You are on page 1of 7

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/304784502

Assessment muscle fatigue using statistical study and classification: A review

Conference Paper · November 2015


DOI: 10.1109/ICCSCE.2015.7482185

CITATIONS READS

4 447

6 authors, including:

Mohamed Sarillee Hariharan M


Universiti Malaysia Perlis National Institute of Technology (NIT) Uttarakhand
10 PUBLICATIONS   131 CITATIONS    151 PUBLICATIONS   2,222 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Anas Mohd Noor Ye Htut


Universiti Malaysia Perlis Mercy Malaysia
62 PUBLICATIONS   156 CITATIONS    71 PUBLICATIONS   847 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

International humanitarian conference 2013 Kuala Lumpur View project

Muscle Fatigue View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Mohamed Sarillee on 21 July 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Assessment Muscle Fatigue using Statistical Study
& Classification: A Review
Mohamed Sarillee, M.Hariharan, Anas M.N., Omar M.I, Aishah M.N. and Q.W.Oung
Biomedical Electronic Engineering,
School of Mechatronic Engineering, Universiti Malaysia Perlis
Campus Pauh Putra, 02600 Arau, Perlis, Malaysia.
sarilleelee@gmail.com

Abstract—Muscle fatigue is very common muscle condition has the MMG is correlated with force production, even a small
been experienced. Different types of myograms have been used change in force which reflected in the MMG amplitude [7,
to assess muscle fatigue and there are Electromyogram, 8]. Therefore, small changes in force during muscle fatigue
Mechanomyogram and Acoustic myogram. Each myogram has were reflected in MMG amplitude, where the EMG
its own advantages in assessing muscle fatigue. Therefore,
amplitude does not follow the force production [7]. The
suitable features are needed to assess muscle fatigue. This
review discusses the on statistical analysis and classification advantages of MMG are, they easy and simple to
result of the myograms features that have been applied. implement. Further, MMG do not contain power line
Towards the end of the paper, challenges and future trends are interference. They also have highest signal and noise ratio
discussed. [9, 10].
That contracting muscle generates sounds has been
Index Terms— Muscle fatigue, EMG, MMG, AMG, Statistical known for nearly two centuries (Wollaston, 1810). The
analysis sound or acoustic signal called as acoustic myogram (AMG)
is audible [11, 12]. The AMG is a low frequency signal, in
1810; William Hyde Wollaston discovered the frequency of
I. INTRODUCTION the sound is 25 Hz [11, 13]. The nature of AMG was related
Muscle fatigue is a very common muscle condition has to the pressure wave generated by the dimensional changes
been experienced in daily activity. Muscle fatigue occurs of the activated fibers, to the lateral movement of the
when the muscle could not maintain or perform expected muscle or to the molecular events of the contracting fibers.
forces or power [1, 2]. Assessment muscle fatigue is It has been proven that its amplitude and its frequency
important in many fields such as sport sciences, clinical content are dependent on the contraction intensity.
analysis and ergonomics. Therefore, different method and Assessment muscle fatigue has been quiet challenging
approach has been applied to assess muscle condition. for last two decades. The EMG signals have been used to
The various techniques that have been used to assess assess muscle fatigue by applying different types of signal
the muscle condition are surface electromyography (sEMG), processing algorithm. In some studies, the MMG signals
isometric strength tests, muscle biopsy (laboratory tests) and have been used to analysis muscle fatigue along with the
muscle imaging techniques. However, sEMG is commonly EMG signals. The advantage of the MMG signals to reflect
has been applied to assess the muscle condition by the force production very useful feature in assessing muscle
recording the muscle electrical activity which controls by fatigue. Furthermore, the researcher has been studying the
the nervous system. The muscle contains motor unit action relation between EMG and MMG signal features by using a
potential trains the action potential to adhesion motor unit in statistical approach. In [11], AMG has been used to assess
the muscle [3]. The sEMG is generated by summing up the the muscle, the researcher state that the root mean square
action potential of the motor unit [4]. During fatigue the low (RMS) of AMG reflected the load.
frequency components and amplitude of the EMG signal The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II
increases due to recruitment of motor unit [5]. There are few describes about analysis has been used to assess muscle
limitations using sEMG such as ability to monitor only a fatigue. This follows by discussion in section III and last
few muscle sites, cross talk and electrode placement [6], section (section IV) explain about conclusion and future
which encourage to use another sensor such as work of the work.
accelerometer (vibration signal) and microphone (sound
signal). II. ANALYSIS
Mechanomyogram (MMG) is mechanical micro A. Statistical
vibration of muscle contraction. MMG technique provides Statistical analysis converts numbers into meaningful
information of muscle activities regarding muscle fiber conclusions in accordance with the intentions of a survey.
change between fast or slow muscle fiber. The amplitude of There are two major classes of statistical analysis. The first
Fig.1. The Statistical Flowchart

