Professional Documents
Culture Documents
144
© Copyright Oxford University Press
145
© Copyright Oxford University Press
2.3 have been good if we’d made a bit more B But it’s been so difficult with all the
progress today. changes. I’m sure you can appreciate, these
Extract 2 Arun Yes, if only I’d known how Rachel are factors which are out of my control.
Heidi OK, given the current situation, I’m would react to the school-leavers proposal. A Yes, I understand that. It’s been difficult
sure you’ll understand the need to improve Heidi Well, we should have anticipated it, for everybody in the group. But the point
our choice of candidates. really – we already knew she was quite I’m trying to make is I’d like to see more
Andy Absolutely, yes. resistant to the idea. evidence of how you deal with these
Heidi Now, I’m not sure what your feelings Conversation 2 challenges.
are about this, but we think we need to Rachel All I can say is, I’m still not convinced Conversation 5
move our focus away from university this is the right move, Andy. I might have A I got some useful feedback from the
graduates. We were wondering if we could been a bit too forthright, but I need to be morning session. Overall it seems they
consider targeting school-leavers instead sure any change is right for the company. don’t feel well informed about the product.
– offering them an apprenticeship with We are partners here, after all! B Really? But don’t we keep them informed
Coben Walsh and paying for them to study Andy Well, it could have been awful if we’d with our newsletter?
for their professional qualifications whilst just gone round in circles. At least we A Yes, but what I mean by ‘well informed’
gaining on-the-job experience. managed to have some kind of discussion. is, they’d have liked to be more involved
Arun Er, Heidi, would this be the right Rachel True. But suppose I hadn’t been there with the product before it came to market.
moment to mention the conditions of to present the other side of the argument? Look … to put it another way, couldn’t we
employment? What would have happened if I hadn’t consider letting them trial the products in
Heidi Oh, yes, thanks, Arun. Well, basically, suggested improving our graduate intake? their own markets first, so that they feel
the new recruits could combine work and And I still don’t think Arun brought much their views count?
study for five years, during which they to the discussion – basically, he relied on
would receive a moderate salary. After Heidi.
five years they should then get their full
professional qualification.
Andy Yes, but it’s a good thing he came to the
meeting, though. It sounds like we’re going
Unit 3
Rachel But surely the best students will want to be working quite closely with him from
to go on to university? And won’t there be now on. 3.1
bad feeling if we then recruit a graduate at a Interviewer OK. Can you tell me a little bit
higher position with a higher salary?
Heidi Now, it’s interesting you should say
2.5 about the company?
Iñaki Yes, well, our consultancy, BICG, was
that, because actually I think the trend Conversation 1 set up in 1999. Principally, we do research
is changing. A lot of good students are A So, what would you do if one of your key in the field of new ways of working, which
really worried about the cost of going members of staff was off sick on the day of is a fusion of several different disciplines
to university, and the prospect of being an important presentation? related to the organizational aspects of a
in debt. It could be that they would be B Um, well … would it help if I gave you an company. So we focus on the infrastructure
really happy to take a secure employment example? – the information and communication
opportunity instead. A Mm. Go on. technologies applied to the workplace.
Andy We’d have to demand very high grades B I mean, something like this happened to me We look at the physical environment,
from the school-leavers, you know, to make in my previous job … architecture and the use of space, the way
sure we get the best candidates. Conversation 2 an office should be built and laid out.
Heidi Yes, quite. Now, coming back to the A Ela, is it OK if we make some changes to And more generally, we deal with the
issue of graduates – they have to complete those plans you sent through? cultural aspects of a company, like working
three years of training once they join us B The ones attached with the proposal? I practices.
in any case. That means that effectively thought they’d all been approved. Interviewer Why does the professional world
they’ll only be two years ahead of the A No, I was actually referring to the ones need new office and workplace concepts?
school-leavers, and since we’re paying for drawn up for internal purposes. Especially Iñaki Well, I think it’s more like the end
five years of education I don’t think the the one on page four – it looks a bit odd to of a process, you know. Basically, we
school-leavers will complain about their me. help companies to move with the times.
comparatively low salary. B Does it? I mean, the business world has been
Rachel Mm, I suppose so. But do you really A Well, if you look at the scale at the bottom evolving rapidly over the last few decades,
think school-leavers will be able to make of the page, you’ll see what I mean. Surely due to new technologies. Things have
such big decisions about their career at the that can’t be right? changed and it’s time for physical spaces
age of 18? Given that we need employees to accommodate the new needs and
who are committed to the profession, Conversation 3
A Sorry, I’m not really sure I’ve understood. requirements of the world of work.
wouldn’t it be better to focus on ways of Interviewer OK. What kind of advantages are
improving our graduate intake? Does everybody need to be informed?
B Sorry? there from a management point of view? Is
Arun Well, I think a lot of eighteen-year-olds this purely a money-saving exercise?
do already have a clear idea of what they A Yes, sorry, let me rephrase that. Am I
supposed to notify everybody in the Iñaki No, not exclusively. I mean, cost-
want to do. Er … something else we’ve saving is certainly one of the results
been thinking about is the introduction of department each time I receive one of these
proposals? you can achieve, but it’s not the most
an entry exam … important. What is essential is being more
B No, of course not, you won’t have time to
do that. What I’m saying is that it’s worth productive and having more efficient
2.4 sending it to the people responsible for that and effective processes, and teams and
particular region. I know Alex is looking working practices. Then, also, having more
Conversation 1
for new contacts, and so is Thierry. In other motivated people.
