You are on page 1of 56

2.

Extended fluid flow


analysis

70
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Many fluid systems are designed to transport a fluid from one location to another
at a specified flow rate, velocity, and elevation difference.

• These systems may generate mechanical work in a turbine or it may consume


mechanical work in a pump or fan during this process.

• These systems do not involve the conversion of nuclear, chemical, or thermal


energy to mechanical energy.

• Also, they do not involve any heat transfer in any significant amount, and they
operate essentially at constant temperature.

71
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Such systems can be analyzed conveniently by considering the mechanical forms
of energy only.

• As well as the frictional effects that cause the mechanical energy to be lost (i.e.,
to be converted to thermal energy that usually cannot be used for any useful
purpose).

• The mechanical energy can be defined as the form of energy that can be
converted to mechanical work completely and directly by an ideal mechanical
device such as an ideal turbine.

• Kinetic and potential energies are the familiar forms of mechanical energy.

72
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Thermal energy is not mechanical
energy, since it cannot be converted to
work directly and completely (the
second law of thermodynamics).

• A pump transfers mechanical energy to


a fluid by raising its pressure, and

• A turbine extracts mechanical energy


from a fluid by dropping its pressure.

• Therefore, the pressure of a flowing


fluid is also associated with its
mechanical energy. 73
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• In fact, the pressure unit Pa is equivalent
to

• Pa = N/m2 = N · m/m3 = J/m3,


which is energy per unit volume,

• and the product Pv or its equivalent


P/ρ has the unit J/kg, which is
energy per unit mass.

• Note that pressure itself is not a form of


energy.

74
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• But a pressure force acting on a fluid through a distance produces work, called
flow work, in the amount of P/ρ per unit mass.

• Flow work is expressed in terms of fluid properties, and it is convenient to view


it as part of the energy of a flowing fluid and call it flow energy.

• Therefore, the mechanical energy of a flowing fluid can be expressed on a unit-


mass basis as

• where is the flow energy, is the kinetic energy, and gz is the potential energy
of the fluid, all per unit mass.
75
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Then the mechanical energy change of a fluid
during incompressible flow becomes

• Therefore, the mechanical energy of a fluid does


not change during flow if its pressure, density,
velocity, and elevation remain constant.

• In the absence of any losses, the mechanical


energy change represents the mechanical work
supplied to the fluid or
extracted from the fluid (if . 76
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Lets examine this

77
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Consider a container of height h filled with water, as shown in the Figure, with
the reference level selected at the bottom surface.
• The gauge pressure and the
potential energy per unit
mass are, respectively,

• at
point A at the free surface,
and

• at
point B at the bottom of the
container.
78
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• An ideal hydraulic turbine
would produce the same
work per unit mass,

• whether it receives water (or


any other fluid with constant
density) from the top or from
the bottom of the container.

• Note that we are also


assuming ideal flow (no
irreversible losses) through
the pipe leading from the 79

tank to the turbine.


Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• Therefore, the total
mechanical energy of
water at the bottom is
equivalent to that at the
top.

• The transfer of
mechanical energy is
usually accomplished
by a rotating shaft, and
thus mechanical work
is often referred to as
shaft work.
80
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• A pump or a fan receives
shaft work (usually from
an electric motor) and
transfers it to the fluid as
mechanical energy (less
frictional losses).

• A turbine, on the other


hand, converts the
mechanical energy of a
fluid to shaft work.

81
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• In the absence of any irreversibilities such
as friction, mechanical energy can be
converted entirely from one mechanical
form to another, and the mechanical
efficiency of a device or process can be
defined as (Fig.)

, ,
, ,

82
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• A conversion efficiency of less than 100%
indicates that conversion is less than
perfect and some losses have occurred
during conversion.

• A mechanical efficiency of 97% indicates


that 3% of the mechanical energy input is
converted to thermal energy as a result of
frictional heating, and this will manifest
itself as a slight rise in the temperature of
the fluid.

83
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• In fluid systems, we are usually
interested in increasing the pressure,
velocity, and/or elevation of a fluid.

• This is done by supplying mechanical


energy to the fluid by a pump, a fan,
or a compressor (we will refer to all
of them as pumps).