emphasizes reducing the data that have been hoarded in a wavelet indices are more significant than mean average
research field. The second emphasizes making inferences voltage and median frequency [16].
from the accumulated information. There is a special
method/process to choose a statistical test (as shown in Fig. b) Student's t-Tests
1). There are two types of statistical test. The first is The t-test is one of the tests based on the hypothesis is
differences (to find the signification between the variables), used to determine the difference between the populations.
where the second is a correlation (to find the relationship The test is only applicable for 2 groups by examining the
between the 2 or more variables. mean of the population. The p value (probability) of the test
determines from the t-statistic, t-distribution and degree of
1) Differences freedom to define whether the population means differ. This
a) Analysis of variance (ANOVA) test is used when the variance of the population is unknown
The general idea of analysis of variances (ANOVA) is and/or the population size is small [19].
to test for significant differences between means [14]. In The mean power frequency (MPF) and root mean
[84], parameter such as mean average voltage, median square (RMS) were extracted from fatigue and non-fatigue
frequency, new spectral, instantaneous mean frequency and EMG signals. The extracted parameters were tested and
instantaneous frequency variance were extracted from the shown that there are significant between fatigue and non-
EMG signal to detect muscle fatigue using one-way fatigue condition [20].
ANOVA test. The test shows that, all 5 parameters are In [21], t-test was conducted to EMG features (such as
significant differences between fatigue and non-fatigue mean power frequency and root mean square) for different
state, where the p value (probability) is less the 0.05 [15- muscle. The authors conclude that, there is significant
17]. variation between the muscles during exercise therefore, not
Parameter such wavelet index ratio: all the muscles were equally fatigued.
• between moment -1 at scale 5 and moment 5 at scale The t-test was carried out for studies of muscle length,
1 muscle fatigue and MMG. It is shown that, there is no
• between moment -1 at maximum energy and moment significant difference between the mean power frequency of
5 at scale 1 MMG and muscle length. However, there is a significant
• between moment -1 at scale 5 and moment 2 at scale difference between the mean rectified of MMG and muscle
2 length. Further, the difference in maximal force output
• of energies at scale 5 and 1 following the fatiguing contraction approached significance
• between square waveform length at different scale between the muscle lengths [22]
(scale 5 and 1) In [23], a study has been carried out to assess muscle
were calculated from the EMG signal [18]. The extracted fatigue. The t-test result shows, no differences in median
parameters were tested and find out that the entire wavelet power frequency between men and women, but there are
indices are significant. The author also mentions that
differences in root mean square between men and women. the four different homogeneous subgroups formed by
Furthermore, there are differences between muscles [23-25]. Duncan’s test. The subgroups are formed by the parameters
whose regressions could be considered equivalents. The first
c) Levene’s Test subgroup involves only the wavelet indices and in the
Levene’s test is used to test when the populations have second and fourth subgroups wavelet indices are present too
equal variances. Equal variances among the populations [18].
known as homogeneity of variances. This test is used to
verify whether the variances of the populations are same
[26].
In [18], the regression cannot be assumed equal because
the test shows significant over the residuals. The variances
of wavelet indexes are most similar among them and
different from the rest of the parameters. Fig.2 shows the
confidence intervals of the distribution of residual for each
parameter.

