Professional Documents
Culture Documents
June 2021
Prepared by the Nauru Port and Maritime Authority for the Asian Development Bank.
(i) currencies that use the “$” symbol.}
This environmental management plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein
do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may
be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section on ADB’s website.
In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation
of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian
Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any
territory or area.
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 i
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
Table of Contents
Abbreviations ...................................................................................................................... iv
6 Weather ........................................................................................................................... 12
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
Appendix 2: Site for storage and disposal of demolition and scrap material (Rubbish
Tip) 14
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 iv
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
ABBREVIATIONS
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
1 SCOPE OF WORKS
1.1 General
This Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan (SEMP) for the Port Entrance Road has
been designed to provide the necessary methodologies and procedures for the upgrading the
existing Entrance Road to protect the environment and workers and surrounding community
from the anticipated negative impacts. The negative impacts have been identified through
completion of an Environmental Hazard Identification (HAZID).
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
➢ Ensure safety, environment and other risk management practices are performed for all
work activities undertaken on site generally. This includes ensuring that such practices are
modified and updated when required;
➢ Conduct pre-start meetings, assign tasks, discuss project needs, potential problems,
project progress, current performance and future plans;
➢ Ensure reporting procedures concerning significant hazards and incidents are followed
accurately in the prescribed time frame;
➢ Liaise with the site management team on the safety aspects plant/process modification,
including equipment specifications, waste disposal and industrial hygiene, protective
clothing and the storage of dangerous materials and other substances;
➢ Ensure that workers are supplied with protective clothing and equipment along with
training in the use Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) where necessary;
➢ Investigate and document all recordable incidents in incident register, and ensure
corrective action and notification is actioned and recorded in Action Tracking Register;
➢ Participate in, and contribute to, the effectiveness of health and safety meetings;
2. 3 HSE officers
The Health, Safety & Environment (HSE) officers (2 persons) are responsible for implementing
and monitoring of the SEMP. As it is not a significant work program, the same two persons are
also able to undertake the daily HSE monitoring activities of the port construction work.
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 6
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
Specific duties of the HSE officers include, but are not limited to:
➢ Ensure implementation of the approved CEMP and its sub-plans and SEMP;
➢ Ensure safety programs and procedures in force at the time are implemented;
➢ Identify safety training requirements and consult with the Contract Manager for appropriate
programs;
➢ Liaise with the management team on the safety aspects plant/process modification,
including equipment specifications, waste disposal and industrial hygiene, protective
clothing and the storage of dangerous chemicals and other substances;
➢ Obtain and coordinate the services and cooperation of external emergency authorities as
necessary.
The number of personnel allocated to the construction of the road has been factored into the
total complement of personnel planned for the port project. Personnel will be deployed in line
with the scheduling and planning of the various project activities current at the time.
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
In-situ
10 Vibrator 50mm Set 2
Concreting
11 Roller / Compacting Set 1
12 Dump Truck / Earthwork Set 2
13 Level ZAL 632 Survey work Set 1
14 Total Station DJ2 Survey work Set 1
GPS
15 X10 Survey work Set 1
instrument
While on the site, standard PPE consists of safety helmet (hard hat). high visibility protective
clothing, steel capped work boots and where appropriate or the specific tasks, the following
protective equipment:
➢ Safety glasses
➢ Safety gloves,
➢ Disposable Mask
➢ Welding Mask
The use of mechanical plant and machinery is to be limited between the hours of 7am and
10pm for all earthworks and preparation of the road foundation and drainage structures. Port
access is required during the daytime and will require coordination of traffic flow to minimize
impact on the road work activities.
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 9
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
To minimize disruption to port traffic and other traffic, night works may be considered for the
concreting of the road surface to take advantage of the cooler temperatures and the reduced
volume of port traffic and other traffic. Night works will be dependent on the approval of the
Safe Work Method Statement (SWMS, including HAZID) for night work which will address the
key issues of the impacts of noise, lighting and worker fatigue management.
