID-19 respiratory symptoms are extremely heterogeneous, ranging from mild

symptoms to severe hypoxia with ARDS (Yuki, K., Fujiogi, M., & Koutsogiannaki, S., 2020).

Ever since the outbreak, the Chinese government and scientific community have moved

quickly to identify the infectious agent, distribute the highly contagious gene sequence, and

implement measures to handle the epidemic. Meanwhile, new research has revealed important

aspects of SARS-CoV-2 biology and disease pathogenesis; other studies have focused on
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 9

epidemiology, clinical features, diagnosis, management, and drug and vaccine development (Shi,

Y., Wang, G., Cai, X. P., Deng, J. W., Zheng, L., Zhu, H. H., ... & Chen, Z., 2020).

According to Dr. Neha Pathak MD (2021), COVID-19 usually spreads when a sick

person coughs or sneezes. They can spray aerosol droplets up to 6 feet away. Some people

infected with the virus do not exhibit symptoms, but they can still spread the virus. Furthermore,

you can catch the virus by touching a virus-infected surface or items located in public and then

touching your face. Most viruses can survive for several hours after landing on a surface.

Impacts of Covid-19 on Education

Furthermore, the Coronavirus outbreak had a negative impact on educational activities all

over the world including widespread school closures (Wikipedia,2020). It caused significant

disruptions in academic activities as well as career plans. Both public and private higher

education institutions have had to adapt to the new scenario, which prohibits face-to-face

interaction and mass gatherings. Teachers and administrators were tasked with modifying and

changing course materials and requirements from the comfort of their own homes as they

transitioned to alternative or remote teaching modalities, both synchronous and asynchronous.

Learning management systems like Canvas, Blackboard, as well as applications like Google

Hangouts, Zoom, and Skype were employed when students and teachers had access to electronic

devices and dependable Internet connections. Where students had limited access to computers or

unreliable Internet connectivity, teachers and students used text messaging, e-mail, Facebook

Messenger, and Twitter to communicate messages, notes, and resources (The Head

Foundation,2020). However, since some schools are unable to adjust to remote learning due to

the absence of internet connectivity, the Department of Education informed the public that
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 10

around 26 million enrolled learners will obtain increased quality self-learning modules (SLMs).

San Antonio noted the Department's quality assurance approach for learning resources, which

was improved as early as January of the year 2021.  The Department of Education also worked

with the Philippine Normal University to double-check the materials. Moreover, the Bureau of

Learning Delivery (BLD) prioritized SLM Enhancement, which aimed to create better versions

of the materials and offer teachers support through notes to teachers (DepEd,2021).

School closures occur as a result of a pandemic, emergencies, labor strikes, catastrophes,

or deliberate efforts to reposition a school or reduce crime on a specific campus or environment.

This means that school closures are used not only for emergencies or pandemics but also to

address some identified gaps in a particular school. School closures, according to Erika and

Nicholas (2020), can be either reactive or proactive. While proactive school closure occurs

before the disease reaches the school's doors. According to Madeline (2020), school closures due

to coronavirus have created new issues, such as how to transition to online and at-home learning,

and how to accommodate those who rely on school for food and housing security. School

closures due to coronavirus tend to put additional strain on students, teachers, and parents,

particularly those with limited digital skills, education, and resources for continuing education. It

places an additional burden on parents, who must not only struggle to provide for their families,

but also perform the supervision task of ensuring that their children learn at home.

Online Distance Learning

Covid-19, in an unprecedented turn of events, has changed the way students are educated

around the globe within a short period (Chung, Subramaniam, & Dass, 2020). Following the

coronavirus (Covid-19) outbreak, which was later declared a pandemic by the World Health
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 11

Organization, the educational system worldwide experienced near-complete closures of schools,

colleges, and universities (WHO). Inevitably, these institutions' stakeholders have been greatly

affected in light of the halted teaching and learning routines.

