Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sizing of
Precise temperature control has a significant influence on performance and quality in chemical
process engineering. The Unistat range of temperature control systems ensure accurate temperatures
and stable process conditions in research laboratories, pilot plants and kilo labs worldwide.
The Unistat principle has been diversified into a wide range of different system designs to be able to
provide accurate temperature control on these different scales. Calculating the best Unistat for your
chemical process is the subject of these works.
3
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
or removal of heat energy during the chemical process output or input of the system as equal to zero. To
to ensure a safe and reproducible delivery of compo- maintain this balance do we therefore: A apply energy
nent C. The requirements for this depend on whether (heat) to promote the chemical reaction (Endothermic)
the reaction is exothermic (heat energy is released to to occur. Or B removes energy (cool) to perform the
the surroundings) or endothermic (heat energy is ab- chemical reaction (Exothermic) in a safe and controlled
sorbed from the surroundings). manner , to prevent side reactions and increase reac-
tion yield. Too much heat can lead to incorrect chirality
Energy balance here is defined as the sum of the heat
or remove functional groups.
Endothermic Reaction
Activation
Energy
Potential Energy
Products
Released
Energy
Reactants
Reaction Progress
Fig. 2: Shown here is a 20l reactor connected to a Grande Fleur, heating the reaction media to +80 °C.
Exothermic Reaction
Activation
Energy
Potential Energy
Reactants
Released
Energy
Products
Reaction Progress
Fig. 3: Shown here is a 50l reactor connected to an Unistat 510w, cooling the reaction media to -40 °C.
4
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
All reactions require molecules A+B to come together In standard process development scenarios, the reac-
with sufficient potential energy to transform to product tion calorimetry analyses take place during identifying
C. An endothermic reaction requires heat to achieve re- synthetic routes, and afterward during optimization of
action initiation, for example heating of a reaction solu- the route selected. Reaction calorimetry will be usually
tion to reflux (see Fig. 2). The potential energy profile ) accompanied by thermal screening (determining the
of an endothermic reaction indicates the activation en- thermal stability of the components/products), to es-
ergy required to generate product is greater than the tablish most efficient and safe process.
energy released by product formation. Therefore a net
However, the temperature control of the chemical pro-
heat gain is required.
cess is only part of the energy balance required. The
In general, exothermic reactions are cooled, often to thermal properties of the equipment used to carry out
sub ambient temperatures and in particular -50 to -78 the experiment must be factored in to achieve preci-
°C. Shown here is a 50l reactor connected to a Unistat sion temperature control.
510w, where we are cooling the reaction media to -40
In the Fig. 4 and 5 we can see heat loss and gains from
°C.
the reactor systems to the local environment. On the
Of note in both images above the Huber unit in both Fig. 4 we have a glass lined stainless steel reactor which
thermal imaging photos show they are thermally inert has a smaller heat loss to the environment than the
and are delivering the required heating/cooling to the reactor in Fig. 5, a jacketed glass reactor. In addition
relevant application . to this we can see the reactor stand frame work in the
RHS side image is being cooled via air flow.
To understand your chemical process, reaction calo-
rimetry has become an invaluable tool for determin- We have to look at all materials involved, not only in the
ing reaction kinetics and optimising known reactions chemical process, but the application and the different
(dosing profiles, process temperatures etc.), while the materials involved in the whole system set-up. Each dif-
most important feature is the determination of pro- ferent component will absorb and emit the heat that is
cess safety, especially when scaling up the process for applied at different rates (heat capacity) and be pres-
production. ent in different masses.
Generally, reaction calorimetry data should be availa-
ble before moving the development of a chemical pro-
cess to a larger scale (Kilo/Pilot plant scale). The data
obtained will provide the thermal and kinetic profile of
the reaction, on which the design of the larger scale
experiment and thus, production processes should be
built upon to run the process under safe conditions
Fig. 4: Shown here is a 80l glass lined stainless steel reactor Fig. 5: Shown here is a 50l jacketed glass reactor connected
connected to an Unistat 912w, cooling down to -90 °C. to an Unistat 510w, cooling the reaction media to -40 °C.
