You are on page 1of 4

Introduction to Environmental Science  The Tragedy of the Commons –

essay written by Garrett Hardin


“In every deliberation, we must consider our impact which describes a major source of
on the next seven environmental conflict.
generations.”  Source pf environmental
(The Iroqouis Confederacy) conflict: commons (areas that
are shared and not owned) are
Environmental Science likely to be depleted as
- Study of the interaction of humans with individuals pursue their own
the natural environment self-interests
- Environment includes all living and  Examples: climate change, air
nonliving things that we interact with pollution, water pollution, and
(climate, soil and landforms, water overfishing of international
sources, other living organisms) waters are all modern
- EnviSci and the issues that it studies are
complex and interdisciplinary; it  The Progressive Era
incorporates concepts and ideas from  In the US, the first environmental
multiple fields of study movement began with a series of
conversation measures taken by
ღ Environmental History President Teddy Roosevelt.
 Humans have impacted the Earth since o National parks – preserved areas
the very beginnings of civilization. that are relatively unaltered
 In 2400 B.C., the agricultural fields of from their original state.
Sumeria had grain production similar to o National Forests – federally-
modern agriculture – about 30 bushels managed, but do allow
per acre. commercial logging and
 The Sumerians relied on irrigation, the recreational hunting and fishing.
artificial application of water from o National Wildlife Refuges – do
another source (Tigris and Euphrates not allow commercial activities,
rivers) but may allow recreational
 All water contains small amounts of hunting and fishing.
minerals called salt, and that salt built
up in the Mesopotamian soil over time.
o Yields declined to half, then a
fourth within a few hundred
years.
o By the 7th century A.D., slave
labor had to be used to strip the
upper salt layer from the soil so
it could still be farmed.
 Hetch Hetchy Debate – from the
o By the 16th century, the Fertile
reservoir to be constructed in Hetch
Crescent of Mesopotamia was a
Hetchy Valley of Yosemite National
salty wasteland.
Park. The reservoir is supply water
to San Francisco after a massive fire
 This is an example of two important
which damaged 90% of the city. For
concepts in environmental science:
the dam to be constructed, a law
o The Law of Unintended
would have to be passed by
Consequences Congress and signed by President
o Unsustainability Woodrow Wilson.
o Led to emergence of two major
philosophies or environmental
ethics; the moral relationship  Automobile, refrigeration systems, air-
that humans have with the conditioning systems, industrial blowers,
environment: industrial gas compressors, industrial
ANTROPOCENTRISM (human heat exchangers, power plants,
centered) and ECOCENTRISM renewable energy.
(nature centered)  A dense smog of from a zinc plant in
o Anthropocentrism won the Donora, Pennsylvania in 1948 sickened
debate. The construction of the thousands.
dam began in 1914 and is still o This was one of the deadliest
used up to this day. incidents of air pollution, the
o Gifford Pinochet summarized his introduction of particles or gases
environmental ethic and into the atmosphere that are
decision making as: “Where harmful to living organisms.
conflicting interests must be  Radioactive fallout from nuclear bomb
reconciled, the question shall testing in the Marshall Islands exposed
always be answered from the native islanders and Navy sailors to
standpoint of the greatest good radioactive fallout.
of the greatest number in the  Extinction is a normal process, with a
long run.” background extinction rate of 1-5
species per year.
 Conservationists during the Progressive o The current rates of extinction are
Era were the most concerned about 1,000-10,000 times that.
resource depletion. They categorized  Extinction lowers the biodiversity, or
natural resources into four groups: amount of variation of species and
1. Inexhaustible resources cannot be genes within an area.
used up.  Rapid increases in the population size of
2. Renewable resources can be countries like India and China caused
replaced, but the process may take fears of human overpopulation and
a long time. famine, an extreme scarcity of food.
3. Nonrenewable resources are  One prediction from the book, The
consumed faster than they Population Bomb:
replenish, as their formation took “The battle to feed all of
millions of years. humanity is over. In the 1970s hundreds
4. Recyclable nonrenewable resources of millions of people will starve to death
also are not replaced at the rate in spite of any crash programs embarked
they are used, but can be used upon now. At this late date nothing can
more than once. prevent a substantial increase in the
world death rate...”
ღ Modern Environmentalism
 major environmental disasters through ღ Laws and Regulations
the early 20th century raised awareness of  A series of laws were passed in response
many other environmental issues besides to the modern environmentalism
resource conservation movement.
 1935, Cane Toads were introduced into o The Safe Drinking Water Act
Australia to help control the grey-backed o The Clean Water Act
