Professional Documents
Culture Documents
684 El60!名06h6ηzゑs!勿ソ
一Technical Paper一
Electrodeposition of Nb−Sn Alloy from SnCl2−NbCl5−EMIC
Ambient Temperat皿e Molten Salts
Nobuyuki KOURA,Takayuki UMEBAYASHI,Yasushi IDEMOTO,*and Guoping LINGa
Faculty of Science&Technology,Tokyo University of Science(2641Yamazaki,Noda−shi,Chiba278−8510,
Japan)
aDepartment of Material Science&Engineering,Zhejiang University(Hangzhou,310027,P.R China)
Received December7,1998; Accepted March l,1999
The electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy from the SnCl2−NbCl5−EMIC melt was investigated.From the results
of the physical properties and cyclic vo]ltammetry,the possibility of electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy was
suggested,which was subsequently obtained from the melt by electrodeposition.However,the Nb content in
the deposits was very low.The Iow Nb content was related to the low limiting current density of Nb。From
the results of bath temperature,melt composition and pulse electrolysis for increasing the Nb content in the
deposits,the Nb−Sn alloy containing69.l wt%Nb was obtained from the2.8mol%SnCl2−68.6mol%NbCl、一
28.6mol%EMIC melt at200mA cm 2with a pulse period of lO ms,duty ratio of O2at160℃.
κ¢y防眺:Electrodepositlon,Ambient Temperature Molten Salt,Nb−Sn Alloy,EMIC
11ntro征uction We clarified that the electrodeposition of Nb−Sn
Nb3Sn is one of the superconductor materials used alloy was possible from an SnC12−NbCI5−BPC melt
practically.However,it is very difficult to make the and the Nb−Sn alloy containing44.3wt%Nb was
Nb3Sn into linear shapes,because Nb3Sn is inter− obtained during pulse electrolysis.14・15)However,the
metallic compound and is very brittle.Therefore, Nb content in the Nb−Sn alloy obtained from the BPC
the powder method,1)初s吻method2)and vapor system melt was low in comparison with the Nb
deposition method3)were developed。These complex content of Nb3Sn having70.1wt%.Therefore,we
process methods,4)however,require many steps.On have to increase the Nb content of the Nb−Sn alloy.
the other hand,it is considered that one can easily use In this paper,we studied the electrodeposition from
the electrodeposition method of Nb3Sn in one step the EMIC system ambient temperature molten salt
an(1continuously make it into various electro(ie that has good physical properties,such as melting
shapes.However,Nb is impossible to(leposit from point,viscosity and con(1uctivity,an(i stability under
aqueous bath,because of the less noble reduction high temperature in comparison with those of the
potential of Nb(Nb(0)/Nb(皿)1−1,10Vvs.NHE). BPC system melt for increasing the Nb content in the
Hence,the halide molten salt at high temperature deposits.
(LiF−NaF,5)LiF−KF,6)LiF−NaF−KF,7)Na(⊃1−KC18)and
LiC1−KCI9)), 1iquid halogen and hydrogen halide, 2 Experimental
such as HF,at low temperaturelo)and organic solvent SnCl2,NbCl5and EMIC used special grade reagents
at room temperature11)have been used for electrode− that had been dried under vacuum for48h.The
positing Nb.Moreover,it was reported that Nb3Sn molten salt was prepared by slowly mixing SnCl2,
was obtained from a high temperature molten salt NbC15and EMIC with stirring until the desired molar
melt.12)However,these baths require a high temper− ratio was obtained in a glovebox containing a dry Ar
ature,therefore they are liable to cause corrosion, atmosphere.
ignition and are poisonous. The conductivity was measure(i by a conductivity
On the other hand,the ambient temperature molten meter(TOA Electronics,Ltd.,CM−40S),and the vis−
salt using1−butylpyridinium chloride(BPC)and1− cosity was measured using a Ostwal(i viscometer.