With the advancement of technology, online distance learning is becoming more common

in the education of students. Many students are familiar with the term "online distance learning,"

which refers to online learning and teaching programs offered by world-class educational

institutions. Unlike traditional classroom education, students are virtually enrolled in their

programs and corresponding classes online (Dhawan, S., 2020).

In an online distance learning setup, students can get their learning materials via e-mail or

the internet. Learning assessments can take the form of written exams or assignments,

performance tasks, or portfolios. Students can also ask for support via their email, messenger, or

instant messaging applications used by their teachers (Moore, J. L., Dickson-Deane, C., &

Galyen, K., 2011).

Online distance learning is the "traditional" self-study course. Teachers mail learning

materials to students, or they can get them online. Students must also complete the learning

assignments according to the schedules that have been provided to them. The students and

teachers can utilize the internet to receive and submit assignments (Kearsley, G., & Moore, M.

G., 2011).

Online learning mainly relies on the internet as a tool for education. Students and

teachers are physically separated, but they can interact during virtual lectures and other online

assessments. Classes are scheduled at a specific time, with students needing to be online to
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 12

attend the virtual lecture. In this setup, students can also ask questions to their teachers in real-

time. (Sousa, S., 2021)

Academic Performance

Several scholars have defined and described academic success. According to Narad and

Abdullah (2016), academic performance is the information learned that is measured by a teacher

through marks and/or educational goals set by students and instructors to be achieved within a

particular time period.

Academic performance difficulties begin with its conceptualization. It is also known as

academic preparedness or school readiness. Achievement and school performance, but because

they are synonyms, the gap in semantics is the only method to communicate things the majority

of the time. As a criterion, academic success has always been agreed upon. In university

populations and academic success in both traditional and alternative schools’ populations with

basic education.

Several writers believe that academic achievement is the consequence of learning, which

is motivated by the teacher's instructional activity and created by the student. Martinez (2007)

defines academic achievement as "the output supplied by the students and it is generally

indicated through school grades" from a humanistic perspective. Pizarro (1985) defined

academic performance fifteen years ago as a measure of the indicative and responsive capacities

that convey, in an approximated fashion, what a person has learned as a result of an educational

or training process.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 13

According to the Deped(2020), in Memorandum OUCI-2020-307, Undersecretary for

Curriculum and Instruction Diosdado San Antonio offered ten highly recommended measures to

enhance flexibility in learning. It’s also the request of the teachers and students to make the

implementation of online distance learning components easier. Reconsidering time allotment for

learners to complete and submit activities; and expanding mental health/socio-emotional well-

being support to teachers, learners, and parents through group wellness sessions are some of the

measures recommended.

Related Studies

The COVID-19 outbreak has had a significant impact on almost every aspect of our

society. There is no exception in higher education. Students face an increasingly uncertain

environment, where financial and academic resources are limited. Health shocks (for example, a

lack of resources to finish their studies or the fear of becoming seriously ill) may have impacted

their academic performance, as well as the transition to online learning.(Aucejo. et al, 2020)

According to Barrot et al. (2020), students faced many obstacles in a home learning

environment, such as lack of mastery of technology, high Internet cost, and limited

interaction/socialization between and among students. Lockdown impacted students’ learning

performance. Its lockdown made significant disruptions in students’ learning experience. The

students also reported some challenges that they faced during their online classes. These include

anxiety, depression, poor Internet service, and an unfavorable home learning environment, which

were aggravated when students are marginalized.


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 14

Since online learning before the pandemic is unusual in the Philippines and the traditional

teaching method is face-to-face, numerous issues concerning the difficulties and challenges that

faculty members and students face in the use of online education, as well as the quality of

education received, were observed (Avila, et al. 2021). Some of students have a negative

perception of distance learning education, believing it to be of poor quality. However, new tools

and techniques, e-learning, new courses, and instructors are also playing important roles in

distance education and increasing student satisfaction. Distance education is utilizing new

technologies and improving services in developed countries, which is encouraging. In addition, a

lack of institutional supports, such as classrooms, face-to-face learning, and instructional

materials, necessitates the use of distance education. As a result, students who easily adapted to

online education had seen their progress on their academic performance. (Avila, et al. 2021)

What this study has in common with other related studies is that, it all defines what

online distance learning is and shows how online distance learning affects the students' overall

performance. Besides that, several students also express their views regarding online distance

learning. However, there are also differences between the related studies from this paper such

that, this study focuses more on the academic performance of the Junior High School learners.