Arun I’m so glad I finally had a face-to-face
words, there’s no point in it sitting in your Interviewer Mm. So, I imagine you make
meeting with the partners – I haven’t had
in-tray for the next few weeks. quite a few changes to the working
much contact with them so far, and at least
environment. How do the people who are
now they know who I am. Conversation 4 actually working there react to that? What
Heidi Yes, it’s just as well I brought you A Well, the last year has obviously had its ups problems do you have to anticipate?
along, Arun – as you’re the one who’s really and downs for you, but look, the fact of Iñaki Well, actually one of the core focuses
going to have to deal with Andy and Rachel the matter is that I need to see a dramatic of our work is to facilitate cultural change
if we do go ahead with the changes. If I’d improvement in your performance over the within companies. People react differently.
thought about it, I could have brought one next six months. Normally the people at the bottom are quite
of the recruitment consultants we use as
happy to get something new; a more open
well, but there’s always next time. It would
and creative environment. Those at the top
146
© Copyright Oxford University Press
of companies, senior management, they are 3.3 working, in whatever capacity, for themselves
the champions or sponsors of these new – and we anticipate that this trend will only
concepts. But middle management tends to Extract 2 increase. And this is my key point – by the
be very resistant to this kind of change, so I’d like to start by saying a few words about mid-21st century a major cultural change will
we have to explain the benefits for them as some of the changes predicted in a recent have taken place. The workforce will have
well – it’s important to generate enthusiasm report. One significant change will be the acquired the power to make choices, and
for these changes. rise in ‘demuting’. By ‘demuting’ I mean employers need to recognize this and start
Interviewer Yeah. How do you see this working remotely from wherever you are, planning for it now. To sum up, forward-
situation developing in the future? Are and not needing to travel to an office. So, the thinking employers would be wise to view
there going to be any more major changes? opposite of commuting really. It’s anticipated this element of choice as just as serious a
Or is it more of an ongoing process? that as many as 12 million people in the UK competitor as other employers are considered
Iñaki I think it’s been more or less an ongoing will be working from home by 2025. If the to be. And solving this dilemma must surely
process for a couple of decades. We’re 20th century was about the 47.6-hour week become a key priority. So, that brings me to
getting more mobile and technology is for British workers, the 21st century is going the end of my talk. Thank you very much
getting smaller and smarter, and this is a to be about a new generation of ‘career for listening. And I’ll be happy to take any
trend that is making us more flexible, more nomads’. Now, I don’t know if you’re familiar questions now.
and more independent of space. So the with this term? Well, ‘career nomads’ refers
office won’t be the place where you have to to employees who are changing the rules of 3.6
go every day and work eight hours. Work time management in ways that suit their new
1 Yes, I can’t see any alternative. I think it’s
will be something that you can do wherever approaches to work and leisure time. To put it
bound to happen sooner or later.
you are and, really, you’ll come to the office another way, employees who no longer think
2 It may happen, but it’s not very likely.
to meet people and exchange information in terms of a job for life, but move around,
3 I think it’s possible that we’ll see new
and knowledge. So that will probably be the changing jobs, and even careers. We need to
innovations in this area, yes.
trend in the near future. ask ourselves – is this a good thing, and for
4 It may well be that things change in the
Interviewer But if people aren’t coming into whom?
next few years. We’ll have to wait and see.
the office, won’t there be a problem with
5 Definitely, yes – there’s certain to be a major
communication? 3.4 change at some point in the future.
Iñaki Mm! Definitely, definitely! I mean, this
Extract 3 6 I think it’s very unlikely that will happen, to
is something you have to take account of,
OK, moving on now to look at how this be honest.
to ensure that people will communicate in
all affects the workforce. One possible 7 Oh, most certainly, yes. And it’s highly
the right way and will still have this ‘we’
consequence of the home becoming the focus likely to impact on all our lives.
feeling – being part of a team. You have
of most people’s working lives will be a rise 8 It’s quite probable that we’ll see some big
to distinguish between the work you can
in ‘binge-time careerism’ – this is where changes in the near future.
do individually wherever you are, and the
employees work non-stop for an agreed 9 It’s certain that there will be significant
kind of work where you need to exchange
period and then take the equivalent amount changes, yes.
information, ideas with your colleagues,
of time off. Personal development could also 10 Oh, definitely, and there’s a good chance
and therefore you go to the office.
benefit as new ways of working give rise to most of us will benefit from these changes.
Interviewer Mm. And how do you assess
your progress? How do you know whether ‘shadow careers’ – and perhaps here I should
or not the work you’ve done has been just explain what I mean by ‘shadow careers’ – 3.7
successful? that’s when amateur activities are pursued to
1
Iñaki Since we deal very often with so-called professional standards. So for example, …
A Hello?
‘soft’ factors, it’s not that easy to measure … Turning to the next point, research
B Hi, Sophia. It’s Manjit. Have you got a few
the success of these kinds of projects. commissioned by British Telecom points
minutes?
Nevertheless, there are other ways to out that 24-7 access to company emails and
A Er, actually I’m quite snowed under at the
measure success. Obviously, you can check information via phones and BlackBerries
moment, with the exhibition only two days
the motivation of the people in a company. could simply translate into staff working
away!
You can also check measurable aspects, harder and longer, unless organizations devise
B I know what you mean. It’s quite hectic
like, for example, the time needed to solve formal policies to deal with their new working
over here, too. I’ll only be a few minutes,
a problem. If you reduce the normal time practices. And as I said earlier, it’s predicted
though.
needed for solving a problem, then you are that there will be tension between employers
A OK. What can I do for you?
more productive. and employees over some new ways of
working. I’ll say more about the effects on 2
employers in a moment. Just to digress for a A How was the presentation? Did it go
3.2 second – the report suggests that the trend according to plan?
Extract 1 towards home working could have other B No, not quite. It wasn’t so great, actually.