Safe barricaded access and defined walkways around the site will be provided to ensure there
is no risk to the community from the construction activities. Notices will be provided to the
community, and adjoining business premises in advance, if there will be changes to existing
access and need for detours.
24/7 security will be arranged to avoid unauthorized entry to the work area.
All the aggregate shall be supplied by Employer free of charge from the Government of Nauru
limestone quarry. No dredged material will be used for the road.
Ambient noise near the NUC power plant (see Figure 4.1), which operates continuously, will
be recorded during both the day and night prior to construction to determine the background
noise levels. Sites along the southern portion of the road will also be recorded to prior to
construction and used in the SWMS.
These measurements will be used to determine the maximum permissible noise levels during
construction, particularly if night works are scheduled.
The night time background noise is 75.1 dB recorded on the night of 27 May 2021.
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 10
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
Workers on site will be equipped with disposable mask in case of dust generated on site during
entrance road construction activities.
Provide appropriately sized channels and soak pits to contain any surface water runoff during
the construction period and as agreed with the PMU/CSC Environmental Specialist. Soak pits
will be placed such they do not impede local traffic access to the housing area.
Due to the highly porous nature of the coral substrate, runoff water in the soak pits will quickly
drain away, as evidenced by similar surface water controls established to manage runoff in the
port area during construction. These soak pits, coupled with cut out drains, have proven to be
a simple and effective way of dispersing high volumes of surface water runoff from large
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 11
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
downpours and reducing scouring of unconsolidated coral material leading to the work areas
on the lower level. Monitoring by HSE staff will ensure these soak pits and cut out drains remain
clear of any buildup of sediment which can retard the ability to soak into the substrate.
Noddy birds are currently roosting in the large casuarina tree near the temporary port offices.
Survey and setout will avoid any alignment in close proximity to the tree to reduce and damage
to the tree root system, to the extent possible. Markers and barricades will delineate the extent
of the road alignment, with excavation being strictly limited to the footprint of the road alignment
to avoid damage to the tree or disturbing the roosting birds. A solid barricade will be provided
around the tree to prevent construction machinery from parking under it.
Two medium-sized coconut trees standing in front of the port access gate will be removed as
part of the road upgrade works. These trees belong to Port Authority Nauru and written
approval will be required before these are removed.
There is a large Ficus tree on the northern road corner which may be affected by the excavation.
Once site setout has been confirmed, the extent to which the aerial roots of the Ficus tree are
to be trimmed will be determined.
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
4.2.6 Spoil
All excavated material shall be removed from the site and disposed of in the approved disposal
site as soon as practicable, so that the work site is kept in a clean and tidy condition. Disposal
of demolition and scrap material will be at the main rubbish tip (see Appendix 2).
Waste material adjacent to the existing road as a result of the donor-assisted power station
refurbishment project, comprised of old boilers, generators, steel framing and other waste
material, as well as a shipping container which is leaking hydrocarbons into the soil, may
require removal to ensure there is sufficient room for the road alignment. This will be discussed
with Nauru Utilities Corporation (NUC) prior to the commencement of any work to ensure it is
removed from the road alignment by NUC and disposed of appropriately.
5 EMERGENCY RESPONSE
CHEC has an approved emergency response plan (ERP) and as part of its entrance road
works, CHEC will follow the ERP approved by the Engineer and Employer.
6 WEATHER
Daily monitoring of the weather will be undertaken by accessing the online weather bureau
website. This information will be conveyed to the worker(s) at the morning pre-start and may
have a bearing on the daily undertakings. More regular monitoring and communications will be
undertaken where weather conditions and the specific work scopes dictate.
Precautions will be taken to ensure that the stability any structures and the safety of worker(s)
on site will be maintained in the event of a sudden and severe change in weather.
All work will cease until conditions abate in case the wind speed is too high to safely operate
and work.