cane beetle, a pest insect destroying o The Clean Air Act
sugar cane crops. o The Resource Conservation and
o The toads became an invasive Recovery Act
species, overpopulating in its new o The Endangered Species Act
environment and outcompeting or o The creation of the Environmental
harming native species. Protection Agency (EPA), which is
charged with enforcing these and to be weaker, unenforced,
other laws. or non-existent in
developing countries.
 While developed countries have a
ღ Global Environmentalism slower population growth rate, they
 Many of those same environmental have a much higher rate of
issues persist today, but are increasingly consumption, the rate of use of natural
complex to deal because they are spread resources.
throughout the entire world, not just a
single country.
 Environmental indicators are used to
describe and evaluate the health of
Earth’s ecosystems.
o Biodiversity
o Food production rates
o Climate change
o Human population growth ღ Economics and the Environment
o Resource depletion  Economic principles has a huge
influence in environmental decision-
ღ The Demographic Divide making.
 Countries are classified into one of two  Supply and demand predicts that the
categories based on their economic cost of a resource (such as oil) will
status. increase when demand is high or supply
1. Developed countries tend to be is low.
wealthier, have higher rates of  A cost-benefit analysis is used by
education, advanced infrastructure, governments and companies to
and an overall better standard of determine whether the benefit of doing
living. something justifies its economic cost.
2. Developing countries tend to be  Many companies use labor in developing
poorer, less education, have countries as a way to reduce their own
inadequate infrastructure, and a costs of production and the final price
lower standard of living. tag of their products.
 Significant differences include: o The workers in these
o Gross domestic product countries often face
(GDP) per capita, a measure dangerous working
of the monetary value of the conditions. These are hidden
goods and services costs not reflected in what
produced per person; higher we pay for the item.
in developed countries,
lower in developing.  Example: accident at a pesticide factory
o Total fertility rates, the located near the town of Bhopal, India.
number of children born to o The plant was built in 1969 to
an average woman; higher produce a pesticide at a reduced
in developing countries, cost.
lower in developed.  Cheaper labor.
o Life expectancy, the number  Fewer environmental and
of years an average person worker safety regulations
will live; higher in developed and inspections.
countries, lower in  A less-expensive chemical
developing. process that used an
o Environmental regulations intermediate chemical
and worker protections tend
called methyl icocyanate 1. planetary management worldview –
(MIC) was used. takes the perspective that humans
o Demand for the pesticide decreased should manage the Earth’s resources to
in the 1980s, and the supply achieve the maximum benefit.
increased, leading to the 2. stewardship worldview – believes that
accumulation of MIC in storage humans should manage the Earth, but
tanks, which were filled past in a more ethical and sustainable way.
capacity. Also anthropocentric, but with more of
o Water leaked into one of the an emphasis on living such a way that
storage tanks, causing a reaction human needs can be met indefinitely.
that led to 30 tons of MIC being This is called sustainability.
vented directly into the 3. environmental wisdom worldview –
atmosphere. believes that we are totally dependent
o Thousands of people died, on nature and should preserve nature
hundreds of thousands of as much as possible to maintain our
people and animals were own species. An ecocentric worldview
sickened. that emphasizes sustainability for all
o Hospitals, which were heavily species.
staffed by underqualified
doctors, were overwhelmed.  Each of these worldviews acknowledges
o The government passed a law that that the Earth is a closed system,
allowed the Indian government to meaning matter does not enter or leave
represent the entire affected it in large amounts.
population of Bhopal. o Resources are finite.
o A settlement of $470 million was o Wastes do not “go away”.
reached by Union Carbide and the  These understandings form the basis for
Indian government, although understanding and solving each of the
originally $3.3 billion was claimed. issues within environmental science.
o In 2004, on the 20th anniversary of
the Bhopal disaster, the Yes Men
performed an elaborate prank to
increase awareness of the still-
unremediated Union Carbide site
and health problems faced by the
survivors.

ღ Ecological Footprint
 The impact of a person on the
environment is expressed as ecological
footprint, an estimate of the amount of
land needed to support their lifestyle.
o If the developing countries
industrialized and matched the
resource consumption rate of the
United States, an estimated three
Earths would be needed.

ღ Environmental Worldviews
There are three perspectives in how we
should deal with issues of pollution, resource
overconsumption, and loss of biodiversity.

You might also like