All right, just to fill you in on some of positive social side effects. It points to the A Oh?
the background; research from Henley fact that three-quarters of people questioned B Well, there just wasn’t enough time to
Management College in the UK has shown believe that flexible work patterns and the rise cover everything. And there were quite a
that middle managers are under increasing of home-based businesses are likely to revive few technical problems along the way. I
pressure and it’s going to get tougher. Why? local communities. And six out of ten people don’t think the organization here has been
Because the flexible working revolution means believe the shift will make larger communities particularly good, actually.
that management will become more about and cities more personal and people-friendly. A No, it hasn’t, has it?
resourcing and measuring results than about B I mean, they should have stuck with the
following day-to-day procedures. People are 3.5 original 45 minutes per presentation.
expected to be working more flexibly in the A Yeah. It might be worth sending an email to
future. In fact, it’s estimated that by 2050 most Extract 4 everyone who came, to cover the parts you
people will have been working flexibly for For employers, however, the flip side to all missed out.
more than a decade. That’s something to think this will be the sheer number of alternatives
about, and I’ll return to this point later … available to individuals. And this brings me
… So, I´ve divided my talk up into three to the last point. Whenever I hear employers
sections. First of all, I’ll consider the current discussing how they are going to compete
research. After that, I´ll go on to talk about the for talent, the focus always seems to be on
impact on the workforce as a whole, and I´ll competition with other employers. But today’s
conclude with some comments about how this technology-aware workers already have
will affect employers. more opportunities than ever before to make
a distinct choice between corporate life and
147
© Copyright Oxford University Press
148
© Copyright Oxford University Press
149
© Copyright Oxford University Press
Riccardo I agree with Jenny. I was really thing if it did. And to be honest, I just don’t Sigma. Now this is a programme aimed at
hoping that we could find a solution that have time to rework it at the moment. improving quality, controlling costs and
suits all of us here. Thinking about this A Look, David, I’m just trying to help. And increasing efficiency, and it doesn’t tolerate
sensibly, the problems with the artwork I’m I’m not expecting you to start again. I’ve mistakes easily. It demands precision, and
prepared to overlook, if we could just sort said there’s nothing wrong with the idea the main idea is to eliminate production
out the problems with that logo. I mean, – you just need to approach it in a slightly defects.
look, would it help if I gave the printer different way. Interviewer Well, McNerney left the company
another call? See if it could be changed in B I see what you’re saying, Roberta, but the some years ago, of course. What’s the
time and get some costs? reason I’m taking this approach is because I situation at 3M since then?
Jenny That sounds sensible. Paul, I need to think this plan will work in the long run. Jost Well, people are asking whether
know we’ve got your approval on this. A No one’s denying that, but I really think McNerney’s efficiency drive hasn’t in fact
Paul OK, fair enough. I’m prepared to wait you’re going to cause yourself a lot of stifled creativity. As you can imagine, that’s
and see what you and the printer come up trouble in the short term. quite a serious concern for a company
with. B Fair enough, but it’s a bit late now. Maybe whose very identity is built on innovation.
Jenny In which case, Riccardo, can I leave you should have said something earlier. Interviewer Is there any hard evidence to
you to liaise with the printer, if we do do a Conversation 3 support these fears?
reprint? A Phew. That was hard work! Jost Well, it’s interesting. In the past, one third
Riccardo Yes, of course. If you both agree to B Yes. And it’s good thing you brought an of sales came from products released in the
this solution, I’d be more than happy to extra copy of the proposal. five previous years – today this figure has
oversee everything personally. I promise A Yeah, that was lucky. So, how do you think slipped to one quarter only. The next CEO,
you, nothing will go wrong this time! it went? George Buckley, was convinced he could
Jenny Thanks. B Pretty good, I think – they signed, anyway. outperform the competition by reigniting
And that last question – you handled that top-line growth. He pulled back from Six
5.4 really well. Sigma just enough to get the creative juices
A Thanks. Though I have to admit, I got the flowing again …
Conversation 1
idea from Jenna – apparently the same issue
A Tomasz, I’m glad I bumped into you. I’ve
had a chance to run through that document
came up last week and she got caught out. 6.2
So what about that new guy?
you asked me to look at. So … whenever Extract 1
B The one we hadn’t met before? Hassan?
you want to discuss it … James So, even though it’s been a surprisingly
Yeah, he was really tough.
B Great. Have you got time now? difficult year for Skion PCs, hopefully today
A Definitely. By the way, thanks for backing
A Yes, I have a few minutes before my next will help generate some ideas for improving
me up with the figures.
meeting. our position in the market. Would anyone
B Hey, no problem. I could see you were
B It shouldn’t take too long. And look, I really like to start?
getting kind of lost.
appreciate this, I know how busy you are. Sue Well, yes … I mean, couldn’t we consider
A I know, I’m afraid that was down to nerves.
So what were your thoughts? ways to develop our image, to show that
B Don’t worry, you did well. You just have to
A Mm, I think my only real doubt is the line we’re a genuinely caring business?
build on that experience now.
you’ve taken on absenteeism. James Sorry, I should also say, I don’t think
A Thanks for your support – it’s good to
B OK … we need to do anything that’s radically
know I’m on the right track.
A I don’t think they’ll accept this approach. different. Also, it’s not clear to me what you
B Oh, really? Why do you think that? mean by ‘caring’.
A Basically, … it … it’s not strong enough. Sue Well, for example, what about moving
B So how do you think I could improve it? Unit 6 into the area of recycling? Most people have
A I’m not sure about including all those no idea what to do with old computers and
transcripts of interviews with staff. 6.1 components – they either keep them or
Couldn’t you just summarize the key issues end up throwing them out. I would have
Interviewer Today we’re continuing our
that came up? thought it would be possible to collect a
theme of innovation, and I’m joined by
B Oh, I see. Well, it seems a pity to have to cut customer’s old computer when we sell
our business analyst, Jost Van der Saar, to
them, but maybe you’re right. Was there them a new one and implement a policy of
talk about a dilemma faced by many large
anything else? recycling.
companies. How do you run an efficient
A Mm. Yes, a slight problem – I think some of Jessica Oh, I see, so you’re thinking of
company, but also create space for those
your data is confidential. something charitable, like maybe, we collect
new, innovative ideas, without cutting into
B Oh, really? I’m sorry, I didn’t realize – in used parts and send X per cent off to
the bottom line? Jost, it’s not always that
thanks for pointing that out. developing countries, am I right?
easy to get the balance right, is it?
