Construction of Dwarka Expressway Package-II

Design Checker's PROOF CHECKING FORM

Period: March 2022

Design Checker: Mr. Jatinder Singh Pahuja

EB-351-DWEXP-PKG02-PCRS-0342-R3-Closed
 Construction of Dwarka Expressway Package – II

DESIGN EPC CONTRACTOR PROOF CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT

Construction of Dwarka Expressway from J. KUMAR INFRAPROJECTS LTD.

Road Under Bridge (RUB) Near Sector 21 Dwarka to Delhi Haryana Border STRUCTCON
DESIGNS
(km. 5.300 to km. 9.500) - Package-2 in State of Delhi PVT. LTD.
TANDON CONSULTANTS PVT LTD

Proof Checker Review Sheet

TCPL PCRS NO.: EB-351-DWEXP-PKG02-PCRS-0342-

Ref.Transmittal no.: TR -2361, 2441, 2449, 2547 R3-Closed
Discipline: Mr. Jatinder Singh Pahuja
Voided Slab Superstructure-P460 to A14- Dsn Note SC-960-S-B3-DN-5202A, SC-960-S-B3-DN-
5202, Drg No-SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3958, SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3959, SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-1 CIVIL/ STRUCTURE
Subject :-
& 2), SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3982, SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1 to 4) , SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3962
(Sheet-1 to 4)
Number DESIGN DOCUMENT/ DRAWINGS/ CALCULATIONS Rev. DATE INPUT/ COMMENTS BY CHECKER DATE DESIGNER'S RESPONSE STATUS
STATUS No. CHECKED RESPONDED (OPEN/CLOSED)
(PD/DD/CRD)

Section no.
At end cantilever dimension given is wrong. It should be "Varies from 500 to 1175"
1 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Plan At E-E 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
instead of "Varies from 645 to 1175".

2 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Section 2-2 Downstand depth of seismic arrestor from superstructure is not given. 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED

Clear gap of 25mm (min) is shown in section 2-

3 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Section 2-2 Clear distance between downstand & pedestal is missing 19-04-2022 CLOSED
2

Construction jt should be also shown in longitudinal elevation also. It dimension should

Longitudinal Elevation
4 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3959 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 be also given. In plan, it should be made clear that 6500 is given along centerline of 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
Along C/L of Voided Slab
voided slab

5 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 Section 3-3 Downstand depth of seismic arrestor from superstructure is not given. 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED

Clear gap of 25mm (min) is shown in section 3-

6 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 Section 3-3 Clear distance between downstand & pedestal is missing 19-04-2022 CLOSED
3

A longitudinal section should be also cut from pedestal so that dimension / clearance of
Section 6-6 added showing longitudinal section
7 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 Section 3-3 downstand seismic arrestor from superstructure is clearly understood. Pl take care of 19-04-2022 CLOSED
at spherical bearing location
longitudinal slope of superstructure also while drawing such section.

With the longitudinal section 6-6 drawn , it is evident that minimum wedge length
Noted and revised Wedge drawing will be
7A DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-2) P1 21-04-2022 Section 6-6 required at bottom of soffit slab should be 2050mm. Pl check & modify . This may 26-04-2022 CLOSED
submitted seperately
require modification in separate wedge drg also.

Longitudinal elevation for Above-mentioned comment will require modification in Drg no- SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962
7B DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-2) P1 21-04-2022 26-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
diaphragm (Sheet-2)

Pl note that approval will be only accorded , once revised wedge rotation drg will be
7C DD General P2 28-04-2022 Wedge Rotation drg 21-06-2022 Noted CLOSED
submitted by DDC which has not submitted by DDC so far.

Effect of above-mentioned comments is still not incorporated in longitudinal elevation on

7D DD SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3959 P2 28-04-2022 Longitudinal Elevation 21-06-2022 Noted and corrected CLOSED
pier P461 by DDC.