Nauru Sustainable and Climate Resilient
Connectivity Project
Re-Development of Aiwo Port
STAGE: Construction DOC. NO.: CHEC/RDAP/EN REV.: R4 13
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
DOC. TITLE: Site-Specific Environmental Management Plan for Port Entrance Road
# Task / Activity Hazard / Aspect Risk / Impact Raw Score Ranking Controls Reference Documents Residual Risk Ranking No: Assessment & Pending Actions By When Responsible Status
L C ∑ L C ∑
1.0 Project Admin & Planning
1.1 Plan construction methodology for upcoming work Construction Method Job planing Submit to CSC its methodology prior to work for
Plan 4 D M7 approval. Work on site shall be carried out consistent 5 E L9
with its approved methodology.
1.2 Undertake appropriate risk assessment prior to Risk Assessments WHS - High Risk Activity High Risk Activities will be identified (within this HAZID for Entrance
undertaking works - identify high risk activities 5 D M8 HAZID) and suitable controls applied. Road 5 E L9
1.3 HSE training Inductions, Training & WHS - Training & All site workers will receive training on Method OHS Plan
5 D M8 5 E L9
Competency Competence Statement, HAZID and SEMP for Entrance Road
1.4 Wear personal protective equipment PPE WHS - PPE CHEC will provide PPE and training for use to OHS Plan
workers. HSE officer will inspect site daily to check
4 D M7 whether workers wear proper PPE. Disciplinary 5 E L9
actions against Individual will be in place if workers
does not wear proper PPE.
1.5 Consultation and communication with communities Land Use ENV - Nuisance to local Notify the local community by the community meeting OHS Plan
community 3 E M7 or in a way agreed by the PMU and CSC. 5 E L9
1.6 Notification of Works Approvals / Permits to ENV - Compliance The Contractor will provide the Engineer with Specification section 4.2
Work 5 D M8 evidence that notification has been given of the 5 E L9
proposed Works
Mobilization of equipment to site Traffic & Transport - ENV - Nuisance to local Limit the work to normal working hour;The OHSP
4 D M7 5 E L9
Terrestrial community Contractors notify the community via Facebook..
WHS - Personnel Safety 5 D M8 Implement TMP; TMP 5 E L9
1.7
ENV - Air quality Implement dust and air emission control measures on Air Quality & Emissions
3 D H6 site. Management 4 E M8
# Activity Hazard / Aspect Risk / Impact Raw Score Ranking Controls Reference Documents Residual Risk Ranking No: Action Requirement By When Actionee Status
L C ∑ L C ∑
2.0 Road Construction
Site set out of alignment Site clearing, removal of Traffic Management WHS - Community Health & Implement Traffic Management Plan TMP
defunct structures and disposal. Safety
Grubbing, removal of roots and vegetation, if any. 3 C H5 4 D M7
Mobile Plant, Equipment WHS - Personnel Health & All personnel to have TBT on working around mobile OHSP
and Vehicles Safety 3 D H6 plant and equipment. 4 E M8
Access & Walkways WHS - Community Health & Provide barricaded and defined walkways TMP
3 C H5 4 E M8
Safety
Guards, Barricading and WHS - Community Health & Provide suitable barricades at critical areas to prevent TMP & SEMP for
Signage Safety 4 D M7 access to the active worksite. Entrance Road 5 E L9
Flora & Fauna - ENV - Ecological diversity No protected species reported. Large Ficus tree on CEMP Flora and Fauna
2.1 Terrestrial northern road corner, care required around site set Sub Plan & SEMP for
out. Noddy birds currently roosting in large Casuarina Entrance Road
tree. Care not to disturb the tree, provide a barricade
3 C H5 around the tree to prevent construction machinery 4 E M8
parking underneath it. No removal of tree or
vegetation is required within the proposed road
alignment.