• Or we are interested in the reverse


process of extracting mechanical
energy from a fluid by a turbine and
producing mechanical power in the
84
form of a rotating shaft that can drive
a generator or any other rotary device.
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• The degree of perfection of the conversion process between the mechanical work
supplied or extracted and the mechanical energy of the fluid is expressed by the
pump efficiency and turbine efficiency,

• The pump effieicency is defined as

, ,

• Where , , , is the rate of increase in the


mechanical energy of the fluid, which is equivalent to the useful pumping power,
, supplied to the fluid.

85
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• The turbine efficiency is defined as

• Where , , , is the rate of decrease in the


mechanical energy of the fluid, which is equivalent to the mechanical power
extracted from the turbine , and we use the absolute value sign to avoid
negative values for efficiencies.

86
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• A pump or turbine efficiency of 100% indicates perfect conversion between the
shaft work and the mechanical energy of the fluid, and this value can be
approached (but never attained) as the frictional effects are minimized.

• The mechanical efficiency should not be confused with the motor efficiency and
the generator efficiency, which are defined as

• Motor
,

,
• And Generator
,

,
87
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• A pump is usually packaged together with its motor, and a turbine with its
generator.

• Therefore, we are usually interested in the combined or overall efficiency of


pump–motor and turbine–generator combinations, which are defined as:

, ,

, ,
• And
, ,

, ,

88
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Note
• The overall efficiency of a
turbine–generator is the
product of the efficiency of
the turbine and the efficiency
of the generator.

• This represents the fraction of


the mechanical energy of the
fluid converted to electric
energy.

89
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


• All the efficiencies just defined range between 0 and 100%.

• The lower limit of 0% corresponds to the conversion of the entire mechanical


or electric energy input to thermal energy, and the device in this case functions
like a resistance heater.

• The upper limit of 100% corresponds to the case of perfect conversion with no
friction or other irreversibilities, and thus no conversion of mechanical or
electric energy to thermal energy

90
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Example
• The water in a large lake is to be used to generate electricity by the installation
of a hydraulic turbine–generator at a location where the depth of the water is
50 m (Figure). Water is to be supplied at a rate of 5000 kg/s. If the electric
power generated is measured to be 1862 kW and the generator efficiency is
95%, determine

• (a) the overall efficiency of


the turbine– generator
• (b) the mechanical
efficiency of the turbine
• (c) the shaft power supplied
by the turbine to the
generator. 91
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• Assumptions.
• The elevation of the lake remains constant.
• The mechanical energy of water at the turbine exit is negligible.

• Properties: The density of water can be taken to be ρ=1000 kg/m3.

92
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• (a) We take the bottom of the lake as the reference level for convenience.
• Then kinetic and potential energies of water are zero, and the change in its
mechanical energy per unit mass becomes

, ,

93
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• Then the rate at which mechanical energy is supplied to the turbine by the fluid
and the overall efficiency become

, , ,

94
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• (b) Knowing the overall and generator efficiencies, the mechanical efficiency
of the turbine is determined from

95
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• (c) The shaft power output is determined from the definition of mechanical
efficiency,
,

, ,

96
Extended fluid flow analysis

Mechanical energy and efficiency


Solution
• (c) The shaft power output is determined from the definition of mechanical
efficiency,
,

, ,

97
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• Most flows encountered in engineering practice are
turbulent, and thus it is important to understand how
turbulence affects wall shear stress.

• However, turbulent flow is a complex mechanism


dominated by fluctuations, and despite tremendous
amounts of work done in this area by researchers,
the theory of turbulent flow remains largely
undeveloped.

98
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• Therefore, we must rely on experiments and the empirical (first-hand) or semi-
empirical correlations developed for various situations.

• Turbulent flow is characterized by random and rapid fluctuations of swirling


regions of fluid, called eddies, throughout the flow.

• These fluctuations provide an additional mechanism for momentum and energy


transfer.

99
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• In laminar flow, fluid particles flow in an orderly manner along pathlines, and
momentum and energy are transferred across streamlines by molecular
diffusion.

• In turbulent flow, the swirling eddies transport mass, momentum, and energy to
other regions of flow much more rapidly than molecular diffusion, greatly
enhancing mass, momentum, and heat transfer.