ethyl−3−methylimidazolium chloride (EMIC)have The cyclic voltammetry(C。V.)was measured by a
advantages such that the process is performed at three−electrode system in a glass ce1L A Pt wire was
ambient temperature,and there is no fFear of igni− used as the working electrode,and an Sn(99.99%)
tion.13) plate or Nb plate(99.8%)were use(1as the counter
67,No.6(1999) 685
electrode.An Sn wire(99,99%,φ:1mm)immersed were less than100。C.The viscosity and the conduc−
in a66.7mol%SnCl2−33.3mo1%EMIC melt in a tivity for the various composition melts were also
pyrex tube(φ:10mm)separated by a G491ass frit measured(Fig.1).The viscosity decreased with
was used as the reference electrode.The C.V.mea− increasing temperature;the viscosity of these melts
surement was carried oUt using a potentiostat/ was less than25cP above130。C.On the other hand,
galvanostat(Nikko Keisoku NPGS−305)connected to the conductivity increased with increasing tempera−
a function generator(Nikko Keisoku NFG3)an(1an ture;it was higher than75mS cm−1above130℃.
X−Y recorder(TOA Electronics,Ltd.,XYR−2B). Hence,the SnCl2−NbC15−EMIC melt was used for the
Electrodeposition was carried out by potentiostatic electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy.
and galvanostatic electrolysis with stirring the melt. 3。1.2 Cyclic voltammetry Cyclic voltammo−
ACuplate(99.99%)wasusedastheworkingelec− grams were obtained in order to investigate the redox
trode. The counter and the reference electrodes behavior(Fig.2).For the SnC12−EMIC melt,a set of
were the same as used for the C.V.measurements. reduction and oxidation peaks related to the(leposi−
The pulse electrolysis was carried out using a current tion and dissolution of Sn was measured.On the
pulse generator(Nikko Keisok}NCPG−10−10)。 The other hand,in the SnCl2−NbCl5−EMIC melt,new cath−
obtained electrodeposit’s composition was analyzed odic current peaks,CI and C2,apPeared in the acidic
by the ICP(inductively coupled plasma atomic emis− and basic melts,suggesting the possibility of
sion spectroscopy)method and structure was deter− electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy.Moreover,the
mined by an X−ray diffraction method. CI and C2cathodic current peaks have different peak
The catho(lic polarization curve for the partial potentials.The amount of ionic species changes
current of Nb and Sn was obtained by the composi− significantly by changing the melt composition based
tion of the electrodeposit determine(i by ICP after the
叩
200
potentiostatic electrolysis. 目 ダ(c)
の
Electrodeposition and the measurements of physi− < 100
…i げノ
cal properties,C。V.,and polarizatiom curve were .一。/ジ:ノ’(b)
、
done in a glovebox containing a dry Ar atmosphere. h
,揖
茄’ “ :’
,、.
ノ
の ’・誉一・一=顎許 (a)
員
o !’
Cl
℃
3 Results and Discussion
qの 一100
り ご
ミ
3.1 Properties of SnCl2・NbCl5−EMIC melt 自 ∼ acidic melt
5
3.1.1 Physical properties Freezing point, り
一200
viscosity and conductivity were measured for obtain− 一〇.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5
ing fundamental physical properties about the SnC12− Potential1Vvs.Sn(II)/Sn(0)
NbC15−EMIC melt and investigating the possibility of
its use as an electrodeposition bath before the 1QG
electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy. The freezing ツ
iii /を.、瀞4緯
50
I
points of measured the various composition melts
! 》遥輩!
O 0:〆ノ (aう)
120の
漉
℃
も50 (b)
9 q
り
一150
ぺ
\
o basic melt
わ40
’お (c 臥
80 .属
ヒ
コ
一200
830
(b
> リ
o ゆニヨ 一1,5 −1,0 −0.5 0.0 0.5
520
の (a)
o 暮
40 ℃ Potential!Vvs.Sn(II)/Sn(0)
唱
10 0
9 Fig.2 Cyclic voltamograms for EMIC system melts at
0 0 130℃.