Plan showing Top bars of 3

8 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 span continuous voided slab There is no third layer over pier P462. then why A52 is shown over P462. Pl delete it. 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
at Deck level

9 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Schedule In bar shape of A1a , bend to be shown at end of bar A1. 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED

Jatinder Singh Pahuja

Jatinder Singh Pahuja Lead Proof Checker
Proof Checker Page 2 of 3
 Construction of Dwarka Expressway Package – II

Proof Checker Review Sheet

TCPL PCRS NO.: EB-351-DWEXP-PKG02-PCRS-0342-

Ref.Transmittal no.: TR -2361, 2441, 2449, 2547 R3-Closed
Discipline: Mr. Jatinder Singh Pahuja
Voided Slab Superstructure-P460 to A14- Dsn Note SC-960-S-B3-DN-5202A, SC-960-S-B3-DN-
5202, Drg No-SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3958, SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3959, SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3960 (Sheet-1 CIVIL/ STRUCTURE
Subject :-
& 2), SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3982, SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1 to 4) , SC-960-S-B3-SPD-3962
(Sheet-1 to 4)
Number DESIGN DOCUMENT/ DRAWINGS/ CALCULATIONS Rev. DATE INPUT/ COMMENTS BY CHECKER DATE DESIGNER'S RESPONSE STATUS
STATUS No. CHECKED RESPONDED (OPEN/CLOSED)
(PD/DD/CRD)

10 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Schedule There is no bar no- A51 in any of sheet. Why it is shown in schedule? 19-04-2022 Bar mark A51 removed from schedule CLOSED

Bar no- A58 is shown as 6nos-10Y . It should be 6nos-16Y . This needs to be changed in
already approved cont unit P456 to P460 also. At edge of cantilever to increase its
11 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Schedule 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
stiffness , more longitudinal reinf is required. This is being fiollowed in all approved
segmental superstructure also.

In earlier submission of continuous unit , bar A21a is continuous till support but in this
Elevation , section 2-2 &
submission it is curtailed very well before support resulting in very large spacing between
SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-2) & (Sheet-4), SC-960-S- Plan showing Bottom bars
12 DD P0 18-04-2022 bars which is not desirable at all to control shrinkage or thermal cracks during hardening 19-04-2022 Noted and modified as per approved drawing CLOSED
B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-1 to 4) of 3 span continuous voided
process of concrete. Pl restore originaly approved detailing in continuous unit under
slab at Soffit Level
consideration.

Elevation , section 2-2 &

SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-2) & (Sheet-4), SC-960-S- Plan showing Bottom bars Above-mentioned comment is not implemented in Elevation & Section 2-2 of Drg no-SC-
12A DD P1 21-04-2022 26-04-2022 Noted and corrected CLOSED
B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-1 to 4) of 3 span continuous voided 960-S-B3-SPR-3961(Sheet-4), Cross-section of SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-2 & 3)
slab at Soffit Level

SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-2) & (Sheet-4), SC-960-S- This is second time we are reminiding to DDC that above-mentioned comment is not
12B DD P2 28-04-2022 Elevation 21-06-2022 Noted and corrected CLOSED
B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-1 to 4) implemented by DDC in Elevation. Very frustrating affair.

Plan showing Top bars of 3

In elevation , curtailment of bar A22a is shown as 4000m from centerline of Pier 461
13 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 span continuous voided slab 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected in plan CLOSED
while in plan it is shown as 3550. Pl correct it.
at Deck level

in solid portion stirrups in front of voider opening are A6e (whose details are given in
14 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3961 (sheet-4) P0 18-04-2022 Section 2-2 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
schedule) & not A6d.

Longitudinal elevation For

15 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Some text is missing at bottom 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
diaphragm
16 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-1) P0 18-04-2022 Section A-A Nos of dots of Bar B1 is not matching with nos of bars shown in schedule. 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
Longitudinal elevation For
17 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 Pier P458 shall be replaced by P461 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
diaphragm
Longitudinal elevation For
18 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-2) P0 18-04-2022 Pier PP459 shall be replaced by P462 19-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
diaphragm
Schedule, Detail-B, Section
19 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-4) P1 21-04-2022 Shape of B68 should be as same as B66 but of lesser width 26-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
6-6 & Section 7-7
Schedule, Detail-A &
20 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-4) P1 21-04-2022 Shape of B64 should be as same as B61 but of lesser width 26-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED
Section 4-4
21 DD SC-960-S-B3-SPR-3962 (Sheet-4) P1 21-04-2022 Schedule Bend of bar should have development length into voided slab 26-04-2022 Noted and Corrected CLOSED

Jatinder Singh Pahuja

Jatinder Singh Pahuja Lead Proof Checker
Proof Checker Page 3 of 3