Fig.3. Mean of SRARs and homogeneous subgroups formed by Duncan’s


test.

f) Bonferroni correction
The Bonferroni correction is a method for correcting
the critical p value when computing multiple comparisons
using any statistical test. To find the new corrected critical
p, divide the old critical p value by the number of
comparisons being made. Compare the p values were
computed from the statistical test using the old p critical
Fig.2.Levene’s test. 95% Bonferroni confidences intervals for variances of with new p critical to avoid false positive. If the computed p
the residual of the regressions of the parameters.
value is less or equal with new critical p then, the
comparison is statistically significant [30, 31].
d) Friedman test This analysis has been carried out on wavelet indices to
Friedman test is a non-parametric statistical alternative compare the differences among the parameter. According to
to the one-way ANOVA with repeated measures. This test is the p-values have been obtained, it shows no differences
used to test different between populations by measuring the among the parameter [18].
summation and mean of ranks of columns. If the sum of the
ranks of columns has a significant difference between the 2) Correlation
populations hence, the p value will be small [27, 28]. a) Pearson Correlation
A study of muscle fatigue based evaluation of bicycle
Pearson Correlation is a test to measure the linearity
design has been carried out and Friedman test was
strength between two variables with coefficient, r ranges
performed. The test was performed on the mean power
from -1 to +1. The r value is +1 means that there is a perfect
frequency and root mean square of the EMG signal. Both
positive linear relationship between variables. The r value is
parameters show significant differences between suspension
-1 means that there is a perfect negative linear relationship
bicycle and sport bicycle for right erector spinae [29].
between variables. When the r value is 0, it means there is
no relationship between variables [32].
e) Duncan's test Pearson correlation revealed that the EMG parameter
Duncan's test was developed in 1955 by David B. correlated with muscle power changes. The most correlated
Duncan. This test compares the sample means by computing parameter is the log-new spectral with a negative slope.
the least signification range (LSR). The LSR depends on the Where, the instantaneous mean frequency and median
number of sample means in the subset. If the range of the frequency correlated with positive slope. The mean average
subset exceeds the LSR then, the sample means have voltage correlated with negative slope [15, 18].
significant difference [14]. In the study of isokinetic work-to-surface EMG signal
Fig.3 shows the mean of square root of the absolute energy ratios, mean power frequency and median power
value of the residuals for each surface EMG parameters and frequency were extracted from EMG signals. The extracted
features was tested with Pearson correlation and it shows the power of i where i = 1 to n. A second order (n=2)
that, mean power frequency and median power frequency polynomial forms a quadratic expression and a third order
are significantly correlated with isokinetic work [33]. (n=3) polynomial forms a cubic expression [37].
The 1st three order polynomial regressions (linear,
b) Kendall’s Rank Correlation quadratic and cubic model) have been used, to find the
Kendall’s rank coefficient is a coefficient that relationship between the mean amplitude of MMG, mean
represents the degree of concordance between two ranked amplitude of EMG, mean power frequency of MMG, mean
data set. Degree of concordance is measured from the ratio power frequency of EMG with peak torque. It shows that,
between different of concordant and discordant, and a total the mean amplitude of EMG and MMG fit with a linear
of concordant and discordant [34]. model. The mean power frequency of MMG and EMG is
In [35], the ratio between isokinetic work and the not significantly related with peak torque [38, 39]
energy of EMG has significantly correlated with the spectral
descriptors. The author was suggested that the ratio between B. Classification
isokinetic work and the energy of EMG can be used to Any classification method uses a lot of features or
indicate muscle fatigue conditions with time and how parameters to characterize each object, where these
efficient a muscle activity can be performed. characteristics should be relevant to the work at hand. We
consider here methods for supervised classification, having
c) Intraclass Correlation Coefficients in mind that a human expert both has determined into what
The Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) is a classes an object may be categorized and also has provided
measure of the reliability of measurements or ratings. The a set of sample objects with known classes. This band of
purpose is to assess the inter-rater reliability and the ICC, known objects is called the training set because it is
two or preferably more rater’s rate a number of study practiced by the classification programs to determine how to
subjects [36]. sort objects. There are two stages of building a classifier. In
• A distinction is made between two work modes: (1) the preparation phase, the training band is used to determine
each subject is scored by a different and random how the parameters ought to be weighted and aggregated in
selection of a pool of raters, and (2) each subject is order to distinguish the several classes of targets [40].
rated by the same raters. Artificial neural network (ANN) was applied to
• In the first example, the ICC is always a measured for determine muscle conditions (fatigue/non-fatigue) using
Absolute agreement; in the second model a selection sEMG. A network which contains more than two layers is
can be created between two types: Consistency when known as multilayer perceptron neural network (MLPNN).
systematic differences between raters are irrelevant, The layers are: input layer, hidden layer and the output
and Absolute agreement, when systematic differences layer. MLPNN is designed with Levenberg-Marquardt (L-
are relevant. M) and gradient descent (GDA) training algorithms. A
ICC analysis has been performed for the spectral fatigue matrix is form after applying Short Time Fourier Transform
index (new spectral), which calculated from the each set of (STFT), Smoothed-Pseudo-Wigner-Ville distribution
the exercise protocol. The analysis shows that, the spectral (SPWVD) and Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT). The
fatigue index data averaged across repetition indicated number of the vector has been reduced using independent
significant intersubject variability in the level of spectral component analysis (ICA). Reduced vector was used as
fatigue index changes within the tested subject population input for MLPNN and obtain results as in TABLE 1 [41].
[16].
TABLE I: Classification performances for different time-frequency tool
[41]
d) Polynomial Regression Models L-M Algorithms GDA Algorithms
Pre-processing method
Polynomial regression is a form of linear regression in (%) (%)
which the relationship between the independent STFT 88.5 87.5
variable x and the dependent variable Y is modeled as an nth SPWVD 90.0 89.0
order polynomial. The basic a polynomial model function to
fit the n order/degree polynomial is: CWT 91.0 89.0