• As a result, turbulent flow is associated with much higher values of friction,


heat transfer, and mass transfer coefficients

100
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
Remember
• That in practice, it is found convenient to express the pressure loss for all
types of fully developed internal flows (laminar or turbulent flows, circular or
noncircular pipes, smooth or rough surfaces, horizontal or inclined pipes) as

• Where is the dynamic pressure and f is the Darcy-Weisbach friction


factor

101
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
Remember also
• That the Darcy-Weisbach friction factor for fully developed laminar flow in a
circular pipe can be expressed as

• This equation shows that in laminar flow, the friction factor is a function of the
Reynolds number only and is independent of the roughness of the pipe surface.

• However, the friction factor equation is valid only for fully developed laminar
flow in circular pipes.

102
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• The friction factor in fully developed turbulent pipe flow
depends on the Reynolds number and the relative
roughness ε/D, which is the ratio of the mean height of
roughness of the pipe to the pipe diameter.

• The practical form of this dependence cannot be obtained


from a theoretical analysis, and all available results are
obtained from careful experiments using artificially
roughened surfaces.

• This artificial roughness is achieved usually by gluing


sand grains of a known size on the inner surfaces of the
pipes.
103
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• In 1939, Cyril F. Colebrook (1910–1997) combined the available data for
transition and turbulent flow in smooth as well as rough pipes into the following
implicit relation known as the Colebrook equation:

• In 1942, the American engineer Hunter Rouse (1906–1996) verified


Colebrook’s equation and produced a graphical plot of f as a function of
and the product.

• He also presented the laminar flow relation and a table of commercial pipe
104
roughness.
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• Two years later, Lewis F. Moody redrew Rouse’s diagram into the form
commonly used today.

• The now famous Moody chart is given in the Supplementary sheet.

• It presents the Darcy friction factor for pipe flow as a function of the Reynolds
number and ε/D over a wide range.

• It is probably one of the most widely accepted and used charts in engineering.

• Although it is developed for circular pipes, it can also be used for noncircular
pipes by replacing the diameter by the hydraulic diameter.

105
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• Commercially available pipes differ from
those used in experiments in that the
roughness of pipes in the market is not
uniform and it is difficult to give a precise
description of it.

• Equivalent roughness values for some


commercial pipes are given in the Table as
well as on the Moody chart.

• But it should be kept in mind that these


values are for new pipes, and the relative
roughness of pipes may increase with use
as a result of corrosion, scale buildup, and 106

precipitation.
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• As a result, the friction factor may increase
by a factor of 5 to 10.

• Actual operating conditions must be


considered in the design of piping systems.

• Also, the Moody chart and its equivalent


Colebrook equation involve several
uncertainties (the roughness size,
experimental error, curve fitting of data,
etc.).

• Therefore the results obtained should not


be treated as “exact.” 107
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
• It is usually considered to be accurate to 115% over the entire range in the
figure.

• The Colebrook equation is hidden in f, and thus the determination of the friction
factor requires some iteration.

• An approximate explicit relation for f was given by S. E. Haaland in 1983 as


.

• The results obtained from this relation are within 2% of those obtained from the
Colebrook equation.

• If more accurate results are desired, this equation can be used as a good first108
guess
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
Lets examine the Moody Chart more closely!

The following observations can be made from the


Moody chart:

• For laminar flow, the friction factor decreases


with increasing Reynolds number, and it is
independent of surface roughness.

• The friction factor is a minimum for a smooth


pipe (but still not zero) and increases with
roughness.

• The Colebrook equation in this case (ε= 0) 109

reduces to the Prandtl equation.


Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
The following observations can be made from the Moody chart (cont’d):
• The transition region from the laminar to turbulent regime (2300 < Re < 4000)
is indicated by the shaded area in the Moody chart.

• The flow in this region may be laminar or turbulent, depending on flow


disturbances, or it may alternate between laminar and turbulent, and

• Therefore the friction factor may also alternate between the values for
laminar and turbulent flow making the data in this range are the least
reliable.

• At small relative roughness, the friction factor increases in the transition


region and approaches the value for smooth pipes.
110
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
The following observations can be made from the Moody chart (cont’d):

• At very large Reynolds numbers (to the right of the dashed line on the chart) the
friction factor curves corresponding to specified relative roughness curves are
nearly horizontal.

• Therefore the friction factors are independent of the Reynolds number.

• The flow in that region is called fully rough turbulent flow or fully rough
flow because the thickness of the viscous sub-layer decreases with
increasing Reynolds number.