More than that, factors that affects their academic performance were further described in this

study.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 15

CHAPTER III

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This chapter describes the researchers' method, the study's design, as well as the

research locale and the respondents. Moreover, the sampling technique, data gathering

instruments, and data gathering procedure were all presumed to gain a better understanding of

how the researchers collect and analyze data.

Research Design

The designs used in the study are descriptive and correlational design. Descriptive

research is one of the main forms of research design. It is a definitive quantitative research

approach used to evaluate certain hypotheses and characterize traits or functions. It is

quantitative research since it aims to collect and statistically assess information. It is a useful

research method that allows a researcher to collect data and explain its demographics via

statistical analysis.

The researchers will also utilize a correlational design to examine the relationship

between two variables and to distinguish the variables presented in the study. The goal of

correlational research is to identify variables that are related to each other in such a way that a

change in one causes a change in the other. Correlational research is non-experimental in the

sense that it does not involve manipulating variables in order to agree or disagree with a

hypothesis. 

With the help of correlational design, the researchers will be able to compare the

students' academic performance during ODL and face-to-face learning. Furthermore, after

comparing the grades obtained by the Junior High School Learners during face-to-face and

online distance learning, the researchers will gather the data and apply descriptive design by
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 16

analyzing and forming statistical graphs that include the grades of the Junior High School

Students.

Research Locale

The researchers chose Philippine Yuh Chiau School as their research locale. The

researchers believe that this school is ideal for the study to be conducted for a variety of  

reasons. First, the school's setting is easily available. Second, the student’s population.

Respondents

  The respondents of this study are Junior High School students of Philippine Yuh Chiau

School. The respondents were chosen considering their experience with online distance learning

and feedback to distinguish which educational platform enhanced their academic performance,

face-to-face or online learning.

The whole population of the Junior High School Learners at Philippine Yuh Chiau

School consists of 256 students in total. The researchers used Slovin's formula to calculate the

appropriate sample size for the given population. As a result, the researchers got 156 as the

sample size. Furthermore, the respondents were chosen through the use of simple random

sampling.

Out of the 156 respondents, 126 learners submitted their response through the survey.

This results to a response rate of 80.8% which is above the typical response rate according to

Lindsay Willcot, 2019. Moreover, the researcher stated that a survey response rate higher than

50% should be considered excellent in most circumstances.

Sampling Technique
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 17

In choosing the respondents of this study the researchers used simple random sampling.

This is a probability sampling procedure in which the researcher randomly selects a small portion

of a population. Each of them has an equal chance to be chosen. Moreover, the researchers

compiled a list of all the Junior High School Learners in Philippine Yuh Chiau School and

choose 156 of them.

Data Gathering Instruments

  In order to answer the questions presented in the study, the researchers conducted a

variety of measurements and used various materials to get the necessary information for this

study. 

These materials were utilized in order to gather the data needed for these studies:

● Consent Form: used to ask respondents for their consent to take part in the study that the

researchers are conducting

● Survey questionnaire: research instrument composed of a sequence of questions

designed to obtain data from respondents

● Google Form: used as the main instrument on the data gathering on the conducted

research because the platform is used to obtain the data that the researchers need

● Permission letter: used to communicate and verify the researcher's participation with an

organization. It is addressed to the principal

Data Gathering Procedures

The data gathering procedure began with the writing of letters, the completion of

consent forms, and the participation of the respondents.


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 18

The permission letter was obtained from the principal and the respondents in order to

establish a formal connection and to explain any essential information regarding the research

and its objectives.

After obtaining the necessary approval and writing the consent form, the researchers

administered a survey to the chosen Junior High School students. Following this, the

researchers compiled all of the responses to the surveys from the students.