A Sorry, I hope this doesn’t sound too Sue Well, not necessarily that … I haven’t
Jost No, that’s right. If you take a company
negative. really had a chance to think it through
like 3M, for example. They tend to be
B No, that’s fine. Actually, I’m very happy to properly, but that’s not such a bad idea.
associated with creativity – as you know,
have some honest feedback. I’ll just keep But thinking about it, we could even set
they invented the Post-it note among
working on it. up a programme where staff can choose to
other things. Now, they underwent some
Conversation 2 spend some of their holiday time working
significant changes when James McNerney
A David, look, I’ve been meaning to say on a project in a developing country, but
took over as Chief Executive Officer – he
something … we’d pay to make sure it’s well-run and
was the first outsider to lead the company
B Yes? responsible. I’ve done something similar
in its 100-year history. The company
A It’s just … I’m kind of worried about that myself. It was actually one of the most
certainly needed knocking into shape at
proposal you’re circulating at the moment. rewarding things I’ve ever done.
that time, and McNerney set out to boost
B OK. What’s the problem? James Gareth, what do you think?
earnings from the start. One of the first
A Well, essentially I like the idea, but you Gareth To tell you the truth, I’m not totally
things he did was to cut the workforce
know how controversial it might be, don’t convinced. I’m concerned about how that
by 11%.
you? would work in practice, and I can’t help
Interviewer What kind of a reaction did he
B No, I’m sorry, I don’t see what you’re wondering whether it would really be cost-
get to these changes?
getting at. effective.
Jost Well, he caused quite a stir. McNerney’s
A I feel you could be making life difficult for James So is that a definite ‘no’?
approach to raising profitability certainly
yourself. You know, this may even go to the Gareth Well, no, but I would certainly need
satisfied the shareholders. He was clearly
workers’ council. to know that it’s profitable, before taking it
attempting to shift the emphasis from
B Look, you’re entitled to your opinion, but at any further.
innovation to quality control. And from his
this stage, you know, it might not be a bad Sue It’s not about cost-effectiveness, it’s about
days at General Electric, he introduced Six
acting responsibly …
150
© Copyright Oxford University Press
Jessica Well, can we try and take this just a James Yes, that’s true. You may have Conversation 2
little bit further after this meeting? I mean, something there. Well, it’s easily the best Eva So what do you think of my draft
obviously we’d need to do a lot more idea I’ve heard so far. And we could proposal? I’d be grateful for your feedback.
research before reaching any final decisions. probably be more competitive on service Dan Yes, it’s not bad. I’d say you’re on the
than some of those larger brokers. right track. In any case, it’s the kind of thing
6.3 Jessica Mmm, I don’t know, I’m not so keen we’re looking for. It just needs a bit more
on the idea. development.
Extract 2 James We should at least consider it, though. Eva More development …?
Jessica It’s an interesting idea. In terms of Jessica Yes, OK. But wouldn’t we be doing Dan You know, explaining the rationale
marketing I think it has potential. It’s exactly the same as Green PCs? I’ve been behind the proposal, why now, and so on.
certainly worth thinking about. In fact … looking at their website and it’s pretty Eva OK … what about the opening
well, I’m not sure how this would work in much the same idea … paragraph? Is it strong enough?
practice, but how about a wider policy on Dan Something along those lines … Yeah, you
environmental issues, you know, similar
to the idea about being ‘the company that
6.5 certainly need something like that, to help
set the right tone, don’t you? Again, I’d say
cares’, but more focused on energy-saving 1 Could I just explain in a bit more detail?
it just needs a bit more work, really.
as well as recycling? 2 You’ve obviously given this some thought.
Eva More work? Could you be more specific?
James OK, would you like to expand on that? 3 I’m not totally convinced.
Dan Well, I could give you a few general
Jessica Well, I was thinking along the lines of 4 It’s been a surprisingly difficult year.
pointers, but I’m afraid I haven’t really got
solar-powered laptops, for instance. 5 It’s easily the best idea I’ve heard so far.
time to get involved in the detail. Anyway,
Sue Solar-powered? 6 I’m just not convinced.
I thought Rob was supposed to be helping
Jessica Look, I only say that because there’s 7 It was actually one of the most rewarding
you with this?
big money in energy-saving and if we things I’ve ever done.
Eva Well, yes, I did email him last week, but
became well known as specialists in this 8 Look, I only say that because there’s big
he still hasn’t got back to me.
area we wouldn’t just sell to domestic money in energy-saving.
Dan Well, he’ll probably get back to you
customers. 9 I’m not so keen on the idea.
before the end of this week – that should
Sue Sorry, are you saying that we could open 10 I don’t really think we could get away with
still give you time to revise your draft.
up market share with this idea? that, do you?
Jessica Er … well, yes … look, could I just
Conversation 3
explain in a bit more detail? I think this is 6.6 Federico Dominique! I thought you were in
Germany?
where our website could play a major role, 1 a Could I explain in just a bit more detail?
Dominique No, I got back last night.
I mean, we could target small businesses, b Could I just explain in a bit more detail?
Federico How did the research go? Did you
educational institutions, and public sector 2 a Surprisingly, it’s been a difficult year.
see any interesting interiors?
organizations around the world. Places b It’s been a surprisingly difficult year.
Dominique Actually, overall it was quite
where electricity supplies are sporadic. 3 a It was actually one of the most rewarding
disappointing.
Does that make sense? things I’ve ever done.
Federico Oh, really?