Four different classifiers such as:


Yˆ = b + b x + b x 2 + ... + b x n (1) • k-nearest neighbor (KNN)
0 1 2 n
• Support vector machine (SVM)
where Y caret is the predicted outcome value for the • Linear discriminant analysis (LDA)
polynomial model with regression coefficients b1 to bn for • Naïve Bayes (NB)
each degree and Y intercept b0. The model is simply a were used to determine muscle condition by using multiple
general linear regression model with n predictors raised to time window features. Eleven features were extracted from
sEMG signals. The features are mean absolute value with power frequency, root mean square and spectral fatigue
two windows (MAVS1 and MAVS2), three time domain index. It's because the nature EMG signals, where the low
features from the Hamming window (MHW1, MHW2 and frequency component and motor unit firing rate are
MHW3), three time domain features from the trapezoidal increased due to muscle fatigue. Wavelet indices of EMG
window (MTW1, MTW2 and MTW3) and three time signals are more significant than mean average voltage and
domain features from the Slepian window (MSW1, MSW2 median frequency and the features are significant over the
and MSW3). The classifications were conducted twice, first variances of residuals. All the common features of EMG
with all the features, and then with selected features by using somehow correlated with muscle power. The frequency
genetic algorithms (GA) and information gain (IG). TABLE features of EMG have significant correlated with isokinetic
2 shows the classification performances for each classifier work.
with all feature and selected feature using GA and IG [42]. The MMG and AMG, which reflex the mechanical
activity (force production in contraction). Based on the
TABLE II: Classification performances with MTW feature [42] statistical studies, the mean power frequency of MMG
Classifier Accuracy shows that there is no significant difference to muscle
NB 89 length, but the rectifier mean shows significant difference in
SVM 90 muscle length. The root mean square of AMG is highly
Full Feature
KNN 92 correlated with the force of contraction and the root mean
LDA 90 square also significant difference between male and female.
NB 86 The root mean square is significantly different between the
Feature selected using SVM 86 muscles.
GA (5 features) KNN 90 There are limited work have been carried out in term of
LDA 88 classification. A review was made with the limited work.
NB 88 Based the TABLE I, II and III, the maximum accuracy of
Feature selected using SVM 87 93% was obtained for multiple time window features after
IG (6 features) KNN 93 selecting the best feature set using KNN.
LDA 89

IV. CONCLUSIONS
TABLE III: Classification performance with time and frequency features
[42]
The discussion seen in the above section shows that the
Classifier Accuracy
three different myogram has been used to assess muscle
NB 82 condition. Different type statistical tests have been
Energy and SVM 81 performed to find the difference, correlation and reliability
Complexity KNN 75 of the features among the myograms. There is no a clear
LDA 88 understanding between the myograms and classification
NB 85 result. Therefore, a multimodal system with combination of
Frequency SVM 90 all three myogram should be developed to study correlation
Information KNN 86 of the myograms and the effect of the feature level fusion
LDA 88 with the classification result.
NB 71
SVM 64
Prediction model ACKNOWLEDGMENT
KNN 78
LDA 72 The work is supported by RAGS (RAGS No.
901800043).