5
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Required Cooling and Heating Capacity for Key componets that influence temperature
Reactor Systems control across all scales
Using our knowledge from above we can calculate the Information required for sizing:
heating/cooling power required for different size re-
• Reactor (Glass, GLS, SS)
actors. However, before we perform a sizing calcula-
tion for the power requirements for the process being • Impeller (Glass, SS, PTFE)
scaled we need to access the application as a global • Baffles, Samplers etc.
function. By this we have to take into account all mate-
rials that shall be in contact with the heat transfer fluid • Reactor Volume
and the reaction medium. • Reactor Jacket Capacity
This calculation must include the supply lines running • HTF feed and return lines
from the temperature control unit to the application (Weight and capacity)
and their return feed also.
Sizing
For a process where the temperature input, tempera- Mass of System
ture output and flowrates of the heat transfer fluid are (kg*cp) System
not known we can calculate cooling and heating capac- = the sum of materials (weight by heat capacity)
ity using the following equation.
Reactor weight (including lid), Impellers, Baffles, Tem-
Kilowatts required for heating or cooling perature Probe, HTF hoses/pipes
{[Mass of Materials x Heat Capacity] x Temp. Difference
start to end}/ required time frame Mass of Thermal Fluid
Q =[(kg*cp) System + (kg*cp) Thermal Fluid + (kg*cp) Thermal Fluid
(kg*cp) Reaction Media] dT/t = the sum of HTF (weight by heat capacity)
If we look at a reactor system and TCU we can break Reactor Jacket, Hoses, Fill Volume of Huber Unit (Esti-
the Mass of Materials component of equation down mated based on unit end temp]
further to 3 components for the mass of materials.
6
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Fig. 6.2: Mass of Thermal Fluid Fig. 6.3: Mass of Reaction Media
Legend:
Q = Power required in kW
[of note a negative value in-
dicates cooling]
kg = kilogram
cp = specific heat capacity
dT = Delta (difference) in
temperature
t = time in seconds
7
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Worked Example:
Customer would like to cool a 50 l reactor containing
toluene from 120 °C to -30 °C in a time frame of 2.5 h. Fig. 7: Key data required for calculation
Calculation
Delta T -150 k
Q =[(kg*cp)Material + (kg*cp)HTF + (kg*cp)Vessel Cont]dT/t
t 9000 s
Q =[59.6 + 41.4 + 80.6 kJ /k]( -150 k) / 9000 s
Q =[181.6 kJ /k] (-150 k) / 9000 s
Q =[181.6 kJ] (-150) / 9000 s
Please Note:
Q = -27,240 kJ / 9000 s
A negative value indicate cooling
Q = -3.0266 kJ/s
power required a positive value
1 kJ/s = 1kW is heating power.
Q = -3.02 kW
Therefore, based on our calculation the custom- From a search of the Huber case studies we can see
er would require 3 kW of cooling power at -30 °C to from the following example in Fig. 8 that in real-world
achieve the desired cool down time. From this calcula- testing we achieved a similar cool down ramp in 2h.
tion we would propose a Unistat 510w system.
Fig. 8: Casestudy
When scaling up a pro-
cess there are some key Jacket temperature
factors in addition to Process temperature
your process calorimetry. Setpoint
Performing a reaction on
benchtop scale we can
The jacket temperature ramps
observe some key data. quickly to -42°C to pull the
process temperature quickly
1. Reactor Volume to to its new setpoint
Jacket Capacity ratio
2. Watts per liter in rela-
tion to HTF in system
3. Flow rate of HTF in Process temperature
system reaches exactly the
new setpoint
By ensuring these values
are accessed in addition
to the process calorim-
etry one can ensure the
scale up of a process is
keeping to the true pa-
rameters of the bench
scale process.
8
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Condenser Cooling
∆ kW ≈ 1/3 X
Liquid Phase
9
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Apparatus Size
Hoses 2 x 1M
Jacket temperature
Process temperature
Setpoint
10
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Elevated Temperature
Open bath systems typically have a lower watts per liter Closed systems typically have a higher watts per lire
ratio due to their larger fill volume, they have a larger ratio, they are highly insulated against heat loss to at-
heat loss via the lid aperture. mosphere.