James Well, yes, but I don’t really think we b Actually, it was one of the most
Dominique Yes. Still, there was one place
could get away with that – do you? It’s such rewarding things I’ve ever done.
that was quite interesting … I haven’t got
a departure from what we’re doing at the 4 a I really don’t think we could get away
my laptop with me now, otherwise I could
moment. I mean, it’s potentially quite high- with that, do you?
show you some photos.
risk. If I’ve understood correctly, you’re b I don’t really think we could get away
Federico Was it typically German? The style,
saying that we should become energy- with that, do you?
I mean.
saving specialists.
Dominique No, not really. It’s difficult to
Jessica Well, I just thought that in a way 6.7 explain, really. It almost had a hint of
maybe we’d gain competitive advantage,
Conversation 1 something oriental – oh, and lots of black
you know, something innovative … after
Anna Tom, I’m in the middle of preparing for and white … it was kind of minimalist.
all, the technology’s there. People are
the sales conference. Federico A lot of lacquer?
already doing it. Why not us?
Tom Oh, yes? Dominique Yes, panelling, partitions, you
Gareth I’m sorry, I’m just not convinced.
Anna Yes … and I have to do a short know, that sort of thing … In fact, you
Look, shouldn’t we be thinking more
presentation. remember that Japanese restaurant we went
about straightforward, commercial
Tom Ah. Lucky you! to in London?
developments? I think we should get back
Anna I know! More worrying still is that it’s Federico Yes, of course.
to discussing what we can do realistically,
only a month away! Dominique Well the partitions were a bit like
now, with the capacity that we have at the
Tom Yeah, it does seem to come round pretty that, but not quite as decorative.
moment, and focusing on the bottom line.
quickly …
6.4 Anna Yes. Anyway, I’ve got a few ideas, but
I still need to bring it all together. I was
Extract 3 wondering if you remember what you said
James Maybe you’re right. What did you have last year?
in mind? Tom Oh, erm, let’s see … Something about
Gareth Well, something similar to Sue and how well we were doing, I think! Er, hmm
Jessica’s ideas earlier, about recycling. … you’ve put me on the spot here. I’m
Supposing we were to sell recovered parts not quite sure now, it seems like a long
through brokers back to the manufacturers time ago. I seem to remember talking
or clients who needed ‘obsolete’ parts? about defending our strategic position –
Sue Obsolete parts? Right, erm … What something like that, in any case.
makes you think that would work? Anna OK. And did you talk about the local
Gareth Actually, it’s not nearly as complicated markets? Erm. Any kind of analysis?
as it seems; we might even be able to set up Tom Yes, I’m sure I would have done. Erm.
links on our own website … And I remember starting off with a short
James Mm, you’ve obviously given this some quiz to break the ice … I’m trying to think
thought … what I would have done with that. I could
Gareth And there’s nothing stopping us from certainly find it, though, and email it to you
setting up as brokers ourselves, is there? We if that’s any help?
could buy up unwanted parts and sell them
on ourselves, to our regular customers.
151
© Copyright Oxford University Press
152
© Copyright Oxford University Press
153
© Copyright Oxford University Press
8.4 B I’m afraid I’m not up to speed on the most analysis from them to make sure that the costs
recent developments. can be covered or offset, and to ensure the
Extract 2 A Oh, I can’t believe that. Someone with your long-term viability of the project. Once we’ve
Ian … Pavla, I’m sorry to put you on the connections? checked the project’s feasibility, we draw up
spot, but would you like to run through the B It’s not for me to say. Sorry. This is HR’s guidelines outlining the scope of work for the
union complaints briefly? We’ve really got responsibility. partners, and we agree goals and objectives.
to do something about job descriptions and 4 We then require regular access to the site,
pay scales. What ideas has your team come A Look, I just need to know. Have they agreed er, plus monthly reports and reviews with
up with so far? to work with us or not? quantifiable data.
Pavla OK. How long do I have? B Well, it’s not that straightforward. There are
Ian As long as you need. still things to consider. 9.2
Pavla Right. Well, it’s probably best if I just A Oh, come on. It’s a simple question. Yes or
highlight some of the ideas we came up Extract 1
no?
with, don’t you think? Erm, it was basically Margit So, looking at the situation from a
B Honestly, Kris. I’m afraid I don’t know any
a brainstorming session. So, the first thing long-term perspective, if the IT system is
more than you do.
is, we feel that people are simply time- updated, you’ll be more efficient in terms of
serving and spending too long here. I don’t 5 your customer admin, and you’ll be able to
know if you agree, but I’m pretty sure that A So, is our budget likely to increase in the continue your expansion plan. Is that right?
this isn’t great for productivity in the long next financial year? Judit Exactly. We need to develop a clear
run. And I think you should be aware that B It’s hard to say at the moment. strategy to move the business forward. At
it’s not limited to one department … A But the decision must have been made, the moment our systems are old, they’re
… it’s crucial in the current climate. So surely? If I find out that you knew outdated, and we don’t have a clear
that’s one key point right there – we need to something … overview of our customers’ transactions.
look at attitudes across the organization. Er, B Look, it’s nothing to do with me, OK? Margit Zoltan …
OK, next point, and I think this is a really 6 Zoltan Well, we have a number of options.
important point: we need to start looking A That was a surprise, wasn’t it, Enzo leaving We’ve already commissioned three
carefully at the current pay-scales … so suddenly? proposals from reputable IT companies.
… and, er, I don’t think there’s anything B Mm … I can’t really comment. Provided we check out the feasibility of
I’ve forgotten, erm … so, the main thing A I heard that he didn’t resign – he was fired. these options thoroughly, I’m convinced we
to remember is to listen. OK, I think that’s B I’m afraid I can’t disclose that information – can find a system upgrade that will work
about it. it’s confidential. for us.