III. DISCUSSION
REFERENCES
In this review paper, we have reviewed the statistical
analysis and classification of 3 different myograms features
/ parameter. There myograms are EMG, MMG and AMG.
Each myogram represent different muscle activity such [1] R. M. E. a. J. Duchateau, "Muscle fatigue: what, why and how it
influences muscle function," J Physiol, p. 13, 2008.
EMG recorded electrical activity, where MMG and AMG [2] M. Sarillee, M. Hariharan, M. N. Anas, M. I. Omar, M. N.
reflect the mechanical activity of the muscle. MMG and Aishah, and Q. W. Oung, "Non-invasive techniques to assess
AMG also reflect force production of muscle. A suitable muscle fatigue using biosensors: A review," in Control and
feature extraction method and features can reveal muscle System Graduate Research Colloquium (ICSGRC), 2014 IEEE
conditions. 5th, 2014, pp. 187-192.
The most common features have been extracted from [3] S. Andreassen and L. Arendt-Nielsen, "Muscle fibre conduction
velocity in motor units of the human anterior tibial muscle: a
EMG signals to assess muscle fatigue conditions and
statistical significant are median power frequency, mean
new size principle parameter," vol. 391, ed: Physiological Soc, contractions of the human first dorsal interosseous muscle,"
1987, pp. 561-571. vol. 89, ed: Springer, 2003, pp. 520-525.
[4] G. S. Rash, "Electromyography fundamentals," vol. 4, ed, 1999. [25] D. Mealing, G. Long, and P. W. McCarthy, "Vibromyographic
[5] J. V. Basmajian, Muscles alive, their functions revealed by recording from human muscles with known fibre composition
electromyography: Williams & Wilkins, 1978. differences," vol. 30, ed: BMJ Publishing Group Ltd and
[6] E. Criswell, Cram's introduction to surface electromyography: British Association of Sport and Exercise Medicine, 1996, pp.
Jones & Bartlett Publishers, 2010. 27-31.
[7] T. W. Beck, "Surface mechanomyographic responses to muscle [26] Levene Test for Equality of Variances. Available:
fatigue," ed. Kerala, India: Trivandrum, India: Transworld http://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/eda/section3/eda35a.ht
Research Network, 2010, p. 15. m
[8] D. T. Barry, T. Hill, and D. Im, "Muscle fatigue measured with [27] R. Lowry. (2012). The Friedman Test for 3 or More Correlated
evoked muscle vibrations," vol. 15, ed: Wiley Online Library, Samples. Available: http://vassarstats.net/textbook/ch15a.html
1992, pp. 303-309. [28] I. GraphPad Software. (2015). Interpreting results: Friedman
[9] M. A. Islam, K. Sundaraj, R. B. Ahmad, and N. U. Ahamed, test. Available:
"Mechanomyogram for Muscle function assessment: A review," http://www.graphpad.com/guides/prism/6/statistics/index.htm?h
PloS one, vol. 8, p. e58902, 2013. ow_the_friedman_test_works.htm
[10] M. Mohamed Irfan, N. Sudharsan, S. Santhanakrishnan, and B. [29] V. Balasubramanian, M. Jagannath, and K. Adalarasu, "Muscle
Geethanjali, "A comparative study of emg and mmg signals for fatigue based evaluation of bicycle design," Applied
practical applications," in 2011 International Conference on ergonomics, vol. 45, pp. 339-345, 2014.
Signal, Image Processing Applications, With workshop of [30] E. W. Weisstein. (2015). Bonferroni Correction. Available:
ICEEA, 2011. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/BonferroniCorrection.html
[11] D. T. Barry, S. R. Geiringer, and R. D. Ball, "Acoustic [31] M. A. Napierala. (2015). What Is the Bonferroni Correction?
myography: a noninvasive monitor of motor unit fatigue," vol. Available:
8, ed: Wiley Online Library, 1985, pp. 189-194. http://www.aaos.org/news/aaosnow/apr12/research7.asp
[12] D. T. Barry, "Acoustic signals from frog skeletal muscle," vol. [32] S.-O. Lee and D.-G. Sim, "Objectification of perceptual image
51, ed: Elsevier, 1987, pp. 769-773. quality for mobile video," Optical Engineering, vol. 50, pp.
[13] Grass, "Acoustic Myography (AMG)," ed: © Grass, An Astro- 067404-067404-9, 2011.