Workplace Delineation WHS - Job Planning Provide clear markers to delineate work area to avoid OHSP, TMP and SEMP
conflict with adjoining properties, structures and for Entrance Road
4 D M7 services. Manage vehicle access with adjoining 5 E L9
owners and stage the works to provide the access to
property.
Public utilities protection WHS - Job Planning Identify utilities and underground faciltites prior to any OHSP
4 C H6 4 E M8
excavation
Removal and disposal of unsuitable road material Earthworks ENV - Nuisance to local Use of mechanical plant and machinery is to be OHSP
3 C H5 4 D M7
community limited between the hours of 7am and 10pm.
Public utilities protection ENV - Nuisance to local Place barricades around any above ground utltiies. OHSP
community 3 D H6 Care requIred when operating machinery. 3 E M7
Traffic & Transport - ENV - Spoil disposal Dispose of spoil in approved location Waste Management
Terrestrial Plan & Method
4 D M7 Statement for entrance 5 E L9
2.2 road
Dust emission ENV - Air quality Spread water on work areas as required CEMP, Air Quality Sub
3 D H6 Plan 4 E M8
Dust emission WHS - Personnel Health & Worker on site will be equipped with disposable mask OHSP & SEMP for
Safety 3 D H6 in case of dust generated on site during Entrance Entrance Road 4 E M8
Road Construction.
Scarify and compact exisitng carriageway Earthworks ENV - Nuisance to local Use of mechanical plant and machinery is to be OHSP
3 D H6 4 E M8
community limited between the hours of 7am and 10pm.
Vibration and Noise ENV - Nuisance to local Noise suppression measures outlined in the Noise Noise and Vibration
community and Vibration Control Management Plan are to be Management Sub Plan;
2.3 implemented at all times.Use of mechanical plant and
3 D H6 machinery is to be limited between the hours of 7am 4 E M8
and 10pm. Establish ambient day and night noise
levels in key locations prior to the commencement of
work
Excavate side drains, install stormwater drainage Erosion & Sediment ENV - Water quality Provide soak pits to contain any surface water runoff. CEMP, Erosion and
system Control 3 D H6 Stop work during high winds or heavy rain. Sediment Control Sub 4 E M8
Plan
2.4
Earthworks ENV - Soil and groundwater Construct soak pits and water runoff controls where CEMP, Erosion and
contamination 4 D M7 required or as agreed with ES. Stop work during high Sediment Control Sub 4 E M8
winds or heavy rain. Plan
Apply crushed aggregate base course and Vibration and Noise ENV - Nuisance to local Noise suppression measures outlined in the Noise Noise and Vibration
compact community and Vibration Control Management Plan are to be Management Plan
3 D H6 implemented at all times.Use of mechanical plant and 4 E M8
machinery is to be limited between the hours of 7am
and 10pm.
Traffic & Transport - ENV - Nuisance to local Trucks to follow designated haulage route and take TMP
Terrestrial community 3 D H6 special consideration to local traffic conditions 5 E L9
Wastes - Uncontrolled ENV - Soil and groundwater Contractor will remove any waste/left over material. Waste management
contamination Disposal of waste resulting from Entrance Road Plan
4 D M7 5 D M8
2.5 construction will comply with the Waste Management
Plan.
PPE WHS - PPE While on the site, every worker shall wear a safety OHSP & SEMP for
helmet (hard hat). Also, every worker shall wear high Entrance Road
visibility protective clothing, steel capped work boots
and where appropriate, the following protective
3 D H6 equipment: 5 E L9
Safety glasses
Safety gloves
Disposable Mask
Welding Mask
Concrete Casting Traffic & Transport - WHS - Community Health & Implement Traffic Management Plan TMP
3 D H6 5 E L9
Terrestrial Safety
Dust emission ENV - Air quality Spread water on work areas as required CEMP, Air Quality Sub
3 D H6 5 E L9
Plan
Lighting ENV - Nuisance to local Lighting may affect adjoining dwellings and facilities, SWMS for Night Work,
community other main road users, if concrete works are SEMP for Entrance
conducted at night time. Notify affected parties by Road
3 D H6 way of meetings. Ensure light towers are not directed 4 E M8
toward any dwellings or facilites or the main road.