Ian Good, thank you for that. I assume Margit OK, that’s all very positive, but I think
everyone participated in the brainstorming, we need to look at the bigger picture. Do
did they? If it was just one or two
individuals, then just how useful are the
Unit 9 we actually have the resources for this?
I mean, there’s no point in investing in a
results? system upgrade if we don’t have the space,
Pavla I can’t remember exactly, but … off
9.1 the personnel or the finances to carry it
the top of my head, I think everyone had 1 through.
something to say. That’s quite a significant Personally, I’m actually against this trend Zoltan Yes, but …
factor, though … I can double check if you for CSR policies. I mean, why should I – a Margit Let’s take a look at our physical
like? shareholder – allow the equity that I’ve resources. Will the new system be linked
Ian Yes, email me later. built up to be spent on so-called social to production? I mean, you have a lot of
Pavla I was wondering if there was anything responsibility? I feel a lot of these projects real estate here, but the facilities are pretty
else you’d like to know about the origins of are set up purely for short-term gain, and in run-down. Is it practical to set up a hi-tech
the ideas? the long run they can become a huge drain system in such an old place?
Ian No, that’s fine, but it might also be worth on resources. I mean, how do we know if the Judit Well, if we’d invested in our production
touching on the numbers of complaints per money to be invested in, say, a school project facilities five years ago, like we wanted
business unit. in a developing country, is actually going to to, we would have knocked down the old
Pavla Well, I don’t have the exact figures, but the right people? We don’t. If I want to donate building and had one purpose-built. It’s
what if I run through the rough numbers my money to something like this, then that’s useless to speculate about that now, of
we’ve come up with so far? my business. What I want is a good return on course …
investment – for me it’s all about the bottom
8.5 line. 9.3
1 2 Extract 2
A Ah! Thierry! Just the person I was looking In my experience, having a sound CSR Margit … OK, so you already have the
for! Is it true you’re considering reducing policy actually increases the market value infrastructure you need to support the new
the amount of staff car-parking? of a company. By that, I mean a company’s system, even if it’s not directly connected to
B Ah … Look, Rachel, I’m afraid I’m really reputation is one of its key assets – it can the production facility.
not in a position to talk about that. have a significant impact on the success of Zoltan, Judit Yes, sure.
A So is it true, then? the brand. Take Coca-Cola, for example: 96% Margit Now, what’s the situation regarding
B No, I’m sorry, but I can’t answer that. of their value is made up of intangibles – the personnel?
brand itself is worth a fortune, obviously. Judit Well, they’d need training. I think our
2 But if they made a major error, socially options are quite clear here. It doesn’t really
A These demonstrations are quite serious,
or environmentally, the reputation of the matter which system we choose – if training
aren’t they? You must be worried about the
company would suffer and it could take a very isn’t on the agenda, we should forget the
political situation at home?
long time to recover. To dismiss CSR policies whole idea. I mean, you can’t expect us to …
B I’m sorry, I don’t know what you mean.
on the basis of short-term profit doesn’t make Zoltan Yes, but we do have some employees
A Oh, come on. It’s all over the news. Your
much business sense to me. who’ve worked on SAP-type systems in
government is taking a very hard line – I
3 previous jobs. If we made them our key
just want to know what you think.
We’re in the textile industry and we run a users, we could gradually train up the rest.
B I’m sorry, Karl. I would prefer not to talk
number of CSR projects with our suppliers, Margit I’m not sure that would work. Do you
about it.
who are mostly from Asia. These range from really have a sufficient skills base to meet
3 helping to improve the working conditions the needs of this strategy? You can’t just
A Can you tell us a little more about the rely on one or two people and you can’t
in factories to helping the local community to
proposed office move? run two systems in parallel. How would it
look after native species. Before our suppliers
become CSR partners we require a cost-benefit work if you took on some younger people?
154
© Copyright Oxford University Press
155
© Copyright Oxford University Press
10.2 applications together. What this will allow us Can you give us an assurance that we’ll get
to do is offer our clients a more personalized the appropriate level of support?
Bruce I’d spent fifteen years as a and customized service – something we Jim Of course. That’s a valid point, but again
manufacturing engineer, eight of them as a couldn’t do before. Another great thing about I really don’t see this as a problem. My
manager. And suddenly here I was, co-leading this development is that it will allow us to understanding is that you will receive all
the team that would design a new fuselage grow our business in our core markets more the instructions and materials you need to
for our latest passenger plane. The technical rapidly. We can get our applications and new help you implement this.
demands were awesome: stretch the plane by products into the market more quickly and Thomas Yeah, well … I guess that should be
eight metres, add lots of functionality, do it in more cost-effectively – which is obviously OK. But I also have some concerns about
less than two years. The human demands were good for the business as a whole. There may the impact on customers. I mean, how do
just as challenging – my job was to coordinate be some short-term inconvenience during the we ensure that we continue to provide a
the work of 300 team members. Most of them implementation and the switchover phase, proper service? What assurances can you
didn’t report directly to me, almost none of but it will be well worth the investment. In give us that it will work?
them knew me very well – and vice versa. the longer term, the benefits are clear. We all Anna That’s a good point. And can we
It’s a kind of daunting prospect! The first thing know that this is a competitive sector – our address the issue of costs and budgeting? I
was, I had to establish my credibility. I had lots customers want a fast, efficient service, and think the basic idea is good, but I have some
of credibility as an engineer, but now I was this is going to allow us to provide this and reservations about the cost implications. I
responsible for all kinds of areas that weren’t to stay ahead of the competition. So, you and mean, whose money are we talking about
in my background. 95% of my people get your teams are crucial to the success of this here? Are there any guarantees that we
their pay-checks from other departments, so strategy. That’s why I want to involve you now won’t be asked to contribute to this out of
all I can do is influence them. I realized pretty in planning the implementation process at a our operational budgets?