After collecting the necessary data, it was handled with statistical tools in order to

obtain the necessary data required through the use of central tendency and inferential statistics.

Finally, it will be interpreted and presented through the use of charts and graphs.

Statistical Treatment of Data

         To collect the needed samples, the researchers used central tendency and inferential

statistics, which are as follows:

● Mean: This is also known as the average of certain data which is the total of a collection

of data divided by the number of data sets.

● T-test: It is a form of inferential statistic used to determine whether or not there is a

significant difference between the means of two groups that may be connected in some

way.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 19

CHAPTER IV

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter focuses on the presentation of findings and the interpretation of data which

includes the data tables and graphs. Moreover, the findings in this section were organized in

accordance with the research objectives.

Learning in the New Normal

The researchers asked the Junior High School students to determine what they like most

about online distance learning. The figures below show the things that Junior High School

learners like during online distance learning.

Figure 1. Things that the Junior High School Learners like during Online Distance Learning
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 20

As an outcome, 57.9 % of them stated that online distance education enables them to

adapt to a wide variety of learning styles. In addition, 57.1% of the respondents stated that it

allowed them to be flexible in their study schedule.

However, there are 0.8% votes of learning despite the pandemic. Similarly, there are

responses that also received 0.8% of votes, such as it teaches them to be more responsible, to

avoid being late as much as they used to be because they are only at home, and to have their eyes

opened to new branches and new visions.

One of the primary advantage of electronic distance learning, according to Bijeesh(2017),

is the flexibility it provides students. You can learn at your own pace. In online learning, students

are not required to attend class at the exact time and location, so they can complete their classes

at their own pace and convenience. You can learn it from anywhere and at any time.

Figure 2. Least interesting aspects of Online Distance Learning according to the students
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 21

Meanwhile, in the figure above, the students responded to which aspect of class they find

the least interesting. Subsequently, 50.8% of them indicated a lack of social interaction with

other students. At the same time, making performance tasks received the fewest votes with 0.8%.

Despite the numerous benefits of online distance learning, students face some challenges

that ultimately result in negative outcomes. In their study, Arkorful and Abaidoo (2015)

discovered that students in online courses held through remoteness and contemplation experience

a lack of interaction. In terms of material equipment and Internet connectivity, there is still a

significant disparity among students. Furthermore, many students lack sufficient knowledge of

how to use technology to enhance their classroom experiences.

Junior High School Students’ Academic Performance

To infer the difference between the academic performance of the Junior High School

learners in Online Distance Learning and Face-to-Face learning, the researchers asked them to

indicate their degree of agreement or disagreement in the ten statements that constitutes to the

aspects that affects academic performance.

The mean and standard deviation were calculated by the researchers. The means were

interpreted as follows: strongly disagree in the range of 1.00-1.75, disagree 1.76-2.51, agree

2.52-3.27 and strongly agree 3.28-4.00.

Table 1. Descriptive Interpretation of Weighted Mean (Pimentel, 2010)

Likert-Scale Description Likert-Scale Likert Scale Interval


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 22

1 1.00-1.75
Strongly Disagree

Disagree 2 1.76-2.51

Agree 3 2.52-3.27

Strongly Agree
4 3.28-4.00

Table 2 shows the Junior High School Students’ perceived effects of online distance

learning in their academic performance in comparison with their academic performance during

face-to-face learning.

Table 2. JHS Learners’ Perceptions Towards Online Distance Learning

Criteria Mean Standard Verbal


Deviation Description

1. I prefer online distance learning rather than face- 2.13 0.95 Disagree
to-face learning. 
2. I am more engaged in online distance learning 2.06 0.860 Disagree 
compared to face-to-face learning.
3. Online distance learning increased my 2.91 0.84 Agree 
opportunity to access and use information.
4. I understand class discussions better in online 2.21 2.21 Disagree 
distance learning
5. I manage my own learning better in online 2.57 0.92 Agree 
distance learning.
6. I have more opportunities to reflect on what I 2.63 0.834 Agree 
have learned in online distance learning.
7. There are more opportunities to collaborate with 2.28 0.86 Disagree 
other students in online distance learning.
8. I have a friendlier class schedule in online 2.74 0.98 Agree 
distance learning.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 23

9. There are lesser distractions in online distance 1.74 0.80 Strongly


learning. Disagree 
10. Response time from teachers is quicker in 1.96 0.80 Disagree 
online distance learning.