Direct lights downward near affected facilites, where
2.6 possible.
Vibration and Noise ENV - Nuisance to local Noise suppression measures outlined in the Noise Noise and Vibration
community and Vibration Control Management Plan are to be Management Plan
implemented at all times.Use of mechanical plant and
3 D H6 machinery is to be limited between the hours of 7am 4 E M8
and 10pm. Establish ambient day and night noise
levels in key locations prior to the commencement of
work
Cranes and lifting WHS - Personnel Safety Crane operation shall be carried out in accordance Plan for Crane
4 C H6 5 E L9
with accepted plan for Crane.
Night Work Niusance to the ENV - Nuisance to local Two week’s notice to nearby residents prior to night OHSP
3 D H6 4 E M8
community community work.
Fitness for Work WHS - Personnel Health & Two shifts -- day shift and night shift, will be arranged
Safety for each work face of each activity.
4 D M7 Changing of shift is arranged to ensure all personnel 5 E L9
of one group could be replaced after one shift..
2.7
Lighting WHS - Personnel Health & Adequate lighting should be provided on site of
Safety corresponding activities. Three points lighting shall be
provided on site, ensure the light is illuminating but
4 C H6 not to blind people. 5 E L9
The lighting arrangement at each working point will
ensure that the safety access is adequately
illuminated.
LIKELIHOOD TABLE
Time Frame 100 year 50 year timeframe 10 - 20 year 5 year strategic 1 - 2 year budget Once or more
Could be timeframe or less timeframe planning timeframe during the next
experienced timeframe year
Experience Unheard of in the Has occurred Has occurred Has occurred Has occurred Has occurred
History of Iindustry or in once or twice in many times in the once or twice in frequently in the frequently at the
Frequency Once every Once every 1000 - Once every 100 - Once every 10 - Once every 1 - 10 More than once a
Continuous 10000 - 100000 10000 years at 1000 years at 100 years at years at location year at location
operation years at location location location location or continuously
Probability 1 in 100000 - 1 in 10000 - 1 in 1000 - 10000 1 in 100 - 1000 1 in 100 - 1000 >1 in 10
CONSEQUENCE TABLE Single activity 1000000 100000
Severity
Financial
Health &
Environment Reputation
Cultural & Social
Legal 6 5 4 3 2 1
Safety Heritage Remote Highly Unlikely Unlikely Possible Likely Highly Likely
NPV A$
> 20 fatalities Regional scale event, Prolonged international Permanent, long-term Criminal prosecution,
or permanent permanenet impact on multi-NGO and media and impact on social potential jail sentences
total environment. by public protest. Loss of structure, and for Directors & Senior
> $5B disabilities. Eradification of local host government support destruction of highly Officers. Civil
A > $1B Project Schedule populations of protected and/or social licence to valued heritage, asthetic, prosecution & class
A 6 5 4 3 2 1
> 24 months species. operate. Company economical or actions. Heavy fines, Catastrophic High High Critical Critical Critical Critical
reputation seriously recreational items. threat to licence to
tarnished. operate or future
approvals.
2 - 20 fatalities Large scale event on International multi-NGO Widespread disruption to Criminal prosecution for
or permanent environment. Extensive and media condemnation. a number of communities Directors & Senior
$1B - $5B total impact on populations of Host government with damage to highly- Officers. Civil
B
$100M -
Project Schedule disabilities. protected species. reggisters concerns. valued heritage, prosecution & class B 7 6 5 4 3 2
$1B Prolonged large protests. aesthetic, economic or actions. Heavy fines, Major Moderate High High Critical Critical Critical
12 - 24 months
Company reputation recreational items. threat to licence to
seriously impacted. operate or future
approvals.