quickly that what the experts say is true. Team local level. It is proposed that we hold a series Jim Well, I understand where you’re coming
leaders don’t lead teams: they lead a collection of seminars for team leaders at the regional from, of course. The core investment comes
of individuals with different strengths and training centres well in advance, to ensure that from central funding, obviously. It’s been
weaknesses, different workstyle preferences everyone is familiar with the system and the suggested that the regional centres should
… There’s no way you can get a team to work procedures. If we’re going to succeed, we need contribute a certain amount of the training
together unless you learn how to work with to realize that we’re all in this together. Each costs, on the basis that this will be recouped
each person on a one-on-one basis. You have to one of you has a key role to play in making in increased business later on …
deal with people based on how they want you the new system work. What I need you to Anna What?
to deal with them – that’s how you get them do, first of all, is to commit to making this Jim Yes. I’ve been told that the costs need to
to follow you. It’s about generating mutual project a success. If you are committed, your be shared around. Apparently the intention
respect. Look, if you want to exert influence teams will realize that and they’ll get behind is to make everyone’s lives easier and better
over hundreds of different people, few of it. I’d like to see all of you being proactive – including yours. Anyway, the decision
whom work for you directly, the only way is and taking a lead in this. Set up regular has already been made. I know it’s not
to work with them on an informal basis – walk meetings or teleconferences, to share ideas great, but come on, let’s give this a chance
around, ask how it’s going. But do it subtly, and coordinate your plans. I’d also like you to work.
in a noninterventionist kind of way. Avoid to work together to develop a schedule for
the temptation to micromanage. It’s easy to
criticize people if you don’t understand their
training – familiarizing your teams with the 10.5
new applications and how they work. Another
roles and their constraints. Take a step back. way you can help is by keeping your team Conversation 1
Most people want to do a good job. You have informed, and asking them for their ideas and A So what did you think of the meeting?
to let them know that you’re there to help, not opinions. I would encourage all of you to do B I thought it was quite productive. But to be
just to tell them what to do. I basically have this. Make them feel involved, make them feel honest with you, I think there are still some
one message to everyone on the team – it’s that their views count – which they do. Well, things to sort out.
designed to reinforce a sense of team spirit and now, I’m sure you have some concerns, so let’s A Oh? Such as?
collaboration: ‘We’re all here to build airplanes. just talk about … B Well, for example, we still don’t really know
If the plane could talk, what would it tell how the new assessment system will work
us to do? And what can we do to make that
happen?’ But I also make sure that I recognize
10.4 in practice. And personally speaking, I
don’t see how we can agree to something
individual achievement within the group. Let Part 2 that we haven’t even been consulted about.
me give you an example. Recently, one of my Jessica Jim, I’d like to raise an issue – I A You’re not in favour of the changes then?
engineers was taking his time authorizing a imagine it’s something all of us are worried B It’s not that. I’m actually quite enthusiastic
decision. I said I’d get him a dozen doughnuts about. I understand the reasons for about them. But it’s the lack of proper
if he’d deliver the signed form that day. At 4.00 upgrading the system, that’s clear, but I’m consultation, the lack of any real discussion.
p.m. it was on my desk. He got his doughnuts slightly concerned about the timing and its I have to say I find that quite difficult to
the next morning. It was neat to see the look in effect on my team. Will we have enough accept.
his eyes, like, ‘You really did that?’. time to prepare properly? And will there be A Yes, I can understand that …
an increase in workload? I wonder if you Conversation 2
10.3 have any information about this? A I was interested in what you said earlier
Jim Well, I understand your concerns, but I about working in Kenya.
Part 1 think we need to look at the positive side.
Jim OK, you’re all aware that a decision was B Yes, it was a good experience for me,
We’ve been given a deadline of the 30th of especially so early in my career. I learned a
taken at last week’s strategy meeting that September, which is still more than three
affects all of us. I hope you’ve read the briefing lot.
months away. As I understand it, the switch A What did you like about it in particular?
document … Yes? Good, so you know what’s over to the new system will be coordinated
involved. I understand you may feel it doesn’t B Well, the people were fantastic – positive,
centrally and you’ll be briefed about it well friendly, incredibly hard-working. But what
address your particular situation, and that’s in advance – so it shouldn’t have an impact
part of the reason I’m here. I’m sure you have I really liked was the independence. It was
on the way you work. As long as your team just me and a team of locals in the field
quite a few questions and concerns, and I’ll have had the training in time, I don’t think
do my best to answer them. But first off, let office – I was accountable to Head Office, of
you need to worry. course, but I was pretty much free to make
me bring you up to speed on some of the key Thomas Well, that’s something I wanted to
points. my own decisions.
mention. You said you wanted us to work A Even so, it must have been challenging at
As you know, it has been agreed that we together, and I like the idea of regular
are going to combine our e-banking systems times?
meetings and sharing ideas, but I’m not B It was challenging, yeah. But to tell you
into a single integrated network – this involves very happy about having to schedule and
the creation of what is called a ‘middle layer’ the truth, I really enjoyed it. To be perfectly
coordinate the training for my team. I don’t honest, I’m not particularly good at
to the network, enabling us to bring all our really feel I have the expertise to do this.
156
© Copyright Oxford University Press
working in a big team. I much prefer to be those of many other countries, for all kinds 11.2
my own boss. of reasons. I’d like some better evidence,
A I can see that that would have been quite frankly. OK, there may be a downturn in Part 1
attractive. So … how does it feel to be back uptake of certain US products – but that Hyun-Ki Hello?
at the centre of things? could be due to any number of economic Laura Hello. Is that Hyun-Ki?
B Honestly? It’s fine, the job’s good, but factors. It doesn’t have to be because people Hyun-Ki Yes. Hello, Laura. How are you?
what I’d really like to do is run my own don’t like America. Laura Very well, thanks. Are you both there?
operation, my own projects, with no … Carla Well, there’s evidence that the number Jin-Ho Yes, I’m here too. Hello, Laura.
well, interference. That would be even of people worldwide who like and use US- Laura Hi, Jin-Ho. Andrew is with me, too.
better. branded products has fallen significantly, Andrew Hello.