In the table above, only statement numbers 3, 5, 6 and 8 got a mean that falls under the

category agree. This means that online distance learning increased learners' access and use of

information. They manage their own learning more effectively and they have more opportunities

to reflect on what they have learned through online distance education. Besides that, they have a

more accommodating class schedule in online distance learning.

However, the data also indicates that there are more disagreements than agreements, such

as the fact that they continue to prefer face-to-face learning over online learning. They are also

more engaged and understand class discussions better when they meet face to face. Additionally,

the learners disagreed that online distance learning offers numerous opportunities for

collaboration with other students. Lastly, they happen to disagree that online distance learning

has fewer distractions.

Difficulties Encountered by Junior High School Learners in Online Distance Learning

Figure 3. Difficulties encountered by the learners during Online Distance Learning


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 24

According to the figure, the majority of learners (79.4%) experience and struggle as a

result of poor internet connection during online distance learning. Some of those who owned

smartphones have no Internet connection due to high cost and the availability of Internet services

at their homes and thus could not use them for educational purposes (Delfino, 2019). Meanwhile,

the least-voted difficulties they face are social interaction or a lack of communication, personal

and mental health issues, and performance tasks in which their group members do not

participate.

Coates (2007) stated that there is growing recognition of the importance of understanding

student engagement and the problem of disengagement in tertiary institutions. Investigating

factors affecting engagement and disengagement can provide insights into student performance,

progression and retention. Assessment of engagement is potentially useful when evaluating the

quality of student learning experiences and making decisions about resource provision, course

content and delivery.

Comparison of the Academic Performance of Junior High School Students During Online

Distance Learning and Face-to-Face Learning

The means of General Weighted Average of the respondents in the SY 2019-2020 is

91.99. In the SY 2020-2021, the mean of the respondents’ General Weighted Average is 92.40.

T-test was used to calculate if there is a significant difference between the General Weighted

Average in the SY 2019-2020 and SY 2020-2021 of the respondents.

Table 3. Average Mean of both school year 2019-2020 and 2020-2021

Mean of GWA (SY 2019-2020) 91.99

Mean of GWA (SY 2020-2021) 92.40


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 25

Standard error of difference 0.2651

Degrees of freedom 107

Two-tailed p-value 0.2654

T-Score 1.5036

Source: https://www.meta-calculator.com/

The computed p-Value is 0.2654. Decision Rule (Johnson & Kuby, 2013), if the p-value

(two-tail) is less than or equal to the level of significance (0.05), the decision must be to reject

null hypothesis. If the p-value (two-tail) is greater than the level of significance (0.05), then the

decision must be to accept null hypothesis. The computed p-value is greater than the level of

significance which indicates that there is no significant difference in the means of General

Weighted Average of the Junior High School learners in the SY 2019-2020 and SY 2020-2021.

The current study shows that there is no significant difference in the performance of the

students between online and traditional classroom. Despite the sample size issues and study

limitations, this assessment shows that both online and classroom learners perform at the same

level.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 26

CHAPTER V

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

Conclusion

The main goal of this study is to determine the effects of online distance learning to the

academic performance of the Junior High School learners. Based from the data gathered, there

are students who improved during online distance learning because it provided them with many

opportunities to learn new things and it constantly tested their time management and self-

learning abilities. Some students, however, claim that face-to-face learning is more enjoyable

and that they are more engaged in the traditional way of learning.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 27

While learners still prefer face-to-face learning than online distance learning, it is evident

that there is a slight increase in their GWA during the first year of ODL. However, when the

means of the General Weighted Average of the learners in the SY 2019-2020 and SY 2020-2021

were compared using T-test, the computed p-Value is 0.2654. Hence, the researchers conclude

that the academic performance of the students during Online Distance Learning and Face-to-Face

learning do not differ significantly.