100 120 140 160
(a):66.7mol%SnC12−33.3mo1%EMIC,(b):64.5mol%
Temperature!OC
SnCl2−3.2mol%NbC15−32.3mo1%EMIC,(c):60.6mo1%
Fig.1Conductivity and Viscosity of SnC12−NbC15一一EMIC SnC12−9.1mo1%NbC15−30.3mol%EMIC.
melt. (a〆):33.3mol%SnCl2−66.7mo1%EMIC,(b〆):32.3mo1%
(a)●,○:66.7mol%SnC12−33.3mo1%EMIC melt,(b)▲, SnCl2−3.2moll%NbCl5−64.5mo1%EMIC,(c’):30.3mol%
△:64.5mol%SnCl2−3.2mol%NbCl5・32.3mol%EMIC SnCl2−9.1mol%NbCl5−60.6mol%EMIC,Cathode:99.99
melt,(c)■,□:60.6mol%SnC12−9.1mol%NbCl5−30.3mol %Pt,Anode:99,8%Nb,Scan rate:10mV sec−1without
%EMIC melt. stirring.
686 EJ66ケooh6窺ゑs渉か
on the studies of the AICI3−BPC,CuC1−BPC and SnC12− increasing Nb content in the melt.
BPC16)systems.Since the peak potential changed by From these results,the low Nb content is caused by
the melt composition,it is considered that the ionic the low limiting current density of Nb compared with
species could be different. Consequently,the differ− Sn.Hence,an increase in limiting current density of
ence between CI and C2could be attributable to the Nb is effective for increasing the Nb content in the
changing ionic species. deposits.The value of the limiting current density,
3.2 Electrodeposition of Nb鶴Sn alloy 歪1,is represented by the next equation.
For the purpose of confirming the electrodeposit C
(3)
from the SnCl2−NbCl5−EMIC melt,we examined the 11二n皿)一
δ
electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy using the60,6
mol%SnC12−9,1mo1%NbCl5−30.3mol%EMIC melt where n is the number of electrons,F is Faraday
that has a Iow viscosity and high conductivity.By constant,Z)is the diffusion coefficient,C is the bulk
electrodeposition using the potentiostatic metho(1at concentration,and δ is the thickness of diffusion
C1(Fig.2),the Nb−Sn alloy was obtained from this layer。
melt.It is considered that C1,that appeared by From equation(3),the method of increasing the
adding NbCl5to the SnC12−EMIC melt,is related to limiting current density of Nb is(i)increasing the
the electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn alloy. Further− diffusion coefficient Z)by increasing the bath temper・
more,the potentiostatic electrodeposition was perfor− ature,(ii)increasing the Nb(IV)species related to the
med in the range of−0.1to−1.O V vs.Sn(0)/Sn(II). deposition,and (iii) decreasing the (1iffusion layer
This result is shown in Table L The Nb content of thickness by pulse electrolysis.Then,we examined
the Nb−Sn alloy was the highest at−0.5V vs.Sn(0)/ these methods.
Sn(II).However,the Nb contents from this melt 3.4 1ncrease in Nb content a皿ing Nb−Sn alloy
were less than10wt%;these results we]re very low plating
compared with Nb3Sn(70.1wt%).The cathodic 3.4.1 Effects of bath temperat皿e The
polarization curves for the partial current of Nb and effect of bath temperature on the Nb content in the
Snusingthe SnC12−NbC15−EMIC meltwas measured in
order to get the informations for increasing the Nb Table l Nb content in the potentiostatic electrodeposited
content in the Nb−Sn alloy. Nb−Sn alloy from60.6mol%SnC12−9.1mol%NbC15・30.3
3.3 Polarization curves for the partial current of mo1%EMIC melt with stirring.(130℃)
Nb and Sn deposition Potentia1 Nb content
The cathodic polarization curves for the partial V vs.Sn(II)/Sn(0) (wt%)
species,respectively.15)
9 ’
9Q100
S論
Sn(II)→Sn(IV)十2e− (1)
”
Sn
Nb(V)十e一→Nb(IV) (2)
<
e ’幡’
This assumption could be correct,because the ぺ
.わ ごNb
current efficiency of electrodeposition of the Nb−Sn 暮10
alloy was approximately100%based on the assump− 名
tion. 揖
む
自
O Cathodic polarization curves for the partial current づ 0.0 −0,1 −O.2 一〇.3 一〇.4
り
of Nb and Sn deposition in SnCl2−NbCl5−EMIC are
Potential/Vvs.Sn(II)!Sn(0)
shown in Fig.3.づNb and Jsn in the figure are the
cathodic polarization curves for the partial current of Fig.3 Effects of the composition of the melt on the
Nb and Sn deposition,respectively.The limiting Iimiting current density with stirring.