At elevated temperature HTFs can fume to the atmos- At elevated temperatures the expansion of fluid is di-
phere as low boiling components boil out of the fluid. rected in to a thermally inert expansion tank resulting
This can lead to the application area being coated in a in no fuming.
thin layer of HTF.
Apparatus Size
Hoses 2 x 1M
Jacket temperature
Process temperature
Setpoint
11
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Subzero Temperature
When we look at comparing open bath to closed sys- Whilst in both scenarios both open and closed systems
tem for subzero temperature a key point is the absorp- will achieve the desired temperature. One then has to
tion of heat and of water into thermal fluid via the large look at efficiencies of the application and turnaround of
surface area in the bath. the process. Of course budgets have to be consulted.
However, a long term view based on HTF fluid lifespan,
Same as before the low watts per liter and level of sys-
time taken to perform experiment and productivity
tem insulation can have an effect on rate of cooling.
have to be taken into account.
Apparatus Size
Hoses M16x1; 2 x 1 m
Control Process
Jacket temperature
Process temperature
Setpoint
12
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Apparatus Size
Hoses M16x1; 2 x 1 m
Control Process
Jacket temperature
Process temperature
Setpoint
13
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Thermal Fluid
(HTF = Heat Transfer Fluid) When selecting a HTF you should
Huber heat transfer fluids have the best thermody- consider the following:
namic and environmentally friendly characteristics. The
choice of the correct fluid is decisive for efficient heat 1. Application material of construction in
transfer. The working temperature range is gene-rally particular seals and gaskets.
the most important criterion for choosing a particular 2. Are you operating an open bath or
fluid. The use of the correct heat transfer fluid guar- hydraulically closed system?
antees reliable and safe operation, optimum tempera-
ture control and a long life. 3. Your pumping capacity.
The majority of heat transfer fluids on the market in- 4. Have you got suitable expansion room
cluding those supplied by Huber are polymer-based in your system to accommodate thermal
fluids as they have excellent specific heat capacities. As expansion of heat transfer fluid.
part of their design, their liner thermal expansion coef- 5. What is your planned operating
ficient is measured. What this means temperature range?
is that when heat is applied the
polymers unfold and can swell 6. What is the viscosity of the fluid over
resulting in a net increase in the your operating temperature range?
volume of fluid in the system. 7. What is the density of the fluid over your
The expansion of the thermal flu- operating temperature range?
ids can be calculated using the
equation formula below.
∆V = Change of volume
1,025 V0 = 10 liters
ß = Thermal expansion coefficient
t0 = -20°C
1,000 =
∆T Working temperature difference
t1 = +100°C
(Difference t1 final temperature
0,975
- t0 starting temperature) ∆T = t1 – t0 = +100°C - (-20°C) = 120 K
0
V0,950 = Filling volume ß = 10-5/K = 0,00101
D0,925
average
= Average density Daverage = 0,935 g/cm³
0,900
1,025
Change of volume:
0,875
1,000
Average density M20.195/235.20 = 0,935 g/cm³ 0,00101 g/ml/K x 120 K x 10 Liter
0,850
0,975 = 1,296 Liter
0,935 g/cm3
0,825
0,950
0,800
0,925 Result: The volume will expand by approx. 1,3 liters.
0,775
0,900
Tipp: Use an expansion tank to drain vessel jackets
0,750
0,875 into if they have swappable benchtop reactors.
-60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 °C
0,850
0,825
0,800
14
Inspired by temperature
0,775
Reactor Applications
In addition to measuring of the liner thermal expansion Another factor that can affect temperature control is
coefficient the specific heat capacity of the thermal flu- the viscosity of a thermal fluid. As with most liquids at a
ids is also measured across a range of temperatures. certain temperature you achieve a pour point. Howev-
Meaning we can fully understand the characteristics of er, building up to this we seen an exponential increase
the fluid. in viscosity.