Severity Level
Single fatality or Medium to large scale Serious public or national Significant impact to Significant, multiple
$100M - $1B permanent total event, medium term media outcry. Damaging regional communities and breaches of regulation
C
$10M -
Project Schedule disability. impact on environment. NGO campaign. Large to heritage, aesthetic, or licence conditions. C 8 7 6 5 4 3
$100M No threat to overall protests. Company economic or recreational Significant litigation and Significant Moderate Moderate High High Critical Critical
6 - 12 months
population viability of reputation impacted. items of significant value. fines.
protected species.
Major injury or Local to medium scale Major adverse national Regional community Serious breach or
illness, event with short to media, public or NGO disruption with moderate regulation. Investigation
$10M - $100M permanent medium term impact on attention. Significant impact on heritage, by regulatory authorities.
D
$1m -
Project Schedule partial environment. No threat to protests. Asset aesthetic economic or Potential litigation and
D 9 8 7 6 5 4
$10M Moderate Low Moderate Moderate High High High
1 - 6 months disability, lost overall population viability reputation impacted recreational values. moderate fines.
time injury. of protected specicies.
Minor injury or Local scale event with Attention from regional Isolated community Minor legal issues.
illness, short term impact on the media with heightened disruption with limited Report provided to
$5M - $10M alternative environment. Minor and concern with local adverse impact on regulatory authorities.
E
$100K -
Project Schedule duties injury, temporary impact on a community. Criticism by heritage, aesthetic, Potential for minor fines. E 10 9 8 7 6 5
$1M medical small portion of the community or NGOs. economic or Minor Low Low Moderate Moderate Moderate High
2 - 4 weeks
treatment population of protected reacreational values.
injury. species.
Slight injury or Local scale event with Short term local concern minor impact on heritage, Breach of internal
illness, first aid temporay impact on or complaints. Low level aesthetic, economic or standards. Potential
< $1 M injury. environment. Behavioural media or regulatory recreational values. scrutiny by regulatory
F < $100K Project Schedule responses issue. authorities.
F 10 10 9 8 7 6
< 2 weeks Insignificant Low Low Low Low Moderate Moderate
inconsequential
ecological significance to
protected species.
Applying the Risk Matrix Risk Response Table
Application of the risk matrix should be a facilitated discussion, or the results peer reviewed to assure risks are Risk Management Response
appropriately evaluated. Escalate
Residual Risk Response Timeframe
Level PMU / CSC CHEC
Determining the Maximum Foreseeable Exposure [MFE]
Critical
Detail risk control plan to mitigate
President
risk must be developed,
Director through
Describe the credible worst case risk event assuming all preventative and mitigating controls fail. The MFE implemented and reported to senior
Director / CEO Project Immediate - 1 month
scenaerio should be described, include an estimation of the financial business impact and, where applicable, the mangement. Senior management
Management
to monitor and ensure
most credible maximum number of fatalities, and the details entered into the Risk Register. Select the highest implementation.
Director
Severity Level from the Consequence table that reflects the scenario impact. The MFE shall be reported as:
High
A risk control plan to be developed Project
• The highest Financial and Non-Finance Severity Level selected; and and authorised by area manager. Directors
Project Director 1 month - 6 months
• Where applicable, the maximum credible number of fatalities expected from the risk event. Implementation to be reported to General
senior management Managers
Select likelihood level from the description that best fits the chance of the selected consequence actually occurring,
Consequence Likelihood Residual
considering existing or applied preventative controls mitigating controls are in place and are effective. X = → Risk Response
Level Level Risk Level
3. Residual Risk Level
The Residual Risk Level is the product of the Consequence and Likelihood Levels as per the Risk Matrix.
Thereafter, Management's appropriate Risk Response should be consistent with the requirements of the Risk
Response Table.