deposits was investigated in the60.6mol%SnC12−9.1 The electmdeposition carried out by changing the
mol%NbCl5−30.3mo1%EMIC melt(Fig.4).When proportion of NbC15and SnC12by keeping the total
the bath temperature was increased from130℃to molar amount of metal chloride(NbCl5and SnC12)
160℃,the Nb content increased and the maximum and EMIC in the melt constant.These results are
Nb content was obtained at160℃.However,the Nb shown in Fig.5.The Nb content was significantly
content in the deposits decreased with increasing increased with increasing amount of NbC15and
temperature above160℃,since the SnC12−NbCl5− decreasing the amomt of SnC12.Particularly,the
EMIC melt was decomposed at high temperature. Nb・Sn alloy containing60.8wt%Nb was obtained
Accordingly,all experiments were performed at from the2 ,8mol%SnC12−68.6mo1%NbCl5−28.6mol
160℃for which the maximum Nb content in the %EMIC melt.It is thought that the limiting current
deposits was obtained. density of Nb had relatively increased by increasing
3.4.2 Effects of immersing Sn wire into the melt the limiting current density of Nb deposition and
The method of increasing the limiting current den− decreasing that of Sn (1eposition by increasing the
sity is increasing Nb(IV),from which Nb is deposited.
It is known that the decreased valence of the ionic Table2 Effect of immersing time of Sn wire on Nb
species in the melt is important for increasing the Nb content in the Nb−Sn alloy from60.6mol%SnCl2−9.1mol
%NbCl5−30,3mol%EMIC melt at l60℃with stirring.
content in the deposits.Accordingly,the Nb ions
ImmersingtIme
望time Current density Nb content
were reduced from pentavalent ionic species to
(hou1)) (mA cm』2) (wt%)
tetravalent by immersing Sn wire in the SnCl2−NbC15−
EMIC melt according to the following equations. 5 3.4
0 50 8.2
Sn(0)→ Sn(II)十2e− (4)
100 16.2
Nb(V)十e一→Nb(IV) (5)
5 3.5
When Snwire immersedinthemelt andtheimmer− 3 50 9.2
100 19.8
Sn wire was fixed at24h.
3.4.3 Effects of NbCl5content in the melt 5 3.8
It was thought that the Nb content in the deposits 12 50 10.2
the Nb content in the deposits increased with increas− 24 50 14.2
ing NbCl5in the melt.However,the Nb content was 100 24.8
only slightly increased. So,for effectively increas−
ing the amount of NbC15in the melt,the amount of 70
NbC15increased and the amount of SnC12decreased. 60
尽
レの
3: 50
17 =1
40
琶i
16 岩 30
尽 15 8 20
3
り
14
‘)
z
≧ 10
5 13 0
砦
8
40 60 80 100
20
12
Current density/mA cm’2
ρ
z 11
10 Fig.5 Relationship between current density and Nb
120 140 160 180 200 content in the galvanostatically deposite(i Nb−Sn alloy
from three kinds of melts,added Sn wire at160℃with
Temperature l oC
stirring.
Fig.4 Effects of the bath temperature on the Nb content (a):57.1mol%SnCI2−14.3mol%NbCl5−28.6mol%EMIC,
in the Nb−Sn alloy from60,6mol% SnCl、一9。1mol% (b):28.6mol%SnCl2−42.8mol%NbCl5−28.6mo1%EMIC,
NbCl5−30.3mol%EMIC melt with stirring. (c):2.8mol%SnCl2−68.6mol%NbCl5−28.6mol%EMIC.