Ensuring you choose the correct thermal fluid for your
application is key to optimized delivery of temperature Case 1: 1:1 Glycol Water in Jacket | SilOil M80 in Vessel
control to your application. t -18 °C in 310 min
Case 2: SilOil M80 in Jacket | SilOil M80 in Vessel
A common choice is a 50:50 mix of glycol water in
t -18 °C in 150 min
benchtop systems. What we can see in Fig. 14 is the
fact that by using a polymer-based heat transfer flu-
id with an improved specific heat capacity we can hit Start Temp End Temp Time
our tMin of 18 °C in over half the time of that with glycol
water. Often customers believe they will make a small Case 1: 100 °C -18 °C 310 min
Glycol Water
cost saving by not using an appropriate HTF. However,
choice of the correct fluid will see productivity signifi- Case 2: 100 °C -18 °C 150 min
SilOil M80
cantly improved and processes speed up from day one.
Setpoint
Jacket Temp Glycol Water as HTF
Process Process Temp Glycol lWater as HTF
Jacket SilOil M80 as HTF
Process SilOil M80 as HTF
100
Viscosity 90
[mm2/s] 80
70
60
50
20
15
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
This is observed in the following graph where we uti- the thermal fluid increases and affects the stability of
lized a Unistat 905 to demonstrate the effect of the the tI curve. This is evident in the temperature of the
increase in viscosity of thermal fluid and temperature evaporator and the return sensor tR also which are be-
control. We can see that cooling down to -40 °C is a fore and after tI in the fluid loop.
steady ramp down. However, at -40 °C the viscosity of
System Pressure
To apply a pressure across a reactor jacket, one would
When it comes to glass reactor applications the ide-
have to shut the reactor jacket outlet with a valve and
al scenario for efficient temperature control is a high
create a dead head pressure across the reactor. A vast
flow, low pressure supply of HTF to the application.
majority of glass reactor manufacturers now fit pres-
However, a lot of concern is generated around system
sure relief devices to prevent this scenario from occur-
pressures. Under German DIN 12876 the maximum
ring.
pump pressure is measured as a dead head pressure
i.e. 0 l/min flow rate. Whereas a standard jacketed reactor will cause a pres-
sure drop due to the HTF entering a large void from a
Pumpenkennlinien
small aperture.
Increasing
pressure does
not increase
Catalouge data
flow
Pressure (bar)
Pressure (bar)
max pressure
Catalouge data
max flow
Förderstrom
Flow ratel/min
l/min Flow rate (l/min) Flow rate (l/min)
16
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
To negate the initial startup pressure or a dead head Unistat with larger capacities (LHS) can control the
pressure being applied we can also look at the use of pressure using a pressure sensor and a stepless au-
three options a variable pressure control pump and tomated bypass. Minimal pressure and maximum flow
automated or manual bypasses. encourage optimal heat transfer. The VPC allows ena-
bles the best operation while remaining within the de-
VPC was developed to protect glass reactors from
fined pressure limits of the application. Placement of
damage caused by high fluid pressure. VPC also com-
a pressure sensor adjacent to the application and not
pensates for changes in viscosity as heat transfer fluid
TCU will ensure an optimal flow rate of HTF through the
is heated and cooled. Unistat for typical laboratory ap-
application.
plications have a variable speed pump with soft-start,
and using a pressure sensor can control their maxi- Where a manual bypass is selected to proportion of
mum fluid pressure. the flow to reduce the pressure it should be placed at
the application to ensure efficient temperature control
This is done by utilizing the pump speed (flowrate) to
occurs at the application.
pressure correlation. Therefore, by reducing pump
speed the observed pressure will be reduced. In the In addition to controlling pressure if we introduce a
Huber systems with a variable speed pump you can mass flow meter we can control on flow to ensure your
control via either RPM or Pressure mode. desired flow rate is achieved.
If quick disconnects are used on glass applications it is
advised to have a pressure relief device fitted between
the quick disconnect and the application. If HTF is
locked into the glass application jacket a slight raise in
Bypass room temperature may lead to an increase in hydraulic
pressure due to thermal expansion of the fluid and net
result in a shattered glass application. Please liaise with
the manufacturer of your glass for their guidelines on
pressure.