Moreover, this indicates that even if difficulties like poor internet connection and

unavoidable distractions from home were encountered while studying under Online Distance

Learning, the change in the learning modality did not cause significant change in the academic

performance of the students. learning.

Recommendation

After thorough analysis and interpretation of the gathered data, the researchers recommend the

following:

For the school and the teachers….

- To make their class more engaging during ODL, they can start their classes with games

or activities so that the students will be more eager to learn and explore the topics to be

discussed.

- They should produce more interactive activities so that the students will be more engaged

with the class.

For future researchers….


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 28

- They should limit the number of respondents in order to obtain high-quality responses

rather than a large number of responses. They can also use other research designs to

reduce the number of respondents.

- They should include a reference list at the end of each chapter to make compiling

resources for the research paper easier.

Reference List

Factors Affecting Students’ Academic Performance By Irfan Mushtaq & Shabana Nawaz Khan

(https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/49686973/3-Factors-Affecting-Students-

Academic-with-cover-page- v2.pdf?

Expires=1638241783&Signature=e2HdL~mdyQd00sE2jSHBLB-

a0kQAcboAISt~T0GOyP6a417ZvMx51ye~LnCNJONOT2sHgl9Tj1SflXvm88fPlOWjM

89gzfYIJhHqXZVmTQTk1LhwJuWUL71VrPVD3S88rZ2raoV5454E-
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 29

gNoVcHUIxgtFImLedG56ypPGmv6wVv-

lymoDbVdLDxGIgWFJBmp3hVvaGb3IMSttdOWQBANIFzPfrw54NTbqOUOqmziGy

HZwvCO7Mgp2fphXMg85BYJVK6TaNzeC62H0shefS5V1b4TQfu~HY1~wD3cKtSUu

\3bjE2HPtu-MvZrTTDUSxrnWVgLhs6bxoiS9Y0hiHCmWmQ__&Key-Pair-

Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA)

What is Distance Learning why is it so important (What Is Distance Learning? And Why Is It So

Important? - ViewSonic Library

Academic Performance: School Performance Lamas, H. (2015). School Performance. Propósitos

y Representaciones, 3(1), 313-386. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.20511/pyr2015.v3n1.74

(https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1135350.pdf)

Analysis of earliest covid-19 cases points to Wuhan market as a source

(https://www.newscientist.com/article/2298195-analysis-of-earliest-covid-19-cases-

points-to-wuhan-market-as-source/)

Coronavirus and COVID-19: What You Should Know

(https://www.webmd.com/lung/coronavirus)

COVID-19 pathophysiology: A review

(https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7169933/)

Distance Learning (Distance Learning Essay | Dissertationmasters.com)

Distance Learning in the Philippines: Is It the Best Method for Your

Child?(https://www.moneymax.ph/lifestyle/articles/distance-learning-philippines)
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 30

FACTORS AFFECTING STUDENTS’ PERFORMANCE IN OPEN AND DISTANCE

LEARNING: A CASE STUDY OF KINONDONI REGIONAL CENTRE

(http://repository.out.ac.tz/1329/1/DISSERTATION_-_SAID_LUKWEKWE_FINAL.pd)

Online Distance Learning Amidst Covid-19 Pandemic Among University Students: A

practicality of Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modelling

Approach(https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1274172.pdf)

SARS-CoV-2: an Emerging Coronavirus that Causes a Global Threat

(https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7098030/)

The COVID‐19 epidemic (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7169770/)

Aucejo, E. M., French, J., Araya, M. P. U., & Zafar, B. (2020). The Impact of COVID-19 on

Student Experiences and Expectations: Evidence from a Survey. Journal of Public

Economics, 191(104271), 104271. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104271

Average Survey Response Rate – What You Need to Know

 Barrot, J. S., Llenares, I. I., & del Rosario, L. S. (2021). Students’ online learning challenges

during the pandemic and how they cope with them: The case of the Philippines.