一L_
688 EJ66’706h召ηzZs’勿v
amount of NbCl5and decreasing the SnCl2in the melt, creased for a high(1uty ratio and the Nb ion is insuffi−
and other reason is thought that ionic species of Sn ciently supplied during the short off−time.Hence,
and Nb change by the melt composition. Nb easily reached its limiting current density,and Sn
3.5 Pulse electrolysis deposition was preceded because Sn composition is
It has been reported that the composition of the low in the melt。
alloy can be changed by changing the pulse perio(1, Fτom the former result of pulse period and duty
duty ratio and pulse current density.For example, ratio for the Nb content in the deposits,it was inves,
the various contents of the Nb−Sn alloy deposited tigated using a constant current density at200mA・
from SnC12−NbCl5−BPC and Sn−NbCl5−BPC by pulse cm−2 Fig.7).When the pulse period,T,decreased
electrolysis15)were reporte(i. from lOOO ms to10ms,the Nb content in the deposits
Based on Fig.3,the increase in the limiting current increased regardless of the duty ratio. The Nb con−
density of Nb is required to increase the Nb content in tent in the deposits obtained from the10ms pulse
the(ieposits. In the case of pulse electrolysis,it is period is larger than of lOOO ms because the thickness
expected that the Nb content in the(1eposits increased of diffusion layer increased with(1ecreasing pulse
because the thickness of the diffusion lay「er decreased period and the deposition of Sn,which has a low
compared to the galvanostatic deposition. deposition current density,decreased.
First,the pulse current density and duty ratio were Finally,we obtained an Nb−Sn alloy containing
changed at the100ms pulse period from the2.8mol% 69.l wt%Nb from the2.8mol%SnC12−68.6mol%
SnCl2−68.6mol%NbCl5−28,6mo1%EMIC melt which NbCl5−28.6mo1%EMIC melt at200mA cm−2when
produced the maximum Nb content by galvanostatic T二10ms and the duty ratio is O.2.Figure8shows
deposition(Fig.6)。As a result,the highest Nb con− the X−ray diffraction pattems in the deposits.The
tent in the deposits was of64.7wt%at200mA cm 2
peaks of the Nb−Sn alloy apPeared and the peak
for a duty ratio of O.2. The effect of duty ratio on the intensity of the Nb−Sn alloy increased with increasing
Nb content depended on the current(1ensity. In the Nb content in the deposits. Therefore,it is expected
case of50mA cm−2and100mA cm皿2,the Nb content that the obtained deposit is the Nb−Sn alloy.The
increased with increasing duty ratio which shows the Nb−Sn alloy is mainly Nb3Sn.The supercon−
effect of a long on−time、The reason is that the ductivity property of the Nb−Sn alloy is now under
reaction rate at low current density is slow in com− inveStigatiOn.
parison with a high current density,therefore,the Nb
deposition did not reach the limiting current density 4 Conclusion
at high duty ratio. On the other hand,in the case of For the electrodeposition of the superconductor
150mA cm2and200mA cm2,the Nb content in− Nb3Sn,the properties of melt,bath temperature,
creased with decreasing duty ratio.It was thought composition of melt and current density during
that since most of the Nb ions were consumed for galvanostatic deposition,and pulse current density,
deposition, the concentration of the Nb ions de一 pulse period and duty ratio during Pulse electrolysis
70 70 (a)
(d) A
60 (c)
60
o
ぷ ま
と
50 一 50
き ≧
(b)
≧ 40 \ 40
8 30
三
8 30
揖
8 20
8 (c)
』
(b)
▽
▽
A Q 20
ゆ
回
z 10 乞 10
(a)
0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.O
0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.O
Duty ratio Duty ratio
Fig.6 Relationship between duty ratio and Nb colltent in Fig.7 Relationship between duty ratio and Nb content in
the deposits at the pulse electrolysis at160℃and100ms the deposits at the pulse electrolysis at l60℃and200mA・
with stirring. cm−2with stirring.
Bath;2.8mol%SnCl2−68.6mol%NbCl5−28.6mo1% Bath:2.8mol%SnCl2−68。6mol%NbCI5−28.6mo1%
EMIC melt added Sn wire. EMIC melt added Sn wire.