17
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Huber-Unit
Com.G@te
VPC
Pilot ONE
LEVEL
POKO/ALARM
AIF REG-E-PROG
ECS STAND-BY
RS232/RS485
SERIAL
Volume VPC Unipump Pilot
flow Bypass ONE
meter
Temperature cont-
rol with Pilot ONE
CAN Switch Com.G@te Fig. 21: Functional diagram –
flow volume measurement/regulation
18
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Case Studies These case studies are performed with a medium load-
ed in the reactor. However, we do not mimic exo- or
At Huber we believe that the application is king, whilst
endothermic scenarios.
we manufacture a vast array of liquid based tempera-
ture control units. Whilst calculations give a ball park huber-online.com/casestudies
figure for cooling and heating this is in an ideal world
We have used the data gathered over the years to as-
scenario. To aid the selection of units Huber in collabo-
semble a quick guide for achievable process tempera-
ration with some of our global partners we have run a
tures versus size of reactor.
selection of case studies on glass reactors.
M240 / GF/
10 Liter M240 U405 U430 U510w U620w U825 U912w
CC505
100 Liter U405 U430 U510w U540w U620w U912w U912w U930w
250 Liter U510w U530w U540w U615w U925w U930w U950w U950w
19
www.huber-online.com
Reactor Applications
Environmental Considerations
Natural refrigerants are the future. No matter what historical record. When choosing a temperature con-
needs to be temperature controlled or cooled in the trol unit, users should keep in mind that the unit will
laboratory: from distillation apparatus through the be in use for many years. During this time, the refriger-
analyzer to the research reactor, natural refrigerants ant has a significant impact on energy consumption. A
contribute to a positive environmental balance. There choice of refrigerant based on sustainability eliminates
are no limitations in terms of performance and the the need for subsequent, costly retrofits and protects
safety concerns are unfounded as can be seen in the against additional investment due to new regulations
common domestic use of these gases as well as the and laws.
Conclusions
When it comes to selection of temperature control ing and cooling. The Unistat principle (Fig. 22), unlike
units for your reactor application, the key factor is de- conventional technology, uses no internal bath. Instead
livery of cooling and heating power in an efficient and a low internal volume in conjunction with an expansion
effective manner. By carefully assessing your applica- vessel is used to compensate for volume change in-
tion as a whole and not just the reaction media you can duced by heating and cooling. This principle reduces
calculate the effective cooling/heating power required the mass of fluid and as a result dramatically increas-
to deliver your process. es the rate of temperature change, achieving cooling
rates of several hundred degrees per hour. Pressure &
At Huber we have built our knowledge and technology
Flow High heating and cooling capacities are worthless
around the temperature control of chemical applica-
if pressure from the pump is too high. Key to good heat
tion by working hand in hand with scientists.
transfer is the pump performance. In order to achieve
Reliable temperature control of a chemical process is optimal circulation, high flow rates with low pump pres-
critical to success and also dependent on an effective sure are required. This allows heating and cooling en-
thermal transfer. With traditional “open bath” thermo- ergy to be transported very effectively by the Unistat so
stats limitations occur: The flash point of thermal fluids fast ramp rates are possible (Fig. 24).
at high temperatures is causing a relatively narrow safe
Many manufacturers promote the high pressure rates
operating temperature range. Degradation of thermal
that are achievable in their systems, but the laws of
fluid, due to evaporation, water absorption and oxi-
physics tell us that high pressure is actually detrimen-
dation, dramatically reduces the thermal conductivity
tal to flow rates and thermal transfer. Pressure reduces
of the fluid. The large volume of fluid required to fill a
flow which causes restricted heat transfer - this has a
bath, limits the performance and the dynamics of heat-
Figure 22:
The Unistat
Principle
20
Inspired by temperature
Reactor Applications
Temperature
21
www.huber-online.com
Peter Huber Kältemaschinenbau AG
Werner-von-Siemens-Straße 1
77656 Offenburg, Germany
www.huber-online.com