A Yes, I know what you mean … and at the same time brands perceived to Hyun-Ki, Jin-Ho Good morning, Andrew. Are
Conversation 3 be non-American have remained relatively you well?
A You were saying earlier that you’d been on stable. It’s … it’s not a disaster – yet – but Andrew Pretty good, thanks. And you two?
a team-building course. it is clearly a warning sign. And in the Hyun-Ki We’re well, thank you.
B Yes, the whole weekend. long term, if attitudes to America become Laura Good. So shall we talk about this email?
A I heard some people thought it was a waste appreciably more hostile, they are saying, Can you clarify the situation for us, please,
of time. the effect on American business could be Hyun-Ki?
B Yeah, well … maybe. Personally, I think irretrievably damaging. Hyun-Ki Yes, of course. Faced with a few
that’s down to their attitude. Doug Yes, but, come on … new developments here, we now have
A What do you mean? Carla OK, right, well, wait, let’s look at some capacity issues. Not only has one of
B Well, I look at it like this: you get out of some figures. Until 2002, NOP found that our contracts just trebled their order, but
these things what you put into them. brands such as McDonald’s and Coca- another new contract has just come in.
A You mean, if you approach it positively, Cola were achieving healthy growth, year Given the unexpected increase in volume,
you’ll get something positive back? on year, in terms of their popularity in we now have a big backlog of work and
B Exactly. And vice versa. Even if you aren’t international markets. But by the middle of are in a very difficult situation. Having
100% sure, at least give it a try. the decade the growth in popularity of all considered all other options, we have to ask
A So …? major consumer brands – including those for an extension on our deadline.
B Look, my attitude is, if you expect from Europe and Asia – had stalled. And Laura I see. Well, that’s not going to be easy
something to be a bad experience, you go recently, this previously positive trend has for us. We have a fixed date to meet, which
in expecting it to be pointless, chances are gone into reverse, with US products the I think we made clear at the start.
it will be – for you. Don’t get me wrong, I hardest hit. Hyun-Ki Yes, that’s quite true and I can only
know when something’s not working. But Doug But you just said yourself it’s not only apologize. But I’m afraid this is beyond our
I do think I have the ability to make the American brands that are taking a hit. Why control now. I was hoping we could discuss
most of my opportunities. It’s one of my are you saying that … a new arrangement.
strengths. Host …OK right, well, let’s try and move Andrew Hyun-Ki, this is not good news for
A Well, good for you. this on. Carla, you said that the NOP study us. As Laura says, we need stock in Berlin
B Yeah … look, anyway, how was your found that this unexpectedly rapid decline in seven weeks. So I think I have to say
weekend? in interest in and respect for American ‘no’ to a new arrangement. If we have no
products was reflected in consumers’ views product there’ll be no product launch,
of American cultural values. What values which means serious problems for the
are we talking about here? company. Do you understand that?
Unit 11 Carla I’m talking about core values like Hyun-Ki Yes, yes. I understand how
honesty, freedom of expression and important this is for you. But please
11.1 tolerance. Internationalism, if you will. understand also I could not have foreseen
Host … So, Carla, just outline the issue for us, Increasingly, consumers around the world this extra work. I wish I could meet your
if you would. are questioning whether these values still order, but I’m afraid it is just not possible
Carla OK. A recently-published study of hold true, and whether they want to be for us now.
consumer attitudes worldwide clearly associated with them. And this is reflected Andrew No, no, look … this is not good
shows a marked decline in respect for in the choices they make about the brands enough. At no time have we suggested that
American values globally. This study was they choose to buy. It’s kind of complicated. we can be flexible on these dates. Offering
carried out by the market research company Doug I’m not sure it is complicated. We’re at flexibility on these dates just isn’t going
NOP World. And the implications for the a time of economic and political change, the to work for us. We have our company
American economy cannot be ignored – this balance of economic power in the world reputation at stake and without wishing to
view of America is having a potentially is shifting. We already know that there sound pushy, you are under contract to …
disastrous effect on the image of major US are certain countries in the Middle East Laura Yes, yes. OK, Andrew, please. As
brands such as McDonald’s, Coca-Cola, and Latin America, for example, where changing the situation is no longer possible,
Nike and Microsoft. consumers with increasing buying power let’s try to find a way round this. OK? So,
Host It’s really that serious? are – and, incidentally, always have been – Hyun-Ki, if I understand you correctly,
Carla It could be. NOP World interviewed unlikely to share American cultural values. you can’t meet the full order in time for the
30,000 people in markets around the Carla But the study also found that people in Berlin exhibition …
world. According to their findings, there a number of major European markets felt
are a number of factors that have all had that their own values were significantly
a profoundly worrying effect on their different to American ones. For example,
perception of American culture and, as a only 65% of British consumers say that they
consequence, on many of its major brands. identify with American cultural values. In
Just for the record, these include recent Italy and France it’s 63%, and in Germany
American foreign policy, which many it’s only 55%. This is a downward trend
people see as controversial, corporate we’re looking at.
financial scandals, and a comparatively Host Well, whether or not this image of
poor environmental record. There’s a America is right, it’s clearly the way we are
real sense that America has lost its moral being perceived. And presumably it will
authority in recent years. become increasingly difficult to reverse the
Host Doug, any thoughts on this? trend the longer it goes on. So the question
Doug Well, I just don’t buy this direct link is, what if anything are we able to do about
that’s being made. Yes, it may be true that it …?
America’s image has suffered, but so have
157
© Copyright Oxford University Press
158
© Copyright Oxford University Press
159
© Copyright Oxford University Press