(a):C.D.50mA cm 2,(b):C.D.100mA cm 2,(c):C.D.150 (a):Pulse period lO ms,(b)=Pulse period100ms,(c):Pulse
mA cm 2,(d):C.D.200mA cm
2.
period1000ms
67,No.6(1999) 689
1000 ■
mol%SnC12−68.6mo1%NbC15−28.6mo1%EMIC melt
(a) ▲ ■
at100mA cm 2and l60。C、
Moreover,the Nb content increased by pulse elec−
500 蓼 trolysis from the2.8mol%SnCl2−68。6mol%NbCl5−
2 28.6mo1%EMIC melt.The Nb content in the
↑
〉500
・錺 ▲ ● ●
‘
ト
⊆
and at160℃。
毎 ゲ
⊆
芒 Φ References
一 〇 り
⊆
20 30 40 50 60 70 80 o 1)R.Bormam,H.C.Freyhardt,and H.Bergmann,∠4勿」。
の
P勿s.L観.,35,944(1980).
1000
(c)
菱 2)H.Kumakura,K.Togano,and K.Tachikawa,
●
≦ !44∂α%66s わz C勿ソog6π6ガ6E多z8ゴπ667Jng,28,515(1982).
.9)
3)S.Gonda・,S銘吻06,19,474(1981)(in Japanese).
500 ▲ 工
● 4)Y.Tanaka,Cho46n40鋸 渉o so%0 0妙o%,Sangyou
Tosyo,p.57(1989)(in Japanese).
5)Q.Zhiyu and T.Pierre,1.El66渉706hωn.So6.,15,259
0
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
(1985),
6)U.Cohen,∫.El60ケooh6別.506。,128,731(1981).
20(Cu−Kα)
7)G。P.Capsimalis,E.S.Chen,and R.E。Peterson,∫.
Fig.8 XRD diffraction pattems of deposits(2.8mol% ノ1、ρブ)」.El‘36孟γ06h6簿z.,17,253(1987).
SnCl2−68.6mo1%NbC15−28.6mol%EMIC melt at200mA 8)1。Nakagawa and Y.Hirabayashi,P6%h診καgα肋(pres−
ently El66か06h6ηz乞s耽y),51,256,(1983)(in Japanese).
cm−2
(a)10.2wt%Nb(丁二1000ms,duty ratio:0.8),(b)24.8wt 9)K.Zhou,T.Takenaka,N.Sato,and M.Nanjo,1)6nh乞
%Nb(丁二10ms,duty ratio二〇.8),(c)69.1wt%Nb(丁二10 κ‘zgαhz6(presently El66か06h6錫πs疏y),59,981 (1991)(in
Japanese).
ms,duty ratio:0.2),●:Nb−Sn Alloy(mainly Nb3Sn),▲:
10)V.Taranenko,K.D.Sienerth,N.Sato,A.G.Edwards,
Sn,■:Cu
and G.Mamantov,〃1鷹7翅s S6勿n66Fo7%解,73−75,
595(1991).
11)N.S.Chong,J.L.Anderson,and M.L.Norton,∫.
were investigated.
El雄706h翻.So6.,136,1245(1989).
The SnCl2−NbC15−EMIC melt could form a molten 12)R.Gel,(}.Drobotenko,and V.Kolosov,〃「.S,3動’.
salt,and the melt煽as useful for the electrodeposition 8y”zρ.〃り1渉。Sα1.,Paris,P.11(1991).
of the Nb−Sn alloy.The Nb−Sn alloy was obtained 13)S.Takahashi and N.Koura,T6孟梛一!〇一施g召彫,77,921
from the melt by electrodeposition. (1991)(in.Japanese).
The methods of increasing the Nb content in the 14)N.Koura,G.Ling,and H.Ito,∫.S鋸4FJ痂sh.So6.〃銘.,
deposits from the melt were investigated by increas− 46,1162(1995)(in Japanese).
15)G.Ling and N.Koura,∫.S%4Fガn乞sh.So6.ヵ)%.,48,454
ing the bath temperature,the addition of Sn wire,
(1997)(illl Japanese).
increasing the NbCl5 content an(1 decreasing the
16)G.Ling;and N.Koura,P6πhJκ㎎αhκ(presently五ll66一
SnCl2content. For these results,an Nb−Sn alloy ケ06h6ηz奮耽y),65,149(1997)(in Japanese)。
containing60.8wt%Nb was obtained from the2.8
『r