Education and Information Technologies, 26(7321–7338).

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-021-10589-x

Daniel. (2020, March 10). What Is Distance Learning? And Why Is It So Important? ViewSonic

Library. https://www.viewsonic.com/library/education/what-is-distance-learning-and-

why-is-it-so-important/#:~:text=The%20top%20benefit%20of%20distance

Distance Learning in the Philippines: What You Need to Know. (2020, June 9). Moneymax.
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 31

https://www.moneymax.ph/lifestyle/articles/distance-learning-philippines

Distance Learning: The Ultimate Guide to Online Learning

(Distance Learning: The Ultimate Guide to Online Learning (educationcorner.com)

FACTORS AFFECTING STUDENTS’ PERFORMANCE IN OPEN AND DISTANCE

LEARNING: A CASE STUDY OF KINONDONI REGIONAL CENTRE SAID

ABDALLAH LUKWEKWE A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL

FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF DEGREE OF MASTERS OF

DISTANCE EDUCATION OF THE OPEN UNIVERSITY OF TANZANIA (2015)

http://repository.out.ac.tz/1329/1/DISSERTATION_-_SAID_LUKWEKWE_FINAL.pdf

https://www.customerthermometer.com/customer-surveys/average-survey-response-

rate/#:~:text=A%20survey%20response%20rate%20of,range%20are%20far%20more

%20typi

Impact of Coronavirus Pandemic on Education (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_ZUwi4-

nNUyKEddVJG- mHH3WnsJbnbUsnyXqOe6V-CM/edit#)

 Lamas, H. A. (2015). School Performance. Propósitos Y Representaciones, 3(1), 351–386.

https://doi.org/10.20511/pyr2015.v3n1.74

 Mushtaq, I., & Khan, S. N. (2012). Global Journal of Management and Business Research

Factors Affecting Students’ Academic Performance Factors Affecting Students’

Academic Performance. https://globaljournals.org/GJMBR_Volume12/3-Factors-

Affecting-Students-Academic.pdf

Page, M. L. (2021, November 25). Analysis of earliest covid-19 cases points to Wuhan market as

source. New Scientist. Retrieved March 31, 2022, from

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2298195-analysis-of-earliest-covid-19-cases-
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 32

points-to-wuhan-market-as-source/ 

Samat, M. F., Awang, N. A., Hussin, S. N. A., & Mat Nawi, F. A. (2020). Online Distance

Learning Amidst Covid-19 Pandemic Among University Students. Asian Journal of

University Education, 16(3), 220. https://doi.org/10.24191/ajue.v16i3.9787

Students’ online learning challenges during the pandemic and how they cope with them: The

case of the Philippines

Students’ online learning challenges during the pandemic and how they cope with them: The

case of the Philippines (nih.gov)

The global impact of the coronavirus pandemic

(https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S135961012030126X)

THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 ON STUDENT EXPERIENCES AND EXPECTATIONS:

EVIDENCE FROM A SURVE

Velavan, T. P., & Meyer, C. G. (2020, March). The covid-19 epidemic. Tropical medicine &

international health : TM & IH. Retrieved March 31, 2022, from

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7169770/ 

w27392.pdf (nber.org)

Willott, L. (2022). Average Survey Response Rate - What You Need to Know - Customer

Thermometer. Customer Thermometer.

https://www.customerthermometer.com/customer-surveys/average-survey-response-

rate/#:~:text=A%20survey%20response%20rate%20of,range%20are%20far%20more

%20typical.

Yuki, K., Fujiogi, M. and Koutsogiannaki, S., (2022). COVID-19 pathophysiology: A review.

Zheng, J. (2020). SARS-CoV-2: an Emerging Coronavirus that Causes a Global Threat.


EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 33

International Journal of Biological Sciences, 16(10), 1678–1685.

https://doi.org/10.7150/ijbs.45053
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 34
EFFECTS OF ONLINE DISTANCE LEARNING 35

You might also like