111
Extended fluid flow analysis
Turbulent flows and the Moody chart
The following observations can be made from the Moody chart (cont’d):

• The Colebrook equation in the fully rough zone reduces to the von Kármán
equation expressed as

• Note that in calculations, the actual internal diameter of the pipe should be used,
which may be different than the nominal diameter.

112
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
• In the design and analysis of piping systems that involve the use of the Moody
chart (or the Colebrook equation), we usually encounter three types of problems
(the fluid and the roughness of the pipe are assumed to be specified in all
cases):

• 1. Determining the pressure drop (or head loss) when the pipe length and
diameter are given for a specified flow rate (or velocity)

• 2. Determining the flow rate when the pipe length and diameter are given
for a specified pressure drop (or head loss)

• 3. Determining the pipe diameter when the pipe length and flow rate are
given for a specified pressure drop (or head loss)
113
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
• Problems of the first type are straightforward and can be solved directly by
using the Moody chart.

• Problems of the second type and third type are commonly encountered in
engineering design.

• An example is in the selection of pipe diameter that minimizes the sum of the
construction and pumping costs.

• The use of the Moody chart with such problems requires an iterative approach
unless an equation solver is used.

114
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
• In problems of the second type, the diameter is given but the flow rate is
unknown.

• A good guess for the friction factor in that case is obtained from the completely
turbulent flow region for the given roughness.

• This is true for large Reynolds numbers, which is often the case in practice.

• Once the flow rate is obtained, the friction factor can be corrected using the
Moody chart or the Colebrook equation, and the process is repeated until the
solution converges.

• Typically only a few iterations are required for convergence to three or four
digits of precision. 115
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
• In problems of the third type, the diameter is not known and therefore the
Reynolds number and the relative roughness cannot be calculated.

• Therefore, we start calculations by assuming a pipe diameter.

• The pressure drop calculated for the assumed diameter is then compared to the
specified pressure drop.

• The calculations are repeated with another pipe diameter in an iterative fashion
until convergence.

116
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Example
• Water at 60°F ( 62.36 lbm/ft3 and lbm/ft · s) is flowing
steadily in a 2-in-diameter horizontal pipe made of stainless steel at a rate of 3.0
ft3/s.

• Determine
• (a) the pressure drop
• (b) the head loss,
• (c) he required pumping power input for flow over a 200-ft-long section of
the pipe

117
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• Assumptions
• 1 The flow is steady and incompressible.
• 2 The entrance effects are negligible therefore the flow is fully developed.
3 The pipe involves no components such as bends, valves, and connectors.
4 The piping section involves no work devices such as a pump or a turbine.

• Properties
• The density and dynamic viscosity of water are given.

• We recognize this as a problem of the first type, since flow rate, pipe length, and
pipe diameter are known.

118
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• First we calculate the average velocity and the Reynolds number to determine
the flow regime

119
• which is greater than 4000. Therefore, the flow is turbulent.
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• The relative roughness of the pipe is
calculated using the mean height of roughness
value (ε) from the Table.

.

• The friction factor corresponding to this


relative roughness and the Reynolds number
can simply be determined from the Moody
chart.

• To avoid any reading error, we determine f 120

from the Colebrook equation:


Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• From the Colebrook equation:

• Using an equation solver or an iterative scheme, the friction factor is determined


to be f = 0.0174.

121
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• Then the pressure drop (which is equivalent to pressure loss in this case), head
loss, and the required power input become

122
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• The head loss and the required power input become:


. .

• Therefore, power input in the amount of 461 W is needed to overcome the


frictional losses in the pipe.. 123
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Solution
• Note: The friction factor could also be determined easily from the explicit
Haaland relation. It would give f = 0.0172, which is sufficiently close to 0.0174.

• Also, the friction factor corresponding to ε = 0 in this case is 0.0171, which


indicates that stainless-steel pipes can be assumed to be smooth with negligible
error.

124
Extended fluid flow analysis
Types of Fluid Flow Problems
Example (Take home)

Heated air at 1 atm and 35°C ( 1.145 kg/m3; kg/m · s;


m2/s) is to be transported in a 150-m-long circular plastic duct at a
rate of 0.35 m3/s. If the head loss in the pipe is not to exceed 20 m, determine the
minimum diameter of the duct.

125

You might also like