Med, Inc. Product Group, 2004, p. 4. [33] F. P. Schwartz, R. S. Celes, M. Bottaro, and F. A. O.
[14] V. Bewick, L. Cheek, and J. Ball, "Statistics review 9: one-way Nascimento, "Isokinetic work-to-surface electromyographic
analysis of variance," CRITICAL CARE-LONDON-, vol. 8, pp. signal energy ratios as a muscular fatigue indicator," in
130-136, 2004. Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2009. EMBC
[15] M. González-Izal, A. Malanda, I. Navarro-Amézqueta, E. M. 2009. Annual International Conference of the IEEE, ed: IEEE,
Gorostiaga, F. Mallor, J. Ibañez, et al., "EMG spectral indices 2009, pp. 1310-1313.
and muscle power fatigue during dynamic contractions," [34] S. Limited. (2015). Kendall's Rank Correlation. Available:
Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, vol. 20, pp. 233- http://www.statsdirect.com/help/default.htm#nonparametric_me
240. thods/kendall_correlation.htm
[16] G. V. Dimitrov, T. I. Arabadzhiev, K. N. Mileva, J. L. Bowtell, [35] !!! INVALID CITATION !!!
N. Crichton, and N. A. Dimitrova, "Muscle fatigue during [36] M. S. bvba. (2015). Intraclass correlation coefficient. Available:
dynamic contractions assessed by new spectral indices," vol. https://www.medcalc.org/manual/intraclasscorrelation.php
38, ed: WILLIAMS & WILKINS, 2006, p. 1971. [37] S. Limited. (2015). Polynomial Regression. Available:
[17] D. R. Rogers and D. T. MacIsaac, "A comparison of EMG- http://www.statsdirect.com/help/default.htm#regression_and_co
based muscle fatigue assessments during dynamic contractions," rrelation/polynomial.htm
Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, vol. 23, pp. [38] K. T. Ebersole and D. M. Malek, "Fatigue and the
1004-1011, 2013. electromechanical efficiency of the vastus medialis and vastus
[18] M.González-Izal, I.Rodríguez-Carreño, F.Mallor-Giménez, lateralis muscles," vol. 43, ed: National Athletic Trainers
A.Malanda, and M.Izquierdo, "New Wavelet Indices to Assess Association, 2008, p. 152.
Muscle Fatigue during Dynamic Contractions," vol. 55, ed, [39] T. W. Beck, T. J. Housh, G. O. Johnson, J. P. Weir, J. T.
2009, pp. 480-485. Cramer, J. W. Coburn, et al., "Mechanomyographic and
[19] (2015). T-Test. Available: electromyographic time and frequency domain responses during
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/t-test.asp submaximal to maximal isokinetic muscle actions of the biceps
[20] G. W. Kroon and M. Naeije, "Recovery of the human biceps brachii," vol. 92, ed: Springer, 2004, pp. 352-359.
electromyogram after heavy eccentric, concentric or isometric [40] R. L. White. (1996). Methods for Classification. Available:
exercise," vol. 63, ed: Springer, 1991, pp. 444-448. http://sundog.stsci.edu/rick/SCMA/node2.html
[21] V. Singh, D. Kumar, D. Djuwari, B. Polus, S. Fraser, J. Hawley, [41] A. Subasi and M. K. Kiymik, "Muscle fatigue detection in EMG
et al., "Strategies to identify muscle fatigue from SEMG during using time-frequency methods, ICA and neural networks," vol.
cycling," in Intelligent Sensors, Sensor Networks and 34, ed: Springer, pp. 777-785.
Information Processing Conference, 2004. Proceedings of the [42] G. Venugopal, M. Navaneethakrishna, and S. Ramakrishnan,
2004, 2004, pp. 547-551. "Extraction and analysis of multiple time window features
[22] J. P. Weir, K. M. Ayers, J. F. Lacefield, and K. L. Walsh, associated with muscle fatigue conditions using sEMG signals,"
"Mechanomyographic and electromyographic responses during Expert Systems with Applications, vol. 41, pp. 2652-2659, 2014.
fatigue in humans: influence of muscle length," vol. 81, ed:
Springer, 2000, pp. 352-359.
[23] M. T. Tarata, "Mechanomyography versus electromyography, in
monitoring the muscular fatigue," vol. 2, ed, 2003.
[24] K. Akataki, K. Mita, M. Watakabe, and K. Itoh,
"Mechanomyographic responses during voluntary ramp

View publication stats

You might also like